PDA

View Full Version : Hershey's



a2j
11-28-2011, 08:21 AM
http://youtu.be/8-h8EBP0JSs

I personally know one guy that appears in this video a few times. Video, obviously, does not tell everything...

stealthify
11-28-2011, 10:36 AM
Maybe I'm just feeling a bit callous today, but is this video basically about people that decided to come to America in order to partake in unskilled labor, and they're upset because they're getting paid unskilled labor wages and having to work in the conditions usually associated with that?

To give them the benefit of a doubt, were they tricked into working at Hershey's? Were they promised a managerial position or something other than packing boxes? Did any of them do any actual research on the likely tasks they would be doing?

a2j
11-28-2011, 10:53 AM
let me fill in some background...
some of those workers, paid all of their money (and then some) to come and work at US (Hershey's). This is some kind of summer exchange student program, or whatever. Because of this, Hershey's don't have to pay taxes (or some of them). They came legally. Average weekly pay is little over $100. after all of "mandatory" deductions (like housing, transportation, etc) that you can not opt out of, ~$8/hour. They were told that if they will strike, they will be deported without any chance to get back in US at all, ever. Hershey's and organizers of this exchange program make money on these students. New students come and go every 4 months. This was going on for ever.
Like I said, video does not say enough, and I just unable to tell everything right now.

stealthify
11-28-2011, 11:14 AM
Still doesn't quite add up.

I'm not sure what the living conditions are like where most of these exchange students are from (they do state third-world a few times), but if Hersey's is paying room and board here in America, transportation, etc, and paying them $100/week on top of that, they're basically getting paid the same as our domestic minimum wage workers.

The video doesn't specifically state where the 3-4 grand per student goes in order for them to join the student exchange program. I'd imagine a lot of this goes towards round-trip international airfare, temporary moving expenses, government paperwork, etc. This needs to be clarified.

UTRacerX9
11-28-2011, 11:31 AM
The video doesn't specifically state where the 3-4 grand per student goes in order for them to join the student exchange program. I'd imagine a lot of this goes towards round-trip international airfare, temporary moving expenses, government paperwork, etc. This needs to be clarified.

Bingo. Friend of mine from Brazil came over and did this same type of thing, working at Disney in Orlando. He and a bunch of other students basically lived in a dorm type building, not too far from Disney. (If you look into how much a hotel room costs anywhere near Disney, you'll see it's VERY expensive.) A bus/shuttle came and picked them up for their shift, and the rest of the time when they weren't working, they could do whatever they wanted. He had a great time.

EDIT: A quick search shows that a round trip flight from RIO to Miami is about $2000. That obviously doesn't include Visa fees, passport fees, etc.

AgentOblivious
11-28-2011, 11:43 AM
J-1 visa - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/J-1_visa)

They were there on J-1 visas, and were there as university students, expecting a placement/travel...its bad when they're coming from China and saying that your work conditions suck...also, old news.

a2j
11-28-2011, 11:51 AM
iirc, there ware deducted $400 per month for a room/apartment. 4 people per apartment. $1600, imho a "little" too much. you could move out, but they would still deduct those $400...

stealthify
11-28-2011, 12:01 PM
iirc, there ware deducted $400 per month for a room/apartment. 4 people per apartment. $1600, imho a "little" too much. you could move out, but they would still deduct those $400...

What are the living conditions like in these condos/apartments? 4 bedroom? Utilities included? Good location?

Around here, in the middle of nowhere, a 4 bedroom apartment with utilities, worry-free and included transportation, etc for four individuals could easily cost over $1200-$1600/mo. A one bedroom apartment alone costs around $600-$750.

If this is an issue over making these deductions mandatory, I don't think Hershey's is to blame for this. This is more likely about government regulations made to ensure non-immigrant workers live healthily and safely while they complete their exchange program.

Thank me if I'm right, grill me if I'm wrong.

eljefefx
11-28-2011, 12:18 PM
Occupy Hershey's?

green-lantern
11-28-2011, 12:26 PM
Occupy Hershey's?

:lmao:

vr4chick
11-28-2011, 07:41 PM
What are the living conditions like in these condos/apartments? 4 bedroom? Utilities included? Good location?

Around here, in the middle of nowhere, a 4 bedroom apartment with utilities, worry-free and included transportation, etc for four individuals could easily cost over $1200-$1600/mo. A one bedroom apartment alone costs around $600-$750.

If this is an issue over making these deductions mandatory, I don't think Hershey's is to blame for this. This is more likely about government regulations made to ensure non-immigrant workers live healthily and safely while they complete their exchange program.

Thank me if I'm right, grill me if I'm wrong.

Hershey is a nice, clean and pretty city. They should stop complaining. Look at the homeless in this country.

AgentOblivious
11-28-2011, 09:01 PM
Hershey is a nice, clean and pretty city. They should stop complaining. Look at the homeless in this country.

I bet you'd be pissed too if you paid $4000 for what you thought would be a learning opportunity related to your field of study, with a chance to see the sights, and ended up being Hershey's discount factory worker...it doesn't matter what the apartments were like.

green-lantern
11-28-2011, 09:05 PM
I bet you'd be pissed too if you paid $4000 for what you thought would be a learning opportunity related to your field of study, with a chance to see the sights, and ended up being Hershey's discount factory worker...it doesn't matter what the apartments were like.

Sounds like a learning experience to me. lol

AgentOblivious
11-28-2011, 09:18 PM
Sounds like a learning experience to me. lol

Ya, but is that what you want foreign up-and-comers to think of your country?

stealthify
11-28-2011, 09:39 PM
I bet you'd be pissed too if you paid $4000 for what you thought would be a learning opportunity related to your field of study, with a chance to see the sights, and ended up being Hershey's discount factory worker...it doesn't matter what the apartments were like.

You're kidding me, right?

Sure, lifting boxes and moving them from point A to point B is crappy work. Though, from how they described it in the video, it looked far from a sweatshop. The working condition in Hershey's plant looked MUCH better than the factories in the third-world countries where these students are likely from.

As I said, I don't know exactly what these students were promised other than a chance to live in the United States for a solid 3-months, with a place to stay, a stable job, and most of the amenities needed to live reasonably comfortable. The work may not be the highlight of their stay, but nothing is preventing them from going out and enjoying what the U.S. has to offer during their off-hours. This includes experiencing and participating in the culture and sights they came here for in the first place.

UTRacerX9
11-28-2011, 10:21 PM
My friend from Brazil just entered his last year of school for engineering there, and has a paid internship there. He didn't come to America to get a job that was related to his field, he came just to come here, see the sights, and be able to work to pay for the trip. He never had any illusions that he would be getting a job in line with his academic resume at Disney, he worked as a ticket attendant and on several of the rides.

Somehow, I highly doubt that Disney or Hershey, or any other companies here would come out and say that the jobs they are looking to be filled will be matched up with the students career path.

green-lantern
11-28-2011, 11:16 PM
Ya, but is that what you want foreign up-and-comers to think of your country?

Not sure about up and comers and I might actually agree with you to a point but I guess I just don't care a whole lot. No offense to the OP and the guy he knows but it seems like another waa waa waa I had to actually work crybaby crap I have come to really get sick of hearing about. I've dug ditches behind backhoes, theses pussies don't know hard labor. If anything the vacation they thought they were going to get was misrepresented. Life is a bitch and expensive, hard work and educated decisions is how you make something of yourself. I'm sure it wasn't what they thought, I hope the packing of chocolate didn't ruin her surgical career.

AgentOblivious
11-28-2011, 11:47 PM
Well I found the company that set them up with Hershey:Students for the Work and Travel Program offered by CETUSA - Council for Educational Travel, USA (http://www.cetusa.org/public/offers/work-and-travel-program/for/students)


If you decide to participate on the CETUSA Work and Travel Program, you are in for an adventure! The Work and Travel Program offers you a chance to spend your summer vacation in the U.S. while working for an American company. You will experience firsthand what life is like for a typical American young adult. You will gain valuable work and life experience, expand your resume, improve your English, have opportunity to travel in the U.S., make great memories and form lasting relationships. No matter where you end up in the U.S., your Work and Travel Program is sure to be a summer you will never forget!

Pretty sad when the Chinese kids are complaining...

thor'svr4
11-28-2011, 11:52 PM
I've worked in a factory for 4 years now. What they described sounds fairly normal. If I only work 40hrs/week ill take home ~1200 per month. Minus rent, gas, insurance, food I would be very lucky to have 400 left over. IF I only worked 40hrs/week these people would be making more money than me. Lucky for me I work ~72hrs/week.

The only part of this video that really stood out was when the girl mentioned that she has to move 50kg (110lb) boxes. That is extremely heavy assuming its something that they do continuously through-out the day.

I think we need more info. No one mentioned if stuff like food was included in the deductions. Or if they were informed of the hourly rate/deductions before they came to America to work.

One thing I dont understand is why someone who's a Med major would ever apply to Hershey? She had to know it would have nothing at all to do with her major. So why would someone come from a third world country to work in America at a factory only to go back to third world country? Its not like it would even look good on a future resume...

93STLTH
11-28-2011, 11:55 PM
A couple of those girls made me want to pack some Hershey fudge. :DevilSmile:

AgentOblivious
11-29-2011, 12:02 AM
I've worked in a factory for 4 years now. What they described sounds fairly normal. If I only work 40hrs/week ill take home ~1200 per month. Minus rent, gas, insurance, food I would be very lucky to have 400 left over. IF I only worked 40hrs/week these people would be making more money than me. Lucky for me I work ~72hrs/week.

The only part of this video that really stood out was when the girl mentioned that she has to move 50kg (110lb) boxes. That is extremely heavy assuming its something that they do continuously through-out the day.

I think we need more info. No one mentioned if stuff like food was included in the deductions. Or if they were informed of the hourly rate/deductions before they came to America to work.

One thing I dont understand is why someone who's a Med major would ever apply to Hershey? She had to know it would have nothing at all to do with her major. So why would someone come from a third world country to work in America at a factory only to go back to third world country? Its not like it would even look good on a future resume...

According to CETUSA, they were all notified of the work, cost of rent, etc. beforehand. Then again, the example contracts that they gave in their press release were in english only, so who knows how much smoke was blown up the student's ass when they signed it, and how much they understood. My guess is that they consider it something along the lines of what backpacking in Europe would be for us.

I can't see why Hershey couldn't cut them some slack, considering how many taxes its avoiding paying, and how many dollars its saving not having to pay the union premium of their regular workers.

eljefefx
11-29-2011, 12:49 AM
Overblown issue.

IPD
11-29-2011, 06:43 AM
Overblown issue.

agreed. leave it to our resident canuck liberal to bandwagon how horrible shit is in the USA...while completely glossing over the conditions in chinese factories like foxconn and universally throughout UAE (and Qatar, i'd wager).

you know what? EVERYONE in the USA is in the 1%. EVERYONE. even the damn bum living in a cardboard box: 1%-er. stop bitching.

green-lantern
11-29-2011, 07:27 AM
http://2.bp.blogspot.com/_jWNhyMUpjSE/SZnPrS3BseI/AAAAAAAACvY/--BGiZRJ01Y/s400/fudge_packer.jpg

a2j
11-29-2011, 10:02 AM
I can't speak for all of them, but some were willing to work. That was the main reason to come from a 3rd world countries to earn some money, or at least make enough to cover those $4k. some of them will return to their families, that are in debt because of this trip, and won't even have money to buy food.
I lived in 3 different places on a globe, speak 3 languages, I know the difference. US is not china, stop comparing these two. The way I see it, these workers got screwed big time. I'm sure NONE of us would want that to happen.