It makes it easier to contact authorities if you do so. Internet fraud is a big no no and if your information is held by an entity, then you will think twice about screwing someone over.
It makes it easier to contact authorities if you do so. Internet fraud is a big no no and if your information is held by an entity, then you will think twice about screwing someone over.
[06-05, 19:29] OhioSpyderman: Brian, finding a woman is NOT the answer, you need to shop for a good VACUUM
I see major issues with posting personal identification scans online. I will flat out never use the for sale section if it comes to that. Why can't we all just use "paypal" and their security? I got hosed on a deal once and nothing ever got shipped. 10 days later after I filed an arbitration with paypal (took 10 mins), I got the money back.
yeah but unfortunately Paypal doesn't always work that easily. I lost $400 on a scam from an auction website through Paypal and they refused to refund me. I wasn't the only one either. I guess this is just one of those places where everybody wants to be as careful as they can be because you really don't know who is selling you parts unless you've personally dealt with them. It's just a safety and precautionary step which I can understand. Maybe you can message him and work something else out like a fax or something.
Sorry but I am going to have to disagree entirely. Having someone, a third party, claim to have proof of identity does nothing legally to any sale gone bad. Look at the scams in the past or bad selling or anything remotely related. The ID or verification did nothing to resolve anything nor have any legal standing at all. Big online talk is one thing, reality in practice is another. This is, IMO, unrealistic expectations.
The most it does is give some small amount of peace of mind (albeit false) or make it a little more difficult for people setout to scam someone. If it had any more teeth than that then there'd be no need for the disclaimer of buyer beware. Pay by paypal or credit card, that's what it's there for. The bank and/or credit card companies have the teeth. This forum or anyone on it has no teeth at all legally.
Having an address or phone number held by administration in order to maybe try some peer pressure or mediate is one thing. Expecting copies of drivers licenses or personal bills is another. In the end it will come down to the parties individually involved and their financial institution(s). Period. Having any added level of "identity verification" really does nothing to give any more power or authority here if there is a problem.
In short, it seems that members wanting to participate in classifieds are being asked to send personal information beyond what is reasonable given the situation (a car forum) while not obtaining any added guarantee or buyer/seller protection. That is a lopsided request. And people's security issues should be respected, right or wrong.
As for 3si being difficult - I do not recall that being the case (or ANY other forum I am a member, mod, or admin on). I remember filling out my address and phone number with an email verification. 'voila, done. Pretty easy.
That's how I see it. People can obviously do whatever they please. In the end, whatever is decided it can be left up to the individual if they want to participate by sending personal information like that or not. I think if left that heavy handed on verification then the classifieds will be left without quite a few sellers that would otherwise contribute positively to the section.
Real scenario from 3SI.
A user is banned for scamming someone.
This user makes a new ID with an address and verifiable phone number.
Connects to 3SI via prosy server so we can't IP match.
He then pretending to be a woman scams some other people.
Having a image of your DL on file with a post from you showing your name and name/address while not 100% secure at lease gives us a change to find you if their is an issue. It is a good trail for any law enforcement agency to find you if you do something you should not do.
Don't want to post them? Fine. how about email?
See that's the thing. How would any different outcome been had with your example? There wouldn't be because you would have just gotten an image of fake DL. Crooks will be crooks and this won't help. In fact isn't fake ID a real small (minute) portion of buy/sell complaints anyway?
Some are only concerned about posting such info or hacking to obtain said info. Personally I flat out will not give out such information, especially just to use the classifieds on a car forum. There's a ton of reasons and facts as to why this is a bad idea but in the interest of brevity here I will leave it at that. I'm sorry but that's how I see it and nothing personal at all should be taken from this. Giving out information of this level via the internet or to an individual carries a risk. Shit happens. And that risk is no where equal to the extremely minimul level of possible buyer protection it may provide in theory.
I'll abide by any reasonable expectations to sell on this forum. Such as: Having a verified paypal business account should easily suffice. A forum that I mod on overseas uses this method to verify. eg: email address provided, money request for $1 sent, it is paid by a verified seller account. Done. You won't get better than that on a forum classified IMO.
The point being that there are many other methods available to achieve the same degree of verification without risking peoples information that can be subject to theft or abuse if mishandled (unintentionally of course). I thought that was the reason for this section. Suggestions.
Plus there are many people on here that are already known either online for years or on a personal and/or face-to-face basis. Surely that matters.
If it requires the personal info as it stands now then I guess I am out. Not worth the risk IMO.
Thanks.
"He that would make his own liberty secure, must guard even his enemy from oppression; for if he violates this duty, he establishes a precedent that will reach to himself."
- Thomas Paine
"This would be the best of all possible worlds if there were no religion in it."
-John Adams
"I must study politics & war that my sons may have liberty to study mathematics and philosophy".
-John Adams
"Christianity is the most perverted system that ever shone on man."
-Thomas Jefferson
"I contend that we are both atheists. I just believe in one fewer god than you do. When you understand why you dismiss all the other possible gods, you will understand why I dismiss yours."
-Stephen F. Roberts
"Never attribute to malice that which is adequately explained by stupidity."
-Hanlon's razor
"The greatest trick that Islam ever pulled, was convincing the world that it was benevolent."
-Anon
"That which can be asserted without evidence can be dismissed without evidence"
-Hitchen's Razor (New for 2018, thanks to Brett Kavanaugh)
Email would be much better, Alan! The option to fax would also be wonderful.
The reason for a verified address is simple. Members make deal, deal goes bad, the wronged person files a suit in civil court. In order to file that suit, the initiating party MUST have a last known address. By requiring verification would give that address for the courts to begin the process. Also, on the chance that law enforcement would get involved, it gives somewhere for them to start.
I back the verification 100%. Just looking for a secure solution to present the information.
Keep up the great work, Alan, and don't forget to take some time for yourself.
BIG THANKS TO ALL THAT HAVE SUPPORTED OUR COMMUNITY!!!
There is no end all solution other than to buy only from people you know or can trust on the board. It's just like any other transaction in this world. Options that I can see "helping" and not requiring anyone to post/email/fax any personal information to sell things are:
1. Minimum post count
2. A link to a positive trader account on a different website (I have this on xceedspeed and greatlakes4x4 and ebay)
3. Requiring that every and all transaction go through a paypal link on 3SGTO. That way there is no bogus fake auction links to attempt to follow and I believe paypal has your address.
4. Explaining to every member the "buyer beware" ideology every time you click the classifieds section.
|
3000gt.com 3000GT / Stealth International WWWboard Archive Jim's (RED3KGT) Reststop |
|
Team 3S 3000GT / Stealth / GTO Information daveblack.net |
|
Michigan 3S MInnesota 3S Wisconsin 3S Iowa, Nebraska, Kansas 3S |
North California 3000GT/Stealth United Society of 3S Owners 3000GT/Stealth/GTO Forums 3000GT/Stealth International |
|
3S National Gathering East Coast Gathering Upper Mid-West Gathering Blue Ridge Gathering |
Bookmarks