PDA

View Full Version : Suspect with a Crowbar is Shot Outside a Carls Jr



Vantage
01-24-2012, 03:26 PM
After a 2nd viewing, there's a couple loud F bombs that get dropped when the perp gets shot, that I didn't pick up on the first time. Be advised.


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=05ts-0WnRyE

FeaRpb
01-24-2012, 03:34 PM
I call that excessive use of force.

MaelstromOC
01-24-2012, 03:57 PM
Yeah, they shot at him 10 times! That's ridiculous from what I can see just in this video. Dude had a stick/crowbar/something and just acted like he was going to hit the cop (I'm sure he intended to) but shooting him 10 times point blank, really?!?

Vantage
01-24-2012, 04:05 PM
He had already been hit with mace and a taser(apparently pulled the prongs out) so he was probably high on something crazy. I would think cops, like the military, are trained to shoot to kill, not wound. Also, both officers fired exactly 5 shots, which could be part of their training as well.

Zaroth
01-24-2012, 04:11 PM
While I don't think they needed to shoot him in that situation, if a cop starts shooting they don't stop till the job is done. If they have decided lethal force is necessary... they are going to make sure its lethal. I have heard of guys that were doped up taking as many as 10 9mm center mass and still fighting for a while.

MaelstromOC
01-24-2012, 05:00 PM
Even still, there is nothing more valuable you can take from a person than their life, it's just something I do not agree with doing. I know many will disagree with me on that (and yes, I know there are plenty of people the world is better off without) but I just don't think it's a decision for us to make (I am not religious either, so it has nothing to do with a supreme being's judgement either.) It may just be that I put a higher value on life than others though, I don't know.

NickS VR4
01-24-2012, 05:26 PM
Using a gun is deadly force, when deadly force is needed, it is by definition "deadly". There is no shooting to wound. It's the guys fault. If you look right before shots were fired, the guy looked like he was gonna swing that crowbar, and the partner was securing the mace, and wouldn't be able to defend himself at that moment. Deadly force was justified IMO.

AdamVR4
01-24-2012, 05:31 PM
A crowbar to the head is deadly force, too, fellas. I'm siding with the cops on this until I see something else.

TonyM
01-24-2012, 05:37 PM
A crowbar to the head is deadly force, too, fellas. I'm siding with the cops on this until I see something else.

Same here. Like the recent story in south Texas about the cops shooting a middle school kid who refused to put down his airsoft gun. The cops don't know what they don't know and if you're dumb enough to ignore police directions to comply . . . well we all know what happens.

FeaRpb
01-24-2012, 05:48 PM
They could have atleast beat him with their metal rod. Have some awesome 1hb vs 1hb

UTRacerX9
01-24-2012, 06:07 PM
The first cop shot him 5 times, after the suspect was about to swing the crowbar. Ok... I wouldn't have fired 5 times, he went down after the first or second, but the act of firing the gun seems justified.

The second officer though, he shoots the guy 5 times when the suspect is already on the ground. THAT is definitely excessive force.

AgentOblivious
01-24-2012, 07:19 PM
Looks triggerhappy. Also, did that taser malfunction?

green-lantern
01-24-2012, 07:45 PM
Looks triggerhappy. Also, did that taser malfunction?

What I was wondering

Guy looked like he was holding a conduit bender. This guy is so fucking stupid it might be best they shot him dead before he had kids....or more kids. Makes me sick the guys filming are laughing. Makes me sick this is our society.

NickS VR4
01-24-2012, 08:02 PM
For those that say 5 shots is excessive.... you shoot until the target goes down. If you shoot once, check to see if it worked, then shoot again, and check again, you will be behind the curve.

MeTarzan
01-24-2012, 08:06 PM
Guy looked like he was holding a conduit bender.

That is really what it looked like and I would say that if he didnt flinch after getting shot in the face with a taser he was high on something. To add to that the fact that the officer decided to fire on the subject instead of releasing his dog on him means he would have been worried that the subject wouldnt have been able to be subdued by that and possibly harm the dog. But 5 shots each was deff a bit much Double tap was all that should have been needed to take him to the ground

onebadmollafolla
01-24-2012, 08:26 PM
A crowbar to the head is deadly force, too, fellas. I'm siding with the cops on this until I see something else.

The perp definitely showed intent of coming to harm the officer with a deadly weapon (a crow bar). Cop had every right to shoot him. As has been said, you don't shoot to wound. You shoot to stop the threatening person/s as quickly as possibly, which happens to be by vital shots. As far as the crow bar goes, one swing with that thing can easily kill a person.

CoopKill
01-24-2012, 09:00 PM
100% totally justified on both cops part.

I have 3 cops in my extended family, and when someone threatens deadly force, you shoot til they move no more.

Beside half the forces in the country mandate 9mm weapons which is not all that great at stopping with one shot. 45cal, different story.


The guy belongs where he is...

stealthee
01-24-2012, 09:05 PM
If I were carrying and someone posed a threat to me I am not going to shoot just once, I am going to empty the damn magazine.

AgentOblivious
01-24-2012, 09:24 PM
Whatever happened to batons? You'd think the three of them could subdue him otherwise...cokeheads think they're superman, but they aren't.

eljefefx
01-24-2012, 09:30 PM
Whatever happened to batons? You'd think the three of them could subdue him otherwise...cokeheads think they're superman, but they aren't.

Easy to say after the fact. A person comes to me with a weapon drawn and I have a firearm in my hand I am not going to step back and return my weapon to the holster to retrieve a LTL device.

Aim for center mass.

onebadmollafolla
01-24-2012, 09:33 PM
Easy to say after the fact. A person comes to me with a weapon drawn and I have a firearm in my hand I am not going to step back and return my weapon to the holster to retrieve a LTL device.

Aim for center mass.

Hold on. You're saying you'd rather fight a person that has a steel crow bar with a gun rather than a baton?! Madness! :lol:

ToMiTo
01-24-2012, 09:41 PM
The shooting of the first official was justified, the second, not so much, that person was on the ground when the second official started shooting; a bullet on the knee could have stopped him as well.

Vantage
01-24-2012, 09:43 PM
For those that can't see, he is still standing up behind the car after the initial 5 shots.

AgentOblivious
01-24-2012, 10:14 PM
Hold on. You're saying you'd rather fight a person that has a steel crow bar with a gun rather than a baton?! Madness! :lol:

Three guys (who should have proper training) with batons,tasers,mace,guns, and who knows what else should have been able to take down one cokehead with a crowbar. If all he had was a crowbar, and I had 2 other people to back me up, I'd give the baton a try first. Mind you I work in retail, and we get more than our share of crazy (ie someone purposely hitting me with his car in the parking lot, having someone's wife/gf run inside for a manager because she thought her man was going to fight me over a propane tank, cars getting bricked, etc.)

Guess who usually gets called to deal with the crazies...

stealthee
01-24-2012, 10:40 PM
Easy to say after the fact. A person comes to me with a weapon drawn and I have a firearm in my hand I am not going to step back and return my weapon to the holster to retrieve a LTL device.

Aim for center mass.

Since you quoted AO and I had to read his drivel I will just quote you.

Apparently AO has never had to deal with a coke head. There is a guy who I went to school with who was all coked out and took a beating and half and didn't flinch. He started some shit with a group of people and they absolutely pummelled him and he kept coming back for more. A few whacks with a baton isn't going to do shit to a coke head.

CoopKill
01-24-2012, 10:44 PM
Watch a couple vids of someone fighting the law on PCP, your mind with change to POP POP POP, and done...

Danube_3KGT
01-24-2012, 11:03 PM
It may be because I work in law enforcement but I can barely watch videos like this anymore just because of what people will say on them. The guy was wielding a weapon that would have easily killed someone if he had struck them in the head,defiantly if he did it multiple times. In law enforcement the rule says that the officer is to use 1 stage above what the suspect is, so for instance if the suspect is punching at them they can use less than lethal force (taser or mace). The only time that officers are allowed to use lethal force is when their in lethal danger. No cop wants to kill someone like that, and I have seen how it effects people who had to right to. Anyone who can sit here and say something like "I think they should have used batons at least, I mean I wouldn't have shot him." has never been in the position. I have fought people on PCP, Meth, Xanax, ect. and It doesn't matter how small or big they are, or how many guys are on your side its never "easy." Thumbs up to the K-9 officer who helped his partner and I hope he was able to deal with it afterward.

Boomer3000
01-24-2012, 11:26 PM
I will add my 2 cents.

The officers were justified in the actions they took to defend each other. The kids in the car need to be beaten by their parents, and as for the Super man comment by AO.

They aren't super man no, but on any type of drug like that they are deff stronger. Its like people who get an adrenaline rush and can move twice their body weight and more. Its the endorphines(sp?) that are released for the drug.

Valhallaz
01-24-2012, 11:50 PM
Jeff Cooper tells a story about an indian tanked on PCP that came at him with a hatchet one night. He emptied his 45 into the guys torso, and STILL had to wrestle him to the ground while avoiding the hatchet. The officers acted appropriately.

A man comes at me with a screwdriver while I'm carrying, he gets at least 2 10mm center of the chest. 9mm, I'd empty the clip.

Alex3000gt
01-24-2012, 11:59 PM
I am not going to pretend to know what it is like to be in that situation.

$$$PIT
01-25-2012, 12:11 AM
Three guys (who should have proper training) with batons,tasers,mace,guns, and who knows what else should have been able to take down one cokehead with a crowbar. If all he had was a crowbar, and I had 2 other people to back me up, I'd give the baton a try first. Mind you I work in retail, and we get more than our share of crazy (ie someone purposely hitting me with his car in the parking lot, having someone's wife/gf run inside for a manager because she thought her man was going to fight me over a propane tank, cars getting bricked, etc.)

Guess who usually gets called to deal with the crazies...

I AM retired Law Enforcement and during my yrs I saw several officers almost killed because they attempted to stop a suspect high on everything from PCP,Meth and paint huffers. The reason they almost got killed was they tried to use a BATON! Even an unarmed man can take a good beating with a baton and keep coming. I've seen it.
We are trained to access the threat. IF they are unarmed you can try your baton. But, if they get control of you, they get control of your weapon. So, if there's ANY doubt of the suspects impairment, you got to the next level. That is your sidearm.
Some of you won't like what I'm about to say, but you can kiss my ass. MY main goal EVERY day was to go home alive. We don't fight fair. If you bring a stick or a knife, WE SHOOT YOU. PERIOD. If you bring a gun, we bring a bigger gun/guns. We will always have the right to be the next level ahead of the suspect. So, until you've been there and done that, your opinions mean SHIT.

AgentOblivious
01-25-2012, 01:08 AM
Fair enough Monepit. I don't blame you for caring about your own safety. I'm just saying what I would do.

As for drug use, very rarely do I have to deal with people high out of their minds (some people like to get high and go shopping), or schizophrenics/people with mental issues (had a guy once that had written all over himself with sharpies and was running around the store screaming how jesus was out to get him), so I'd say you have a much better understanding of it than I do. I think overall, that situation could have gone better.

$$$PIT
01-25-2012, 03:57 AM
I don't know the national numbers, but in my experience, I'd say 80% of our calls involved people impaired by alcohol or drugs. That's why I say that until you've done the job for years, you have no idea what you would do in that situation. Most officers killed in the line of duty "let their guard down" for just a moment and it costs them their life. Most of the time, we DON'T deal with "normal" people. You HAVE TO think that EVERY person you meet could try to kill you. That's how you stay alive to go home everyday. It may seem sad or extreme. But that's how you stay alive for 20 yrs.

Danube_3KGT
01-25-2012, 09:25 AM
Thanks for adding that Randy. Basically anyone who says that they would just fight a guy who was trying to hit them with a crowbar is full of shit in my opinion. I hope I would have the guts to shoot that guy like the officer did.

On a side note is that a crowbar? It almost looks kind of like an axe to me..

bluefox1081
01-25-2012, 11:30 AM
Looks like a pipe-bender.

And I agree with the officers. If you commit a crime and can see that there are LEOs with weapons drawn, and you make an attempt to attack one of them with a deadly weapon...well, you get whatever's coming to you.

j2k4
01-25-2012, 11:55 AM
I never had the idea that it was a good idea to take on a cop in any circumstance - I reckon I would if I thought I were about to be executed by a lone wolf, but even a cop who may be a bit more forceful than necessary will get my respect, because that's the way the shit is supposed to work - minor quibbles can be addressed later on.

If an offender is so totally out-of-it that he doesn't realize who he is threatening, he doesn't (can't, actually) escape responsibility for his actions.

As for cops, the badge is the substitute for the stickers that usually say something like "Don't stick your hand in the fan, you dumbshit".

It will never keep an idiot or his family from filing suit, anyway, but there you have it.

Don't stick your hand in the garbage disposal, and don't choose off the cops - odds are never going to be with you either way.

And yes, it looks like a pipe-bender.

AgentOblivious
01-25-2012, 02:08 PM
Just a question for LEOs/former LEOs: How much training do/did you guys get in talking people down, vs. range time? I'm curious now.

j2k4
01-25-2012, 03:40 PM
Just a question for LEOs/former LEOs: How much training do/did you guys get in talking people down, vs. range time? I'm curious now.

You should be curious more often.

I'll add another question:

How much time did you "LEOs" get to practice physical management and other non-lethal techniques against drug-addled mental patients?

ictponder
01-25-2012, 04:14 PM
It almost looks like the perp was pretending like he was going to take a swing (maybe to scare the cops) but who knows. These two cops were fully justified IMO

AgentOblivious
01-25-2012, 05:03 PM
It almost looks like the perp was pretending like he was going to take a swing (maybe to scare the cops) but who knows. These two cops were fully justified IMO

That's what I thought too, looks similar to what black bears do, which is to charge right up to your face...then again that's a call you don't want to get wrong.

j2k4
01-25-2012, 05:28 PM
It almost looks like the perp was pretending like he was going to take a swing (maybe to scare the cops) but who knows. These two cops were fully justified IMO

Keep 'em coming, Isaac - I haven't seen him tap-dance like this...


That's what I thought too, looks similar to what black bears do, which is to charge right up to your face...then again that's a call you don't want to get wrong.

...uh...since, well, since his last post, actually. :huh:

AO...don't EVER go away. :)

j2k4
01-25-2012, 05:42 PM
AO...don't EVER go away. :)

And I mean that sincerely.

The US needs you, son. :wink: