PDA

View Full Version : pcv blowby or bad rings?



gltasn
07-19-2011, 11:47 AM
i pulled my plugs and tested out my new borescope and pistons 1 and 2 were nice and dry but the others were wet with oil as were the sprarkplug threads(plug dry).

im thinking the pcv could use improvements in the way i have it setup and im actually waiting for chris to reply about his pcv system. ive read that he has a catch can at every vac port(http://www.3sgto.org/f13/crankcase-ventilation-1042-7.html page 7) but where does he place them,lol.

my guess is that the rings are fine as ive got 2 very dry cylinders and wouldnt they be wet too as all 6 cyl have the same miles/abuse?

my current system has a small krankvent at the front valvecover the rear is vented thru a catch can(no pcv or crankvent in rear) then open air filter with, the splitter inlet plugged. i know it can be improved so id like suggestions.

i found catch cans on ebay with open air filters at the top would these be any benifit?Oil Catch Can Breather Tank with Filter Nissan R12 R13 | eBay (http://cgi.ebay.com/ebaymotors/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&item=150628017152)

speedy25
07-19-2011, 04:10 PM
Do a leakdown test to see if you do have good ring sealing. No sense guessing. The PCV system gets overcome when there is leakage into the crankcase.

-SP

AdamVR4
07-19-2011, 06:48 PM
The spark plug threads could have easily gotten wet with oil upon removal. Your spark plug gaskets may leak?

The krank vent in the front would be a lot more effective at creating vacuum in the crank case if the 2nd krank vent were installed in the rear. Think about it -- your engine is sucking air in from the crank case (thru the front krank vent), but the crank case is open to the atmosphere and allowing unmetered air into the system. If you install the rear krank vent, you'll have vacuum in the crank case at all times other than WOT. During WOT, the front vent closes and the rear opens to achieve (hopefully) atmospheric pressure.

If you want vacuum at WOT, you'll need an electric pump and catch can. This really shouldn't be necessary though. I use krank vents as they're intended with my loose, original block.

Are you 100% sure the oil isn't actually fuel? If it's oil, is there a chance the front KV failed? installed backwards? If not, I will have to second the leak down test.

Are you confident in the VSS installation?




i pulled my plugs and tested out my new borescope and pistons 1 and 2 were nice and dry but the others were wet with oil as were the sprarkplug threads(plug dry).

im thinking the pcv could use improvements in the way i have it setup and im actually waiting for chris to reply about his pcv system. ive read that he has a catch can at every vac port(http://www.3sgto.org/f13/crankcase-ventilation-1042-7.html page 7) but where does he place them,lol.

my guess is that the rings are fine as ive got 2 very dry cylinders and wouldnt they be wet too as all 6 cyl have the same miles/abuse?

my current system has a small krankvent at the front valvecover the rear is vented thru a catch can(no pcv or crankvent in rear) then open air filter with, the splitter inlet plugged. i know it can be improved so id like suggestions.

i found catch cans on ebay with open air filters at the top would these be any benifit?Oil Catch Can Breather Tank with Filter Nissan R12 R13 | eBay (http://cgi.ebay.com/ebaymotors/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&item=150628017152)

gltasn
07-19-2011, 08:20 PM
thanks for the replys! after talking with ray i added the rear kv back in the loop(was told it was better without it when i asked before,lol). i also moved the catch can to the front valve cover. i will be watching my oil consumtion to see if its working better. i use about 1/8qt a week(100 miles) of oil and knew there was a better way.

sure is noisy though, sucking sound from the air rushing threw the lines, to and from, the oil catch can.

green-lantern
07-20-2011, 12:05 AM
Sounds like the rings might be beat, or the dreaded ringlands (no kidding).

I've never had anything but trouble running a rear KV, it's a big restriction. Is it smoking bad? on decell? on throttle? all the time?

AdamVR4
07-20-2011, 12:54 AM
I've never had anything but trouble running a rear KV, it's a big restriction.


I really don't think it is.

My engine is so old and loose that when I pressure test, I absolutely have to cap the rear krank vent, otherwise the system doesn't hold pressure long enough for me to poke around for leaks :p ... And I run 30 psi. How much air flow do you really need through the check valve on a healthy engine? My car has never had a smoking problem.

I thought you had tiny return lines or something last time we discussed this..?

green-lantern
07-20-2011, 08:17 AM
I really don't think it is.

My engine is so old and loose that when I pressure test, I absolutely have to cap the rear krank vent, otherwise the system doesn't hold pressure long enough for me to poke around for leaks :p ... And I run 30 psi. How much air flow do you really need through the check valve on a healthy engine? My car has never had a smoking problem.

I thought you had tiny return lines or something last time we discussed this..?

Not me, never had little hoses on my vents. I did however blow a turbo because of a Krank Vent. The large ones aren’t to bad of a restriction but a lot of places are selling people two of the same size (the smaller ones). I know they restrict a lot compared to the open hose. I bought a set and put them on before BRG a few years back and started smoking right after I put them on. I was pushing oil out of the exhaust seals and ended up blowing the rear turbo. If I knew any better at the time I would have pulled the vent off but live and learn. I didn’t quite understand the system at the time.

I’ve always heard people say if the bottom end of an engine is healthy then the stock system is fine but I’ve had issues with perfectly healthy engines that passed leak down and compression tests. I’m not sure if it has something to do with the tune on a car or what but some cars seem to have more issues than others. My car stays rich too long after letting off the throttle so perhaps it’s washing some of the oil from the cylinder walls or something. IDK just throwing that out there. I’ve seen new engines have issues until broken in.

Anyway the rear one doesn’t really do anything for blow by. It just closes and helps create a vacuum in the crankcase when off the throttle. Other than that it’s just a restriction.

Gltasn, what size are your Krank Vents? Do you have one big one and one small one or are they the same size?

gltasn
07-20-2011, 10:47 AM
heres a pic of my new setup
http://i287.photobucket.com/albums/ll126/gltasn/crankvent004.jpg
ive got the small crankvent before the catch can on the front vc and the large crank vent is vented open. i dont really smoke unless i hit over 17-18 lbs and then its mostly black from fuel but i was looking at my pistons and the look fine with my borescope(no appearent damage) but i was discouraged to see some with oil on the piston tops. according to ray its going to happen and if i still get oil on the 4/6 pistons to try open air vent on all 4 ports with no crank vents. ray said he has had cars set up both ways.

so my new toy borescope got me triing to perfect my system and this should help. perhaps me running no rear crank vent and the catchcan on the rear wasnt catching any oil. i will have to get out and flog her today and report back.

green-lantern
07-20-2011, 12:30 PM
Always liked your car man.

You could try running it without that hose between the heads for a bit (that should give it plenty of room to breathe) then check your pistons again. You just have to keep an eye on it so you don’t blow oil all over the engine. Most people I know just run hoses off of all the vents and forget about it.

AdamVR4
07-20-2011, 01:17 PM
Not me, never had little hoses on my vents.

I was asking about your turbo oil drain lines.



I did however blow a turbo because of a Krank Vent

Wait, what? What "blew" because some oil leaked past the c-clip into the exhaust? Again, I think you're giving the krank vents too much credit.

We talked about this before....

3000GT/Stealth Tech - Login (http://www.3stech.org/forum/viewtopic.php?f=9&t=3009&p=35467&hilit=turbo+oil+return#p35467)

green-lantern
07-20-2011, 03:51 PM
I was asking about your turbo oil drain lines.

Oh OK, I thought you were talking about the vent hoses.

Yeah those oil return lines were very small compared to the stockers. Unfortunately I seemed to have the same issues after I installed the stock lines. :(

I still wouldn’t run those lines again (even though they are easier to work with). I’m pretty skeptical of most aftermarket lines now, none seem to have the ID of the stock ones.






Wait, what? What "blew" because some oil leaked past the c-clip into the exhaust? Again, I think you're giving the krank vents too much credit.

We talked about this before....

3000GT/Stealth Tech - Login (http://www.3stech.org/forum/viewtopic.php?f=9&t=3009&p=35467&hilit=turbo+oil+return#p35467)

The performance shop that sold me the KV’s sent me two small ones. When I called him about it he said that’s the way they came now. The small one is just too small and restrictive for the rear hose. On my way to BRG I noticed some smoke after boosting. By the time I got it home it was smoking pretty bad. Even after removing the rear KV it wouldn’t quit smoking during normal driving. It did quit smoking as bad as it was after booting but it pretty much smoked all the time then. It appears the oil on the exhaust side wheel threw the balance off and screwed up the seal. The KV might not have been the only thing causing the turbos demise but it the evidence suggests it was the main issue that pushed it over the edge. I’ve never used the large KV so they might flow well enough to avoid excessive pressure.

gltasn
07-20-2011, 09:05 PM
after a drive across town i didnt see any hint of anything from my exhaust. so happy and will look at my pistons when i have my plenum custom engraved in about a week.
i bought a shaved plenum and we have a custom engraving machine at work. i plan on putting: 3.4l brian crower billit crank stroker, built and maintained by jasin canfield, i cant wait!