PDA

View Full Version : New Mustang v6 (no mods) suffers driveshaft failure, talk about cost cutting!



Telionis
12-20-2011, 03:41 AM
Everyone's been praising the new 305 bhp V6 Mustang, which will get you a 14.0 @ 104 mph for about $23k. Ford has been marketing them as a legitimate racing machine, even offering serious brake and suspension upgrades as one of the options, as well as the option of GT-spec gears and a factory GT-spec LSD. One such car, which cost about $26k, beat the 2011 WRX STi and the R-spec Genesis Coupe around VIR in a magazine test (C&D maybe). The thing is nearly identical to last years GT in performance, but can be had for less than a base model Camry.

Yet all is not well in the land of the sub-25k sports-car, the car clearly has some well hidden flaws. This guy removed the speed-limiter (set to 115) to see how fast he could go on the desert roads. The car was stock aside from that. Once he got to about 130 mph you could hear the driveshaft start to bow, and then totally failed at around 135 mph.

Mirrored video (original was removed):

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-qWhxYElSW0

Original Description:

I had an opportunity to drive my Mustang on a closed road at high speeds and this is what happened. Apparently the standard tires are not the only reason for the car being limited to such a sub performance speed of 113MPH. (Even slower then Ford's Fiesta and Focus models = 118MPH) My stock driveshaft failed at about 135MPH, so if these cars are run flat out in the real world without the ridiculous speed governor to keep them together, the drivetrain is not actually designed to handle the power of the engine. Major damage caused by the broken shaft included a hole in the metal floorpan, major exhaust system and muffler damage, broken transmission shifter, broken parking brake, broken interior plastic trim parts, etc. My 1997 Mustang Cobra could run 152MPH for unlimited time periods and this new car only held together for about 15 seconds under full throttle!!! Give me a break!!! The drivetrain is a REALLY BAD place to cut costs for a net profit $, especially on a 305HP Mustang! I really hope that Ford makes a change to the V6 drivetrain for 2013. After all, many of these cars are driven regularly on the German Autobahn and a failure like this could be very dangerous! Solution = Ditch the governor and install a decent driveshaft! Even a 23K Honda Civic can go 137MPH without breaking!!! Come on!!! This is my 5'th Mustang and my 1'st major failure. This is totally unacceptable for a performance car!

Cheap bastards! As someone on reddit said, I wonder if they plan to sell these cars to the Germans, I doubt many autobahn cruisers are willing to settle for 115 mph.

onebadmollafolla
12-20-2011, 04:01 AM
That sound at the end was horrifying. Looks like it was built Ford tough.

GTOJOE
12-20-2011, 07:17 AM
wow that's a scary sound to hear when doing 135mph. Some smart person will create driveshafts capable of much higher speeds and will make a killing.

IPD
12-20-2011, 09:30 AM
MAJOR fail. i have even MORE legit reasons to hate on rustangs now.

DrGonzo
12-20-2011, 10:04 AM
Not the first time this has happened. The 05 Mustang has the same issues with Drive shaft failure at only 110mph cause they only peened the u-joints bearing caps in place. Later years they actually used retaining clips.

AdamVR4
12-20-2011, 10:52 AM
Has anyone else reported similar problems?

bluefox1081
12-20-2011, 10:59 AM
Damn...that's gonna be an expensive fix.

IPD
12-20-2011, 11:49 AM
Not the first time this has happened. The 05 Mustang has the same issues with Drive shaft failure at only 110mph cause they only peened the u-joints bearing caps in place. Later years they actually used retaining clips.

your car looks like domo

aaronatstate
12-20-2011, 12:00 PM
Just to play devils advocate, you think Ford put the 115mph speed limiter in there for a reason? Maybe they knew the driveshaft couldn't handle higher speeds? Just sayin is all.

aaronatstate
12-20-2011, 12:03 PM
As someone on reddit said, I wonder if they plan to sell these cars to the Germans, I doubt many autobahn cruisers are willing to settle for 115 mph.

And easy trip to Startseite Ford-Werke GmbH | Ford Deutschland (http://www.ford.de) shows that the Mustang is not available for sale in Germany.

BigTyla
12-20-2011, 02:50 PM
I didn't know people bought the V6 models for performance. Learn something everyday!

IPD
12-20-2011, 02:57 PM
I didn't know people bought the V6 models for performance. Learn something everyday!

i don't really think you could consider any domestic v6 a "performance engine" before the current crop of coupes. the last domestic 6 that was worth a damn was the syclone--and that was a freakin truck.

AdamVR4
12-20-2011, 03:14 PM
I didn't know people bought the V6 models for performance. Learn something everyday!


Woah, woah woah... You mean to tell me that if I intentionally modify this car it might catastrophically break something in the drive train? Are we upset because it hits so close to home (t-cases)? The car gives you great bang for your buck. Oh no! you'll have to spend $500 (or less, c'mon, its a Mustang) on a drive shaft if you want to go balls deep into triple digits on a public road in your econo sports car... FORD SUKS!1

BigTyla
12-20-2011, 03:46 PM
Woah, woah woah... You mean to tell me that if I intentionally modify this car it might catastrophically break something in the drive train? Are we upset because it hits so close to home (t-cases)? The car gives you great bang for your buck. Oh no! you'll have to spend $500 (or less, c'mon, its a Mustang) on a drive shaft if you want to go balls deep into triple digits on a public road in your econo sports car... FORD SUKS!1

Oh, I totally agree. I'm not saying the V6 Mustang isn't a great buy, I just had no idea it had such a following as described by the OP. I thought almost everyone aiming for performance grabbed the V8 and left the V6 for the girls. Classically, that's the way it's always been, but then again the V6s back then didn't boast over 300hp.

AdamVR4
12-20-2011, 04:06 PM
Oh, I totally agree. I'm not saying the V6 Mustang isn't a great buy, I just had no idea it had such a following as described by the OP. I thought almost everyone aiming for performance grabbed the V8 and left the V6 for the girls. Classically, that's the way it's always been, but then again the V6s back then didn't boast over 300hp.

haha... I hear ya. Your post just motivated me to further question the outrage present in this thread.

UTRacerX9
12-20-2011, 04:12 PM
Woah, woah woah... You mean to tell me that if I intentionally modify this car it might catastrophically break something in the drive train? Are we upset because it hits so close to home (t-cases)? The car gives you great bang for your buck. Oh no! you'll have to spend $500 (or less, c'mon, its a Mustang) on a drive shaft if you want to go balls deep into triple digits on a public road in your econo sports car... FORD SUKS!1

The Mustang (even a V6) is still a pony car. I don't think it's a stretch to say that Ford intended the V6 car to be for the dragstrip too, I mean come on, putting the rev limiter just a tick above what the car can do in the quarter? They marketed the car as being a muscle car, even with the V6. Our cars went 160 stock with our TC's (and can hit 180 fairly easily with no drivetrain mods.) I don't know much about Mustangs so I was surprised to hear just how low that rev limiter is considering the horsepower. To me, that definitely says they were aware the drivetrain isn't suitable for the power of the engine.

FeaRpb
12-20-2011, 04:14 PM
WOw, that sounded horrible.

DrGonzo
12-20-2011, 04:33 PM
I thought almost everyone aiming for performance grabbed the V8 and left the V6 for the girls.

Hey wait now.... I got a V6 mustang but only got the V6 as back when I bought it gas was through the roof, so I needed something economical. Plus I knew it would beat the older model stock GT's.....LOL I was pissed to find out about the Drive train problems but all in all it is my DD. It's pretty decent on gas and it's got enough power to make me happy on my 2 hour round trip to work every day. It's quite comfortable for me being 6'2" and it rides pretty decent. On the plus side I have not had a single issue with it and it's about to turn 100k.

I still prefer driving my Stealth any day!!!! :P

BigTyla
12-20-2011, 04:42 PM
Hey wait now.... I got a V6 mustang but only got the V6 as back when I bought it gas was through the roof, so I needed something economical. Plus I knew it would beat the older model stock GT's.....LOL I was pissed to find out about the Drive train problems but all in all it is my DD. It's pretty decent on gas and it's got enough power to make me happy on my 2 hour round trip to work every day. It's quite comfortable for me being 6'2" and it rides pretty decent. On the plus side I have not had a single issue with it and it's about to turn 100k.

I still prefer driving my Stealth any day!!!! :P

All of the reasons you stated are fine reasons to buy a V6. I just think of modding the V6 platform as analogous to the n/a guys here trying to dump money into their cars to compete with TTs when it's obvious that the TT is the much stronger platform.

DrGonzo
12-20-2011, 04:45 PM
^^^^ Got Ya!!!

Telionis
12-20-2011, 06:53 PM
I didn't know people bought the V6 models for performance. Learn something everyday!

Considering that the v6 version outruns a stock VR4 :( and last generation's 260 hp Mustang GT v8 on the highway (104 mph traps) and on a road course (believe me, it hurts to say, but even the STi got beat). I'd say people do indeed buy them for performance. They are damn near identical to last year's V8, which people considered pretty respectable.


i don't really think you could consider any domestic v6 a "performance engine" before the current crop of coupes. the last domestic 6 that was worth a damn was the syclone--and that was a freakin truck.

Indeed, but the current generation is top notch. All three Detroit powers now offer 300+ hp v6 engines. They are quite advanced too, usually DOHC, 24-valve engines with variable timing and direct injection, etc. That puts them on par with last generation's 350z and Hyundai's current 3.8L Genesis Coupe. It is also way too close [for Nissan's comfort] to the current 370z. For a base engine, that is pretty freaking respectable, especially considering just a year ago the GT got similar power levels from a V8 (as did our beloved VR4s).


Woah, woah woah... You mean to tell me that if I intentionally modify this car it might catastrophically break something in the drive train?

LOL. Not even the Integra owners consider removing the speed governor to be a real mod. This is nothing like putting 860 cc injectors and 20g turbos on a VR4 and destroying the stock transfer-case (bad syncros != exploding driveshaft). Ford advertised this car as a performance vehicle. They claim it is in every way comparable to last year's GT, which is why they specifically offered GT suspension, gears, LSD and brakes as an add-on. As such, there is no excuse for them to skimp out on such a consequential part of the drive-train.

Ford was marketing the v6 as a cheaper, but similarly performing, alternative to the Genesis 3.8, which is capable of reaching 149 mph safely. To imply that their product is comparable, despite it literally falling apart at 135, is downright disingenuous. My Dad's 92 Maxima SE could do 137 mph (according to the magazines), for a "performance" sports-car to self-destruct at speeds that a 20 year old Maxima can handle is downright unacceptable.

Frankly, I consider it a textbook example of bad engineering. A car should never be capable of going fast enough to fall apart. When it comes to top speed, or any performance category for that matter, the limiting factor should always be the car's capabilities (power, drag, gears, grip, etc.), it should never be safety.

I'm surprised that you consider this engineering disparity acceptable just because it is so unintrusive. Yes, admittedly, you have no business doing 115+, but that is not the point at all. Imagine if the problem was more obvious: "don't use the brakes to their fullest extent or the caliper brackets will snap" or "don't ever go WOT because the differential will break, saying "never go as fast as the car is capable of going because the driveshaft will shatter is just as preposterous.


Oh no! you'll have to spend $500 (or less, c'mon, its a Mustang) on a drive shaft if you want to go balls deep into triple digits on a public road in your econo sports car... FORD SUKS!1

I'd be very weary to drive the car aggressively now. Even if you upgrade the driveshaft, who knows what else they skimped on. Maybe you go WOT at the drag-strip and the flywheel explodes... Maybe the suspension is held together with hot glue...

BigTyla
12-20-2011, 07:39 PM
Considering that the v6 version outruns a stock VR4 :( and last generation's 260 hp Mustang GT v8 on the highway (104 mph traps) and on a road course (believe me, it hurts to say, but even the STi got beat). I'd say people do indeed buy them for performance. They are damn near identical to last year's V8, which people considered pretty respectable.

Agreed, but I'm not comparing across platforms, I'm comparing within.

What I'm wondering is if the potential of the V6 platform outweighs the performance difference between it and the V8. In other words, could you invest the difference in cost between the V6 and V8 models in a turbo or supercharger for the V6 and spank the V8s ass?

IPD
12-20-2011, 07:53 PM
Agreed, but I'm not comparing across platforms, I'm comparing within.

What I'm wondering is if the potential of the V6 platform outweighs the performance difference between it and the V8. In other words, could you invest the difference in cost between the V6 and V8 models in a turbo or supercharger for the V6 and spank the V8s ass?

not likely. it's not like they ripped the v6 directly from an ecoboost & simply made it N/A. now slap an ecoboost from an f-150 in there, and you've got a sleeper of biblical proportions...especially once you tweak it a bit. you have MUCH greater bang for the buck by simply buying a GT in the first place. that said, with a GT, there's little upward room you have--unless you spend $$$$$$$ on forced induction. i think the 6's have better hope--at least if said ecoboost transplants are pretty straightforward and somewhat inexpensive.

Turbo Beast
12-20-2011, 11:20 PM
Warranty void!

(i wanna see pics of the damage!!)

EDIT: The new mustang V6 is like when you dip a chip in some salsa and it breaks.

Telionis
12-20-2011, 11:54 PM
Agreed, but I'm not comparing across platforms, I'm comparing within.

What I'm wondering is if the potential of the V6 platform outweighs the performance difference between it and the V8. In other words, could you invest the difference in cost between the V6 and V8 models in a turbo or supercharger for the V6 and spank the V8s ass?

I might have considered that, if the v6 was built well. It'd be like comparing the Genesis turbo 4 with the v6, for $4k the 2.0T should be able to smoke the 3.8. This v6 Mustang might very well do the same, have a notable hp advantage and outrun the V8 for a few grand. BUT, performance is irrelevant if the car is poorly built. Considering what we've seen here, I'd be blown away if the rest of the v6 could handle 400 bhp. If the GT was built like a tank, I'd think that that alone would be worth the difference in price, even if the power and stock performance was the same.

Frankly I wouldn't even consider a v6 stang now (even though I wanted one of the new ones for a while). I'd never even dream of modifying it, the thing falls apart with stock hp, what would it do with a s/c on top?

AdamVR4
12-21-2011, 10:28 AM
...saying "never go as fast as the car is capable of going because the driveshaft will shatter is just as preposterous..

It's capable of 115 mph :p

UTRacerX9
12-21-2011, 11:54 AM
It's capable of 115 mph :p

So was my mother's 1989 Lincoln Towncar. The brakes, unfortunately, weren't up to the task...

:wink:

aaronatstate
12-21-2011, 12:48 PM
not likely. it's not like they ripped the v6 directly from an ecoboost & simply made it N/A. now slap an ecoboost from an f-150 in there, and you've got a sleeper of biblical proportions...especially once you tweak it a bit. you have MUCH greater bang for the buck by simply buying a GT in the first place. that said, with a GT, there's little upward room you have--unless you spend $$$$$$$ on forced induction. i think the 6's have better hope--at least if said ecoboost transplants are pretty straightforward and somewhat inexpensive.

Actually the 3.7L in the Mustang is pretty much an N/A version of the EcoBoost. They use the same block, the 3.7 is just bored 3mm over. I believe they also both have forged rotating assy's too. I think the 3.7 uses an 11:1 compression ratio, and the EcoBoost is 10:1, so not far off there either.

AudibleSilence
12-21-2011, 01:34 PM
Has anyone else reported similar problems?

I mean, maybe I'm just getting old..but I too reserve my lettuce and tomato throwing for actual confirmed problems.

IPD
12-21-2011, 04:14 PM
Actually the 3.7L in the Mustang is pretty much an N/A version of the EcoBoost. They use the same block, the 3.7 is just bored 3mm over. I believe they also both have forged rotating assy's too. I think the 3.7 uses an 11:1 compression ratio, and the EcoBoost is 10:1, so not far off there either.

well that's great. if you can direct transplant it, it's worth it. it's NOT worth it if you have to tear down the damn block so you can alter the compression; although to be honest, if you DID do that, you could lower the compression to 8:1 and start spanking vipers with some upgraded turbos. :p

R/T93
12-21-2011, 05:01 PM
I mean, maybe I'm just getting old..but I too reserve my lettuce and tomato throwing for actual confirmed problems.

Saw a video of a v6 Stang having catastrophic driveshaft failure on a dyno at 135 mph...

i3igpete
12-21-2011, 05:32 PM
I mean, maybe I'm just getting old..but I too reserve my lettuce and tomato throwing for actual confirmed problems.

according to jalopnik front page, there are 4 videos of v6 mustangs blowing driveshafts so far (two on dynos), and more anecdotal evidence.

IPD
12-21-2011, 05:51 PM
according to jalopnik front page, there are 4 videos of v6 mustangs blowing driveshafts so far (two on dynos), and more anecdotal evidence.

the v6 mustang driveshaft is the new GT-R transmission?

BigTyla
12-21-2011, 05:57 PM
the v6 mustang driveshaft is the new v8 mustang transmission?

Fixed.

aaronatstate
12-21-2011, 07:56 PM
So if you want to disable the FACTORY speed limiter, and want to drive it beyond the FACTORY suggested limit, you need to upgrade the driveshaft... Sorry just playing devils advocate again :)

UTRacerX9
12-21-2011, 08:10 PM
So if you want to disable the FACTORY speed limiter, and want to drive it beyond the FACTORY suggested limit, you need to upgrade the driveshaft... Sorry just playing devils advocate again :)

Devils advocate be damned, if they are ripping apart at 125mph, it's almost a guarantee that a catastrophic failure could also occur with repeated 0-60 launches or multiple 1/4 mile runs with no mods whatsoever.

aaronatstate
12-21-2011, 08:26 PM
Devils advocate be damned, if they are ripping apart at 125mph, it's almost a guarantee that a catastrophic failure could also occur with repeated 0-60 launches or multiple 1/4 mile runs with no mods whatsoever.

Who buys a V6 Mustang to race in the first place? LOL If you want to race it, gotta upgrade the driveshaft first!

OBXBoost
12-22-2011, 09:54 AM
Who in their right mind would ever race a car with a V6?

Oh, wait. :(

i3igpete
12-22-2011, 10:56 AM
Have those guys on the mustang forums calculated the critical speed of their shafts yet? It looks awful thin for it's diameter.

aaronatstate
12-22-2011, 11:27 AM
Who in their right mind would ever race a car with a V6?

Oh, wait. :(

Meh if it was the EcoBoost V6 in the Mustang, I'd probably get one. A Twin Turbo V6 is a lot diff than a N/A V6 :)

If I ever get a new V6 Mustang, first thing I'm doing is putting a Shelby driveshaft in it!

92RT-TT
12-22-2011, 02:36 PM
Not saying I like or dislike the ford mustang, but for the price and what you pay it seems to be a pretty good deal.

I'd still take a Challenger over it and if I was spending that much, I'd spend a little more and buy an SRT8 or the GT. IMO no replacement for the V8 rumble.

Then again, no need for a new challenger when I've got a 1970 Cuda ;)

j2k4
12-22-2011, 03:13 PM
...no need for a new challenger when I've got a 1970 Cuda ;)

340?

440?

426?

TonyM
12-22-2011, 04:13 PM
Have those guys on the mustang forums calculated the critical speed of their shafts yet? It looks awful thin for it's diameter.

Exactly.

To me this is a case of the car being fine in stock form, but when you modify it from stock form you need to make the other necessary upgrades to ensure it'll perform to your expectations. This driveshaft deal is aking to someone cranking the boost on a stock 3S without any fuel mods and complaining Mitsu undersized the injectors and set the car up to fail, overhyped it, blah blah . . .

The V6 Stang uses a pretty thin 1-piece aluminum driveshaft I believe (to keep rotational mass down and achieve their coveted 31mpg highway number). The GT uses a two piece for obvious reasons. Solution? If you want to go fast in a V6, upgrade the drive-shaft. Otherwise, keep your 115 limiter in place and enjoy your 31mpg "muscle" car. ;)

Chris@Rvengeperformance
12-22-2011, 04:21 PM
What is the big deal here? If you operate your car in conditions outside of its design limitations failure may follow. What is a driveshaft for a mustang anyway? $250?

Telionis
12-22-2011, 07:57 PM
Meh

Well, the n/a V6 does pretty well in the 370Z.


if it was the EcoBoost V6 in the Mustang, I'd probably get one. A Twin Turbo V6 is a lot diff than a N/A V6 :)

An ecoboost Mustang would be awesome!

In Australia, Ford offers the Falcon in both turbo-6 or v8. Both made about the same power, both were about the same price, and both were considered the "upgraded engine" over the base I6; the only difference was the character of the car. In fact, when FPV (their SVT) got a chance to make a special version, they made one of each. FPY just recently released an even more powerful version of the car with a s/c V8, but they still offer the n/a V8 (422 bhp / 402 ft-lbs) and turbo I-6 (416 bhp / 417 ft-lbs). It'd be awesome if Ford did the same in the US with the Mustang GT.


If I ever get a new V6 Mustang, first thing I'm doing is putting a Shelby driveshaft in it!

Somehow, I doubt that the drive-shaft is the only part on the entire car that they skimped on.

AudibleSilence
12-22-2011, 08:07 PM
Well, the n/a V6 does pretty well in the 370Z.

It's also 200+lbs lighter and has better balance, suspension, and basically anything and everything you'd need to have it be a better track car.


Somehow, I doubt that the drive-shaft is the only part on the entire car that they skimped on.

Skimped? They put a limiter on the car to prevent you from having exactly this happening. People are acting like these things are blowing up left and right at 60mph. Don't want to be limited to 115mph? Don't buy a smurfing v6 Mustang.

green-lantern
12-22-2011, 08:54 PM
I didn't know people bought the V6 models for performance. Learn something everyday!

This! or any mustang really :p

arm0red1
12-23-2011, 01:00 AM
this! Or any mustang really :p


hatuhs gonna hate!

92RT-TT
12-23-2011, 01:23 AM
340?

440?

426?

Its a 383... but soon to be a twin turbo 383 :D

j2k4
12-23-2011, 08:27 AM
Its a 383... but soon to be a twin turbo 383 :D

Oh, Dan, at least root out a 440 to drop in for a TT setup...

Alex3000gt
12-23-2011, 10:52 AM
What is the speed rating of the tires? Could be another accident waiting to happen.

UTRacerX9
12-23-2011, 11:31 AM
Skimped? They put a limiter on the car to prevent you from having exactly this happening. People are acting like these things are blowing up left and right at 60mph.

I have a feeling that in a few years, we'll hear a lot more about driveshaft failures from stock cars, just from people who engage in stoplight races or occasionally take it to the track. It really doesn't make any sense to have cut corners on the driveshaft, as others have noted, it would cost ~$250 for one of us to put an upgraded shaft on it? That probably equates to about $50 for Ford to have done it with a proper size/strength DS from the get go.

green-lantern
12-23-2011, 04:02 PM
hatuhs gonna hate!

Yep :lo5l:


http://www.google.com/url?source=imglanding&ct=img&q=http://www.funny2k.com/sites/default/files/styles/large/public/Pictures/Haters-Gonna-Hate_1.jpg&sa=X&ei=6N30TvC9EoLx0gGGxc2mAg&ved=0CAsQ8wc4cA&usg=AFQjCNEgh_y4cI_k5fmFrpaXFaeweADqmw


I see so many Mustangs around here it makes me want to puke.

BigTyla
12-23-2011, 05:40 PM
Yep :lo5l:


http://www.google.com/url?source=imglanding&ct=img&q=http://www.funny2k.com/sites/default/files/styles/large/public/Pictures/Haters-Gonna-Hate_1.jpg&sa=X&ei=6N30TvC9EoLx0gGGxc2mAg&ved=0CAsQ8wc4cA&usg=AFQjCNEgh_y4cI_k5fmFrpaXFaeweADqmw

I see so many Mustangs around here it makes me want to puke.

Better than seeing a Camaro though.

IPD
12-23-2011, 05:49 PM
Better than seeing a Camaro though.

so many goddamn camaros in this town. there's a lot of mustangs too...but the number of NEW style mustangs is dwarfed by all the fox bodies thru 04 shitpiles.

green-lantern
12-23-2011, 05:50 PM
Better than seeing a Camaro though.

Lot's of those too but I guess you could say I'm more of a Chevy guy when it comes to domestics. :D


I'd give my left nut for a ford GT though.

IPD
12-23-2011, 06:09 PM
Lot's of those too but I guess you could say I'm more of a Chevy guy when it comes to domestics. :D


I'd give my left nut for a ford GT though.

screw the GT. both nuts for a last-production-year pantera.

green-lantern
12-23-2011, 06:39 PM
screw the GT. both nuts for a last-production-year pantera.

Both nuts > Pantera

Is the 3s not unreliable enough for you Thadd?

HilbillyHomeboy
12-23-2011, 07:16 PM
What is the speed rating of the tires? Could be another accident waiting to happen.

I believe they are T, which is 118 mph. They use the Michelin energy savers, which is another trick they're using to get the 31mpg.

Jeremy

R/T93
12-23-2011, 07:19 PM
I believe they are T, which is 118 mph. They use the Michelin energy savers, which is another trick they're using to get the 31mpg.

Jeremy

As ABM said, CAFE laws are governing car design and production, for the worse.

Sent from my ADR6350 using Tapatalk

Ninja Performance
12-24-2011, 12:15 AM
And it's an auto LOL

That sound is horrific. I would have shat myself LOL

-Chris

IPD
12-24-2011, 01:08 AM
Both nuts > Pantera

Is the 3s not unreliable enough for you Thadd?

351 cleveland? fuck yes. add some turbos and i'm in heaven. plus the body on the 91's is sexxxxy.

AudibleSilence
01-31-2012, 10:07 AM
I have a feeling that in a few years, we'll hear a lot more about driveshaft failures from stock cars, just from people who engage in stoplight races or occasionally take it to the track. It really doesn't make any sense to have cut corners on the driveshaft, as others have noted, it would cost ~$250 for one of us to put an upgraded shaft on it? That probably equates to about $50 for Ford to have done it with a proper size/strength DS from the get go.

Your logic is flawed. My 4L65e is rated to 400hp. GM put tq management on the trans and engine to govern how much hp and tq can flow through it. If I blow it up after removing those limiters and pushing +400hp/tq does that mean that GM skimped or that I am a fucking tool for bitching about a limimitation to a hard part that they built in safeguards around? Basically at this point if your driveshaft fails from going faster than the limiter allows you are a fucking moron.

I find it hilarious that any time someone talks about changing something on a car on a car forum, someone always swoops in like Spider-Man to talk about how the engineers that get paid tons and manufacturerers that pay a ton in R&D know better..but here we second guess them because we are defeating a safety that they installed on the damn car to prevent just what you're complaining about. You want to go +110mph? Don't buy a v6 Mustang...it is just that simple.

p.s. Big difference between blowing them up at cruising speed and blowing them up at almost double that.

R/T93
01-31-2012, 10:19 AM
Pretty sure a 74 pinto driveshaft is safe at 135 mph. A car developed nearly 40 years later is engineered worse than that?
Ford fail.

AudibleSilence
01-31-2012, 10:29 AM
They also exploded when hit from the rear.... Still want a pinto over a Mustang? It is also nonsensical to compare top speeds of cars without taking into account the materials used for the driveshaft and the driveshaft thickness/diameter. The new driveshaft might be more efficient, lighter, and relatively stronger considering the power output between the cars. Pete was on the money.

R/T93
01-31-2012, 11:15 AM
Point is, there are much less performance oriented cars with driveshafts that are safe at 115% of their "limited" top speed. Most cars are probably good to at least 150%. Why isn't the v6 stang?

Sent from my ADR6350 using Tapatalk

AudibleSilence
01-31-2012, 12:00 PM
Point is, there are much less performance oriented cars with driveshafts that are safe at 115% of their "limited" top speed. Most cars are probably good to at least 150%. Why isn't the v6 stang?

Sent from my ADR6350 using Tapatalk

Sigh.. Where are you getting these percentages from? What "limited" cars do you speak of?

Edit: NM I honestly don't care anymore.. You guys are still bitching over something retarded. I.E. the right to circumvent factory safeguards without damaging a car.

j2k4
01-31-2012, 12:23 PM
The thing is, we're just not used to hearing of stock-ish cars destroying their driveshafts, period.

AudibleSilence
01-31-2012, 12:35 PM
The thing is, we're just not used to hearing of stock-ish cars destroying their driveshafts, period.

Happens often actually....just depends on the application.

TonyM
01-31-2012, 12:44 PM
The thing is, we're just not used to hearing of stock-ish cars destroying their driveshafts, period.

Thing is, once the speed limiter was removed that car ceased to be "stock".

j2k4
01-31-2012, 12:52 PM
Thing is, once the speed limiter was removed that car ceased to be "stock".

That's why I said "-ish", Tony. :)

HilbillyHomeboy
01-31-2012, 01:14 PM
Both points are well received, IMO. Removing an important safety feature, well, you can't really bitch about what happens next. At the same time, it is peculiar that these driveshafts reach/exceed critical like this. V-6 or not, the common conception is that a Mustang is a hi-po car(which is why people are up in arms over this).

The best that comes out of this mess is a now known failure point that can easily be corrected if one wants to exceed the factory speed limiter.

Jeremy

j2k4
01-31-2012, 01:55 PM
Both points are well received, IMO. Removing an important safety feature, well, you can't really bitch about what happens next. At the same time, it is peculiar that these driveshafts reach/exceed critical like this. V-6 or not, the common conception is that a Mustang is a hi-po car(which is why people are up in arms over this).

The best that comes out of this mess is a now known failure point that can easily be corrected if one wants to exceed the factory speed limiter.

Jeremy

Thus endeth this thread. :)

mb3000
01-31-2012, 06:15 PM
If you designed a park bench, you would need to test how much weight it could support, right? Lets say a relatively small bench, so it is tested and safety rated at 600lbs. Would you engineer the bench to support 610lbs, or would you engineer it to hold 750, just in case?

In my eyes, this is a large aspect of quality.

HilbillyHomeboy
01-31-2012, 09:02 PM
If you designed a park bench, you would need to test how much weight it could support, right? Lets say a relatively small bench, so it is tested and safety rated at 600lbs. Would you engineer the bench to support 610lbs, or would you engineer it to hold 750, just in case?

In my eyes, this is a large aspect of quality.

All things have specific limits for a reason. The idiot factor is not a liability to the engineer(s).

Jeremy

AudibleSilence
01-31-2012, 09:15 PM
If you designed a park bench, you would need to test how much weight it could support, right? Lets say a relatively small bench, so it is tested and safety rated at 600lbs. Would you engineer the bench to support 610lbs, or would you engineer it to hold 750, just in case?

In my eyes, this is a large aspect of quality.


All things have specific limits for a reason. The idiot factor is not a liability to the engineer(s).

Jeremy

And the idiot that knows it is limited to 610lbs and tries to put 750 on it is...well an idiot. Kinda like an idiot that loads an elevator past its weight limit. This is why they began putting printed limits well below what the elevator can carry, because of special people that like to tempt fate and then bitch about it later.

IPD
01-31-2012, 09:41 PM
And the idiot that knows it is limited to 610lbs and tries to put 750 on it is...well an idiot. Kinda like an idiot that loads an elevator past its weight limit. This is why they began putting printed limits well below what the elevator can carry, because of special people that like to tempt fate and then bitch about it later.

the REAL idiot is someone who believes that the tolerance limit should be 1% or less difference from the tested strength. such a person is an idiot because offering any product with such a thin margin of error gives no room for prolonged stress, fatigue, or momentary overstress (like the 250lbs man who PLOPS down on a sofa, rather than gingerly being seated). defend FROD all you want, there's still a reason why their name stands for:

Found
On
Roadside
Dead

AudibleSilence
01-31-2012, 11:17 PM
I'm not defending anyone, I'm calling people retarded for complaining about parts failure after exceeding limits the engineers put a system in place to keep you behind. None of those failures were instant, they occurred after seconds of running on the wrong side of the redline for the driveshaft. Your example of the man plopping down is flawed.

mb3000
02-01-2012, 01:10 AM
I'm not defending anyone, I'm calling people retarded for complaining about parts failure after exceeding limits the engineers put a system in place to keep you behind. None of those failures were instant, they occurred after seconds of running on the wrong side of the redline for the driveshaft. Your example of the man plopping down is flawed.

The new v6 mustang driveshaft is flawed.

onebadmollafolla
02-01-2012, 04:35 AM
Pretty sure a 74 pinto driveshaft is safe at 135 mph. A car developed nearly 40 years later is engineered worse than that?
Ford fail.

This is all relative though. One drive shaft could easily take speeds of 135mph as could the other. However, if one had a lot more power going to it at the time it could very well break. Same thing, and much more commonly seen at lower speeds. Not defending Ford's inadequacy, just giving perspective. :)

j2k4
02-01-2012, 08:06 AM
What I will take from this thread:



Plop = flawed :wink:

IPD
02-01-2012, 01:35 PM
What I will take from this thread:



Plop = flawed :wink:

rofl.