PDA

View Full Version : BC 280's have issues and Ray Rocks!



Ninja Performance
05-03-2013, 11:17 PM
Long read but worth it.

So as some may know I am working on Courtney's car. Had to replace all the old braided SS lines as they were all leaking like a sieve everywhere. Old lines just not E85 compatible.

So got that all done and also replaced the fuel filter element that was paper with a stainless steel element, replaced the old PTE 1000s injectors with new Deatschwerks 1000s since they would be full of disintegrated fuel hose.

Found NGK copper 9's were installed which are way to cold for a street only car so I installed a set of the Champion race plugs.

His AEM WB sensor was dead so I replaced that with a new one. And configured the AEM for the new battery off set table for the DWs.

First startup an it seems to run not as smooth as I would like but it does have BC 280/280 cams so maybe that is why. I try to drive it a little to see where we are at with the new injectors. It does NOT want to accel smoothly, and low rpm lo load low MPH drive-ability is horrid. Missing, sputtering, no power. I obviously am not going to try loading it up and high rpm with it running like that. So back into the shop.

Feeling like it's got a cylinder out I start testing. Since it is AEM I can turn off injectors. Turning off one at a time cylinders 1, 3, or 5 the car will chug and die. 2, 4, or 6 no change at all. They are not contributing. I can even unp;lug the rear injector harness. No change.

I could pull plug wires for 2/4/6 off the coil pack, no change.

Ok, for 2 days I tear the car apart and put it back together trying to find out why the rear 3 cylinders are almost dead at idle, and cruising. Very rough, low power trying to cruise at slow speeds at low RPM.

With plenum off I can see the injectors firing, Plugs on the ends of the wires to test the entire ing system and the plugs are igniting.

Swapped out injectors twice, PTU, Coil pack, plug wires, plugs, Traced all the wires in the ign and fuel inj system plug to plug and to the AEM and found no breaks. The plenum has been off no lie about 12 times. Even tried my AEM with no change, and his AEM in my car which ran fine.

Checked timing and found he had Fidanza cam gears and surprise...they had slipped like they always do. Rear exh was at +5 degrees instead of -3. Front exh at +3 instead of -3. You can tell where they used to be by the score marks the washers made as hey slipped. Thought I found it. Removed the cam gears and after finding true 0 cause they are mis marked making -1.5 true 0 I Pin/locked them down at +1 -3 as I always suggest and how I run them on my car. Now they can not move unless they sheer the bolts, which they won't.

Still, no change. WTF?

At this point I am pulling my hair out. Last night Vicki says, "Ask Ray, he may have run into this issue." I have always said, I don't know everything, someone else always has an idea or direction you may not have pursued. And sometimes you just need to step back and get a new set of eyes on the issue. And at this point I have no other directions to go.

So I asked Ray Pampena, Told him the whole scenario as I have written above. First thing he asked me straight up was "Does it have BC 280 cams?"

I said, YES!. He said, take them out. Put stock TT cams in it.

He has had this happen 3 out of the 3 times he has tried BC 280 cams in cars. Back bank, dead stumlinb missing at low RPM low load. Back bank just not contributing as it should. Every one fixed by putting in stock cams.

So even though I just had the tbelt off to do the cam gear fix and had put it all back together (i thought I found the problem) Today I pulled is all back apart and swapped in a set of stock TT cams (V/D).

Know What? Purrring like a kitten. In the AEM I can now turn off each injector one by one and each one is contributing and turning just one front bank of doesn't make it die. Every one is equally contributing.

Ray says he has never figured out why the BC280s are doing this but every time stock cams have fixed it. My take is they are probably so far off that is makes the rear valve timing such that they don't contribute.

I ran into BC issues in the past, A set of BC cams would be degreed using a degree wheel and all 4 were so far off from each other in a set it was as if they should all have different cam cards. BC always denied ANYTHING was wrong with their precious cams. We knew different. I used to sell them. I have taken them off our site. I refuse to sell a customer a problem. We are working on a solution.

Thank you Ray! You rock. All of the parts, wiring checking, running in circles. All because shitty cams.

-Chris

tabasco122
05-03-2013, 11:56 PM
there was a batch of bc 270's for the SR that also had this issue, thankfully i had no issues with my 264's but after reading up on them, i wont run BC cams again.

Primus101
05-04-2013, 04:20 AM
Prior to pulling the BCs, did you get a chance to check the cylinder pressures after you had the gears dialed in?

Tigchamp
05-04-2013, 05:58 AM
It sounded like the problem I had when 3SX accidently sent me two rear inlet cams which I fitted without knowing:rolleyes3:
Took me months to figure out. Must have taken the plenum off 20 times:lo5l:
Jeff:coo3l:

IPD
05-04-2013, 08:32 AM
i'm NEVER buying cams. thanks for the info.

mehrshadvr4
05-04-2013, 08:57 AM
I'm thinking the cams have big over lap that's why it's hard to get it running on low RPM or idle and since we have very high gear ratio the car is always down low in rpms. I got to look in to the cam card sheet to see how much overlap they have. Now I Can't comment on cam timing difference though. I have yet to match the bc cams vs stock cams but i try to do it today. Trevor and saf are running same cams and they don't have the problem of rear bank not running right though as far as i could tell. I just Talked to Saf about his BC 280 cams and he said the car is powerless under 2500rpm but above that the car makes tons of power. This is a character of big cams. ruff idle is a down side on big cams. I guess the best is to time them right on both banks with cams timing gear and run higher compression to get rid of that no power down low problem? Saf is running 8:1 compression and Trevor running 9:1 compression. I'm now kind of concern about running these cams on street cars. I'm going to ask Trevor and see what his car is to drive on normal driving condition with higher compression ratio, but he has 6 speed so the car picks up speed easier. :(. I know he does have stock 74 camgears so I am sure his cams are not timed to the spec.
edite: It seems he has the same problem, but not sure if he has fixed it yet with tune.
AEM - Ignition Setup & Injector Advance - 3000GT/Stealth International Message Center (http://www.3si.org/forum/f1/aem-ignition-setup-injector-advance-549666/)

I'm going to see if a better ECM (proefi 128) can fix this problem. It seems there is window where AEM can't keep up with the engine?

Ninja Performance
05-04-2013, 11:49 AM
Wow, and Trevor is running BC 280s. And looks like going back years on 3si others have BC issues. They have been junk since they came out and that is why we won't sell them. j

-Chris

familyMAN
05-04-2013, 12:33 PM
When you degreed them, did you check more than just #1 and #4 cylinders? I bet they are way off cylinder to cylinder on the same cam/bank. (i.e. degree cam at TDC #5 also and compare to the adjustment needed when degreeing #1)

Any regrind isn't going to be perfect, the info I read said to just shoot for the average but I bet the BCs are off a lot. My web cams front intake is of a few degrees cylinder to cylinder but I just split the difference.

Edit: reread your post, if you "zeroed" based only on the known mistake of the cam gears and not actually degree the cam, there is no way of knowing where you actually have the cam set. It may be close, or you may be off a whole tooth... or more. Not really fair to blame the cam yet if that is the case...

Ninja Performance
05-04-2013, 01:00 PM
When you degreed them, did you check more than just #1 and #4 cylinders? I bet they are way off cylinder to cylinder on the same cam/bank. (i.e. degree cam at TDC #5 also and compare to the adjustment needed when degreeing #1)

Any regrind isn't going to be perfect, the info I read said to just shoot for the average but I bet the BCs are off a lot. My web cams front intake is of a few degrees cylinder to cylinder but I just split the difference.

Edit: reread your post, if you "zeroed" based only on the known mistake of the cam gears and not actually degree the cam, there is no way of knowing where you actually have the cam set. It may be close, or you may be off a whole tooth... or more. Not really fair to blame the cam yet if that is the case...

Yeah, I am NOT degreeing 4 cams in the engine, with the engine in the car. Not happening. LOL

-Chris

Trevor
05-04-2013, 01:12 PM
Yeah, I guess I'm nuts for still running the BC 280's.

Bad:
- As was said I'm running stock 6G74 cam gears and from what I've heard the cams are most certainly offset by a couple degrees.
- <3200 is relatively weak. Might have something to do with the GTX4202R with a 1.44 A/R T-Housing though. ;) VD Dynojet shows 177 lbft @ 1500, 200 @ 1936, 250 @ 2864, & 300 @ 3142
- At 1600-2400 rpm & in slight vacuum (4-8 in Hg) it's very stuttery/gurgley. Pretty sure it's a harmonic or a reversion overlap issue due to the cams.
- Idle is a bear to tune. At 1k it only pulls about 8-9 inches of vacuum.


Good
- The rear bank is definitely doing good work. :p
- Torque goes damn near vertical at 3500.
- Even with the tuning difficulty idle is still consistent...the car never dies. Sounds great too:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jIUtjYzG_n4

After the next track day I'm planning on going back to regrinds of some sort. I'm tired of the stuttering & popping during cruise. DR, Delta, WebCam...the most aggressive ones I can track down. At least then I'm sure peak lift will be in the right place without the need for degreeing. :(

familyMAN
05-04-2013, 01:21 PM
Trevor, even if you swap to a different set of cams, do your car a favor and degree them. My DR street cams were anywhere from 1.5-8* off. You'll more than likely have to pull the motor, but you can probably do that in your sleep anyway.


Not sure if I can say it any clearer, aftermarket cams MUST be degreed. We are the only platform that seems to regularly just drop them in and hope for the best. I know I'm not Chris, Ray or Matt, but I have seen the difference first hand on cams that are considered to be the best for quality on the forums. The car felt noticeably different as well. After degreeing, the before felt like it was fighting itself. Boost took longer to build and tq dropped off faster as well. Unfortunately I can't find the logs anymore to compare the VD, but I'll keep looking.

Edit: found an old log. Started a new thread to show comparison.

Tigchamp
05-04-2013, 02:36 PM
Trevor, even if you swap to a different set of cams, do your car a favor and degree them. My DR street cams were anywhere from 1.5-8* off. You'll more than likely have to pull the motor, but you can probably do that in your sleep anyway.


Not sure if I can say it any clearer, aftermarket cams MUST be degreed. We are the only platform that seems to regularly just drop them in and hope for the best. I know I'm not Chris, Ray or Matt, but I have seen the difference first hand on cams that are considered to be the best for quality on the forums. The car felt noticeably different as well. After degreeing, the before felt like it was fighting itself. Boost took longer to build and tq dropped off faster as well. Unfortunately I can't find the logs anymore to compare the VD, but I'll keep looking.

I will be yanking my motor again soon to replace the PWR cambelt with a Gates one and re-welding the rear manifold for the second time I also have a slight leak from either the gearbox or transfer box so decided it would be easier to take the motor out to do all this.
I guess it would be sensible to have a go at degreeing my 3SX 264/270 cams at the same time I think I saw a thread on here on how to go about it without a cam card
Jeff:coo3l:

mehrshadvr4
05-04-2013, 07:17 PM
I talked to BC about this but since it's saturday I will have to wait. but here is the respond I got from Mr Dustin Spencer.

We have had good success with both the 272 and the 280. I will email you the statistics on Monday as we are closed today. It is a 4 cam engine and there are many things that can affect cam timing. I looked thru the thread and the cams have not been degreed just adjusted to a setting. We have sold over 600 sets of these cams to date and I do not know exactly why these particular engines are having issues. If it was a cam timing problem it would be constant as the cam timing does not change. It can be a tuning issue or he can have the cam gears in the incorrect location. These cams have big lift and duration and if the cam gear is adjusted Incorrectly the engine will have overlap and it can cause this as well. If that is the case you would retard the intake and advance the exhaust and this would smooth the idle and powerband. It is also very easy to be a tooth off on these as well( I have done it myself). About a year ago a customer sent in a cam he claimed was off but I checked the dowel pin timing, lobe timing , duration and lift and everything was within spec. I can only control the cam itself- not the installation or tune.


Just to clarify if it was a cam timing issue it would be at all RPM not just at the low RPM as the cam timing on the 6g72 is fixed not variable. I know it's easy to find blame on the cams but 99 percent of the time there is more to the story.

Here is Saf's car idleing . the car sounds sick though. lol
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rHNFmQ0d4mc

Ray Pampena
05-04-2013, 07:21 PM
it must not be all the BC cams especially since Trevors is running well. its not a degreeing problem either.. nor any charateristic of the cam being large or overlap. its got to be waaay off like not fixable with degreeing. ive never installed the BC cams but ive had cars come in for tunes with them and they had 3 dead cylinders like Chris. you add load and rpm and those 3 come to life but at idle it sounds like a lawnmower. i took those cams out of those cars and put others in.. i never bothered looking into why

donniekak
05-04-2013, 09:51 PM
Why do people spend 10's of thousands of dollars on a build, and not even degree the cams? I highly suggest that anyone doing a build get a build sheet, and fill out the entire sheet.

Trevor
05-04-2013, 11:25 PM
Why do people spend 10's of thousands of dollars on a build, and not even degree the cams? I highly suggest that anyone doing a build get a build sheet, and fill out the entire sheet.
I guess I'm being unreasonable when I expect to an aftermarket cam set to be engineered from the get go to perform when installed properly and set to zero on a car that's never had the block or heads decked. I must ask too much.

When I say "perform properly" I expect 99% of the performance in the intended/designed powerband for the type of cam. That last bit that you might find by tweaking the overlap is a massive amount of work for relatively little return. To quantify it makes much more sense to me to skip to just turning up the boost and optimizing the ignition timing.

You know...let me put this on it's ear. A better question is why do people doing "big" builds get mired down in the minute things like cam degree'ing when they could turn up the boost and make 8-10x the power? Too many people scared of 30+ psi in this joint...but I digress...

familyMAN
05-05-2013, 12:29 AM
Trevor, with the attention to detail you have paid to every other part of your build I just don't understand your stubborn attitude towards degreeing your cams.

Look at the thread I just posted. No amount of turning up the boost makes up for improper mechanical setup.

Maybe your cams are okay, but if they're not, wouldn't you want to pick up 500 rpm of spool and/or extra hp??? Even if the cams are perfect (or 99%), head shaving can throw it off a couple degrees. If +1,-3 makes a noticeable difference on stock cams why wouldn't a couple degrees off from head shaving make a noticeable difference? BTW, if you had "head lift fix" done, I imagine the heads would be slightly decked afterwards.

donniekak
05-05-2013, 01:52 AM
You know...let me put this on it's ear. A better question is why do people doing "big" builds get mired down in the minute things like cam degree'ing when they could turn up the boost and make 8-10x the power? Too many people scared of 30+ psi in this joint...but I digress...
That is one of the problems with turbo builds in general, people rely on the boost controller.
If people actually raced these cars in any spec'd series they would find that the benefits of doing things the way you are supposed to, and going the extra mile makes you faster than the next guy with the same setup.
If you want to see this in action, watch pro stock drag racing. Same size engine, same size carb, and yet some people are way faster than others.

Ray Pampena
05-05-2013, 10:31 AM
To be fair.. degreeing would definitely would have caught the problem with the sets of bc cams. Also if your not going to use a dyno you definitely should degree on the stand also. But.. besides these fucked up cams.. and those bad gears..you can take any of the good cams with good gears like UR and set them at zero and do all the adjusting on the dyno. Different setups use different cam timing depending on boost backpressure and powerband. I've had to move them way off from where they were degreed on the stand to get where I want.. and other times they are best right near zero (quality grinds and gears). It is good to find a good starting point though especially if you're using unkown parts.

familyMAN
05-05-2013, 10:41 AM
But.. besides these fucked up cams.. and those bad gears..you can take any of the good cams with good gears like UR and set them at zero and do all the adjusting on the dyno.

I have UR gears and DR cams and mine were so far off cam to cam and bank to bank, degreeing on a stand is the only way to start. (Supposedly the best, right?) Dialing in on the dyno after degreeing is the only way to go....

Edit: from my other thread, here's how far off mine were...Front bank: +1.5 Intake +8 Exhaust. Rear: +5.5 Intake +2.5 Exhaust.

Trevor
05-05-2013, 11:08 AM
I don't think you guys get what I'm saying. Increase the boost by 1 psi on a good setup and you'll pick up 20...even 30-35 whp. Unless you're clueless and installed the cams 1+tooth off that's about all you're probably going to gain in the meat of the powerband by degreeing 2* here and 6* there.

To further clarify...quite a few people on here don't have the balls to turn it up past 18-23 psi when their setups are capable of much more. Yet they're real quick to point out that their cams are degreed to a nat's ass. That setup is far from optimized too---no difference in my eyes.

43 psi has a knack for making up for making up for a lot of things BTW. ;)

Don't get me wrong. I'm very familiar with how cam overlap affects power output. I spent alot of time getting my STi's variable cam setup tuned to a nat's ass. I was floored with the torque gains I found below 5200 rpm. I ended up with a 2.46L 8.0:1 motor that puts down 319 lb ft at just 15 psi and 3439 rpm and 500 lb ft at 27.8 psi and 4362 rpm. Most of that is because of the AVCS (running 45* of intake cam advance in places) as optimizing ignition timing only takes you so far. With that easy to change ECM driven setup I realized that the 2* here 6* there based gains on a fixed setup are pure give and take and probably not worth chasing. On the STi the same intake cam advance that netted me 90 lb ft at 3700 cost me almost 78 lb ft at 5450. Huge...

familyMAN
05-05-2013, 11:17 AM
You don't get what I'm saying. Read what I just posted. My DR cams were 1.5-8* off. 8* is a whole tooth but they were installed correctly. That particular cam was off from cylinder to cylinder a couple of degrees. Another cam was 5* off, so don't try to say it was just incorrect installation.

BC is known to have poor quality control. How can you seriously be arguing and have not even checked your cams. By your own argument a tooth off is bad. Guess what, "good, quality" cams were off a tooth.

Maybe your gut is right and your cams are only a couple degrees off and it makes little difference. You could probably check the front bank with engine in car if you want to really make your point;)

Trevor
05-05-2013, 11:32 AM
I'm not arguing with you. They're crap. Got it. Cylinder to cylinder variance in itself sums that up. Which cylinder do you trust when degreeing then? Sounds like a giant waste of my time busting my hump to get it "right" when the cylinder next door is off doing its own thing.

Pretty sad when "engineers" kick out an improperly designed part as good. Also disappointing when the guys that do regrinds cant even get peak lift right and you have to degree those too. How in the world do they mess that up?

8* sounds huge to the 3S community. Got it. 8* to me means turn the boost up 2 psi until I get a chance to swap em out. Which I'll do...later. http://everyday48.net/forum/images/smilies/Smiley_Shake_Fist_by_Mirz123.gif

;)

familyMAN
05-05-2013, 11:36 AM
It is sad, even 1* off should be an eternity for precision parts. My customers sure wouldn't except that amount of variance!

I just shot for the average of the cylinders on that bank. May try to get a replacement cam from webcam. At my pansy boost level I didn't see a power difference, but I picked up 500 rpm in spool with no corresponding loss up top;)

donniekak
05-05-2013, 12:41 PM
I'm not arguing with you. They're crap. Got it. Cylinder to cylinder variance in itself sums that up. Which cylinder do you trust when degreeing then? Sounds like a giant waste of my time busting my hump to get it "right" when the cylinder next door is off doing its own thing.

Pretty sad when "engineers" kick out an improperly designed part as good. Also disappointing when the guys that do regrinds cant even get peak lift right and you have to degree those too. How in the world do they mess that up?

8* sounds huge to the 3S community. Got it. 8* to me means turn the boost up 2 psi until I get a chance to swap em out. Which I'll do...later. http://everyday48.net/forum/images/smilies/Smiley_Shake_Fist_by_Mirz123.gif

;)
And this is why no one in a 3s makes comparable power out of the same turbo as supras, evos, dsm's, or Hondas.
The goal of building a car shouldn't be buying a better setup than everyone else, but making more power on the same setup as the next guy.
Look at NASCAR. They all have the same car, except for small differences in setup that add up to winning.

Trevor
05-05-2013, 12:49 PM
Oh sorry...I didn't realize 147 traps and over 880 at the wheels sucks for a street car. I'm just F'in up by the numbers. I'll work harder in the future Sir. http://www.familyfriendsfirearms.com/forum/fffmain/smilies/animatedsalute.gif

donniekak
05-05-2013, 01:00 PM
Wow. I've been trolled for telling people to do things the right way.
While I love your car, and have respect for the time, and money you have put into it, the truth is if you tried to actually race it against people in other platforms with the same turbo, you would get killed. Ive seen cars with smaller engines, running less boost, make more power. An old gt4202 has seen 1033 at the wheels on a 4g63 at 38 psi.

IPD
05-05-2013, 01:13 PM
now that the thread is completely derailed?

trevor, did you make SMSgt yet?

Trevor
05-05-2013, 02:48 PM
trevor, did you make SMSgt yet?
Lookin' like I'll pin on 1 Jun. Wife made Senior too.

IPD
05-05-2013, 04:51 PM
Lookin' like I'll pin on 1 Jun. Wife made Senior too.

Congrats to you both! Wish our paths had crossed before now, but I should be so lucky. How's your new locale compare to AZ?

J. Fast
05-05-2013, 05:05 PM
Cam timing doesn't change the peak number donniekak. It just changes when the numbers arrive. Ignition timing is the secret to success on heads. More secrets in racing come from suspension, aero , and driver setup vs. cam timing adjustments on an engine. 10hp gain in a set of cams means nothing when you can turn up the wick two lbs and make 50hp more.

Trevor
05-05-2013, 07:53 PM
How's your new locale compare to AZ?
I'm not a fan. We were here from 94-02. We're hoping for another assignment.

mehrshadvr4
05-05-2013, 08:55 PM
Wow. I've been trolled for telling people to do things the right way.
While I love your car, and have respect for the time, and money you have put into it, the truth is if you tried to actually race it against people in other platforms with the same turbo, you would get killed. Ive seen cars with smaller engines, running less boost, make more power. An old gt4202 has seen 1033 at the wheels on a 4g63 at 38 psi.
You know it's hard to believe that car made that power with such small boost where other DSMs run well over 50psi on same turbo to make 1000whp. If E85 can make that much power on 12-15psi less boost then I don't see why anyone would run race gas anymore.

Stealth_RT
05-05-2013, 10:40 PM
Back to the OP's first post, this sucks to hear. I bought BC 264 cams from Ninja last year and put them in. Even learned how to degree them. All four cams 'seem' to be degreed well, none are hugely off the mark. Most of the variance is probably from the heads having been decked at least twice. Hope these cams work out. Still in the process of getting a chrome ecu setup up and running, so I don't have any idea if the cams are good or junk.

donniekak
05-05-2013, 10:55 PM
Cam timing doesn't change the peak number donniekak. It just changes when the numbers arrive. Ignition timing is the secret to success on heads. More secrets in racing come from suspension, aero , and driver setup vs. cam timing adjustments on an engine. 10hp gain in a set of cams means nothing when you can turn up the wick two lbs and make 50hp more.
What if the turbos are maxed out?
If you think cam timing has nothing to do with peak power, set yours off a tooth and see what happens.

J. Fast
05-06-2013, 06:38 AM
What if the turbos are maxed out?
^^Has nothing to do with cam timing events.

If your cam's are installed straight up then advancing or retarding cam timing events only influences the torque/hp vs rpm onset. The peak tq and hp will be the same until you reach severe degreeing power fallout. Cam adjustments are typically made for traction and torque influence compensations largely due to altitude or air density compensation and driving environment.



If you think cam timing has nothing to do with peak power, set yours off a tooth and see what happens.l
Pretty sure that's why this thread was made. Fidanza and 3sx cam gears are prone to slippage unless you lock them down.

2nd point taken was the precision on BC cam's installed at center is significantly influenced when the deck heights have been modified from stock and the front and rear banks have different machined cuts.

Aftermarket cam's were designed for stock deck and block height. You can't correct non uniform engine machinework with aftermarket cam's and cam gears.

Sounds like some grinds out there don't pair well. Good to know.

mehrshadvr4
05-06-2013, 03:06 PM
Ok I got an email from BC and they offer to send both my 280 cams and factory cams. They are going to make sure that there has not been any change in making the cams by comparing it to my factory cams. I'll let you guys know if they find any defect.

J. Fast
05-06-2013, 07:26 PM
Hrmm, I received an email from Dustin @ BC. I'm going to hedge a bet on the cams being correct at straight up and the issue being machine work and unchecked engine math.

Blackmount
05-06-2013, 07:45 PM
Here is Saf's car idleing . the car sounds sick though. lol
SAF68 Dragpro Just for fun ^^ - YouTube (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rHNFmQ0d4mc)

God that sounds sick, the sound is almost worth the price of cams alone lol :D

is he too running BC280s? seems like a hit or miss so far.

5ubb3d

dustin213
05-06-2013, 08:15 PM
This is Dustin from BC. I have been in touch with Chris and Ray and am currently trying to get the cams in question back here for inspection to figure out the issue. The 280's have big lift and duration and were never really designed to make power under 2500 RPM but that doesn't explain the sputtering issue. From the symptoms it sounds like there are some overlap issues but i can check the cam timng here on the CAM PRO and verify dowel position, lobe position, duration and lift. We know Chris and Ray are very knowledgable and respected as they are the best at what they do. There are many variables on the 6G72 that can alter cam timing, decking the block, shaving the head ETC and sometimes aftermarket gears ZERO isn't actually zero and we will get to the bottom of this as we stand behind our products.
If anyone has any questions or conerns my direct line 619-749-9018 or you can email me at dustin@briancrower.com

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

dustin213
05-06-2013, 08:34 PM
(Hrmm, I received an email from Dustin @ BC. I'm going to hedge a bet on the cams being correct at straight up and the issue being machine work and unchecked engine math. )




Whatever the outcome I will post the results along side the results of an OEM set for comparison.

mehrshadvr4
05-06-2013, 08:44 PM
God that sounds sick, the sound is almost worth the price of cams alone lol :D

is he too running BC280s? seems like a hit or miss so far.

5ubb3d

Yes BC 280. He does say the on lower RPM it's hard to drive but it must be because of 280 cams.

Blackmount
05-06-2013, 08:48 PM
well, yeah. I've been in DSM's with big cams such as 280's or 288s suck for low end for driving cruising too, I would imagine really with most cars using a high profile cam, low rpm driveability is a little finicky.

Nice to see you guys making a effort to stand by your product and figure out what the deal is, from what I understand tho its not just BC cams we have issues with it seems alot of the cams for our cars (based on what i've been told) are off in some form or another.

It would be nice if we could just get it all settled for good.

Fakepower
05-07-2013, 12:01 AM
I bought the BC272's, installed them, obviously I degreed them in (I made the how to guide from my experience). There was one cam that I sent back, it was obviously incorrectly made. It was simply so far off that 3sx gears couldn't correct for it. So I'm a believer with Ray, Chris, and Matt (DR) that BC cams REQUIRE degreeing in. With respect to Dustin, he agreed to send me a new cam, which he did, it was probably the best cam of the 4. The cam I sent back he claimed was perfect. So either my method changed (it didn't), or repeated experience (guys mentioned above) have the correct idea. Either way, dustin was very nice to talk to even though he clearly thought I had no idea what I was talking about. So bottom line: BC cams require work to get right, customer service is very good though.

Someday (hopefully this summer) I'll get my car running, and I'll post my experience with the 272's. My two cents: never go to medical school. really puts everything else in the backburner. and it's awful.

http://www.3sgto.org/turbo-engines-systems/8785-how-guide-degreeing-cams-6g72-w-pictures.html

Edit: started reading thru this whole thread. Found something interesting!
From Post #13: This was an email from Dustin.
"About a year ago a customer sent in a cam he claimed was off but I checked the dowel pin timing, lobe timing , duration and lift and everything was within spec. I can only control the cam itself- not the installation or tune. "

Guess who that "customer" was??
=)

J. Fast
05-07-2013, 12:11 AM
Whatever the outcome I will post the results along side the results of an OEM set for comparison.

Dustin, our platform is lacking in experience with build logs and qualifying questions. For example, I recently picked up a vehicle with a set of Delta 272 cams and Unorthodox cam gears. It's down on compression on one cylinder. I asked the previous owner and previous previous owner for specifications on the engine, no one knows.

what's the calculated bore?
what's the calculated stroke?
what's the single cylinder displacement?
what's the area of the bore?
what's the combustion chamber volume?
whats the deck clearance volume?
whats the head gasket volume?
what's the total combustion volume?
what's the total combustion volume for each individual cylinder?
whats the combustion distance from individual top dead center verses crankshaft reference to journal axis at center, top, and bottom?

So... Now I get to take it apart so I can document the answers.

You'd be surprised on how many guys you could ask questions like that to that would look at you like a deer in headlights. The answer the give you is... "Man, I have no idea!" With answers to questions like that then of course it's the cams's fault.

It's quite unfortunate that BC has gotten a bad rep in our community due to a lack of build experience and actual engine math verification. And engine is built nearly every day without any documentation or guideline for future reference. My thinking is the issue lies there.

Fakepower
05-07-2013, 12:26 AM
what's the calculated bore?
what's the calculated stroke?
what's the single cylinder displacement?
what's the area of the bore?
what's the combustion chamber volume?
whats the deck clearance volume?
whats the head gasket volume?
what's the total combustion volume?
what's the total combustion volume for each individual cylinder?
whats the combustion distance from individual top dead center verses crankshaft reference to journal axis at center, top, and bottom?

It's quite unfortunate that BC has gotten a bad rep in our community due to a lack of build experience and actual engine math verification. And engine is built nearly every day without any documentation or guideline for future reference.

I'd be very interested to see you break out 3 variable calculus to determine most of those answers. The reason why those questions aren't answered is because they are difficult to measure, and aren't necessary for a successful build. While those values may be nice to have, there are far better numbers to have. BC cams has a "bad" reputation because of a limited number of the most respected and accomplished individuals with this platform have had difficulty with their products. Frankly I'm not aware of a single dyno sheet or proven performance of any BC cams on a 3/s. BC could go a long way with a proven dyno numbers, and also working with the "elite members" of this community. It appears the latter is happening. BC has proven performance in the DSM world. Chris was alittle premature in the universal statement they are garbage, I will admit that. I sure hope the 272's work good for my own sake.

dustin213
05-07-2013, 12:45 AM
I will work on getting some current dyno sheets with the BC cams and if I in any way gave off the impression that you didn't know what you were talking about it was not my intention. It's hard to judge who you are talking too. If you wouldn't mind sending me an email to dustin@briancrower.com and I will send you some profile info and a dyno as soon as I have it.

J. Fast
05-07-2013, 01:01 AM
I'd be very interested to see you break out 3 variable calculus to determine most of those answers. The reason why those questions aren't answered is because they are difficult to measure, and aren't necessary for a successful build.

I beg to differ. If you can't do the math you have no business building a high performance engine...
(let alone machining one). How do you check the work and verify the blueprints? THAT IS THE PROBLEM!

Fakepower
05-07-2013, 01:20 AM
I will work on getting some current dyno sheets with the BC cams and if I in any way gave off the impression that you didn't know what you were talking about it was not my intention. It's hard to judge who you are talking too. If you wouldn't mind sending me an email to dustin@briancrower.com and I will send you some profile info and a dyno as soon as I have it.

Trust me I didn't take it personally. Welcome to the Community, I hope you spend more time here, you could sell a lot of cams. I'd highly recommend posting the information on this forum. We love when manufacturers put in face time and post real data on here. However I'll also shoot you an email.

I'd also appreciate if you would look thru the link I posted on post #44, it's the how-to guide that I make after degreeing your BC272 cams. Let me know what you think, see if the method is sound. Thanks Jason

donniekak
05-07-2013, 02:30 AM
Dustin, our platform is lacking in experience with build logs and qualifying questions. For example, I recently picked up a vehicle with a set of Delta 272 cams and Unorthodox cam gears. It's down on compression on one cylinder. I asked the previous owner and previous previous owner for specifications on the engine, no one knows.

what's the calculated bore?
what's the calculated stroke?
what's the single cylinder displacement?
what's the area of the bore?
what's the combustion chamber volume?
whats the deck clearance volume?
whats the head gasket volume?
what's the total combustion volume?
what's the total combustion volume for each individual cylinder?
whats the combustion distance from individual top dead center verses crankshaft reference to journal axis at center, top, and bottom?

So... Now I get to take it apart so I can document the answers.

You'd be surprised on how many guys you could ask questions like that to that would look at you like a deer in headlights. The answer the give you is... "Man, I have no idea!" With answers to questions like that then of course it's the cams's fault.

It's quite unfortunate that BC has gotten a bad rep in our community due to a lack of build experience and actual engine math verification. And engine is built nearly every day without any documentation or guideline for future reference. My thinking is the issue lies there.

Let me get this straight. You want all that info, but cam timing is irrelevant?

GTOJOE
05-07-2013, 06:57 AM
In for results of testing.

J. Fast
05-07-2013, 08:45 AM
Let me get this straight. You want all that info, but cam timing is irrelevant?

I agree with you. Lack of build sheets and log books on builds is the problem. Post #35 will clarify what I said about maxed turbos.

I may not have an 800whp veh yet (due to altitude) but Im pretty sure I have one of the longest standing/highest mileage high performance engines on the board. It has been nearly 8 years and it now has nearly 90k miles at 27-32 psi. I even drove on maxed turbos for 3 years. The reason is the build sheet, continued build log and precision. I checked the work and had someone check my work. It went back to the machine shop 3 times. A lot of times people just go with it. Mathematical build errors and bottom end flaws really start to show themselves when you put a cam on with a lot of overlap. You can immediately see the difference in compression.

MistercVR4
05-07-2013, 11:04 AM
Hey guys, I'm the owner of the car Chris is working on. I'm very thankfully he's working on my problem. It's really frustrating to invest such large amount of money and in a short time to have so many issues. The car was built at 3sx. I believe it the 3rd time the motor was build there doing the time it was there. The other apparently blow up on their dyno. At the time I was running stock cams. It wasn't until the 3rd build I went with the BC. I went on what I was recommended base on what I planned on doing with the car. It wasn't gonna be a track car more of a highway and weekend warrior. As I told Chris, it's the build from hell.
But as far as the spec on the engine build that something 3sx should be able to address for it was built and tune at their shop. I do know when I drove the car back from their shop to my house it was on the highway. Never got to open the car up due to my father following me back from picking the car up from them. And he drives like a snail. Sad part he has a 2010 370x. Well hopefully soon all this can get resolved and my bank account want take another major hit due to having to rebuild an engine again within just a few months of getting the car back.
I do hope & trust being a loyal customer with 3sx for over 7 yrs that they will also step do right with these build issues I'm having.

familyMAN
05-07-2013, 11:31 AM
Had no idea you had that much trouble Courtney. So it has been rebuilt after your 700hp dyno? And that is also when cams were installed? If so, they should have degreed them in for you at that time, but sounds like it wasn't.

Hopefully it will all be worth it for you in the end!!

MistercVR4
05-07-2013, 11:59 AM
Yeap, it's being a real headache. I'm sure Chris is pulling his hair out. It's like he found one thing, then other issues started popping up. Those BC cams were added on 3rd build when they dyne her at 700 mark. I guess we will know for sure soon if they did or didn't. If not, I wonder how that would get played out.

J. Fast
05-07-2013, 01:02 PM
Hey Courtney,

Sorry to hear about your difficulties with this build. Builds are tricky, there’s a lot of numbers involved. I’m curious as to what influenced your decision to go with a big overlap cam like a BC 280. What is your sweep volume and static compression ratio? What is your dynamic compression ratio? Not estimated, but measured mathematical actual?

You lose a lot of stroke and sweep volume in an engine with the intake closing event on those cams. I’m curious as to whether or not the recommendations made to you took into account that you’re dynamic compression is likely below 7:1 which is absolutely why you’re car runs like ass on those cams. It also makes me wonder if the seat times were taken into account.

Compression doesn’t take place in overlap, it only takes place when intake valves are closed (which is not at .050” timing). It also makes me wonder about your piston and rod position at the closing event. You likely need more static compression to have successful results with a wild 6g7 cam profile like this. Truth be known any engine with a dynamic compression ratio below about 7:1 will run like ass and has difficulties accepting pump gas… or hell, even idling.

A 9:1-8.5:1 static compression engine with this cam grind actually has a dynamic compression/running compression around 6.7:1-6.9:1 (that’s way to low) which is a terrible pairing for your bottom end and obviously not accounted for in the engine design/build phase with anyone with any engine blueprint experience. A lot of really experienced guys out there forget to take into account the intake center lines which dramatically influence the dynamic compression.

When you have a low compression engine the last thing you want is a 70 degree intake timing event. No amount of boost or ignition timing can overcome the intake valve being in overlap which results in low dynamic compression. Dynamic compression is fixed. If you have low dynamic compression you will always have low compression. You are stuck with that forever until you raise the compression ratio.

I’m pretty floored why nobody here knows why the OEM cams worked… (Frankly, they should know better) I bet it wasn’t because the BC 280 cams were shit-tastic. It was likely because the engine wasn’t mapped by a professional who could of spotted a low compression situation when the static and dynamic compression ratios should have been evaluated. Of course you’re car ran like ass, you’re cam’s slipped for 1, and for 2... you’re dynamic compression ratio is prolly so dam low that you can’t even combust fuel because the intake valve is open so damn much.

The reason why the OEM cams worked? Because they likely raised your dynamic compression ratio from below 7:1 to 8.5:1. I’m really flippin surprised that the vets in here didn’t see that.


A long time ago engine builders and racers used to lower dynamic compression ratio's to prevent knock. You took a huge stroked motor and put a wild cam on it to drop the dynamic compression so it wouldn’t ping. Well, now you just use fuels like ethanol or you inject meth and you crank it up. An 8.5:1 static compression engine with a 260 cam had a dynamic compression around 8:1. A 10.5 engine with a 280 cam has nearly the same dynamic compression. The reason why? The intake valve isn't seated till nearly 15 degrees later because it's in overlap.

If you want to run a grind like this 280 BC up your compression ratio above 10.5:1… then there’s something special. That’s how the NABR guys do it on 2.0L engines on E-85.

There’s some food for thought for some guys on this board.


Cheers!

DK77
05-07-2013, 01:10 PM
Thanks for that knowledge drop J, something I never would have thought of. Would that problem be something that could be partially alleviated by advancing the intake cams and/or retarding the exhaust cams?

J. Fast
05-07-2013, 01:25 PM
Thanks for that knowledge drop J, something I never would have thought of. Would that problem be something that could be partially alleviated by advancing the intake cams and/or retarding the exhaust cams?

The only thing that will dramatically sway the dynamic compression ratio on the top end is the valve seat times. You have to close the intake valve to keep the compression up. The intake center lines can be manipulated but the cam grinds are fixed. It is up to the engine builder to spec the bottom end and spec the cam based on the final compression ratio.

MistercVR4
05-07-2013, 01:47 PM
J.Fast - thanks for the info. Now that's differently food for thought in fact the 3sx may have over look portion of the build.
As far as the BC 280 I was recommended those. I pretty much told them what I wanted and how I plan on using the car and hope to haven't reach my goal. It was never intended to be a track car. I made a granny a promise that I would stop racing.

So Could it be that 280 were to big for that setup? I wonder that when Chris informed me about the issuing he found with 2,4, 6 cyl wasn't firing. It's like one thing after another.

From reading you post, it could seem as if a lot was overlooked, I'm learning the hard way building and knowing how to build this car is very tricky. I'm pretty mush stuck with almost wipe out side cash account and a car that doesn't performance. SMDH.

But as i stated I hope the folks involved with this build would step up and do the right thing.

OH the compression ratio was suppose to be 8 5 1 from what i was told.

J. Fast
05-07-2013, 02:48 PM
J.Fast - thanks for the info. Now that's differently food for thought in fact the 3sx may have over look portion of the build.
As far as the BC 280 I was recommended those. I pretty much told them what I wanted and how I plan on using the car and hope to haven't reach my goal. It was never intended to be a track car. I made a granny a promise that I would stop racing.

So Could it be that 280 were to big for that setup? I wonder that when Chris informed me about the issuing he found with 2,4, 6 cyl wasn't firing. It's like one thing after another.

From reading you post, it could seem as if a lot was overlooked, I'm learning the hard way building and knowing how to build this car is very tricky. I'm pretty mush stuck with almost wipe out side cash account and a car that doesn't performance. SMDH.

But as i stated I hope the folks involved with this build would step up and do the right thing.

OH the compression ratio was suppose to be 8 5 1 from what i was told.


On a huch I ran some quick numbers thru a Wallace Racing Dynamic Compression Engine Calculator: >>> Wallace Racing: Dynamic Compression Ratio Calculator (http://www.wallaceracing.com/dynamic-cr.php) <<<

I entered this:

Cylinders: 6
Bore in Inches: 3.67"
Stroke in Inches: 2.99"
Rod Length: 5.536"
Static Compression Ratio: 8.5:1
Inlet Valve Closes ABDC: 65
Boost Pressure: 0
Target Altitude: 1000ft

Here's the results when you are running 0 vac or idling...

Static compression ratio of 8.5:1.
Effective stroke is 2.30 inches.
Your dynamic compression ratio is 6.57:1 .
Your dynamic cranking pressure is 122.76 PSI.
Your dynamic boost compression ratio, reflecting static c.r., cam timing, altitude, and boost of 0 PSI is 6.57 :1.
V/P (Volume to Pressure Index) is 52


Therein lies the problem. If you run the same numbers and only change the cam to the stock cam ABDC the compression raises almost a full point!

Primus101
05-07-2013, 02:58 PM
Post #3



Prior to pulling the BCs, did you get a chance to check the cylinder pressures after you had the gears dialed in?


No response

J. Fast
05-07-2013, 03:07 PM
Haha, I gave you rep for it :p

J. Fast
05-07-2013, 03:14 PM
I have been a Performance Trends Engine Analyzer for nearly 4 years, an EFI Certified Calibrator from EFI U since 2009. I have a Masters equivalent in Civil, Electrical, and Structural Engineering, I've worked as a Reconstruction Expert for 3 years, am a crew chief, I own my own Race/Fab Shop and Reconstruction Firm. I am for hire for engine blueprinting and assembly work and I'm OCD, LOL!

vroom4
05-07-2013, 03:29 PM
You are the freaking man, no one doubts that.

Well aside from your financial decision making skills, you know, those might be in question after a recent debacle.

Blackmount
05-07-2013, 04:32 PM
Lots of good info in this thread

Tigchamp
05-07-2013, 06:03 PM
J.Fast.
Does running the 264/272 combination get round the low Dynamic compression ratio problem?
Jeff:coo3l:

J. Fast
05-07-2013, 07:52 PM
J.Fast.
Does running the 264/272 combination get round the low Dynamic compression ratio problem?
Jeff:coo3l:
That is an excellent question. I would need to get some information from Dustin regarding the ABDC valve timing when the cams are positioned straight up. I would also need to know your actual stroke, bore, rod length, static compression ratio, and you're DA to make a scientific guess.

Dustin, can you please post BC' s ABDC for your 264, 272, and 280 cam when they're straight up?

familyMAN
05-07-2013, 08:30 PM
I believe cam cards are available on BC's website and shows timing location for .050 lift.

AdamVR4
05-07-2013, 09:55 PM
How does low dynamic compression explain the difference between the banks that Chris described while troubleshooting?



I have been a Performance Trends Engine Analyzer for nearly 4 years, an EFI Certified Calibrator from EFI U since 2009. I have a Masters equivalent in Civil, Electrical, and Structural Engineering, I've worked as a Reconstruction Expert for 3 years, am a crew chief, I own my own Race/Fab Shop and Reconstruction Firm. I am for hire for engine blueprinting and assembly work and I'm OCD, LOL!

http://4.bp.blogspot.com/--mZvTa4f_uY/UOyhcKMWefI/AAAAAAAAFTI/SxTkl78Jdxc/s1600/tom-delonge.jpg

Hobby/recreational use of ~$110 software; 5-day $5000 course; "masters equivalent" (do tell) in 3 engineering fields... Reconstruction... Like accident reconstruction? or like.. construction?

J. Fast
05-07-2013, 10:10 PM
How does low dynamic compression explain the difference between the banks that Chris described while troubleshooting?



The difference is machine work. I bet if Ninja takes it apart the banks have different cuts and the compression distances are different in the cylinders. That is not a cam issue, that's a machine work issue. Prolly some pothead on a mill that knows and gives jack shit about math and precison. It was rebuilt what.... 3 times according to the owner? Yahh, it's the cam.

You're a smart guy with all that rep... and you missed it and you just don't have the build experience to spot it. I do.

J. Fast
05-07-2013, 10:33 PM
So to answer Tigchamps question from earlier regarding 264 and 272 grinds on an 8.5:1? Using this calculator I developed and embedded in this thread...Post #73 >>>http://www.3sgto.org/turbo-engines-systems/8785-how-guide-degreeing-cams-6g72-w-pictures-2.html#post213496 <<<


Not sure if this upload will work but here's a cam algorythm I came up with. You can enter in the durations for your exhaust and intake cams and the advance or retard (retard will be negative advance) and it will spit out your overlap. You can also make adjustments to the cam timing and it will give you the revised centerlines :)

4855

For clarification the lobe separation angle for the stock cam profile is 108 degrees. The stock intake cam has a duration of 251, the stock exhaust cam has a duration of 247. There's 1.5 degrees of advance on the stock duration...

You can use the calculator to find the new lobe centers. Just enter in your gear adjusted advance numbers in the lower red tables.

I come up with ABDC at:

66.5 degrees on a 280 cam
62.5 degrees on a 272 cam
58.5 degrees on a 264 cam
52.0 degrees on a 251 cam (stock)

Using these 0 values insert your stroke, bore, rod length, static compression, altitude and ABDC for cam selection into the Wallace Racing Algorythm and you will have your answer. If the dynamic compression is below 7:1 the engine will run like ass in closed loop and you'll likely have too low of compression under vac conditions to idle.

Chris@Rvengeperformance
05-07-2013, 10:55 PM
I have been a Performance Trends Engine Analyzer for nearly 4 years, an EFI Certified Calibrator from EFI U since 2009. I have a Masters equivalent in Civil, Electrical, and Structural Engineering, I've worked as a Reconstruction Expert for 3 years, am a crew chief, I own my own Race/Fab Shop and Reconstruction Firm. I am for hire for engine blueprinting and assembly work and I'm OCD, LOL!

people would take you a lot more seriously if you didn't post this all the time.

AdamVR4
05-07-2013, 11:25 PM
The difference is machine work. I bet if Ninja takes it apart the banks have different cuts and the compression distances are different in the cylinders. That is not a cam issue, that's a machine work issue. Prolly some pothead on a mill that knows and gives jack shit about math and precison. It was rebuilt what.... 3 times according to the owner? Yahh, it's the cam.

You're a smart guy with all that rep... and you missed it and you just don't have the build experience to spot it. I do.

I've admitted, recently, that I'm no cam expert. I'm just hear trying to pay attention. Based entirely on what you posted (appears to be an email or PM to MistercVR4), the low dynamic compression is surely at least contributing to why the car runs rough at low rpm's. It does not -- straight up can not -- explain why the entire rear bank has virtually no compression (at idle only?). The most interesting part of the whole story and you're dismissing it as a one-time machinist error that made it out the door of BC? How unsatisfying.

I know in another thread you said you were too good for 3Si (banned), so I assume you haven't seen this thread's twin over there. I keyed in on a couple responses that I'll paste in order to get your expert opinion.


{Chris,} Take those cams and plot out the actual lift profile of the valves on all four cams and you'll find even more surprises.


Dustin, do you use the same profile for the two intake cams, and then the same profile for the two exhaust cams - or do you use individual profiles for each cam?


The 2 intake cams have the same profile and the 2 exhaust cams have the same profile. Also with the duration of 218 on the intake and 216 on the exhuast with the 108 lobe seperation these cams are right on the edge of overlap and any variance at all in the block or shaving of the head will have this number increase but it can be dialed in with gears.

but as previoulsy stated we have the utmost respect for the knowledge of Chris and Ray as we are not tuners but machinist and we are trying to get the cams back as if there is a problem we will find it.

:confused2: Care to make sense of it all for us?

J. Fast
05-07-2013, 11:27 PM
people would take you a lot more seriously if you didn't post this all the time.
You're right. My wife mentioned it might come across as arrogant. I will refrain. My bad.

AdamVR4
05-07-2013, 11:44 PM
You're right. My wife mentioned it might come across as arrogant. I will refrain. My bad.

Your wife said it was arrogant? To drop your intentionally vaguely worded resume, out of no where, in the middle of a thread? While you were bragging to her about how you schooled us? She's fucking crazy dude.

J. Fast
05-07-2013, 11:45 PM
I've admitted, recently, that I'm no cam expert. I'm just hear trying to pay attention. Based entirely on what you posted (appears to be an email or PM to MistercVR4), the low dynamic compression is surely at least contributing to why the car runs rough at low rpm's. It does not -- straight up can not -- explain why the entire rear bank has virtually no compression (at idle only?). The most interesting part of the whole story and you're dismissing it as a one-time machinist error that made it out the door of BC? How unsatisfying.

I know in another thread you said you were too good for 3Si (banned), so I assume you haven't seen this thread's twin over there. I keyed in on a couple responses that I'll paste in order to get your expert opinion.







:confused2: Care to make sense of it all for us?

I will go visit 3si and have a read.

Greg E
05-07-2013, 11:46 PM
:confused2: Care to make sense of it all for us?

Well... I'm no cam expert but it would appear to me that cutting down the heads too much then running with 280 cam gears increases overlap.

Especially with the rear head which has to be compounded by not only its its own deck but the deck of the front head too.

familyMAN
05-08-2013, 12:13 AM
You're right. My wife mentioned it might come across as arrogant. I will refrain. My bad.

Wait, what? Your wife proofreads your posts? Maybe she should've stopped this one too;)

JK. Still a funny post though that I had to quote.

J. Fast
05-08-2013, 12:44 AM
Hrmm... Nothing at 3si. Im sure Chris Hill will examine those cam's on a set of heads.

It would appear mannushj was hinting at the cam's being reversed?

I'm hoping Dustin will confirm the ABDC.

It really sucks to not have a build sheet for the bottom end.

Ray Pampena
05-08-2013, 12:59 AM
I wish I knew engine stuffs! Since I'm probably one of the "vets" who somehow missed why oem cams worked fine or in other cases dr cams worked fine in place of these.. its not my job to take someone's car who's in for a tune but runs on 3 cylinders and pull out their engine to play science class with their cams so I can post it on the internet. Either I replace them with known good cams or I have them replace them and come back in. I've never installed a set of bc cams so I have no idea what they degree at I just know I had 3 different 3 cylinder cars. So when Chris asked me about his 3 cylinder car I asked if it had bc cams.. he said yes so I said try taking them out.

Could they have been degreed in to possibly work? Maybe.. is there a dowel location defect? Maybe.. I don't know nor do I care. Its not my jobto figure it all out unless I'm the guy who installed them. I wish you guys had experience running a performance shop! Then you'd know why a "vet" doesn't know why a certain cam didn't work

dustin213
05-08-2013, 01:04 AM
I will email you the timing events in the morning and I believe the cams will be back soon as we sent a UPS label for the return. I will post as soon as I have the results.

J. Fast
05-08-2013, 01:11 AM
In your opinion is the dynamic compression too low with a 280 grind on an 8.5:1 static compression build, Ray? How aggressive duration have you had success with on low compression builds? What have you observed to be good pairing with 8.5:1 SCR's?

Ray Pampena
05-08-2013, 01:26 AM
In your opinion is the dynamic compression too low with a 280 grind on an 8.5:1 static compression build, Ray? How aggressive duration have you had success with on low compression builds? What have you observed to be good pairing with 8.5:1 SCR's?

I think it works just fine. You just need to be more critical of the overlap with a large cam and low compression small engine. So if there's something wrong with the cam timing whatever the reason being cam defect or other alignment issues then you run into this problem. As you cansee.. the front 3 cylinders ran fine so the cams work without bringing cylinder pressure below a working threshold. And cars like Saf and Trevor have 6 working cylinders! I've never installed the bc cams so I don't know what the exact issue at hand is. I'm sure Dustin will get to the bottom of it..

Tigchamp
05-08-2013, 03:56 PM
So to answer Tigchamps question from earlier regarding 264 and 272 grinds on an 8.5:1? Using this calculator I developed and embedded in this thread...Post #73 >>>http://www.3sgto.org/turbo-engines-systems/8785-how-guide-degreeing-cams-6g72-w-pictures-2.html#post213496 <<<



I come up with ABDC at:

66.5 degrees on a 280 cam
62.5 degrees on a 272 cam
58.5 degrees on a 264 cam
52.0 degrees on a 251 cam (stock)

Using these 0 values insert your stroke, bore, rod length, static compression, altitude and ABDC for cam selection into the Wallace Racing Algorythm and you will have your answer. If the dynamic compression is below 7:1 the engine will run like ass in closed loop and you'll likely have too low of compression under vac conditions to idle.

My question was just a general question after reading your post, which I have to admit went straight over my head as in reality I am just a nuts and bolts person all the science stuff leaves me totally confused.
A general question as I am in fact running 3SX 264/272 cams (not BC's) and after my build problems of being supplied two rear inlet cams 1-264 & 1-272 which I fitted not knowing any better, naturally this resulted in a three cylinder engine & after choosing AEM 8 channel CDI & coil on plugs in sequential firing not wasted spark which due to my new AEM EMS2 pin number 91 not working which resulted in a five cylinder engine. Having eventually cured all these problems the engine ran well on the AEM base map with good even idle and the car pulled clean from low revs, It would seem that all this must be pure luck as when I went to degree my cams I realised that I didn't have any cam cards with the cams, 3SX would not supply me with any figures at all advising me to install them as stock, which I felt at the time was a bit poor really, non the less I just installed them using the standard timing marks and my 3SX adjustable cam gears set to zero which apparently could be anything.
Maybe by chance I have stumbled upon a decent setup for the cams as although the map sensor was faulty my tuner managed to get 440 bhp on the dyno at only .80bar boost for my TD05 20G's.
The only build information that I can give you is: 3SX Ross pistons 91.5mm @ 8.5:1, 3SX custom rods, which I assume are the standard stroke, Heads have not been decked. (Because if it aint broke don't fix it)
Jeff:coo3l:

J. Fast
05-08-2013, 06:05 PM
I spoke with Dustin regarding the can specifications for the 280 and 272 grinds.


*The Bc0142 cams have a 108 lobe separation.**The Bc0142 cams have a 108 lobe separation*The timing events I’m getting for the 280

INTAKE OPENING: 31 BTDC
INTAKE CLOSING: 69 ABDC
EXHAUST OPENING: 67 BBDC
EXHAUST CLOSING:*33 ATDC**

The timing events for the 272 are:*

IO 27 BTDC
IC 65 ABDC
EO 63 BBDC
EC 29 BTDC*
*

The numbers Dustin gave me are actuals when the cams are set to zero (aka straight up).

I cross referenced stealth316 piston specifications and inserted the diameter and cuts off the block of Courtney's build. I determined the actual static compression is approximately 8.3:1.

Using the dynamic compression calc with his blueprint and 280 degree cam's installed at stock centerline I determined the dynamic compression is 6.01: 1 and the cranking compression is 104psi at an elevation of 1000 feet above sea level.

If you took that same engine and brought it to Denver the dynamic pressure would be 5.40: 1 and the cranking pressure would be 85psi.

If anyone is wondering how wild this cam is? For the sake of comparison a stock TT engine has a dynamic compression of 7.85: 1 and cranking pressure is 155psi.

People who select this cam on low compression setups need to ditch it. At any elevation higher than sea level you be lucky to even fire your engine. This cam is designed for a static compression ratio of 10.5: 1 or greater or an engine with at minimum a 1/2 litre more displacement. Thank you for your honest answers Dustin.

Greg E
05-08-2013, 06:13 PM
JFast, can you post/PM/link me to sites where all the math is shown for figuring this out? I'm curious about some things.

J. Fast
05-08-2013, 06:28 PM
JFast, can you post/PM/link me to sites where all the math is shown for figuring this out? I'm curious about some things.
Most certainly Greg. I need to do some Chrome sharing with you also. When I get a few minutes I'll shoot you an email. PM me your addy .

3SX Service
05-14-2013, 12:41 PM
When Courtney’s vehicle left our facility the startup, idle, cruising, light acceleration, and heavy acceleration qualities were excellent. In fact we were actually very impressed with the low RPM running qualities of the engine considering the duration of the cams. Courtney himself even sent us an email telling us about how well the car drove and how hard it pulled.

The first time we heard of any driveability issues, with the vehicle, was in the post Chris made at the beginning of this thread. From what we can see the issues arose after injectors, spark plugs, and the tuning calibration had been changed. While the driveability may have changed the cams are absolutely not the culprit of the change.

Cam pulley slippage has been a common problem with the 6G72 engine when adjustable cam pulleys are used. While this is a well known fact, there are some things we have found that may help to alleviate the issues people are having. Chris uses a method of “pinning” the pulleys, as he stated in his previous post. We don’t disagree that this will, without question, keep a cam pulley from slipping. One problem with this method is there is no longer adjustability without removing the bolt, making adjustments, and then re-drilling and tapping the cam pulley. Another issue is balance. Crankshaft balancing is a common practice in engine building, but one of the less common practices is camshaft balancing. By installing an extra bolt in the cam pulley imbalance will result. The imbalance can cause valve train fluctuations that can ultimately result in broken parts.

The 3SX Cam pulleys are what we try to use on all of our builds. At times availability or a customer supplied part prohibits this. The reason we like the 3SX pulleys is in the way they “lock” the adjustment. To date we have not had any issues with the 3SX pulley slipping in our shop. The key to using the 3SX pulley, as with all pulleys, is to be sure the proper torque specifications are used.

Fidanza pulleys seem to have the worst reputation with the 3S market. While we don’t care for the design of the Fidanza pulleys as much as the 3SX pulley, we can’t say they are bad. The main issue we have found with the Fidanza pulleys is the way the two halves of the pulley are clamped together. Their design uses a button head allen bolt with a nut and washers. We have found that using some very basic, but specific, procedures these pulleys do not seem to cause problems.

In the case of Courtney’s cam pulleys Chris says he believes they slipped due to markings in the pulleys. We have not seen the pulleys to be able to verify this, but we have reason to believe they have not slipped based on the numbers stated in Chris’ post. Since those cam pulleys have been on that engine since 2006 there is a good possibility what Chris is seeing are markings from places the nuts have been tightened on a previous build, while degreeing, or while making adjustments on the dyno.

Brian Crower Cams have been used in a few of our builds in the last two years. All of these have been after Chris’ position at 3SX was terminated. While Chris was Service Manager here I was building an engine for Steve. The plan during the build was to test 3 different sets of cams, one of which was a set of BC Cams. At the time I was the first and only employee of 3SX with the knowledge and equipment to degree cams. Up until this point all cams were installed with either OEM cam pulleys, or with adjustable pulleys set at the famous +1 Intake -3 Exhaust setting. FYI – this setting is only applicable to camshafts using OEM centerlines, it may work for others, but can only be verified by testing. After degreeing the 3 sets of cams I found the BC cams to be so far out of specification there wasn’t enough adjustment in the pulleys to “zero” the cams. Since the other 2 sets of cams (one of which was OEM) both came in perfect or almost perfect it was decided to contact Brian Crower about the issues found. I spent a lot of time getting this issue resolved with Brian Crower. While Chris is correct in saying they did not ever really admit to anything he does not have the entire story. Those cams were sent to Brian Crower and eventually we were sent new cams. The new cams were installed on an engine after Chris’ termination and it was found that the cams were within an acceptable specification. They were by no means perfect, but acceptable. Using those cams, the engine was installed in a vehicle and dyno tuned. I was happy with the final outcome of the build so it was decided to give them another shot in a later build. Again the cams were not perfect, but acceptable. Since that time we have used them in a few of our higher power builds with good results, and we will continue to do so.

In the end just calling the Brian Crower Cams junk is not doing anything to help build the aftermarket parts availability for the 3S platform. However, working with the companies that manufacture the parts does. If everyone just jumps on the bandwagon, when a part is found to have a problem, tells many companies this is a platform to stay away from. It makes it look as though everyone is out to drag someone’s name through the mud every chance they get. This is why The Performance Factory and 3SX are trying to work with companies like Brian Crower to grow the parts availability for the 3S platform. In fact we have been in contact with Dustin from Brian Crower. We would like to do some extensive testing of their products to see some of the pros and cons, and see if we can work together to create a top notch product that everyone will be happy with. Keep in mind all of the other cams on the market are regrinds of some sort. Brian Crower is producing cams from cam blanks. Based on our experience this is much better, with much less of a chance of throwing rocker arms due to the correct base circle size keeping valvetrain geometry the way it was designed to be.

-John

Ninja Performance
05-14-2013, 01:14 PM
To state fact, The engine 3SX built for Courtney was built, installed, tuned and blown up on the dyno at 3sx, then Courtney was charged to build another engine.

Ray has run into this issue with these cams 3 times. I trust him over myself when it comes to cams, I admit that. I took his advice, as I posted I did, and sure enough, the rear cylinders came to life.

-Chris

dustin213
05-14-2013, 01:35 PM
To state fact, The engine 3SX built for Courtney was built, installed, tuned and blown up on the dyno at 3sx, then Courtney was charged to build another engine.

Ray has run into this issue with these cams 3 times. I trust him over myself when it comes to cams, I admit that. I took his advice, as I posted I did, and sure enough, the rear cylinders came to life.

-Chris

The cams in question are on the way back here and i will post the timing results side by side to the stock cams and we can figure out if it was a cam issue or something else.

Ninja Performance
05-16-2013, 08:27 PM
As mentioned previous, it could be that 280 is just too aggressive for idle and street cruise.

-Chris

J. Fast
05-17-2013, 12:15 PM
Dustin, can you release any pressure angle information and harmonic balance info on this cam thru 180 degrees? Also can you provide the lift for a 10 degree step increment from base circle to full throw? I'd like to see the working curve and understand how this cam ramps.

dustin213
05-17-2013, 04:22 PM
Dustin, can you release any pressure angle information and harmonic balance info on this cam thru 180 degrees? Also can you provide the lift for a 10 degree step increment from base circle to full throw? I'd like to see the working curve and understand how this cam ramps.

The BC0142 intake:
(these numbers are at the cam and pick up 16-18 degrees at the valve after the rocker ratio)
.006" - 262.41 (at the valve 280)
.020" - 233.97
.050" - 202.11 (at the valve 218)
.100" - 166.07
.200" - 91.87

BC0142 exhaust
.006" - 262.12(at the valve 280)
.020" - 229.35
.050" - 198.08 (at the valve 216)
.100" - 162.12
.150" - 127.82
.200" - 87.00

dustin213
05-17-2013, 04:25 PM
Dustin, can you release any pressure angle information and harmonic balance info on this cam thru 180 degrees? Also can you provide the lift for a 10 degree step increment from base circle to full throw? I'd like to see the working curve and understand how this cam ramps.

The BC0142 intake:
(these numbers are at the cam and pick up 16-18 degrees at the valve after the rocker ratio)
.006" - 262.41 (at the valve 280)
.020" - 233.97
.050" - 202.11 (at the valve 218)
.100" - 166.07
.200" - 91.87

BC0142 exhaust
.006" - 262.12(at the valve 280)
.020" - 229.35
.050" - 198.08 (at the valve 216)
.100" - 162.12
.150" - 127.82
.200" - 87.00

J. Fast
05-17-2013, 06:04 PM
What are the numbers off the stock cams you've received for comparison?

Do you have a harmonic plot?

dustin213
05-17-2013, 06:33 PM
[QUOTE=J. Fast;237939]What are the numbers off the stock cams you've received for comparison?



The stock cams we already have here that we used in the beginning are:
(centerline of the dowel to the centerline of the 1st lobe)
clockwise:
FRONT INTAKE - 338.2 DEGREES
FRONT EXHAUST - 283.15 DEGREES
REAR INTAKE - 113.15 DEGREES
REAR EXHUAST - 24.3 DEGREES


We should have a few more sets of stock cams back hear next week to compare along with the cams from this thread.

Fakepower
05-26-2013, 07:08 PM
Just to alert anyone interested, things are getting quite interesting over at 3SI. The thread has now been named "Cam Talk", which I think we should do here as well. Some very fundamental aspects of the 6g72 engine are being discussed. I'd suggest you take a look.

I'd ask Ray to bring the information over here for a quick summary.

J. Fast
05-27-2013, 12:35 AM
There is a program for this very issue in Perfomance Trends.

Rocker Ratio (http://performancetrends.com/Definitions/Rocker-Ratio.htm)

http://performancetrends.com/Definitions/Images/True-Rocker-Ratio-Lrg.gif


Rocker Ratio is always changing because the Rocker Arm tip is moving on an arc around it's center pivotpoint, but the valve stem goes straight up and down. This means that as the Rocker Arm moves, the distance from the pivot point to the contact point on the valve stem is always changing. If this distance is changing, the Rocker Ratio is also changing. For Over Head (http://performancetrends.com/Definitions/Heads.htm) Cam valve trains, the change in Rocker Ratio is much more dramatic. It is not unusual for the ratios to change from 3.0 to 1.5 during the entire valve lift event.
Programs that take Rocker Ratio into account that work with Rocker Ratio when conducting Engine Simulation (http://performancetrends.com/Engine-Simulation.htm) are Performance Trends: Engine Analyzer (http://performancetrends.com/Engine-Analyzer.htm) v3.4, Engine Analyzer Plus (http://performancetrends.com/Engine-Analyzer-Plus.htm) v3.4, and Engine Analyzer Pro (http://performancetrends.com/Engine-Analyzer-Pro.htm) v3.9.

I'm truly surprised the advanced tech's that have been dogging cam profiles and building performance engines for all these years have never once verified an engine blueprint. Again, issues like this are very simply identified by calculating the dynamic compression ratio of an engine build. You typically verify the dynamic compression and combustion chamber volume numbers from full valve close for all the cylinders. When the machine work is in spec and TDC numbers are off by 5 degrees on a degree wheel from bank to bank and the cylinder compression volumes at full valve closing events are off by 20%... it's time to start looking at the rocker ratio.

Part of building performance engines requires evaluating changes in block deck height, head surface milling, gaskets, and other machine work which may impact rocker arm geometry. Proper performance engine building practice demands the inspection and verification of proper rocker arm geometry to optimize combustion chamber sweep volume.

In racing where everyone has to use the same cam and spec engine... the difference between the winners and loosers often times comes down to rocker ratio optimization. The effect of changing the rocker ratio is often an increase in horsepower of about 5-10%.

I personally don't think the 6G72 requires cams of any sort. I think it would benefit most from aftermarket rockers which would lengthen the overall valve timing. It's a kiss solution also because 6g7TT cams are symmetrical.

Blackmount
05-27-2013, 04:38 AM
I've been reading between the two threads for the info between the lines that neither share.

Revised epic awesomesauce BC Cams... Or some Epic CNC/Billet/whatev Rocker Arms in pretty colors..

eitherway I want whatever parts may come out of this thread...

mehrshadvr4
05-27-2013, 05:51 AM
The rocker arms on our engine is different. It's being pushed from the top instead of V8s that a rod is pushing them up from one end. The pivot point is different for them so they can change the ratio pretty easy.

J. Fast
05-27-2013, 12:22 PM
This is not a new discussion. I spoke with doctorstupid about this many many years ago. There was once this thread at 3si regarding cams and this very issue. It's in the archives...

What camshafts for a highly modified 6G72 ? - Page 12 - 3000GT/Stealth International Message Center (http://www.3si.org/forum/f42/what-camshafts-highly-modified-6g72-290498/index12.html#post3293249)


The Race cams properly set up (222 at .050) are DEFINITELY worth the cash. They are dynamicaly sound if installed properly. I used to think re-grinds wern't worth it, but if you do your homework, and do just go "yay, I have cams, let's go!", you will have very pleasant results. I have been informed by some of the best in this game that anything past .400 is risky in these cars (valve spring bind could occur.......that bends rockers, breaks springs, and wears out cams if you have solid lifters). I spent SEVERAL hours measuring my cam lobes, rocker ratio, valve travel, cam position, etc. etc. etc, and once I got it ALL done, the cams are 222 at .050 http://www.3si.org/forum/images/smilies/smile.gif, but they are around 290 at .006 (what most people "advertise"). You have to make sure the lobes are set up right 'though. Mine had a slight machining goof where the front bank cams were cut backwars (intake cam had slow ramp open time and exhaust had quick ramp open time). All it took was switching them and breaking out the degree wheel to fix 'though. At spec card settings, The cams are set up to give you good spool up and high flow. I actually have 2 settings that I use now. using engine analyzer pro, I figured out that if you retard the race intake grind cam 12 degrees and Advanve the Race exhaust cam 8 (sounds wierd, I know), then you won't get the hard torque hit from boost comming on, but it will make substantially more power past 5K (the range I plan to be in). of course this isn't proven yet, but the other signs the program has given me were right, so I trust it (like the compression test psi numbers were DEAD ON, the vaccuum numbers were close, and the description of how the car would drive was exactly like the computer said. 0 intake and 0 exhaust would give high compression becuase of the average total lift increase on the intake cam during the intake down stroke, but it would give a higher valve overlap compared to my other setting. -12 intake +8 exhaust would give less compression pressure becuase of the reduced ammount of average lift on the intake down stroke, and the ammount of time the valve is open on the compression up stroke, but it has almost no overlap. It even idles beter at that setting (computer said it would do that also). The boost makes up for the drop in compression pressure well 'though. The only thing that is kinda annoying about that setting is the noise. since the intake valve opens about the same time the exhaust valve closes, the combination of noise resonates into a kind of clatter that sounds like bent valves. it doesn't show up on the knock logger, but you can hear it if the hood is open. I checked that out pretty throughly.

All in all I would say if you want to make 700+ whp or want to rev past 7K and still make power and have the turbos to do it, DEFINITELY go with the DR Race cams. The shims that come with them are for STOCK LIFTERS!, so if you get aftermarket or different year lifters, you have to take that into account (get some calipers and measure a fully extended lifter set, take the average, and measure the average of the new lifters fully extended and shim accordingly...........or else your car won't run right). Hardened shims isn't bad for your motor unless you are no longer getting proper oiling to your lifter oil port. as long as that lifter port is still getting oil, everything is oiled just like it was from the OEM. Hydraulic lifters give you a little "cushion" on the cam shaft so they don't take as much abuse and can be made from cheaper tempered materials. solid cams (like in some poerformace v8's 2jz and 3s toyota motors, RB nissan motors, etc) have to be made HARD so they can last a long time. hydraulic roller cams don't have as much as a wear problem becuase of that. That being said, I have seem some 7M Toyota cams that were BEAT UP becuase of abuse. Now, I know there will be some people that disagree with me, but please just go measure some stuff first. I spent a good bit of time making sure i did my setup right, and I am fairly confident in my findings]

Cam chart is Courtesy of doctorstupid...

http://i788.photobucket.com/albums/yy163/JFastMotorsports/CamSheet_zps219b1a13.png
Again, you have to actually measure and mathematically calculate the specs for your valetrain and take into acoount how it interacts with the bottom end to have positive results with cams. There are two schools of thought. First, go with it... and figure it out on the dyno. Second, actually measure and rely on real numbers and software... to give you an optimized answer (and then fine tune it on a dyno). I personally think it would take hours on a dyno to work your way towards -12 intake +8 exhaust on a racegrind camshaft. I seriously don't think anyone would feel comfortable degreeing a cam that far without software either.

I choose engine math and method #2.

I did notice someone gave up the ghost on aftermarket camshafts being cut incorrectly because the rocker ratio was never evaluated correctly. Some folks had that answer a long time ago when they actually measured. I understand measuring takes a lot of time and it's much easier to bolt stuff on an post up dyno results which show you make more power... but is that really the right way?


Got shit to do... Cheers!

RealMcCoy
05-27-2013, 01:59 PM
Just to alert anyone interested, things are getting quite interesting over at 3SI. The thread has now been named "Cam Talk", which I think we should do here as well. Some very fundamental aspects of the 6g72 engine are being discussed. I'd suggest you take a look.

I'd ask Ray to bring the information over here for a quick summary.

I have my doubts Ray has any desire to mess with this thread anymore... It stopped being about solving a problem a long time ago. Ray is a nice guy, and has earned the respect he's not getting in this thread. I do wish this thread could be about members working together to solve a problem, but until it stops being about who's the smartest guy in the room, it's not going anywhere...

I'll recap a bit of what is going on in the other thread:

Ray is working with Dustin to resolve the issue, and design a cam that works well in our engines... The issue has been identified as an improper design by almost all the aftermaket builders. The factory designed the lobes of the cam with a profile that could be used in all locations. (a mirror image) So that the front bank cams lift ramp was the rear bank cams closing ramp. This compensated for the difference in the lift arc as the front cams are lifting the opposite side of the roller than the rear cams.

The different aftermarket companies either built cams with all the same profiles, or if they did recognize that they were mirror images, they didn't map out and design the ramps to work equally on both banks.




I personally don't think the 6G72 requires cams of any sort. I think it would benefit most from aftermarket rockers which would lengthen the overall valve timing. It's a kiss solution also because 6g7TT cams are symmetrical.

WTF did I just read...?

J. Fast
05-28-2013, 01:44 AM
This is a 1.86:1 Dodge manufactured roller rocker. Dodge manufactures a number of roller rockers with respective ratio's of 1.64, 1,71, 1.76, and 1.86. If one were so inclined they could easily be manufactured to a custom spec for somwhere in the $20 each range but since Mopar makes one lets use this one. :)

http://i788.photobucket.com/albums/yy163/JFastMotorsports/fev2_zps977fe475.jpg

Stock cam lift on a 1G cam is .215 Intake and .204 Exhaust and the stock 6g72 rocker arm ratio is 1.71 so at max lift ==>>> Intake = .215 x 1.71 = .368 and Exhaust = .204 x 1.71 = .348. Those numbers jive with doctorstupid's actual measured and confirmed numbers provided in the above cam spec table.

Now lets swap to a different hydraulic roller rocker arm from say a VMXX dodge like the one depicted, that "FITS" and soo...

Same stock cam with a 1.86 roller rocker ratio calc's out at... Intake .215 x 1.86 = .400 the Exhaust calc's out at .204 x 1.71 = .380.

No need for guessing if it will work or not, it's complimetary of the OEM cams so lift will arrive at the MFR's optimized spec. No sacrifice in excessive duration which results in high boost power fall off due to boost escaping in overlap. It achieves approximately .40 lift which is comparable to a 272 spec cam, except it ramps exactly like a stock cam (because it's following one :) ) and according to the table has the same amount of lift as a Dynamic Racing 292 Advertised duration race spec camshaft.

Truth about how engines work... that is what you just read.

GTOJOE
05-28-2013, 06:17 AM
Although most of jfast's posts seem extremely arrogant this one makes sense. If the stock cam is 99% right then upgrading the rocker instead of cams would eliminate the need to degree the cams. A bonus if the engine is already in place.

Sent from my GT-I9300 using Tapatalk 2

Boostaddict
05-28-2013, 11:49 AM
If they were indeed 100% compatible with our stock valvetrain geometry that would be pretty slick. Buy one and test fit ;)

anyonebutme
05-28-2013, 05:02 PM
The factory designed the lobes of the cam with a profile that could be used in all locations. (a mirror image) So that the front bank cams lift ramp was the rear bank cams closing ramp. This compensated for the difference in the lift arc as the front cams are lifting the opposite side of the roller than the rear cams.



The stock cams are not mirror images....and the opening ramps on the front cams are not the closing ramps on the rear. I'm at work so I can't explain it with pretty graphs, but all cams rotate the same direction so the opening ramps are on the right side of the lobe on all 4 cams....the slight difference in lobe profile is for kinematic purpose and is not in fact a mirror image. The entire issue with all the tested cams is they incorrectly used a mirror image profile.

Fakepower
05-28-2013, 09:41 PM
I have my doubts Ray has any desire to mess with this thread anymore... It stopped being about solving a problem a long time ago. Ray is a nice guy, and has earned the respect he's not getting in this thread. I do wish this thread could be about members working together to solve a problem, but until it stops being about who's the smartest guy in the room, it's not going anywhere...


Yeah, this thread is going great, we've got rockers with hypothetical fitment/custom manufacturing to change valvetrain geometry. Since this has everything to do BC cams and/or cam design this thread has essentially died. When the hypothetical engineering happens someone let me know, I'll be reading at 3si.

Unknownvr4
05-28-2013, 09:46 PM
In to see if those dodge rockers work.

RealMcCoy
05-28-2013, 11:18 PM
Truth about how engines work... that is what you just read.

Well thank you for explaining all that complicated multiplication... I never would have figured that out on my own. And to think for the last 30 years I've been using non stock rocker ratios on performance engines because of their pretty anodized colors... (I'm partial to the blue ones, but the red ones and gold ones aren't bad either) Who knew they actually did something...? I never did understand the customers that insisted on spending twice the money for those plain forged steel ones, they aren't nearly as pretty as the blue ones.

So when you change the rocker ratio, how do you propose to do it...? Are you going to move the roller closer to the pivot? (rolling the contact point around the base circle and fucking the cam timing) Or are you going to figure out a way to move the pivot closer to the roller, shortening the rocker? (increasing attack angles, increasing the scrub across the tip of the valve stem, and potentially building a motor that eats valve guides for lunch)

Of course with both options, you have the little issue of modifying the geometry and potentially causing the very issue that sparked this thread...

Or are you now going to take the position that it's a small variation, and for the projected cost of less than $500 it's an acceptable compromise... No extensive computer models and testing needed?

OH.... One more thing:

Do you have a harmonic plot?




The stock cams are not mirror images....and the opening ramps on the front cams are not the closing ramps on the rear. I'm at work so I can't explain it with pretty graphs, but all cams rotate the same direction so the opening ramps are on the right side of the lobe on all 4 cams....the slight difference in lobe profile is for kinematic purpose and is not in fact a mirror image. The entire issue with all the tested cams is they incorrectly used a mirror image profile.

I may have misread or misunderstood the statements made in the other thread, and made that assumption.(I'll have to go back and review) I also may have made my statement poorly, allowing for easy misinterpretation. I didn't mean to imply that there were opening ramps on different sides of the cams. My assumption was that the lobes were ground to the same profile for both front and rear,(intake and exhaust separately) but flipped in a mirror image depending on what side of the rocker the lobe was climbing...

That assumption, while it may very well be wrong, was backed up by observation... If you look at the cams, you can visibly see the steep ramp on one side, and the slower ramp on the other, If you set the front and rear intake cams side by side, the steep ramp is on the left of one cam, and on the right of the other. If you flip one of the cams around backwards so that the steep ramp is on the same side of both, there is no visible difference in the lobes whatsoever.

I'm fully aware that you can't eyeball a cam profile, but when comparing two samples side by side, you can see some pretty minor variations. So I can say, if they aren't mirror images, they're pretty damn close...

wingnut
05-28-2013, 11:31 PM
http://replygif.net/i/665

anyonebutme
05-29-2013, 02:07 AM
I may have misread or misunderstood the statements made in the other thread, and made that assumption.(I'll have to go back and review) I also may have made my statement poorly, allowing for easy misinterpretation. I didn't mean to imply that there were opening ramps on different sides of the cams. My assumption was that the lobes were ground to the same profile for both front and rear,(intake and exhaust separately) but flipped in a mirror image depending on what side of the rocker the lobe was climbing...

That assumption, while it may very well be wrong, was backed up by observation... If you look at the cams, you can visibly see the steep ramp on one side, and the slower ramp on the other, If you set the front and rear intake cams side by side, the steep ramp is on the left of one cam, and on the right of the other. If you flip one of the cams around backwards so that the steep ramp is on the same side of both, there is no visible difference in the lobes whatsoever.

I'm fully aware that you can't eyeball a cam profile, but when comparing two samples side by side, you can see some pretty minor variations. So I can say, if they aren't mirror images, they're pretty damn close...

I know that it looks that way, and if you are eyeballing or measuring an aftermarket cam, that will very well be the case as every one what was measured in fact had mirrored profiles down to 0.012". But the stock cams are a little more complicated. I'll have to ask Steve Lawtey for permission to use his measurement graphs of stock cams and web grinds that he made for private use to show the difference. Comes down to the fact that the rockers are reversed doesn't mean you mirror the profile, as all 4 cams still rotate the same direction. Looks small on stock cams, and is supposed to look small on large cams.

I also don't know if Steve already dumped this info onto the 3si thread......

IPD
05-29-2013, 02:13 AM
Yeah, this thread is going great, we've got rockers with hypothetical fitment/custom manufacturing to change valvetrain geometry. Since this has everything to do BC cams and/or cam design this thread has essentially died. When the hypothetical engineering happens someone let me know, I'll be reading at 3si.

ain't never bad enough to warrant that.

J. Fast
05-29-2013, 11:30 AM
OH.... One more thing:

Do you have a harmonic plot?


LOL... I do now :) . I just used the lift profile from Ray Pamena's cam profiler... Max lift at .195 with a roller rocker ratio of 1.71 yield's Lawtleys max lift number of .335. So with a 1.85 it will map out like this. I'm feeling pretty lazy ATM so no need for computer aided drafting but I suppose I could overlap the intake and exhaust plots for a 3 periods or so on a CAD program and examine a full harmonic plot. A pencil and paper is much faster for me since I'm in the field ATM.

Have a lovely day :D


http://i788.photobucket.com/albums/yy163/JFastMotorsports/20130529_081223_zps319222e5.jpg

Ninja Performance
05-29-2013, 01:40 PM
This is a 1.86:1 Dodge manufactured roller rocker. Dodge manufactures a number of roller rockers with respective ratio's of 1.64, 1,71, 1.76, and 1.86. If one were so inclined they could easily be manufactured to a custom spec for somwhere in the $20 each range but since Mopar makes one lets use this one. :)

http://i788.photobucket.com/albums/yy163/JFastMotorsports/fev2_zps977fe475.jpg

Stock cam lift on a 1G cam is .215 Intake and .204 Exhaust and the stock 6g72 rocker arm ratio is 1.71 so at max lift ==>>> Intake = .215 x 1.71 = .368 and Exhaust = .204 x 1.71 = .348. Those numbers jive with doctorstupid's actual measured and confirmed numbers provided in the above cam spec table.

Now lets swap to a different hydraulic roller rocker arm from say a VMXX dodge like the one depicted, that "FITS" and soo...

Same stock cam with a 1.86 roller rocker ratio calc's out at... Intake .215 x 1.86 = .400 the Exhaust calc's out at .204 x 1.71 = .380.

No need for guessing if it will work or not, it's complimetary of the OEM cams so lift will arrive at the MFR's optimized spec. No sacrifice in excessive duration which results in high boost power fall off due to boost escaping in overlap. It achieves approximately .40 lift which is comparable to a 272 spec cam, except it ramps exactly like a stock cam (because it's following one :) ) and according to the table has the same amount of lift as a Dynamic Racing 292 Advertised duration race spec camshaft.

Truth about how engines work... that is what you just read.

So what is the dodge part# for the 1.86?, I will try a set real world.

-Chris

donniekak
05-29-2013, 02:30 PM
With the cam, valve, and lash adjuster being fixed, a different ratio rocker will have to be the same length as stock, with a moved roller. This will change valve to cam timing events.

Ray Pampena
05-29-2013, 03:55 PM
to sum up some of the developments in the other thread.. heres what we have.

the stock cams are ground near symmetrical. the very slight ramp change bank to bank is to compensate the slight offset of the rocker when pushed off center. when measured at the valve they are symmetrical

there are aftermarket cams that copied that but exagerated the reversed ramping way too much that when measured at the valve you now have reverse profiles front to back.. which was never meant to be.

then there are other cams that made all 4 the same way but are missing the slight difference needed for front and rear bank placement due to rocker offset.

im working with BC to get cams that are the same front and back measured at the valve... which will be slightly different measured at the lobe due to the rockers being moved slightly from center when open.

final open and closing ramps will have to be determined on the dyno for power

RealMcCoy
05-29-2013, 04:36 PM
Awesome.... Helpful accurate and informative update, while deftly sidestepping the train wreck...

Well played sir.. :lol:

AdamVR4
05-29-2013, 05:35 PM
Cash in hand, patiently waiting for the group buy... soooo happy this is happening!

Ninja Performance
05-29-2013, 10:41 PM
Only 20+ years after it's release, Proper cams may exist soon. This would be a great development. Crossing my fingers. A nice street cam, nothing crazy, would be a nice start.

-Chris

R/T93
05-29-2013, 11:19 PM
If a proper street cam was released... I may bite.

Sent from my SCH-I535 using Tapatalk 4 Beta

IPD
05-30-2013, 03:41 AM
i thought 272's were street cams & 280's were race cams...

mehrshadvr4
05-30-2013, 03:51 AM
to sum up some of the developments in the other thread.. heres what we have.

the stock cams are ground near symmetrical. the very slight ramp change bank to bank is to compensate the slight offset of the rocker when pushed off center. when measured at the valve they are symmetrical

there are aftermarket cams that copied that but exagerated the reversed ramping way too much that when measured at the valve you now have reverse profiles front to back.. which was never meant to be.

then there are other cams that made all 4 the same way but are missing the slight difference needed for front and rear bank placement due to rocker offset.

im working with BC to get cams that are the same front and back measured at the valve... which will be slightly different measured at the lobe due to the rockers being moved slightly from center when open.

final open and closing ramps will have to be determined on the dyno for power

Could you reveal What changes they are planning to make? are they revising the both front and rear bank or just the rear?

J. Fast
05-30-2013, 10:36 AM
Good to hear the progress on the development of a correct cam grind.

On with the cam topic... I'm sure some, self included, are interested in opinions on OEM lifters vs. solid lifters with aftermarket cams and OEM cams. Ninja, are you currently running solid lifters? Any chance you can degree now and then upgrade just lifters (BLE Solids) to see if there are any gains in lift and on the top end? A before and after test with OEM lifters vs. solid lifter would be fantastic before you cam swap. It would be interesting to see if any gains were to be had from a lifter swap alone. A swap to solid lifters alone peaks my interest. It makes me wonder if the solid allows the valve to come back to the seat in high rpm (vs. collapsing like the OEM ones do) and keeps the cylinder pressure from bleeding off. I don't think anything like that has been measured yet. Sure would be another excellent cam related item to get some results on.

Ninja Performance
05-30-2013, 10:47 AM
I have always run old first gen stock lash adjusters in my car. No solids.

-Chris

Tigchamp
05-30-2013, 10:56 AM
I have always run old first gen stock lash adjusters in my car. No solids.

-Chris

I guess the first Gen ones wont bleed down as fast at high revs as the later 3mm ones.
I did try the BLE solid lifters in mine but never set them up quite right and bearing in mind that I only have standard oil pump gears I will not be revving too high so replaced them with the 3mm hydraulic ones.
Jeff:coo3l:

J. Fast
05-30-2013, 11:14 AM
I have always run old first gen stock lash adjusters in my car. No solids.

-Chris

I read this article many years ago regarding Solid vs Hydraulic lifters in Mopar Magazine. The gains going to solids in above 5000rpm conditions were very convincing. I too have "laggy" TD-05's and get the top end crash when I wrap it out to 8000rpm's. I often wonder if the fallout is due my 3rd gen lifters overextending and locking which keeps the valve off the seat just enough to bleed off cylinder pressure. Apparently solid lifters (lashed correctly) are less susceptible to this? I will try and dig this article up with the back to back dyno results this afternoon. I want to say the engine sustained rougly 100 ft/lbs of tq more for about 1000rpms longer, and picked up rougly 50hp above 5000rpm's with a solid lifter swap.

Ninja Performance
05-30-2013, 11:26 AM
I read this article many years ago regarding Solid vs Hydraulic lifters in Mopar Magazine. The gains going to solids in above 5000rpm conditions were very convincing. I too have "laggy" TD-05's and get the top end crash when I wrap it out to 8000rpm's. I often wonder if the fallout is due my 3rd gen lifters overextending and locking which keeps the valve off the seat just enough to bleed off cylinder pressure. Apparently solid lifters (lashed correctly) are less susceptible to this? I will try and dig this article up with the back to back dyno results this afternoon. I want to say the engine sustained rougly 100 ft/lbs of tq more for about 1000rpms longer, and picked up rougly 50hp above 5000rpm's with a solid lifter swap.

I can tell you this, first gen or big bore, when I rev out at the dragstrip to 8700-9000 I come back to the pits with bled down clattering lash adjusters and have to rev, rev, rev for 5-10 minutes to get them bled and full again. Maybe solids would be something I should try.

-Chris

J. Fast
05-30-2013, 11:38 AM
I can tell you this, first gen or big bore, when I rev out at the dragstrip to 8700-9000 I come back to the pits with bled down clattering lash adjusters and have to rev, rev, rev for 5-10 minutes to get them bled and full again. Maybe solids would be something I should try.

-Chris

I experience the same condition. I think that's an overextending instance where the valves aren't able to fully seat because the lifters are locked? A few times I tried to push past 8200rpms I swear I thought I fouled a plug or something when I came off the rev limiter because my engine sounded like it was choking and clanking. I definitely think the lifter swap alone is worth a try. If it works for V8 applications I would have to assume the same will ring true for us.

I would have swapped out to solid lifters awhile ago but it's a huge ass hastle because you have to take the whole top end off two or three times and fine adjust the lash... big pain in the ass! I'm lazy when it comes to my cars now. I just want to drive them.. When you work on everyone elses it sucks to work on your own. Not having to is a breath of fresh air, LOL.

RealMcCoy
05-30-2013, 11:52 AM
Simply swapping in solid lash adjusters is not an ideal solution... If you run the clearance really tight on a roller type follower, you can often get away with it without damage, but a properly designed mechanical cam profile has a pre-lift ramp ground into the profile to take up the lash as it begins the lift. You also lose lift and duration in the amount of whatever lash clearance you run.(X rocker ratio)

If you tried that with an older design flat tappet cam, it would beat itself to death in minutes....

It's not like we have a lot of options in this platform, and you do what you gotta do, but I don't think I would be swapping to solids unless I was really twisting the hell out of the motor, and could afford to lose a little camshaft profile. There is little comparison between our lash adjusters, and the old Chevy/Ford/Mopar lifters that would pump up at 6-7K RPM. If you're exceeding 8K, I can understand the desire to stabilize the valvetrain, (and reduce top end oil flow) but under that I don't think the value ads up...

Ninja Performance
05-30-2013, 11:54 AM
I experience the same condition. I think that's an overextending instance where the valves aren't able to fully seat because the lifters are locked? A few times I tried to push past 8200rpms I swear I thought I fouled a plug or something when I came off the rev limiter because my engine sounded like it was choking and clanking. I definitely think the lifter swap alone is worth a try. If it works for V8 applications I would have to assume the same will ring true for us.

I would have swapped out to solid lifters awhile ago but it's a huge ass hastle because you have to take the whole top end off two or three times and fine adjust the lash... big pain in the ass! I'm lazy when it comes to my cars now. I just want to drive them.. When you work on everyone elses it sucks to work on your own. Not having to is a breath of fresh air, LOL.

Yes, the Initial break in/heat cycle and resetting them 2-3 times is a PITA. One reason I never did it on my car. I did it on T4 many years ago. It sux, you have to pop off rockers, remove lash, adjust, put in, check, pull back out repeat. 24 times.

-Chris

AdamVR4
05-30-2013, 12:23 PM
I can tell you this, first gen or big bore, when I rev out at the dragstrip to 8700-9000 I come back to the pits with bled down clattering lash adjusters and have to rev, rev, rev for 5-10 minutes to get them bled and full again. Maybe solids would be something I should try.

-Chris


So are you saying I should not install the '99 lifters I bought from you on my 3.5L that may have FP greens and spin up to 8000 RPM's? :p

Ray Pampena
05-30-2013, 12:43 PM
theres a few different things happening here that you guys are describing. personally on my own cars ive never had any of those problems.

#1 make a high rpm run and afterward you have ticking but runs fine still= the lifters are bleading off during your run. too much valve spring tension, worn or poor quality lifters or not enough oil pressure to the heads.

#2 the other.. make a high rpm run and the car makes some noises and has dead cylinders and runs poorly for a while= over extended lifters from the not enough spring tension resulting in floating valves. when the valves float, the lifter takes up the slack and now the valves dont close.

as McCoy said, the "solid" portion of a cam is only just one piece of the puzzle. on the domestics discussed, the cam grind itself is designed to be solid. also, the tension of the springs used for the revs desired and the open and close ramp dont work well with hydraulics. but thats those cars. in those engines, the lifter is also responsible for moving the weight of a pushrod and rocker.

i have this neat tool i made a bunch of years back that i never tried. its a lifter that i machined and rigged to hold memory of how far it is bled down.. if any during a run. you KNOW if it were bled UP because the car would run how i described in description #2

http://i27.photobucket.com/albums/c178/raysinsomnia/20130530_114155_zps7b9b1871.jpg (http://s27.photobucket.com/user/raysinsomnia/media/20130530_114155_zps7b9b1871.jpg.html)

donniekak
05-30-2013, 02:22 PM
I run the same lifters in Dsm's and have no issues up to 9k. A possible issue with the 6g72 may be the really small oil restrictor in the oil passage to the heads.

Tigchamp
05-30-2013, 02:42 PM
mmmm, if the gains are noticeable at only 5000 revs perhaps I may re-install mine when I do the cam timing belt.
Jeff:coo3l:

Ninja Performance
05-30-2013, 02:46 PM
When I drag run and run 3rd out to 8800 or so I get awful bleed down lash adjuster clatter. But mine is as Ray described #1, car runs perfect. Smooth. Just noisy lash adjusters. I run stock cams with hi rev spring kit, cause back in the day I tested all kinds of cams in my heads until settling on stockers.

So maybe I should be on stock springs? I rev up to 8500 so I don't want float. But have stock cams.

-Chris

mehrshadvr4
05-30-2013, 03:11 PM
What springs are you using?

Ninja Performance
05-30-2013, 03:36 PM
It was back when I worked for 3SX, so whatever springs they used, can't remember where they got them from. They are single springs.

-Chris

Stealth_RT
05-30-2013, 10:06 PM
Running BC264's I bought off Ninja. When they were listed on his website, the description stated something along the lines of only requiring the stock valve springs, IIRC. Can't remember the exact words or descriptions. I took that to mean that, since these cams are pretty mild, 264 vs the stock 256, that high tension, hi-rev springs weren't needed. I'm not running above the stock redline, so I'm hoping I don't run into problems like rockers coming off or floating valves.

J. Fast
05-30-2013, 11:14 PM
I believe I've encountered condition #2 as Ray described. I'm running stock valve springs and 3rd gen lifters winding up to 8500rpms or so. When I come off the limiter if I miss a shift it clankity clanks. Sounds like it's down on a cylinder and the wakes up about a min later. Definitely not knock related.

Soundslike the undertone on the BLE lifters is use only with an aftermarket cam, did I hear that right? What is the design intent of the BLE's? I'm a little confused regarding their application intent and wether or not they are compatible with stock cams? Sounds like some are saying they are not? They are not a flat tappet lifter so let's discuss.

RealMcCoy
05-30-2013, 11:27 PM
I believe I've encountered condition #2 as Ray described. I'm running stock valve springs and 3rd gen lifters winding up to 8500rpms or so. When I come off the limiter if I miss a shift it clankity clanks. Sounds like it's down on a cylinder and the wakes up about a min later. Definitely not knock related.

Soundslike the undertone on the BLE lifters is use only with an aftermarket cam, did I hear that right? What is the design intent of the BLE's? I'm a little confused regarding their application intent and wether or not they are compatible with stock cams? Sounds like some are saying they are not? They are not a flat tappet lifter so let's discuss.

It sounds like you're simply floating the valves... Even with stock cams, 8500 is pretty extreme for stock valve springs.

I'm not saying the solids won't work, I'm saying the cams are not ground to be mechanical cams... If you run the lash tight enough, it may not know the difference. I'm just pointing out that it's a factor that needs to be considered when making that call. For me, the fact that I can't call up a supplier and buy a mechanical cam and lifters for my car, puts it in the realm of: I would REALLY have to NEED solid lifters, and have no other options, to make me go there...

J. Fast
05-30-2013, 11:51 PM
It sounds like you're simply floating the valves... Even with stock cams, 8500 is pretty extreme for stock valve springs.

I'm not saying the solids won't work, I'm saying the cams are not ground to be mechanical cams... If you run the lash tight enough, it may not know the difference. I'm just pointing out that it's a factor that needs to be considered when making that call. For me, the fact that I can't call up a supplier and buy a mechanical cam and lifters for my car, puts it in the realm of: I would REALLY have to NEED solid lifters, and have no other options, to make me go there...

Yep, definitely floating valves. But it's a double edge sword. Too much spring vs, not enough... Trial and error thing I suppose. You've made several valid points. I'm still thinking the hydraulic lifters were merely installed for production simplicity. They zero lash on their own very quickly, are quiet (sometimes lol), and take up some of the valvetrain resonance with their dampening effects. I think they were put there for pure longterm maint and lash adjustment simplicity. My brain tells me because they have pumped spring tension/compresion preload... as we excite them they get naturally get stiffer. A certain part of me truly believes part of the top end power drop-off in our engines is due to the gap left on the valve seat from hydraulic lifter pump up. They get progressively stiffer the higher we rev our engines. I think their design intent was for sub 6000rpms. Anything above and they interfere with the valve closing event. Possibly, it's just a natural characteristic of hydro adjusters? Solids don't necessarily have a preload built in so they'll be a bit louder till the oil is pumped up but eventually they will splash as intended. They won't hold preload so they'll just keep pumping and the valve will return to full seat. In our case the lifters don't scrub the cam so I believe solid cams are not necessary. With OEM lifters I believe the "lift" window shinks for one, and the the window stays open at high rpm's which allows for compression to escape. It's a fatal flaw in a hydralic lifter becuse of their design. I think because of this design flaw our valvetrain would benefit most from solid lifters in high rev/high boost applications. Yes, ofcourse cam's are a great addition also, but simply from a performace standpoint I believe a solid lifter swap is a perfomce gain if you have good oil pressure. Thoughts?

RealMcCoy
05-31-2013, 12:31 AM
That was my point about the necessity to run the lash clearance very tight... In order for the cam to not be impacting the follower every time it takes up the lash. (or falling out from under it on the closing event and possibly creating a bounce) Ever taken the cams out of one of our motors that's been allowed to run with bad lifter tick for many thousands of miles? the cams get beat to hell...

The mechanical rollers I used to run in the race big block Chevys had a lash spec of usually around .020"-.023", with over .700" lift, and around 310deg duration. (with an 8K rev limit) if they weren't ground to gently take up and release the lash, they would have beat themselves to death in one race, roller or not...

I agree the hydraulic lash adjusters are designed for ease of maintenance... (As well as faster build production) But I don't believe ours to have an issue with pumping up unless the valve springs are inadequate. I still have the stock ECU in my car, so I'm limited to the stock rev limit (7300 I think?) but I spent enough time hovering under it that I know there is no issue whatsoever in the 6-7K range. the DSM guys run the same lifter, and are often way over 8K...

I"m not trying to deter anyone from going with solids, I just think that a properly matched valve train with adequate valve springs will work just fine for most people. For those that want to take the plunge, I'd just want them to have an idea of the design differences, and what they're getting into...

donniekak
05-31-2013, 01:37 AM
I run the same lash adjusters in my 4g63, and rev to 9000 rpms with high tension supertech duels that put me around 250lbs over the nose of my cam. No bleed down, or valve float issues. I firmly believe the lash issues in 6g72's are because all the oil in each head has to pass through this first.
http://i408.photobucket.com/albums/pp170/donniekak/IMAG0039.jpg (http://s408.photobucket.com/user/donniekak/media/IMAG0039.jpg.html)

NOMIEZVR4
05-31-2013, 08:44 AM
I run the same lifters in Dsm's and have no issues up to 9k. A possible issue with the 6g72 may be the really small oil restrictor in the oil passage to the heads.

Has anyone ever attemtpted to change this?

Ninja Performance
05-31-2013, 10:12 AM
Start changing parts like that, in attempts of 8000-9000RPM runs, and guess wrong and you may starve the bottom end of oil. That's a big risk just to test thing out.

-Chris

NOMIEZVR4
05-31-2013, 10:21 AM
gotcha...I'm not trying to rev to 9k like you fellas..8k rpms works fine for me..:)

J. Fast
05-31-2013, 12:21 PM
I run the same lash adjusters in my 4g63, and rev to 9000 rpms with high tension supertech duels that put me around 250lbs over the nose of my cam. No bleed down, or valve float issues. I firmly believe the lash issues in 6g72's are because all the oil in each head has to pass through this first.
http://i408.photobucket.com/albums/pp170/donniekak/IMAG0039.jpg (http://s408.photobucket.com/user/donniekak/media/IMAG0039.jpg.html)

Are you saying you believe the lifters are oil starving or over oiling as in they're unable to maintain predictable lift characteristics with 100+psi of oil pressure at 6000+ rpm pump rate? If you remove the restricter what are you starving in the block from getting oil when you drop oil pressure? We would need a cutaway of the galleys to see if it feeds the big end bearings, mains... or?


Start changing parts like that, in attempts of 8000-9000RPM runs, and guess wrong and you may starve the bottom end of oil. That's a big risk just to test thing out.

-Chris

I'd have to agree, but he does have a point. We share the same lifters and rockers. I said the same thing to myself... "Where does the oil pressure from that restrictor go?"

I was thinking a little more about this earlier and started looking at reasons why hydraulic lifters would have difficulties maintaining max lift characteristics. I'm thinking one possibility is due to how we vent our crankcases. Running open vent does lower our oil pressure and allows for air to free flow into the crankcase. If the oil pump is lifting small air pockets caused from oil scatter, because we lack an aeriation/windage tray, we could certainly be lifting non uniform fliud colums throughout the oil galleys. Air pockets in the lifters could be a lash hinderance also.

donniekak
05-31-2013, 01:45 PM
The oil galley that feeds the heads come from mains 2, and 4, which also feed 2 rods each. Mains 1, and 4 only feed 1 rod each. Not only is this not even close to a priority main oiling system, but it can cause localized low pressure on the 2 center mains. Ever notice they are the most worn bearings in about every used 6g72? The restrictors were probably used because mitsu was trying to adapt a v6 sohc bottom end, and oiling system to run dohc heads, and turbos.

I'm willing to bet that a good dry sump setup, with oil feeds directly into the heads could stop the bleed down issues. With the issues these cars have, I would be very wary of removing the restrictors in a stock oiling setup. The most I would dare to do would be to drill the restrictor out slightly.

Ninja Performance
05-31-2013, 06:03 PM
In stock - sold individually (of course as a set for cheaper than 24 singles)

BLE SINGLE Solid Lifter to Degree Cams (SolidLashSingle) - Ninja Performance - Affordable (http://www.ninjaperformance.com/ble-single-solid-lifter-degree-cams-p-21912.html)

https://fbcdn-sphotos-h-a.akamaihd.net/hphotos-ak-prn2/971079_573448762677975_271585975_n.jpg

-Chris

Tigchamp
06-01-2013, 05:44 AM
I have a set of these Chris, & I am thinking of putting them in when I change my Fooked PWR cam belt. What clearance would you recommend I set them at?
Jeff:coo3l:

Ninja Performance
06-01-2013, 10:25 AM
I have a set of these Chris, & I am thinking of putting them in when I change my Fooked PWR cam belt. What clearance would you recommend I set them at?
Jeff:coo3l:

If they are BLE, they recommend Min .0015"-max .004"
.0015" intake .002" exhaust

Bring engine to operating temp, let cool, recheck.

-Chris

Tigchamp
06-01-2013, 02:33 PM
Thanks Chris, from what you have been posting lately, I may even take out my 3SX 264/272 cams and put in the Gen1 stock cams and timing gears at the same time.
Jeff:coo3l:

Ninja Performance
08-09-2013, 10:54 PM
I have a set of the new BC 272s. They are going into Courtney's car.
The car arrived here puking coolant, even at 20psi, so we are going to pull the engine, R&R heads, check head and block deck for truness etc, new HGs, new Head bolts.

He has Adjustable cam gears, so while the engine is out and on the stand, his new BC 272's will get degree'd in. I will post what the results are (measurement number info).

Should have something about end of next week. Need to pull the engine first ;)
Don't get crazy if I don't get it done by next friday. As my cancer has started to re surface I get tired faster, especially in this heat, so since it is 90+F out, and 110+ in the garage....I have very short service garage days and end up spending the rest of the day inside at the computer and phone shipping packages and answering calls.

Cross fingers, hoping these cams work out great. Courtney rally needs to have his car running and he needs to enjoy it. It has been many many many years for him.

-Chris

familyMAN
08-09-2013, 11:21 PM
Hope you get Courtney back on the road! Asked on other forum but will here as well...planning on oringing while its all apart or just resurface and MLS?

J. Fast
08-10-2013, 01:32 AM
^Good question^ Who do you trust to do O-ring machine work Chris?

J. Fast
08-10-2013, 01:36 AM
family MAN, AdamVr4, or Ninja are the new BC 272's 4 unique cam profiles since they are in push pull configurations or are they asymmetric still?

AdamVR4
08-10-2013, 02:10 AM
family MAN, AdamVr4, or Ninja are the new BC 272's 4 unique cam profiles since they are in push pull configurations or are they asymmetric still?

Havent received mine yet... but they gotta be 4 unique... right?! Haha

Ninja Performance
08-12-2013, 11:35 PM
Not O-ringing Courtney's car. He shouldn't need it. My theory is it came here already pushing coolant because the insane timing that was tuned into his AEM EMS. The timing map was even more advanced than my car. And I run straight alcohol and well, push beyond what I would on any customer car cause if it blows I can fix it myself. His timing map made me go "WHOLLY CRAP"

I think, and guessing is all I can do, is in order to get the big numbers whomever worked on it was trying to get, they pushed everything to 11.

It will have a much more sensible timing map once I tune it, a map in line with the E85 he runs but not pushing the edge or way over it like it was. He also will only be running 28-30psi. So with new OEM headbolts torqued to 105, new OEM HGs, and good tuning, he shouldn't need O-Ringing.

He is not willing to sacrifice reliability to get any magical dyno number or so he can say "I run XXpsi" He just wants to be able to enjoy his car. Something he hasn't been able to do for eh last 3+ years due to engine failures. It's time build it right, and tune it well, if not even lean on the conservative side. So he can just enjoy the damn thing for once.

I will however be degreeing in the new BC 272s. From what I have heard, they are all different, no more mirroring front to back. They are made correct now.

Down the road I may even put a set of the 272s in my car. Waiting to see how Courtney's car does. Should have it done in about a week. Engine is out. Heads off tomorrow. Along with pan to check bearings. Heads are new, it was all put together only a few hundred or less miles ago. So no surfacing should need to be done. I will flat bar check to make sure they are flat and true on all decks of course.

-Chris

Ninja Performance
08-13-2013, 09:28 PM
My Testing/Degree'ing in of the new BC 272s I have from BC for Courtney's car will be postponed for a couple weeks while we get a new block to the machine shop.

When his car arrived here for gushing fuel lines it was found, after we replaced all the fuel lines, to have a miss/dead cylinders and a full overflow bottle. While replacing the BC cams with stock cams cured most of the dead rear bank, and fueled this thread and hopefully a new better correct product, it was still having a mild running issue and what I suspected as coolant push.

When the car arrived here there was a LOT of timing advance in the AEM EMS timing map, more than I run on my 100% alcohol car and I run more than you should for shits and giggles, it is my car and if it explodes oh well (which is never has).

While this car is on E85, it isn't on Nitromethane. I think this led to the head gasket breach. We saw the timing map and corrected it while changing out the fuel injectors which were clogged with old fuel line gunk. We got it running half way decent on our new fuel injectors and fuel lines and stock cams but the damage was already done. I recommended at the very least new head gaskets before we installed the new BC 272s. But it was too late.

Here is the head gasket breach, which I figured we would find:
http://www.ninjaperformance.com/images/customer/headgasketbreach.jpg

This is what we didn't expect to find:
http://www.ninjaperformance.com/images/customer/headdamage.jpg

http://www.ninjaperformance.com/images/customer/pistondamage.jpg

Heads are toast, pistons are toast, and the cylinders (already 92.5) are scored to hell.

So starting with a used 91.1 block, new 91.5 Wiseco pistons, and will try to salvage the heads. We will be O-Ringing the block.

Once we get everything back from the machine shop, we will degree in the new BC 272s and report our findings. Just won't be in 1 week as we previously thought.

-Chris

mehrshadvr4
08-13-2013, 10:14 PM
damn....

GTOJOE
08-13-2013, 10:20 PM
Those heads are fucked. Obviously a lot of knock. Has to be related to the tune. Is it worth trying to recover some costs from the tuner?

Sent from my GT-I9300 using Tapatalk 2

familyMAN
08-13-2013, 10:29 PM
Those heads are fucked. Obviously a lot of knock. Has to be related to the tune. Is it worth trying to recover some costs from the tuner?


I would think tough to pinpoint true root cause since he stated injectors were clogged also. Also aren't you usually on your own with tuning related failures.

Ninja Performance
08-13-2013, 11:38 PM
I can say the ignition advance in the AEM when it was dropped off to us was thru the roof. It's E85, but this map was just silly.

And to be honest, the surface on the block and heads does not look like a machine shop surface job. Looks like rough sandpaper was just used to clean it off for another build. Which sometimes you can get by with when using a flat bar, known true block, but surface Ra is pretty rough.

-Chris

Ninja Performance
08-14-2013, 12:17 AM
Here is the timing map as it was when the car arrived. I always save in customer folder the original before I load up a fresh map and start everything over. This way I know what it was should questions arise. And yes, all other timing additions/subtractions make this advance map you are seing, the timing it will see. Base timing was dead on.

http://www.ninjaperformance.com/images/customer/courtneyoriginaltiming.jpg

-Chris

Ninja Performance
08-14-2013, 12:21 AM
I run stupid insane timing advance on mine, I run 100% alcohol, and I push it beyond what is sane. But I am still roughly 10 degrees back from this map.

-Chris

GTOJOE
08-14-2013, 08:22 AM
I would think tough to pinpoint true root cause since he stated injectors were clogged also. Also aren't you are usually on your own with tuning related failures.

My understanding was that the injectors where clogged with hose material because the same shop that tuned it for E85 installed non ethanol safe lines which then caused all the issues. I would be asking some questions. Got nothing to lose.

HilbillyHomeboy
08-14-2013, 09:34 AM
Yeah, that map is definitely North of sanity. Wow.

Jeremy

Ninja Performance
10-10-2013, 08:03 PM
Small Update. With all that has been going on, starting back on Chemo etc, It has taken a longer time to do some of the things I want to do or need to do.

Finally got Courtney's engine rebuilt. New build, started with a bone stock OEM bore 2 bolt TT block. Wiseco 91.5 slugs, bored, honed, Copper O-Ring Deck (what I do for coolant push), OEM crank. Rods and mains spec'd to 18-20, nice and snug but not too snug. Heads have been milled at least twice, block at least once after O-ring grooves cut.

Received a set of the new BC 272s from Dustin for Courtney's car.

Courtney has the Fidanza adjustable gears, they and all others (except I think UR) are off. The true 0 on the adjustable is 1 Degrees retarded.

I can get the front Exhaust cam where the cam card says it should be at .050", 33ATDC and -1 BBDC by adjusting the cam gear to +1.75 advanced. So 2.75 cam degrees total.

Ran out of time to go to next cam.

-Chris

AdamVR4
10-10-2013, 08:37 PM
Promising. Thanks for the update!

Ninja Performance
10-21-2013, 09:43 PM
Update on the NEW style BC 272s. We carry them and are installing them into a customer's engine (Courtney)

Using solid lash adjuster set to 5 thou/.005" pre load.

I set TRUE TDC using the dial indicator and the forward/reverse divide to find center. Setup and verify. Since throttle stops on these heads are a little more difficult I use the dial indicator, easy setup and quick. Rechecked often.

One this setup, True TDC is 2 crank degrees early on the crank/sprocket/oil pump mark. Moving the marks on oil pump and cog to dead/aligned hits +2 ATDC at crank which is 1 degree on cam. So we know to check True TDC and set that as ZERO. That is good info to know, I have told people in the past, don't trust the oil pump/cog TDC mark. Find tru TDC! More times than not, it is wrong. Milling heads and block deck will do that. And aftermarket parts, things not being dead on from factory, lots of factors.

Engine has adjustable cam gears and here is what I can achieve using them.

The "Actual" numbers are what I can get the cams to adjust to using the adjustable gears. And get them as close to matching the pair. Int to Int and Exh to Exh.

EO=Exh Open
EC=Exh Closed
IO=Int Open
IC=Int Closed

Exhaust cams are set
Exh Spec EO 33 BBDC EC -1 BTDC
Front Exh cam Actual EO 32.5 BBDC EC -1.5 BTDC (half crank degree-1/4 cam degree)
Rear Exh cam Actual EO 32.0 BBDC EC -2.0 BTDC (one crank degree-1/2 cam degree)
Not even going to try to split hairs on a 1/4-1/2 camshaft degree. Very happy with these numbers.

Intake cams are set
Int Spec IO 7 ATDC IC 31 ABDC
Rear Int cam Actual IO 6.0 ATDC IC 31 ABDC (1 crank degree 1/2 cam degree and just on IO)
Front Int cam Actual IO 6.0 ATDC IC 31 ABDC (1 crank degree 1/2 cam degree and just on IO)

All done with aftermarket adjustable cam gears which in themselves are all a little different for what is actual TDC.
With that said, to get the cams degree'd in satifactoryl, and pretty damn good I think, the max adjustment is at 1.75 degrees advance and the least and more common is 1.0 degrees advance.

https://scontent-a-lga.xx.fbcdn.net/hphotos-prn2/1391863_638245069531677_732573260_n.jpg

-Chris

mehrshadvr4
10-21-2013, 11:27 PM
If you adjust the crank at 2 degree atdc and the cams 1 degree atdc the wouldn't it still set the timing like the factory? I would think if the crank is 2 degree atdc and the cams are lined up with the marks would make the difference and change the actual timing.

Ninja Performance
10-27-2013, 02:51 AM
Ninja Performance (https://www.facebook.com/pages/Ninja-Performance/196265690402522?directed_target_id=0) Engine/car build. Took a bit of time and energy to breath new life into her. She was a mess. Everything from electronics, a full engine build with new style BC 272 cams degreed in, Ninja Performance dual pump dual feed fuel system, AEM EMS S1.

Just broke in the engine yesterday and this morning. Baseline knock cal runs done. Start-up, idle, cruise is about 90% done.

Started low boost power tuning on the last half of today.

Still on conservative timing, probably 2-3 degrees back from where I will end up. E85 likes 12.0afr, as the graph shows, it is very rich up top past 5000RPM. So more fuel to pull.

Car is full weight, seats and all, full interior, stock ECS, plus very heavy chrome rims, plus added weight of larger turbos, FMIC kit etc. So the actual weight is probably higher than what I put in the dyno software. But should be close enough.

This is 14-15psi, I will probably end up around 28-30psi.
525AWHP 493AWTQ

She is running like a top! Can't wait to see what 28psi will do.


-Chris

https://scontent-b-lga.xx.fbcdn.net/hphotos-ash4/q71/s720x720/1378889_641153649240819_1499862773_n.jpg

sergechronos
10-27-2013, 10:07 AM
That's a crazy amount of power for such low boost. This is TD05 right?

Ninja Performance
10-27-2013, 02:06 PM
That's a crazy amount of power for such low boost. This is TD05 right?

TD05 manifolds, Very large, close to GT35, turbos. IMO too large turbine on TD05 hotside. But that wasn't my decision.
Running E85, 272 cams and heads. Boost is relative as it's a measurement of resistance not of power. Better flow less restriction less boost makes more power.

-Chris

mb3000
10-27-2013, 04:07 PM
Good stuff!

i3igpete
10-28-2013, 07:41 PM
5k rpm spool up isn't very fun unless he's gonna rev it up to 8k

NOMIEZVR4
10-28-2013, 09:07 PM
yeah...things are definitely slow to get going...what is being used to control boost? If he has heads/cams you may as well rev out to 8k...

I wanna see how that tq curve holds out...especially with it leaned out and more boost

Ninja Performance
10-30-2013, 12:55 AM
Greddy Profecb SpecII, I have the start and limit higher than set, so it spikes. Just need to move from 60% to maybe 65-70% to make the beginning spike the same across the board. Then keep raising boost.

-Chris

oohnoo
10-30-2013, 11:58 AM
Curious to what your opinion is on the new cams if you see any real performance gains over other performance cams that are out there. Just not the BC old ones cause those had issues as you know.

GTOJOE
10-31-2013, 06:48 AM
Curious to what your opinion is on the new cams if you see any real performance gains over other performance cams that are out there. Just not the BC old ones cause those had issues as you know.

I think all aftermarket cams available for our cars are wrong. Except for regrinds I think.

mehrshadvr4
10-31-2013, 06:58 AM
You are thinking wrong. BC cams are fixed now.

GTOJOE
10-31-2013, 07:04 AM
You are thinking wrong. BC cams are fixed now.

Obviously :eh:
oohnoo's question was about other performance cams. Is there any benefit of the new BC over other cams. But IIRC this thread or the other one on 3si pointed out that all aftermarket cams for our cars have this issue. BC is just the only company to fix it.

mehrshadvr4
10-31-2013, 07:54 AM
I don't know if regrind cams have this issue since no one really tested them, but I think not having to run shims on BC cams is a good enough reason for me to buy blank cams.

Ray Pampena
10-31-2013, 10:55 AM
i have a set of DR street regrinds that are not ground wrong

oohnoo
10-31-2013, 11:27 AM
That's good to hear as I have those on my car :)


i have a set of DR street regrinds that are not ground wrong

CoopKill
10-31-2013, 02:25 PM
So the BC stage2 are regrinds, and 2+ and up are from blanks?

Also, has the ,fix been applied to all of their cams?

mehrshadvr4
10-31-2013, 04:30 PM
yes. Ray has the new 262 IPO has the 272s and I have the 280s.

Ninja Performance
11-25-2013, 12:47 AM
We have the new style BC 272s in Courtney's car. I may do the new BC 264s in my car. Time to get more top end.

Ninja Performance (https://www.facebook.com/pages/Ninja-Performance/196265690402522?directed_target_id=0) Customer build/tune. Still have some boost left in her (turbos are good for at least 34psi).

Dyno graph shows 20psi but is really 24psi, this is due to the AEM data reading boost lower than it really is (all taken into account in the fuel and ignition maps)

Will probably get her to around 28psi max to allow for some reliability. And obviously from the graph, pull more fuel up top. E85 likes 11.8-12.0 (leaning on 12.0). But this is a good start.

https://fbcdn-sphotos-e-a.akamaihd.net/hphotos-ak-ash3/1404843_656846017671582_2056789642_n.jpg

-Chris

familyMAN
11-25-2013, 12:58 AM
Looking good! Hope Courtney finally gets to enjoy his car.

Chris, I think you will see big gains from an intake mani. Here is a supra comparison on stock cams, big turb/low boost.....
http://www.spracingonline.com/images/products/37892.jpg

Any losses should end up below where yours or Courtney's turbos would be moving air anyway. Running your car out to 8k+ is well beyond what our ridiculously long runner and small plenum mani's are designed for. By the time your turbos spool up, the intake harmonics are not playing nice. Just think what cams would do on top of it:)

donniekak
11-25-2013, 10:49 AM
It's a much different feeling driving a car with power that climbs to the limiter, compared to falling off a cliff.

J. Fast
11-25-2013, 11:19 AM
Yep, the torque yanks you back in the seat and then it feels like you deployed a parachute around 6000rpms. That's a typical result 3000gt with a tiny turbo and no top end work.

Ninja Performance
11-25-2013, 11:36 AM
Looking good! Hope Courtney finally gets to enjoy his car.

Chris, I think you will see big gains from an intake mani. Here is a supra comparison on stock cams, big turb/low boost.....
http://www.spracingonline.com/images/products/37892.jpg

Any losses should end up below where yours or Courtney's turbos would be moving air anyway. Running your car out to 8k+ is well beyond what our ridiculously long runner and small plenum mani's are designed for. By the time your turbos spool up, the intake harmonics are not playing nice. Just think what cams would do on top of it:)

Question is, what manifold is available and proven on the 3S?

-Chris

CoopKill
11-25-2013, 12:31 PM
Trying to work on that as we speak...

J. Fast
11-25-2013, 01:47 PM
Question is, what manifold is available and proven on the 3S?

-Chris
I don't know about you buy anything bigger than the stock 63mm (2.5in) throttle body inlet with a surge tank bigger than the stock 1.48litre (90 cubic inches) is a worldly improvement.

The XM surge tank I looked into in March of 2012 is finally being realized and Bill Cooper has been so kind as to setup a GB for us. The Surge tank capacity is 3.1litres (290 cubic inches) which is equal to our engines natural capacity. Additionally, it comes fitted with a Q45 throttle body with an 82mm (3.25in) throttle body. The N/A runners being fitted are 1.2 times the diameter of the intake valves and the runners are around 13" or so. It's a good design.

http://www.3sgto.org/3000gt-stealth-gto-related-topics/7978-i-want-plenum-anyone-know-who-made.html#post156598

You'll lose some bottom end with the manifold under 4500rpms but likely gain what's lost in the top end above 5500rpms. What you lose down low is really miniscule because as you know when we rev past 8000+rpm's the tach never drops below 5000rpms on a shift so it's deminimis.

The GB is here... >>> http://www.3sgto.org/turbo-engines-systems/13223-guaging-interest-excessive-manufacturing-intake-plenum-gb.html <<<

familyMAN
11-25-2013, 03:45 PM
Question is, what manifold is available and proven on the 3S?

-Chris

There are manifolds available. XM as jfast mentioned. There is an eBay unit that people have used that has a plenum design looks good. DR has a mani. None have back to back that I am aware of but GTPRO did a budget mani years ago that is basically the same design as all of these listed and picked up 35hp on 16gs at only 12.5psi. Results are on other forum but I posted the graphs here as well.

Depends what you want out of your setup but shorter runners and bigger plenum should give you more hp up top where you drop off now. Or if you are looking to get more power in the midrange as you had mentioned in another thread, you could do smaller turbos with a larger plenum/TB and maybe small cams and possibly match your current hp but reduce lag and push your power left.

familyMAN
11-25-2013, 03:50 PM
The XM surge tank I looked into in March of 2012 is finally being realized and Bill Cooper has been so kind as to setup a GB for us.

It could have been bought at anytime and was always available with TB on either side. All you had to do is order;)

NOMIEZVR4
11-25-2013, 08:14 PM
It's a much different feeling driving a car with power that climbs to the limiter, compared to falling off a cliff.

That's what I'm in the market for..:D

Ninja Performance
11-27-2013, 01:21 PM
Ninja Performance Customer engine build/tune. She is just about where I want her. Enough power (I know never enough) with a strong flat power curve, and at only 28psi, she will be "relatively" reliable, not pushed to the limits.

Still a little fine tuning. Probably not too much power as I want to keep her semi reliable for Courtney, he has driven it maybe 2 weeks in 5 years. Time to enjoy it.

Plus the 1000cc inj are at 99% idc even at 55psi base pressure. But still running a tad rich up top, will lean her out to get closer to 11.8-12.0

E85, 28psi, Ninja Performance Stage3 Engine build/tune, Ninja Performance Complete Dual Feed E85 safe Fuel System, BC 272/272 cams, twin TD05 turbos.

http://www.ninjaperformance.com/images/customer/Courtney28psiE85.jpg

-Chris

familyMAN
11-27-2013, 01:56 PM
Good stuff. Now we need some vids of Courtney ripping it up!

Are you using the ninja rods in this? I'm getting ready to order them and want to make sure the lighter weight ninja vs BC rods can take the tq.

HilbillyHomeboy
11-27-2013, 01:58 PM
From 4,000 rpms to 5,000 rpms looks like one helluva fun ride!

Jeremy

mb3000
11-27-2013, 02:57 PM
Awesome! About time he receives a properly built car.

NOMIEZVR4
11-27-2013, 05:30 PM
impressive power but man that thing takes a dive...

HilbillyHomeboy
11-27-2013, 05:37 PM
impressive power but man that thing takes a dive...

Look at the A/F up top. Once that's leaned out (which Chris mentioned) it will stay more linear.

Jeremy

familyMAN
11-27-2013, 07:12 PM
Look at the A/F up top. Once that's leaned out (which Chris mentioned) it will stay more linear.

Jeremy

Leaning out a point or so isn't going to make up a 100hp drop from peak hp to end of pull. There is a restriction somewhere, exhaust, intake, turbo hotside, whatever.

We can pick apart all we want though, it's still a badass car and more powerful than 99% of us including me by a long shot!! Plus, based on Chris's success and reliability he has had with his car, Courtney will be able to beat on it his and enjoy it.:DevilSmile:

HilbillyHomeboy
11-27-2013, 07:33 PM
Where did I say it would hold 749 all the way to 7200? It will stay *more* linear; those are the words I used.

Jeremy

familyMAN
11-27-2013, 07:43 PM
Okay, but Nomie's point is still valid, it will still drop. He spends most of his time on evo forums though and is used to seeing hp climb but not make 730awtq! :D

J. Fast
11-27-2013, 07:46 PM
Congrats on the build Chris Hill. You're a top notch 3stech!

Congrats to the owner and to the platform in which great things came about as a result of said thread!

Looks like you've hit the restriction limit of the stock TB and mani. Welcome to the 1% Court!

HilbillyHomeboy
11-27-2013, 08:00 PM
For the last time, I never said it wouldn't drop. More linear, as in it won't be as drastic of a fall off. Of course it will drop. Hell, I had a 800+ wheel 3/S with a 5" true cold air intake, larger TB, ported heads, oversized valves, 280 cams, GT42, 4" turbo back, and mine still dropped. My next move was to be a larger tb and im. I knew that was the bottleneck at that point. In other words, I'm aware of how it goes..

Nomie was speaking directly to the massive drop. Chris already said he intends to lean it out more up top. Probably a good reason why he stated that, ya know? All I was doing was drawing attention to that stock like A/F in the upper register to make sure he noticed it.

Jeremy

familyMAN
11-27-2013, 08:36 PM
For the last time, I never said it wouldn't drop. More linear, as in it won't be as drastic of a fall off. Of course it will drop. Hell, I had a 800+ wheel 3/S with a 5" true cold air intake, larger TB, ported heads, oversized valves, 280 cams, GT42, 4" turbo back, and mine still dropped. My next move was to be a larger tb and im. I knew that was the bottleneck at that point. In other words, I'm aware of how it goes..

Nomie was speaking directly to the massive drop. Chris already said he intends to lean it out more up top. Probably a good reason why he stated that, ya know? All I was doing was drawing attention to that stock like A/F in the upper register to make sure he noticed it.

Jeremy

I guess I didn't state that I don't think leaning it out will make that much difference. Yes, common knowledge is that E85 "likes" lean to light off, but leaning it out doesn't seem to make that much difference on power on my car from 11s up to 12.8:1. Same on many other results I saw. As everyone says, every car is different though and very interested in being proved wrong.

edit: since I guess this is getting rowdy by your typing tone...for the last time, when it's leaned out, even if it is "more linear," it will still drop and somebody could still come in and say, "man that thing takes a dive." As you said yourself with your car....big turbo, big cam 3S and it still does the same thing. :GroupHug::drunk:

Interested in hearing the owner's reaction on the first drive:)

Chris you still running 40* of timing like it was when dropped off to you? JK! :D

HilbillyHomeboy
11-27-2013, 08:43 PM
Yeah, I can't wait to hear Courtney's reaction first time he rips this beast down the street. He's been through a lot with this car. Dude deserves it, for sure.

Jeremy

familyMAN
11-27-2013, 08:54 PM
Here is the timing map as it was when the car arrived. I always save in customer folder the original before I load up a fresh map and start everything over. This way I know what it was should questions arise. And yes, all other timing additions/subtractions make this advance map you are seing, the timing it will see. Base timing was dead on.

http://www.ninjaperformance.com/images/customer/courtneyoriginaltiming.jpg

-Chris

Just a trip down memory lane on what you started with!