PDA

View Full Version : I Fail...



Nihil
10-04-2011, 03:36 AM
So, I've finished my 3rd attempt at eliminating leaks and to no avail...did the 120k service, first attempt, cleaned and prepped both surfaces with 600 or 400 (can't remember) wet-n-dry, used gasgasinch on gaskets, torqued everything to spec, let sit over night before adding fluids and starting, had a small leak after a month, so tore it all back down, used fel-pro gaskets, cleaned and prepped the same, this time, installed gaskets dry (no sealants of any type) torqued by feel, sat over night before adding fluids and starting, ended up using an old Right stuff on the oil pan, that didn't dry so it leaked like a sieve, tore it down to find the other gaskets were leaking some as well.....

THIRD TIME'S A CHARM...fel-pro gaskets again, this time used Roloc green discs on everything, nicely/evenly scuffed up, used permatex copper spray on gaskets, over torqued everything by 2 ft/lbs, let sit over night before adding fluids and starting...after two months, leaks again...

What the hell am I doing wrong here? Only thing I can think of is, after full assembly, run engine to operating temp. let fully cool, then go through and re-torque everything??

I can't stand leaks and there's no excuse or reason to have any, not even the smallest of leaks, I've tried with and without any sealants, torqued to spec, torqued by feel, over torqued...I dunno, I'm baffled, I've never had this much trouble with anything, I dunno what I'm doin wrong here, I feel retarded...*sigh*

What's your process? Also torque wrench is -/+3% like most so I wouldn't think I was using inferior tools and Fel-Pro is good stuff from what experience I've always had before...

box
10-04-2011, 04:35 AM
for those of us who havnt been following your posts, what exactly are you fixing "leaks" on? Headgaskets? Water pump? Oil pump? Sump? And what fluid is leaking?

Roybatty
10-04-2011, 10:15 AM
Don't use the prefabbed gaskets that they sell for oil pan! Only use the FIPG FTW.

AdamVR4
10-04-2011, 10:54 AM
I've never experienced "old" right stuff, but it's certainly possible that it can get old and no longer cure.

Why are you messing around with Felpro gaskets?

Go buy a new tube of the right stuff for $15 and seal this shit up. I've done ~15, 120K's and NEVER had a leak afterwards. I use NOTHING but OEM gaskets and The Right Stuff. Get both surfaces clean and dry and use liberal amounts of TRS on the oil pan flange. I put a fat bead on the flange then spread it over the whole surface with my finger (wear latex gloves). Once I've got a nice layer over the entire surface, I add TRS to the trouble areas (the bends). You need to be very careful during installation not to drag the mating surface across the girdle. Do some dry runs BEFORE putting TRS on the oil pan.

There's absolutely no need to "retorque" anything after warm-up.

Nihil
10-04-2011, 12:29 PM
for those of us who havnt been following your posts, what exactly are you fixing "leaks" on? Headgaskets? Water pump? Oil pump? Sump? And what fluid is leaking? 120k service (water pump, oil pump, oil pan)


Don't use the prefabbed gaskets that they sell for oil pan! Only use the FIPG FTW. Definitely know better on that!


I've never experienced "old" right stuff, but it's certainly possible that it can get old and no longer cure.

Why are you messing around with Felpro gaskets?

Go buy a new tube of the right stuff for $15 and seal this shit up. I've done ~15, 120K's and NEVER had a leak afterwards. I use NOTHING but OEM gaskets and The Right Stuff. Get both surfaces clean and dry and use liberal amounts of TRS on the oil pan flange. I put a fat bead on the flange then spread it over the whole surface with my finger (wear latex gloves). Once I've got a nice layer over the entire surface, I add TRS to the trouble areas (the bends). You need to be very careful during installation not to drag the mating surface across the girdle. Do some dry runs BEFORE putting TRS on the oil pan.

There's absolutely no need to "retorque" anything after warm-up.

Well...I work at a baxter auto parts, my boss "hooked me up" with some right stuff that was on the back shelf......dumb bastard, later I found out it was some old stuff that was given out as a sample, or recalled or somethin, wasn't sure, it was the grey kind and I've heard from others that it did the same to them, didn't cure.

I was thinkin maybe Fel-Pro was causin the problems, and I wouldn't use TRS on water pump or oil pump, not with the small channels, it'd be too risky to end up with that stuff in the flow of things. I wouldn't think Fel-Pro is any different than OEM though...a paper fiber gasket, but I dunno...and I get'em at cost...but shit, if that's what it takes to have a leak free car again...I'll have no choice I guess...

The Right Stuff is awesome...I can say that...no oil pan leaks lol

AdamVR4
10-04-2011, 12:57 PM
120k service (water pump, oil pump, oil pan)

Well...I work at a baxter auto parts, my boss "hooked me up" with some right stuff that was on the back shelf......dumb bastard, later I found out it was some old stuff that was given out as a sample, or recalled or somethin, wasn't sure, it was the grey kind and I've heard from others that it did the same to them, didn't cure.

I was thinkin maybe Fel-Pro was causin the problems, and I wouldn't use TRS on water pump or oil pump, not with the small channels, it'd be too risky to end up with that stuff in the flow of things. I wouldn't think Fel-Pro is any different than OEM though...a paper fiber gasket, but I dunno...and I get'em at cost...but shit, if that's what it takes to have a leak free car again...I'll have no choice I guess...

The Right Stuff is awesome...I can say that...no oil pan leaks lol


You're using felpro gaskets on the oil pump and water pump!?!?! No wonder you develop leaks. This makes me want to hit myself in the face.

Use OEM gaskets with a VERY thin layer of RTV (I use TRS) on each side. Anything else is just begging for problems. A Mitsu master mechanic taught me this in 2004 as I WATCHED him do an oil pump swap (he used Mitsu OEM RTV).

And for the love of god, in the future, can you please specify where the leak IS so the rest of us don't waste so much time trying to help you?

Nihil
10-04-2011, 07:24 PM
Well, I figured, I mentioned the 120k service, so everyone would know what's involved and where leaks were, though I suppose I didn't specify oil or water or both...sorry about that, but to clarify it is both...

Also, upon disassembly, the gaskets weren't metal gaskets, this IS on a SOHC though, but I don't think that would matter...at least not on the water pump...I know I only go with metal gaskets if that's what stock is, which is why I never thought twice about felpro since the gaskets that were removed were fiber/cellulose...Someone did change the water pump once before me though, but never the oil pump and it had the general common fiber type gasket...

I was thinking about that, using TRS thin coat on all gaskets, that stuff is magic, but from my understanding though, coating a gasket with anything sort of defeats the purpose of the gasket? So...couldn't you just use straight TRS and be just as affective, minus the fact it could squish out and clog or narrow passages? I realllly don't wanna do this for a fourth time just to have it fail AGAIN

cjbyron
10-05-2011, 01:05 PM
Replace your bolts for water pump and oil pump. They like to stretch. Fairly common actually. Especially if overtorqued at some point in their life. When they stretch they will not retain the correct torque on them at all. This causes leaks almost always. Seen it more than once. Usually you can feel the bolt stretching but someone inexperienced might not notice. I keep a bin of these bolts (new) just for this reason.

AdamVR4
10-05-2011, 01:47 PM
Well, I figured, I mentioned the 120k service, so everyone would know what's involved and where leaks were, though I suppose I didn't specify oil or water or both...sorry about that, but to clarify it is both...

Also, upon disassembly, the gaskets weren't metal gaskets, this IS on a SOHC though, but I don't think that would matter...at least not on the water pump...I know I only go with metal gaskets if that's what stock is, which is why I never thought twice about felpro since the gaskets that were removed were fiber/cellulose...Someone did change the water pump once before me though, but never the oil pump and it had the general common fiber type gasket...

I was thinking about that, using TRS thin coat on all gaskets, that stuff is magic, but from my understanding though, coating a gasket with anything sort of defeats the purpose of the gasket? So...couldn't you just use straight TRS and be just as affective, minus the fact it could squish out and clog or narrow passages? I realllly don't wanna do this for a fourth time just to have it fail AGAIN



Keep in mind I've never even seen under the hood of a SOHC, so someone correct me if I'm wrong...

The water pump gasket is metal, the oil pump gasket is fiber. Always, always, always use a thin layer of RTV on both (entire) sides of the oil pump gasket. Yes, you can seal the oil pump with just RTV. I did it on my SL and I seem to recall maTT (3SX guy) saying he did the same thing back in the day. My choice though? OEM gasket + RTV.

Be sure to apply RTV to the threads of the bolts that hold the oil pump on. Again, this was an instruction by the Mitsu mechanic, I've never taken the time to confirm that some (or any) of the threaded holes go into oil passages.

On the water pump, a thin layer of RTV on the metal gasket around the coolant passages.

I've never seen any issues with RTV squishing into the tiny passages on the oil pump housing. Again, apply a thin layer to both sides of the gasket -- we're not sealing an oil pan here ;)

I've never seen the oil pump or water pump bolts stretch, especially not to the point where they wouldn't hold torque or remain tight. You're only torquing them to what, 12 ft-lbs? Now, the small bolts that hold the cam caps on, I know from experience, will stretch like crazy if you over torque them.

Anyway...

cjbyron
10-05-2011, 02:53 PM
I've never seen the oil pump or water pump bolts stretch, especially not to the point where they wouldn't hold torque or remain tight. You're only torquing them to what, 12 ft-lbs? Now, the small bolts that hold the cam caps on, I know from experience, will stretch like crazy if you over torque them.
Anyway...

Yeah, happens quite a bit from my experience. Had two incidents of this very thing this year on some VR4s. I use a digital snapon torque wrench so maybe it is a bit easier to see them stretch. You can watch the torque go up and then drop right back off while they stretch. It is usually not every bolt holding on the oil or water pump but one or two. Which is enough to cause problems. Bolts are relatively cheap so I replace them w/o concern if there is question. Also had a tensioner bolt stretch this year too. Again, on a couple VR4s. These days I keep a selection of new ones ready to go as needed.

Maybe it is the digital torque wrench that allows for more easily noticed? I dunno. But the difference is immediately noticed, and corrected, by getting new bolts in there that hold. 'voila, problem solved.

AdamVR4
10-05-2011, 03:09 PM
Yeah, happens quite a bit from my experience. Had two incidents of this very thing this year on some VR4s. I use a digital snapon torque wrench so maybe it is a bit easier to see them stretch. You can watch the torque go up and then drop right back off while they stretch. It is usually not every bolt holding on the oil or water pump but one or two. Which is enough to cause problems. Bolts are relatively cheap so I replace them w/o concern if there is question. Also had a tensioner bolt stretch this year too. Again, on a couple VR4s. These days I keep a selection of new ones ready to go as needed.

Maybe it is the digital torque wrench that allows for more easily noticed? I dunno. But the difference is immediately noticed, and corrected, by getting new bolts in there that hold. 'voila, problem solved.


Interesting. Yeah, the digital torque wrench is undoubtedly the difference. So you're saying the bolts never make it to the target torque? At what torque do they begin to stretch?

cjbyron
10-05-2011, 03:32 PM
Sometimes they make it. But they fall right off again. I can actually feel it in the wrench while also watching the number fall as pressure is still being applied. Watch it go up and either get to or approach the target and then once further torque is stopped the number just drops down. I don't recall exactly to what. Something like 5 or 6 IIRC. When that happens it doesn't matter what gasket or sealant one uses. It will likely leak.

I don't think it is a fluke or uncommon though. We've done probably a dozen or more 120k (high performance and standard) in my shop this year. Because these bolts stretching became more than a one time thing I have one drawer just for these bolts in my OEM new parts bins. Water pump/oil pump bolts and tensioner bolts.

I keep these as they are the ones that have stretched more than once: MF140027 and MF140040 (oil pump bolts, about $2 ea), MF140036 (water pump bolt, again, $2), MD173607 (timing bolt train bolt, about $3.50 ea), and MD145360 (tensioner bolt, has unique shoulder, around $8 ea). Prices are estimate dealer prices. Cheaper of course if you have a shop account with your local dealer or maybe an online dealer. Either way, they aren't expensive considering the alternative (leaks and doing it all over again).

AdamVR4
10-05-2011, 04:42 PM
Sometimes they make it. But they fall right off again. I can actually feel it in the wrench while also watching the number fall as pressure is still being applied. Watch it go up and either get to or approach the target and then once further torque is stopped the number just drops down. I don't recall exactly to what. Something like 5 or 6 IIRC. When that happens it doesn't matter what gasket or sealant one uses. It will likely leak.

I don't think it is a fluke or uncommon though. We've done probably a dozen or more 120k (high performance and standard) in my shop this year. Because these bolts stretching became more than a one time thing I have one drawer just for these bolts in my OEM new parts bins. Water pump/oil pump bolts and tensioner bolts.

I keep these as they are the ones that have stretched more than once: MF140027 and MF140040 (oil pump bolts, about $2 ea), MF140036 (water pump bolt, again, $2), MD173607 (timing bolt train bolt, about $3.50 ea), and MD145360 (tensioner bolt, has unique shoulder, around $8 ea). Prices are estimate dealer prices. Cheaper of course if you have a shop account with your local dealer or maybe an online dealer. Either way, they aren't expensive considering the alternative (leaks and doing it all over again).

Interesting. If what you're saying is true, (a) I'm glad I don't do this work anymore and (b) The Right Stuff is even more amazing than I thought (never had any sort of leak following a 120K)! haha

cjbyron
10-05-2011, 05:01 PM
Personally I prefer the Mitsubishi Gray RTV. :)
But TRS has it's place and many swear by it. It's a PITA to get off I know that! LOL.

Not every service job has had those bolts stretch by any means. I hope my post didn't sound like that is what I experienced or meant. But it happens enough (to me) that it is worth paying close attention to. Because if you lose the torque by the stretching of the bolt(s) then no matter what sealant you use it has a strong possibility of leaking. Much will depend on what the bolt will hold or not. Each situation will be different.

It is definately a testimonial though for always using a torque wrench (which surprisingly many don't seem to do on a lot of areas and then wonder why their oil pan or valve cover or whatever leaks from being bent, overtorqued, or bolts break!). That overtorquing practice might be the reason for some oof these bolts stretching (overtorqued previously and exceeded the bolts capacity).

AdamVR4
10-05-2011, 05:05 PM
Personally I prefer the Mitsubishi Gray RTV. :)
But TRS has it's place and many swear by it. It's a PITA to get off I know that! LOL.

Not every service job has had those bolts stretch by any means. I hope my post didn't sound like that is what I experienced or meant. But it happens enough (to me) that it is worth paying close attention to. Because if you lose the torque by the stretching of the bolt(s) then no matter what sealant you use it has a strong possibility of leaking. Much will depend on what the bolt will hold or not. Each situation will be different.

It is definately a testimonial though for always using a torque wrench (which surprisingly many don't seem to do on a lot of areas and then wonder why their oil pan or valve cover or whatever leaks from being bent, overtorqued, or bolts break!). That overtorquing practice might be the reason for some oof these bolts stretching (overtorqued previously and exceeded the bolts capacity).

I always use a torque wrench, but have yet to splurge on a digital one. You just made the most compelling argument I've heard. Which model snap-on torque wrench do you use?

cjbyron
10-05-2011, 05:23 PM
I use the Techwrench type. The FR240 1/4" drive for smaller stuff (2-20) and the FR100A for the majority of everything else higher (20-100).
Snap-on Tools (http://buy1.snapon.com/catalog/tools.asp?tool=all&Group_ID=19918&store=snapon-store)

For above 100 I have a craftsman digital 250 that works well (but really eats up batteries).

Sometimes you can find good deals on them on eBay too but still a lot more money than old click style (but worth it IMO)

You get real used to the niceties of the digital ones. Much better than the click click ones. Plus you don't have to reset back to zero every time you put them away. All automatic and they shut themselves off. less to worry about or bother with.