PDA

View Full Version : Electronic Boost Controllers



GTOJOE
08-12-2011, 03:09 AM
I would like To discuss EBC's. Pros and cons. Also closed lop vs. open loop. I currently have my Vi-PEC ECU controlling boost with a switch setup to switch between 7psi and 12psi using closed loop. Now the problem with using the ECU for this is that to set a new boost setting it has to be tuned/programmed in at that boost level. I discussed closed loop EBC's with my tuner and he said there any plenty out there and some of them are good lol.
I also just looked at the TurboXS dual or Quad stage EBC but from what I can gather it's an open loop setup.

High Performance Dual Stage Boost Controller (http://www.turboxs.com.au/products/boost-controllers/high-performance-dual-stage)

Quad Stage Boost Controller (http://www.turboxs.com.au/products/boost-controllers/quad-stage-boost-controller)

Discuss.

Cheers,

Joe

j2k4
08-12-2011, 09:11 AM
/subscribed

MR2
08-12-2011, 11:10 AM
are you not tuned with MAP? my understanding was MAP was pretty good at just flip a switch to change style thing? or is your problem that you only have 2 settings to tell the ECU to choose from? (I know this is not helpful but figured I'd ask anyway)

95gto
08-12-2011, 11:30 AM
I guess I don't understand the question completely. Regardless of the ebc's control method, different boost pressures require two different fuel maps. The only real expception would be tuning your car for high boost and using low boost as a neutered mode for something like the odd occasions someone inexperienced is driving the car. And in my experience when you run two different maps, one map is typically setup for race fuel, meth injection, etc rather than just for turning up the boost pressure.

Are you needing something for a racing application, and if so what kind of racing?

mb3000
08-12-2011, 12:03 PM
Whatever you do, don't get the AVC-R.

I would rather tune a car with AEM EMS, in rush hour traffic, by myself, than deal with that crap.

IPD
08-12-2011, 08:21 PM
Mbc 4-life

GTOJOE
08-12-2011, 11:58 PM
I guess I don't understand the question completely. Regardless of the ebc's control method, different boost pressures require two different fuel maps. The only real expception would be tuning your car for high boost and using low boost as a neutered mode for something like the odd occasions someone inexperienced is driving the car. And in my experience when you run two different maps, one map is typically setup for race fuel, meth injection, etc rather than just for turning up the boost pressure.

Are you needing something for a racing application, and if so what kind of racing?

No not using it for race. It's a semi daily driver so the low boost setting is for cruising to work etc while the high boost is for spirited driving lol. It's set to max 12psi cus that's all we could safely do on the stock injecotrs. I have lots of fuel mods to install to resolve this and then it needs to be re-tuned. So my dilema is that I would like to be able to change the boost myself but if I use the ECU to control it I won't be able to [unless I learn to tune]. M ytuner told me if I use a good EBC then I could change it myself and it would only take a few pulls to get it right.


Joseph,

There is some work needed to get the Vipec controller to give you a range of selectable boost pressures. This is just more dyno time. The engine has to be run at all boost pressures to tune the settings. But when done, it works well.

With the good external closed loop controllers, they can be quickly setup on the road with just a few acceleration runs. Also offer a quick way to make changes as no PC is needed.

Ray.


The other option is an MBC or something like the TurboXS controller that has a manual adjustment knob and then a switch to swap between the 2 settings. The settings could then be very easily changed.

BlackStealth
08-13-2011, 12:55 PM
I used to run a MBC in my early days but it's lacking. No shut down safety mechanism if you overboost, no turbo spoolup assistance to make your car faster, nothing to help compensate for boost loss at higher rpms.

My old Greddy Profec-A boost controller (closed loop) worked okay sometimes, and sometimes not. Twin turbos and long vacuum lines creates a lot of variables and this caused havoc on the Profec-A fuzzy logic at high boost.

Next I moved onto the GM Boost solenoid + AEM EMS, using the standalone ECU to control boost. It worked great as open loop, but required a lot of time to setup and adjusting boost on the fly was not possible unless you had your notebook with you at all times. Closed loop has many options and I didn't get the advanced stuff programmed in before I dumped the AEM EMS cuz of poor starting was getting on my nerves.

Next I used a Greddy Profec-B Spec II boost controller, menu's are a little confusing, after a few months I'd forget what was what, and had to refer to the manual often. The Greddy Profec-B worked like a champ.

Next I made my own electronic boost controller and used the same duty cycle approach as the Profec-B, more duty cycle=more boost. Mine function much like the Profec-B but I added these extras:
- adjustable boost curve (ie. add extra duty cycle to compensate for boost loss at higher rpms)
- reduce boost when knock is present
- reduce boost when water/alchy is low on fluid
- compensate for temperature changes
- two threshold spoolup assistance, this is very handy for twin turbo engines with long vacuum line plumbing (puts a stop to temporary overboosting).

guido1205us
08-13-2011, 01:46 PM
No not using it for race. It's a semi daily driver so the low boost setting is for cruising to work etc while the high boost is for spirited driving lol. It's set to max 12psi cus that's all we could safely do on the stock injecotrs. I have lots of fuel mods to install to resolve this and then it needs to be re-tuned.

Hmm, I thought 14lbs was about max with stock injectors. That's what I have set with am AEM tru-boost. I do have a hotwire denso fuel pump so I'm getting enough fuel, and I've got no knock.

I pretty much like it, but I may not have all the settings right - A = 44 and B = 46. I do spike to 15 and settle back to 13 on a hard pull.

Frostedbutts
08-13-2011, 04:35 PM
I always suggest a manual boost controller. I know this is a thread for EBCs, probably due to varying boost settings, but there's MBCs that can do that too.

After 3 different EBCs I finally went with a manual and have never had an issue. On top of having fewer things that can go wrong, a CO3S friend of mine was explaining to me other problems with voltage drops/spikes and EBCs responding poorly to them.

NickS VR4
08-13-2011, 06:22 PM
I always suggest a manual boost controller. I know this is a thread for EBCs, probably due to varying boost settings, but there's MBCs that can do that too.

After 3 different EBCs I finally went with a manual and have never had an issue. On top of having fewer things that can go wrong, a CO3S friend of mine was explaining to me other problems with voltage drops/spikes and EBCs responding poorly to them.

On that topic, which is the best MBC? Hallmann?

IPD
08-13-2011, 08:25 PM
i'm going with a hallman. if you need 1 set setting, you can go with ninja's or make your own. if you're a geek and a tweaker, you might appreciate an EBC better. for ease of use and sheer simplicity, MBC makes the most sense, imho. if it start's messing up, you can fix them pretty easily. they'r ealso very cheap.

also imho, if you're in the market for EBC, you're probably also in the market for AEM; which makes the matter simple.

mrgtott
08-13-2011, 09:00 PM
Hmmm..... I use a Profec E-01 ebc, yest it is expensive and fancy but this is not necessarily a good thing. There are far too many gain, duty rate etc etc that need to be set and it can really get frustrating. I have yet to properly set it up, but it really does get annoying. However on the pro side of things, it has a nice big graphical lcd screen and a seperate remote to control everything. And i can set the boost on the fly to whatever I want, it also has a button for overtake boost, I have this set to maximum boost.

IPD
08-13-2011, 09:48 PM
Hmmm..... I use a Profec E-01 ebc, yest it is expensive and fancy but this is not necessarily a good thing. There are far too many gain, duty rate etc etc that need to be set and it can really get frustrating. I have yet to properly set it up, but it really does get annoying. However on the pro side of things, it has a nice big graphical lcd screen and a seperate remote to control everything. And i can set the boost on the fly to whatever I want, it also has a button for overtake boost, I have this set to maximum boost.

the hallman can set boost from the cabin. just sayin...

mb3000
08-14-2011, 02:02 AM
It's more fun to pull over in random parking lots, pop the hood for 5 seconds, then drive away. So much fun.

GTOJOE
08-14-2011, 05:05 AM
If I go for any setup it either has to be adjustable from the cabin [ie Hallman pro] or can have multiple boost settings. Ray Hall said if I use a manual boost controller he just needs to tune it at the max boost I want then it will run fine for anything below that. So the easiest option might be to go for the TurboXS high performance dual stage and have one set for max and one for daily driving. If I want to change them I can pop the bonnet. I don't think I need quad boost settings.

BlackStealth - would your unit run as a stand alone boost controller without pairing with the ECU?

R/T93
08-14-2011, 03:11 PM
Blitz SBC Id III

A very good EBC, love mine.

95gto
08-15-2011, 03:52 PM
Based on the fact that the OP wants a controller for street car here is my two cents:

1 - Two maps for a high and low boost setting isn't really beneficial. Unless your high boost setting is on the edge of dangerous for your motor, which is a bad idea imo, you don't get any real benefit from driving with a low boost map unless you are concerned about fuel economy. You just basically run a powerful car on a low power setting all the time which doesn't take full advantage of the upgrades you have installed. So if you aren't setting the one of the two maps up for a "higher than pump gas" octane I wouldn't be concerned about tuning for two different maps.

2 - Closed loop versus open loop doesn't make much difference if you know how to setup the controller. Closed loop is nice in that it adjust on the fly to compensate for outside factors but at the end of the day I don't know that I would say they are worth the added cost over open loop models.

3 - EBC > MBC, an ebc comes with stuff that lets you spool faster and protect against overboost. Not to mention the fact that they are more likely to fail in a motor safe condition than an mbc. They do cost more but you definately get more for your money

If I were in your spot I would tune my car for "X" boost and run it at that boost all the time, except for when the occasion called for lower boost due to someone else driving, something wrong with the car, etc. And if cost is a concern and you currently have a method to control boost pressure via your management system I would just use what you already have. Otherwise I would find an ebc I liked and learned how to set it up and use it.

GTOJOE
08-15-2011, 08:30 PM
Based on the fact that the OP wants a controller for street car here is my two cents:

1 - Two maps for a high and low boost setting isn't really beneficial. Unless your high boost setting is on the edge of dangerous for your motor, which is a bad idea imo, you don't get any real benefit from driving with a low boost map unless you are concerned about fuel economy. You just basically run a powerful car on a low power setting all the time which doesn't take full advantage of the upgrades you have installed. So if you aren't setting the one of the two maps up for a "higher than pump gas" octane I wouldn't be concerned about tuning for two different maps.

2 - Closed loop versus open loop doesn't make much difference if you know how to setup the controller. Closed loop is nice in that it adjust on the fly to compensate for outside factors but at the end of the day I don't know that I would say they are worth the added cost over open loop models.

3 - EBC > MBC, an ebc comes with stuff that lets you spool faster and protect against overboost. Not to mention the fact that they are more likely to fail in a motor safe condition than an mbc. They do cost more but you definately get more for your money

If I were in your spot I would tune my car for "X" boost and run it at that boost all the time, except for when the occasion called for lower boost due to someone else driving, something wrong with the car, etc. And if cost is a concern and you currently have a method to control boost pressure via your management system I would just use what you already have. Otherwise I would find an ebc I liked and learned how to set it up and use it.

This [in bold] as it's often used during the week driving to work. Low boost for economy and high boost for weekend driving in the hills. No need for low boost for other drivers cus I don't let anyone else drive it ever. 4 other ppl have driven it since I owned it [since early 2007]. One mate who then curbed my rims... he never drove it again, my mechanic, my tyre guy and my dad.
Now I read somewhere that the stock boost solenoid was only good for 14psi. Is this correct? I assume I'm going to have to buy an aftermarket solenoid if I do continue using the Vi-PEC or go for an EBC. I also need to find out if the BlackStealth unit will work as a stand-alone boost controller.

BlackStealth
08-16-2011, 10:07 AM
My boost controller also works without an ECU connected. However, to access some of the cool features of the boost controller such as reduce boost in case of knock won't be available on your Vi-PEC ECU.

If your Vi-PEC uses a serial port for communication, it would be possible to adjust my software to work with your Vi-PEC. I would need to know the serial commands to access that information. Would the manufacturer of Vi-PEC give that info out, or would we have to sniff the serial port?

95gto
08-16-2011, 12:15 PM
This [in bold] as it's often used during the week driving to work. Low boost for economy and high boost for weekend driving in the hills. No need for low boost for other drivers cus I don't let anyone else drive it ever. 4 other ppl have driven it since I owned it [since early 2007]. One mate who then curbed my rims... he never drove it again, my mechanic, my tyre guy and my dad.
Now I read somewhere that the stock boost solenoid was only good for 14psi. Is this correct? I assume I'm going to have to buy an aftermarket solenoid if I do continue using the Vi-PEC or go for an EBC. I also need to find out if the BlackStealth unit will work as a stand-alone boost controller.

To truly get better fuel economy for a low boost mode you will need two very different maps. What I would be concerned about is how much of an mpg increase would actually be possible on a super lean/low boost tune, it may be very little for the required work.

GTOJOE
08-16-2011, 08:10 PM
My boost controller also works without an ECU connected. However, to access some of the cool features of the boost controller such as reduce boost in case of knock won't be available on your Vi-PEC ECU.

If your Vi-PEC uses a serial port for communication, it would be possible to adjust my software to work with your Vi-PEC. I would need to know the serial commands to access that information. Would the manufacturer of Vi-PEC give that info out, or would we have to sniff the serial port?

I believe there is an option for both serial or USB. I'm not sure about getting the info but Ray is pretty cool about it all so maybe jump on his forum and he might be able to give you the answers.

Customer Support Forum • Index page (http://www.vi-pec.com/forum)

Ray is semi retired now so he might take a few days to answer or some of the other engineers will answer. However I emailed him on a Sunday and got a reply a few hours later.

rayhall@turbofast.com.au
info@vi-pec.com

Also could the unit function as a standalone wideband so I could monitor AFRs?


To truly get better fuel economy for a low boost mode you will need two very different maps. What I would be concerned about is how much of an mpg increase would actually be possible on a super lean/low boost tune, it may be very little for the required work.

I suspected I would need 2 fuel maps to do it properly which then means I have to use the Vi-PEC to hand boost. Which leaves me back at the same point not being able to change the boost without a laptop and a quick tune.
Would running a very low boost setting help if I just used a unit like the TurboXS Dual EBC? as it's basically just an MBC with a switch.

GTO Assassin
08-16-2011, 09:40 PM
Joe - I was talking with a Haltech tuner over east about letting the ecu control boost and he was all for it. But then I speak with tuners over west and they say that the Haltech ecu isn't reliable for controlling boost. They said that boost spike is quite common.

Scotty

GTOJOE
08-16-2011, 10:02 PM
I talked to Ray about this sort of thing and he said often that is the case and he only recently introduced boost control on his ECU's as he was not willing to add it until he was 100% happy with it.

95gto
08-17-2011, 01:37 PM
I suspected I would need 2 fuel maps to do it properly which then means I have to use the Vi-PEC to hand boost. Which leaves me back at the same point not being able to change the boost without a laptop and a quick tune.

This isn't necessarily true. You can run two separate maps on your ecu with boost control being external to the ecu. However in doing so you run the risk of damaging the engine if you boost is set to hi and your ecu is set to the low map. However the ability to overboost the motor is a condition present on all cars with boost control, ebc or mbc. I use a Blitz Dual SBC Type-R and if I crank up my boost beyond what my tune can handle I will grenade my motor. So I just leave it set so that I stay at the boost pressure my tune can handle.



Would running a very low boost setting help if I just used a unit like the TurboXS Dual EBC? as it's basically just an MBC with a switch.

Running a boost pressure lower than what your tune setup for won't really help your fuel economy. It will shift your parameters slightly to the leaner side of the map, but you are talking about a small change. Ideally if your low boost map is set to 10psi you should leave your boost settings at 10psi when using that map. As for wheter you use the ecu, an ebc, or an mbc to control boost it won't really matter.

KeithMac
08-17-2011, 04:59 PM
I run a Blitz SSBC (really old EBC!), it`s perfect no spiking and easy to use with 2 settings. Was looking to upgrade recently but I have no need at all.

The actual boost does not alter depending on air temps, summer or winter for me at all.

vr4god
01-19-2016, 05:47 PM
I wish someone would/could find the solenoids used in the EBC's. I have a Dual BC made by Blitz. I love it. 1 solenoid is bad. I have to buy a brand new unit as Blitz wont sell just a solenoid. Im sure those parts are available at industrial suppliers here in the states. I need to find them so we stop getting ripped off by Blitz for that little black box. Anyone know where to find these solenoids here in the USA?