PDA

View Full Version : Clutches: Re-use flywheel vs. Replacing vs. Step height vs. Performance vs. MFR



J. Fast
07-10-2011, 08:58 PM
I went to Havana Machine to have three OEM TT flywheels balance checked. One was brand new in the box from Mitsu, the other two were used but in good enough shape to salvage. Everything balanced out just fine but when it came to having the two used ones resurfaced I thought I'd share something interesting, the spec isn't in any of the manuals at Team 3/S, Stealth316, 3si, or here. The machine step height spec for our flywheel (according to whatever manual the machine shop was referencing) is apparently .827? I couldn't find it in the 1991 Technical Information Manual, The 3S Transmission Rebuild Guide, or the paper or disc manual so what's the spec? I didn't have internet on my phone to check the spec when I was there so I called Erron S to verify the cut and he couldn't find it either. Apparently the book the machine shop is using is called the Automotix Flywheel Spec Book. This is the spec info they gave me for mitsu was incorrect as this is what it says verbatum:

MITSUBISHI F FLAT 1.5 G15B CARB MIRAGE PRECIS
C .600-.605 2.0 4G63 DOHC MFI ECLIPSE
F FLAT 2.4 4G64 MFI SOHC
C .605-.608 3.0 MIF DOHC
SEG/PED

DIAMANTE
C .603-.608 3.0 MFI DOHC TURBO 3000GT
C .620 3.0 MPFI SOHC 60^ DIMANTE
C .820 3.0 DOHC 60^V6 DIMANTE
C .600-.605 3.0 DOHC TURBO 3000GT


Well, I called a Master Elite Tech buddy of mine for the spec and he gave me a measurement of .827. So here's the kicker, the OEM flywheel I purchased from Cherry Hill was cut to .834 and the two used ones were .838 and .832. Erron and I both found it strange that the spec isn't referenced in the manual. What I ended up having to do is taking the pressure plate and clutch pack (I luckily had with me at the time) and measuring from the seat on the pressure plate to the backside of the clutch disc laying on it. I came up with .822 for the total space requirement loose laid. From there I realized there book was way wrong. Looks like it's reversed in there manual so I had to phone a friend. If the step height is supposed to be .827 is .005 of clearance between the pressure plate, disc, and flywheel enough? That seemed really tight so I just wanted to double check.

Anyway, the last time I changed my clutch and resurfaced the flywheel I just had them take a measurement on the flywheel surface before they cut it and then take a measurement afterward. Whatever was taken out... I had them cut that off the step. I never checked the spec before and never had an issue. So was I just lucky then?

This is pretty much the first time I really checked on it and I wouldn't have caught it if the machinist didn't call me and ask me if I wanted to cut all the flywheels to the same spec since they were all different. I said show me and returned to the shop and sure as shit he measured all three flywheels right in front of me and all three flywheels were a different spec. None of them were cut to the OEM spec either. How important is that? I went ahead and cut two of the flywheels to .827 and one to .832. It seemed strange that all the flywheels were out of spec, especially the OEM unused one.

How much does this effect chatter and engagement and what not? Maybe we could start a database of various styles of pressure plates and clutch discs ant write down the measurements to see if the are all the same spec and if not how that effects engagement and long term performance.

I will say the last ACT disc and HD Pressure plate I had in there was on a flywheel cut to .838 according to my old reciept I dug up to check. The engagement on that was awesome and it had like zero chatter on it. Was that because of the extra tenth? Had it been cut to OEM spec of .827 instead of .838 would it have chattered more or changed the engagement? Lets discuss...


Jeremy

Chris GTO TT
07-10-2011, 09:06 PM
Iirc the reason there is no reference is because Mitsubishi says you are supposed to REPLACE the flywheel it is not supposed to be resurfaced.

J. Fast
07-10-2011, 09:20 PM
I'm not getting it, is resurfacing bad? My new in box OEM flywheel was out of spec and had to be recut. None of them were warped and all were still balanced so what gives?

Ninja Performance
07-10-2011, 10:12 PM
.827" +/-.002" is what I have always used for the TT. The NA is different and I can't remember off hand as I only have done a few.
I measured a new OEM and it was .827" +/-.002"

-Chris

TwIzTeD_3kGt
07-10-2011, 10:23 PM
.827" +/-.002" is what I have always used for the TT. The NA is different and I can't remember off hand as I only have done a few.
I measured a new OEM and it was .827" +/-.002"

-Chris

This is what I've always gone by. I want to say NA is .613 +/-.002". I've done both resurface and brand new, doesn't make a difference so long as it has the correct step height.

I would say you got lucky, and perhaps a tenth over isn't 'too far'. I do know I've completely worn out a clutch in 1200 miles thanks to too much clearance. Didn't have the flywheel resurfaced and learned my lesson. How much past spec it was, I don't know. But if you were a tenth past and it was fine, it would be interesting to know the real limit and pros/cons.

Ninja Performance
07-10-2011, 11:45 PM
Iirc the reason there is no reference is because Mitsubishi says you are supposed to REPLACE the flywheel it is not supposed to be resurfaced.

I have replaced umpteen clutch and flywheel combos reusing the OEM flywheel that came out and having it step cut to .827" and have never had an issue. My own car included. Clutch grabs and releases, wear is fine.

Of course they want you to replace it, they are proud of that part, ever price one?

-Chris

Chris GTO TT
07-11-2011, 12:08 AM
I have replaced umpteen clutch and flywheel combos reusing the OEM flywheel that came out and having it step cut to .827" and have never had an issue. My own car included. Clutch grabs and releases, wear is fine.

Of course they want you to replace it, they are proud of that part, ever price one?

-Chris

Hey I'm not saying you can't resurface it, I'm just saying that its not recommended by the mfg. I'd rather do it right once than cut corners and have to do it twice.

J. Fast
07-11-2011, 12:27 AM
I have replaced umpteen clutch and flywheel combos reusing the OEM flywheel that came out and having it step cut to .827" and have never had an issue. My own car included. Clutch grabs and releases, wear is fine.

Of course they want you to replace it, they are proud of that part, ever price one?

-Chris

That's exactly why I took the used ones in. I was surprised to find the one I just took out that had the CM HD pressure plate and ACT 6 puck unsprung fuzed together on it was still balanced. You could just tell that thing was used and got very hot. Cut back to .827 and it looks brand new.

You think you can keep resurfacing them as long as they will balance and the surface is still raised above the main casting or do you thin you can keep resurfacing well below the casting?

For future reference you or anyone else have a good pressure plate or unused clutch disc laying around to pull some measurements from? What's the height and end gap on the Spec clutches, same as Clutchmaster and ACT, .0025 on each side of the disc or .005 between the pressure plate, disc, and flywheel? My new clutch setup has a height of .822 so that leaves .005. What's your opinion on the endplay? Should that number stay the same with stage 4 clutches and above? This one goin in is really aggressive. It's another multi disc unsprung with a clamp rating of 700ftlb.

Ninja Performance
07-11-2011, 09:18 AM
Hey I'm not saying you can't resurface it, I'm just saying that its not recommended by the mfg. I'd rather do it right once than cut corners and have to do it twice.

Just for the record, having it correctly 2 step turned at a good machine shop is not cutting corners. I have run a whole drag season on turned flywheels, and have customers with many 10's of thousands of miles without a complaint. If done right there is not an issue and it's not cutting any corners, just the flywheel.

That would be like saying don't bore out a block, just get a new one. It's just machining. When done right.

-Chris

Chris GTO TT
07-11-2011, 06:51 PM
Just for the record, having it correctly 2 step turned at a good machine shop is not cutting corners. I have run a whole drag season on turned flywheels, and have customers with many 10's of thousands of miles without a complaint. If done right there is not an issue and it's not cutting any corners, just the flywheel.

That would be like saying don't bore out a block, just get a new one. It's just machining. When done right.

-Chris

I know it can be done and many have success with it, but I won't be turning mine.

Also a more apt analogy is; its like turning brake rotors down to their min thickness. Most will have no problems, but I still won't recommend it.

I really don't think there is anything wrong either way, I just like following directions. As such if the fsm says replace I usually will.

Broomfield Racing
07-11-2011, 07:36 PM
Ive got a few hundred track passes on my turned flywheel...did it myself though. So you know its accurate :)

Gearheadvr4
07-12-2011, 02:30 AM
A new from Autozone is ~ $60 so I just get one of those. Never had any trouble and it's not much more than getting it resurfaced and zero shop downtime too. Its possible that it's a remanufactured part but they are working great.

I would trust few shops to actually do the two step right. The two step was verified correct on the Autozone flywheel on my last two clutch changes.

Ninja Performance
07-12-2011, 10:37 AM
A new from Autozone is ~ $60 so I just get one of those. Never had any trouble and it's not much more than getting it resurfaced and zero shop downtime too. Its possible that it's a remanufactured part but they are working great.

I would trust few shops to actually do the two step right. The two step was verified correct on the Autozone flywheel on my last two clutch changes.

Still available? Last I looked the NA was but not the TT.

-Chris

Gearheadvr4
07-12-2011, 04:39 PM
It's been a while but I've purchased both types. I hope they still have the TT!

KeithMac
07-12-2011, 07:02 PM
My original one was 0.828 and it`s been fine.

J. Fast
07-12-2011, 11:39 PM
What's the float on the TT supposed to be, .005 for all clutches? If you use a different type of clutch or pressure plate do you have to cut the flywheel to keep within that limit?

RealMcCoy
07-13-2011, 12:10 AM
What's the float on the TT supposed to be, .005 for all clutches? If you use a different type of clutch or pressure plate do you have to cut the flywheel to keep within that limit?

I'm confused by what you're asking.... What do you mean by "float"? The only distance I can think to be measured without somehow releasing the pressure plate would be the preload.

Most clutch manufacturers build their products to fit the stock flywheel. Many use non standard disc thickness and pressure plate height, so it's important to stick with the same manufacturer, or do your research and make sure the parts you're using are compatible. If you start mixing and matching parts that aren't stock thickness, all bets are off...

Gearheadvr4
07-13-2011, 02:52 AM
Autozone doesn't list the TT part anymore. Possible you could still order in store but I think that deal ran out.

Ninja Performance
07-13-2011, 09:29 AM
Autozone doesn't list the TT part anymore. Possible you could still order in store but I think that deal ran out.

That is what I ran into years ago. No longer available :(
Find a good machine shop, even a napa, and turn it.
And check it when you pick it up.

-Chris

J. Fast
07-13-2011, 09:43 AM
I'm confused by what you're asking.... What do you mean by "float"? The only distance I can think to be measured without somehow releasing the pressure plate would be the preload.

Most clutch manufacturers build their products to fit the stock flywheel. Many use non standard disc thickness and pressure plate height, so it's important to stick with the same manufacturer, or do your research and make sure the parts you're using are compatible. If you start mixing and matching parts that aren't stock thickness, all bets are off...

I'm not talking about the preload on the spring though. I'm talking about the freeplay or endplay you need to cut off the step or the flywheel to keep from having engagement issues. If the free play is too tight the clutch wont release properly. If it's too much it won't engage or bite properly and will tear a clutch up in short time.

MFR's combinations of the pressure plate and disc do not yield the same nominal thickness, and a number of MFR's use the same pressure plate. What I'm after is working my way towards finding the highest holding capacity pressure plate and best clamping clutch disc and pairing them together. That way when you burn one up all you have to do is buy the PP and disc and just call for machining. Since it's already been acknowledged to be okay to re-use our flywheels without any loss in performance why not do it, right? Which is less expensive, buying a disc and a pressure plate and paying $31 to balance and machine a flywheel? Or buying a clutch kit. Add to that the rumor it's necessary to buy a brand new flywheel? When I say that I'm not refering to Round the corner parts or Ebay clutches either. I'm talking a 2500-3000lb pressure plate and a sintered center hub disc.

Lots of people I'm sure on the board have tried several combinations of pressure plate and discs. Some of those combinations were shared between different MFR's. When they got the result they wanted they stuck with it.