PDA

View Full Version : Cool vid of F-35 carrier testing.



93STLTH
01-14-2012, 11:04 PM
I didn't realize they were that far along in the VSTOL version of the F-35. Cool stuff!!


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ki86x1WKPmE

TT4ME
01-14-2012, 11:55 PM
Awesome!!

nodoze
01-15-2012, 12:36 AM
if it can land vertically why can it not take off vertically? i see the take off speeds are much slower than other jets allowing for less runway needed . Maybe its and obvious answer but regardless idk

aaronatstate
01-15-2012, 12:49 AM
if it can land vertically why can it not take off vertically? i see the take off speeds are much slower than other jets allowing for less runway needed . Maybe its and obvious answer but regardless idk

It can take off vertically if it has too. But my guess is it can take off at a higher weight if it doesn't take off vertically.

There are 3 versions of the F35, the A, B, and C. The A is a conventional take off and landing jet for the Air Force. The B is a VSTOL to replace the Harrier Jump Jet for the Marines. The C is for the Navy and is designed for carrier operations.

AgentOblivious
01-15-2012, 01:52 AM
This far along? The X-35 demonstrated STOVL back in 2001. I don't think it can do a vertical takeoff...and wasn't meant to in any reasonable combat situation, hence Short Takeoff...its impressive, even if its a mix of american and soviet tech from 30 years ago, and some trick code on the onboard computers.

aaronatstate
01-15-2012, 11:30 AM
This far along? The X-35 demonstrated STOVL back in 2001. I don't think it can do a vertical takeoff...and wasn't meant to in any reasonable combat situation, hence Short Takeoff...its impressive, even if its a mix of american and soviet tech from 30 years ago, and some trick code on the onboard computers.

It can take off vertically, if it has the ability to land vertically. If just can't take off vertically if it is loaded to heavily.

IPD
01-15-2012, 12:07 PM
it's STOVL. that's Short Take Off, Vertical Land. it was never designed to take off vertically--and even if it does, it's usefulness would be severely hampered (i.e. no bombs, no gas). besides, it doesn't NEED to take off vertically. it just needs a compressed space within which to launch.

whitedragon
01-15-2012, 01:08 PM
This far along? The X-35 demonstrated STOVL back in 2001.

The F-35 has been plagued with delay after delay for sure, but they keep throwing money at it.

Mikes2nd
01-15-2012, 03:34 PM
for a low low price of 300 million a piece! Wowser! Seriously can we have ferrari build these? It would be ALOT cheaper

And its junk


The Helmet mounted display system does not work properly.
The fuel dump subsystem poses a fire hazard.
The Integrated Power Package is unreliable and difficult to service.
The F-35C's arresting hook does not work.
There are classified "survivability issues", which have been speculated to be about stealth.[101]
The wing buffet is worse than previously reported.
The airframe is unlikely to last through the required lifespan.
The flight test program has yet to explore the most challenging areas.
The software development is behind schedule.
The aircraft is in danger of going overweight or, for the F-35B, too nose-heavy for VTOL operations.
There are multiple thermal management problems. The air conditioner fails to keep the pilot and controls cool enough, the roll posts on the F-35B overheat, and using the afterburner damages the aircraft.
The automated logistics system does not work properly.
And the lightning protection on the F-35 Lightning II is uncertified, with areas of concern.


Those houses in Virginia cost alot... this is the "most expensive military project in history"...


Cost estimates have risen to $382 billion for 2,443 aircraft, at an average of $156 million each. The rising program cost estimates have cast doubt on the actual number to be produced for the U.S. In January 2011, the F-35B variant was placed on "probation" for two years because of development problems. In February 2011, the Pentagon put a price of $207.6 million for each of the 32 aircraft to be acquired in FY2012, rising to $304.15 million ($9,732.8/32) if its share of RDT&E spending is included.[15][16]

where is Ron Paul when you need him?

IPD
01-15-2012, 03:40 PM
for a low low price of 135 million a piece! Wowser!

And its junk




Those houses in Virginia cost alot... this is the "most expensive military project in history"...



where is Ron Paul when you need him?

speculatoin, bs, etc. every time you hear of a "price figure", no one ever actually specifies what it specifically entails. sure they break it down on a "per unit" basis...but what exactly does that entail? raw manufacturing cost? annual operating costs? airframe projected lifetime service costs? (i don't remember the exact terminology, but you get the gist).

and yet...even IF there was grounds to balk at the costs of this program, what...pray tell...is our alternative? more 4th gen fighters that are already out of production and handily demonstrated to be woefully incapable for future combat? keep our current crop of fighters that have long since exceeded their design service life....in combat? repel the enemy with sticks and bottle rockets?

anyonebutme
01-15-2012, 03:48 PM
speculatoin, bs, etc. every time you hear of a "price figure", no one ever actually specifies what it specifically entails. sure they break it down on a "per unit" basis...but what exactly does that entail? raw manufacturing cost? annual operating costs? airframe projected lifetime service costs? (i don't remember the exact terminology, but you get the gist).

and yet...even IF there was grounds to balk at the costs of this program, what...pray tell...is our alternative? more 4th gen fighters that are already out of production and handily demonstrated to be woefully incapable for future combat? keep our current crop of fighters that have long since exceeded their design service life....in combat? repel the enemy with sticks and bottle rockets?

All we need is an updated F-15, and we are set.

Maybe start buying export SU37's?

whitedragon
01-15-2012, 04:53 PM
speculatoin, bs, etc. every time you hear of a "price figure", no one ever actually specifies what it specifically entails. sure they break it down on a "per unit" basis...but what exactly does that entail? raw manufacturing cost? annual operating costs? airframe projected lifetime service costs? (i don't remember the exact terminology, but you get the gist).

and yet...even IF there was grounds to balk at the costs of this program, what...pray tell...is our alternative? more 4th gen fighters that are already out of production and handily demonstrated to be woefully incapable for future combat? keep our current crop of fighters that have long since exceeded their design service life....in combat? repel the enemy with sticks and bottle rockets?

First of all, you have no idea what you're talking about in terms of "cost".

Second, I'm not sure what you mean by "out of production" fighters right now. I'm not privy to Lockheed's delivery information, but I know they are going strong building F-16's that are for the USAF (as well as our foreign allies), and the F-18 is in production on a multi-year procurement through 2014 for the USN. The F-15 is not in production for the USAF, but F-15's are being built as we speak for Korea, Singapore and Saudi Arabia, making a new buy for the USAF particularly attractive.

Also, every single one of these aircraft is fully supported with upgrades, retrofits and service life extensions by a veritable army of industry and government manufacturers, engineers and support folks to keep them in the air and keep them deadly. None of these programs is nearing the end of their lifetime anytime soon, and each have proven battle records.

While it's true that we need to continually innovate and produce new things, but we also need to meet our requirements, schedule and cost. McDonnell Douglas and Northrup Grumman were held accountable for the A-12, so the question is why does Lockheed get a pass for the F-35?

IPD
01-15-2012, 06:25 PM
First of all, you have no idea what you're talking about in terms of "cost".

Second, I'm not sure what you mean by "out of production" fighters right now. I'm not privy to Lockheed's delivery information, but I know they are going strong building F-16's that are for the USAF (as well as our foreign allies), and the F-18 is in production on a multi-year procurement through 2014 for the USN. The F-15 is not in production for the USAF, but F-15's are being built as we speak for Korea, Singapore and Saudi Arabia, making a new buy for the USAF particularly attractive.

Also, every single one of these aircraft is fully supported with upgrades, retrofits and service life extensions by a veritable army of industry and government manufacturers, engineers and support folks to keep them in the air and keep them deadly. None of these programs is nearing the end of their lifetime anytime soon, and each have proven battle records.

While it's true that we need to continually innovate and produce new things, but we also need to meet our requirements, schedule and cost. McDonnell Douglas and Northrup Grumman were held accountable for the A-12, so the question is why does Lockheed get a pass for the F-35?

part of the problem is that we've bankrupted the bulk of defense contracting. 60 years ago, we had about a dozen major contractors for jets. now we have essentially 2. that kind of market hegemony means that we end up paying higher costs.

ftr, f-18's aren't in production. SUPER hornets, yes...but not legacy ones. that's one of the reasons why the navy's legacy hornets are literally having their wings flown off. f16's? sure, but again, you're talking a retrofit of a retrofit of a retrofit. the f16 was a great fighter when it was designed in 1974. i'll remind our our casual readers that 1974 was back before even 5.25" floppy drives were even in use. consider if you will your average passenger car from 1974, and one from 2012 (nearly 40 years later). a LOT has changed with technology. now of course you can put electronic fuel injection, flashable ECU and a host of other gizmo's into a 74 chevelle....but it still lacks the FORM that is made possible by 40 years of advances.

now if we were merely talking about a bomb truck to replace the ancient b52...that'd be a no-brainer. a bomb truck doesn't need stealth, flashiness, speed, or maneuverability. it primarily needs to be fuel efficient, durable, survivable, able to withstand decades upon decades of use, and have an adequate payload. that's a relatively easy billet to fill (at least compared to other procurement programs). but the f35 (like the 16's and 18's it will replace) is not merely a bomb truck: it also needs a capable air-air performance. the f16 was the ticket back in '74 when the mig-21 was still the primary threat. in the 21st century, the primary air-air threat isn't even a mig-29; it's probably a su-30mkk. the f16 was sized about the same as a mig-21; both are significantly smaller than a f15 or especially a su-27/30. anyone who has studied the combat simulation analysis done by the DOD should be aware of the relative kill ratios of any given blue airframe against another given red airframe. even the f15c is projected to have a .8:1 kill ratio against something like a su-30mkk. the 16's would be bantha fodder. worse, i've already SEEN with my own two eyes what a 5th gen fighter can do against 16's (block 40/50's). it's rather disgusting actually.

again though, we don't need super hornets or eagles. we need a smaller, multi-role fighter to replace the 16/18's that have previously performed the same role. yes that would rule out flanker's entirely (not to mention the absurd idea of defending ourselves with a red system). now if we hadn't axed the f22, then MAYBE we could afford not to worry so much about multi-role...because we'd have enough air superiority fighters to package with every use of multi-role fighters. but since congress in its infinite wisdom kept hammering on the USAF until the production run eventually dwindled from nearly 400 to under 200 total frames...that's just not a possibility.

i fully expect that the old joke about the USAF eventually having only 1 airplane in the entire force....will eventually come true.

AgentOblivious
01-15-2012, 08:31 PM
Anyone else think the US needs another f-15 type project, where instead of trying to shove everything into one package vis a vis "engineering" solutions (a.k.a. tack on capability that represents a compromise on the structure, a.k.a. every odd angled aerofoil on the Phantom), and instead design a package that's meant to fly very, very well on its own. I always thought that was funny that the f-15 was the first american fighter designed to handle well, as opposed to simply going faster.

Trevor
01-15-2012, 09:25 PM
worse, i've already SEEN with my own two eyes what a 5th gen fighter can do against 16's (block 40/50's). it's rather disgusting actually.
Yep...to put it into car terms it's kinda like this:
http://cdn3.worldcarfans.co/2011/9/29/medium/14348980761118358212.jpg
vs this:
http://okinawa.j-kj.com/600_skyline13.JPG

anyonebutme
01-15-2012, 09:38 PM
We don't need a small number of great jets, just need shitloads of OK jets with decent ordinance. Ask Israel. Import a bunch of 29's and teach more to fly seems like a better solution from a cost perspective to me.


Russia is totally our friend now, right?

NickS VR4
01-15-2012, 10:00 PM
We don't need a small number of great jets, just need shitloads of OK jets with decent ordinance. Ask Israel. Import a bunch of 29's and teach more to fly seems like a better solution from a cost perspective to me.


Russia is totally our friend now, right?

Or a few really good jets and a bunch of cheap UAVs. Pretty sure that's the current plan.

Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Tapatalk

IPD
01-15-2012, 11:33 PM
We don't need a small number of great jets, just need shitloads of OK jets with decent ordinance. Ask Israel. Import a bunch of 29's and teach more to fly seems like a better solution from a cost perspective to me.


Russia is totally our friend now, right?

are you going to be the one to convince the american public that we don't need to put a premium on US lives? that we don't want the latest & greatest for our servicemembers? that lives are expendable because we opted to "cheap out" on national defense so that joe blow who bought a house that someone with 3x his income should be buying--can be bailed out of his mortgage?

AgentOblivious
01-15-2012, 11:41 PM
are you going to be the one to convince the american public that we don't need to put a premium on US lives? that we don't want the latest & greatest for our servicemembers? that lives are expendable because we opted to "cheap out" on national defense so that joe blow who bought a house that someone with 3x his income should be buying--can be bailed out of his mortgage?

Expensive birds =/ latest and greatest. There have been plenty of very expensive, slick aircrafts that turned out to be turds that cost servicemembers their lives. Its especially unnerving that the Canadian government seems to be the only ones not worried about whether it'll live up to hype without breaking the bank...mind you, the Cons also have a problem with things like science and statistics, so...

anyonebutme
01-16-2012, 01:30 AM
are you going to be the one to convince the american public that we don't need to put a premium on US lives? that we don't want the latest & greatest for our servicemembers? that lives are expendable because we opted to "cheap out" on national defense so that joe blow who bought a house that someone with 3x his income should be buying--can be bailed out of his mortgage?

You're on the ground facing an enemy column, what would you rather have overhead? An upgraded A-10 or an F-35? Be honest.


I can give you a list of service men and women who will tell you just what our armed forces need right now, and none of them will tell you the JSF.

IPD
01-16-2012, 09:50 AM
You're on the ground facing an enemy column, what would you rather have overhead? An upgraded A-10 or an F-35? Be honest.


I can give you a list of service men and women who will tell you just what our armed forces need right now, and none of them will tell you the JSF.

regardless of the hot air that congress is pushing about replacing the a-10 with the f-35...that'll never happen. so let's keep this an apples to apples comparison. f-35 vs. the f-16 and legacy f-18's they were designed to replace. and frankly, the biggest debacle of the whole contract has been the b-models; which are actually designed to replace the harrier (which at this point are so freakishly old that they're decrepit).

now i'll agree that the entire project has been a giant charlie-foxtrot and that the cost overruns are abhorrent. that said, i stlil maintain that our alternatives offer substantially LESS performance for marginally less money. furthermore, scrapping the program to build another is even more ridiculously costly.

eljefefx
01-16-2012, 04:05 PM
God we don't need this bird.

IPD
01-16-2012, 05:22 PM
God we don't need this bird.

and what's your solution, jeff? just super hornets? i'd be ok with that. the USAF still needs it though, imho.

aaronatstate
01-16-2012, 09:37 PM
and what's your solution, jeff? just super hornets? i'd be ok with that. the USAF still needs it though, imho.

F22 not good enough?

Mikes2nd
01-16-2012, 11:22 PM
and what's your solution, jeff? just super hornets? i'd be ok with that. the USAF still needs it though, imho.

big issues with the F35 still... its going to call another 100 billion just to fix it.

zelstin
01-16-2012, 11:40 PM
are you going to be the one to convince the american public that we don't need to put a premium on US lives? that we don't want the latest & greatest for our servicemembers? that lives are expendable because we opted to "cheap out" on national defense so that joe blow who bought a house that someone with 3x his income should be buying--can be bailed out of his mortgage?

Does the "latest & greatest" include bulletproof vests?

IPD
01-16-2012, 11:53 PM
F22 not good enough?

oh i'd LOVE to have a shitton more f22's. it'd be much simpler, and we could invest more heavily in an evolution of the f22 to replace the strike eagle. problem is, someone already killed off that line. at a MINIMUM, the usaf needs an true air-superiority fighter. if it comes with a capable multi-role function as well...that's great. if not, then it needs a supplemental multi-role fighter as a workhorse.

now my personal idea was to simply create an f22 of sorts, and then have an "entry level" model that was far cheaper to make and had less bells and whistles. no stealth paint, no thrust vectoring, wing hardpoints, limited internal stores, etc. while it wouldn't reduce cost to the 50M range that some pundits have wet dreams for...it could probably drop the cost to the 90M range or so. the secret to cost effectiveness in defense contracting is NUMBERS. if you're going to get the costs down to a healthy level, you need to build sufficient quantities--but not more than is required.

don't get me wrong, i think the LWF idea is valid (or at least was), but i also think the reality is that a stripped-down raptor makes an effective tactical air-strike asset--and the fewer types of airframes we have, the shorter our logistics supply chain is--and subsequently, the more cost effective everything becomes.

it's the same reason why i think the uh-60 and the ah-1 need to die. i firmly believe the y-model hueys and z-model cobras are every bit up to the task, and the commonality between those platforms behooves our logistics. until and unless the army either adopts these two platforms (or adopts similar platforms with shared commonality) we're going to be bleeding unnecessary cash. and i'm not even asking for the marines and army to use the same helos....i'd be nice if the army could just find a blackhawk and apache that had the same 80% shared parts of the huey and cobra--regardless if they actually were swappable with marine helo parts.

IPD
01-16-2012, 11:54 PM
Does the "latest & greatest" include bulletproof vests?

what's your point/what's your question? the USA has a palatable aversion to the death of its citizens at the hands of foreigners. do you deny this?

whitedragon
01-17-2012, 09:51 AM
now my personal idea was to simply create an f22 of sorts, and then have an "entry level" model that was far cheaper to make and had less bells and whistles. no stealth paint, no thrust vectoring, wing hardpoints, limited internal stores, etc. while it wouldn't reduce cost to the 50M range that some pundits have wet dreams for...it could probably drop the cost to the 90M range or so. the secret to cost effectiveness in defense contracting is NUMBERS. if you're going to get the costs down to a healthy level, you need to build sufficient quantities--but not more than is required.


We have a jet like that, it's called the F-15. The production line is running strong too, so the air force could probably get a hell of a deal if they jumped in within the next couple of years.

IPD
01-17-2012, 01:46 PM
We have a jet like that, it's called the F-15. The production line is running strong too, so the air force could probably get a hell of a deal if they jumped in within the next couple of years.

i've seen the price on the f-15SE, and frankly, i don't see how we'd be saving moeny over raptors/lightnings.

of course the biggest problem with your suggestion is that it completely misses the point about having fewer airframes to reduce logistical costs. lifetime costs will be substantially lower (even with a marginally higher initial unit cost), if the entire fleet is comprised of 90% of the same parts.

Ange
01-17-2012, 04:18 PM
word on the street is that the f35 and F22 is a POS compared to Russian Sukhoi T-50 PAK FA
and Chinese Chengdu J-20

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=27qdB1D0s9M

Vantage
01-17-2012, 04:45 PM
FYI, Ange.


Recent claims that Russian fighters defeated F-35s in a Hawaii-based simulated combat exercise are untrue, according to Maj. Gen. Davis.

"The reports are completely false and misleading and have absolutely no basis in fact," Maj. Gen. Davis said. "The August 2008 Pacific Vision Wargame that has been referenced recently in the media did not even address air-to-air combat effectiveness. The F-35 is required to be able to effectively defeat current and projected air-to-air threats. All available information, at the highest classification, indicates that F-35 is effectively meeting these aggressive operational challenges."

The Pacific Vision Wargame was a table-top exercise designed to assess basing and force-structure vulnerabilities, and did not include air-to-air combat exercises or any comparisons of different aircraft platforms.

Setting the Record Straight on F-35 | Lockheed Martin (http://www.lockheedmartin.com/news/press_releases/2008/0919ae_f-35settingrecordstraight.html)

Obviously, Lockheed will defend their product. The video however makes no mention of the F-22, besides it apparently being in the 'scenario.' Calling the Raptor a POS, couldn't be further from the truth.

Ange
01-17-2012, 05:39 PM
FYI, Ange.



Setting the Record Straight on F-35 | Lockheed Martin (http://www.lockheedmartin.com/news/press_releases/2008/0919ae_f-35settingrecordstraight.html)

Obviously, Lockheed will defend their product. The video however makes no mention of the F-22, besides it apparently being in the 'scenario.' Calling the Raptor a POS, couldn't be further from the truth.

yeah I obviously have no deeper knowlage in this. it was just a youtube vid linked to the vid TS posted. maybe it's biased. But I don't think they lied about the simulation of F35's and F22's vs the Sukhoi and Chengdu.

I wonder how Swedens own JAS39 Gripen would do. Maybe outdated by now.

IPD
01-17-2012, 08:19 PM
yeah I obviously have no deeper knowlage in this. it was just a youtube vid linked to the vid TS posted. maybe it's biased. But I don't think they lied about the simulation of F35's and F22's vs the Sukhoi and Chengdu.

I wonder how Swedens own JAS39 Gripen would do. Maybe outdated by now.

you're fucking hilarious. first you repeat some baseless BS like how the f-22 is worthless against pak-fa/su-50/j-20....then you follow it up with the rediculous suggestion that a swedish 4th gen fighter will somehow outperform the worlds premier 5th gen fighter.

my normal reaction to armchair QB's like you is a mixture of amusement, rage and pity. i can't tell you how many times i've heard the same crap from some idiot about the raptor/lightning 2--and then a plug for the goddamn grippen. you people are batshit insane.

for the record, if you WERE going to pick a fighter other than the raptor to put up against the su-50/j-20...you'd have at least sounded somewhat intelligent if you'd suggested the eurofighter or the rafale. and even then, neither of those would stand a chance. those who decry the raptor have ZERO idea what it is capable of. i do....i've worked with them. maybe once the su-50/j-20 reach operational status for a few years...THEN we can try a head-head comparison. until then, it's just a lot of hot air from the peanut gallery.

p.s.
i've seen that video multiple times. those who actually work with blue force fighters for a living know all too well that we like to handicap our own forces in any exercises. consider it a psychological advantage when the enemy doesn't know wtf just happened. we've done it with exercises with the IAF too. so i'll keep smiling while the BS keeps flowing.

Ange
01-17-2012, 09:42 PM
you're fucking hilarious. first you repeat some baseless BS like how the f-22 is worthless against pak-fa/su-50/j-20....then you follow it up with the rediculous suggestion that a swedish 4th gen fighter will somehow outperform the worlds premier 5th gen fighter.

my normal reaction to armchair QB's like you is a mixture of amusement, rage and pity. i can't tell you how many times i've heard the same crap from some idiot about the raptor/lightning 2--and then a plug for the goddamn grippen. you people are batshit insane.

for the record, if you WERE going to pick a fighter other than the raptor to put up against the su-50/j-20...you'd have at least sounded somewhat intelligent if you'd suggested the eurofighter or the rafale. and even then, neither of those would stand a chance. those who decry the raptor have ZERO idea what it is capable of. i do....i've worked with them. maybe once the su-50/j-20 reach operational status for a few years...THEN we can try a head-head comparison. until then, it's just a lot of hot air from the peanut gallery.

p.s.
i've seen that video multiple times. those who actually work with blue force fighters for a living know all too well that we like to handicap our own forces in any exercises. consider it a psychological advantage when the enemy doesn't know wtf just happened. we've done it with exercises with the IAF too. so i'll keep smiling while the BS keeps flowing.

dude...

why are you always so angry? do you have some sort of diagnose?

Like I said I know nothing about this topic. I never said Jas39 was capable of anything it was a question but thanks for the answer I guess...

Trevor
01-17-2012, 10:37 PM
J-20 is pure vaporware right now. It'll be quite a while before it's even worthy of burning brain cycles on.

zelstin
01-17-2012, 11:36 PM
what's your point/what's your question? the USA has a palatable aversion to the death of its citizens at the hands of foreigners. do you deny this?

I think the argument of casualties in a $XX Million aircraft vs a $XXX Million aircraft is pretty ridiculous when we send infantry to war without the protection garnered by a deputy badge here in the states. I understand the higher capability of a pilot, public relations, and all the other factors that make this a remotely debatable topic. But, stripped down to a purely life to life argument, it don't make no fuckin' cents.

AgentOblivious
01-18-2012, 01:01 AM
As I understand it, the Rand test wasn't an actual war games battle, but rather a computer simulation.

Either way, it doesn't matter if the F35 is superior to Russian and Chinese fighters, as it'll more than likely be outnumbered in any real scenario, which is a bad spot to be in with so few onboard weapons.

IPD
01-18-2012, 08:36 AM
I think the argument of casualties in a $XX Million aircraft vs a $XXX Million aircraft is pretty ridiculous when we send infantry to war without the protection garnered by a deputy badge here in the states. I understand the higher capability of a pilot, public relations, and all the other factors that make this a remotely debatable topic. But, stripped down to a purely life to life argument, it don't make no fuckin' cents.

it's not just death that we dislike...it's the loss of billions of dollars of equipment that we'd have to replace. in the air-air realm, you don't simply repair the losers--it's not like you might be able to do with tanks. if the difference between $$ and $$$ airplanes is the difference between a 51-49 victory and 100-0 victory....then it really behooves us to pony up the extra cash.