View Full Version : What is a better dyno-Dyno Dynamics or Mustang?
Sin'sVr4
09-20-2011, 11:00 AM
Ok I was at the dealership last week and a guy came in who had a built subaru legacy that he said he had 400whp. He got it tuned by Revolutions performance. I told him I had a 3000gt vr4 that i had tuned by TOBZ in Denver and he had a Mustang dyno. He laughed and said that Mustangs are terrible and give alot higher power numbers. I said are you serious? He tried to act like he knew alot about cars but after talking with him figured not so much. He ended up blowinf up his engine for racing at his limiter and completely blew up his engine.
I guess I just wanted to know what is good? And I know they are both eddy current dynos. But whay is this guy stating this? I thought Mustangs dynos were one of the most accurate and lowest reading dynos?
lawdogg
09-20-2011, 11:43 AM
I've understood Dyno Dynamics to be the most accurate and lowest reading. Iirc they read ~15% lower than Mustang and ~20-25% lower than dynojet. These are general numbers from their website though (and off the top of my head so I could have had a brain fart) not actual back to back comparison data so who knows.
The strength of Dyno Dynamics dynos is the accuracy - they are dead balls on accurate every time. So when you tune with one, or tune and come back to one, you get the most accurate representation of gains.
I had my VR-4 dyno'd on a Dyno Dynamics dyno at Dent Sport Garage - it put down 330awhp & 330awtq at ~15psi with a good tune on pump 93 a year (or so) after I ran the 11.8 @ 116 at ~16psi with a ~25 counts of knock shit ass tune.
To clarify this post, I am addressing the importance of comparing apples to apples. The fact that a number is generated by one dyno is arbitrary until it is corroborated by other performance data like 1/4 mile times which are more universally comperable.
x2xtreme360
09-20-2011, 11:44 AM
The Mustang puts on lower numbers than the DynoJet. That's all I know. We have a Mustang dyno here at school, and the numbers it puts out are pretty damn accurate and consistent.
Sin'sVr4
09-20-2011, 11:48 AM
ya thats why i went with the mustang and had it done twice once with the L and the HL wheels for comparison. was pretty damn close. I just want to get her back to the track. Too bad i have to wait till next season as our track already closed for the year
HilbillyHomeboy
09-20-2011, 12:14 PM
Just a misinformed smack talkin kiddo. Nobody races dynos. :)
Jeremy
Sin'sVr4
09-20-2011, 12:18 PM
haha ya i know jer. He was a total idiot. But I heard these are better than those, thats all. Just trying to see what everyone knows. He ran 14's lol!!
Ray Pampena
09-20-2011, 12:48 PM
lower numbers arnt better either. dyno dynamics is nice to use but the numbers are so low it cant even be right. if i built a dyno that reads 10hp with an 11 sec car would that be the best one? lol the dynojet i have never reads anywhere near the advertised engine hp on any given car. thats already low! 300hp at the engine cars put 220 to the wheels... what good would it be if the reading were 175?? it gets a little silly. last time i tuned on a dyno dynamics in Tn, i couldnt tell if the cars were not right or if it was the dyno. it made me affraid to push them more and made the tuning tool not much use to me.
vr3.9
09-20-2011, 07:55 PM
The only time mustang is better than dyno jet is when some mustang owner starts talking about how he made 560hp last week at so and so's on a dyno jet and your both about to dyno on a mustang. You've dyno'ed on the Mustang before and know you can get down over 500awhp. Mustang owner gets bewildered at his 480hp pull, you smile at your 535.
GTOJOE
09-20-2011, 08:26 PM
Over here the only dynos used are DynoDynamics. Some guys are running other brands but I would say 80% of the country are all using DD. There are 3 AWD dyno's in town here and all are DD. A dyno is a tuning tool and you learn to use your tool. Just like Ray said really. He knows his and trusts it which means he can get consistant results every time, however it does cause issues if he tries to use someone else's equipment. To make things worse each country seems to use a different setup somehow and UK dyno's won't even come close to USA numbers. The Aust are close to the USA but I'm not 100% on that either.
Hans@GZP
09-20-2011, 09:12 PM
My last dyno day people said my dyno read low and there was something wrong with it. Their numbers on my dyno jet were different than another dyno jet 2 towns over. But, from what my dyno puts out, it seems to be right on for what stock cars make. So, I'm not sure what's up with the other one. Hell, someone tried comparing their numbers from a dynapak to my dynojet. That's not even a close comparison considering you don't even dyno with your wheels on using a dynapak LOL.
And numbers don't mean anything. It's a tuning tool. I can have the same car come back on months later and push out the same numbers.
green-lantern
09-20-2011, 09:22 PM
And numbers don't mean anything. It's a tuning tool.
Exactly what I was getting ready to post.
The tool bag that laughed about your numbers on a Mustang dyno is nothing short of idiot.
i don't give a crap what you use. just use the same one over and over so you can tune consistently. dyno numbers don't mean shit unless you can back it up with a timeslip. like that old joke about the 600whp and 1200whp supras have the same ET? yeah....
Permanent grin
09-21-2011, 04:02 PM
DD's are supposed to remove as much of the operator input as physically possible, thereby yielding more consistent results between dynos not just repeatability on the same dyno. To give an actual example, I had my 15G set up dyno'd on one dd and got 535 hp, a week later with no changes, the same car dyno'd at 525 hp on a different dd.
I completely agree with IPD though. A dyno is a gauging and tuning tool, time slips are more of a true measure
André
BaadVR4
09-21-2011, 05:07 PM
Ummmmmmmmm.............sort of.................. I have owned and driven a drag only car that ran as slow as 10.93 @123 mph and as quick as 10.29 @ 132.5 mph. While the car remained exactly the same, the weather didn't. My point is there are enough variables in virtually every measure of performance as to make some pretty dramatic differences in measured performance without any change in the equipment. So dynomometers, like flow benches and micrometers, are TOOLS. As useful as they are, they are useful only to the extent the user is able to implement the measurements to improve the performance of the end product. To achieve that goal, the tool has to eliminate as many variables as possible. And when variables are unavoidable, correction factors are used to reduce the impact the variables have on the results.
So, minimizing variables and maximizing operator skills yields the most reliable, consistent and meaningful results. That's why there are so many heated debates about which numbers are best. Most of the time, there are enough circumstantial variables that it's meaningless to talk about which dyno is better/more accurate/etc/etc/etc.
That's why we don't race flow benches or dynos, and we do use impartial and extremely accurate timing devices.
DD's are supposed to remove as much of the operator input as physically possible, thereby yielding more consistent results between dynos not just repeatability on the same dyno. To give an actual example, I had my 15G set up dyno'd on one dd and got 535 hp, a week later with no changes, the same car dyno'd at 525 hp on a different dd.
I completely agree with IPD though. A dyno is a gauging and tuning tool, time slips are more of a true measure
André
Permanent grin
09-21-2011, 05:26 PM
Like barometric pressure and ambient temperature to name a couple. Are you seriously suggesting that one operator has MORE experience in applying a 'correction factor' to get a more accurate dyno reading than a dyno that was designed built and tested (many more hours than a single dyno operator would spend on a dyno in an entire lifetime) to take barometric and temperature measurements and adjust for them based on fact rather than feeling? Please.......
I agree that a dyno is best used to tune and measure gains rather than producing figures you would bet your life on but to suggest that a dyno operator fudging figures yields more accurate results is plain ludicrous.
On a personal level, I don't care which one produces the nearest figure to actual output, what I care about is which gives the most repeatable results under varying conditions.
André
wingnut
09-21-2011, 05:36 PM
And numbers don't mean anything. It's a tuning tool. I can have the same car come back on months later and push out the same numbers.
+1...no such thing as "better" when it comes to dynos :D
Hans@GZP
09-21-2011, 06:09 PM
Dynojets, you put in your serial number. That serial number contains the dyno's vitals (drum diameter, weight, etc) which automatically calibrates the program. There is a weather station part that measures temperature, barometric pressure, and humidity. That is used to take into consideration for correction factors. You can pump out raw numbers, but they can change greatly between different times of the day. It's a necessity to use a correction factor if you are tuning the car over a long period of time or if you tune it multiple times over different days. Of course, the performance of the car can vary greatly from day to day due to the temperature, humidity, and barometric pressure that the correction factor can not take into account.
Permanent grin
09-21-2011, 06:13 PM
the dd has its own weather station for correction purposes too.
André
BaadVR4
09-21-2011, 08:18 PM
I did not say any operator could/would/should "fudge" the numbers on any given dyno. What I said was that the value of any tool often varies with the operator's skill in using the tool, as in measuring crankshaft bearing journals with a micrometer.
I am not saying one operator has more "experience" in applying correction factors. Most dynos have built in correction algorithms; all the operator does is select which correction factors are selected. That said, some dyno operators are more experienced than others.
As for dynos, there are some user determined options that will affect the corrected measurement. One of these "smoothing" factor which makes the power/torque graphs look smoother. Another operator determined option is what type of correction factor is applied (like "SAE"/etc or if there is no correction for temperature/barometric pressure)
Like barometric pressure and ambient temperature to name a couple. Are you seriously suggesting that one operator has MORE experience in applying a 'correction factor' to get a more accurate dyno reading than a dyno that was designed built and tested (many more hours than a single dyno operator would spend on a dyno in an entire lifetime) to take barometric and temperature measurements and adjust for them based on fact rather than feeling? Please.......
I agree that a dyno is best used to tune and measure gains rather than producing figures you would bet your life on but to suggest that a dyno operator fudging figures yields more accurate results is plain ludicrous.
On a personal level, I don't care which one produces the nearest figure to actual output, what I care about is which gives the most repeatable results under varying conditions.
André
Permanent grin
09-22-2011, 03:54 AM
the dd's don't have either of those. I believe the only actual inputs from the operator are transmission type, centre diff type and tyre pressure, so the operator cannot apply varying correction factors which is exactly why they are so repeatable between different operators and even different dynos.
André
BaadVR4
09-22-2011, 08:58 AM
Not so. Dynos have different, selectable correction algorithms to correct for atmospheric conditions at the time of the test. Here is an excellent write up on the entire issue:
There are few standards used in the dyno world for gathering HP and TQ numbers, UNCORRECTED, SAE and STD. Uncorrected is NEVER accepted in the world of dynoing and tuning as it does not factor in any weather conditions etc. Now here is where the big debate comes...is between SAE and STD. SAE (Society of Automotive Engineers) is the MOST ACCURATE AND WIDELY ACCEPTED FORM OF MEASUREMENT when it comes to the world of dynoing. Here is some more info I have gathered between the two.....
A lot of people have been asking about SAE .vs STD Dyno numbers so I thought this would help. Most people know that showing STD numbers read higher but not many know why. SAE represents more realistic standard conditions, STD artificially boosts numbers.
Identifying Your Correction Factor:
Dynojet:
If you look at a dynojet graph in the upper right corner, you will see where it says the correction method being used. The options are SAE, STD, Uncorrected and a few not needed for discussion. You will also notice a smooth factor (up to 5) which dyno operators use to make the power curves and any other data displayed, such as AFR, seem more accurate and smooth. You will also see AFR graphs scaled DOWN to hide flaws in the curve.
MD:
A Mustang Dyno ONLY uses SAE Corrections. Smoothing can also be controlled as well as scale for the Graphical Outputs.
Overview:
Most of the stated horsepower numbers are “Corrected” values. The correction standards were developed to discount the observed horsepower readings taken at different locations and weather conditions. It is obvious that an engine builder in Colorado could not produce as much horsepower as a shop at sea level. There is just less oxygen for the engine to burn at the higher altitude. What are less obvious are the other weather condition effects on the engine. So in order to compensate for this all advertised horsepower is “corrected” to several different industry standards.
SAE:
"SAE (Society of Automotive Engineers), USA. Power is corrected to reference conditions of 29.23 InHg (99 kPa) of dry air and 77 F (25°C). This SAE standard requires a correction for friction torque.
STD:
STD is Another power correction standard determined by the SAE. Power is corrected to reference conditions of 29.92 InHg (103.3 kPa) of dry air and 60 F (15.5°C). Because the reference conditions include higher pressure and cooler air than the SAE standard, these corrected power numbers will always be about 4 % higher than the SAE power numbers. Friction torque is handled in the same way as in the SAE standard."
Here is some quick math (using assumptions and round numbers):
STD:
Air Temperature: 60F
Absolute Pressure: 29.92 inches Hg
Relative Humidity: 0%
Relative Horsepower : 104.8%
Air Density: 1.223kg/m3
Relative Air Density: 99.8%
Density Altitude: 67feet
Virtual Temperature: 60F
Vapor Pressure: 0 inches Hg
Dyno Correction Factor: .955
SAE:
Air Temperature: 77F
Absolute Pressure: 29.23 inches Hg
Relative Humidity: 0%
Relative Horsepower : 100%
Air Density: 1.157kg/m3
Relative Air Density: 94.4%
Density Altitude: 1952feet
Virtual Temperature: 77F
Vapor Pressure: 0 inches Hg
Dyno Correction Factor: 1
the dd's don't have either of those. I believe the only actual inputs from the operator are transmission type, centre diff type and tyre pressure, so the operator cannot apply varying correction factors which is exactly why they are so repeatable between different operators and even different dynos.
André
HilbillyHomeboy
09-22-2011, 09:30 AM
Re: weather station.
Guess what putting a space heater under the station does? Yes, I absolutely know people that have done that...
Jeremy
re: Weather station.
Guess what putting a space heater under the station does? Yes, i absolutely know people that have done that...
Jeremy
brilliant!
BaadVR4
09-22-2011, 09:39 AM
Deliberate deception is always possible. I'd hope to not ever select someone who would do that. But on another topic as yet unmentioned, the Mustang Dyno employs an eddy current brake as well as an inertial drum brake (as used by DynoJet). Mustang Dynos claim this more accurately reflects aerodynamic and rolling friction losses. Not sure how accurate that claim is, but I am pretty sure it will affect the final numbers.
Re: weather station.
Guess what putting a space heater under the station does? Yes, I absolutely know people that have done that...
Jeremy
HilbillyHomeboy
09-22-2011, 09:52 AM
Yeah, since it was brought up, I was just throwing it out there that the weather station is far from infallible. That's one reason why I started running my numbers uncorrected. :)
Jeremy
Permanent grin
09-22-2011, 09:53 AM
The problem is the world of dynoing is bigger than just Dynojet or Mustang!
The ONLY correction factors used by the dd are the ones that correct for atmospheric conditions and AIT. The software does corrections automatically based on readings from its integrated weather station and AIT probe.
Atmospheric Correction Screen
Inlet air temperature
Ambient temperature
Barometric pressure
Relative humidity
Mechanical efficiency (Dyno Dynamics ATMC2 only)
Resultant correction factor
Taken from here (http://www.dyno.com.au/dyno/controller/specs/showAWD450DSQRPage)
To explain in detail I copied this from a post on EvolutionOz.net
The whole point of a dyno correction factor is to be able to test in different atmospheric conditions (eg. summer, winter, different locations) and to still be able to compare the results from any given test.
As the engine relies on mass air flow to make power any change in air density can have a large effect on the output of the engine. If the air is more dense (lower temperature, lower atmospheric pressure) you will make more power, if the air is less dense (higher temperature, higher atmospheric pressure) you will make less power.
So what happens is a "standard air condition" was created. A formula was then derived taking into account the air density components (temperature, pressure and humidity) that allows a correction factor to be calculated.
This correction factor is applied to the measured power to give a result AS IF THE ENGINE WAS ACTUALLY OPERATING on a day with " standard air conditions".
As it happens there are a few different correction standards!
The Dyno Dynamics dyno uses SAE J1349 however with the Mainline dyno you can select from a number of corrections including SAE J1349 however most people use J607.
The main difference between J1349 and J607 is the "standard" operating conditions chosen.
SAE J1349 "standard conditions"
Barometric pressure = 990 mb
Humidity = 0%
Temperature = 25 degrees C
SAE J607 "standard conditions"
Barometric pressure = 1015 mb
Humidity = 0%
Temperature = 15 degrees C
For example another non automotive standard
International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO) "standard conditions"
Barometric pressure = 1013.5 mb
Humidity = 0%
Temperature = 15 degrees C
To highlight the difference at 20C the J1349 correction would subtract power and the J607 correction would adding power!
The difference in the "standard day" conditions chosen means for any given conditions J607 will always read higher than J1349.
So some points.
1) To compare dyno data both dynos have to be using the same correction factor!
2) To compare Dyno Dynamics data with Mainline data the Mainline dyno needs to select J1349 for the print out. This can be done with the Mainline dyno as the raw data is saved so you can select either correction standards when printing out results, or even print out both.
3) The position of the intake air temperature (IT) sensor on the Dyno Dynamics is very important as it can dramatically effect the correction factor.
4) With the Dyno Dynamics dyno the barometer pressure must be entered by the operator as read from the dyno shops own barometer, this also can dramatically effect the correction factor
5) The local barometer pressure typically published for weather purposes is a altitude corrected pressure (corrected-to-sea-level atmospheric pressure ) not the actual atmospheric pressure.
Example correction.
Dyno test conditions
Barometric pressure = 932 mb
Humidity = 68%
Temperature = 19 degrees C
J607 correction = 1.114
J1349 correction = 1.081
Base "uncorrected measured power" 236kW
J607 corrected power = 262.9 kW (Mainline J607 selected)
J1349 corrected power = 255.1 kW (Dyno Dynamics)
Note: Section 5.1 of SAE J1349 AUG2004 standard makes it clear that the equations are not intended to provide accurate corrections over an extremely wide range, but rather that the intended range of air temperatures is 15 to 35 deg C (59 to 95 deg F), and the intended range of dry air pressures is 900 to 1050 mb (26.58 to 31.01 inches-Hg). Values outside of this range may produce inaccurate results for SAE Relative Horsepower and Dyno Correction Factor, but all other calculator results (such as Density Altitude, Air Density, etc) will still be correct.
It would appear there are only 2 areas a dd operator CAN affect the results 1) inputting a false barometric pressure if the dd is one that doesn't have the integrated weather station or 2) incorrect placement of the AIT probe such as deliberately putting it in a hot part of the engine bay.
It would further appear that some other types of dyno rely heavily on the operator using the correct SAE correction J607 or J1349.
I reiterate my earlier point that there is less a dd operator can do to mess with the figures, therefore they are more repeatable in terms of results between different dyno's and operators.
If Joe Blogs is off sick and he dyno'd my car last time, I want to know that Fred Blogs will get the same results that Joe would have.
André
Ray Pampena
09-22-2011, 10:09 AM
DD has an "x" correction key. you can take the dyno numbers and have them multiplied by ANY % that you feel like entering. so dyno a car that makes 300whp and enter 40% in there and you get a nice dyno graph of 420whp. ask anyone who USES a dyno dynamics about that. the same goes for the mustangs dyno and the superflow. thats why you see them running so called dynojet numbers.
they dynojet has NO USER CORRECTION.. only weather which all dynos have. the weather reads live weather and gets printed on the bottom of the chart to weed out any heat lamp people. if you see a dynojet run thats really high power... and it has the weather printed on the bottom... its real and thats that. theres no other math involved.
im not saying dynojet is the best. ive tuned on many different dynos and they all have cool features. dynojet is the only one that is not user definable with an "x" multiplier and is the most widely used whp standard in the US. i dynoed my red car a year ago and made 520whp. i dynoed it the other day and it made 523whp then went 10.97@126@3825lbs on regular tires so i think the numbers are accurate too
GTOJOE
09-22-2011, 10:17 AM
What is this "shoot-out mode" then... isn't it a mode that cannot be modified so there is no possibility of fudging the numbers by the operator?
Permanent grin
09-22-2011, 10:23 AM
Ray, I would go with that and agree with your figures translating to track times on street tyres. Mine was making very similar power (measured on a dd) and ran 10.96 @ 124 with a high terminal of 128.
The x factor as you say is also quoted on the graph for all to see as are thee baro readings, therefore is as transparent as Dynojet which may be the most popular in the States but is it worldwide?
André
Hans@GZP
09-22-2011, 10:24 AM
But Ray, you can change your elevation!!!! :lol:
Permanent grin
09-22-2011, 10:27 AM
Exactly that GTOJOE, dd's should always be run in shoot_44 mode as shown below with baro etc.
http://i616.photobucket.com/albums/tt242/agysler/Dynos/DR750dyno080710305psiraceafwhpvsafw.jpg
André
Ray Pampena
09-22-2011, 10:59 AM
lol@hans Andre, the shootout mode is the way to go! you just never see people using it
Permanent grin
09-22-2011, 11:23 AM
Ray
That's all that ever gets used over here!
André
Ray Pampena
09-22-2011, 11:44 AM
Ray, I would go with that and agree with your figures translating to track times on street tyres. Mine was making very similar power (measured on a dd) and ran 10.96 @ 124 with a high terminal of 128.
The x factor as you say is also quoted on the graph for all to see as are thee baro readings, therefore is as transparent as Dynojet which may be the most popular in the States but is it worldwide?
André
i know of shops that have a 15% cor factor in their DD and its definitely not on the print out. world wide is a handy thing about DD but they are not all that common here and not enough people use the shootout mode.
GTOJOE, yes the shootout mode is a fixed standard that cant be changed
Permanent grin
09-22-2011, 11:55 AM
I think that is why inertia dynos don't have much credibility over here as there were too many cases of operators pulling on 2 clicks of the e brake whilst measuring transmission losses to give people a 'feel good' factor LOL. Amongst other tricks and excuses.
I personally have seen a dyno sheet from an inertia dyno reporting 175 hp losses on a 350 whp car making it a 52x fwhp car over here! Hence my faith in dd shoot_44.
André
BaadVR4
09-22-2011, 12:09 PM
If you want to know how much HP a car makes, the single most accurate method to determine HP is trap speed on a 1/4 mile drag strip. Terminal velocity is exactly correspondent with "power under the curve". Elapsed Time can be adversely affected by wheel spin as well as several other factors. With the exception of "driver error", such as missing a shift or shifting at different RPM, the terminal speed is totally a function of "power under the curve". The "curve" is the graph generated by plotting HP vs time down the strip.
Again, even if we dismiss all the deliberate manipulations of horsepower output, this is why we don't race dynos. And it is why we use very sophisticated and accurate timing devices to determine race outcomes.
I think that is why inertia dynos don't have much credibility over here as there were too many cases of operators pulling on 2 clicks of the e brake whilst measuring transmission losses to give people a 'feel good' factor LOL. Amongst other tricks and excuses.
I personally have seen a dyno sheet from an inertia dyno reporting 175 hp losses on a 350 whp car making it a 52x fwhp car over here! Hence my faith in dd shoot_44.
André
Permanent grin
09-22-2011, 12:19 PM
Terminal velocity is exactly correspondent with "power under the curve".
To a degree yes. Then you get into atmospheric conditions, tyre pressures etc. My car ran 128 mph terminal on day 1 and terminals between 122 and 125 mph on day 2 after it had rained on the afternoon of day 1. The car never left site as we camped there and had no modifications to it. A worse case scenario of 6 mph difference!
What I am trying to say is terminal velocity can be used as a guide but is not an absolute definitive.
André
Ray Pampena
09-22-2011, 01:16 PM
I think that is why inertia dynos don't have much credibility over here as there were too many cases of operators pulling on 2 clicks of the e brake whilst measuring transmission losses to give people a 'feel good' factor LOL. Amongst other tricks and excuses.
I personally have seen a dyno sheet from an inertia dyno reporting 175 hp losses on a 350 whp car making it a 52x fwhp car over here! Hence my faith in dd shoot_44.
André
haha i got ya.. yea thats strange. the inertia dynos over here dont work that way. its power at the wheels only with no flywheel hp estimate. if you were to drag the e brake the power would be less due to the frictional loss as well as the trap speeds would be lower doing the same thing.
Permanent grin
09-22-2011, 01:26 PM
But conversely Ray, our flywheel figures seem to produce similar times and trap speeds to a lot of awhp quoted figures from over there. I don't think one is right and one is wrong, it is about comparison. For me, I will always try to back up a dyno run with a run down the strip to verify it.
André
Ray Pampena
09-22-2011, 01:43 PM
But conversely Ray, our flywheel figures seem to produce similar times and trap speeds to a lot of awhp quoted figures from over there. I don't think one is right and one is wrong, it is about comparison. For me, I will always try to back up a dyno run with a run down the strip to verify it.
André
yea me too! drag racing is the end result tell all :)
Permanent grin
09-22-2011, 02:08 PM
:DevilSmile:
Hopefully something to tell soon.....
:evilbanana:
niterydr
09-22-2011, 02:45 PM
the dd's don't have either of those. I believe the only actual inputs from the operator are transmission type, centre diff type and tyre pressure, so the operator cannot apply varying correction factors which is exactly why they are so repeatable between different operators and even different dynos.
André
As Ray pointed out, you can put in an x correction factor. We had a competitor doing that to us until we called them out on it (sent one of our good friends over there from our dyno to their dyno, made 15% more power. When we called them out, they said so it would be comparable to a dynojet). Now they use shootout mode.
DD has an "x" correction key. you can take the dyno numbers and have them multiplied by ANY % that you feel like entering. so dyno a car that makes 300whp and enter 40% in there and you get a nice dyno graph of 420whp. ask anyone who USES a dyno dynamics about that. the same goes for the mustangs dyno and the superflow. thats why you see them running so called dynojet numbers.
they dynojet has NO USER CORRECTION.. only weather which all dynos have. the weather reads live weather and gets printed on the bottom of the chart to weed out any heat lamp people. if you see a dynojet run thats really high power... and it has the weather printed on the bottom... its real and thats that. theres no other math involved.
im not saying dynojet is the best. ive tuned on many different dynos and they all have cool features. dynojet is the only one that is not user definable with an "x" multiplier and is the most widely used whp standard in the US. i dynoed my red car a year ago and made 520whp. i dynoed it the other day and it made 523whp then went 10.97@126@3825lbs on regular tires so i think the numbers are accurate too
The "X" Factor is bs. I know the numbers I put up on my car were not in shootout (inflated) numbers. I either posted atmospheric correction or raw numbers, whichever was lower.
What is this "shoot-out mode" then... isn't it a mode that cannot be modified so there is no possibility of fudging the numbers by the operator? Cannot be modified, but has other factors in it that automatically factor in, such as weather and atmospheric correction. Problem is you can still muck with those, see the previous "space heater" remark made in this thread.
i know of shops that have a 15% cor factor in their DD and its definitely not on the print out. world wide is a handy thing about DD but they are not all that common here and not enough people use the shootout mode.
GTOJOE, yes the shootout mode is a fixed standard that cant be changed Shootout mode locks out the 'x' factor, this is true. Car's make "More" on that number though. My friends galant picked up something like 100AWHP going from standard graphing, without an X, with weather corrections, to shootoutmode.
Dyno's are tuning tools.
Ray Pampena
09-22-2011, 03:06 PM
the shootout mode reads higher than the standard with no "x" factor? that i didnt know. i never got to use the shootout while tuning cars. most shops always had some x factor in or the super low reading standard which is waaay low
Sin'sVr4
09-22-2011, 03:20 PM
well, if i dont end up selling my vr4 ill definitly run it at the strip next season. With a new clutch and tranny should do better than the previous 121 traps i did
HilbillyHomeboy
09-22-2011, 03:22 PM
Thanks for chiming in, Josh. :)
Jeremy
Permanent grin
09-22-2011, 03:25 PM
I know the numbers I put up on my car were not in shootout (inflated) numbers.
You really ought to get your facts straight before spouting a whole heap of BS! Shoot out will inflate or deflate as conditions dictate. It is not an automatic inflation!
Cannot be modified, but has other factors in it that automatically factor in, such as weather and atmospheric correction. Problem is you can still muck with those, see the previous "space heater"
Other dyno's use weather station readings too not just dd's.
André
Ray Pampena
09-22-2011, 03:29 PM
You really ought to get your facts straight before spouting a whole heap of BS! Shoot out will inflate or deflate as conditions dictate. It is not an automatic inflation!
Other dyno's use weather station readings too not just dd's.
André
i think he means over the dd standard numbers? he did own one of these for a long time. i dont have experience with shootout mode. ive only used dd with standard and X% modes
HilbillyHomeboy
09-22-2011, 03:30 PM
Considering niterydr personally owned a DD, I'm going to take him at his word.
Jeremy
niterydr
09-22-2011, 03:50 PM
the shootout mode reads higher than the standard with no "x" factor? that i didnt know. i never got to use the shootout while tuning cars. most shops always had some x factor in or the super low reading standard which is waaay low
I wouldn't say "always" higher, but in my experience I would put it as a "usually higher". The point of shootout mode is to lock all factors in to a preset condition. It is meant for comparison between Dyno Dynamic using shops. The correction factors utilized will appear on the bottom of the chart.
niterydr
09-22-2011, 03:52 PM
Considering niterydr personally owned a DD, I'm going to take him at his word.
Jeremy
I have a love/hate relationship with dyno's, can't stay away from these threads, plus I need to get my teeth cut with this new forum. It is weird seeing the same topic here and on 3si.
niterydr
09-22-2011, 03:53 PM
You really ought to get your facts straight before spouting a whole heap of BS! Shoot out will inflate or deflate as conditions dictate. It is not an automatic inflation!
Other dyno's use weather station readings too not just dd's.
André
In my old shop and the shops around here they typically show higher due to the dyno room conditions and the correction factors that get applied. Being around 950 elevation with crazy temperature and humidity swings can really account for some favorable corrections. I never said higher or implied that they are higher, just that usually in shootout mode the numbers show up "higher". In the end, WHO CARES? They are numbers and it is a tuning tool.
Permanent grin
09-22-2011, 05:40 PM
In my old shop and the shops around here they typically show higher due to the dyno room conditions and the correction factors that get applied. Being around 950 elevation with crazy temperature and humidity swings
Maybe I was a bit harsh in my previous post, for which I apologise Niterydr. I do think that needed to be clarified though as obviously I wasn't the only one who mistook what you were saying.
Ray Pampena
the shootout mode reads higher than the standard with no "x" factor? that i didnt know.
The shoot out mode is there to allow comparative figures so that results at higher altitude or in a hotter climate can be compared with results at sea level, in colder climatic conditions and / or in different seasons. In other words, it creates a level playing field be it inflating or deflating figures to equate to test results that would be produced according to SAE correction J1349.
Like you say though, the dyno is a tuning tool to measure gains rather than absolute numbers. The best proof is at the track.
André
BaadVR4
09-22-2011, 05:46 PM
Ummmmm..........let me see..................my car had a difference of 9.5 mph (123 vs 132.5 mph) in trap speeds due to different weather conditions. You ran 128 on day one and BETWEEN 122 and 125 on day two. I would be much more concerned about what caused a 3 mph difference on the same day. Unless the weather changed a good deal on day two, there was something else that caused the difference between 122 and 125 on day two. Usually, what causes differences other than weather is shifting at different rpm or some change in engine tune (i.e., change in ignition timing). I would say your engine made less power on day two, probably due to weather condition differences. Tyre pressure will affect traction and thus Elapsed Time, but not trap speed; wheelspin has virtually zero effect on trap speed.
To a degree yes. Then you get into atmospheric conditions, tyre pressures etc. My car ran 128 mph terminal on day 1 and terminals between 122 and 125 mph on day 2 after it had rained on the afternoon of day 1. The car never left site as we camped there and had no modifications to it. A worse case scenario of 6 mph difference!
What I am trying to say is terminal velocity can be used as a guide but is not an absolute definitive.
André
niterydr
09-22-2011, 05:52 PM
Maybe I was a bit harsh in my previous post, for which I apologise Niterydr. I do think that needed to be clarified though as obviously I wasn't the only one who mistook what you were saying.
The shoot out mode is there to allow comparative figures so that results at higher altitude or in a hotter climate can be compared with results at sea level, in colder climatic conditions and / or in different seasons. In other words, it creates a level playing field be it inflating or deflating figures to equate to test results that would be produced according to SAE correction J1349.
Like you say though, the dyno is a tuning tool to measure gains rather than absolute numbers. The best proof is at the track.
André
No worries Andre, you came off sharp, as so did my first post. You don't know me from Adam, and sometimes I won't post a fully detailed explanation. Ray and Jeremy know that and will ask me probing questions if I need more detail.
What I was saying that in my experience, locally in the MN area, the shootout mode tends to raise the values for the cars. This is because of the dyno room setup, and typically weather conditions when tuning. The only time I've ever seen shootout drop is when I was tuning my car mid winter with the shop doors open, and it was cold. Weather correction offset was .8xx or a very low .9xx something, it was very favorable to tune. Granted, this was 5 years ago now, so memory could be a bit foggy, I just remember the negative correction factor was impressive.
I've got a few graphs to post up to show the discrepancy, need to validate it with my friend first as it is his car using that local shops dyno.
Sin'sVr4
09-22-2011, 05:53 PM
i post on both because alot of people stay away from the other site and some dont come over here.
Permanent grin
09-22-2011, 06:12 PM
I would be much more concerned about what caused a 3 mph difference on the same day
Yes there were some differences between the runs as this was only my 2nd ever 1/4 mile!
Tyre pressures that are lower do have a greater rolling resistance.....fact. Mine were lower on day 2 to try to reduce wheelspin.
I had difficulties with the launch where the clutch would just bite and bog therefore covering distance with far from optimal acceleration.
Most of the runs yielded 124 mph with 1 at 122, 1 at 123 and 1 at 125 mph and yes there was some experimentation with different shifting points. I ended up shifting at 6500 rpm to get my best times.
I think you are trying to find fault here there is none.
Perhaps something else that I misunderstood was that this thread was about dynos??????
André
BaadVR4
09-22-2011, 08:36 PM
Not trying to find fault at all. I agree lower tyre pressure would tend to offer more rolling resistance, but IMHO not enough to have much of an effect on trap speeds unless you lower the pressure to where the tyre is nearly flat. My comment was in response to your statement that on two different days your car had 6 mph difference in trap speeds and that was an indication that trap speed was an unreliable measure of HP. But, as you now post, there were differences in driving methods/etc which affected the trap speed. What I'm saying is the most accurate indicator of how much HP a car is producing is 1/4 mile trap speed. That's what you use to tell you what rpm to shift/what driving methods produce the best result. Just as you did on day two at the track.
I readily admit to electronic incompetence. That means I don't have the knowledge or skills to tune my AEM car myself. But I DO have nearly 50 years of drag strip experience and a more than a little knowledge of drag racing. And, IMHO, the drag strip is the most accurate dyno of them all. If you make back to back runs and the trap speed changes dramatically (without dramatic temp/press changes), then the HP output of the car has changed. We use dynos to tune our cars. We use the drag strip to tell us how well we have done and how we should drive the car to optimize the car's performance.
Yes there were some differences between the runs as this was only my 2nd ever 1/4 mile!
Tyre pressures that are lower do have a greater rolling resistance.....fact. Mine were lower on day 2 to try to reduce wheelspin.
I had difficulties with the launch where the clutch would just bite and bog therefore covering distance with far from optimal acceleration.
Most of the runs yielded 124 mph with 1 at 122, 1 at 123 and 1 at 125 mph and yes there was some experimentation with different shifting points. I ended up shifting at 6500 rpm to get my best times.
I think you are trying to find fault here there is none.
Perhaps something else that I misunderstood was that this thread was about dynos??????
André
Powered by vBulletin® Version 4.2.3 Copyright © 2026 vBulletin Solutions, Inc. All rights reserved.