View Full Version : engine cyl walls / rust question
TajMan
08-28-2011, 01:59 PM
Ok, it happens for various reasons, water can get into engines and water on unprotected steel = rust.
I recently pulled my old Stealth SOHC engine apart that Jordan still owned, he had left it sitting in the dirt uncovered and rain could go right into the lower intake manifold.
Rust was BAD. Some work to scrape cyl walls and get pistons out the top, my goal was to salvage possibly pistons but mainly rods and crankshaft.
http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v608/TajMan/100_0282.jpg
I recently also pulled the head off my Talon to fix, it overheated bad warping the head a few months ago and has just been sitting that way.
Well, I guess from driving the car just a few more times at the end, and from topping off plain water in cooling system to keep it going for a few more miles.... coolant in engine was mostly water alone and of course some of it pooled on top of pistons as car just sat... THIS caused rust.
Not to the point of having to dis-assemble the bottom end again I believe, but requires some good cleanup now and requires oil/filter changed quickly a couple times after I get it running again.
My question, after I carefully scrape surface rust from cyl walls, what is the best sandpaper to hit those rust spots with lightly?
1,000 grit or 1,500 grit or emery cloth?
BaadVR4
08-28-2011, 04:11 PM
I have a set of new, in the box, .020" oversize pistons for a 3.5l SOHC engine. $175 shipped in US. LMK.
KeithMac
08-28-2011, 05:48 PM
Best off bying a honeing tool you can fit in a drill and hone them out. Worth the investment.
Also depends how pitted the cylinder walls are after you`ve cleaned them up.
Chris@Rvengeperformance
08-28-2011, 07:11 PM
yeah I was going to say honing tool as well, but holy shit that looks rough. may need a bore
green-lantern
08-28-2011, 10:26 PM
may need a bore
This is what I'm thinking.
TajMan
08-28-2011, 11:49 PM
THAT PIC IS NOT THE ENGINE I'M FIXING
if you read my story...
One engine is a Montero 6G72 SOHC V6, pic is of my old Stealth engine that had bad damage (but the rods and crankshaft were fine).
Cyl walls with real light surface rust in some spots, I'll be cleaning up, is on my Talon 4G63T engine.
NOT taking pistons out the bottom-end, probably not buying a hone, probably use some 1,500 paper I have here very lightly in a couple spots..
BaadVR4
08-29-2011, 09:54 AM
Not a problem. My pistons are for a 6G74 engine anyway.
As for cleaning up the cylinder walls without piston removal, it isn't the best way to proceed. It is all but impossible to keep the sanding debris from getting behind the piston rings. Even with 2500 grit paper, there will still be significant dirt/dust/debris generated. With the piston still installed, that all has to go somewhere. It can easily act as a cutting medium and ruin the cylinder wall and the rings/pistons. If you are able to get all the trash out of the cylinder, most of it will wind up in the oil pan. From there it can wipe out the crankshaft/bearings. Good luck with the repairs. Just my 1.5 cents worth.
THAT PIC IS NOT THE ENGINE I'M FIXING
if you read my story...
One engine is a Montero 6G72 SOHC V6, pic is of my old Stealth engine that had bad damage (but the rods and crankshaft were fine).
Cyl walls with real light surface rust in some spots, I'll be cleaning up, is on my Talon 4G63T engine.
NOT taking pistons out the bottom-end, probably not buying a hone, probably use some 1,500 paper I have here very lightly in a couple spots..
Chris@Rvengeperformance
08-29-2011, 02:58 PM
THAT PIC IS NOT THE ENGINE I'M FIXING
if you read my story...
One engine is a Montero 6G72 SOHC V6, pic is of my old Stealth engine that had bad damage (but the rods and crankshaft were fine).
Cyl walls with real light surface rust in some spots, I'll be cleaning up, is on my Talon 4G63T engine.
NOT taking pistons out the bottom-end, probably not buying a hone, probably use some 1,500 paper I have here very lightly in a couple spots..
'
Jesus Taj, there is no need to be a dick, sorry I couldn't read your mind. I was only trying to help.
TajMan
08-29-2011, 08:31 PM
hey hey not trying to be a dick, just wanted people to understand the real story, everyone jumping on the bandwagon of 'oh that pic is bad, you need a hone'
I appreciate advice and suggestions.
I'm considering things from a few sides, and my Talon is NOT that bad...
BaadVR4
08-29-2011, 09:02 PM
hey hey not trying to be a dick, just wanted people to understand the real story, everyone jumping on the bandwagon of 'oh that pic is bad, you need a hone'
I appreciate advice and suggestions.
I'm considering things from a few sides, and my Talon is NOT that bad...
Not to beat a dead horse..............but I've been doing this for right at 50 years...........and people think they can polish a rod or main journal with the crank in the car, put a new bearing in and all will be fine..........or that they can remove metal from a cylinder wall without removing the piston and all will be fine. Maybe you can, maybe you can't. But I've never done either successfully, nor have I ever seen anyone else do either successfully. On the other hand, I've seen probably 50-100 attempts at one or the other that turned a rebuildable engine into a boat anchor. And I've never been sorry I took the time to do it right the first time. Again, just my 1.5 cents worth.
TajMan
08-29-2011, 09:56 PM
I have a 150K mile SOHC montero engine apart, and just at that mileage oil buildup can be BAD.
On the old set of pistons I meticulously cleaned up by hand, I'd say 95% of the oil-holes around piston rings were clogged shut. Typical of most high-mile engines, the amount of 'permanent' buildup on the pistons/block/valves/etc old hardened oil residue can be horrible.
I say permanent in a sense of no 'engine clean' wonder product or anything you'll add into your oil will ever clean completely off.
That engine is going together with the crankshaft from my old 275K+ mile Stealth, crank is good and machine shop just polished. They also pressed 6 Stealth rods onto 6 Montero pistons for me. New STD rings and bearings.
I mean to get to the point, I have some experience with engine semi-rebuilds. The surgical care required in assembly, and the quick cleaning/oil changes that should occur a few times quickly after the newish engine runs.
This particular '91 Talon being fixed has 98K original miles.
1K miles ago, I did some work. Stock rods were modified to fit new 2G nippon racing pistons. New STD size rod bearings & piston rings.
The recent failure, was caused by a coolant hose that sprung a leak. I ran empty and hot extra long- radiator fan issue I was still dealing with, once its THAT hot and you realize you know its too late.
Anyway I work with the ACTUAL world and what I can judge while its being inspected, I'll see if I can get it and keep it running good this time..
BaadVR4
08-30-2011, 10:10 AM
None of this has anything to do with the original question or the original issue of how best to address rust on one of the cylinder walls. Since you've suggested the engine was overheated badly and for an extended period of time, I'd be concerned about warping. And not just the heads (although heads warp more often than other components).
If you work with the "ACTUAL" world and what you can judge while it's being inspected, why are you so willing to ignore some very REAL WORLD possibilities that could have very expensive REAL WORLD consequences? And why would you not simply disassemble the engine and have EVERYTHING inspected? With the overheating you describe, I wouldn't be surprised if the engine block was warped, particularly the cylinder bores which were overheated the most severely.
I don't have a horse in this race. It's YOUR engine, YOUR money and YOUR car that are at risk. Fix your car anyway you deem appropriate. You asked for opinions/advice. You got opinions and advice. If you don't like those opinions/that advice, you are perfectly free to ignore them and proceed however you wish. But what has been suggested to you by more than one forum member is that your proposed methods are likely to produce results which are less than satisfactory. By choosing to attack the advice giver's competency/intentions, all you achieve is alienating folks, which will cause them to not give you any more advice or opinions.
Your last post seems to be an effort to validate your skills/competency. Nobody ever questioned those traits. Nor did anyone question what success you may have had on any given repair/modification in the past.
Good luck with your repairs. Just my 1.5 cents worth.
I have a 150K mile SOHC montero engine apart, and just at that mileage oil buildup can be BAD.
On the old set of pistons I meticulously cleaned up by hand, I'd say 95% of the oil-holes around piston rings were clogged shut. Typical of most high-mile engines, the amount of 'permanent' buildup on the pistons/block/valves/etc old hardened oil residue can be horrible.
I say permanent in a sense of no 'engine clean' wonder product or anything you'll add into your oil will ever clean completely off.
That engine is going together with the crankshaft from my old 275K+ mile Stealth, crank is good and machine shop just polished. They also pressed 6 Stealth rods onto 6 Montero pistons for me. New STD rings and bearings.
I mean to get to the point, I have some experience with engine semi-rebuilds. The surgical care required in assembly, and the quick cleaning/oil changes that should occur a few times quickly after the newish engine runs.
This particular '91 Talon being fixed has 98K original miles.
1K miles ago, I did some work. Stock rods were modified to fit new 2G nippon racing pistons. New STD size rod bearings & piston rings.
The recent failure, was caused by a coolant hose that sprung a leak. I ran empty and hot extra long- radiator fan issue I was still dealing with, once its THAT hot and you realize you know its too late.
Anyway I work with the ACTUAL world and what I can judge while its being inspected, I'll see if I can get it and keep it running good this time..
BaadVR4
08-30-2011, 10:18 AM
One more question. I'm just curious why you would put a picture of a horribly rusted engine in a "help" thread, ask a question about how to sand a cylinder bore after scraping off the surface rust and then get upset when people get the idea that the picture is the engine in question? Maybe if you'd posted a pic of the actual engine you wanted advice about you would have received different responses?
green-lantern
08-30-2011, 07:45 PM
hey hey not trying to be a dick, just wanted people to understand the real story, everyone jumping on the bandwagon of 'oh that pic is bad, you need a hone'
I understood your 1st post (even though it was hard to do, all over the place and didn't need the pic) but if you had rain water into the intake (like that engine but not as bad) I still wouldn't use it without disassembling the engine and honing the cylinders. I sure as hell wouldn't use sandpaper and get grit down in between the cylinder walls and into the rings.
GTOJOE
08-30-2011, 08:22 PM
Only way to avoid grit falling between the cylinder walls and rings is to spin the engine upsidedown and a stand and sand it that way so all debris would be falling away from it. Still sounds easier to just pull it down properly.
green-lantern
08-30-2011, 09:06 PM
Only way to avoid grit falling between the cylinder walls and rings is to spin the engine upsidedown and a stand and sand it that way so all debris would be falling away from it. Still sounds easier to just pull it down properly.
Unless there is some kind of lube in there to trap the sand. lol
If you have it to that point why not pull the pistons?
TajMan
08-31-2011, 01:21 AM
lol I'm sorry for my bad thread
... Yeah at this point I believe I'm probably going to pull out my whole short-block and pull out pistons. I'll get a hone.
Main reason is the work required to pull the oil pan in the car... I might as well pull the whole block and install a stage 3 clutch kit also.
The whole point of a thread in the first place was to discern what was better at removing LIGHT surface rust from cyl walls, 1,000 - 1,500 grit or emery cloth.
Powered by vBulletin® Version 4.2.3 Copyright © 2026 vBulletin Solutions, Inc. All rights reserved.