PDA

View Full Version : Quick starter removal question.....



OhioSpyderman
07-04-2011, 11:51 AM
1994 VR4, do you HAVE to unbolt the downpipe to replace the starter?

Thanks in advance....

Bob. :)

stealthee
07-04-2011, 12:01 PM
I never have.

OhioSpyderman
07-04-2011, 12:03 PM
Does it being a 6sp/AWD make any difference?

Bob.

Jimvr4
07-04-2011, 12:03 PM
I don't think so. The M/T removal steps in the manual call for removing the Right Member, then starter cover, then starter. No mention of downpipe.

OhioSpyderman
07-04-2011, 12:07 PM
Stealth 316 - Starter (http://stealth316.com/2-starter.htm)

OhioSpyderman
07-04-2011, 12:24 PM
Here's a little background on the reason for the question....

My oldest son called from Toledo Wednesday night to say that his car would not stay running, based on some tests he ran, I ordered and IAC from Rock Auto to be there Friday. We were headed that way Friday morning to move him into a new house (along with my middle son, his g/f and his old roommate. Got to Toledo, emptied the 17" truck with my middle son's stuff [also had more furniture, mower, fridge......]). Then headed to Alex's to get his stuff (oldest). Loaded it full and he said he had an errand and would meet us at the new house.

Fast forward 20 minutes, frantic call saying car would not start...heard a clicking from the engine bay.

Exchanged vehicles at the new house and headed back to troubleshoot. Battery was good, all lights and other accessories worked, only click from what I thought was the starter relay. His car has YOUR neutral safety circuit [Jim :)], so I wasn't sure if what I was about to try would work: Boys got behind the car, I put the car in first with clutch fully depressed, key in ON position...push...VROOM...push start...good, we can get back to the new house.

We located a starter and went to work on the IAC (he also had slave issues a few weeks back, got a crappy replacement, so I had ordered a slave, SS clutch line and speed bleeder from 3SX, so we installed those as well).
NOTE: battery and tray were removed....

Got the car re-assembled (hadn't touched the starter yet) and for shits and grins he tries to start the car....VROOM...WTF?

We're thinking the battery pull somehow "unconfused" his alarm/auto start system (he had been complaining about his auto start not working right lately too).

He still has the new starter, and just in case he get "stuck" again, I asked the original question...

Feel free to add ANY input/opinions>>>

Bob. :)

OhioSpyderman
07-04-2011, 07:05 PM
Can anyone give me a definitive answer? :)

I "think" I see where you're getting your info from Jim, but it's not straight forward to me....

Jeff's info is good for a 5 speed/1g....

Surely someone has had to replace a starter in a 2g TT, no? (If NOT, I'm emailing Ripley's...I KNOW they won't believe it....)

Bob. :)

TwIzTeD_3kGt
07-04-2011, 07:18 PM
Pretty sure you can just unbolt the 2 bolts without removing anything. If you have swivel sockets or adapters they would come in handy. Mine slides out over my Stillen down-pipe.

dbest671
07-04-2011, 07:20 PM
The general consensus is you do NOT have to remove the downpipe. However that shield can be a royal PITA to get off with the downpipe on. If you leave the downpipe on and get the shield off, it just a matter of limited space for tools and wiggle room. But to answer your question, yes the started can be removed with the downpipe still on.

OhioSpyderman
07-04-2011, 07:38 PM
Thank you Twisted (I need your real name for my chat list :) and April (I'm assuming it's you, April...).

Not sure what my son has downpipe wise....have NOT been underneath it (YET :) )

My main concern is all he has is a jack, jack stands, decent tools (wish I would have remembered to leave the BPBlaster I bought him when I was there, but I accidently brought it back in the wife's van...)

Again, thanks...

Bob.

dbest671
07-04-2011, 07:54 PM
Yes this is April, I remember the starter being a PITA for me on the Spyder for some reason, and I had the downpipe off (plus I have small hands :)). But I remember it coming off pretty easy on the 94, but the heat shield was missing to begin with. It can be done with downpipe on, but he may find it easier taking it off. Is there a particular reason you are avoiding dropping the downpipe?

OhioSpyderman
07-04-2011, 08:01 PM
Yes this is April, I remember the starter being a PITA for me on the Spyder for some reason, and I had the downpipe off (plus I have small hands :)). But I remember it coming off pretty easy on the 94, but the heat shield was missing to begin with. It can be done with downpipe on, but he may find it easier taking it off. Is there a particular reason you are avoiding dropping the downpipe?

Not sure if just PBBlaster and a breaker bar will get the DP off without breaking bolts :)

He's 2 hours away, works and attends class daily with near ZERO time to work on his car....just looking out for him...

Thanks again for the post...hopefully we'll meet at the next NG and I can shake your small hand :)

Bob.

dbest671
07-04-2011, 08:06 PM
I found this stuff to work much better than PB blaster for some reason, especially on exhaust bolts.

http://contentinfo.autozone.com/znetcs/product-info/en/US/crc/05002/image/4/
http://www.onlyomega.com/images/Catalog_Products/Numb_Nuts.gif

OhioSpyderman
07-04-2011, 08:09 PM
Funny, because the guy behind the desk at Advanced mentioned the same thing, should have bought it....live and learn...WILL try...

Thanks again April (and Don, correct?)

Bob. :)

dbest671
07-04-2011, 08:38 PM
The stuff does work better, our local shop gave us a can of Numb Nuts which is about 5x better than the AA or AZ stuff, but I can't find that Numb Nuts anywhere.

Yes Don... but it is me 99% of the time. Don will sign his name if he posts.

Jimvr4
07-05-2011, 12:20 AM
Can anyone give me a definitive answer? :)

I "think" I see where you're getting your info from Jim, but it's not straight forward to me....

Jeff's info is good for a 5 speed/1g....

Surely someone has had to replace a starter in a 2g TT, no? (If NOT, I'm emailing Ripley's...I KNOW they won't believe it....)

Bob. :)

Hey Bob,
I took off to San Francisco and spent all day at the ball park so I never saw your reply :redface:

So, Alex couldn't start his car - you push started it and then later it started right up, correct?

On the Neutral Safety circuit - it basically prevents the starter motor from being engaged when the car is in gear. Push starting bypasses it so it works as you confirmed :)

I would have him take a very close look at the magnet and magnetic switch under the shifter. If these have shifted it is possible to get intermittent starting behavior. The magnets should be in proximity only when the car is in neutral. If the magnet slips out of position then the circuit will not close and the starter will not be enabled.

Jim :) (hoping to shake your hand at the next NG too!)

TwIzTeD_3kGt
07-05-2011, 09:49 PM
I found this stuff to work much better than PB blaster for some reason, especially on exhaust bolts.

http://contentinfo.autozone.com/znetcs/product-info/en/US/crc/05002/image/4/
http://www.onlyomega.com/images/Catalog_Products/Numb_Nuts.gif


+1 for that. One of the old timer mechanics I work with swears by that stuff.