View Full Version : After 60K of beating @ 500hp let's see how it looks?
J. Fast
10-09-2011, 06:53 PM
No spun bearing, no knock, no nothing. I just hit 60K on my build and I'm curious to see how well she was built last time and how the bearings are doing. Compression is around 145 +/- on all cylinders. I haven't refreshed this engine since I rebuilt in 2007. It has a Wiseco Piston and Pauter Rod Forged bottom. She's treated me pretty good so I'm going to undress her and take a look at the bottom end, do some headwork, and work on a few things when the engine's pulled. Hopefully I put it all back together again and have it running before Valentines Day. This will be the winter project along with all the panel, paint, and acrylic glass work.
Couple of questions before I dig into this.
1) Is my ARP hardware re-usable? Rods, Mains, and Headstuds?
2) Best headgasket to come back with?
3) Mic'd tolerances for the crank?
4) Good place to get a full gasket/rebuild kit?
Last time I used Top Line rebuild kit and a few of the gaskets failed such as the oil pump seal, two cam seals and two of the oil feed line gaskets. Won't be going back with that one again. Who and where do I get a solid kit with legit performance parts?
UTRacerX9
10-09-2011, 07:01 PM
At 500hp I wouldn't worry about the ARP stuff. I'd just say to avoid most of the Ebay gasket kits, several members have either been missing a few gaskets, or they are poor quality over the years. 3SX has several kit options IIRC so you can pick and choose.
J. Fast
10-09-2011, 07:18 PM
I used an E-gay top line gasket kit last time back and it was complete but a few of the seals were complete crap. Oil pump seal... comeon, that's a big friggin leak. Hrm I will look at 3sx. Or I will wait for IPS black friday sale in a month or so for an oem kit :)
2fnloud
10-09-2011, 09:31 PM
In for knowledge.
fullracegt
10-10-2011, 12:17 AM
from my experience oem gaskets are well worth the money.
and good luck with the rebuild!!
-matt
niterydr
10-10-2011, 02:07 AM
I've always had great luck using mitsubishi gaskets. I am a fan of ARP hardware as it typically isn't TTY like some of the factory stuff is, plus the higher tensile strength (in most cases) is always a plus. For the heads it appears that the stock head bolts really are the way to go as the heads seem to "lift" no matter the stud or bolt utilized.
My answers
1) Maybe, depends upon what you torqued it to and how many times you've torqued them.
2) Stock with copper spray would get my vote
3) I try to shoot for the tight end for most motors unless you are shooting for high boost and nitrous. My last car was running 36psi and a 60 dry shot on the twin 50 trims when we finally lifted the heads, bearings were great (King bearings) and didn't spin, tolerances were middle to high end of spec because we knew it was going to be an "all" boost situation. Redline 20w50 was used in that engine and changed every 1000 or less miles for safety.
4) Mitsubishi? (I am a little out of touch as I did take a few year hiatus)
In for results!
mehrshadvr4
10-10-2011, 02:33 AM
oem head bolts and head gasket are the way to go. i would replace main studs with new ones also.
J. Fast
10-10-2011, 08:58 AM
So ARP is not the way to go? I know you can use the over torque method on the OEM's but I already have these and that's $600 worth of hardware. I can't reuse any of this?
I do still have my original OEM mains and headstuds, they were never leaned on, ever.
Headgasket, I will change for sure. I was also thinking about a stainless or copper O-ring and putting compression rods on the deck too.
2fnloud
10-10-2011, 09:00 AM
Why not go and have Ray do the "head lift fix" if you are concerned with lift?
niterydr
10-10-2011, 10:59 AM
I agree, get the head lift fix. In my experience with the super high strength A1 research headstuds, they help, but not as much as you'd think. The factory hardware is very strong. If you didn't overtorque the ARP's, you should be fine to torque them back down + a little for stretch, especially if you only used them once.
TurboSinceBirth
10-12-2011, 01:04 AM
I won't go back to ARP head studs. They're smaller in diameter than OEM head bolts believe it or not so even though the material is stronger they give out much sooner than OEM. I plan to use ARP main studs. Most of the Pampena motors use ARP mains and rod bolts, then the head bolt choice is left up to the customer. OEM FTW!
Permanent grin
10-12-2011, 05:12 AM
This was a discussion in the UK
has anyone fitted these?
reason i ask is that when i stripped my old engine last week the centre 8 bolts holding the centre mains were noticeably slacker than the outer 8 bolts!! i have yet to measure them but they appear to have stretched thus causing main bearing failure on my centre 2 mains only!!! the outer 2 main bearings were perfect!
Ye I am pretty sure the crank has flexed, the 2 centre journels are shot! I am just trying to work on a viable solution for my new engine! I know it will not cure it completly!
by GTO NEMESIS » Sun Aug 21, 2011 8:29 pm
Mine were all equally tight and no issues with bearing wear.
I went with stock as this is what Ray Pampena suggested I should use.
ok i have had chance to measure the bolts today
i have measured 4 of the 8 centre mains and 4 of the 8 outer mains
the 4 centre mains measure:
104.49mm
104.51mm
104.54mm
104.57mm
the 4 outer mains measure:
104.38mm
104.38mm
104.39mm
104.40mm
André
J. Fast
10-12-2011, 09:52 AM
This was a discussion in the UK
André
Was it a high horsepower engine? My engine alone is in the 650+hp range. I would have to say I'm pretty reluctant to believe they torqued them down properly with numbers all over the place like that. With stretch numbers like that it first appears a torque wrench was used to install the ARP's? Using a torque wrench on ARP hardware is a big no no! You use a stretch gauge. Measure the stretch progressively till you get within the thou (0.001) in the revised ARP Stretch Torque spec reference guide. The guide says for every "x" of mic'd stretch the bolt is exactly "y" torque. If you overstretch by .001" you're overtorqued and supposed to throw them away or send then in for a single replacement. Can you ask the owner (or maybe send them over here) how they installed them, i.e. which torque method did they use; Torque wrench, Torque Angle, or Stretch Gauge?
A stretch gauge was used when building this motor roughly 5 years ago, I think I wrote down all the spec's for the mains, rods, and headstuds. I Also have all the mic #'s for the journals, and bearings, to include bearing weights and the weights of each piece of the rotating assembly (even the oil pump gears). Crankwalk specs, torque measurements, type of dino oil, type of gasket (wether it was Topline or OEM), I snapped pictures and wrote everything down.
Those numbers are pretty crazy and would normally leave me skeptical. However, the majority of my crew is running ARP Hardware on their DSM's and Evo's and I dwarf them on power. For the most part all of them are pretty much 1000hp engines and all are using ARP. The only exception in the crew is Erron S and I think he actually stretched the OEM headstuds when he tested the limits of his build. I know at one point in time he lifted the head (or better yet, compressed the deck), but I don't know if he measured for bolt stretch though? I don't even know if he mic'd the bolts and reused them or put in new? I'll ask him today.
I've always wondered in the back of my mind if that's why he's been battling high temps the last few years, if he stretched the headstuds and the engine separates at the deck when he tries to cram too much in there. We would've found out for sure last Saturday. Our crew was supposed to go to High Plains Raceway for a track day. Unfortunately it snowed and rained all day so we postponed and started taking our cars apart. After the first snow that's pretty much what we all do every Winter :p.
I will definitely report back with stretch resuls, if any, on the rods, mains, and headstuds. It wil be interesting to see if I get similar results. If so, I'll have to find something else.
Permanent grin
10-12-2011, 11:01 AM
I don't know but I'll ask. Interesting thought though.
The car was running 506 hp and 520 ft lbs on the equivalent to 91 MON
André
paulw1028
10-14-2011, 08:17 AM
I don't know but I'll ask. Interesting thought though.
The car was running 506 hp and 520 ft lbs on the equivalent to 91 MON
André
Hi guys, the above quotes from the uk were from me :)
it seems there has been some mis interpretation in the journey across the pond!!! :rolleyes3:
the discussion was about my stock main bolts stretching due to possible crank flex.
Paul
J. Fast
10-14-2011, 09:58 AM
I don't know but I'll ask. Interesting thought though.
The car was running 506 hp and 520 ft lbs on the equivalent to 91 MON
André
I've had several discussions with Erron about headlift and hardware strength. We've even discussed tension, compression, and the tensile strength test conducted by a 3/S member on ARP headstuds compared to OEM headstuds. Surprisingly, the results of the test illustrated COLD OEM studs resisted tension and compression more than COLD ARP studs. OEM studs could take more than the ARP's before deformation.
My questions regarding the test were, "What were the test results when the bolts were heated up to 600* and tested? Engines only stretch headstuds under severe conditions right, were the studs heated when tested? Were they torqued down using a torque plate to see if the deck deformed when you pushed them that far?" The answer was "No!"
Does that mean OEM is superior or better suited? Not to me, especially when I KNOW, ARP hardware is keeping 5 little 2.0 litre Mitsu engines together with HUGE horspower and it's never failed.
If I remember way back, maybe 5 + years, ARP admitted some of their studs were failing due to them not publishing torque stretch specs. Engine builders were using torque wrenches to install their hardware and it was failing. They've since corrrected the problem, published new installation procedures, retested, and refined their products. You buy ARP hardware now and it's good!
Hi guys, the above quotes from the uk were from me :)
it seems there has been some mis interpretation in the journey across the pond!!! :rolleyes3:
the discussion was about my stock main bolts stretching due to possible crank flex.
Paul
Was your engine out of balance or something? Were they re-used main's or were they new? What method were they torqued with on install?
futurevr4man
10-14-2011, 01:29 PM
USE OEM PLEASE. headgaskets, headbolts, mains... use oem!! there is a reasons ray hasnt had to tear his engine apart since ~05'. thats a good amount of time for 700+ hp to the wheels (right at 1100 most of the time). OEM headgaskets are by far the best, and im speaking from experience of buying ebay, 3sx, and now i have oem sitting in my garage. the quality is just something else.
i bought all my stuff from mitsparts.com which is the only way to order from cherry hill now. use "3SI" as your coupon code to recieve a little extra off the price.
i plan on running close to 700 wheel on my 3.7 build all the time. the car is not going to be my dd, but it should still start, idle, and drive well enough to be one as far as im concerned. OEM is where its at with these engines.
familyMAN
10-14-2011, 02:01 PM
there is a reasons ray hasnt had to tear his engine apart since ~05'.
Actually for accuracy, Ray tore it down this summer to put in his billet crank. Your point is still still valid though.
futurevr4man
10-14-2011, 02:11 PM
ah, true. lol i suck.
paulw1028
10-15-2011, 01:33 PM
Was your engine out of balance or something? Were they re-used main's or were they new? What method were they torqued with on install?
it was a stock motor, the bottom end had never been touched.
Paul
green-lantern
10-15-2011, 02:40 PM
USE OEM PLEASE. headgaskets, headbolts, mains... use oem!! there is a reasons ray hasnt had to tear his engine apart since ~05'. thats a good amount of time for 700+ hp to the wheels (right at 1100 most of the time). OEM headgaskets are by far the best, and im speaking from experience of buying ebay, 3sx, and now i have oem sitting in my garage. the quality is just something else.
i bought all my stuff from mitsparts.com which is the only way to order from cherry hill now. use "3SI" as your coupon code to recieve a little extra off the price.
i plan on running close to 700 wheel on my 3.7 build all the time. the car is not going to be my dd, but it should still start, idle, and drive well enough to be one as far as im concerned. OEM is where its at with these engines.
This
Cherry hill is a great place to get stock parts.
If you are doing head work then before you start send them to Ray for the head lift fix.
Powered by vBulletin® Version 4.2.3 Copyright © 2026 vBulletin Solutions, Inc. All rights reserved.