View Full Version : DG's Bitch Thread
...because ImperfectDarkness asked for it...
This is a thread for me to pass on some hard-won information and advice. I've been turning wrenches and racing cars for something like 25 years and learned a thing or two along the way. Reading this board, I see a lot of people making some of the mistakes and holding a lot of the misconceptions that I did when I was younger, so maybe by recording some of this stuff I can save some folks some time and money.
And my current job has lots of dead time and affords me time to do some writing.
I suppose I should start with my credentials... you know, I don't want to make to big a deal about this. I've lived a very... active... life so far, and when I put it on paper, it starts to look like bullshit because so much seems so improbable.
But here's the high points as far as this thread is concerned:
- I worked for Chrysler (later DaimlerChrysler) from 1997 until 2003. I was an IT guy, not a car engineer, but I had the run of the place and knew a lot of the engineers, so I got a really good feel for how a car company works from the inside. I watched the build progress on my Talon through an internal 3270 mainframe app that tracked manufacturing status. I also got to visit the shop floor where Vipers and Prowlers were made, I got to drive the Nurburgring in a company Mercedes convertable, and I had a gig that ran for 4 years where I'd (along with a bunch of other drivers; not just me) teach vehicle engineers how to drive Vipers and Prowlers in competition.
- I ran a pro racing team from 1998 until 2005, where I was driver, engineer, and team principal. Granted, SCCA ProSolo is as about as low as you can get on the totum pole and still call yourself a "pro" with a straight face... but I was committed to a race series with a half-dozen events a year across the country, and another dozen or so supporting races. For eight years, pretty much every weekend from Feb to Sept was spent racing or testing. And when I say "racing" I mean racing - with results recorded and published, not Internet bench racing. Real competition. And along the way, I invented a new class (Street Modified - wrote the first set of rules) sat on SCCA committees, was a Safety Steward, and basically got to see how a sanctioning body works from the inside.
- Based on my success racing, I got hired as the racing engineer for a Corvette team from 2003 to 2005, where we built a million dollar C5 Corvette that was the most insane car I have ever worked with. I also got access to all kinds of cool tools, including my very own shock dyno. We also tried our hand at becoming an aftermarket parts manufacturer, so I designed and built about a hundred different parts, ranging from adapter plates to fit lightweight batteries into the OEM trays, to a adapter assembly to fit AP racing master cylinders to a C5, to (I'm not making this up) billet aluminum valve covers for the C5 including integrated coil mount bosses. Our shop was just down the road from Pratt & Miller, so I befriended one of their engineers and had the run of their shop (and their spare parts room) so not only did I learn my own stuff, I got to see behind the curtain of a very successful and professional pro race team.
There's lots more and I can tell racing war stories until the cows come home, but at some point, it's guilding the lilly.
Maybe I'll do an AMA later. ;)
The bottom line here is that I've been places and done stuff, so when I have something to bitch about, there's probably something behind it.
If you want more information - or confirmation - see Far North Racing - Home (http://farnorthracing.com)
Enough about me. On to the bitches.
DG
J. Fast
07-03-2011, 11:00 AM
What are you bitching about now? Haha... you do realize we're talking about cars on the internet :lo5l:
When auto companies decide to build a car, it (almost always) isn't just somebodies Good Idea; each model of car has a design purpose.
The ultimate purpose of any car is to generate sales. Sometimes (usually, in fact) that is through straight-up sales of that particular model. Best example - the Chrysler minivan. That's a practical vehicle for any family that has multiple children a couple of years apart, and Chrysler sells a ton of them.
But sometimes the purpose of a car is to sell an image, which in turn has a halo effect over the rest of the manufacturer's product line. Viper, for example, was not a high-volume seller - but by incorporating Viper features into a minivan (the cross-grille, for example) you could invoke some exotic chic into your more pedestrian products and through that, increase sales.
That tactic totally works, BTW. The Escalade, adopted for whatever God-knows reason as the car of choice for rappers and B-List celebrities, saved Cadillac. The Escalade single-handedly transformed Caddy from the choice of fossilized octogenarians to the must-have brand for Young Hollywood....
The Japanese are also big on the concept of the "technology demonstrator", where they build a small-run semi-exotic and cram all the coolest high-tech stuff they can into the car, as a way of demonstrating engineering expertise. The most current example is the Nissan GTR, but there have been others....
So then, the 3000GT.
The 3000GT was Mitsubishi's GTR at the time. It is a technology demonstrator car - AWD, AWS, Electronic Suspension, Auto Climate Control, ABS - the whole kitchen sink of top-line Mitsu tech at the time.
And - this is very important - it is a GT.
"GT" means "Grand Touring" and it is a very specific car segment*. The concept dates back to the European custom of the "Grand Tour" which is an extended driving vacation visiting all the major European capitals or cities with tourist interest.
A Grand Tour would be undertaken by a reasonably wealthy man and his wife/mistress (rarely both at the same time) and its purpose was a good time and plenty of sex.
Accordingly, a GT needs to have the following characteristics:
- It needs to look hot, primarily for reasons of attracting and retaining madmoiselle. Fashion counts in these things.
- It needs to be powerful, partially because the purpose of a Grand Tour are the activities at each stop, not the drive itself so much, so minimizing the time spent getting from point A to B is important. But secondarily, that rush of power and the thrill that comes with it madmoiselle will associate with monsieur and that's good for monsieur's propsects of getting laid.
- It needs to be comfortable, because it will be covering a lot of ground during the Tour and madmoiselle will not tolerate being bounced and rattled around in a tin can for several hours every couple of days. It need not be a limo - some concessions can be made in the direction of performance. But it will need lots of leather, functional climate controls, and it must have a good ride with no banging, jiggling, or rattling.
- It needs to be reliable, because it won't be operating near home nor will it have the squad of attendant mechanics (the passenger seat in a sports car was originally for the mechanic after all) Madmoiselle will not tolerate nor understand a car that won't start, can't be driven slowly in traffic (due to overheating and/or an on-off clutch) or in any other way obstructs the Tour itinerary.
- It needs to have a reasonably amount of luggage capacity. Madmoiselle will wish to bring a selection of outfits for dinner and cocktails, plus those hat boxes can get bulky. And she will wish to collect souvenirs of the trip; some of which the hotel concierge can have shipped straight back to the chalet, but some of which will be coming along in the car.
It's like a checklist for the 3S, isn't it?
- Hot styling? Well there are certainly lots of Ferrari influences (and Viper influences on the Stealth - remember, the Viper concept was developed in 1988 and was shown in early 1989)
- Power? Right at the Japanese power limit.
- Comfortable? Standard leather (and comfortable too; they really are good seats) A high-end (for 1991) automatic climate control system (hell, there are as many sensors for the HVAC system as there are on the engine) Plus the ECS and the electric exhaust are ways to tone the car down but still retain the performance aspect when needed) And AWD means none of that crass tire squealing when accelerating hard.
- Reliable? Notwithstanding the exotica, it's based on standard passenger car bits, and it uses turbos to make power rather than revving to the stratosphere, or super-lightweight engine bits, or whatever. Plus the AWD gives an all-weather capacity.
- Luggage capacity? Fold the rear seats down, and it's amazing what that thing will swallow. Tons of space back there.
Now there are a couple of things that naturally follow out of the GT segment and, in particular, the approach Mitsubishi took with the 3S:
- All those luxury touches and extra gadgets tend to make the car heavy. Heavy is not a problem for a GT; in fact, the extra weight and inertia on the spung mass tends to help with the ride comfort aspect.
- The need for enough space for the passenger and all her luggage tends to make the car bigger. Not HUGE by any stretch of the imagination - but compare to a Miata, 240 SX, Viper, or Porsche 911. (The AWS is a way to help deal with this and the weight)
- The AWD layout not only drives all 4 wheels, it concentrates most of the weight of the powertrain right on the front axle line.
All this stuff was very well executed and the 3S is really a VERY good GT. Compare it to the other cars of the time, and it comes out very well. It has a lot in common with the Ferarri 456 (losing out mostly in power, thanks to the Japanese power limit) but it does well compared to the C4 Corvette (despite the inferior suspension in the 3S) and it beats the C4 in interior room and cargo space, plus does better in poor weather too.
And you can tell that Mitsubishi is VERY proud of this car. It is no accident that it shows up in every version of Gran Turismo.
But what it definately is NOT is a race car:
- It's too big
- It is WAY too heavy and cannot be made light enough
- The distribution of the major heavy components puts the weight too far forward
- The AWD layout doesn't fit 90% of the rules for the various "GT" race series worldwide, which require RWD
- The transmission is specific to this single model and cannot be upgraded or replaced with an off-the-shelf racing transmission
- The suspension is not particularly racy (although this on its own isn't a showstopper; there are "racy" McStrut cars out there)
Compare to BMW M3, Toyota Supra, various Mercedes coupes, the Corvette, the Viper, all of which are smaller, lighter, RWD, and have easily adapted race transmissions - an all of which have a racing heritage.
The 3S is a very, very good street car platform. It is, however, categorically NOT a race car and never has been - it wasn't designed that way, Mitsubishi didn't race it, there is no racing history in this car.
If you want to go racing - by which, I mean you intend to compete against other human beings in a motorsports competition, there are far, far, FAR better car choices
*It is really easy to get wrapped around the axle about car segmentation and definition. You can find car websites where people will argue endlessly about if a specific model is or is not a "real" "sports car" or "GT" or whatever. The borders between segments are not hard edges and there is some deliberate segment blurring. Don't think of them as discrete categories or "buckets" - think of classification as points on a line or spectrum. "Sports Car" blends into "Sports GT" into "GT" into "Sport Luxury" etc etc
alexw3000gt
07-03-2011, 12:39 PM
I don't quite understand the point of this?
So you want to go racing.
And by "racing", I mean you want to engage in an actual competition against other human beings, using cars. You and your car will attempt to cover some piece of ground as quickly as possible, and your measured performance will be compared to other people who do the same thing, and the quickest time (or whoever crosses the finish line first) will be recorded the winner.
Not bench racing. Not who can cook the biggest dyno number. Not random forum arguing. I mean actual driver, actual car, actual race.
No matter what form this race might take (drag racing, rally racing, road racing, autocross, hillclimbing, or something else) all racing has one thing in common:
A rule book.
That rule book is the be-all and end-all of car design for that series. Within it lie all the freedoms, constraints, and restraints granted and imposed on the cars that compete in that series.
Your best course of action is to use a car purpose-built for that series, one that makes use of every aspect of the rulebook to optimize the performance of the car. Every aspect of your car that is sub-optimal will eventually need to be addressed, and each aspect that has to be addressed will cost time and money - way, way more time and money than you expect.
The very best case is a car purpose built from scratch - meaning a Formula car, or perhaps a "ship in a bottle" car (where the chassis is scratch built inside an OEM body shell - but the body is just for show) And the best case for "built from scratch" is to buy a used race car with a proven history in the series you intend to run; where the original owner(s) have already worked out the initial bugs.
For drag racing, that means a rail or a Pro chassis. Road racing, Formula Ford (or similar) Or the single biggest bargain in competitive motorsport, the F125 kart.
if you must go down the road of a modified production car, pick something for which there is a dedicated series - like Spec Miata. Or pick as the foundation for your modified car a chassis that, as much as possible, is optimized for your class right off the showrooom floor: Miata. Corvette. M3. If you are rallying, EVO or STI. Go with whatever requires the absolute minimum amout of modification to make work.
It is always far cheaper in the long run to buy the right car right up front than to try and make what you have "right now" work. Used race cars in particular are HUGE bargins (nobody ever gets more than a fraction of their money back out of a race car when they sell it)
It may not seem that way. You crack open Sportscar to the classifieds, and you see a sorted Formula Ford for $20,000, that seems like a lot of money. But that car will be sorted right off the trailer (or be very close) it will behave in predictable ways, it will be legal, and if it breaks - so what? You aren't out your daily driver.
But if you try to mod the car that you already have, unless you already have a car that is matched up for that series, you will spend and spend and spend while you discover each sucessive weak link and figure out a way around it.
And once you get the car sorted - you are now at the same place you would have been had you bought a sorted car up front, but you have spent two, three, four times as much money - money that could have been used to go racing.
It is even worse when the car on hand is something odd or unusual - like a 3S. There is no aftermarket support to speak of, and the odd driveline layout means there is no alternate heavy-duty transmission option. If you look at the current state of the art for the 3S driveline, you see a collection of hacks and kludges to try and get the transmission and transfer case to hold together under twice to three times as much power as designed. Granted, some of these hacks are pretty ingenious and some success is being had - but wouldn't it be nicer to not have to do that? wouldn't it be nicer to show up at the track, and know you are in the hunt and the car is not about to explode without warning?
I have done it the hard way, and I know WHY people do it the hard way. My Talon was my lease car. I have worked the miracles, designed my own parts, did custom job after custom job - and in the end, my car was about the equal of an off the shelf C5 Z06. With the purchase price of the car, plus the total cost of all the mods, and not counting my time, I effectively bought a Z06 for twice the money - and got half the use out of it.
That's just not good sense.
Don't let tribalism and pride get in the way of what should be a simple economic decision. You wouldn't try and modify a hockey stick into a baseball bat so you could play baseball - why do it with a car?
And here's the real kicker - if you cannot afford to buy a dedicated race car, you cannot afford to race. You should be capable of setting your race car on fire and walking away from the blaze. if you can't do that - if that race car represents some capacity that you cannot do without - then Other Sports Beckon. At least until you can afford it.
Hard words to be sure - but also the cold hard truth.
DG
Sin'sVr4
07-03-2011, 12:47 PM
me either. I still call my car my "race car"
i'm not sure why i insired this thread. should i take that as a compliment?
UTRacerX9
07-03-2011, 01:08 PM
The C4 has better suspension than the 3S? I don't think so, not by a long shot. Hell, the C4 is nothing more than a rattle trap surrounded by cheap plastic. And the Viper influenced the Stealth??? The Stealth was first, and the crosshairs were a hallmark of Dodge, not from the Viper. In fact, I'd argue the cars share nothing design-wise. As you put, the 3S was built as a technological tour de force. The Viper was a big engine and fat tires, end of story.
HellBringer
07-03-2011, 01:11 PM
I think this is the most relevant bit of information posted since this site's inception.
MADMarc
07-03-2011, 01:28 PM
lol I'm diggin' it. Come on! I'm waiting on #3!
One of the odder things I have seen on this board are the claims that the ABS installed in the 3S somehow hurts performance.
Granted, the 3S system is 20-ish years old, and improvements have been made in computer and actuator technology since that have raised the bar in terms of sophistication of ABS systems. The 3S ABS is not the best ever made.
But notwithstanding, the ABS is more than capable of beating a human driver when it comes to braking, especially in the wet, for the simple fact that the ABS can control individual braking circuits (and can exactly detect lock) where the human must modulate all four wheels at the same time (and can only infer lock from effects or occasionally sound)
I have had occasion to test several different ABS systems, including the 3S system. Braking distances are reliably and repeatably shorter with the ABS active than disabled.
There are two exceptions:
The first is when sticky race tires are installed that produce grip levels well in excess of what the ABS system was designed to expect. The ABS cycle rate is designed to match the grip level and rotational inertia levels from the OEM wheels and tires. When active, it "clamps" the grip at the expected level. While still very high, if the system were more agressive in it's cycle rate (or incorperated a feedback mechanism) it could produce even more grip; as it sets, it leaves a little on the table. A human can beat the ABS if he can apply the brakes to produce grip in excess of the "clamp" level without locking the wheel.
But the ABS still has something to offer in this scenario - it will detect lock and activate far faster than any human can. This prevents flatspotting on soft race tires. It also provides instant feedback to the human that a wheel has locked, so the human can back off the pedal and reapply the brakes, getting back into the operating area where he can beat the ABS.
When you drive a formula car, you can see the front wheels and know instantly when you lock a wheel. ABS provides a similar fuction on a production car, even if you aren't relying on it for stopping the car.
The cost savings in keeping the tires round alone justifies the ABS, but it also provides a performance-increasing feedback source.
If the grip level falls below the clamp level, there is no place for the human to beat the ABS and the ABS is optimal. If the driver needs to steer at the same time as brake, the ABS will enable the car to steer while still braking (although at a reduced level - there's no getting around the grip limits of the tire) If it is wet, or otherwise slippery, the ABS will save your ass.
The second is in the case of deep snow or very loose gravel. In this case, there is a slight benefit to locking the wheels and allowing a wedge of snow or gravel build up in front of the tire. The difference, however, is very, very small - this is largely theoretical, not practical.
If you are braking and the ABS goes off, is means that conditions are slippery and you are going too fast for the conditions - and the ABS is in the middle of saving your ass. It can be scary to nail the brake, hear and feel the buzz, and the car isn't stopping anywhere near as fast as you think it should. But what is making that happen is a wheel locking and you continuing to produce enough pedal pressure to keep the wheel locked. If you had no ABS in this situation, not only would you not be stopping, you'd be travelling even faster, and on top of that, you'd've lost directional control as well.
The bottom line here is that there is nothing wrong with the ABS - that even though it may be an older design, it is still far, far better than no ABS at all. Keep it.
DG
i don't doubt ABS as a concept. i doubt its implementation on the 3/s. and i'm far, far from alone in that opinion.
JasonY
07-03-2011, 02:16 PM
Only time i've had a problem with the 3/S ABS is in snow/ice. Worked fantastic on the road course at NG.
Jason
RealMcCoy
07-03-2011, 02:35 PM
I mostly agree with your assessment of the ABS, I've had an ABS system save my ass once when I was on ice, and the truck in front of me had no brake lights... I've also had the ABS in my Cobra almost kill me. If you're going to rely on it in a performance car, you need to actually use it periodically and know it's quirks. It is just a computer program after all, and it isn't going to be perfect. In my case, it turns out the recovery time didn't match the sensitivity... I was laying on the brakes pretty hard coming up to a stop that had a RR crossing right before. The unexpected ABS activation from the four inches of slip over the tracks added about 25 feet to my stopping distance, and put me nosed out in an intersection.
Bitch #4 - Emissions Equipment
The musclecar era peaked in 1970. Large displacement, high compression engines. High octane leaded fuel, and no emissions equipment more sophisticated than a PCV valve made it easy to make big power and big torque with nothing more than a 4 barrel carb and a distributor.
But a smog crisis in California and a fuel crisis worldwide quickly put an end to that. Within the space of 5 years, lower octane unleaded fuel killed high compression, vacuum-operated EGR came in, and cat converters (with tiny inlets/outlets and restrictive catalyst bricks) and power plummeted. My 6.6 litre 1977 Trans Am made 200 HP and (at 3800 lbs) ran 16.2 second quarter miles.
By comparison, a 2011 Dodge Caravan makes 263 HP out of an engine half the size.
So emissions equipment got a bad reputation with the tuner set. The first thing you did if you wanted to make power was to turf the cat, block off the EGR, and rip out the charcoal canister (and the air pump, if it had one).
And there was a certain validity to this approach. The cat converters of the era were god-awful in terms of flow. EGR on a V8 took exhaust from each head and ran it right under the carb flange where it would heat up the intake charge - and the actuator was a simple vacuum-mechanical valve that offered very little in the way of control save a basic load sensitivity.
But much the same way that carbs and vacuum-advance distributors gave way to computer controlled EFI and ignition, the emissions controls (although working under similar basic principles) have gotten increasingly sophisticated as well.
I've been delving into the EGR system so I can get it operating with my AEM, and the maps used to control the EGR are every bit as sophisticated as the fuel and ignition controls. It is clear that the ER system has been tuned to provide maximum benefit when applicable, and to disable when it would be detrimental (for example, EGR self-disables under boost)
And more than just limiting production of NOx, EGR can be used to increase fuel miliage through the reduction of pumping losses.
Similarily, modern high-flow cats can be had for a fraction of the cost of an OEM cat, flow almost as well as an open pipe, but still scrub the pollution out of the exhaust.
The power hit that once came with emissions equipment has been effectively eliminated - there really is no good reason not to be running full emissions equipment on any street-going 3S. Not only does removing it not help performance, it may actually hurt (economy in particular).
And here's the thing - the emissions equipment actually works in its primary task; that of reducing air pollution. Smog over major cities used to be horrible; if you see pictures of LA in the 70s it looks like something out of Mad Max. 2011 LA still has the dirtiest air in the country, but pollution levels have dropped something like 85% - and there is a strong argument that nationwide adoption of California-level emissions equipment prevented a similar crisis elsewhere. The stuff works.
There's absolutely no good reason to not run intact emission systems. I have a high-flow cat, all my emissions equipment is in place, and I'm working on adapting the OEM control strategy for the EGR to the AEM.
Frankly, a "cleaner engine bay" just isn't a good enough reason to remove emissions. Leave it in place.
DG
EGR can be used to increase fuel miliage through the reduction of pumping losses.
this needs to be explained in great detail; because i, for one, can't even begin to understand that.
i've got no problem using a high-flow cat; but EGR/vac...just seems like unnecessary complexity and of marginal benefit--if that.
Drummer
07-03-2011, 03:30 PM
**eggs him on for more**
mb7050
07-03-2011, 08:43 PM
-to reduce carbon build up- inside the intake was the primary reason for me
MADMarc
07-03-2011, 08:55 PM
Is now a good time to mention that I finished up removing all of the remaining vacuum lines from doing the reduction, the clutch assist is gone and I did away with my precats and tossed on some eliminators? :) mmmm....I can't wait to start it up when I get the last of my parts in the mail.
VR-4 0wnz j00
07-03-2011, 09:26 PM
The C4 has better suspension than the 3S? I don't think so, not by a long shot. Hell, the C4 is nothing more than a rattle trap surrounded by cheap plastic. And the Viper influenced the Stealth??? The Stealth was first, and the crosshairs were a hallmark of Dodge, not from the Viper. In fact, I'd argue the cars share nothing design-wise. As you put, the 3S was built as a technological tour de force. The Viper was a big engine and fat tires, end of story.
Haha, the Viper used our mirrors :D
Geordon
07-03-2011, 11:42 PM
[snip]
I was an IT guy, not a car engineer, [snip]. I also got to visit the shop floor where Vipers and Prowlers were made,
[snip]
Enough about me. On to the bitches.
DG
I knew there was a reason I liked this guy. I am an IT guy, and I visited the CRAP to admire the Vipers on the line 10 years ago. The Viper is my dream car. However, I ordered an R/T TT without so much as a test drive, and to this day is the only new car I have personally owned.
Thanks for sharing about the origins of the 3S platform. It really made me feel good about the car. Keep up the posts. So glad you have joined the community.
TT Eric
07-04-2011, 12:53 AM
Great write up DG. As always!
Eric
CoopKill
07-04-2011, 02:15 AM
This is very interesting...
__________________________________________________ ____________________
Tapatalk Bitches! :transform:
Greg E
07-04-2011, 04:13 AM
hahahaha!
Denis, I love your mind. That is all.
shmoo
07-04-2011, 04:23 AM
lot's of cool information!
i might consider running a high flow cat.. but, i've got an ich 3inch, and it goes straight from the downpipe to the back. and.. half of it ended up falling off `again`, however this time someone was kind enough to run it over. but only on one end with the last wheel of their trailer.
anyways, i'm still only running four.5 feet after the downpipe. since it's somewhat reasonable,:if i just tacked on a 3 inch high flow to the end of that 4 feet of ich... would you expect that i'd get better gas mileage?
i honestly want four inch. i know i only have 13t's, but i want slightly larger. sooo, maybe i shouldn't waste money on high catalytic converters, or a four inch exhaust.. maybe i should just save for bigger twins., dohhh new plan even still. i should keep everything even, performance wise. that should make for a decent ride.
and i'll consider the evap. it shouldn't be too hard to relocate.
but really, what do you think about adding a high flow cat to increase gas mileage. just to the end of my four feet of 3 foot ich?
thanks, great infough!
_isiah
stealthify
07-04-2011, 05:57 AM
Very interesting and well-written so far, DG! I've seen these topics (often misconceptions) come up quite a bit, good to see someone take the time to address them.
...because ImperfectDarkness asked for it...
i'm not sure why i insired this thread. should i take that as a compliment?
This is that original content, exclusive to 3SGTO, that you were talking about. ;)
Very interesting and well-written so far, DG! I've seen these topics (often misconceptions) come up quite a bit, good to see someone take the time to address them.
This is that original content, exclusive to 3SGTO, that you were talking about. ;)
i did ask for original content. unfortunately, i don't think the intent is original content...so much as it is in response to me taking issue with a couple of topics DG has voiced himself on.
it's a free country. everyone has a right to an opinion. i respect DG's experience & his right to an opinion. i reserve the right to exercise mine.
stealthify
07-04-2011, 08:10 AM
Ah, I didn't know you two had disagreements.
:inout:
Carry on. :)
not being offensive more attempting to make an explaination, there is something about making a car that you own and love better....especially after you've spent so much time working out what vehicle you want...and making sure it's just what you want (I spent 2 years working out what car I wanted to buy) while I fully understand that I could buy 50,000 other cars that for no money (comparibly) could be made to run faster, I just love my car, I really don't care if I ever win a race, I don't care if it costs Nelson money with similar results (lol) if I were to get "rid" if the GTO, I would never spend any money modding any other car again.
love the discussion on Smog equipement though, the whole thing you guys have of removing 02's cracks me up, after listening to how you can get 40% better economy (in theory while cruising) with the right EGR has me keen to explore that possibility too!
i wouldn't remove o2 sensors...i'd just see about getting a JDM ecu, thereby eliminating most of the problem in the first place.
you can't sit there & tell me that the cal-spec ecu's offered performance benefit over their JDM bretheren.
I really appreciate Dennis' take on cars generally, and these cars in particular; his practical experience is a great benefit and asset to the board.
I await with 'bated breath his conclusions on the matter of AEM tuning.
'DG on cars' beats the hell out of 'DG on Politics'. ;)
i wouldn't remove o2 sensors...i'd just see about getting a JDM ecu, thereby eliminating most of the problem in the first place.
you can't sit there & tell me that the cal-spec ecu's offered performance benefit over their JDM bretheren.
Sorry, not 02's...(getting tired) I meant Cat's.
After I left pro racing, I went back to the full-time Army.
I have done... a bunch of stuff... since my return; a couple of times I have been called on to instruct on basic training or trade training. This has me responsible for transforming civvies into soldiers.
And I have noticed something about the current intake: a lifetime of being told that you are a precious, special, unique snowflake; a childhood of junior soccer where nobody keeps score and everybody gets a trophy, has taught an entire generation that what matters is their opinion and that nobody is ever "wrong". Needless to say, this is a demographic that does not handle correction and conflict very well, and curing them of it can present a challenge.
This attitude shows up elsewhere, not the least on message boards.
Now some subjects are not particularly conducive to logical, measured analysis. Asthetics, for example, truly are in the eye of the beholder and no one observation can truly be said to be "right" or "wrong" (I don't find Beyonce attractive *shrug*). But physics (and its bastard cousin, engineering) don't work that way - there is a "right" or "wrong" answer, based on the operating principles of the universe.
"Opinions" don't keep bridges from collapsing. We didn't send men to the moon on the strength of warm and fuzzy feelings. And your car will get no faster based on your feelings not getting hurt.
Over and over and over again, I see "opinions" expressed which have no basis in physical reality. I see "common knowlege" trotted out as gospel fact, when none of the people involved have ever performed a single objective measurement themselves (or have never had their performance tested in an objective manner). And then when more experienced people contradict their ever-so-beloved opinions, they get all butthurt and pouty - and will go right on spouting their nonsense.
There have already been a couple of examples in the responses to these threads.
I used to be a drag racer; a bracket racer to be sure, but I built a couple of drag cars and had a degree of success at local tracks. One day I walked into Guyon Racing in Calgary and bought a book called "Tune to Win" written by a former F3000 and LeMans engineer named Carroll Smith. That book changed my life. from that point onward, I was a student of vehicle dynamics and was looking for an opportunity to go racing in which I could apply those skills. I bought all Carroll's books (plus many, many more on the subject) and when I got involved in the SCCA, applied all those principles to my operation as best I could.
In 2002, I won the SM Pro championship and the HSC championship. Then, two days later, at the amateur championship, on the same surface, at the same site, on the same tires, I went into the first turn and the car snap-spun without warning. My confidence in the car was shattered, I drove like crap, and I wound up way back in the pack. Hero to zero in 48 hours.
Now it just so happened that Carroll Smith was at the event. I approached him, told him my tale of woe, and asked him to help me figure out what was wrong with the car. How could it go from perfect to undriveable with no changes in the same conditions?
Now understand what this meant to me - the is the guy who got me started down this path. I'm not big on hero worship, but if you wanted to label him as "my racing hero" you wouldn't be that far off the mark. I had the opportunity to get help from the authority on the subject, at the site where the problems were happening.
So Carroll starts asking me questions (because he knows jack shit about Talons and he needs info to perform a diagnosis) and my answer to 80% of them is "I don't know". After about a dozen "I don't know"s, a clearly frustrated Carroll says "Well don't you think you should know these things?" and when I looked puzzled, he points at the Talon and says "Measure the damn car!" and walks off.
He stopped just short of calling me a "dumbass" but I have no doubt he was thinking it.
Did I get all butthurt? Did I go sulk in the trailer? Did I put on some Taking back Sundayand sit in the corner, sobbing and cutting myself? No I did not. I took his words to heart, and started planning a measuring and modelling program to get answers to all the questions he asked.
And those answers proved HIGHLY instructive, and not only revealed the answer to my problems, but shed light on a whole category of problems that, to that time, were completely unknown. (in particular, how badly most aftermarket shocks really sucked)
I had a toe in that water previously, but after Carroll Smith's bitchslap, I got the objective data religion in a huge, huge way - and I have never regretted it. Quite the contrary; insisting on measured data and objective comparisons in all things automotive performance has done nothing but eliminate waste - wasted time, wasted energy, and above all, wasted MONEY.
It can be expensive to test. It can be expensive to instrument, record, and analyze data. But it is far, far cheaper than doing it wrong even once (never mind multiple times).
Now sometimes things are a work in progress. Sometimes, in the process of science, initial hypothoses are presented. And quite frequently, later analysis refutes these hypothoses. Nobody is immune to being proven wrong - hell, with the EGR work I'm doing right now, I've been wrong at least three times: three times I came to conclusions that were perfectly reasonable at the time but were demonstrably WRONG when other data came to light.
Here's the thing - THAT'S OK.
Being "wrong" simply means that your expressed opinion is not in alignment with observed reality. It doesn't (necessarily) mean you are an idiot, or a bad person, or less of the Alpha Male, or whatever - it just means that your current understanding of the facts is incorrect.
That is a correctable fault. It is a transient condition - if you let it be.
It is appropriate to demand to see the data. It is perfectly reasonable to conduct your own independant observation. (in fact, I encourage such independant testing, because sometimes multiple tests reveal deeper truths). It is good to pose questions, and/or produce conflicting data (should that data be objectively collected). It does not matter WHO is right, only that the ANSWER be right - and NOBODY has a monopoly on the truth. But there is, unquestionably, a real truth to be discovered.
So, for example, to refute the statement "the C4 Corvette has a superior suspension that the 3S" with "the C4 is a rattletrap covered in cheap plastic" competely misses the mark. It is getting all butthurt and emo, instead of presenting objective facts. Facts like:
- The C4 uses a double A arm suspension (with camber compensation in roll) rather than a McStrut (with no camber compensation in roll);
- The C4 uses a transverse leaf spring, which while odd, incorporates a spring preload adjuster which can be used to corner weight the car;
- The C4's shock mounts are ideally placed so that converting from the transverse leaf spring to a proper motorsports coilover is trivial; almost entirely off-the-shelf;
- The C4 uses aluminum A-arms (on some models at least) and has minimal uprights, all of which serve to keep unsprung weight down; and
- The C4 wheelwells and suspension will swallow very wide wheels and tires with no modification
All of these are observable facts and do not rely upon "opinion".
If you are going to be in the performance car game, and ESPECIALLY if you are going to go racing, you have to learn to forget (at least temporarily) that your mama loves you and thinks everything you do is perfect. You need to be able to read something that is orthagonal to your current understanding and process the correction with your feelings not in the loop. You need to understand that, if you just dropped a shitload of money on a Tein suspension only to find out that they are utter junk after the fact that, while that is undoubtably upsetting, it is not a judgement on you as a person, and no amount of wishing otherwise will make your Teins not suck.
(It is better to do the research before laying down the cash, but sometimes you get caught out. hey, it happens.)
And understand this too - it is the refusal to accept contradiction that keeps the experienced people away from message boards, and is the primary reason why places like 3SI turn into cesspools of ignorance. Not everyone is as stubborn as I.
DG
After I left pro racing, I went back to the full-time Army.
I have done... a bunch of stuff... since my return; a couple of times I have been called on to instruct on basic training or trade training. This has me responsible for transforming civvies into soldiers.
And I have noticed something about the current intake: a lifetime of being told that you are a precious, special, unique snowflake; a childhood of junior soccer where nobody keeps score and everybody gets a trophy, has taught an entire generation that what matters is their opinion and that nobody is ever "wrong". Needless to say, this is a demographic that does not handle correction and conflict very well, and curing them of it can present a challenge.
This attitude shows up elsewhere, not the least on message boards.
Now some subjects are not particularly conducive to logical, measured analysis. Asthetics, for example, truly are in the eye of the beholder and no one observation can truly be said to be "right" or "wrong" (I don't find Beyonce attractive *shrug*). But physics (and its bastard cousin, engineering) don't work that way - there is a "right" or "wrong" answer, based on the operating principles of the universe.
"Opinions" don't keep bridges from collapsing. We didn't send men to the moon on the strength of warm and fuzzy feelings. And your car will get no faster based on your feelings not getting hurt.
Over and over and over again, I see "opinions" expressed which have no basis in physical reality. I see "common knowlege" trotted out as gospel fact, when none of the people involved have ever performed a single objective measurement themselves (or have never had their performance tested in an objective manner). And then when more experienced people contradict their ever-so-beloved opinions, they get all butthurt and pouty - and will go right on spouting their nonsense.
There have already been a couple of examples in the responses to these threads.
I used to be a drag racer; a bracket racer to be sure, but I built a couple of drag cars and had a degree of success at local tracks. One day I walked into Guyon Racing in Calgary and bought a book called "Tune to Win" written by a former F3000 and LeMans engineer named Carroll Smith. That book changed my life. from that point onward, I was a student of vehicle dynamics and was looking for an opportunity to go racing in which I could apply those skills. I bought all Carroll's books (plus many, many more on the subject) and when I got involved in the SCCA, applied all those principles to my operation as best I could.
In 2002, I won the SM Pro championship and the HSC championship. Then, two days later, at the amateur championship, on the same surface, at the same site, on the same tires, I went into the first turn and the car snap-spun without warning. My confidence in the car was shattered, I drove like crap, and I wound up way back in the pack. Hero to zero in 48 hours.
Now it just so happened that Carroll Smith was at the event. I approached him, told him my tale of woe, and asked him to help me figure out what was wrong with the car. How could it go from perfect to undriveable with no changes in the same conditions?
Now understand what this meant to me - the is the guy who got me started down this path. I'm not big on hero worship, but if you wanted to label him as "my racing hero" you wouldn't be that far off the mark. I had the opportunity to get help from the authority on the subject, at the site where the problems were happening.
So Carroll starts asking me questions (because he knows jack shit about Talons and he needs info to perform a diagnosis) and my answer to 80% of them is "I don't know". After about a dozen "I don't know"s, a clearly frustrated Carroll says "Well don't you think you should know these things?" and when I looked puzzled, he points at the Talon and says "Measure the damn car!" and walks off.
He stopped just short of calling me a "dumbass" but I have no doubt he was thinking it.
Did I get all butthurt? Did I go sulk in the trailer? Did I put on some Taking back Sundayand sit in the corner, sobbing and cutting myself? No I did not. I took his words to heart, and started planning a measuring and modelling program to get answers to all the questions he asked.
And those answers proved HIGHLY instructive, and not only revealed the answer to my problems, but shed light on a whole category of problems that, to that time, were completely unknown. (in particular, how badly most aftermarket shocks really sucked)
I had a toe in that water previously, but after Carroll Smith's bitchslap, I got the objective data religion in a huge, huge way - and I have never regretted it. Quite the contrary; insisting on measured data and objective comparisons in all things automotive performance has done nothing but eliminate waste - wasted time, wasted energy, and above all, wasted MONEY.
It can be expensive to test. It can be expensive to instrument, record, and analyze data. But it is far, far cheaper than doing it wrong even once (never mind multiple times).
Now sometimes things are a work in progress. Sometimes, in the process of science, initial hypothoses are presented. And quite frequently, later analysis refutes these hypothoses. Nobody is immune to being proven wrong - hell, with the EGR work I'm doing right now, I've been wrong at least three times: three times I came to conclusions that were perfectly reasonable at the time but were demonstrably WRONG when other data came to light.
Here's the thing - THAT'S OK.
Being "wrong" simply means that your expressed opinion is not in alignment with observed reality. It doesn't (necessarily) mean you are an idiot, or a bad person, or less of the Alpha Male, or whatever - it just means that your current understanding of the facts is incorrect.
That is a correctable fault. It is a transient condition - if you let it be.
It is appropriate to demand to see the data. It is perfectly reasonable to conduct your own independant observation. (in fact, I encourage such independant testing, because sometimes multiple tests reveal deeper truths). It is good to pose questions, and/or produce conflicting data (should that data be objectively collected). It does not matter WHO is right, only that the ANSWER be right - and NOBODY has a monopoly on the truth. But there is, unquestionably, a real truth to be discovered.
So, for example, to refute the statement "the C4 Corvette has a superior suspension that the 3S" with "the C4 is a rattletrap covered in cheap plastic" competely misses the mark. It is getting all butthurt and emo, instead of presenting objective facts. Facts like:
- The C4 uses a double A arm suspension (with camber compensation in roll) rather than a McStrut (with no camber compensation in roll);
- The C4 uses a transverse leaf spring, which while odd, incorporates a spring preload adjuster which can be used to corner weight the car;
- The C4's shock mounts are ideally placed so that converting from the transverse leaf spring to a proper motorsports coilover is trivial; almost entirely off-the-shelf;
- The C4 uses aluminum A-arms (on some models at least) and has minimal uprights, all of which serve to keep unsprung weight down; and
- The C4 wheelwells and suspension will swallow very wide wheels and tires with no modification
All of these are observable facts and do not rely upon "opinion".
If you are going to be in the performance car game, and ESPECIALLY if you are going to go racing, you have to learn to forget (at least temporarily) that your mama loves you and thinks everything you do is perfect. You need to be able to read something that is orthagonal to your current understanding and process the correction with your feelings not in the loop. You need to understand that, if you just dropped a shitload of money on a Tein suspension only to find out that they are utter junk after the fact that, while that is undoubtably upsetting, it is not a judgement on you as a person, and no amount of wishing otherwise will make your Teins not suck.
(It is better to do the research before laying down the cash, but sometimes you get caught out. hey, it happens.)
And understand this too - it is the refusal to accept contradiction that keeps the experienced people away from message boards, and is the primary reason why places like 3SI turn into cesspools of ignorance. Not everyone is as stubborn as I.
DG
Great post, Dennis.
You still don't know dick about American politics. :D
CoopKill
07-04-2011, 03:44 PM
Waiting on #6...
There is no sadder statement than "Too long; didn't read".
Not all truths can be squished into a tweet.
DG
NOMIEZVR4
07-04-2011, 04:23 PM
Hey DG, GREAT POST!!!
Its like reading the factory brochure for what Mitsu intended for the 3000GT when it was developed late in the 80's and early 90's..I really enjoyed reading it!! :D
Though the ABS, AWS, and Emissions crap on my car is gone...and its not coming back.
Nomie
*utterly confused as to why DG hangs out here with the 3/s crowd, rather than on "legit" racing forums where he and his like-minded cronies cohort.*
i mean, after all, the 3/s is a GTO...not a race-car; so why bother sharing the "hardcore racing" lessons-learned with people who cling tenaciously to a car that's "decidedly not" a race car? for that matter, those who do feel that the 3/s is a GTO...are likely attracted to what the spirit of a GT is; so they mod their cars accordingly. after all, the 3/s is the "swiss-army-knife" of sports cars, so who really cares if it's the best at any one thing?
if your not hardcore enough to gut your car, why should you care extensively what coilovers you choose--provided that they offer a comfortable ride & acceptable aesthetic value? are some coilovers better than others? certainly, and without a doubt. is that sufficient to justify arguing that there is one and only one proper way to modify any given car? hell no.
DG, i've seen your posts about coilovers. i'm not saying you're wrong; it's true that some are better than others. what i am saying is that your average owner (especially a 3/s owner, who cares about more than just hardcore performance) doesn't derive the benefits you ascribe to such things. most owners know of suspension by how hard or how soft each pothole hits them in the ass--and that's it. preaching the gospel to the nth degree to someone who has no need of or desire to learn it is decidedly futile.
even if your research could be counted as biblical truth, companies change. product lines change. mobil 1 may have been the shiz-nett 30 years ago...but it's not nearly the same today. it's the same with practically everything. ohlins may be great today...but 5 years from now, who knows? putting in "requisite research" for something like coilovers is very much worth the effort to hardcore racers. it's a very tenuous proposition for casual drivers and weekend warriors.
RealMcCoy
07-04-2011, 05:06 PM
I love an informative read that is fact based and backed up... Thank you.
I for one welcome an objective view on these cars. I may go ahead and waste money and time in it making it into what it never was intended to be, but I do it with a full realization that it's an emotional choice due to the love of a particular car or platform. Posts like yours do a great service to those that may have a blurred understanding of the difference.
I'm particularly interested in your findings on the EGR thing... I'm certainly on board with your thinking, but have no real opportunity to do any R&D myself. I hope you'll share when you get it lined out.
I found your e-book on your linked webpage. Spend some time poking through it this morning. very good read as well. Found my quote of the day in there, and got a good LOL:
A McStrut FWD is pretty much the perfect storm of suck when it comes to tradeoffs between maximum cornering and maximum straight-line acceleration.
StealthyStu
07-04-2011, 06:37 PM
This thread is awesome! I've owned my Stealth since summer of '05. When I bought my car I knew absolutely nothing about it. Learning as much as I have has been a long, slow process and I know I'm still very far behind lots of my closest friends. I'm working on a mechanical engineering degree right now. I graduate in August (sweet!) and this thread is interesting to me for even more reasons because of my engineering background. There are so many things that are said on 3Sgto without evidence, and aftermarket parts that are sold without performance data. A good chunk of the 3S knowledge that I've picked up has been learned on hearsay which is a scary thought. DG and other people with his experience in racing circuits and automotive engineering can teach this platform about the proper way to transform a car.
I appreciate the effort put in by DG to share the knowledge. Your posts read like a book :)
dbest671
07-04-2011, 06:48 PM
This has to be one of the best threads I have read in a very long time. +1 to you.
n2nsanity
07-04-2011, 07:44 PM
I agree with you on most of what you're saying. I don't think many are trying to build full out race cars here and most are going for light to moderate mods.
I don't really consider them race cars either and like you said there are much more efficient platforms. But with enough money, time and work, you can turn any car into anything you want.
I don't have either, so my goal for mine is to be quick and look good doing it. I've been a fan of the 3/s platform for nearly 20 years and still think they are some of the sexiest cars ever made.
I still have the picture I cut out from an article I read in the paper when the 94 vr4 came out.
UTRacerX9
07-05-2011, 12:51 AM
Being "wrong" simply means that your expressed opinion is not in alignment with observed reality. It doesn't (necessarily) mean you are an idiot, or a bad person, or less of the Alpha Male, or whatever - it just means that your current understanding of the facts is incorrect.
So, for example, to refute the statement "the C4 Corvette has a superior suspension that the 3S" with "the C4 is a rattletrap covered in cheap plastic" competely misses the mark. It is getting all butthurt and emo, instead of presenting objective facts. Facts like:
- The C4 uses a double A arm suspension (with camber compensation in roll) rather than a McStrut (with no camber compensation in roll);
- The C4 uses a transverse leaf spring, which while odd, incorporates a spring preload adjuster which can be used to corner weight the car;
- The C4's shock mounts are ideally placed so that converting from the transverse leaf spring to a proper motorsports coilover is trivial; almost entirely off-the-shelf;
- The C4 uses aluminum A-arms (on some models at least) and has minimal uprights, all of which serve to keep unsprung weight down; and
- The C4 wheelwells and suspension will swallow very wide wheels and tires with no modification
All of these are observable facts and do not rely upon "opinion".
DG
Since you chose to quote me, I'll respond. I didn't think I would NEED to give you detailed facts regarding a car that you say has a better suspension than the 3S, since every magazine that ever compared the two gave the nod to the 3S. Let's see, .89g vs .93 for the 3/S seems to be pretty factual to me.
The 3/S has a multilink rear suspension that is a decade more advanced than the Corvette. The AWD system keeps the car planted extremely well and is far less likely to spin. Here's an article from Car and Driver, which was probably the magazine most biased AGAINST the 3/S, and we see that the 3/S won in the handling department, emergency lane change maneuver, bested only by the RX7 which weighed 1000 lbs less, and kicked the Corvettes ass in braking by 15 ft from 70mph, using 245 tires vs the Corvette having 275 all around.
http://www.derekspratt.com/PDFs/Automotive/1994%20Toyota%20Supra/Car%20&%20Driver%20-%20Toyota%20Supra%20-%20September%201993.pdf
By the way, I love how some of your points regarding the Corvette suspension rely on UPGRADING to perform better. The C4 has an outdated suspension compared to the 3S, end of story. Oh, and a chassis that dates back to 1982, which is notorious for flexing over nearly every pebble in the road.
Now, if you want to get "butthurt and emo" that your statement that the C4 has a better suspension is false, that's your problem. On the racetrack, the C4 was 1 second faster, and that is due to better power to weight ratio, NOT on the basis of a better suspension.
Chris GTO TT
07-05-2011, 02:27 AM
I'm interested in your 'facts' showing the Tein coil overs are crap.
yeahhhh nooo I have had bad experiances with Teins...would never do that again.
The 3/S has a multilink rear suspension that is a decade more advanced than the Corvette. The AWD system keeps the car planted extremely well and is far less likely to spin. Here's an article from Car and Driver, which was probably the magazine most biased AGAINST the 3/S, and we see that the 3/S won in the handling department, emergency lane change maneuver, bested only by the RX7 which weighed 1000 lbs less, and kicked the Corvettes ass in braking by 15 ft from 70mph, using 245 tires vs the Corvette having 275 all around.
http://www.derekspratt.com/PDFs/Automotive/1994%20Toyota%20Supra/Car%20&%20Driver%20-%20Toyota%20Supra%20-%20September%201993.pdf
By the way, I love how some of your points regarding the Corvette suspension rely on UPGRADING to perform better. The C4 has an outdated suspension compared to the 3S, end of story. Oh, and a chassis that dates back to 1982, which is notorious for flexing over nearly every pebble in the road.
Now, if you want to get "butthurt and emo" that your statement that the C4 has a better suspension is false, that's your problem. On the racetrack, the C4 was 1 second faster, and that is due to better power to weight ratio, NOT on the basis of a better suspension.
I think DG's point is easily discerned.
Very simply, if a working and workable racing suspension is the desired result, The C4 Corvette was the far better starting point.
While a 3S was more capable in OEM form, it literally could not be properly adapted for racing use owing to the extra weight and the specialized suspension's resistance to off-the-shelf mods.
The Corvette, on the other hand, lent itself quite well to race-type suspension upgrades.
Again - the stipulation was, 'If you're going to build a racer...'
BigTyla
07-05-2011, 02:22 PM
Now some subjects are not particularly conducive to logical, measured analysis. Asthetics, for example, truly are in the eye of the beholder and no one observation can truly be said to be "right" or "wrong" (I don't find Beyonce attractive *shrug*). But physics (and its bastard cousin, engineering) don't work that way - there is a "right" or "wrong" answer, based on the operating principles of the universe.
This needs to be a sticky above every section of every automotive forum in existence.
This needs to be a sticky above every section of every automotive forum in existence.
Quite right - the only true 'option' should be color.
lawdogg
07-05-2011, 03:20 PM
Great thread!!!!!
DG's posts reflect upon a number of the reasons why I've decided to make my Miata my dedicated race car and not my Stealth. Cost, also, being not the least significant reason.
Great thread!!!!!
DG's posts reflect upon a number of the reasons why I've decided to make my Miata my dedicated race car and not my Stealth. Cost, also, being not the least significant reason.
this is the only miata i would even remotely consider owning.
http://i917.photobucket.com/albums/ad14/Mafiaman09/fastback.jpg?t=1254535596
BigTyla
07-05-2011, 03:43 PM
Great thread!!!!!
DG's posts reflect upon a number of the reasons why I've decided to make my Miata my dedicated race car and not my Stealth. Cost, also, being not the least significant reason.
I remember when everyone used to tell all the n/a guys to get a TT to solve all of their problems. Now when TT owners ask how to make their car into a racecar, perhaps we should tell them to buy a Miata or DSM. :p
I remember when everyone used to tell all the n/a guys to get a TT to solve all of their problems. Now when TT owners ask how to make their car into a racecar, perhaps we should tell them to buy a Miata or DSM. :p
not a dsm. weren't you paying attention when DG explained that?
Jimvr4
07-05-2011, 05:11 PM
Years ago I ran my 91 VR4 in a two day Miata sponsored event and they hated me. I passed or held them off during all the straight sections but in the curves they were faster. Brakes on a Miata can be made crazy good in comparison with a 3S.
BigTyla
07-05-2011, 05:25 PM
not a dsm. weren't you paying attention when DG explained that?
Not really. Needless to say I don't take everything he says as the end-all-be-all.
Dbeltran24
07-05-2011, 06:38 PM
subscribed. :)
Not really. Needless to say I don't take everything he says as the end-all-be-all.
oh believe me, i agree with you. i'm grateful to have his experiences and his lessons learned therein. it still baffles me why he wants to share them with us though. we're (in his own words) not a race-car platform.
the whole debate on suspension is a pet-peeve of mine. i support what he's saying, and i understand the logic in it. i also feel that for average/casual usage, the effort, time and money it takes to "research" what he would deem as "acceptable" is well beyond the point of diminishing returns for most people. fire & forget, inexpensive coilover kits are sufficient to make the bulk of owners happy--regardless of whatever stress-testing dyno results say.
hell it's like turbos. yes, dr750's are the best td04 turbos (at least currently)...but that doesn't mean that an owner can't be happy with 13g's or 13t's.
RealMcCoy
07-06-2011, 12:55 AM
hell it's like turbos. yes, dr750's are the best td04 turbos (at least currently)...but that doesn't mean that an owner can't be happy with 13g's or 13t's.
I get what you are saying, but I have to admit I've come away from his writings(primarily his website rather than his forum posts) with a different feeling of what he's trying to say. Primarily that the vast majority of shock systems he's tested are a downgrade from stock... In your above example, it would be like trying to find something that performs worse than a 9B, and calling it an upgrade.
I have no personal knowledge of the validity of those statements, but as he is the only person I know that's ever tested the different systems on a shock dyno, I have no reason to doubt him.
AdamVR4
07-06-2011, 12:57 AM
I get what you are saying, but I have to admit I've come away from his writings(primarily his website rather than his forum posts) with a different feeling of what he's trying to say. Primarily that the vast majority of shock systems he's tested are a downgrade from stock... In your above example, it would be like trying to find something that performs worse than a 9B, and calling it an upgrade.
Did I miss the link?
RealMcCoy
07-06-2011, 01:05 AM
Did I miss the link?
He did link it in post #1, but here it is again:
Far North Racing - Home (http://farnorthracing.com/)
AdamVR4
07-06-2011, 01:48 AM
He did link it in post #1, but here it is again:
Far North Racing - Home (http://farnorthracing.com/)
This is what I was interested in and it took a fair amount of time to find, haha....
Far North Racing - The Car - ShockTek to Bilstein Conversion (http://farnorthracing.com/shocks_2.html)
Gearhead
07-06-2011, 03:40 AM
I just ordered all three of Carrol Smiths books. :p
I get what you are saying, but I have to admit I've come away from his writings(primarily his website rather than his forum posts) with a different feeling of what he's trying to say. Primarily that the vast majority of shock systems he's tested are a downgrade from stock... In your above example, it would be like trying to find something that performs worse than a 9B, and calling it an upgrade.
I have no personal knowledge of the validity of those statements, but as he is the only person I know that's ever tested the different systems on a shock dyno, I have no reason to doubt him.
again though, regardless of what dyno results say, if the owner feels that the performance of the new parts is sufficiently satisfactory...why argue with that? sure, if you downgrade from 9b's, you can feel the car be slower. swapping in coilovers isn't like that. the car doesn't "feel worse" to people--and if it did, they'd be liable to change their setup again.
my car, for instance, feels firmer in the corners now; and it doesn't "float" around on the suspension as much as it used to. (not to mention that the reduction in travel has finally stopped shredding my goddamn tires. now you can dyno that shit all you want, comparing it to stock or whatever--but the fact remains that my end-user analysis is that the coilovers are functioning BETTER than the OEM bits that i took off. maybe that's because the OEM bits are past their service live. maybe that's because the AWD conversion compromised the ability of the OEM stuff to work sufficiently well. i don't know. what i do know is that with the coilovers, the car feels and handles better than it did previously.
So you're saying his shock dyno was a 'mustang' shock dyno?
i'm not making any judgments about the quality/caliber of his tests. all i am saying is that removing the used, OEM stuff and replacing it with the d2 coilovers resulted in much better handling on my car...from my perspective. do better solutions exist? certainly. for about the same amount of money? debatable. but it's not worth it (for me, in this particular case) to invest that level of effort to divine it.
again, from what i can deduce, DG's entire point of creating this thread is because of those (who like me) take issue with how he presents the material--NOT with the content thereof. yes, if you are competing, you certainly should pay attention to the finer details--and DG's advice is most apt. what i have issue with is the notion that "this is the only correct way to do things"--regardless of user demand.
my car is a DD. maybe once per year, it might make it to the dragstrip. i've yet to take it to a road course--and i don't know if i ever will. so yes, from DG's perspective i'm "settling" for performance. and so what? do you yourselves constantly second-guess your personal relationships because you think there "might be someone better out there"? "good enough, and i'm happy with that" is sufficient for me. leave the "high and mighty" pomposity BS out of it.
vr3.9
07-06-2011, 10:53 AM
I find this thread very interesting and am all in for more info. I think the above suspension posts may reveal some of what DG is trying to help with. Just because your suspension feels better to you and seems to handle better is still just a subjective perception. Obviously if you like it then on one hand that's all that matters. However, suspension has 2 specific functions, increase traction decrease vibration/movement. Both of these are measurable factual quantities. A well tuned suspension may feel less functional because it's doing its job so well that going through the corner just doesn't feel as fast. Also I believe it's difficult to spend money, time and work on an upgrade to be very objective about it afterwards. I remember after buying a complete upgraded suspension system for my 80 vette it was very difficult for me to objectively back up and admit that it was just way too bouncy and really not good at all.
AdamVR4
07-06-2011, 11:06 AM
Where's the data supporting DG's position that Teins suck?
BigTyla
07-06-2011, 11:43 AM
Where's the data supporting DG's position that Teins suck?
I would be interested in this as well.
VR-4ever
07-06-2011, 12:06 PM
If you have to have the best lap times to be happy, buy the typical spec-miata or C5. Hope that no one on track is faster than you.
If you have to have the fastest ET to be happy, buy a notchback. Hope that no one at the dragstrip is faster than you.
If you simply enjoy being an automotive enthusiast, you're in luck, buy whatever car that interests you / makes you happy.
Sure, there's a difference between great expectations and sobering actual real-life data. Knowledge is good. But knowing why you're in this hobby to begin with is key.
keep in mind that even with comprehensive, convincing, accurate, analytical results...a test is only as good as a snapshot in time. making a judgment call on a brand, unilaterally and without deliberate time-restraints, is as fallacious as thinking that products never improve or deteriorate.
i doubt very much that testing of any given brand of motor oil from 5 years ago will match the same brand of oil if tested today. the same holds true for most every product.
mb3000
07-06-2011, 02:10 PM
For racing purposes, the actual racing is the testing. You swap from a quality "stock like" setup DG described in his other thread, to Tien coilover's.
Now your new Tien's might be a total hack job in comparison to other setups, but if you can drop your lap times when using them than they have served their purpose.
Every racer will have a different feeling as to what the "right" suspension feels like. It's up to you to find it.
For racing purposes, the actual racing is the testing. You swap from a quality "stock like" setup DG described in his other thread, to Tien coilover's.
Now your new Tien's might be a total hack job in comparison to other setups, but if you can drop your lap times when using them than they have served their purpose.
Every racer will have a different feeling as to what the "right" suspension feels like. It's up to you to find it.
that's a wild stab at it, but it's not accurate. you need to eliminate the human factor from the equation for the results to be accurate.
mb3000
07-07-2011, 12:23 AM
In a racing application, what could matter more than - lap times?
Steve '92ES
07-07-2011, 12:59 AM
In a racing application, what could matter more than - lap times?
Avoiding the wall??
mb3000
07-07-2011, 01:12 AM
http://www.decaljunky.com/images/Product/medium/7914.jpg
:lol:
In a racing application, what could matter more than - lap times?
well if you can consistently drive faster laps, then i suppose it's sufficient proof. you'd have to have an established time, backed up with consistent results. the problem is, the more you drive a course, the better you get at it (under normal circumstances). so it's hard to weed out the human improvement factor from the mechanical improvement factor.
now i suppose that if you modded in reverse, and put the OEM stuff back on AFTER you did several laps with the coilovers...you could use that as a "control-group" compraison. if you drove slower in this scenario, that would be sufficient proof.
p.s.
keep in mind though, track conditions change from hour to hour, day to day. if the ambient conditions aren't exactly the same...and the mechanical mods on the car aren't exactly the same--you don't really have an apples to apples comparison.
DocWalt
07-07-2011, 09:45 AM
When you're in a racing series that uses a points system for mods where coilovers cost, say, 10 points. You'd want the best damn coilovers you can squeeze into the rules to maximize your use of those 10 points.
Coilovers are not at all necessary for street use. They're not even necessary for track use. They can greatly improve your car's performance in both situations, or they can reduce the performance. A super stiff track coilover isn't going to be ideal for street use and can cause handling issues over poor road surfaces that you wouldn't find on a track, but that same super stiff coilover could be fantastic for the track.
There ARE coilovers out there that are a very good combination of street and track performance. If you pick street or track performance to tune to though, the other area will still suffer.
Geordon
07-08-2011, 03:08 PM
It's like a checklist for the 3S, isn't it?
- Hot styling? Well there are certainly lots of Ferrari influences (and Viper influences on the Stealth)
- Power? Right at the Japanese power limit.
Here's a sidebar preview from the March 1990 issue of a more popular (non-automotive) magazine.
2911
looks like a cross between 1g and 2g skirts. i like it.
Gearhead
07-08-2011, 04:42 PM
looks like a cross between 1g and 2g skirts. i like it.
And look at the size of those wheels!
And look at the size of those wheels!
yeah, the wheels on concept cars are always better looking than the production ones.
Geordon
07-08-2011, 05:34 PM
Glad you guys like it. Took me quite awhile to dig through back issues. I replaced the image with one which wasn't scaled down as much (75% of original scan vs 50%).
TT Eric
10-22-2011, 08:41 PM
Where is Bitch #7 ??
#6 was the last DG's post on the forum, never posted anything else since then!
I always liked his post/thread, from NABR to here, they come from hard gained experience and it's very interesting to read.
Eric
Powered by vBulletin® Version 4.2.3 Copyright © 2026 vBulletin Solutions, Inc. All rights reserved.