View Full Version : A letter from a Navy Wife to the Master Chief Petty Officer of the Navy.
eljefefx
01-13-2012, 07:09 PM
A message from Ember R Hulett to MCPON...
MCPON,
With all due respect, several weeks ago I posted on your page in regards to the likelihood of suicide triggered by the stress of ERB information right before the holidays, followed by a period off of work with nothing to keep the mind busy and little supervision.
Petty Officer Hatfield shot himself a few days ago in his home, broken under the stress of losing his career. His wife lived with the body for days before blood seeped through the ceiling in the garage and told her where he had gone to end his life, hiding in the attic. Perhaps he wished to make it impossible for her to be the one to find him. Who knows? We've lost a sailor.
His wife Nikki is devastated.
400K is NOTHING to her.
Please, please take better care of your sailors, Master Chief.
In fact, I'm now a Navy wife, and our President, your boss, works for me, the American People.
So with all due respect, Master Chief...
That's an ORDER.
DO SOMETHING, now, before it's too late.
I know there is only one of you, and there are thousands of them, but my comments about the manner in which our Navy is drawing down have held true.
10 years ago so many of my friends and family were barely beyond teenagers. We were partying, preparing for college, falling in and out of love... being young people.
Our Nation called us.
For whatever reason, you called.
Just as generations of young people have done at various times for this country, we put on boots, helmets, and a load of responsibility far beyond our years, and we responded, filling out the required ranks of enlisted personnel in every armed force.
We were not always prepared, not always well protected, NEVER well informed, and not always at our best, but we were THERE for our country when our country called.
We gave you our BEST years.
10 years later we have forgone college, deferred our dreams, and in some cases given our lives for the call. Now, 10 years later, our country has spent BILLIONS and claims it can no longer afford our services.
We are being turned out of the jobs we have grown to love at an increasing rate to face an unemployment rate approaching ten percent. We are behind in education, unprepared in many cases for civilian life, and untrained to be much other than the soldiers, sailors, marines and airmen we were asked to become.
Where is the job training?
Aggressive, not just "adequate," transition services?
Why are we being so abruptly shunted aside?
Where are the tools we will need to face the nation that we were asked to defend?
Without an AGGRESSIVE CAMPAIGN to re-introduce the sailors you are letting go to civilian jobs- job matching, placement and training, you are leaving thousands with little hope and great fear.
ERB, PRT, and HYT changes are hurting your sailors, and destroying families.
Changes to the GI bill mean sailors in North Carolina may suddenly see out of state rates from one semester to the next.
We kept our promises to you.
We manned the Greatest Navy on the planet when you called us.
Keep the Navy's promise to us.
Support our families both on Active Duty and in the wider Navy family.
STOP throwing us away in favor of green recruits who cost less to maintain because they do not have families and can live on the ship or in barracks.
SLOW RECRUITING, SLOW FORCED ATTRITION.
Draw down, and stay that way, but do it fairly.
Do it with respect for the men and women who have freely stepped up to entrust their lives to you at an age when they generally had no CLUE what they were signing up for over a 10-20 year period.
With compassion, and Very Respectfully,
Ember R. Hulett
-USN-Veteran
-Active Duty Navy Wife
-Sailor forever
Police think body is missing VB man | WAVY.com | Virginia Beach (http://www.wavy.com/dpp/news/local_news/va_beach/Police-think-body-is-missing-VB-man)
Fair Winds and Following Seas, Petty Officer Hatfield.
We have the watch.
Vantage
01-13-2012, 07:47 PM
I'm not really familiar at all with the navy's draw down plans or their ets clearing procedures but that sounds like a lot of moaning and groaning to me. Leadership at that level is damned if they do, and damned if they don't. The problem is that we let to many dirt bags swell our ranks andhad no choice but to keep them because we were hurting that bad on personnel. Now that we longer need to beg people to join, people are afraid they will no longer get their welfare the military really is. The new SMA said it best, "Your a 15 year E-5, what's going on?" People know now that they can no longer hide out for 20 years and collect an easy retirement, and they are scared. I know where I'm stationed, SM's getting out are told to immediately apply for unemployment, so no shit, veteran unemployment rates are rather high.
And what is this diarrhea that people are not being giving the skills to be successful outside of the military? Get the fuck over yourself lady. You can not talk about how you were part of the greatest navy on Earth, and then cry that you and others can't make it on the outside. Last time I checked, millions upon millions of people have had great and successful lives without having ever been in the military. My phones about to die so Ill try and continue this rant later. This is just my $.02 .
eljefefx
01-13-2012, 07:50 PM
Look up ERB. Also, it's not 15 year E5's (no such thing in the Navy). In many cases, it's individuals who just did their last reenlistment (or at least putting them up to 20) as an E6.
Vantage
01-13-2012, 08:24 PM
After briefly getting up to speed on the ERB, from my outside the navy viewpoint, I still see no issues with how it helps to reduce the Navys total end strength. All branches are having similar things to reduce troop levels. A performance oriented review board seems like a far way to go about it, while still being feasible. But in your last post, are you saying the board is purposely targeting those closest to their 20 year mark for termination under the ERB program? How would you reduce end strength to the approved levels? And why is this lady writing the Master Chief Petty Officer of the Navy, instead of Congress? He doesn't decide how many sailors the Navy gets...
Alex3000gt
01-13-2012, 10:30 PM
Police think body is missing VB man | WAVY.com | Virginia Beach (http://www.wavy.com/dpp/news/local_news/va_beach/Police-think-body-is-missing-VB-man)
Fair Winds and Following Seas, Petty Officer Hatfield.
We have the watch.
A year ago I would have passed this story up without thinking about it.
It now brings me to tears. Rest in peace.
AgentOblivious
01-13-2012, 11:24 PM
That's balls. Hows about less corporate welfare, more taking care of your own. I don't care if you're the gutsiest John Wayne muthafucka out there that managed to walk out of the armed forces and into a dream job; that's not indicative of the situation of your peers. They were there when they were needed, don't let them down.
eljefefx
01-14-2012, 08:51 AM
After briefly getting up to speed on the ERB, from my outside the navy viewpoint, I still see no issues with how it helps to reduce the Navys total end strength. All branches are having similar things to reduce troop levels. A performance oriented review board seems like a far way to go about it, while still being feasible. But in your last post, are you saying the board is purposely targeting those closest to their 20 year mark for termination under the ERB program? How would you reduce end strength to the approved levels? And why is this lady writing the Master Chief Petty Officer of the Navy, instead of Congress? He doesn't decide how many sailors the Navy gets...
he problem that we're facing right now is that with the implementation of ERB and the ground rules for being selected for separation, many are reporting that there are individuals who did not meet the criteria for separation but who were not selected. I have seen numerous reports of people who, after having just made E6 at between the 10-14 year range (and who then reenlisted, some up to 19 years of total service), were selected to be separated in September of this year. These people have passed our other RIF tool, Perform To Serve, and were approved to stay in in their rate, or cross-rated to another job in the Navy.
The guidelines are not being followed, and people are pissed off. Now, we have one sailor who was so distraught with the situation that he took his own life. Did he feel betrayed? Possibly.
And that is the problem. While the MCPON doesn't set this policy, he does have the ear of those who do, namely the Chief of Naval Operations, SevNav and SecDef. He can help.
Vantage
01-14-2012, 12:18 PM
OK, I think I'm beginning to understand now. It is unfortunate that the program is not being performed to standard or IAW the regulations/guidelines that were established for it. Has any other senior Navy leadership made any mention of tis apparently broken system? Or are they turning a blind eye, pretending all is well and good?
eljefefx
01-14-2012, 12:57 PM
Nothing that has been officially put out criticizing it. Plenty of talk around the spaces that it's bullshit.
i'll add that regardless of how well the aid to transition is, you can't escape the simple fact that someone age 40+ (who doesn't necessarily qualify for military retirement) has a LOT harder time in the job market than a 20-something. age-ism is alive and well.
BaadVR4
01-14-2012, 10:15 PM
I served 21 1/2 years in the Navy from May 1964 to Nov 1985. Clearly my service was LONG ago. But the more things change, the more they remain the same. Some well intentioned bureaucrat some where (who probably makes more in a month than the dead sailor did in a year) decides we need to save money or improve force "readiness" and creates a "program" to achieve the lofty goal he has in mind. It is then VERY SELECTIVELY applied, and most often to the detriment of a large group of otherwise well qualified, dedicated servicemen and women. It takes several years to find/fix the "glitches" in the program, but in the meantime many hundreds (if not thousands) of lives and families are irreparably damaged, if not utterly destroyed. "Up or Out" blatantly discriminated against minorities as it was initially implemented. And the "fat boy" programs of the 1970's and 80's cost many thousands of sailors their careers because the could not meet height/weight standards that didn't exist when they were making career choices to remain in the service.
The problem is NOT fair and impartial enforcement of rules and policy. The problem is the rules and policies are changed AFTER the fact.
And, no, Vantage, military retirement is NOT welfare. If you added up just the HOURS I spent deployed in Submarines and Aircraft Carriers, my 21 1/2 years of service more accurately reflect a 40-45 year career. I EARNED every damned penny of every paycheck I have EVER received, both while Active Duty and during my retirement. And EVERY Sailor, Soldier, Airman or Marine who takes his or her own life as a result of the ignorance and lack of caring of the self serving bean counters might as well have been executed by them.
And, no, Vantage, I lack neither intelligence (member of the triple one club) nor employable skills (I have been General Manager of two companies during my retirement). I enlisted in the Navy. I advanced in rate through E-9. I won selection to Warrant Officer and held rank from W-1 through W-4. I won selection to Limited Duty Officer and held rank from O-1 through O-3. My entire Naval career was spent as a Nuclear Propulsion Systems specialist. I never lacked for promotion. I never faced losing my career. But I watched many who did, through no fault of their own.
All that Navy wife is asking is the MCPON uphold the oath he took. The oath to protect those men and women entrusted to his care when they are unable to protect themselves. Whether in battle with an armed enemy or in battle with the demons of war or in battle with the self imposed demons of hopelessness, our servicemen and women DESERVE to be protected with every last ounce of our power. And that applies to every link in the Chain of Command from the bottom all the way to the Commander-In-Chief. And ANY one who doubts that is welcome, in my opinion, to stand between those service members and the enemy with real bullets in real guns. If you are willing to do that, I accede you the right to complain about our whining. If you are not, then kindly refrain from denigrating those who ARE willing to do so.
Vantage
01-15-2012, 04:37 AM
And, no, Vantage, military retirement is NOT welfare. If you added up just the HOURS I spent deployed in Submarines and Aircraft Carriers, my 21 1/2 years of service more accurately reflect a 40-45 year career. I EARNED every damned penny of every paycheck I have EVER received, both while Active Duty and during my retirement. And EVERY Sailor, Soldier, Airman or Marine who takes his or her own life as a result of the ignorance and lack of caring of the self serving bean counters might as well have been executed by them.
Being on my phone when I initially responded to this thread, I couldn't elaborate as well as I would have liked. The context in which I made my welfare comment is not how I truly wanted it come off. While in my opinion I still think it's true, there's undoubtedly a great many number of servicemen and women who, as you pointed out, earned every penny they make. As I said, I can't speak to the Navy, but over the course of the GWOT, the burden on the Army became such that all forms of admittance standards went out the window. You could be the biggest scum bag in the world, but hey, if you wanted, the Army had a bunk with your name on it.
Now after 10 years on conflict, PTSD has finally been recognized as a legitimate issue, but at the same time, it can be extremely difficult to tell if someone truly has it or is just making it up. Because of this, I have openly heard and had discussions with NCOs, to include Senior NCOs, who have come out and said they will claim PTSD regardless if they actually do or not, simply to receive the disability. Clearing PAX are told what tests to go take at the health clinic in hopes of maybe catching a break, and getting some sort of disability claim. Who cares if your fine or not, lets see if we can take Uncle Sam for every dime he's got! It's absolutely deplorable. The phrase 'Fraud, Waste, and Abuse' comes to mind. To me, I liken it to government sponsored welfare. Take offense to the connection, get upset about it, I don't really care. The military has become, for far to many, an easy paycheck for doing usually close to nothing.
And as much as I hate all the "self serving bean counters," it's hard to believe that termination from the service would bring one to kill themselves. Do I agree for many, it probably is devastating? Of course, but there's always more than one issue at hand. In this case, this sailor had gambling problems, and once he found out he would be terminated at the end of the year, he began gambling again. The military is not a day care. We do not have time to constantly rehab service members over and over again, or beg them get in shape so if God forbid the time ever came, they could help face the enemy without being a handicap to the men and women next to them.
So for discussions sake, how would you change the system? How would you create a program to reduce service levels, while still remaining feasible at the size and scope it needs to be accomplished at?
And, no, Vantage, I lack neither intelligence (member of the triple one club) nor employable skills
I never came close to making that claim. Quite the opposite in fact, but well done I guess, it looks like you had a great career.
And ANY one who doubts that is welcome, in my opinion, to stand between those service members and the enemy with real bullets in real guns. If you are willing to do that, I accede you the right to complain about our whining.
And that's where I have been for just about the better part of a decade. Maybe it's the reason I'm rather unsympathetic to these types of things. Anyways, thanks for your service BaadVR4.
BaadVR4
01-15-2012, 09:54 AM
Vantage, I think you gild the lily. There are cheats/slimeballs/scumbags and even career criminals in every branch of the service. Their numbers are extremely small. And they should be investigated, prosecuted and punished to the extent the law allows. But that is not the purpose of the current programs, nor are they even the primary target of the new programs. But even that is not the biggest problem.
Here's an analogy. Your team is leading the football game 35-7 at halftime. During the halftime intermission, the league has a meeting. The second half revenues will be reduced; people will leave without consuming more beer, they'll change the TV channel, missing all the high dollar commercials. Something simply MUST be done!! So the rules are changed. If your team scores a touchdown, it will be worth nothing. But if the other team scores a touchdown, it is worth 77 points, field goals 35. For the other team, a first down is worth 7 points and a pass completion 3. Oh, and your team will only be allowed nine players on the field. And your opposition gets to pick which two are banned.
Absurd? Certainly. Unfair? Absolutely. But very much like how we deal with force reductions? All too unfortunately, it is also just like the way we reduce our end levels.
It is common for the "bean counters" to authorize manning levels at 60-70% of documented absolute "NEED" levels. And that is for programs that are in the classification "highly required/vital to national security", like Nuclear Power. Then when the overall force reduction programs begin, they are applied like a "one size fits all" glove. So we just "weed 'um out" at the right percentages until we get to our target numbers. Then we pat ourselves on the back for having protected our vital military needs while simultaneously defeating the rabid dogs of fiscal irresponsibility from gutting our military mission. Well done, Mr. Beancounter!! Well done, indeed!!!!!!!! In the meantime our enemies laugh at us all the way to victory. It's ancient history, but Vietnam comes to mind.
If there is a problem of over-manning, it has been created by the same idiotic beancounters who are behind our draw down policy debacle. When they needed bodies, they changed the rules to allow all those scumbags/thieves/slime balls to enlist so the force end strength would reach the goals, ensuring our military was the best, most well trained fighting force in the world. That didn't work too well, either. So now the rest of the folks not only have to perform their own jobs but take up the slack for all the dead weight the beancounters used to fill out the force. So just cut out the dead weight and get capable recruits, you say? The same policy makers who change/modify/bend or re-write the rules for their own ends have made it so hard to legitimately cleanse even one scuzbag that it is easier to just send them home and not recommend them for re-enlistment. Now THAT is military welfare. But back to the current issue. We needed a TON of service members to go fight for our country's interests. Our extraordinarily gifted and visionary beancounters got them by relaxing rules for both recruitment and retention. Now, 10 years on, the country has financial problems and we need to downsize our military. Them folks with 10-19 years make a LOT more money than a new recruit. So let's set up a program that has all the APPEARANCES of being fair and impartial, but which, in fact, will allow us to be very selective about who we separate. Since the current economy sucks, recruiting any required replacements will be dead easy. After all, a body is a body.
I did have a great career. But I saw thousands who didn't and it wasn't their fault. But make NO MISTAKE: it was NOT the troops who created this problem. It wasn't even the dirtbags and scumbags. It was the policy makers/enforcers and beancounters. Defend the policy makers and bean counters if you wish. Just don't pretend to give a damn about the innocent they hurt while you are doing it.
i'm with milt 110%. if you want to reduce force strength (regardless of the merits of reduced forces), the way to do it is through natural attrition. reduce recruiting & kill off retention bonuses. hell, my own career field just saw a RECALL TO ACTIVE DUTY (on a volunteer basis) for a lot of people with 15-20+ years of experience who had previously separated. why? because they gutted the force structure to the point they realized that there weren't enough bodies with sufficient seniority where they were needed. that's a problem caused by flagrant force-structure cuts, rather than relying on natural attrition.
and for those who believe there are still a lot of fat to be cut, i'll have you know that my unit is averaging a 1:1 dwell ratio right now. that means that for every month the member is at home (stateside), he/she will spend 1 month deployed. and i'm in the frickin air-force. previously we'd deploy, fly our tails off for 60 days at a feverish pitch, and then go home (limited based on regulations for maximum flight hours). they've decided to up that to 180 days at a stretch "just like the rest of the air force". problem is, if someone in finance screws up in month 5 of a deployment, the worst that usually happens is a chargeback against an overpaid member. if someone in maintenance or ops screws up 5 months in, someone usually dies, or a multi-million dollar aircraft is lost.
but yes, by all means, please continue to cut the force structure to the point where i'll have to be deployed 330 days out of every year while simultaneously praying that the strain (physically and mentally) doesn't cause me to seriously f-up and get dozens of people killed or worse. i don't need a personal life--and i apparently don't need a family either. volunteering for the military in the 21st century means that i've volunteered to forgo any semblance of self--and am merely to perform as a mindless automaton that's happy to be forever suck in the ass-cracks of the world on an indefinite basis while never enjoying the freedoms that i've sworn to defend with my very life. thank you so very much.
/sarcasm.
Vantage
01-15-2012, 01:34 PM
BaadVR4, the Army currently has 90,000 non-deployable soldiers. Half of those are because of apparent combat related injuries. But how many of even those are just riding the wave, hiding out, and collecting their checks? I wouldn't say it if I hadn't seen it. IPD, I understand that not everyones optempo has come down. Aviation and JSOC have had to step up their optempo tremendously to pick up the slack and fill the voids left by everyone else. I never said I was a fan of, or agreed with, 'random lets see who the dart hits next' troop reductions.
I'm honestly impressed and shocked that the Army is apparently the only service getting this right this time around. You can agree, disagree, moan, groan, bitch, cry or complain until the cows come home. Congress has mandated cuts, and we need to listen to the boss, like it or not, it's just the way it is. Aside from natural attrition and slowed recruiting, I've still seen no suggestions on how to reduce the force efficiently and fairly. The military is a pendulum, and it will forever swing from one extreme to the other.
Above all else, if you are that upset with the system and want to see it changed, stay in long enough, become that senior official, and mold the service to your liking. Make no mistake, I'm not defending the politicians or even supporting them, heck, if I could go pistol whip all of them into quitting, I'd do it, but when our boss gives us an end state, it's our job to meet that goal and accomplish the mission, whether we like it or not. Life's just not fair, and we need to accept that.
Run for Congress and see if the American people agree that the military deserves to be spared from these reductions and budget cuts. So far the vast majority do not believe so. But then again the public has never really had any sort of grasp on what the military does and accomplishes for this country.
BaadVR4, the Army currently has 90,000 non-deployable soldiers. Half of those are because of apparent combat related injuries. But how many of even those are just riding the wave, hiding out, and collecting their checks? I wouldn't say it if I hadn't seen it. IPD, I understand that not everyones optempo has come down. Aviation and JSOC have had to step up their optempo tremendously to pick up the slack and fill the voids left by everyone else. I never said I was a fan of, or agreed with, 'random lets see who the dart hits next' troop reductions.
I'm honestly impressed and shocked that the Army is apparently the only service getting this right this time around. You can agree, disagree, moan, groan, bitch, cry or complain until the cows come home. Congress has mandated cuts, and we need to listen to the boss, like it or not, it's just the way it is. Aside from natural attrition and slowed recruiting, I've still seen no suggestions on how to reduce the force efficiently and fairly. The military is a pendulum, and it will forever swing from one extreme to the other.
Above all else, if you are that upset with the system and want to see it changed, stay in long enough, become that senior official, and mold the service to your liking. Make no mistake, I'm not defending the politicians or even supporting them, heck, if I could go pistol whip all of them into quitting, I'd do it, but when our boss gives us an end state, it's our job to meet that goal and accomplish the mission, whether we like it or not. Life's just not fair, and we need to accept that.
Run for Congress and see if the American people agree that the military deserves to be spared from these reductions and budget cuts. So far the vast majority do not believe so. But then again the public has never really had any sort of grasp on what the military does and accomplishes for this country.
you've hit upon the #1 reason why i think military service should be a requirement to holding public office. all excuses of why that is a bad idea (usually unfounded ideas involving some BS about turning the USA into a totalitarian regime) are hogwash. in a representative democracy, it is our legislators who have a say in the direction our country takes. by handing them the keys to the nation--and without having any military experience to draw upon--we have charged them with steering the most important service our federal government provides...and without an iota of knowledge to do it with.
p.s.
one other aspect of force reduction that NO ONE EVER SEEMS TO THINK OF...is the cost and replace-ability factor. individuals who work in trades that have a 6-week (post-boot) course for training...are MUCH MUCH easier to replace than individuals who have 2-3 years of post-boot training--just to become initially CMR. to wit, a nuclear weapons technicians should be looked at much further down the list for force reductions than infantry or security forces.
additionally, how MUCH does that training cost? individuals in flying career fields usually cost exponentially more to train than those in non-flying fields. this is partially due to the length of the course, but also to the resources needed to train (jp-8, flight instructors, etc).
imho, the military should almost NEVER look at force shaping from career fields where the average time between service entry and CMR (barring casual status) is 2 years or greater.
p.p.s.
and don't get me started on the enron-style book-cooking being done with the 1A4/1A5 career fields. oh sure, on PAPER we have 80% manning. IRL (because we're forced to man separate platforms that don't have allotted manning billets) our manning is closer to 40-50%.
BaadVR4
01-15-2012, 10:01 PM
Vantage, you REALLY miss the point. Your argument is "follow the order and damn the consequences". Would you follow an order that was unlawful? Based on your responses, I guess you would.
Let's try this one LAST time. This country has a legal system that is designed to protect the innocent.......to the extent that "it is better that 99 guilty go free than 1 innocent be wrongly convicted". But you have no compunction about whatever havoc is visited upon the "innocent" in the name of "listen to the boss...it's just the way it is". How wonderful to have no conscience. How marvelous to not give a damn about real tragedy in real people's lives. But, wait, I forget........"Life's just not fair, and we need to accept that." No, Vantage, life is NOT fair. But that doesn't mean we should ignore wrongs just because life isn't fair. If I apply that logic, then it should be perfectly okay if some one invades your home, wipes out your whole family and leaves you a quadriplegic. We should let whoever did that just get away with it. After all, whatever happens to you is "just life". And we all know that "Life just isn't fair". Injustice is injustice no matter who the victim might be. You seem to have decided that because SOME members deserve to be separated, ALL members should be subject to the same process. Except, of course, yourself and those YOU deem worthy. Just a touch of hypocrisy, don't you think?
BaadVR4, the Army currently has 90,000 non-deployable soldiers. Half of those are because of apparent combat related injuries. But how many of even those are just riding the wave, hiding out, and collecting their checks? I wouldn't say it if I hadn't seen it. IPD, I understand that not everyones optempo has come down. Aviation and JSOC have had to step up their optempo tremendously to pick up the slack and fill the voids left by everyone else. I never said I was a fan of, or agreed with, 'random lets see who the dart hits next' troop reductions.
I'm honestly impressed and shocked that the Army is apparently the only service getting this right this time around. You can agree, disagree, moan, groan, bitch, cry or complain until the cows come home. Congress has mandated cuts, and we need to listen to the boss, like it or not, it's just the way it is. Aside from natural attrition and slowed recruiting, I've still seen no suggestions on how to reduce the force efficiently and fairly. The military is a pendulum, and it will forever swing from one extreme to the other.
Above all else, if you are that upset with the system and want to see it changed, stay in long enough, become that senior official, and mold the service to your liking. Make no mistake, I'm not defending the politicians or even supporting them, heck, if I could go pistol whip all of them into quitting, I'd do it, but when our boss gives us an end state, it's our job to meet that goal and accomplish the mission, whether we like it or not. Life's just not fair, and we need to accept that.
Run for Congress and see if the American people agree that the military deserves to be spared from these reductions and budget cuts. So far the vast majority do not believe so. But then again the public has never really had any sort of grasp on what the military does and accomplishes for this country.
Vantage
01-15-2012, 11:02 PM
BaadVR4, you can’t be serious? That’s your rebuttal? What about my comments thus far are unlawful? Since we are apparently making this personal, I guess 20 years absent the military has dulled your mindset.
Try this one last time, try it a few more after that, hell don’t try at all, I could care less. Your likening the members of the military to those of a bunch of inmates at the state pen. Are your serious? No one here is guilty, and no one here is innocent. This isn’t a court room. You openly admit life is not fair, but yet you offer no suggestions on how to change the system to make it better, and allow every service member their due. Besides your gripes, what are YOU bringing to the table?
You talk as if Congress is out to sabotage the military and take down as many souls as possible. Even if it seems like that, open your eyes. They do what they must for votes, and as I said before, America does not believe we need an overly stout military. They don’t care how or why, they just want results. Politicians will stop at nothing to show them they are the ones accomplishing those tasks. You talk of injustice, and honestly I must agree. I think veterans are owed more than their country(OUR COUNTRY) could ever give, but like I said what would you have them due? YOU HAVE STILL NOT GIVEN AN ALTERNATIVE SOLUTION TO SERVICE REDcCTIONS.
You seem to have decided that because SOME members deserve to be separated, ALL members should be subject to the same process. Except, of course, yourself and those YOU deem worthy. Just a touch of hypocrisy, don't you think?
How fucking dare you. Who are you to fucking question me, and what the fuck I have done for this country? EVERY member is afforded the opportunity to make themselves untouchable, it is up to them to follow through. I thought we could have an apparently adult, and educated discussion on this topic and see where it took us, and with any luck, to the benefit of all. I guess that’s just not possible. I have done what it takes to make myself ‘untouchable’ in the eyes of the Army, and for PERSEC reasons, I won’t elaborate about myself beyond that.
It is YOU BaadVR4, that seems to keep missing MY point, that regardless of whether we agree with the powers at be(which I don’t), TROOP LEVELS MUST BE REDUCED. You and the rest of 3sgto & 3SI can keep thinking I’m a terrible person with an awful mindset, but keep in mind, we are the ones keeping you safe at night, letting you sleep peacefully in your beds. And just for your SA, as combat arms, I consider myself pretty mild mannered. Most people I work with would have told this lady to shut the fuck up and drink water.
I feel as though we are trying to fight the same battle, but from different sides. It seems like your trying to make me out to be some sort of government bandit with the sole intent of crushing our service members when that is simply not the case. I hope you reply, and we can maintain a healthy discussion on how to benefit all involved, both the American tax payer, and the American military.
jbuhrman
01-15-2012, 11:23 PM
IMHO- There is no "good" way to go about troop reductions.. in the end people still will get put out... its what leads up to that time that matters. There was a comment in the letter than mentioned training and such. I can tell you that if you join, 75% of the jobs in the military won't get you a job in the civilian world as most require either licenses or certifications that the military does not require its member's to get. The only way to prepare a service member for transition is to start early. I haven't read too much up on ERB's as they do not at this time effect me. I guess I should as I am coming into that area pretty damn fast.
In the months prior(as they damn well better not ERB with a less than 90 day notice) once the member knows they are being processed they should start looking at what is required of them to continue that job in the civilian world.. but its up to the commands to afford the members the time to pursue the licenses/certificates and that is where the issues with Operational Commitment arise.
Again simply put, there is no easy answer to this. If they say people gotta go... there is no easy way to put out over 30,000 military members in a 12 month span and have everyone ready for whats awaiting them.
BaadVR4
01-16-2012, 01:14 AM
Vantage, I was there on the Big E when helicopters were denied landing permission. I watched the refugees fleeing for their lives being gunned down by their own countrymen. I saw them executing their friends and neighbors in the name of "kill or be killed". Sometimes we shot them as an act of mercy. Sometimes we shot them for for sport, like target practice. These were people our government had PROMISED to protect. And we abandoned them to their fate. Life. Which can be unfair. If you align yourself with the right enemy. We promised them we would not desert them under any circumstances for any reason. And then we abandoned them. Left them to the "fairness of life" Oh, and as you might guess, the vast majority did not survive the night. But Washington achieved the boss's order. And a fine piece of military precision it was. In practically every aspect of the operation our beancounters declared great victory. And another thousand innocent Vietnamese died brutally in the street. Such a small price to pay. Just another faceless, anonymous one of "them".
I do agree with one point you make, though. Politicians certainly do whatever they must for votes. And, shit, if in getting elected/re-elected you accidentally do something beneficial to the American people, well, just damn the bad luck
BaadVR4, you can’t be serious? That’s your rebuttal? What about my comments thus far are unlawful? Since we are apparently making this personal, I guess 20 years absent the military has dulled your mindset.
Try this one last time, try it a few more after that, hell don’t try at all, I could care less. Your likening the members of the military to those of a bunch of inmates at the state pen. Are your serious? No one here is guilty, and no one here is innocent. This isn’t a court room. You openly admit life is not fair, but yet you offer no suggestions on how to change the system to make it better, and allow every service member their due. Besides your gripes, what are YOU bringing to the table?
You talk as if Congress is out to sabotage the military and take down as many souls as possible. Even if it seems like that, open your eyes. They do what they must for votes, and as I said before, America does not believe we need an overly stout military. They don’t care how or why, they just want results. Politicians will stop at nothing to show them they are the ones accomplishing those tasks. You talk of injustice, and honestly I must agree. I think veterans are owed more than their country(OUR COUNTRY) could ever give, but like I said what would you have them due? YOU HAVE STILL NOT GIVEN AN ALTERNATIVE SOLUTION TO SERVICE REDcCTIONS.
How fucking dare you. Who are you to fucking question me, and what the fuck I have done for this country? EVERY member is afforded the opportunity to make themselves untouchable, it is up to them to follow through. I thought we could have an apparently adult, and educated discussion on this topic and see where it took us, and with any luck, to the benefit of all. I guess that’s just not possible. I have done what it takes to make myself ‘untouchable’ in the eyes of the Army, and for PERSEC reasons, I won’t elaborate about myself beyond that.
It is YOU BaadVR4, that seems to keep missing MY point, that regardless of whether we agree with the powers at be(which I don’t), TROOP LEVELS MUST BE REDUCED. You and the rest of 3sgto & 3SI can keep thinking I’m a terrible person with an awful mindset, but keep in mind, we are the ones keeping you safe at night, letting you sleep peacefully in your beds. And just for your SA, as combat arms, I consider myself pretty mild mannered. Most people I work with would have told this lady to shut the fuck up and drink water.
I feel as though we are trying to fight the same battle, but from different sides. It seems like your trying to make me out to be some sort of government bandit with the sole intent of crushing our service members when that is simply not the case. I hope you reply, and we can maintain a healthy discussion on how to benefit all involved, both the American tax payer, and the American military.
BaadVR4
01-16-2012, 01:25 AM
Vantage, you are not keeping America safe for me, you are keeping it safe for yourself and those you judge worthy of saving. You present yourself as the mildest mannered member of an elitist group of "brothers-in-arms" protecting selected groups from enslavement and deprivation. Sounds like another famous group with the same high goals. The Nazi SS. Your rhetoric is much lke theirs
Vantage
01-16-2012, 11:38 AM
Let me preface by saying I was rather drunk last night, and that resulted in an overly emotional response, and for that, I apologize.
The end to Vietnam was indeed tragic. But again I ask you, what was the alternative? Should we have stayed and lost tens of thousands of more American lives? Maybe we should've just had a coup, and taken over Washington for ourselves! What would your battle plan have been to appease everyone, since you apparently have some magic gift that makes all parties involved happy with their end of the deal, but you just won't let any one else in on your secret.
So BaadVR4, how do we follow the orders of our bosses, the taxpayers, all the while giving everyone else what they want? You can't sit in your castle of noble ideas and preach cheer and presents for everyone, yet offer no plan on how to accomplish such a thing.
I'm not out to condemn anyone, particularly service members, regardless if that's what you believe or not. The bottom line is, everyone knew this pendulum would swing back and the military would see drastic cuts. They didn't just randomly pull this rabbit out of the hat.
Vantage, you are not keeping America safe for me, you are keeping it safe for yourself and those you judge worthy of saving. You present yourself as the mildest mannered member of an elitist group of "brothers-in-arms" protecting selected groups from enslavement and deprivation. Sounds like another famous group with the same high goals. The Nazi SS. Your rhetoric is much lke theirs
Yea, you got me down to a T. :rolleyes: Could you do me a favor and help enlighten me. Who exactly do I want to protect, and who am I trying to enslave?
I get kinda scratchy when I see all you guys going at each other - even given the commonalities of your experience, it's not at all surprising to see the variety of reactions to the methods employed to down-size our forces.
These are tough times all around, but the fact that the same politicians who presided over our economic collapse are directing the draw-down from a relatively comfortable remove is particularly galling - incompetence on parade.
They will no doubt complain about their own hardships in making their stupid decisions.
I really hope we do a better job electing people going forward.
BaadVR4
01-16-2012, 01:42 PM
Vantage, those are questions only you can answer.
I never said we should give everyone everything they WANT. I only want to give everyone what they need to have a fighting chance to survive.
j2k4 has stated it well. We allow billions of dollars in benefits for non-citizens who are not even in the country legally. Why? Well, depending on which political side you're on, rounding them up and deporting them is either "inhumane" or not cost effective. And those same self-serving hypocrites will separate American citizens who have stood in harm's way to protect our freedom and kick them out the door without so much as a "hello", "goodbye" or "kiss my ass"?
How can you defend that kind of callous disregard for the hardship visited on those separated this way? I don't care how much you try to disguise the issue with cries of "force end strength is inevitable" or "it's just the way it is", the truth is we are changing the rules and disregarding who it hurts. It's like saying "rape is inevitable, so lay back and enjoy it".
I think the commonality of experiences is only a small part of our end product view point. I think personal world perspective plays a far greater role in shaping our mindset. For the first several years of my military service, my world view was ego-centric. As my authority/responsibility expanded, my perspective changed to being more outward. By the time I retired, I had come to understand that people are not the most important asset, they are the ONLY important asset. True, you have to have airplanes to have an Air Force and ships to have a Navy. But none of those assets matter without the people to man/maintain them. Period.
What value do you place on going "in harm's way"? For standing at the gates of hell and NOT yielding? You don't. Those acts are beyond price. Yes, there are those who "play the system" and fake injury/disability. But those folks are just as prevalent in the private sector. We don't treat civilian workers who lose their jobs this way. We don't change the rules on them and them kick them to the curb. Why would we treat our service men and women this way? Because we can. At least that's the way the politicians and beancounters see it. And that's why the Navy wife wrote the letter to the MCPON. To try to do something about an egregious wrong. To try to prevent the next Petty Officer Hatfield.
One last comment/opinion. Vantage, it is always better to give reasoned thought to a statement before you make it. A long time ago, I was told about the Loud Mouth's Prayer: "Lord, make my words tasty and filling. For, tomorrow, I may have to eat them." All of us have eaten the odd syllable or two.
BaadVR4
01-16-2012, 01:50 PM
Here's a plan. Every politician/civil servant who makes over $100,000.00 per year donates the amount over $100,000.00 to a fund that uses the donated money to provide transitional services (including grants) to separated members in need.
BaadVR4
01-16-2012, 02:08 PM
Oops. I forgot. We're not allowed to touch our sacred cows or their nice little paychecks. Especially not for something as worthless as an ex-service member.
And we wonder why they feel so useless they see suicide as the only way to be of use to their families. At lease that way the spouse gets the insurance.
Tell me, Vantage, if you value and honor your own service so much, why don't you value and honor theirs? Is it because they lacked the means to make themselves "untouchable"? Does that make their wives and children less valuable, too?
Here's a plan. Every politician/civil servant who makes over $100,000.00 per year donates the amount over $100,000.00 to a fund that uses the donated money to provide transitional services (including grants) to separated members in need.
I'm with you, there; fits the current popular trend, too - no more target-rich environment than the U.S. Congress. :)
BaadVR4
01-16-2012, 04:26 PM
If I had my way, every elected federal official would have his/her term extended indefinitely, their pay stopped, their assets frozen and they and their families would be provided food stamps for food and moved to government housing. They would remain in this status until the top ten problems (as defined by a nation wide poll) were fixed.
I'm willing to bet the deficit, balanced budget, unemployment, dependency on foreign oil and illegal immigration would magically find solutions in less than 60 days.
A politician's ONLY goal is getting elected/re-elected. And he/she will do WHATEVER it takes to achieve that goal. If we want to talk about welfare on the federal dime, there it is.
I'm not sure whether the American electorate lacks the will or lacks the process to fix our federal government, but it is more than broken, it is actively bleeding us dry. But that is a whole 'nother discussion.
BaadVR4
01-16-2012, 04:29 PM
Or as someone said, "we have become a nation of the lawyers, by the lawyers, for the lawyers". And 99+per cent of federal elected officials are lawyers.
i have zero respect for anyone who uses the "i was drunk" excuse. NONE WHATSOEVER.
Or as someone said, "we have become a nation of the lawyers, by the lawyers, for the lawyers". And 99+per cent of federal elected officials are lawyers.
it IS the one career field that doesn't seem impacted by economic hardships whatsoever.
BaadVR4
01-16-2012, 05:36 PM
it IS the one career field that doesn't seem impacted by economic hardships whatsoever.
Yep. The ONLY completely recession proof occupation under the sun. In fact, it's even DEPRESSION proof. And the only required qualifications are total selfishness and ability to shaft anyone and everyone equally.
AgentOblivious
01-16-2012, 07:26 PM
Here's a plan. Every politician/civil servant who makes over $100,000.00 per year donates the amount over $100,000.00 to a fund that uses the donated money to provide transitional services (including grants) to separated members in need.
If I could run, I'd do it for Cost of living +$20,000, the rest can go towards that. With congressmen making upwards of $170,000 a year, that's $100,000+ for the grants, and a much better investment than what its probably being spent on now.
If I could run, I'd do it for Cost of living +$20,000.
What an oddly Canadian idea. :huh:
Vantage
01-16-2012, 08:23 PM
Obviously we are all in agreement that Congress and politicians are worthless. But to say the service doesn't give people the opportunity to make something of themselves beyond their career in the military, is simply not true. There are dozens of programs for people to seek assistance in everything from drafting your resume(hell, they usually just do it for you!) to getting you ready for school. Besides taking people right from the service and putting them straight into a job and giving them a wad of cash, how much more aggressive can they be? You say these are only questions I can answer, but yet your the one standing there saying service members are being pissed on, but you have no idea where to find an umbrella.
I do honor peoples service. The point I was trying to make was that people are given the opportunity to become mission essential, be it by attending certain schools, learning a critical job, or joining certain units. If they really want nothing more than to be in the service, but won't reach out and take whats in front of them, then they must not want it that bad. You should know, the military is not going to give you anything, you have to take it. And if at first you don't succeed...
Clearly the Navy has done an awful job implementing the ERB, and people are upset, but sailors have/had the opportunity to remain in the Navy, and switch to low strength jobs.
i have zero respect for anyone who uses the "i was drunk" excuse. NONE WHATSOEVER.
Well lucky for me, your respect isn't on my to-do list. :rolleyes3: Take your useless banter somewhere else.
AgentOblivious
01-16-2012, 08:56 PM
What an oddly Canadian idea. :huh:
I'd do it for free, but I wouldn't be able to do my best if I had a second job to cover my expenses, so...
vantage, frankly i don't give 2/3rds of a flying fucking rats ass about your reception of my evaluation of your behavior. the fact of the matter is, alcohol is the 2nd most scapegoatted thing in history--trailing only religion. (i believe obama is a distant 3rd). when i was 15, 4 residents of my hometown who were would-be good samaritans responding to a crash were gunned down by the drunk who caused it. and no, he was not executed because of it--and his defense? you guessed it: alcohol.
so kindly go fuck yourself. your inability to own your own words or to show any modicum of personal responsibility not only makes me despise you as a person, it completely poisons any service record you've had in the US military. the trainees who got booted out of training the fastest were always the ones who couldn't admit to and own up to their own mistakes. i wholeheartedly endorse that policy. accountability is the most egregiously lacking aspect of anything in our government--and to have someone who blatantly dodges personal responsibility as you do...to be in the military...sickens me to the core.
p.s.
i also call BS on the "making yourself essential". military policy (as pushed by the bean counters who have never held a rifle in their goddamn lives) is one which promotes sycophants over scholars; brown-nosers over the bold; and shirt-thumbers over the shit-hot. i've watched quite a handful of my peers get drummed out--even while completing all the "wickets" that they're charged with completing. it's based on year/rank & total number in your field--nothing else. there isn't anything remotely logical about it. frankly, who gives 2-shits if you're overmanned in year "x". simply STOP recruiting for a period of time. regardless of how top-heavy the field may get, you'll still get to the end strength you want, and with very little pain involved for the members currently serving.
oh, and don't give me BS about how the military should do like the civilian world and hire newbies at 1/2 the pay to replace the old-timers who've been there forever. that's a sure-fire way to create brain-drain and to instill a sense of being "get what you can while you can" across the entire DOD. with an average wage of less than 50k across the all branches (last time i checked). that's not a lot of dough for someone who not only is away from CONUS on a frequent basis, but also is sworn to die in defense of the US constitution if necessary.
again though, i guess the rational aspects of it elude you.
BaadVR4
01-17-2012, 07:22 AM
Okay, Vantage, here's your chance.
In the build up for war, policy makers DELIBERATELY recruit men and women who lack the intellect/skills to EVER do much besides cook/clean/act as infantry. We swell the ranks with otherwise nearly unemployable men and women, stick them in where they can contribute, if not excel. We allow them to remain in the service, even if they fail to advance. We know they barely have the aptitude/learning capacity to perform their entry level assignments, and will never be leaders. We promise them a retirement they can survive on if they stay in 20 years. Then, 10, 15 or 19 years on, we tell them "we don't need your services any more, here's a class on how to get a job."
And your counter argument is "it's their fault, they didn't prepare themselves to be Nuclear Weapons Specialists while they had the chance." I'm surprised you didn't take them to task for not getting at least a Master's Degree, if not a PHD while they were freeloading on the military dime. To hear you tell it, the average military job (except, of course, yours) allows plenty of time for members to re-train themselves into whatever career field they want.
Your argument is classic victim-stance; blame the victim. If someone gets murdered in a Pizza Hut robbery, it's their own fault for being there to start with. They should have known the area was unsafe and not gone to that Pizza Hut. If a woman is raped, it is her fault because she wore revealing/suggestive clothing.
If your defense of your position is "I was distracted/drunk", you are really saying "I was wrong, but....And that is the problem with your arguments. As soon as you say "But", you negate everything stated before the "but".
I'm not going to berate you as harshly as did IPD, but I am going to suggest you examine your statements/positions BEFORE you make them public. Otherwise, you run the risk of others actually concluding you really BELIEVE what you say. Once an indefensible, ignorant or stupid statement has escaped your mouth (or your keyboard), it is forever linked to you, stuck on you like white on rice. It just WON'T go away.
If you drink to the point of getting drunk, you should apply rule number one: "Better to keep your mouth shut and be thought a fool than to open it and remove all doubt."
BaadVR4
01-17-2012, 07:34 AM
"Clearly the Navy has done an awful job implementing the ERB, and people are upset, but sailors have/had the opportunity to remain in the Navy, and switch to low strength jobs. "
And what if they are already in low strength jobs? What if they lack the aptitude to retrain? Oh, I forgot, that's their fault. Nothing to do with the intelligent elite like yourself. Life's not fair, get over it. You can't feed your children now that the Navy has separated you after 18 years of promises of a retirement if you just agreed to stay 20 years? Your fault, you should never have had children.
You really don't see just how ignorant and prejudiced you sound, do you? Too bad.
Zaroth
01-17-2012, 11:28 AM
vantage, frankly i don't give 2/3rds of a flying fucking rats ass about your reception of my evaluation of your behavior. the fact of the matter is, alcohol is the 2nd most scapegoatted thing in history--trailing only religion. (i believe obama is a distant 3rd). when i was 15, 4 residents of my hometown who were would-be good samaritans responding to a crash were gunned down by the drunk who caused it. and no, he was not executed because of it--and his defense? you guessed it: alcohol.
so kindly go fuck yourself. your inability to own your own words or to show any modicum of personal responsibility not only makes me despise you as a person, it completely poisons any service record you've had in the US military. the trainees who got booted out of training the fastest were always the ones who couldn't admit to and own up to their own mistakes. i wholeheartedly endorse that policy. accountability is the most egregiously lacking aspect of anything in our government--and to have someone who blatantly dodges personal responsibility as you do...to be in the military...sickens me to the core.
It sickens you to the core that he appologized for posting 1 emotional post? It's not like he is trying to change his point of view on the topic. He is owning up to his own mistake... that is what appologies are for. No need to get in such a hissy fit over it.
Vantage
01-17-2012, 01:03 PM
IPD, I didn't attempt to back track on what I said, I simply apologized for the verbiage I used to say it.
oh, and don't give me BS about how the military should do like the civilian world and hire newbies at 1/2 the pay to replace the old-timers who've been there forever. that's a sure-fire way to create brain-drain and to instill a sense of being "get what you can while you can" across the entire DOD. with an average wage of less than 50k across the all branches (last time i checked). that's not a lot of dough for someone who not only is away from CONUS on a frequent basis, but also is sworn to die in defense of the US constitution if necessary.
again though, i guess the rational aspects of it elude you.
I never made any statement remotely close to this. I guess once reading comprehension eludes you, so maybe your core can get a little sicker.
Okay, Vantage, here's your chance.
In the build up for war, policy makers DELIBERATELY recruit men and women who lack the intellect/skills to EVER do much besides cook/clean/act as infantry. We swell the ranks with otherwise nearly unemployable men and women, stick them in where they can contribute, if not excel. We allow them to remain in the service, even if they fail to advance. We know they barely have the aptitude/learning capacity to perform their entry level assignments, and will never be leaders. We promise them a retirement they can survive on if they stay in 20 years. Then, 10, 15 or 19 years on, we tell them "we don't need your services any more, here's a class on how to get a job."
You continually take my statements to the extreme. The "Sanctuary" program is designed to stop things like that from happening, and active duty personnel are automatically enrolled. True, it only kicks in at the 18 year mark, but that seems to be the majority of your examples, so I guess it's quite appropriate.
You talk about fairness and equality, so where is the fairness for the guy in the fox hole next to your sub-par performer? Why should Jimmy be mowed down by the horde because 14 year E-4 Johnny, a decade later, still can't figure out how to reassemble his M240? Where is the fairness in that? Who is going to write that letter to Jimmy's family letting them know their son died because it was only right we gave Johnny a chance. Who's the victim now? I guess you should write a letter to SMA Chandler letting him know he's an elitist, self-righteous asshole because he only wants to keep the "best and brightest" in the Army. Why are you not outside your local MEPS, protesting, letting them know just how terribly their bigotry is when they turn people away for mental or health issues. It's not the fault of those people, why shouldn't they be given a chance to serve their country?
You say the military is anything but a welfare check, but yet here you are, proposing it become exactly that. I guess the intelligent elite like myself and SMA Chandler will never understand why good people should put their lives at more risk than they already do, just to give those who lack intellect/skill a job.
Vantage
01-17-2012, 05:54 PM
p.s.
i also call BS on the "making yourself essential". military policy (as pushed by the bean counters who have never held a rifle in their goddamn lives) is one which promotes sycophants over scholars; brown-nosers over the bold; and shirt-thumbers over the shit-hot. i've watched quite a handful of my peers get drummed out--even while completing all the "wickets" that they're charged with completing. it's based on year/rank & total number in your field--nothing else. there isn't anything remotely logical about it. frankly, who gives 2-shits if you're overmanned in year "x". simply STOP recruiting for a period of time. regardless of how top-heavy the field may get, you'll still get to the end strength you want, and with very little pain involved for the members currently serving.
Like I've said more than a few times, I speak from my experiences in the Army and that's it. Just off the top of my head, heres a few ways to accomplish such a status in the Army.
1) Move to a JSOC unit. All JSOC units are fenced and their personnel are "untouchable" and not subject to these boards. They are also almost always short handed on support personnel.
2) Become 'Victor qualified' (Ranger School). You are automatically a critical asset, and pretty golden for your next promotion. Your job is now safe.
3) Reenlist for a critically short MOS. You'll get a pretty bonus and will no longer fear for your job.
There's 3 off the top of my head ways to reach the "untouchable" status I mentioned previously.
you make the over-reaching assertion that cross-training will be allowed. even IF a member has the aptitude and capability to function in the new career field...the service may not allow that transition.
Vantage
01-17-2012, 07:12 PM
Straight from the Armys reenlistment website:
3. Approval of the requested MOS is not automatic because the Soldier meets the MOS qualifications; RMT decision is
based upon Army strengths and training seat availability. If the requested MOS in para 2c is not available, RMT may
reply with ONE MOS training option that is non-negotiable. In rare cases when RMT is unable obtain a MOS for the
Soldier; RMT may offer a one-time extension of UP TO 9 months for the purpose of obtaining the minimum qualifications
for an MOS listed as balanced (N/N) or shortage (Y/N). The opportunity to extend will be provided by RMT in the hotline
response and may not be requested by the Career Counselor.
4. Soldiers must be aware that training seats could result in a quick ship PCS and must be prepared and available for
PCS. If training is offered it is non-negotiable and Soldiers must remain fully eligible for the MOS and PCS.
Soldiers placed on assignment instructions in conjunction with training who refuse to take action to meet the
SRR for the follow on assignment will sign a DCSS (when applicable), IAW AR 601-280 para 4-11 and 4-12.
5. Soldiers offered retraining will have 14 days from the approval date to execute their reenlistment. Soldiers,
who fail to reenlist within 14 days from the approval date will be deleted and no longer eligible for the Army
training reenlistment option. These Soldiers should be counseled on DA Form 4856 stating they have been afforded
the opportunity for continued service in the Army but have decided not to take action.
It would seem the Army is doing what it can to hold on to soldiers, and appears to be the rule, rather than the exception.
BaadVR4
01-17-2012, 07:47 PM
I agree with your assertion about Jimmy should not be made to suffer for Johnny's ineptitude. Where we disagree is in where the responsibility for the problem lies. Johnny was recruited and repeatedly retained, despite his ineptitude, by the policy makers and beancounters. You want to blame Johnny. You think it's perfectly okay to shunt him aside now that he isn't needed to "fill a hole". But Johnny didn't create the problem, he didn't exacerbate the problem and he certainly didn't do anything intentionally to harm Jimmy.
When Johnny is separated involuntarily, it isn't just Johnny who is hurt. His wife and children suffer with him. It is likely the entire family will end up on welfare and the American public will support them all, just like the way you bemoan we do through the "military welfare" system.
The problem I have with your positions is that you keep wanting to blame the victim, Johnny. But all Johnny did was BLINDLY OBEY ORDERS FROM HIS SUPERIORS. Just like you said everyone should do. But Johnny's reward was separation.
The word is "empathy".
"Empathy is the capacity to recognize and, to some extent, share feelings (such as sadness or happiness) that are being experienced by another sapient or semi-sapient being. Someone may need to have a certain amount of empathy before they are able to feel compassion."
That is what I find so lacking in you, Vantage. It is my greatest hope that you are never in a leadership position until you are able to feel empathy. Only then will you not blame the victim; only then will you be able to see the problem-the real problem. Only then will you be see others-all others- as valuable human beings. Only then will you be able to lead.
IPD, I didn't attempt to back track on what I said, I simply apologized for the verbiage I used to say it.
I never made any statement remotely close to this. I guess once reading comprehension eludes you, so maybe your core can get a little sicker.
You continually take my statements to the extreme. The "Sanctuary" program is designed to stop things like that from happening, and active duty personnel are automatically enrolled. True, it only kicks in at the 18 year mark, but that seems to be the majority of your examples, so I guess it's quite appropriate.
You talk about fairness and equality, so where is the fairness for the guy in the fox hole next to your sub-par performer? Why should Jimmy be mowed down by the horde because 14 year E-4 Johnny, a decade later, still can't figure out how to reassemble his M240? Where is the fairness in that? Who is going to write that letter to Jimmy's family letting them know their son died because it was only right we gave Johnny a chance. Who's the victim now? I guess you should write a letter to SMA Chandler letting him know he's an elitist, self-righteous asshole because he only wants to keep the "best and brightest" in the Army. Why are you not outside your local MEPS, protesting, letting them know just how terribly their bigotry is when they turn people away for mental or health issues. It's not the fault of those people, why shouldn't they be given a chance to serve their country?
You say the military is anything but a welfare check, but yet here you are, proposing it become exactly that. I guess the intelligent elite like myself and SMA Chandler will never understand why good people should put their lives at more risk than they already do, just to give those who lack intellect/skill a job.
Vantage
01-17-2012, 08:16 PM
You mistake me. I absolutely think senior leadership and bean counters deserve blame, and should be held accountable. The way they have handled the military the past 10 years and grew it to such a large extent so quickly, was neither wise nor sustainable. At the time, America was all about the troops, and wanted whatever it took to help them. The result was grow the military to increase dwell time. It's effectiveness is a topic for another time. But the American public has a short memory and politicians, as we've established, will due what it takes for votes. The current trend is getting our budget on track, and unfortunately the DOD is an easy target. The lack of accountability for members of Congress and the Americas senior leaders is ridiculous. Their inability to effectively and efficiently create a long term force solution is due to nothing more than their lack of intestinal fortitude in the face of forgetful voters.
Johnny may be the victim, but I do not think he's blameless. His inability to ever learn his job, which resulted in the death of his buddy Jimmy, can't not be placed solely on the shoulders of his leaders. There comes a point when someone is just not trainable, and just not suited for the military. So what then? What should become of Johnny? Should he be moved to a desk job in the States, put into a non-deployable status, and left there until retirement? What if Johnny is single? Should he get the same benefits and treatment even if he doesn't have a family? And what of his peers? Is that really fair to them? For the same pay and benefits, they get to deploy time and again, leaving behind their families, all because they are dependable and competent? Is that their fault? Why should they have to pick up the slack that Johnny left behind? All the players here are victims of different circumstances, how do you decide who gets the shaft, and who doesn't?
If putting lives over livelihood makes me unemphatic and an elitist, I'll sit on that pedestal all day long.
BaadVR4
01-18-2012, 07:03 AM
Empathy is unconditional. It does not discriminate. You continue to place blame where none exists and choose expediency over creative problem solving. Clearly you are either unable or unwilling to see the difference. Maybe the next step in your thinking is "because Johnny is a liability in the field, we should take him out ourselves before he gets one of US killed"?
Enough. I will leave you to your own devices and hope they don't hurt too many others.
Powered by vBulletin® Version 4.2.3 Copyright © 2026 vBulletin Solutions, Inc. All rights reserved.