View Full Version : Apple's Next Lawsuit: Apple v. Nokia
NickS VR4
09-13-2012, 07:22 AM
How the New iPod Nano Copied the Nokia Lumia (Or How the Lumia Copied the iPod Nano) (http://gizmodo.com/5942815/how-the-new-ipod-nano-copied-the-nokia-lumia-or-how-the-lumia-copied-the-ipod-nano)
The next Apple v. Samsung.
http://img.gawkerassets.com/img/17yxnszzzu8v3jpg/xlarge.jpg
Wonder what patent Apple has on this particular shape.
Disrupter
09-13-2012, 07:50 AM
I kinda wish I went into patent law...
did you know that stanley kubrick infringed upon apple's patents for the ipad with a movie prop from "2001: a space odyssey" years before apple was ever a company?
stealthify
09-13-2012, 01:45 PM
did you know that stanley kubrick infringed upon apple's patents for the ipad with a movie prop from "2001: a space odyssey" years before apple was ever a company?
That's the same argument the Samsung lawyers used in their defense -- did you see how well that worked out for them? :p
This is pretty funny though. :p
That's the same argument the Samsung lawyers used in their defense -- did you see how well that worked out for them? :p
This is pretty funny though. :p
star trek also used it decades before apple did. microsoft did it years before as well. suing over a "Rectangle with rounded corners" is like ford suing GM because chevy released a black 2-door coupe.
stealthify
09-13-2012, 02:42 PM
star trek also used it decades before apple did. microsoft did it years before as well. suing over a "Rectangle with rounded corners" is like ford suing GM because chevy released a black 2-door coupe.
That's also the same statement Samsung's lawyers and CEO said to try to gain public favor, which you've clearly bought into. This ended up being a big part of why they lost -- it's not all about suing over a "rectangle with rounded corners" - as there are many smartphones that are rectangular with rounded corners that aren't being sued.
If we're being serious in this thread, here's a simple test. Take the Lumia, which is about the size of a deck of cards, and compare it to the new Nano, which is about the size of a stick of gum. If you saw either out in the wild, would you ever really confuse the two? Especially if you were a techno-noob? Probably not.
That wasn't the case with the tradedress issues in the Samsung vs Apple case, and that's a big reason they lost. Even Samsung's own lawyers couldn't tell them apart.
NickS VR4
09-13-2012, 02:55 PM
That's also the same statement Samsung's lawyers and CEO said to try to gain public favor, which you've clearly bought into. This ended up being a big part of why they lost -- it's not all about suing over a "rectangle with rounded corners" - as there are many smartphones that are rectangular with rounded corners that aren't being sued.
If we're being serious in this thread, here's a simple test. Take the Lumia, which is about the size of a deck of cards, and compare it to the new Nano, which is about the size of a stick of gum. If you saw either out in the wild, would you ever really confuse the two? Especially if you were a techno-noob? Probably not.
That wasn't the case with the tradedress issues in the Samsung vs Apple case, and that's a big reason they lost. Even Samsung's own lawyers couldn't tell them apart.
http://www.techlicious.com/images/computers/samsung-galaxy-tab-8_9-vs-10_1-vs-ipad2-front.jpg
Understandably so. So a black rectangle is owned by Apple? Guess my GNex is at risk. It is all black on its face.
Sent from my Nexus 7 using Tapatalk 2
That's also the same statement Samsung's lawyers and CEO said to try to gain public favor, which you've clearly bought into. This ended up being a big part of why they lost -- it's not all about suing over a "rectangle with rounded corners" - as there are many smartphones that are rectangular with rounded corners that aren't being sued.
If we're being serious in this thread, here's a simple test. Take the Lumia, which is about the size of a deck of cards, and compare it to the new Nano, which is about the size of a stick of gum. If you saw either out in the wild, would you ever really confuse the two? Especially if you were a techno-noob? Probably not.
That wasn't the case with the tradedress issues in the Samsung vs Apple case, and that's a big reason they lost. Even Samsung's own lawyers couldn't tell them apart.
the issue i have is with patenting a design...and not just any design, an obvious one. a rectangle is the logical format for any display. for a portable device, rounded corners are a a de-facto standard (at least since the original gameboy). having a flat, black face is what all touchscreen interfaces look like. yet to apple, these are features which only apple is allowed to use.
and while we're at it, if you're going to throw out that "samsung's own lawyers couldn't tell them apart"--i'll have to assume that's because the images displayed in court were the ones apple doctored to distort the aspect ratio in order to enhance their case. apple has no soul.
stealthify
09-13-2012, 03:21 PM
the issue i have is with patenting a design...and not just any design, an obvious one. a rectangle is the logical format for any display. for a portable device, rounded corners are a a de-facto standard (at least since the original gameboy). having a flat, black face is what all touchscreen interfaces look like. yet to apple, these are features which only apple is allowed to use.
None of those features alone lost the case for Samsung. It was the combination of all of those elements, plus some signature styling (such as the chrome bezel around the outside), and the software design similarities, combined, that lost it for Samsung.
If you want proof that a phone can be different, take a look at Windows Phone. That's innovative, yet still slightly ugly (IMO), but at least it could never be confused for an Apple product.
and while we're at it, if you're going to throw out that "samsung's own lawyers couldn't tell them apart"--i'll have to assume that's because the images displayed in court were the ones apple doctored to distort the aspect ratio in order to enhance their case. apple has no soul.
See, now I know you didn't read up on the case. The judge actually held up the physical devices, side by side. And if you want to see a doctored image, take a look at the first photo in this thread. The two products are not even REMOTELY the same size or ratio in reality, hence why it's humorous. ;) The same things the anti-Apple cult accused Apple of doing, they're doing themselves. Cute.
None of those features alone lost the case for Samsung. It was the combination of all of those elements, plus some signature styling (such as the chrome bezel around the outside), and the software design similarities, combined, that lost it for Samsung.
so let me get this straight.
ford patents:
-black
-2-door cars
-v8 engines
GM is legally permitted to use these...but not in combination with each other.
....this is the essence of your argument here? wow...you should check your iphone for radiation leaks. i think apple causes brain damage.
stealthify
09-13-2012, 03:45 PM
so let me get this straight.
ford patents:
-black
-2-door cars
-v8 engines
GM is legally permitted to use these...but not in combination with each other.
More like if Ford were to design a car such as the Mustang (which they have), and someone were to come along and mass-produce a car that looks, and is easily mistakable, for a Mustang (which no one has).
The Camaro looks nothing like the Mustang, yet they both come in black, have 2-doors and v8 engines. Keep trolling.
More like if Ford were to design a car such as the Mustang (which they have), and someone were to come along and mass-produce a car that looks, and is easily mistakable, for a Mustang (which no one has).
The Camaro looks nothing like the Mustang, yet they both come in black, have 2-doors and v8 engines. Keep trolling.
we're also talking about a device a hundred times smaller. since way before the debut of the iphone, smartphones have been rectangular. adding a touch-screen necessitates minimal adornment. what apple is essentially trying to say--in your own admitted description--is that it wants to eliminate the possibility of anyone designing a device that has the functionality of an iphone.
stealthify
09-13-2012, 04:21 PM
we're also talking about a device a hundred times smaller. since way before the debut of the iphone, smartphones have been rectangular. adding a touch-screen necessitates minimal adornment. what apple is essentially trying to say--in your own admitted description--is that it wants to eliminate the possibility of anyone designing a device that has the functionality of an iphone.
Samsung vs Apple was more about design, not functionality. The two are not easily confusable - how are you doing that?
And regardless of size, a phone can be made to look different. The phones now look nothing like that did in 2001.
Cologne bottles - same functionality, but each popular brand looks different enough from another as to not let them easily be confused when seen on the same shelf.
More:
Wristwatches (Rolex vs Casio), sunglasses (Oakley vs Rayban), laptops (Sager vs Apple), etc - all the same functionality, different signature designs, and all a hundred times smaller than the cars (Mustang vs Camaro) comparison.
Should I keep going?
NickS VR4
09-13-2012, 04:33 PM
Samsung vs Apple was more about design, not functionality. The two are not easily confusable - how are you doing that?
And regardless of size, a phone can be made to look different. The phones now look nothing like that did in 2001.
Cologne bottles - same functionality, but each popular brand looks different enough from another as to not let them easily be confused when seen on the same shelf.
More:
Wristwatches (Rolex vs Casio), sunglasses (Oakley vs Rayban), laptops (Sager vs Apple), etc - all the same functionality, different signature designs, and all a hundred times smaller than the cars (Mustang vs Camaro) comparison.
Should I keep going?
Shit, I think Boeing and Airbus look pretty similar.
All these LCD TVs on the market, they look similar too.
Damnit I get so confused, when I shop for Toilets and mailboxes, they look too damn similar.
My hamper to hold my clothes looks similar to others for sale.
Shit my basic dryer and washer look similar to the other washer and dryers on the market.
Fuck who the hell invented utilitarianism. Basic form and function makes products look too similar.
I want a pyramid tablet.
http://www.inewidea.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/01/20120101003.jpg
Why the hell would I want a retangular phone when the screen in rectangular. Why would I want it black when the screen off is black, why would I want a speaker on top and microphone on bottom, why would I want a button on the bottom of the screen instead of the top (i really want to reach over the screen i'm looking at to press it)?
I didn't know lack of identifying features was a copyrightable thing? Shit, I need to patent my human body without tattoos. Everyone else needs to get a unique tattoo, or i'm going to sue them for copying me.
Need I go on?
Oh, i'll throw another in there, AMC Movies should sue Regal Cinemas, their screens in the theatre look too similar, they both sell popcorn and soda, and both charge too much for movies.
that should be post of the year.
stealthify
09-13-2012, 05:02 PM
Shit, I think Boeing and Airbus look pretty similar.
All these LCD TVs on the market, they look similar too.
Damnit I get so confused, when I shop for Toilets and mailboxes, they look too damn similar.
My hamper to hold my clothes looks similar to others for sale.
Shit my basic dryer and washer look similar to the other washer and dryers on the market.
Fuck who the hell invented utilitarianism. Basic form and function makes products look too similar.
Oh, i'll throw another in there, AMC Movies should sue Regal Cinemas, their screens in the theatre look too similar, they both sell popcorn and soda, and both charge too much for movies.
Congratulations, you just listed a bunch of stuff that was unique and patentable at one time, but later became standard and essential.
Examples:
George Becket - House-door Mailbox Patent (http://inventors.about.com/od/photogallery/ig/African-American-B/George-E-Becket--483-525.--1c.htm)
Patent US2392405 - HAIR DRYING PROCESS - Google Patents (http://www.google.com/patents/US2392405)
Why the hell would I want a retangular phone when the screen in rectangular. Why would I want it black when the screen off is black, why would I want a speaker on top and microphone on bottom, why would I want a button on the bottom of the screen instead of the top (i really want to reach over the screen i'm looking at to press it)?
No one, not even Apple, said you can't make a tablet that is rectangular with rounded corners. The new Kindle Fire HD is a rectangle with rounded corners, with a bezel and front-facing camera. Yet doesn't necessarily look like an Apple product. Get it?
I see an example of this every day. I have a client that comes in with his Android Galaxy Tab tablet. He's not technically savvy at all, yet he refers to it as an iPad. I feel the urge to remind him that it's not an iPad, but rather a tablet made by Samsung, yet I don't have the heart. He sees the design similarities, and assumes they're the same (in looks, functionality and quality). Any marketing Apple does for their iPad, spending money on advertising, etc, directly benefits those tablets like the Galaxy Tab that looks so similar to it. How is that even close to fair?
NickS VR4
09-13-2012, 05:22 PM
The new Kindle Fire HD is a rectangle with rounded corners, with a bezel and front-facing camera. Yet doesn't necessarily look like an Apple product. Get it?
http://www.nscelica.net/fire.png
http://www.techlicious.com/images/computers/samsung-galaxy-tab-8_9-vs-10_1-vs-ipad2-front.jpg
They all look the same to me.
stealthify
09-13-2012, 05:35 PM
http://www.nscelica.net/fire.png
http://www.techlicious.com/images/computers/samsung-galaxy-tab-8_9-vs-10_1-vs-ipad2-front.jpg
They all look the same to me.
And that's exactly my point (thanks?). This is why Apple was upset with how similar the Galaxy Tabs looked to the iPad.
The back of the Fire looks completely un-Apple like.
Toss a Motorola Droid xyboard in there:
http://cdn1.sbnation.com/products/medium/4271/Droid%20Xyboard%2010.1.png
Now who's putting in an at least minimal effort to be different?
NickS VR4
09-13-2012, 05:39 PM
And that's exactly my point (thanks?). This is why Apple was upset with how similar the Galaxy Tabs looked to the iPad.
The back of the Fire looks completely un-Apple like.
Toss a Motorola Droid xyboard in there:
Now who's putting in an at least minimal effort to be different?
My point is that its a basic design, and even your comment on the Fire does not pass the test. That first image is the Kindle Fire HD. Its a black rectangle with rounded corners. Its called utilitarianism.
The XYBoard is ugly, and just one example of purposefully going against the grain.
Also, the back of the Galaxy Tab looks different too
http://www.shaswatpatel.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/04/Samsung-Galaxy-Tab-10.1-Back.jpg
http://www.androidnova.org/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/ipad-vs-galaxy-tab-back.jpg
stealthify
09-13-2012, 05:55 PM
My point is that its a basic design, and even your comment on the Fire does not pass the test. That first image is the Kindle Fire HD. Its a black rectangle with rounded corners. Its called utilitarianism.
And that's why Amazon hasn't been sued over the Fire? (at least not yet, and not likely in the future)
As I said, this never was about patenting a shape or color, no matter how much anti-Apple haters try to make it out to sound.
And regarding the xyboard, yeah it's ugly, but it still functions perfectly well as a tablet that doesn't look like something out of Cupertino..
NickS VR4
09-13-2012, 06:03 PM
And that's why Amazon hasn't been sued over the Fire? (at least not yet, and not likely in the future)
As I said, this never was about patenting a shape or color, no matter how much anti-Apple haters try to make it out to sound.
And regarding the xyboard, yeah it's ugly, but it still functions perfectly well as a tablet that doesn't look like something out of Cupertino..
I'm confused, so its not the design thats the issue. It's the features. So I guess copying "bounce back" was worth $1billion. Because all the other software features were prior art, despite what the jury said.
stealthify
09-13-2012, 06:37 PM
Even though that's just one of the many patents Apple successfully defended, the "bounce back" patent is still largely a design choice. There's many ways an OS or program can show when you've reached an end of a scroll (via scroll bars, showing blank space, or just preventing you from scrolling further).
The "bounce back" just added some nice flair that, once you've tried it, makes most other techniques feel cheap/underdeveloped. That's why others want it, but they don't want to pay for it.
wait...
so because apple's target market is too stupid to tell one phone from another--or one tablet from another--that is sufficient grounds to justify them suing their competitors?
...just wanted to make sure i heard that correctly.
stealthify
09-13-2012, 07:28 PM
wait...
so because apple's target market is too stupid to tell one phone from another--or one tablet from another--that is sufficient grounds to justify them suing their competitors?
...just wanted to make sure i heard that correctly.
It's not just their target audience, but people in general -- whether they're into tablets or not (but more so if they're not). I can probably spot the differences between a Galaxy Tab and an iPad a lot easier than my parents could, but that's only because I'm constantly involved with this stuff. I, we, us - those that know computers - are still in the minority.
Is Samsung's target audience those that can't tell the difference between an authentic Apple product and those that are not? I rarely hear about people buying a product because "It's a Samsung." ;)
NickS VR4
09-13-2012, 07:35 PM
It's not just their target audience, but people in general -- whether they're into tablets or not (but more so if they're not). I can probably spot the differences between a Galaxy Tab and an iPad a lot easier than my parents could, but that's only because I'm constantly involved with this stuff. I, we, us - those that know computers - are still in the minority.
Is Samsung's target audience those that can't tell the difference between an authentic Apple product and those that are not? I rarely hear about people buying a product because "It's a Samsung." ;)
Well since one is found in an Apple store, and has a picture of an Apple on it, and the other is in another store, and says Samsung Galaxy Tab on it, or Samsung something else.... if you buy the wrong item, you are a complete idiot, the XYBoard's design is not going to stop someone that stupid. Thats like someone accidentally buying a Toyota Yaris as a Toyota dealer thinking it was a Honda Civic.
It's not just their target audience, but people in general -- whether they're into tablets or not (but more so if they're not). I can probably spot the differences between a Galaxy Tab and an iPad a lot easier than my parents could, but that's only because I'm constantly involved with this stuff. I, we, us - those that know computers - are still in the minority.
Is Samsung's target audience those that can't tell the difference between an authentic Apple product and those that are not? I rarely hear about people buying a product because "It's a Samsung." ;)
rarely? wow. you need to stop hanging around with only iTards. i know just as many people who have a galaxy as have an iphone (probably more with a galaxy of some type).
samsung's target audience are the people who know better than to fall into the morass that is apple's proprietary bs.
stealthify
09-13-2012, 08:21 PM
Well since one is found in an Apple store, and has a picture of an Apple on it, and the other is in another store, and says Samsung Galaxy Tab on it, or Samsung something else.... if you buy the wrong item, you are a complete idiot, the XYBoard's design is not going to stop someone that stupid. Thats like someone accidentally buying a Toyota Yaris as a Toyota dealer thinking it was a Honda Civic.
I don't know what to tell you. How about you go and spend hundreds of millions of dollars to design something, have someone rip it off and make their product look strikingly similar, and then come back and let me know how you feel.
NickS VR4
09-13-2012, 08:30 PM
I don't know what to tell you. How about you go and spend hundreds of millions of dollars to design something, have someone rip it off and make their product look strikingly similar, and then come back and let me know how you feel.
That's the name of the game. They made billions, competition comes up and makes it more difficult. Happens in every market. Auto industry, PC market, wave runners, dirt bikes, bicycles, airplanes, etc.
Apple is just being a cry baby and wants a monopoly on the market.
Sent from my Nexus 7 using Tapatalk 2
stealthify
09-13-2012, 08:32 PM
I rarely hear about people buying a product because "It's a Samsung." ;)
rarely? wow. you need to stop hanging around with only iTards.
Considering I work mostly with non-Apple based people and organizations, I hear a lot about what people prefer. Most just say "cheaper" - and yes, in most cases, that's not Apple, but very few say Samsung. Don't believe me? Here's an easy social experiment you can conduct at home:
Google Search - 'I love Apple' (https://www.google.com/search?q="i+love+apple") - 2.8 million results
Google Search - 'I love Samsung' (https://www.google.com/search?q="i+love+samsung") - 990,000 results
What does this tell me? That Samsung needs to step up their game. Make products that are unique, quality and that people truly love and want to stick with. Sure, the haters will call it a cult, but in reality, its just a result of concrete customer satisfaction.
stealthify
09-13-2012, 08:54 PM
That's the name of the game. They made billions, competition comes up and makes it more difficult. Happens in every market. Auto industry, PC market, wave runners, dirt bikes, bicycles, airplanes, etc.
Apple is just being a cry baby and wants a monopoly on the market.
In relation to a game, you can either play fair or you can play dirty. Samsung wanted to play dirty. Let someone else do all the legwork, product testing, paying designers, etc and then come in and steal the results.
Sure, Apple, and even Microsoft, have done this in the past. Some were justifiable (e.g. Xerox was never capable or particularly interested in bringing their graphic interface to market), others were not (e.g. when Google got wind that Apple was was working on a mobile OS through insider information, put Google Chairman Eric Schmidt on Apple's board, and essentially betrayed their trust). Here's an interesting read, in case you missed it:
What Really Made Steve Jobs So Angry at Google? (http://gizmodo.com/5941817/what-really-made-steve-jobs-so-angry-about-google)
So, in short, Apple just doesn't want others to copy the ingredients that made their products so successful. Just like how the recipe for Coca-cola is so well guarded. If the knock-off brands could make it and have it taste exactly the same, then why buy the real thing? Call that monopolizing all you want, but most creators would just call this protecting their investment.
NickS VR4
09-13-2012, 09:09 PM
In relation to a game, you can either play fair or you can play dirty. Samsung wanted to play dirty. Let someone else do all the legwork, product testing, paying designers, etc and then come in and steal the results.
Sure, Apple, and even Microsoft, have done this in the past. Some were justifiable (e.g. Xerox was never capable or particularly interested in bringing their graphic interface to market), others were not (e.g. when Google got wind that Apple was was working on a mobile OS through insider information, put Google Chairman Eric Schmidt on Apple's board, and essentially betrayed their trust). Here's an interesting read, in case you missed it:
What Really Made Steve Jobs So Angry at Google? (http://gizmodo.com/5941817/what-really-made-steve-jobs-so-angry-about-google)
So, in short, Apple just doesn't want others to copy the ingredients that made their products so successful. Just like how the recipe for Coca-cola is so well guarded. If the knock-off brands could make it and have it taste exactly the same, then why buy the real thing? Call that monopolizing all you want, but most creators would just call this protecting their investment.
You are clearly buying into Apple's plea. Ever think that people bought Samsung devices because they didn't want an Apple device? Just like there are Apple fanboys, there are Anti-Apple (Android fanboys). Many wanted a system not Apple which is why they bought other than Apple. Since Apple was the first to have the iPhone, how come those that bought Samsung didn't just buy Apple since it was available?
It's complete crap to think that any device that Samsung sold should have been an Apple sale. That is complete bullshit. At tops I say 5% may have decided to go to Apple without features like bounce back.
Lets be honest here, Android's UI has never been as smooth or as fast as Apple until ICS and JB. It has always had a second class UI. So since Apple was better, why didn't they win people over? BECAUSE PEOPLE DIDNT WANT APPLE. $1 Billion in lost sales would ONLY be true if they had a true monopoly. Tell me I'm wrong.
stealthify
09-13-2012, 09:44 PM
You are clearly buying into Apple's plea. Ever think that people bought Samsung devices because they didn't want an Apple device? Just like there are Apple fanboys, there are Anti-Apple (Android fanboys). Many wanted a system not Apple which is why they bought other than Apple. Since Apple was the first to have the iPhone, how come those that bought Samsung didn't just buy Apple since it was available?
I'm well aware of that. I have learned that you and IPD are the "anything but Apple" type of guys. Some for reasonable reasons, others for completely non-factual, biased and/or straight-up bogus reasons. Some of the things you two say leaves me scratching my head -- "is that really what Android users think?" You sound like people that haven't used an Apple product since 1994, let alone ever.
It's complete crap to think that any device that Samsung sold should have been an Apple sale. That is complete bullshit. At tops I say 5% may have decided to go to Apple without features like bounce back.
I didn't say that. This is in relation to the few Samsung phones that violated Apple's patents. Which is not their entire smartphone lineup.
Lets be honest here, Android's UI has never been as smooth or as fast as Apple until ICS and JB. It has always had a second class UI. So since Apple was better, why didn't they win people over? BECAUSE PEOPLE DIDNT WANT APPLE. $1 Billion in lost sales would ONLY be true if they had a true monopoly. Tell me I'm wrong.
They did win people over, lots and lots of people in fact. But as you pointed out, this didn't include everyone, as there are understandably people out there that an Android device would be better suited for. I've said it in nearly every thread we've debated in: pick the phone that works best for you.
Also the $1 billion settlement wasn't just for lost sales. It was to cover legal fees, the time of every employ that had to be dragged into court to speak, some lost sales (sure), but ultimately to give Apple their cut for the design elements that went into making Samsung's patent-violating products more successful than they would have been without it.
stealthee
09-13-2012, 10:36 PM
The funniest thing about all of this, is Samsung is still the big winner. The Iphail5 is comprised of many Samsung supplied parts.
Rakuny
09-13-2012, 11:19 PM
I still don't know what to say.. I'm losing faith in humanity, what IPD and Nicksvr4 said
http://imageshack.us/a/img84/3680/30504828194657857653915.jpg (http://imageshack.us/photo/my-images/84/30504828194657857653915.jpg/)
Edit: in my opinion, Apple suing Samsung will hurt sales more than anything "else"
Samsung couldn't have bought better advertising with any amount of money. Maybe some of the Ipeople will pull their heads out of the sand to buy a product that's cheaper and better.
To clarify my position, yes I am biased against apple. However, I have seen and experienced the faults with their products first hand. Steve Jobs marketing sure brought in the sheep with money in hand. We'll see how they do the next ten years without him at the forefront...
stealthify
09-13-2012, 11:45 PM
What Android fanboys hear: "Apple said that Samsung products are 'substantially the same'."
What an expert witness actually said: "It's my opinion that this phone [Galaxy S 4G], the design of this phone would be considered substantially the same."
http://www.techradar.com/news/world-of-tech/apple-vs-samsung-designs-substantially-similar-1091309
When people don't do their research and depend on quotes taken out of context, I lose my faith in humanity.
What Android fanboys hear: "Apple said that Samsung products are 'substantially the same'."
What an expert witness actually said: "It's my opinion that this phone [Galaxy S 4G], the design of this phone would be considered substantially the same."
Apple vs. Samsung: 'Designs substantially similar' | News | TechRadar (http://www.techradar.com/news/world-of-tech/apple-vs-samsung-designs-substantially-similar-1091309)
When people don't do their research and depend on quotes taken out of context, I lose my faith in humanity.
"expert witness"? i'm guessing that's someone about as unbiased as your average video-game-reviewer for a big-name publication.
stealthify
09-14-2012, 03:55 AM
"expert witness"? i'm guessing that's someone about as unbiased as your average video-game-reviewer for a big-name publication.
And yet he came up with the same conclusion a 2 year old could make. :p You'd have to be blind not to say the same.
And yet he came up with the same conclusion a 2 year old could make. :p You'd have to be blind not to say the same.
i don't say the same, and i'm hardly blind (mild myopia, perhaps, but not blind). if i were samsung right about now, i'd continue making whatever devices i wanted--and put a giant "NOT APPLE" logo on the back. i don't know who these idiots are the claim that the devices look alike--but clearly they never compare the back of the devices--the only area where aesthetics aren't overruled by the necessities of function.
apple is wrong. only here in the US do the judges appear so completely biased:
DailyTech - Apple Forced by UK to Print Public Apologies to Samsung for Design Theft Accusations (http://www.dailytech.com/Apple+Forced+by+UK+to+Print+Public+Apologies+to+Sa msung+for+Design+Theft+Accusations/article25208.htm)
NickS VR4
09-14-2012, 08:46 AM
Personally I think more people should listen to and be like Steve Wozniak. For someone that should be bias towards Apple as a major share holder, I find his opinions to be very unbiased.
His views are basically that iPhone is more polished, and basic is functionality, while Android is improved and gives a greater range of options for those wanting more out of their phone.
He also thinks this approach Apple is taking in suing everyone is bad.
I do agree with his views, but I hate the Apple fanboys that insist in the iPhone being better and innovative. They swear that Apple gets all credit for everything in the smartphone market and that Android phones are just iPhone imitators.
They need to give credit where credit is due. Regardless though these lawsuits just limit choice and slow down progress. I like it better when each has to one up the competitor, whether through new ideas or improving existing ones. That's how software works.
Look at the android dev community. Everything is open source and everyone builds off each others ideas and code. Android even gives out its code to be improved upon.
Obviously giving out the source code will not work for apples business model, and that's fine, but recreating features should be allowed IMO. Its not like they are stealing code, they have to make it from scratch.
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Tapatalk 2
stealthify
09-14-2012, 08:46 AM
i don't say the same, and i'm hardly blind (mild myopia, perhaps, but not blind). if i were samsung right about now, i'd continue making whatever devices i wanted--and put a giant "NOT APPLE" logo on the back. i don't know who these idiots are the claim that the devices look alike--but clearly they never compare the back of the devices--the only area where aesthetics aren't overruled by the necessities of function.
apple is wrong. only here in the US do the judges appear so completely biased:
DailyTech - Apple Forced by UK to Print Public Apologies to Samsung for Design Theft Accusations (http://www.dailytech.com/Apple+Forced+by+UK+to+Print+Public+Apologies+to+Sa msung+for+Design+Theft+Accusations/article25208.htm)
Ah, that was a pretty funny announcement (they always have a great sense of humor in the UK), but the ruling was stayed and is in the process of being appealed.
Apple doesn't have to apologise to Samsung | News | TechRadar (http://www.techradar.com/us/news/mobile-computing/tablets/apple-doesnt-have-to-apologise-to-samsung-yet-1090327)
Regardless, not all tablets need to look the same (as other successful manufacturers have shown), and I applaud anyone that makes an effort to be different.
NickS VR4
09-14-2012, 08:52 AM
Regardless, not all tablets need to look the same (as other successful manufacturers have shown), and I applaud anyone that makes an effort to be different.
I find absolutely nothing wrong with the styling of the Xoom, kindle Fire HD, Galaxy Tab, iPad, Transformer, or any other tablet that is a black rectangle. Simple and plain should be allowed to all.
Fancy specific added on flairs can be protected. For example Burberry and LV patterns, or trademark symbols, not a utilitarian look.
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Tapatalk 2
stealthify
09-14-2012, 09:05 AM
Nick, I have mixed feelings about you. Some of the things you say resonate with me, others not so much.
It's not that you're anti-Apple that bothers me, but rather that you guys no longer give them a chance (and that you put down others that enjoy them). That you only choose to see the bad, and rarely the good (IPD was complimenting the retina screens the other day).
Woz seems like a great guy (I love seeing his posts in the Gizmodo comments from time to time). I also enjoy when he comes out to set the record straight about Apple's history. I especially love that he carries both an Android phone and an iPhone on him at all times, because he sees the value in both.
Open source has it's place. I know this because I use a lot of open source software (particularly in web development), but it's not always the best option for developers. Windows is not open source, Microsoft Office is not open source, this forum software that we're using is not "technically" open source, yet we still value them and use them daily.
These are the options we're faced with. It's not so black and white, good vs evil as some like to make it sound. Innovation will continue, whether by Google, Microsoft or Apple, and I look forward to each of them stepping up their game and not letting development stagnate. They must not become complacent with the design and functionality options that we have available to us today -- there's so much more to be discovered on what these devices can do to make our lives better.
NickS VR4
09-14-2012, 09:21 AM
Well I used to recommend the iPhone to those technically challenged. Now however I am so sick of Apples business practices that I cannot support them in any way, just like how I wouldn't buy a Chris Brown album.
On top of that with Apple not churning out anything special this time around, it makes it easy to talk crap on them. Android is really maturing well with ICS and JB and Apple really isn't anything special anymore, just a status symbol.
The ONLY thing I envy about the iPhone is the battery life, but even there, the RAZR Maxx HD can compete.
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Tapatalk 2
stealthify
09-14-2012, 09:33 AM
The ONLY thing I envy about the iPhone is the battery life
OK. The only thing I can say is that I wouldn't buy a Chris Brown album either. High five. :p
Disrupter
09-14-2012, 09:43 AM
Whats wrong with Chris Brown? He sure can dance!
NickS VR4
09-14-2012, 10:14 AM
http://news.idg.no/cw/art.cfm?id=AB47D67D-FF79-7563-AABFA1C5AC8AB23A
Another reason Google is great.
Make an app for Android first, then convert it to Apple ;-)
Sent from my Nexus 7 using Tapatalk 2
Boost4VR4
09-14-2012, 10:45 AM
I think the patent system needs to enforce more stringent rules on the actual patent applications. I think that companies should be required to be very specific in their patents.
ictponder
09-14-2012, 10:45 AM
I wonder if they are going to try and get an injunction against sales in the US before the 920 is released in November. If the 920 is carried on the big 3 networks, especially Verizon, it's going to do very well. And with the disappointing release of the new iPhone 5, the door is opened up for a new flagship device.
I also fail to see how Apple would take any damages whatsoever in this case. Does this particular iPod have navigation and cellular capability? I'm sorely tempted to take my iPod touch and give it to my dog.
simple, utilitarian design is open-source--it is NOT the proprietary format of apple.
NickS VR4
09-14-2012, 04:25 PM
Shit, looks like LG's flagship phone with the Snapdragon S4 Pro will be the next lawsuit for copying Apple.
http://www.droid-life.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/09/lg-optimus-g-1-325x325.jpeg
stealthify
09-14-2012, 07:20 PM
I also fail to see how Apple would take any damages whatsoever in this case. Does this particular iPod have navigation and cellular capability? I'm sorely tempted to take my iPod touch and give it to my dog.
They can't, because the lawsuit in this thread's title doesn't exist.
Nick was just kidding, and trying to stir up more Apple hate.
NickS VR4
09-14-2012, 08:02 PM
They can't, because the lawsuit in this thread's title doesn't exist.
Nick was just kidding, and trying to stir up more Apple hate.
This... yes, this thread is to poke fun of and hate on apple, just like the other one announcing the iPhone 5.
During this time of year I am conflicted, I hate Apple and want to campaign for Android, but I also dislike Obama and want to campaign for Romney (even though I do not think he was the best option, he's way better than Obama). It's almost too much for me to take, Apple Fans and Obama Supporters... at least they are probably mainly the same group.
stealthify
09-14-2012, 08:24 PM
That's a bit of a stretch. My dad is the most right-wing person you may ever meet, but he loves his iPhone and will be getting the iPhone 5. He also sees Apple as the epitome of a proper business success story (start in a garage, build up, work hard, don't accept government handouts, make money legitimately via genuine capitalism, and don't stop building until you're on top... and then build some more). http://www.city-data.com/forum/members/jill61-603505-albums-emoticons-pic42899-american-flag-smiley.gif
I hope this doesn't tarnish your view of your chosen political party, but I saw MANY iPhones in the audience and news coverage of the RNC.
But what's really funny here is my mother is actually the opposite. Liberal, and for most of the last 5 years, completely anti-Apple. She didn't want to "join the cult" and her first two smartphone ended up being Android. That was, until last year, when she finally decided to give Apple a chance for one contract period. She hasn't called me with a single phone problem since.
so your mom is a techno-noob who is also one of those people prone to answering nigerian phishing emails. maybe she should have gotten a jitterbug.
i don't see phone sales as broken along party lines. party-line voters are the same people who are in apple's target audience. although i'd venture to guess that libertarians are probably more apt to be android users; such would almost be self explanatory.
stealthify
09-15-2012, 05:34 AM
I could see that with libertarians. That'd be a good study.
And yes, my mom is/was a techno-noob. Funny enough, though, has been watching her become noticeably more technologically ambitious after the acquisition to her iPhone. She's doing stuff I never thought she'd know how, or even be interested in, doing. She even just joined Twitter the other day. :p Baby steps.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OFBEJL8HbXo
KeithMac
09-15-2012, 06:49 PM
stealthify, how do you stand on Apple`s use of the 4g LTE and the blatant rip off of Samsung and HTC patents?.
stealthify, how do you stand on Apple`s use of the 4g LTE and the blatant rip off of Samsung and HTC patents?.
didn't you know? apple's copyright infringement rules don't apply to itself.
stealthify
09-15-2012, 09:21 PM
I'm sure Apple will be held to the same standard in court (if it were to ever happen), but it likely won't be an issue like the Apple-hater sensationalist would have you believe.
Apple and Samsung secure LTE patents ahead of next round of lawsuits (http://www.mobileburn.com/20478/news/apple-and-samsung-secure-lte-patents-ahead-of-next-round-of-lawsuits)
Reason #1: Apple has legitimately amassed their own large collection of LTE patents:
The Korean Intellectual Property Office notes that Apple has increased its total number of LTE patents from 0 in 2011 to 318 today, most of which were acquired as a member of a group that bought Nortel's patents.
Reason #2: LTE, just like 3G that Samsung also claims to own the "rights to", may be considered standard-essential patents:
It is unknown how many of Samsung's 819 LTE patents are industry-standard patents. Standard patents must be licensed at fair, reasonable, and nondiscriminatory rates, so any FRAND patents that Samsung hold would provide little to no leverage in its ongoing battle with Apple.
And finally:
Reason #3: Qualcomm, the company that provides the wireless data chips for Apple and many other smartphones already license the necessary patents for LTE. So by Apple using Qualcomm chips as well, it's already covered by the pre-existing licensing agreements.
So let me get this straight. You guys are mad because you think Apple is "claiming to own the rights to rectangles with rounded corners", but you're cool with Samsung saying they "own the rights to industry-standard wireless data frequencies"? Hypocrite, much? :Doh:
NickS VR4
09-15-2012, 09:34 PM
So let me get this straight. You guys are mad because you think Apple is "claiming to own the rights to rectangles with rounded corners", but you're cool with Samsung saying they "own the rights to industry-standard wireless data frequencies"? Hypocrite, much? :Doh:
lol, not hypocritical because I dont think we'd care of apple didn't start picking fights and trying to "destroy android". Apple has been taking the first shots, anything from this point forward is only a strike back.
Being how Android is open source and free, its naturally not going to be the aggressor. All these lawsuits on the android side are defensive.
Sent from my Nexus 7 using Tapatalk 2
stealthify
09-15-2012, 10:10 PM
This isn't Google defending. This is Samsung and their design choices alone, and Samsung is no stranger to acting like a child, copying and lawsuits.
The fact that you guys stand up for a company that, at times, is as scummy as Samsung just in spite of Apple amazes me. I understand some of you don't like Apple because of whatever reason (you think they're too expensive, you don't like fanboys, you don't like Apple's OS exclusivity, etc), but it's really blinding you to the stupid crap these other companies pull.
If you think Apple is the only one protecting their legitimately filed, non-standard and accepted patents, or is even the tech company that is in litigation the most, you've got another thing coming.
NickS VR4
09-15-2012, 10:59 PM
If you think Apple is the only one protecting their legitimately filed, non-standard and accepted patents
Prior art that wasn't patented before for a reason, simple stuff that shouldn't be patentable.
Sent from my Nexus 7 using Tapatalk 2
i'm not a fan of samsung. i'm a fan of HTC...and i saw how apple steamrolled HTC--a minor player, mind you. so as far as i'm concerned, i will now root for anyone who is suing apple. apple can go fornicate itself.
stealthify
09-16-2012, 07:43 AM
Nick, would it take that chip off your shoulder if I told you that all of the patents having to do with prior art and what you guys call the 'rectangle with rounded corners' patent, specifically in regards to the iPad vs Galaxy Tab, weren't included in Apple's victory? In fact, this was about the only thing the court let Samsung get away with:
Samsung must pay $1.05 billion in damages, court rules | Digital Trends (http://www.digitaltrends.com/mobile/apple-vs-samsung-verdict/)
Patent ‘889 (iPad design – specifically, “clean front, edge-to-edge glass, thin bezel, thin outer border, and rounded corners”): On this patent, Samsung and its Galaxy Tab devices were determined to not have infringed on Apple’s patent
And IPD, I'd say Samsung got steamrolled a lot harder than HTC (and rightfully so). HTC only infringed on 2 patents ('647 (http://patft.uspto.gov/netacgi/nph-Parser?Sect1=PTO1&Sect2=HITOFF&d=PALL&p=1&u=%2Fnetahtml%2FPTO%2Fsrchnum.htm&r=1&f=G&l=50&s1=5,946,647.PN.&OS=PN/5,946,647&RS=PN/5,946,647) and '263 (http://patft.uspto.gov/netacgi/nph-Parser?Sect1=PTO1&Sect2=HITOFF&d=PALL&p=1&u=%2Fnetahtml%2FPTO%2Fsrchnum.htm&r=1&f=G&l=50&s1=6,343,263.PN.&OS=PN/6,343,263&RS=PN/6,343,263)), that turned out to be patents that were easy to work-around (http://androidcommunity.com/htc-finishes-workaround-for-avoiding-apple-patent-ruling-20111221/), weren't forced to pay anything, and are currently in joint-mediation (http://www.talkandroid.com/112437-delaware-court-says-enough-fighting-orders-apple-and-htc-to-discuss-lawsuit-settlement-on-august-28th/) with Apple about trying to further work things out reasonably. Compared to the smackdown Samsung just got, this isn't bad at all.
NickS VR4
09-16-2012, 08:46 AM
They didn't lose with the galaxy tab, but just about every phone.
Sent from my Nexus 7 using Tapatalk 2
lawdogg
09-16-2012, 09:40 PM
Hey stealthify, I didn't know you were into patent law!! :bigthumb:
stealthify
09-16-2012, 09:47 PM
I'm really interested in it, hopefully I'm on the right track with the interpretations. Would you agree it's a good thing to know these days?
lawdogg
09-16-2012, 10:18 PM
Its a great thing to know these days! I didn't read every post of this thread but from what I did read, everyone's on the ball and having a good discussion. A good source for patent news is Dennis Crouch's patentlyo ... for example, Apple wins $1.05 billion verdict - Patent Law Blog (Patently-O) (http://www.patentlyo.com/patent/2012/08/apple-wins-105-billion-verdict.html).
One of the big things about this lawsuit is how much was recovered over a design patent. Historically, design patents have never been thought of as so significant.
In general, something is eligible for patent if it is a new, useful, and non-obvious machine, process, manufacture, or composition of matter. A utility patent requires claims, a specification that enables the claims and discloses the best mode of practicing the patent, and drawings. It lasts 20 years from issue. A design patent requires only one claim, claiming "an ornamental design as follows" or something along those lines, followed by drawings. It lasts 17 years. Do you think that Apple's design patents in the lawsuit were new (i.e., never done before in the same way), useful (i.e., having some utility), and non-obvious (i.e., not even a combination of previously existing stuff obvious to one of ordinary skill in the art)? It's a fun conversation to have.
Also, the problem with standards essential patents is that they come with an asterix. That is called FRAND, which means that the owner of a standards-essential patent is bound to license the patent to anyone who requests a license on fair, reasonable, and non-discriminatory terms. This sucks for these big players, who are always seeking to enjoin each other and claim the market share. Kind of like highlander. FRAND is a pretty hot topic these days too. There's a buzz about Samsung filing against Apple regarding the iPhone 5's 4G technology, of which Samsung claims to own a standards-essential patent. But undoubedly they will seek an injunction. It will be interesting to see what happens.
stealthify
09-16-2012, 10:27 PM
I'll definitely be staying tuned. Thanks for the link on Patently-O. I keep finding myself on FOSS Patents (FOSS Patents (http://www.fosspatents.com/)), but I need to branch out.
You were on your way to getting licensed, weren't you? Are you out battling in cases like this yet?
lawdogg
09-16-2012, 10:38 PM
I'll definitely be staying tuned. Thanks for the link on Patently-O. I keep finding myself on FOSS Patents (FOSS Patents (http://www.fosspatents.com/)), but I need to branch out.
You were on your way to getting licensed, weren't you? Are you out battling in cases like this yet?
Nice, FOSS is good stuff too, it's cool you like this stuff! I'll be sure to ask what you think about big patent stuff as it comes down.
I am, I'll be taking the patent bar late fall / early winter and the Illinois state bar next year. The firm I was a summer associate at over the summer (try to find me in the group pic lol Global IP Law Group :: International Intellectual Property Law Firm (http://giplg.com/), I think I'm still listed on the "analyst" page) was a player in the $4.5B Nortel deal, and has their hands in pretty much every single big patent transaction that has ever happened. It's really neat to be right in the middle of it.
Right now I'm at a different firm for an externship which doesn't do as much transactional stuff, I've been supporting the litigation and prosecution teams and doing some soft IP. Just finished a memo on the recent Louboutin v. Yves Saint Laurent red sole shoe trademark decision. :p The court used 15 usc 1119 to modify the principle trademark register!! For the federalists on here ... there's a fun discussion.
stealthify
09-17-2012, 04:57 AM
Sounds good, I'd love to hear what you think too. You picked a good field to get into, patents are such a hot topic and seemingly more high profile than ever (the Nortel auction was a great reminder of just how important they are to all the major players). That's cool that your firm had a part of that!
Reading into the red-sole case made me feel glad that it's not just the tech industry running into these challenges.
NickS VR4
09-20-2012, 10:24 PM
Google, Stack Exchange, and USPTO Giving The People Power To Squash Patent Trolls For Good (http://phandroid.com/2012/09/20/google-stack-exchange-and-uspto-giving-people-the-power-to-squash-patent-trolls-for-good/)
Awesome... basically allows you to report invalid patents. I have a feeling that 95% of those reported will belong to Apple.
this will get very interesting, very fast.
NickS VR4
10-18-2012, 01:11 PM
Apple loses UK appeal, must place ads saying Samsung is no copycat (http://phandroid.com/2012/10/18/apple-loses-uk-appeal-must-place-ads-saying-samsung-is-no-copycat/)
haha, nick beat me to it.
i want a framed copy of that apology.
fullracegt
10-19-2012, 03:04 PM
Apple loses UK appeal, must place ads saying Samsung is no copycat (http://phandroid.com/2012/10/18/apple-loses-uk-appeal-must-place-ads-saying-samsung-is-no-copycat/)
good..
PearlWhiteR/T
10-22-2012, 11:02 PM
^ Hahaha that's almost laughable. Yet pathetically stupid all at the same time. The Samsung tablet looks so similar from the front compared with the iPad.. Almost identical. That judge clearly lacks good character. Ignorance really is bliss.
NickS VR4
10-22-2012, 11:29 PM
^ Hahaha that's almost laughable. Yet pathetically stupid all at the same time. The Samsung tablet looks so similar from the front compared with the iPad.. Almost identical. That judge clearly lacks good character. Ignorance really is bliss.
Yes, the App drawer looked somewhat close to Apple's homescreen. The pics used are always misleading.
Sent from my ASUS Transformer Pad TF700T using Tapatalk 2
NickS VR4
10-23-2012, 01:11 PM
USPTO Axes Rubber-Banding Patent Used in Apple’s Case Against Samsung – Droid Life (http://www.droid-life.com/2012/10/23/uspto-axes-rubber-banding-patent-used-in-apples-case-against-samsung/)
good. because "Rubber-banding" has been a feature on a lot of different programs since practically y2k (if not before). several games i've played have had that action built into menus or other aspects. once again, prior art that--only in apple's mind--is completely invalid because apple says so.
stealthify
10-24-2012, 03:12 AM
There's no doubt it's a seemingly obvious piece of flair that makes other products that don't have it feel cheap in comparison, but perhaps the USPTO shouldn't have granted the patent in the first place.
of course not. that's what i've been hammering. apple is simply trying to capitalize on that shortcoming. legal? yes. moral? not in the least.
NickS VR4
10-24-2012, 12:33 PM
Next up, the prior art of pinch-to-zoom.
Sent from my Nexus 7 using Tapatalk 2
stealthify
10-25-2012, 07:52 AM
Maybe they'll fix the patent system one day, but until then...
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7huae767Rxg
well....at least it's 100% true. it may sound annoying, but it's all true. :p
stealthify
10-25-2012, 10:06 AM
I hear it far too often :)
I hear it far too often :)
truth hurts. :p
ictponder
10-25-2012, 11:08 AM
More durable?
NickS VR4
10-25-2012, 11:28 AM
More durable?
http://cdn.pocketnow.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/01/casio-gshock-15.jpg
Android has more than one phone.
NickS VR4
10-26-2012, 11:19 AM
And Apple puts the statement up, but is still a baby about it...
Apple - Samsung/Apple UK judgment (http://www.apple.com/uk/legal-judgement/)
Samsung / Apple UK judgment
On 9th July 2012 the High Court of Justice of England and Wales ruled that Samsung Electronic (UK) Limited’s Galaxy Tablet Computer, namely the Galaxy Tab 10.1, Tab 8.9 and Tab 7.7 do not infringe Apple’s registered design No. 0000181607-0001. A copy of the full judgment of the High court is available on the following link www.bailii.org/ew/cases/EWHC/Patents/2012/1882.html (http://www.bailii.org/ew/cases/EWHC/Patents/2012/1882.html).
In the ruling, the judge made several important points comparing the designs of the Apple and Samsung products:
"The extreme simplicity of the Apple design is striking. Overall it has undecorated flat surfaces with a plate of glass on the front all the way out to a very thin rim and a blank back. There is a crisp edge around the rim and a combination of curves, both at the corners and the sides. The design looks like an object the informed user would want to pick up and hold. It is an understated, smooth and simple product. It is a cool design."
"The informed user's overall impression of each of the Samsung Galaxy Tablets is the following. From the front they belong to the family which includes the Apple design; but the Samsung products are very thin, almost insubstantial members of that family with unusual details on the back. They do not have the same understated and extreme simplicity which is possessed by the Apple design. They are not as cool."
That Judgment has effect throughout the European Union and was upheld by the Court of Appeal on 18 October 2012. A copy of the Court of Appeal’s judgment is available on the following link www.bailii.org/ew/cases/EWCA/Civ/2012/1339.html (http://www.bailii.org/ew/cases/EWCA/Civ/2012/1339.html). There is no injunction in respect of the registered design in force anywhere in Europe.
However, in a case tried in Germany regarding the same patent, the court found that Samsung engaged in unfair competition by copying the iPad design. A U.S. jury also found Samsung guilty of infringing on Apple's design and utility patents, awarding over one billion U.S. dollars in damages to Apple Inc. So while the U.K. court did not find Samsung guilty of infringement, other courts have recognized that in the course of creating its Galaxy tablet, Samsung willfully copied Apple's far more popular iPad.
stealthify
10-26-2012, 11:37 AM
Quoting the judge doesn't make Apple out to be a baby, and there's absolutely no reason why Apple can't mention what other courts around the world ruled. Everything they stated was fact, whether Apple haters like it or not.
proof that the patent system is completely FUBAR--that apple knows this, and is intentionally seeking to profit by it.
DailyTech - ITC Judge Says Samsung Violated Four Apple Patents (http://www.dailytech.com/Article.aspx?newsid=29031&red=y#816706)
seriously? "detecting" when a headset is plugged in? how in the world is that able to be patented, let alone wtf would ever possess apple to even try to patent something that has been a standard feature ever since the headphone jack was invented?
http://http://images.dailytech.com/nimage/28824_28822_large_samsung-did-not-copy-the-ipad.jpeg
stealthify
10-27-2012, 10:54 AM
You should really check your sources, IPD.
Not only does that article over-simplify the actual patents, it also reports false information about "Samsung deciding to cut ties with Apple":
Samsung says it's still supplying LCD panels to Apple | Apple - CNET News (http://news.cnet.com/8301-13579_3-57537773-37/samsung-says-its-still-supplying-lcd-panels-to-apple/)
As I said earlier, you can't patent a concept (e.g. detecting when a headset is plugged in). You can patent how the detection occurs when the headset is plugged in. Two very different things.
The real question is how can Samsung claim ownership and charge exuberantly for standard-essential patents like connectivity to LTE (http://news.cnet.com/8301-13579_3-57510080-37/samsung-will-reportedly-sue-apple-over-lte-use-on-iphone-5/), which has created an investigation by the DOJ (http://news.cnet.com/8301-1035_3-57538936-94/apple-doj-has-samsungs-standard-essential-patents-in-its-sights/), I'll never know.
NickS VR4
10-27-2012, 11:35 AM
You should really check your sources, IPD.
Not only does that article over-simplify the actual patents, it also reports false information about "Samsung deciding to cut ties with Apple":
Samsung says it's still supplying LCD panels to Apple | Apple - CNET News (http://news.cnet.com/8301-13579_3-57537773-37/samsung-says-its-still-supplying-lcd-panels-to-apple/)
As I said earlier, you can't patent a concept (e.g. detecting when a headset is plugged in). You can patent how the detection occurs when the headset is plugged in. Two very different things.
The real question is how can Samsung claim ownership and charge exuberantly for standard-essential patents like connectivity to LTE (http://news.cnet.com/8301-13579_3-57510080-37/samsung-will-reportedly-sue-apple-over-lte-use-on-iphone-5/), which has created an investigation by the DOJ (http://news.cnet.com/8301-1035_3-57538936-94/apple-doj-has-samsungs-standard-essential-patents-in-its-sights/), I'll never know.
Didn't read and I don't know how either do it. If I were to do it, I would use the metal on a headphone jack to create a short, acting as a switch. Or, if that is not feasible (due to interfering with other signals), have a little button switch at the end when you push the headphone jack all the way in.
stealthify
10-27-2012, 11:38 AM
Didn't read and I don't know how either do it. If I were to do it, I would use the metal on a headphone jack to create a short, acting as a switch. Or, if that is not feasible (due to interfering with other signals), have a little button switch at the end when you push the headphone jack all the way in.
Definitely more than one way to skin a cat.
As I said earlier, you can't patent a concept
but you CAN patent a shape or an idea....like a rectangle with rounded corners.
/sarcasm
stealthify
10-27-2012, 10:14 PM
but you CAN patent a shape or an idea....like a rectangle with rounded corners.
/sarcasm
You can't patent a rectangle with rounded corners either, otherwise the manufacturers for all rectangular, round-cornered smartphone would be getting sued too. They're not.
On the flipside, what you can't do is make your product look strikingly similar to another product already on the market, down to the silver trim, color choices, bezel, power cable and even packaging, and expect not to get sued.
lawdogg
10-28-2012, 11:22 PM
Design patents are really interesting creatures. Originally, starting in 1870 at least, the test for infringement of a design patent is similarity to an ordinary observer. But over time the courts stretched and twisted the precedent, and up until recently, the test of infringement was a two prong test which looked for a "point of novelty" over the prior art, and involved cataloging every tiny difference between the patent and the alleged infringer. Under this test, it was very hard to find infringement. In a case called Egyptian Goddess, the court of appeals for the federal circuit went back to the old ordinary observer test. This makes it much easier for a jury to find infringement of a design patent, and is a huge reason why design patents have turned out to be so valuable.
If you take a look at the design patents at issue, you'll see how interesting they are and how simple they seem.
NickS VR4
11-01-2012, 12:23 PM
http://www.droid-life.com/2012/11/01/apple-must-rewrite-we-didnt-copy-samsung-post-must-last-until-december/
Sent from my Nexus 7 using Tapatalk 2
stealthify
11-01-2012, 01:24 PM
Would make for a very nerdy monty python skit... :p
nick's posting the info before i can get it. damn these work-hours in dirka-dirkastan
NickS VR4
11-02-2012, 02:13 AM
Lol. I have droid life on my Facebook so I get a feed of topics on there.
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Tapatalk 2
apple's "new" apology. still not a fricking apology. no expression of regret/remorse = NOT AN APOLOGY.
DailyTech - Quick Note: Apple's Rewritten Apology to Samsung Appears in UK Newspapers (http://www.dailytech.com/Article.aspx?newsid=29098&red=y#818137)
of interesting note:
Anthropologist: Apple is a religion | Technically Incorrect - CNET News (http://news.cnet.com/8301-17852_3-57540154-71/anthropologist-apple-is-a-religion/)
i myself have already noted 3 distinct similarities between apple and N. Korea, so for an anthropologist to see similarities between apple and cult-like behavior doesn't surprise me in the least.
oh, and for shits and giggles:
What apple sees:
http://tctechcrunch2011.files.wordpress.com/2012/07/samsung_phones_before_after_iphone.jpg
and what's actually true:
http://cdn.arstechnica.net/wp-content/uploads/2012/08/samsung-before-iphone-3.png
stealthify
11-03-2012, 06:52 AM
apple's "new" apology. still not a fricking apology. no expression of regret/remorse = NOT AN APOLOGY.
DailyTech - Quick Note: Apple's Rewritten Apology to Samsung Appears in UK Newspapers (http://www.dailytech.com/Article.aspx?newsid=29098&red=y#818137)
of interesting note:
Anthropologist: Apple is a religion | Technically Incorrect - CNET News (http://news.cnet.com/8301-17852_3-57540154-71/anthropologist-apple-is-a-religion/)
i myself have already noted 3 distinct similarities between apple and N. Korea, so for an anthropologist to see similarities between apple and cult-like behavior doesn't surprise me in the least.
Just goes to show you haven't been paying attention, or reading beyond the bias headlines.
The judge didn't tell Apple to apologize. He ordered them to post a notice that, in his court, he did not find Samsung to be infringing on Apple's design. Beyond that, he went as far as to say the reason Samsung didn't infringe was because Samsung's design "wasn't cool enough (http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2012-07-09/samsung-wins-u-k-apple-ruling-over-not-as-cool-galaxy-tablet.html)."
Apple posted all of that and then some. No where did the judge ask Apple to apologize:
Judge Says Apple Must Publish Notice Regarding Samsung (http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2012-07-18/apple-must-publish-notice-samsung-didn-t-copy-ipad-judge-says.html)
"The notice should outline the July 9 London court decision that Samsung’s Galaxy tablets don’t infringe Apple’s registered designs" Judge Colin Birss said.
As far as comparing Apple fans to a cult, which is a tired argument now: find me one well-liked brand or product that doesn't have a passionate fanbase that can be called a cult and I'll give you a cookie.
Just goes to show you haven't been paying attention, or reading beyond the bias headlines.
The judge didn't tell Apple to apologize. He ordered them to post a notice that, in his court, he did not find Samsung to be infringing on Apple's design. Beyond that, he went as far as to say the reason Samsung didn't infringe was because Samsung's design "wasn't cool enough (http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2012-07-09/samsung-wins-u-k-apple-ruling-over-not-as-cool-galaxy-tablet.html)."
Apple posted all of that and then some. No where did the judge ask Apple to apologize:
Judge Says Apple Must Publish Notice Regarding Samsung (http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2012-07-18/apple-must-publish-notice-samsung-didn-t-copy-ipad-judge-says.html)
As far as comparing Apple fans to a cult, which is a tired argument now: find me one well-liked brand or product that doesn't have a passionate fanbase that can be called a cult and I'll give you a cookie.
passion is one thing. we're talking rabid-hysteria.
NickS VR4
11-03-2012, 09:06 PM
Apple UK updates Samsung statement, but makes sure people don’t see it (http://phandroid.com/2012/11/03/apple-uk-hides-samsung-statement/)
And apple makes their site purposely put it off screen w/o scrolling through styling code. Makes sure it is the only part off screen.
par for the course. apple gives another giant FU to the courts that don't agree with their own lawyers. this is the classic example of WHY i hate apple. i don't hate competition. i don't hate innovation.
i hate that apple's vision is one of a world in which they are the only legitimate manufacturer of smartphones or tablets. that they would rather litigate than compete. that they apparently spend more on their legal team than their product dveleopment team (by a wide margin). that they choose to abuse the broken patent system by trying to claim prior art (from everyone between garmin to LG) as their own.
if apple could just put a product to market and then try and improve upon it dramatically with each new product cycle--that would be amazing. instead, we get products that are often scarcely better than the last--because all of the R&D funding apparently went into legal fees to try and convince federal judges in 50 different countries that every single one of its competitors are "ripping off" apple. apple doesn't even need to win. it seeks preliminary injunctions against competing devices--which means that regardless of eventual outcome, if it wins the preliminary, it effectively crushes the competition. those products will be woefully outdated by the time they are allowed to come to market--if at all.
apple has made it perfectly clear that it is willing to outspend all competitors on the legal front as the primary means of proping itself up in the tech market. the only reason that samsung/google get more coverage is because those companies are best equipped to actually go toe-to-toe with apple over its BS litigation. HTC and others simply aren't. I'm not a samsung fan in the least--but i do root for their victories; because i'm against apple. it's like how people voted AGAINST kerry, rather than FOR bush.
antics like the original "apology" and the underhandedness of its new one simply highlight the underlying mindset of the company. apple is evil.
for the record, i didn't hate dell when they were the industry leader. nor hp. nor blackberry. i just hate apple for what apple has become. if apple were a singer, he would sue every other musiciain for stealing the ideas of singings songs about partying or telling someone you love them.
stealthify
11-04-2012, 09:46 AM
IPD, it's pretty clear at this point that you have a pretty warped view of Apple.
You know, back in the 90's, this was a whole different deal. Apple didn't adequately patent or protect shit (and neither did Xerox for that matter), but any ground Apple gained or new innovation provided by Apple was stripped by the competition. This included by Microsoft, most of all.
Apple Computer, Inc. v. Microsoft Corporation - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apple_Computer,_Inc._v._Microsoft_Corporation)
When Apple released the initial iPhone in 2007, they knew they had something special on their hands. Everything else in the market was crap and wasn't taking off. You think it was pure luck and a bit of marketing that made the iPhone was a hit? No. They took everything that other phones at the time were doing wrong, and they made it better. That's what made it a hit.
Then what's happened since then? They had a near repeat of exactly what happened a little over a decade before, but instead of Microsoft, we have Google creeping around. Then CEO of Google, Eric Schmidt, gains Steve Job's trust and gets himself a seat on Apple's Board of Directors. While at the same time taking what he's learning at Apple and applying it to Android and Chrome OS. There's absolutely no respect to be gained in that.
And Apple wanting to be the only game in town? That's an impossibility. They knew getting into the smartphone market would bring competition, but they weren't about to let the 90's repeat itself. That's why at the original iPhone introduction keynote they made it a point to declare that "they patented the hell out of it."
Since then, they have had many, many phones emerge as competitors. Those that bluntly copy, most of which happened to come from Samsung, have been brought to court. Those that actually try to be different, have been left alone. The point is, there can be legitimate competition, but they don't need to mimic Apple. Funny enough -- you know which company isn't mimicking Apple these days? Microsoft and the direction they're going with Windows and Windows Phone. Man, how the times have changed.
As far as Apple litigating as opposed to working on R&D? Do your research. Google will help you find it, that's something they're very good at:
Check, Please: Experts Say Apple, Samsung Face Sky-High Legal Fees - Law Blog - WSJ (http://blogs.wsj.com/law/2012/08/24/check-please-experts-say-apple-samsung-face-sky-high-legal-fees/)
Mr. Dunner estimated that each side could have spent $10 to $20 million on the case.
Apple increased R&D spending by $1 billion in 2012 | Ars Technica (http://arstechnica.com/apple/2012/11/apple-increased-rd-spending-by-1-billion-in-2012/)
The filing reveals spending on research and development has grown significantly to $3.4 billion—an increase of $1 billion over 2011
With the Samsung vs Apple case probably being Apple's largest ever, and only costing between $10-20 million, even if you were to add up the smaller cases, it wouldn't even be able to hold a candle to Apple's 3.4 billion in R&D spendings. Nice try though.
Sorry man, but just about everything you say in these anti-Apple threads is FUD.
NickS VR4
11-04-2012, 09:53 AM
If apple is the largest tech company in the world, why would any competition out sell apple? If they truly are the innovators, why can't they stay on top?
If Microsoft and Google are copiers, why do they beat apple in a market "they created"?
Its cause apple is not as good as you say.
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Tapatalk 2
stealthify
11-04-2012, 10:17 AM
If apple is the largest tech company in the world, why would any competition out sell apple?
Let's rephrase the question:
"If HP is the largest computer maker in the world, why would any competitor outsell them?"
Apple Now Top PC Maker, Report Says - Hardware - Desktops/PCs - (http://www.informationweek.com/hardware/desktop/apple-now-top-pc-maker-report-says/232500794)
"If Symbian is the largest smartphone OS in the world, why would any competitor outsell them?"
File:World Wide Smartphone Sales Share.png - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:World_Wide_Smartphone_Sales_Share.png)
The answer is simple. You put down your guard and you stop predicting where the market will go, or someone starts providing a significantly better product or service for the masses, you will fail. Apple can't litigate their way out of that equation.
And you read me wrong. Microsoft is not a copier anymore (at least when it comes to OS's). Perhaps that's why they're not in court. Windows 8 and Windows Phone are prime examples that an OS can be different enough. Does that make it better? That's yet to be seen. But I'm proud of them for not taking the easy way out.
NickS VR4
11-04-2012, 10:28 AM
The answer is simple. You put down your guard and you stop predicting where the market will go, or someone starts providing a significantly better product or service for the masses, you will fail. Apple can't litigate their way out of that equation.
Exactly my point. The best product sells the best. Apple was on top, now they want to be on top with a weaker product and cry that they aren't.
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Tapatalk 2
stealthify
11-04-2012, 10:45 AM
When it comes to sales numbers, another way to outsell a competitor is to sell to a different market population. In the S3's case, that meant dropping the price down to $99 (or even $49 refurbished) to horde up as many sales as you can get. Is that a totally legitimate way to get sales? Absolutely. Does that make it a better product? Not necessarily.
If Apple lowered the price of the iPhone 5 down to $49 or $99 when they first released it, do you think they'd easily outsell the competition? Just a hunch here, but I'm pretty sure they would.
So while the S3 might temporarily be "on top" when it comes to sales numbers, that does not make the iPhone a "weaker" product. That's a fallacy if I've ever heard one.
NickS VR4
11-04-2012, 10:50 AM
Price to benefit. I could buy a Ferrari, but I get more value out of a civic for driving to work.
In the end profit is all that matters. Just don't cry that you sell less phones or are losing market share. If they want to sell more, or keep a larger market share, price competitively.
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Tapatalk 2
stealthify
11-04-2012, 10:54 AM
In the end profit is all that matters.
You said it, not me. Quoted for when Apple and Samsung announce their next earnings.
NickS VR4
11-04-2012, 10:56 AM
You said it, not me. Quoted for when Apple and Samsung announce their next earnings.
I'm fine with apple making more money, I'm not ok with Apple suing all competition to avoid being competitive.
They feel entitled to be the only one on top.
That's like the patriots suing the Giants for beating them in the Super Bowl.
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Tapatalk 2
stealthify
11-04-2012, 11:00 AM
Apple suing all competition
Apple is not suing all competition.
Period.
NickS VR4
11-04-2012, 11:05 AM
Apple is not suing all competition.
Period.
Not yet, but they are suing essentially all Android competition. Most of the suits involve android functionality.
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Tapatalk 2
that's funny, because as far as i can tell, apple isn't even close to top-dog.
Hewlett-Packard top PC seller globally: Gartner - The Times of India (http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/tech/tech-news/hardware/Hewlett-Packard-top-PC-seller-globally-Gartner/articleshow/14840288.cms?)
for the record, your own article says that 10-20 million was the LOW estimate for their legal fees. another estimate was half a billion. now apple can claim whatever the frack it wants on R&D, but if it really is spitting out that much on it--then WTF is the ipad mini the worst excuse for a tablet PC since whatever acer put out last. innovation my ass; they couldn't even put a retina display in it. either apple is cooking the books, or they are incompetent beyond belief. and there's no way in holy hades they couldn't "afford" to beef up the specs on the mini.
failure to predict the market is HOW the market works. survival of the fittest. so your entire argument is based on apple's "clamping down" on "illegitimate copying". i'd love to see how apple DEFINES that term. by every tangible measure i can summon, they have a double standard of staggering proportions.
by the way, apple didn't "innovate" back in the 90's. apple nearly died entirely because of professional mismanagement. microsoft didn't kill them. offering shitty PC's nearly did. they tried to survive on making colorful cases---rather than quality hardware. the software wasn't helping either. lots of compatibility issues (still the case to this day, though they have improved). bottom line though, they offered tepid value compared to compaq, emachines, dell, hp, gateway, and virtually every brand available. i actually applauded the move to bring jobs back. what i DIDN'T anticipate was that barely a decade later, jobs would turn into the antichrist and apple would turn into an army of hellspawn.
now let's be clear here. if apple has a beef with the OPERATING SYSTEM, then it needs to take that up with google. what it has a beef with--instead--is the implementation, which is why it's suing samsung. so your argument about schmidt is largely invalid; sony-ericcson, motorola, HTC and others all make android devices. the argument against android is as stupid as insisting that lindows is illegal because it emulates windows. the reality is, MS ended up buying it rather than fighting it (lindows had the better case anyways). that works when it's a small company you can muscle around. it doesn't work when it's an 900 lbs gorilla like samsung. so of course, apple is pitching a fit.
SHOW me the proprietary art. show me the exact specific "features" that apple claims it alone has the rights to. please. i'd love--just once--for someone to prove to me how apple has any legitimate claim on one frigging thing they've ever done.
DailyTech - Wisconsin Judge Kicks Apple v. Google Out of Federal Court for a Third Time (http://www.dailytech.com/Wisconsin+Judge+Kicks+Apple+v+Google+Out+of+Federa l+Court+for+a+Third+Time/article29125.htm)
apple to federal judge: we'll only accept your ruling if we like it.
stealthify
11-07-2012, 06:41 AM
Finally got some time.
that's funny, because as far as i can tell, apple isn't even close to top-dog.
Top-dog in what way? Customer support? Customer approval ratings? Tablet unit sales? In your world, Apple is good at nothing. In my world, Apple is good at a lot of things, but not at everything (just to keep it real). There's always room for improvement.
Did you really have to venture all the way into a tech blog from India to find someone that disagrees that Apple isn't kicking every other hardware manufacturer's ass at making personal computing devices? Your article excludes tablet PCs. Including tablet PCs, Apple is on top. Irrefutable.
for the record, your own article says that 10-20 million was the LOW estimate for their legal fees. another estimate was half a billion.
I know what my article said. The most talked about and trust-worthy estimate that has been making the rounds seems to be the 10-20 million range. Even if you take the high estimate, $500 million, that's still 1/7 what Apple spends on R&D. Your statement that Apple spends more in court than it does on R&D is false, no matter how you look at it.
WTF is the ipad mini the worst excuse for a tablet PC since whatever acer put out last. innovation my ass; they couldn't even put a retina display in it. either apple is cooking the books, or they are incompetent beyond belief. and there's no way in holy hades they couldn't "afford" to beef up the specs on the mini.
That's entirely opinion. iPad Mini the worst excuse for a tablet PC? Really? Apple clearly made some key choices on how to make an affordable, yet quality, tablet for those that don't want or can't afford the 9.7in iPad. I'm a little bummed to hear the iPad Mini didn't get a retina display, but is it a deal-breaker for the price I'd be paying? No. I understand that at the near-$300 price range, some things had to go. The device is still extremely well built, with quality materials, and feels very lightweight.
I predict that we'll see retina displays become a standard within the next 2-3 years across all products (including iMacs and all MacBooks). The price on retina displays just needs to come down a bit for this to happen. Everyone wants it, but very few are willing to pay extra for it.
apple nearly died entirely because of professional mismanagement. microsoft didn't kill them. offering shitty PC's nearly did. they tried to survive on making colorful cases---rather than quality hardware. the software wasn't helping either. lots of compatibility issues (still the case to this day, though they have improved). bottom line though, they offered tepid value compared to compaq, emachines, dell, hp, gateway, and virtually every brand available. i actually applauded the move to bring jobs back.
A lot of things hurt Apple back in the mid-90s: professional mismanagement, failure to protect their technological advancements and OS improvements, and a momentary loss of vision and direction without quality people in charge. And you have your timeline a little messed up - the colorful cases are, arguably, one of the decisions that made Apple unique at the time and restarted their movement back into a successful company. Along with the success of the iPod, the color iMac changed the game on how PCs should look, and sparked interest in a whole new demographic of people that otherwise weren't interested in computers. Looking back at the design of the old iMacs today, I think they look pretty ridiculous. But at the time, I think that kind of design is exactly what was needed to turn things around for the computer industry as a whole. It made one key point that most other manufacturers at the time didn't understand: design matters.
Compared to how I remember it 5+ years ago, the compatibility issues are solved. Between VMs and Bootcamp, there's not a single file I can't open these days on an Apple computer.
now let's be clear here. if apple has a beef with the OPERATING SYSTEM, then it needs to take that up with google. what it has a beef with--instead--is the implementation, which is why it's suing samsung. so your argument about schmidt is largely invalid; sony-ericcson, motorola, HTC and others all make android devices.
Just based on the cases we've seen so far, it is clear that Apple mostly has problems with other company's leaching on their success with design. Some of this is related to software (which would land on Google's lap, minus situational cases that come up with each manufacturer's unique UI customizations), and some of it has to do with hardware (creating your product to look and act as much like an Apple product as possible, without actually being an Apple product).
Why doesn't Apple just sue Google? Maybe they will. You really think Google is playing fair? You should decide for yourself:
FTC Staff Said to Formally Recommend Google Patent Suit - Bloomberg (http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2012-11-01/ftc-staff-said-to-formally-recommend-google-patent-suit.html)
This is fundamentally what makes Google different, and perhaps more evil, than you consider Apple to be. Every patent Apple has defended, as vague of a patent as you generally think it is, has never been considered to be an industry-standard, FRAND patent, which would require Apple to license them under fair, reasonable, and non-discriminatory terms. Google, on the other hand, uses these "necessary" patents to force competition out of the market, or to cut in and require unreasonable licensing fees. That, by all definitions, is anti-competitive, and I'm surprised you're okay with that.
SHOW me the proprietary art. show me the exact specific "features" that apple claims it alone has the rights to. please. i'd love--just once--for someone to prove to me how apple has any legitimate claim on one frigging thing they've ever done.
When you say art, I think of design. Show me a computer that looked like the first iMac before the iMac came out. Show me a tower PC that looked even close to how the Mac Pro looks, before the original G5 came out. These are just a few examples of Apple trying something "different," with complete innovative design.
I've said it once, and I'll say it again. Everything we create in this world is inspired by something else. Architecture, computers, and even cars. What was the prior art for the original automobile? Stagecoaches. What was the design inspiration for stagecoaches? Chariots. The list goes on. There's been little tweaks along the way, but the list always goes on.
Using your argument, the automobile could not legitimately be claimed as an invention. But rather, you'd argue the invention of the automobile is nothing more than a rip-off of a stagecoach, with a slight tweak to make it move without horses. It's really a pointless argument.
So, Apple didn't create the original GUI, but they took something that arguably would have never made it to market or become a success under Xerox, they saw the potential, improved it, and eventually released it as a brand new product. All tweaks, but all successful tweaks.
A great argument to be had is, how is Apple pushing certain markets forward? It can't be denied that Apple is pushing the bounds when it comes to design -- they're good at it. They're also pushing the bounds on making computer technology easier to use, and more accessible to the masses. They're also actively working to take stagnating technology and making it obsolete (e.g. declaring war on 3.5 disk drives, Flash, and now optical media). I really hope Apple doesn't lose this vision and drive, but I equally hope competitors pick up where Apple slacks. My ultimate interest is seeing computers, smartphones and technology progress, and completely imitating/copying the competition as much as you can doesn't work towards this goal one bit.
To conclude, answer me this: where, if ever, has Samsung shown innovation?
this isn't a samsung argument. samsung is ONE manufacturer. the argument centers around android--which itself is a linux construct. google has THREE primary partners for the nexus line (one for each size).
what has samsung invented? i honestly don't know. nor do i rightly give a shit. i'm not a samsung fan. i'm an ANTI-APPLE fan. for all it's worth, in the public eye, both apple and samsung accuse each other of a LOT of shenanigans. i don't take issue with that. i take issue with the company BEHIND the alleged shenanigans. i somewhat know where samsung has come from and where it is--it's certainly not a rose (LCD price fixing, etc). i know a lot more about apple and its draconian approach to consumers, the free market, etc. it's not the innovation (not that apple actually has any) that bothers me, it's the mindset of the company. i used word perfect & netscape back in the day because i saw the same type of behaviors being used by MS.
interesting that you post a BS article about people who decline to be named--who support the idea of suing google. roflcoptor. i'm sure that those people are in no way related to the legal team that told federal judge #3 (yes, we're counting) that Apple would reject royalty payments of > $1 per phone. (which i can only assume that apple would make 32.75% profit on each iphone, rather than 33%--or something thereabout). the iZombies don't realize that the "public support" in favor of apple is heavily comprised of people who either use their products almost exclusively, are paid shills, or a combination of both (tony swash, classic example). judge koh was in no way an "unbiased party" when she was presiding. outside the apple sphere of influence (beyond the reach of the reality distortion field), apple's motive is pretty clear. all that stuff that apple declares as "apple innovation" is simple, obvious, and virtually a requisite for any product in the field.
and for the record, i said "prior art" not "art". if design is the best "innovation" you can come up with, fine. school is in session
now let me see.....design you say? ok. imac...all in 1 pc. oh shit, commodore did that back in the 70's. hell tandy did that with the "Trash-80" i grew up with. so it's "blue". who gives a crap? the idea isn't new. kaypro II anyone? apple made it slightly less blocky & added color--thereby increasing heat dissipation problems (signature feature of all apple products since). hell, even the current iteration is about as "straightforward" of an evolution as you can get; migraction to LCD from CRT. and with an army of existing laptops providing thin-form-factor guts...slapping them on the back of a MONITOR instead of UNDER A KEYBOARD (ala laptop) is a no-brainer.
now let's see. "mac pro" (i'm going to assume you meant power-mac g5 (or prior). ok so powermac g4. fairly "unique" case design. so what? who has copied this design, and why would i be opposed to copy-cats of this CASE design being sued? the case has NOTHING to do with the user experience. NOTHING. the mouse doesn't interact with the case. there's no touchscreens on the case. it doesn't have to fit in your pocket so you can take it places. that's like arguming that your disposable water-bottle is superior because of its shape. it's probably the reason that people vain enough to care about such things are now putting led lights and other "ambience mods" in their own cases. for what it's worth though, apple wasn't the first one to make a "unique" dektop case. alienware was doing it years before that--among others:
Alienware Aurora DDR Review & Rating | PCMag.com (http://www.pcmag.com/article2/0,2817,1366363,00.asp)
so again, apple doesn't "invent" anything. they're as full of hot air as they have ever been. maybe next time you'll find me some actual features that i can pick apart.
p.s.
i'd post that 20-min youtube video of the guy debunking the "apple inventions" myths, one by one...but i'm at work and can't get to youtube.
stealthify
11-07-2012, 09:51 AM
now let me see... design you say? ok. the first self-propelled automobile...4 wheels. oh shit, horse buggies had this 85 years ago. hell, even my Amish uncle had a "Ishmael Dart" i grew up with. So it doesn't require a horse trainer? the idea isn't new. pulled rickshaw anyone? Siegfried Marcus put a liquid-fueled internal combustion engine on a simple handcard & became the first man to propel a carriage by means of gasoline--thereby increasing gas consumption and pollution (signature feature of all automotive products since). hell, even the current iteration is about as "straightforward" of an evolution as you can get; migration to electric from gasoline. and with an army of existing cars providing increased fuel efficiency internals... finding a more efficient way of pushing an automotive (ala hybrid) is a no-brainer.
{repeat for Mac Pro}
so again, Siegfried Marcus, Karl Benz, Gottlieb Daimler or Wilhelm Maybach didn't "invent" anything. they're as full of hot air as they have always been.
p.s.
the video of the fashionably-challenged, hideously bearded man hanging out in his mom's basement making YouTube videos about how insignificant he thinks others are has already been posted.
um, no. not his basement. nor do i care what you think. truth hurts:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wFeC25BM9E0
oh, and if that snarky response is the best you can muster, then i've either touched a nerve, or you've truly run out of legitimate rebuttle to what i posted. for what it's worth, if benz tried to patent the idea of putting 4 wheels on a car, the patent office should tell them to go fornicate themselves in the most expeditious manner possible. so thanks for proving my point; apple isn't DOING anything that's worth a legitimate patent. so again, their BS should get thrown out of court with extreme prejudice.
stealthify
11-07-2012, 07:37 PM
if benz tried to patent the idea of putting 4 wheels on a car, the patent office should tell them to go fornicate themselves in the most expeditious manner possible. so thanks for proving my point; apple isn't DOING anything that's worth a legitimate patent. so again, their BS should get thrown out of court with extreme prejudice.
Funny you mention that. Benz was actually award the patent for the "first engine" in 1879. A frickin' engine. Trains had those nearly 100 years earlier. Was internal combustion available before then 1879? Yes. But was it still a valuable innovation that pushed the transportation industry forward? Absolutely.
Then Benz went on to patent "the automobile." A simple object with multiple wheels, 2 seats, a carriage, and an engine. It's patent number 37435 (http://www.gizmag.com/the-birth-certificate-of-the-automobile-was-issued-125-years-ago-today/17725/), and is titled, simply, "vehicle powered by a gas engine." Sound as vague as patents you hear about today? Yeah, I guess everyone abuses the patent system -- even in the late 1800's. Using your thought process, all illegitimate patents. Insignificant. Unoriginal.
Guess anyone that has ever innovated should go "fornicate themselves." - IPD.
Funny you mention that. Benz was actually award the patent for the "first engine" in 1879. A frickin' engine. Trains had those nearly 100 years earlier. Was internal combustion available before then 1879? Yes. But was it still a valuable innovation that pushed the transportation industry forward? Absolutely.
Then Benz went on to patent "the automobile." A simple object with multiple wheels, 2 seats, a carriage, and an engine. It's patent number 37435 (http://www.gizmag.com/the-birth-certificate-of-the-automobile-was-issued-125-years-ago-today/17725/), and is titled, simply, "vehicle powered by a gas engine." Sound as vague as patents you hear about today? Yeah, I guess everyone abuses the patent system -- even in the late 1800's. Using your thought process, all illegitimate patents. Insignificant. Unoriginal.
Guess anyone that has ever innovated should go "fornicate themselves." - IPD.
You miss the point yet again. I'm beginning to think of you less-and-less like the "well-balanced, apple-user-by-choice" individual that you portend to be.
Let me break this down for you in parochial terms. Patents come in two variets: inventions (to cover functions) and designs. In theory, these are distinct branches. What has traditionally happened (and what is going on in the oingoing apple-wars) is the clash between these two separate categories. Now inventions (we'll just call functions henceforth, for simplicity) are unique modes of operation, new methods for completing a process, or something along those lines. Designs are purely cosmetic. The way patent law is supposed to operate is that a patent on a design cannot conflict with a patent on function. When such a conflict exists, function trumps design (or it should).
Now this doesn't present much of a problem if one patent holder owns patents on both the functions and design--overlap is irrelevant in this case. However, if there is a patent on function, then a competing product must offer a different method of functionality--even if the devices look similar. If there is a patent on design, then a competing product can use similar functionality--but needs to formulate a different design.
Here's where you have to pay attention. When the functions of a device are either open-source or not held in a patent--but the design of a device is seen as inherent to the basic functionality of a device--then a patent on design becomes illegitimate. For example, Benz could legitimately patent a new type of valving mechanism for an internal-combustion engine. It could NOT, however, patent the design of putting the engine bay in the front of a car.
Now let's take your beloved iPhone (or iPad, maxiPad, mini-mega-micro, whatever). Apple wants a patent on design.
Apple awarded design patent for actual rounded rectangle | Ars Technica (http://arstechnica.com/apple/2012/11/apple-awarded-design-patent-for-actual-rounded-rectangle/)
Why is this illegitimate? Let's examine. First, computing devices use a 16:9 or 16:10 aspect ratio; from this we deduce they will have displays of almost universally the same external dimensions (for any given size). Second, thick bezels have been have been unpopular and are rapidly disappearing from all variety of displays (this has been going on since people first started running dual-displays for their desktops. This makes sense, as the smaller the bezel, the smaller form a laptop or other portible device can have. Third, for any portible device, rounding the corners on the device makes it less cumbersome, (and less painful) when one carries it in a pocket. Though more prior-art exists, I'll point to the original Nintendo Gameboy as a classic example.
Fourth, due to human anatomy, phones have always had a long shape. In order to keep a 16:9 or 16:10 aspect ratio--yet keep phone-like functionality--logic dictates that any additions to the basic display should come on the long axis, as this will best mimic the "classic" shapes of existing phones (rather than transmute a smartphone into a rectangle). Fifth, the step between a smartphone and a tablet is an evolutionary one--not a revolutionary one. People familiar with existing smartphones would not want to transition to a tablet from the same manufacturer which has its button placement (and other features) in a completely different location. Sixth, also due to human anatomy, placing buttons at the bottom of a device makes more egonomic sense--and also eliminates the hand from blocking the display screen while using the device. Buttons at the bottom of the device has also been done on phones since the 80's. Seventh, the advent of the touchscreen (prior-art, I'll remind you) has eliminated the need for nearly all traditional "tactile" buttons on a touchscreen device.
How does Apple's design patent stack up in light of this? Not well. When you boil away all the existing prior art and factor in designs that are mandated by anatomy--there really isn't any room for patenting the design of what apple claims belongs solely to itself. In order to make a touchscreen phone, the particulars of design are largely dictated by function--functions which are prior-art or open-source. Insisting that competitors add gaudy buttons or bezel adornment to "differentiate" their devices is like insisting that GM put fins (ala 1950's) on all its cars in order to differentiate them from Ford.
This is a clear case of form/function coliding, and when that happens in patent law, form takes a back-seat. Cry about it all you want, but that's how it SHOULD be.
p.s.
DailyTech - Apple Looks to Ruin Google's Jelly Bean Party With More Lawsuits (http://www.dailytech.com/Apple+Looks+to+Ruin+Googles+Jelly+Bean+Party+With+ More+Lawsuits/article29136.htm)
DailyTech - Apple to Pay VirnetX $368 Million after Losing FaceTime Lawsuit (http://www.dailytech.com/Apple+to+Pay+VirnetX+368+Million+after+Losing+Face Time+Lawsuit/article29138.htm)
apple:
"we should pay you because you didn't invent this technology." the duplicity of logic is staggering.
stealthify
11-08-2012, 07:26 AM
I'm beginning to think of you less-and-less like the "well-balanced, apple-user-by-choice" individual that you portend to be.
I had no idea you felt this way about me to begin with. :glee: And all this time I thought you despised me.
:GroupHug:
Now let's take your beloved iPhone (or iPad, maxiPad, mini-mega-micro, whatever). Apple wants a patent on design.
Apple awarded design patent for actual rounded rectangle | Ars Technica (http://arstechnica.com/apple/2012/11/apple-awarded-design-patent-for-actual-rounded-rectangle/)
I couldn't find any obvious flaws in your explanation of design vs function patents. This is much of how I understand the system to work and granted, at times, the line between the two can be rather blurry.
Where I take issue is with the above quote, and perhaps this is where I think you and most Apple-haters miss the point. You cannot, I repeat, cannot patent a design for rounded rectangles alone. Ever. No one has done it, and that is NOT what Apple's has done with US Patent D670,286.
Rather, when it comes to design patents, there is an itemized list of design elements that add up to create the larger picture. What this means is; can Samsung, HTC, your mom still make portable devices in a rectangular shape? Yes. Can Samsung make a damn near replica of an iPad, down to the silver trim, screen bezel widths, button placements, port locations and whatever have you? No, and if you get too close to doing so, the court will strike you down.
In the case of the Galaxy Tab 10.1, Samsung got very close to being too close. That is what Apple took issue with. Samsung's main saving grace is that they made the backside different enough and made just enough exterior design tweaks to dodge the bullet from the jury. That is why this, or similar, design patents didn't end up holding up in court, while the other ones did.
Seeing as how this patent is bound to stir up so much controversy by the doomsayers, here's a perfect explanation of what this design patent is for (via CNET (http://asia.cnet.com/apple-wins-patent-on-a-rectangle-with-rounded-corners-62219397.htm)):
While it may seem overly broad, the patent is probably only useful against counterfeiters who copy the exact design of the iPad. None of Apple's competitors have products that are identical to the iPad. They may have rounded corners, but the aspect ratio, which could matter in a design patent, is usually different. They also may not have the flat front surface that's described in the patent.
Everything else you said about aspect ratio, bezel sizes, rounded corners, buttons being placed at the bottom of the device are all things that have become preferred, logical and obvious to us. Some of these elements go beyond design, and are now very much in the territory of function. But Apple's patent doesn't claim the rights to these functions either. You can make a tablet with the same aspect ratio, bezel sizes, rounded corners and a button on the bottom of the device, and STILL have it not look exactly like the iPad. Tweak enough, like Samsung did, and as the courts have shown, you'll be fine. Even if it's obvious you didn't spend a cent in R&D to try to come up with something more original against the competition.
So the day Apple truly starts a lawsuit over a rectangular shape alone, I will concede defeat and yield to your amazingness. Until then, it is very unlikely that this patent will see the light of day in court again unless we have someone else that is trying too hard to imitate the near-exact look and style of the iPad. We have and will continue to see many tablets that don't fit this criteria.
stealthify
11-08-2012, 07:36 AM
DailyTech - Apple to Pay VirnetX $368 Million after Losing FaceTime Lawsuit (http://www.dailytech.com/Apple+to+Pay+VirnetX+368+Million+after+Losing+Face Time+Lawsuit/article29138.htm)
I understand you want Apple to lose and all, but now you just made it clear you're rooting for the real patent trolls, which VirnetX is known to be.
i honestly don't care what virnetX is. what i do care about is the mixed-message apple sends; namely that what they accuse everyone else of doing doesn't apply when the tables are turned.
regarding patent design? what i continue to dislike about apple is the push for things like PRELIMINARY injunctions. apple has demonstrated a willingness to go for knee-jerk litigation. if i were a federal judge, i wouldn't even lift a finger to consider a preliminary injunction--apple's track-record clearly seems to suggest they intend the act as a weapon, not a legitimate defense of their business. if anything, their litigation should be relegated to damaged incurred, nothing more. how much and against which companies---i'll leave that to the real judges.
what i see, as i've explained, is product lines where form is dictated by function--and there's very, very little room to maneuver with differentiation. "case backs" as you say, being principle means. i happen to believe that samsung (and all others) shouldn't have to resort to makign their cases "hot pink" just so they are "different enough" from apple.
stealthify
11-08-2012, 08:46 AM
Okay. I didn't say anything about Samsung or others having to make their tablets "hot pink" to avoid a lawsuit. That's an exaggeration, and as I stated in my last post, the patent in question is likely only to protect Apple from counterfeiters that make exact duplicates. The images used in the patent are detailed enough to help support this, not to mention other high-profile, similarly designed tablets like the Surface aren't getting sued too.
As far as preliminary injunctions go, I wish I had a better answer for you. Unless I'm missing something, I think Apple would have more to gain if they didn't do a preliminary injunction, let the products hit the market, win the lawsuit, get a huge percentage of every infringing device sold, and then file an injunction. Perhaps Lawdogg or someone in the field could explain to us why preliminary injunctions are more beneficial to a company than exploiting the sale of a product from a manufacturer that refused to sign a licensing deal to begin with. I suppose we can speculate on this, but I, too, would like an official answer.
Okay. I didn't say anything about Samsung or others having to make their tablets "hot pink" to avoid a lawsuit. That's an exaggeration, and as I stated in my last post, the patent in question is likely only to protect Apple from counterfeiters that make exact duplicates. The images used in the patent are detailed enough to help support this, not to mention other high-profile, similarly designed tablets like the Surface aren't getting sued too.
As far as preliminary injunctions go, I wish I had a better answer for you. Unless I'm missing something, I think Apple would have more to gain if they didn't do a preliminary injunction, let the products hit the market, win the lawsuit, get a huge percentage of every infringing device sold, and then file an injunction. Perhaps Lawdogg or someone in the field could explain to us why preliminary injunctions are more beneficial to a company than exploiting the sale of a product from a manufacturer that refused to sign a licensing deal to begin with. I suppose we can speculate on this, but I, too, would like an official answer.
preliminary injunctions are rendered because the release of a product would "cause irreparable damage" to the solvency of a company. apple isn't in this condition. all that injunctions do is constrict market choices for the consumer. now if apple had invented cold-fusion and sought a preliminary injunction against competitors offering cold-fusion....THAT maybe i could understand. that's not what we have here, and i think the grounds for such an injunction is beyond reaching.
stealthify
11-08-2012, 11:45 AM
iPhone 6, now with cold-fusion technology.
I can see the headlines now.
:p
DailyTech - Report: Samsung Now Charging Apple 20% More for iPhone Processors (http://www.dailytech.com/Report+Samsung+Now+Charging+Apple+20+More+for+iPho ne+Processors/article29166.htm)
i love the top comment. "irony, thou art a heartless bitch".
1. 1B judgment against samsung for apple.
2. samsung charges 1B extra for goods it sells to apple
3. lulz
stealthify
11-13-2012, 04:29 AM
Samsung is always a few steps behind:
Apple rethinking Samsung chip partnership, say sources | Business Tech - CNET News (http://news.cnet.com/8301-1001_3-57531694-92/apple-rethinking-samsung-chip-partnership-say-sources/)
Even going back to 2011:
Apple moving away from Samsung memory components | TUAW - The Unofficial Apple Weblog (http://www.tuaw.com/2011/09/22/apple-moving-away-from-samsung-memory-components/)
It wasn't a relationship that was meant to last.
of course it's not going to last. i think everyone is aware of that. might as well fleece them while you've got them--they certainly aren't doing you any favors in return.
p.s.
i maintain moving away from mainstream chips is going to hurt apple's marketshare.
stealthify
11-13-2012, 06:19 AM
they certainly aren't doing you any favors in return.
The same can certainly be said about Samsung. With so much conflicting interests going on between these two companies I'm honestly surprised Apple didn't invest its boatloads of cash to transition away sooner.
As far as moving away from mainstream chips hurting Apple's marketshare; it'll be really interested to see what comes of this. If Apple falls behind and is no longer able to keep up with the speed and efficiency of the mainstream chips... we'll have a problem on our hands. If, by some miracle, Apple is able to do something with their own chips that the competition can't easily match, this could be great for Apple. Guess we'll see.
The same can certainly be said about Samsung. With so much conflicting interests going on between these two companies I'm honestly surprised Apple didn't invest its boatloads of cash to transition away sooner.
As far as moving away from mainstream chips hurting Apple's marketshare; it'll be really interested to see what comes of this. If Apple falls behind and is no longer able to keep up with the speed and efficiency of the mainstream chips... we'll have a problem on our hands. If, by some miracle, Apple is able to do something with their own chips that the competition can't easily match, this could be great for Apple. Guess we'll see.
it didn't go well for them before switching to intel. i'll say that much.
stealthify
11-13-2012, 08:31 AM
Definitely not looking forward to another PowerPC era.
NickS VR4
11-14-2012, 06:25 PM
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FT7K_429YWc
there's no resolution to that! should have at least had an ipad mini going down in a ball of flames as it crashed into the "death star" (i.e. steve job's ass). :D
stealthify
11-15-2012, 02:00 PM
The casting for the Nokia was superb. :p :)
lawdogg
11-24-2012, 09:59 PM
Here's a great read for those interested. David Kappos (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/David_Kappos), Director of the PTO, gave a great Keynote Address to the Center for American Progress, covering many things but spending a decent amount of time on software patents. It's nicely objective, but it also responds to criticism without sounding too defensive.
An Examination of Software Patents (http://www.uspto.gov/news/speeches/2012/kappos_CAP.jsp)
And my favorite line:
It’s time for the patent system to man up.
stealthify
11-25-2012, 01:27 AM
An Examination of Software Patents (http://www.uspto.gov/news/speeches/2012/kappos_CAP.jsp)
Interesting read, and nice to hear it directly from the horse's mouth.
It seems they understand the complications and complexity that comes with software patents, and it's nice to see that they believe in pushing for improved quality throughout the system. The message appears to be directly aimed at those that have little faith in the system because they only read the glorified headlines.
One argument he makes:
But it’s important to note that, during the so-called smartphone patent wars, innovation continues at breakneck pace. A system like ours, in which innovation is happening faster than consumers can keep up, cannot fairly be characterized as “broken”. Nor can it be said that the U.S. is just a receiver of all this innovation. Most of the innovation is taking place right here.
Is a good point. While our patent system isn't perfect, I certainly don't desire any other country's setup. Hopefully things continue to improve right here at home.
Interesting read, and nice to hear it directly from the horse's mouth.
It seems they understand the complications and complexity that comes with software patents, and it's nice to see that they believe in pushing for improved quality throughout the system. The message appears to be directly aimed at those that have little faith in the system because they only read the glorified headlines.
One argument he makes:
Is a good point. While our patent system isn't perfect, I certainly don't desire any other country's setup. Hopefully things continue to improve right here at home.
replace "patent system" with government system" and it still holds true.
lawdogg
11-26-2012, 05:09 PM
Patent Wars Video
LOL! That's awesome!
At Chicago-Kent, our IPLS has hosted two discussions called "Patent Wars" ... we had some promotional material made in a similar vein:
https://lh5.googleusercontent.com/-2zavLX17PrQ/ULPZLMBpFOI/AAAAAAAADx0/LKV8htTwm84/s800/IMAG0611.jpg
stealthify
11-26-2012, 06:50 PM
https://lh5.googleusercontent.com/-2zavLX17PrQ/ULPZLMBpFOI/AAAAAAAADx0/LKV8htTwm84/s800/IMAG0611.jpg
I'd watch these movies :D
stealthee
12-14-2012, 02:13 PM
Apple iPhone found to infringe on three MobileMedia patents in US court (http://www.engadget.com/2012/12/13/apple-iphone-found-to-infringe-on-three-mobilemedia-patents/?icid=maing-grid7%7Cmain5%7Cdl32%7Csec3_lnk1%26pLid%3D245501)
Powered by vBulletin® Version 4.2.3 Copyright © 2026 vBulletin Solutions, Inc. All rights reserved.