Originally Posted by
99 vr4
jester . . . for an experienced tuner such as your self . . . the lack of a completely functional knock sensor is apparently a non issue. But for the normal DIY, this should be an area of concern. Big concern.
I am not saying that having a completely tunable ECU is a bad idea. Having a completely tunable ECU in which you THINK the knock sensor is working 100% is a bad idea. Would you remove your knock sensor completely and keep driving your car? I don't think so. If you knew your knock sensor was bad would you throw caution to the wind and say forget about it? Maybe you would. But you shouldn't.
I will try to shed some light on this in non-technical terms. The knock sensor is a piezo element which generates an electrical signal in response vibrations very much like a microphone generates electircal signals in response to sound waves. Think of the knock sensor circuit like an amplifier, audio filter, and signal processor. The filters and amplifers are hardware based while the signal processor is software based. If your filters and amplifers are not tuned the sound you get will be junk. You can't fix it the signal processor. Lets say your have a new audio amp for your car. It can pump 300 watts from 20 to 20K. But your speakers are rated from 70 to 15K. So you throw in a filter but miscalculate and your filter passes 50 to 5K. So now you have no high end (sounds like shit) and your driving too much bass to your speakers. Does it work? Yes. Does it work well? No. Will your speakers last? Time will tell. Probably if you don't drop any deep bass at high power.
I know you would never really mismatch your shit like that, but you are if you use an unmodified ECU. If you say its a non issue - then I wouldnt let you near my car if you paid me. I know your a smart man. I know your an experienced tuner. I also know that no one else has reported this problem. But you have heard of the Diamante and Montero "wierd" knock issue. Well guess what? Its the same circuit as what is in the SL ECU. Its only a matter of time. Sorry to bust your bubble. - Brett