PDA

View Full Version : compression ratio questions



futurevr4man
07-06-2011, 01:17 PM
the infamous compression ratio debate...

i understand (and agree) that a lower compression ratio, in a boosted application, will yield bigger horsepower numbers.

my questions are:
1) hoe big of a difference does .5 extra compression really make? for example, 8:1 compared to 8.5:1... what about 8.5:1 compared to 9:1?
2) is there a limit to when it really doesnt do any good to lower compression? or better yet, is there a limit when you start sacrificing more than you gain (torque for top end power)?
3) if you had the option what ratio would you select to get the BEST combination of low end torque and high end boosting ability? right now (from my research) it seems 9:1 is a good balance, but would 8.5:1 really be better? remember im not talking in general, im talking about for our v6 engines.

debate.

-nate-

IPD
07-06-2011, 01:30 PM
subscribed. i need to know if running 90 psi on 6:1 is for me.

AdamVR4
07-06-2011, 01:41 PM
the infamous compression ratio debate...

i understand (and agree) that a lower compression ratio, in a boosted application, will yield bigger horsepower numbers.

my questions are:
1) hoe big of a difference does .5 extra compression really make? for example, 8:1 compared to 8.5:1... what about 8.5:1 compared to 9:1?
2) is there a limit to when it really doesnt do any good to lower compression? or better yet, is there a limit when you start sacrificing more than you gain (torque for top end power)?
3) if you had the option what ratio would you select to get the BEST combination of low end torque and high end boosting ability? right now (from my research) it seems 9:1 is a good balance, but would 8.5:1 really be better? remember im not talking in general, im talking about for our v6 engines.

debate.


-nate-


You don't need a debate full of anecdotal evidence and speculation, you need a thermodynamic model... Get on it.

In the mean time google provides some information...

Engine Compression Ratio - Tech - Popular Hot Rodding Magazine (http://www.popularhotrodding.com/tech/0311_phr_compression_ratio_tech/index.html)

Ray Pampena
07-06-2011, 02:41 PM
heres my input. 8.0:1 is best. the higher comp engines always run into knock at lower power output vs octane.

futurevr4man
07-06-2011, 02:46 PM
LOL at IPD.

adam, i am so sick of thermo.... uuuggghhhh lol

ray, i hope you are getting ready for me and my engine/head/tranny build. and you still need to check out my email!

AudibleSilence
07-06-2011, 03:06 PM
subscribed. i need to know if running 90 psi on 6:1 is for me.

LuLz!!!

AudibleSilence
07-06-2011, 03:10 PM
heres my input. 8.0:1 is best. the higher comp engines always run into knock at lower power output vs octane.

I thought the power 10:1 creates at 9 psi was relative to the power 8:1 makes at 12psi (obviously these psi ranges are approximations) because of the extra heat/compression generated?

Oh and someone had a 13:1 engine once on 3si iirc.

futurevr4man
07-06-2011, 03:19 PM
audible you may be right... but extend that thought to 10, 11, or 12psi on 10:1... you will hit knock pretty quick.

on 8:1 you can boost to 18-20psi before ever seeing knock... there is more power to be made at the higher boost like that.

i was just wondering if 8.5:1 would be worth it, if there was a happy median on raising CR without killing your boosting capabilities

i3igpete
07-06-2011, 03:28 PM
I thought the power 10:1 creates at 9 psi was relative to the power 8:1 makes at 12psi (obviously these psi ranges are approximations) because of the extra heat/compression generated?

Oh and someone had a 13:1 engine once on 3si iirc.

you're right. here's a better diagram we can use to discuss...
THERMODYNAMICS 101 IN 3 MINUTES

http://www.grc.nasa.gov/WWW/K-12/airplane/Images/otto.gif

in general, the energy for an engine cycle is the area in this box.

advancing ignition timing or increasing compression increases the area in the box by moving point 4 higher and higher, while keeping point 5 the same. but keep in mind that higher pressures cause bent rods and lifted heads.

Instead, let's lower point 4 by decreasing the compression ratio and retarding ignition timing. We can instead raise point 5 by increasing the air mass in the cylinder - higher boost and/or larger turbos. so yes, it's theoretically less efficient because 4 isn't as high as it could be. but the amount of energy is higher, and you do it more safely because peak cylinder pressures are lower.

Of course, it takes more $ to buy the turbos that can raise point 5 higher. It's easier to play with your emanage and increase your ignition timing and raise point 4. ***I should mention at this point that knock is something different: it's an uncontrolled burn where point 4 spikes sky high, but point 3 moves to the right. So the net effect is that you get the same or less area in the box, with a ton of damaging cylinder pressure.



on a side note, this diagram explains why engineers find the debate of torque vs HP kind of dumb.
-Torque is simply "how big can you draw this box?". this alone doesn't mean anything, if you draw it slowly.
-RPM you can think of as "how fast can you draw boxes?". this alone doesn't mean anything either, if you draw a bunch of tiny boxes.
-Multiply the two, and you have power: "how much AREA can you draw in a second?".
-This is where the Torque*RPM/5252 equation comes from.

AudibleSilence
07-06-2011, 03:49 PM
I never got going turbo and still having the engine do the compression for you. There is a kid on the goat board that is going to push 13:1 psi and try to run at least a bar vs. keeping away from the knock and running more boost (less compression). Why people make their lives difficult, I have no idea.

aaronatstate
07-06-2011, 03:53 PM
heres my input. 8.0:1 is best. the higher comp engines always run into knock at lower power output vs octane.

With you on this one. I fully believe why I get knock sooner is because I run the 8.3:1 Wisecos, and had my heads decked. If I could do it all over again, I'd stick with 8:1.

familyMAN
07-06-2011, 04:04 PM
heres my input. 8.0:1 is best. the higher comp engines always run into knock at lower power output vs octane.

Ray, what if you remove pump gas from the equation and only use race gas or ethanol? Other platforms (porsche, supra, dsms) seem to have good results with higher comp (9 to 11:1) with turbos and significant boost. What are your thoughts if you are removing octane limitation?

AudibleSilence
07-06-2011, 04:22 PM
Personally, I don't want to set my car up to run on e85 or race gas only. She gets shitty gas mileage as is and those fuels are not readily available anywhere I go.. I'd rather set my car for the fuel I can get the easiest and still make awesome power.

familyMAN
07-06-2011, 04:31 PM
The reason I ask, is "personally" I will be setting mine up to run on E85 all the time. It's not a DD (hell, it's not even a driver now:)), but it will be mostly a street car. I am strongly considering 9:1 Mahle pistons. 9:1 will be fairly mild compared to some of the builds on other platforms though.

IPD
07-06-2011, 05:42 PM
that's a good read, adam. too bad it doesn't even begin to touch on forced induction. what i did learn though, was that cams effect dynamic compression ration--which is highly related to how much a turbo can feed into the chamber.

AudibleSilence
07-06-2011, 05:46 PM
that's a good read, adam. too bad it doesn't even begin to touch on forced induction. what i did learn though, was that cams effect dynamic compression ration--which is highly related to how much a turbo can feed into the chamber.

Which is why I am waiting to get a turbo/blower cam :D

IPD
07-06-2011, 05:59 PM
Which is why I am waiting to get a turbo/blower cam :D

i gotta ask though, since i don't recall anyone ever trying it. why not 7.5:1? 7:1? at what point does the loss of compression not yield greater HP benefit with more turbo boost? there's got to be a limit somewhere; because if there wasn't, we'd all be running 2:1 motors boosted with saturn V rocket-engine-sized blowers.

BaadVR4
07-06-2011, 06:13 PM
Top Fuel dragster engines running 90% Nitromethane for fuel typically run 6.5:1 CR and around 60 psi boost. The real question is how much boost can/will I run on a "street" car. Once the upper boost limit is fixed, then the optimum CR can be determined.


i gotta ask though, since i don't recall anyone ever trying it. why not 7.5:1? 7:1? at what point does the loss of compression not yield greater HP benefit with more turbo boost? there's got to be a limit somewhere; because if there wasn't, we'd all be running 2:1 motors boosted with saturn V rocket-engine-sized blowers.

AdamVR4
07-06-2011, 06:17 PM
Top Fuel dragster engines running 90% Nitromethane for fuel typically run 6.5:1 CR and around 60 psi boost. The real question is how much boost can/will I run on a "street" car. Once the upper boost limit is fixed, then the optimum CR can be determined.

And the upper limit for boost would be determined by intercooling.

That's a much easier answer than a thermo model :p lol

i3igpete
07-06-2011, 06:19 PM
i gotta ask though, since i don't recall anyone ever trying it. why not 7.5:1? 7:1? at what point does the loss of compression not yield greater HP benefit with more turbo boost? there's got to be a limit somewhere; because if there wasn't, we'd all be running 2:1 motors boosted with saturn V rocket-engine-sized blowers.

just a matter of how big your wallet is... moving point 5 is a lot more expensive than moving point 4.

IPD
07-06-2011, 06:48 PM
so your consensus is that lower than 8:1 is diminishing returns with pump gas & air-cooled intercooler?

KeithMac
07-06-2011, 08:08 PM
If you could push enough boost to warrant 7:1 or 6:1 CR pistons it would be a lag monster on pump and nearly undrivable off boost I would think?.

I like my M20 mixes, 20% Methanol in the tank allowing me to run more ignition advance than straight petrol.

IPD
07-06-2011, 09:04 PM
that's why i asked. i'd like to get the full story. it's an obvious continuum, and what happens on both extremes is of interest to me. somewhere around the middle has to be a range of acceptable performance. my gut instinct is that 7.5:1 is probaby as easy of an adjustment from 8:1 as 8.5:1 is. but i'd really like to hear details.

p.s.
thanks again for the article. now i have something definitive to shove in the face of people who swear up and down that ethanol is shit.

Ray Pampena
07-06-2011, 10:39 PM
Ray, what if you remove pump gas from the equation and only use race gas or ethanol? Other platforms (porsche, supra, dsms) seem to have good results with higher comp (9 to 11:1) with turbos and significant boost. What are your thoughts if you are removing octane limitation?

it all works out to be the same on gasoline. power before spark knock is reduced even on race gas. think of things in extremes when comparing boost level and compression ie. 10:1 and 9psi vs 8:1 and say 15psi... which makes more power on the same gas before knock 13:1 and no boost? or, 7:1 and 25psi?

e85 seems to run better with higher compression and boost because of its resistance to knock

familyMAN
07-07-2011, 09:21 PM
it all works out to be the same on gasoline. power before spark knock is reduced even on race gas. think of things in extremes when comparing boost level and compression ie. 10:1 and 9psi vs 8:1 and say 15psi... which makes more power on the same gas before knock 13:1 and no boost? or, 7:1 and 25psi?

e85 seems to run better with higher compression and boost because of its resistance to knock

Thanks for the reply Ray. I am in the parts gathering phase and was thinking of 9:1 Mahle pistons for an E85 only, 16G build. Not really wild CR like some of the DSM and Supra ethanol builds.