View Full Version : Hybrid fuel mileage
DuTTch
03-07-2011, 01:56 AM
Hybrid this hybrid that, are these cars really getting that good gas mileage? If they are using e85 in that mix for stating that they get 42 miles to the gallon for example, I know for a fact that im getting about 40% less miles per gallon on that stuff. so if a gallon of e85 is $3.00 and lets say it takes 30% more e85 every gallon the price will eb $4.00 right. I am just not seeing this correctly? What am I missing.
Chris GTO TT
03-07-2011, 02:50 AM
You have about 3 different topics in that question.
First hybrids highway mileage is based mostly off of tricks in aerodynamics and a very fuel efficient gasoline engine. Their city mileage is based off of the fact they can accelerate from a stop with no or limited help from a gas engine. Since accelerating worse for gas mileage than maintaining a speed using electricity helps lower gas usage. Also hybrids use start stop technology so the engine doesnt idle at stoplights wasting even more gas. Idling is one of the least fuel efficient things you can do.
Ethanol in gas has some interesting effects, I've read more than one study that argues we should remove all ethanol from gasoline because we end up polluting more and using more gasoline due to its incorporation in gas. Ethanol has less energy per gallon than gasoline but a higher resistance to knock. When you mix them as in E10 or E85 you need more fuel to achieve the same power levels (worse fuel economy) but it can allow higher timing and compression so that allows more power. CA only uses E10 gas and I track my fuel mileage using Fuelly | Share and Compare Your MPG (http://www.fuelly.com) my Maxima should be able to attain 25-26mpg on the hwy easily but because of the lower gasoline content in our fuel I sometimes struggle to get 23mpg in mostly highway driving.
What do these two topics combined mean...Hybrids use lots of tricks to get 'better mileage' but when you combine them with E10 fuel their advertised mileage will drop drastically.
I believe that it takes about 33% more E85 to run a car. so if the E85 isnt 33% cheaper you are still better of getting the 100% gas (assuming its even available where you live)
R/T93
03-07-2011, 03:42 AM
America's tactics for developing "fuel efficient vehicles" has failed miserably. It's criminal. There are dozens and dozens of European cars that get over 50 mpg, yet a medium sedan's mileage in America is deemed "good" at 30 mpg. There was a top gear episode, they drove like 800 miles on one tank of gas....in a FULL SIZE JAGUAR, it got like 50 mpg, like a 3 liter diesel. There was another car in the group that got 70+ mpg, it was even decent looking and I am sure better quality than any shitty Toyota Echo or something crappy like that, had a 1.3 liter diesel. There is no reason these cars arent available in America other than auto makers refusing to actually use the technology they know just for their oil buddies to make more money.
colt45 gto
03-07-2011, 04:40 AM
we got a peugeot 306 HDi its a 2L turbo diesel and its averaging 40mpg round town it getting around 50-55mpg on a highway use. so i dunno about the hybrid thing i think its a fallacy!
DocWalt
03-07-2011, 09:23 AM
The problem is, fat Americans want nothing to do with a "real" fuel saving car. They want nothing to do with diesel. They want nothing to do with not driving like total assholes. Every Prius driver I see is a jackass; not one of them drives sensibly to save gas. "Oh, it's ok, I drive a Prius!" If they wanted to save money, they wouldn't be driving a Prius.
Hym3n
03-07-2011, 11:05 AM
My '88 CRX averages 40mpg in mixed city/hwy driving. Best I have ever gotten was 47.8mpg over a long stretch of 80mph interstate-only driving. At 65mph I would've probably crested 50mpg.
I see the new CR-Z driving around and I have to ask... Why?
KeithMac
03-07-2011, 11:51 AM
VW Polo Blue Motion diesel in the UK gets 70+mpg combined.. The new VW Passat Blue motion can do 1000 miles to a tank of diesel.
colt45 gto
03-07-2011, 12:24 PM
haha thats because they see diesel as slow and sluggish unless its a 7L cat or cummins engine. our little 2L is a lot quicker off the mark than a prius.
and for the prius drivers.....the diesel produces coal dust not toxic fumes and its cheaper on the environment to produce ;)
i am very tempted to slot a 3L TD mercedes engine, gearbox into the gto. it wont loose much umph and be twice as good on fuel :)
Ethanol in gas has some interesting effects, I've read more than one study that argues we should remove all ethanol from gasoline because we end up polluting more and using more gasoline due to its incorporation in gas. Ethanol has less energy per gallon than gasoline but a higher resistance to knock. When you mix them as in E10 or E85 you need more fuel to achieve the same power levels (worse fuel economy) but it can allow higher timing and compression so that allows more power. CA only uses E10 gas and I track my fuel mileage using Fuelly | Share and Compare Your MPG (http://www.fuelly.com) my Maxima should be able to attain 25-26mpg on the hwy easily but because of the lower gasoline content in our fuel I sometimes struggle to get 23mpg in mostly highway driving.
I've always thought that the E10 gas was a complete scam. 1- Ethanol production in the US uses more than 1 gallon of gasoline to produce 1 gallon of ethanol. 2- Adding ethanol increases octane, so the oil companies can use a cheaper-to-produce, lower octane fuel as the fuel base. 3- Most vehicles see reduced efficiency and lower fuel mileage with E10.
E10 gas is not good for the consumer or the environment. Oil companies are the only real beneficiary. It ultimately increases fuel consumption and lowers costs for them. This unfortunately is a case of the oil companies and government instituting an unjust law that benefits them and hurts everyone else. They tell us that we are helping the environment, bolstering the US economy, and reducing our dependence on foreign oil, while, behind closed doors, they laugh at our stupidity and gullibility. This has become somewhat normal practice for our government and it's pretty sad.
The "safety laws" that almost require a compact car to weigh 2 tons to comply are much the same thing. How the hell are you going to require every car to meet government safety standards? If the consumer wants to buy a less safe and more fuel efficient car, that should be their choice.
i3igpete
03-07-2011, 05:18 PM
My '88 CRX averages 40mpg in mixed city/hwy driving. Best I have ever gotten was 47.8mpg over a long stretch of 80mph interstate-only driving. At 65mph I would've probably crested 50mpg.
I see the new CR-Z driving around and I have to ask... Why?
because NHTSA requires 50 airbags and the ability to survive getting run over by a tank, so this inevitably adds a ton of weight
DocWalt
03-07-2011, 05:46 PM
because NHTSA requires 50 airbags and the ability to survive getting run over by a tank, so this inevitably adds a ton of weight
Protecting ourselves from ourselves. If cars weren't so heavy, we could get away with less safety crap.
DuTTch
03-07-2011, 09:07 PM
so a flex fuel car is not a hybrid? Can a hybrid be a flex fuel car or are they always electric con gaz? I need to egt educated here quick with these rising gas prices lol.
VR-4 0wnz j00
03-07-2011, 09:48 PM
I calculated it a couple years ago but it would like close to 10 years of driving a Prius to justify buying one vs buying a base model civic. That included the costs of both cars and gas mileage. Plus, you have to worry about replacing the batteries of a Prius but the civic should be good for 300k miles.
Nytron
03-07-2011, 09:51 PM
Hybrid vehicle technology is in it's early early stages still.
They have not beaten the mileage of the 1989 honda crx. I'd still rather have a jetta tdi than a prius, about the same mpg if not better with the tdi.
Chris GTO TT
03-07-2011, 09:52 PM
so a flex fuel car is not a hybrid? Can a hybrid be a flex fuel car or are they always electric con gaz? I need to egt educated here quick with these rising gas prices lol.
As far as I know no current hybrids are 'Flex Fuel.' Flex Fuel, E85, is an even bigger scam by both the US car manufacturers and the corn growers. E85 is a way for car manufacturers to artificially inflate their CAFE numbers. When a car is Flex Fuel capable the manufacturers are only required to report the mpg based off of how far the car travels on gasoline only, basically all the ethanol miles are free and count as nearly infinite MPG.
Also instead of using food to feed people (even the poor people here in the US) we throw it away and use it to create fuel for cars at an enormous expense to consumers of both food and gasoline. And just to top it off these farmers only grow corn simply because the Federal Government pays them to grow it...then they sell it and make more money.
Chris GTO TT
03-07-2011, 09:55 PM
I calculated it a couple years ago but it would like close to 10 years of driving a Prius to justify buying one vs buying a base model civic. That included the costs of both cars and gas mileage. Plus, you have to worry about replacing the batteries of a Prius but the civic should be good for 300k miles.
Yes but they are making an environmental statement with their nickle based batteries that use strip mining to harvest their raw materials. Building a hybrid is anything but green or environmental.
CoopKill
03-07-2011, 10:21 PM
It's all called marketing!
The news reports it and the puppets buy it...
TurboSinceBirth
03-08-2011, 01:36 AM
My 1.9L Jetta TDI gets about 38 city 46 highway. I've gotten as bad as 31.5 when it was below freezing and the whole tank I made short trips 10 miles or less. I can't start the car up and expect it to warm up in the winter time. It will never even get to 120 degrees! I just get in and drive. It's pretty sad how many euro cars are more fuel efficient.
colt45 gto
03-08-2011, 01:32 PM
My 1.9L Jetta TDI gets about 38 city 46 highway. I've gotten as bad as 31.5 when it was below freezing and the whole tank I made short trips 10 miles or less. I can't start the car up and expect it to warm up in the winter time. It will never even get to 120 degrees! I just get in and drive. It's pretty sad how many euro cars are more fuel efficient.
most european cars are complete shite! Italy make diabolical cars except lambo's, france produce some shit too but the peugeot (unbias report) have been making the best small bore diesel engine since time began, its pretty robust and does good MPG. Citreon are just crap but they have the peugeot diesel engine (or used to have), renualt are a complete fail with a company motto of (its not a fault its a feature). seat are now owned by VAG along with many other manufacturers.
but worst of all are those damn fords! they still haven't figured out how to make a car go 4 mile without filling up!
Chris GTO TT
03-08-2011, 04:41 PM
most european cars are complete shite! Italy make diabolical cars except lambo's, france produce some shit too but the peugeot (unbias report) have been making the best small bore diesel engine since time began, its pretty robust and does good MPG. Citreon are just crap but they have the peugeot diesel engine (or used to have), renualt are a complete fail with a company motto of (its not a fault its a feature). seat are now owned by VAG along with many other manufacturers.
but worst of all are those damn fords! they still haven't figured out how to make a car go 4 mile without filling up!
So the Fiesta, Focus and Mondeo get worse mpg than a semi truck?
Odd considering they are 3 of the top selling cars in Europe.....
Sent from my PC36100 using Tapatalk
colt45 gto
03-08-2011, 04:47 PM
they get worse mileage than other equivalents. so no they really aint that great its just people stuck in their ways.
we got the results of our fuel consumption on the peugeot....79.5mpg which i think its fcuking outstanding!
KeithMac
03-08-2011, 04:53 PM
Our Ford Focus 1.8 Duratorq get`s 47mpg combined, not bad at all..
As far as I know no current hybrids are 'Flex Fuel.' Flex Fuel, E85, is an even bigger scam by both the US car manufacturers and the corn growers. E85 is a way for car manufacturers to artificially inflate their CAFE numbers. When a car is Flex Fuel capable the manufacturers are only required to report the mpg based off of how far the car travels on gasoline only, basically all the ethanol miles are free and count as nearly infinite MPG.
Also instead of using food to feed people (even the poor people here in the US) we throw it away and use it to create fuel for cars at an enormous expense to consumers of both food and gasoline. And just to top it off these farmers only grow corn simply because the Federal Government pays them to grow it...then they sell it and make more money.
At least in the case of e85, we get a cheap race fuel. Still bullshit, but at least someone that isn't lining the pockets of politicians can benefit. Hardly "environmentally friendly" though.
I saw news about gasoline produced by algae several years ago here:
Sapphire Energy unveils world?s first renewable gasoline (http://www.sapphireenergy.com/press-article/67406-sapphire-energy-unveils-world-s-first-renewable/22042-corporate)
That looked promising, but I had a feeling that could be difficult on a large enough scale and figured the oil companies would not be happy with such discoveries. I cringed watching commercials in the last year where exxon-mobile "scientists" were speaking like they had discovered this. This makes me think that something like this will not see the light of day until the oil companies can profit from it themselves. It makes me sick when greed hinders innovation.
most european cars are complete shite! Italy make diabolical cars except lambo's, france produce some shit too but the peugeot (unbias report) have been making the best small bore diesel engine since time began, its pretty robust and does good MPG. Citreon are just crap but they have the peugeot diesel engine (or used to have), renualt are a complete fail with a company motto of (its not a fault its a feature). seat are now owned by VAG along with many other manufacturers.
but worst of all are those damn fords! they still haven't figured out how to make a car go 4 mile without filling up!
Are you talking about reliability or performance? If it's reliability, that's no good. If it is performance though, you need to remember that the person that wants 50+ mpg does not really want or need to go fast. He most likely just wants a vessel to carry himself, his family, and his things from place to place. Many of us here would find it unacceptable for a car to take 20 seconds to get to 60 and top out at 75, but that type of vehicle is fine for the majority of people. I think the main complaint is that many newer, small, cheesy cars in the us still manage to get relatively crappy fuel mileage, while the European small cars just seem to be more efficient as a whole. I mean, you talk of fords having poor fuel mileage, but the focus is probably one of our better vehicles in that category.
x2percentmilk
03-08-2011, 10:53 PM
A regular diesel volkswagen bluemotion polo gets like 75-90 mpg. That was enough for me to not give a rats ass about hybrids.
colt45 gto
03-09-2011, 03:57 AM
Are you talking about reliability or performance? If it's reliability, that's no good. If it is performance though, you need to remember that the person that wants 50+ mpg does not really want or need to go fast. He most likely just wants a vessel to carry himself, his family, and his things from place to place. Many of us here would find it unacceptable for a car to take 20 seconds to get to 60 and top out at 75, but that type of vehicle is fine for the majority of people. I think the main complaint is that many newer, small, cheesy cars in the us still manage to get relatively crappy fuel mileage, while the European small cars just seem to be more efficient as a whole. I mean, you talk of fords having poor fuel mileage, but the focus is probably one of our better vehicles in that category.
build quality, reliability and fuel economy. why would i be talking about performance in a fuel saving thread?
DuTTch
03-09-2011, 02:22 PM
how much is the diesel in europe on average, per gallon?
KeithMac
03-09-2011, 05:10 PM
£1.32 a litre at the moment.. Super Unleaded is £1.35/l or more..
build quality, reliability and fuel economy. why would i be talking about performance in a fuel saving thread?
I think I misread one of your earlier posts about Americans thinking diesels are slow and sluggish. Just skimming it, I thought it said they are slow and sluggish. My fault.
Powered by vBulletin® Version 4.2.3 Copyright © 2026 vBulletin Solutions, Inc. All rights reserved.