View Full Version : NG11- Scary Stuff
speedy25
06-28-2011, 05:03 PM
Like this-
http://i451.photobucket.com/albums/qq233/psmak/cars/3s/SDC11985.jpg
I wouldnt be racing on those rotors, but yet the owner just excused it away and didnt seem concerned at all. I'm glad the lack or concern didnt become an incident.
What happened to the tech inspections that were in the information? I'm sure most everyone had well prepped cars, but as a past race inspector I have caught things that people overlooked or had not checked so I saved them from expensive failure. I'm glad only a few driveshafts and transmissions were destroyed in our fun time.
Walking around the car show with all the hoods open, I was appalled at how many cars were VERY low on brake fluid, or how dirty that fluid was. Dont your low level lights work??
I hope more of you do some safety checks and make sure your car is roadworthy. yes these ARE high maintenance cars and they deserve a little extra time from you.
-SP
call out the guilty party. wtf would you be racing with a cracked rotor?
The cars are self-inspected at the road course and autocross. We trust that people aren't going to do anything stupid or to run a car that isn't safe. Drag race tech inspections are run by the track. Everyone receives a list of the tech requirements and is expected to abide by them.
anyonebutme
06-28-2011, 05:58 PM
Looks like Scott's rotors, which cracked during the roadcourse. Wouldn't bother me either for the drags or autoX, I've blown up my fair share of rotors, none of them doing the slow stuff.
i3igpete
06-28-2011, 06:09 PM
I've always had to tech myself for HPDE events when running at NASA and MCSCC events. driver's responsibility, not the track or organizer's.
but i agree, it likely happened during the event and he planned to replace it once he limped it home. we've all limped it home before.
Amphiron
06-28-2011, 06:16 PM
I was gonna say that was most likely a result from the abuse from the roadcourse and autocross.
Chris@Rvengeperformance
06-28-2011, 06:21 PM
I agree that the rotor needs to be replaced, but how exactly do you know how dirty brake fluid is without taking off the lid?
My fluid is about a month old from a complete flush and is clear, but looking through the side of the reservoir it looks dirty because the reservoirs are not clear from old age.
Sent from my DROIDX using Tapatalk
Gearheadvr4
06-28-2011, 07:15 PM
I'd agree that was probably from the roadcourse. I trashed my brake pads to nubs and had to change them the next day. A cracked rotor would have been serious enough that I would have stopped driving and towed it back.
2fnloud
06-28-2011, 07:27 PM
Like this-
http://i451.photobucket.com/albums/qq233/psmak/cars/3s/SDC11985.jpg
I wouldnt be racing on those rotors, but yet the owner just excused it away and didnt seem concerned at all. I'm glad the lack or concern didnt become an incident.
What happened to the tech inspections that were in the information? I'm sure most everyone had well prepped cars, but as a past race inspector I have caught things that people overlooked or had not checked so I saved them from expensive failure. I'm glad only a few driveshafts and transmissions were destroyed in our fun time.
Walking around the car show with all the hoods open, I was appalled at how many cars were VERY low on brake fluid, or how dirty that fluid was. Dont your low level lights work??
I hope more of you do some safety checks and make sure your car is roadworthy. yes these ARE high maintenance cars and they deserve a little extra time from you.
-SP
Are you saying you started popping open caps and started looking at fluids and fluid levels? IF that is the case it is a good thing I didn't see you under my hood like that
Alex3000gt
06-28-2011, 07:40 PM
You would have found topped off and two day old fluid in my reservoir!
Brand new rotors and pads all the way around too.
Slacker1357
06-28-2011, 08:50 PM
and heres a good reason I didnt get drilled rotors. Just slotted and dimpled.
EBC FTW
lawdogg
06-28-2011, 08:54 PM
Terry cracked one too.
Some driveshafts broke.
An axle.
Also a few VCUs.
A transmission.
And a couple boost controllers.
Also, my heart broke when Zucchini said he didn't love me like that.
I think people were on a whole very responsible ... limping home on that rotor may not have been the best choice though.
2fnloud
06-28-2011, 08:58 PM
and heres a good reason I didnt get drilled rotors. Just slotted and dimpled.
EBC FTW
EBC rotors I take?
TT4ME
06-28-2011, 09:09 PM
Also, my heart broke when Zucchini said he didn't love me like that.
LOL^
& I didn't know people were inspecting my brake fluid reservoir!!!
green-lantern
06-28-2011, 09:17 PM
Like this-
http://i451.photobucket.com/albums/qq233/psmak/cars/3s/SDC11985.jpg
I wouldnt be racing on those rotors, but yet the owner just excused it away and didnt seem concerned at all. I'm glad the lack or concern didnt become an incident.
What happened to the tech inspections that were in the information? I'm sure most everyone had well prepped cars, but as a past race inspector I have caught things that people overlooked or had not checked so I saved them from expensive failure. I'm glad only a few driveshafts and transmissions were destroyed in our fun time.
Walking around the car show with all the hoods open, I was appalled at how many cars were VERY low on brake fluid, or how dirty that fluid was. Dont your low level lights work??
I hope more of you do some safety checks and make sure your car is roadworthy. yes these ARE high maintenance cars and they deserve a little extra time from you.
-SP
While I'll say if you pointed out my rotor was cracked I'd be scared to drive it and limp it back to the hotel, or run to auto zone for a rotor to get me by until I get a worthy replacement, it seems every post I've seen from you comes off pretty arrogant. Most people here take great pains to make sure their car is very safe and maintained. I might have you wrong but this sounds like a lecture to all. :shake2:
Broomfield Racing
06-28-2011, 09:36 PM
Also, my heart broke when Zucchini said he didn't love me like that.
ahahahahhah
Chris GTO TT
06-28-2011, 10:14 PM
Also, my heart broke when Zucchini said he didn't love me like that.
Should have had more salad....
Sent from my HTC EVO
TT Eric
06-28-2011, 10:44 PM
and heres a good reason I didnt get drilled rotors.
EBC FTW
Yup!
Eric
Maximal
06-28-2011, 10:44 PM
Like Ryan said I cracked one too and was going to call it a day on the road course but Dan (maddog) pretty much forced me to take his spare and change it. Glad I did too because had a blast in the sessions after that.
If Dan didn't have a spare I probably would have chanced it on the autocross and the drags as neither is really killer on brakes like the road course is. I wouldn't say that's irresponsible at all. Shit breaks and you have to make best with what's due. As long as he wasn't going all into corners on the road course I don't see the issue.
I have a feeling most of those cars with low or dirty brake fluid probably weren't racing either. Knowing most of the road course guys that run hard enough to need fresh fluid I'm sure it was good in their cars. Mine was 3 weeks old and topped off before loading the car on the trailer to head to the NG.
green-lantern
06-28-2011, 10:56 PM
I have a feeling most of those cars with low or dirty brake fluid probably weren't racing either. Knowing most of the road course guys that run hard enough to need fresh fluid I'm sure it was good in their cars. Mine was 3 weeks old and topped off before loading the car on the trailer to head to the NG.
Exactly what I was thinking. There were some that pulled whatever they had together to make the trip and slept in their cars just to be a part of NG. They didn't run the events but they could find the Event registration at Official Hotel.
Boomer3000
06-29-2011, 12:31 AM
Ok let me close this one out... the op of this thread.....WTF dude you found the most ridiculous thing to post about... Scott maybe crazy but he is no idiot.. and he trailered his car home.. just saying
Show Killer
06-29-2011, 12:47 AM
Walking around the car show with all the hoods open, I was appalled at how many cars were VERY low on brake fluid, or how dirty that fluid was. Dont your low level lights work??
-SP
You need to get a better hobby.
J. Fast
06-29-2011, 01:08 AM
I wouldnt be racing on those rotors, but yet the owner just excused it away and didnt seem concerned at all. I'm glad the lack or concern didnt become an incident.
What happened to the tech inspections that were in the information? I'm sure most everyone had well prepped cars, but as a past race inspector I have caught things that people overlooked or had not checked so I saved them from expensive failure. I'm glad only a few driveshafts and transmissions were destroyed in our fun time.
Walking around the car show with all the hoods open, I was appalled at how many cars were VERY low on brake fluid, or how dirty that fluid was. Dont your low level lights work??
I hope more of you do some safety checks and make sure your car is roadworthy. yes these ARE high maintenance cars and they deserve a little extra time from you.
-SP
What's wrong with not having the brake fluid topped off? In actuality it's a tell tale sign of the condition and the amount of wear on the brake pads or rotors. Put new brakes on, bleed them, bed the pads, and top off the fluid. From there out you should never need to add fluid, at all, period because it's a closed system. Consequently, the oem reservoir has a generous reserve in fluid and the level should serve as a diagnostic tool for inspecting the amount of wear on the brake system.
As you take more material off the pad, or wear the rotors, you extend the brake pistons further and further which will lower the level in the brake res. Being that I'm someone who works as a crew member and am also a crew chief on several race teams I am very familiar with inspecting these systems. The amount of fluid present lends general insight as to the amount of wear on the clamping system (if the brake fluid itself is clean). So from a visual inspection standpoint, low fluid doesn't necessarily mean one's brakes have been... or are poorly maintained. It may actually mean, the brakes are being used and either the rotor is wearing. or the pad is (which can easily be inpected by pulling the tires and grabbing a straight edge and a set of calipers). Regardless of the amount of fluid present in the brake fill reservoir, there's plenty of reserve fluid available if you can still see it. If it's low (and no leaks are present), it's time to inspect your rotors and pads... not just fill the reservoir.
To clarify, you shouldn't just top it off when it's low, you should be inspecting the wear on the brake pads and rotors. The reservoir is just that... a reserve-oir, low fluid = used brakes, not necessarily poorly maintained brakes.
Jeremy
You need to get a better hobby.
You mean looking out for the safety of fellow competitors isn't good enough?
I used to be an SCCA Safety Steward. I used to do safety inspections, controlled course design, and would patrol events with an eye to catching and rectifying safety concerns. And let me tell you, you cannot trust people to self-police safety. Some of the shit I've seen would curl hair.
Good on you OP. Keep it up.
DG
pezcore
06-29-2011, 10:37 AM
You mean looking out for the safety of fellow competitors isn't good enough?
I used to be an SCCA Safety Steward. I used to do safety inspections, controlled course design, and would patrol events with an eye to catching and rectifying safety concerns. And let me tell you, you cannot trust people to self-police safety. Some of the shit I've seen would curl hair.
Good on you OP. Keep it up.
DG
Did you point out dangers out at the course or did you post about it on a message board days later?
If he was concerned for safety, he would have said something at the track.
If he was that concerned about safety, why did he try to take someone out on the AutoCross with him in shorts?
B-Man
06-29-2011, 10:45 AM
If he was that concerned about safety, why did he try to take someone out on the AutoCross with him in shorts?
Aww, snap!
2fnloud
06-29-2011, 10:57 AM
Aww, snap!
Plus eleventy billion.
tabasco122
06-29-2011, 11:20 AM
this just got real...
green-lantern
06-29-2011, 11:34 AM
:lo5l: Nothing wrong with looking out for peoples safety. Doing it in a condescending arrogant way and essentially calling out the whole community is what bugs me. Like we junked up monument circle or something.
tabasco122
06-29-2011, 11:39 AM
:lo5l: Nothing wrong with looking out for peoples safety. Doing it in a condescending arrogant way and essentially calling out the whole community is what bugs me. Like we junked up monument circle or something.
I did :(
green-lantern
06-29-2011, 11:49 AM
I did :(
:lo5l:
ChargerX3
06-29-2011, 12:18 PM
What's wrong with not having the brake fluid topped off? In actuality it's a tell tale sign of the condition and the amount of wear on the brake pads or rotors. Put new brakes on, bleed them, bed the pads, and top off the fluid. From there out you should never need to add fluid, at all, period because it's a closed system. Consequently, the oem reservoir has a generous reserve in fluid and the level should serve as a diagnostic tool for inspecting the amount of wear on the brake system.
As you take more material off the pad, or wear the rotors, you extend the brake pistons further and further which will lower the level in the brake res. Being that I'm someone who works as a crew member and am also a crew chief on several race teams I am very familiar with inspecting these systems. The amount of fluid present lends general insight as to the amount of wear on the clamping system (if the brake fluid itself is clean). So from a visual inspection standpoint, low fluid doesn't necessarily mean one's brakes have been... or are poorly maintained. It may actually mean, the brakes are being used and either the rotor is wearing. or the pad is (which can easily be inpected by pulling the tires and grabbing a straight edge and a set of calipers). Regardless of the amount of fluid present in the brake fill reservoir, there's plenty of reserve fluid available if you can still see it. If it's low (and no leaks are present), it's time to inspect your rotors and pads... not just fill the reservoir.
To clarify, you shouldn't just top it off when it's low, you should be inspecting the wear on the brake pads and rotors. The reservoir is just that... a reserve-oir, low fluid = used brakes, not necessarily poorly maintained brakes.
Jeremy
This!
CoreyB
06-29-2011, 01:33 PM
I would rock that rotor, to get home.
DocWalt
06-29-2011, 01:54 PM
If he had just mentioned it there instead of waiting to get home... Calling somebody out for safety issues at the track is a good idea, but doing it here? /facepalm
green-lantern
06-29-2011, 04:08 PM
I wouldnt be racing on those rotors, but yet the owner just excused it away and didnt seem concerned at all. I'm glad the lack or concern didnt become an incident.
-SP
It sounds like he did say something. What and how IDK.
speedy25
06-29-2011, 04:50 PM
Well interesting that this thread got some attention, but there sure were some bizarre posts.
Thanks J Fast and DG for stepping up. You have seen what I have seen too. DG's experience is exactly what I have seen over the years as a tech inspector.
Yes we are responsible for our own safety but at the track its easy to overlook something and forget. It should NOT be insulting for someone to notice something and point it out. I have been the recipient of this and I've also pointed out things to others. This was my first event. NOWHERE in the paperwork I was given said that our cars were "self inspected." I'm not the guy running it so I went with the program.
Other than a fire and some smashed cones, everyone had a good day until more expensive carnage happened at the strip, but nobody was harmed from those broken parts.
Brake fluid- HEY! Didnt you guys put your hoods up and bolt on all that shiney stuff for us to look at?? I looked. It just caught my eye a few times that some reservoirs were down quite a bit and others had fluid MUCH darker than the plastic containing it. I'm not the brake fluid police, just making an observation.
-SP
bluemax_1
06-29-2011, 05:42 PM
It just caught my eye a few times that some reservoirs were down quite a bit and others had fluid MUCH darker than the plastic containing it. I'm not the brake fluid police, just making an observation.
-SP
Can you absolutely confirm that they WEREN'T using ATE SuperBlue ( a very popular brake fluid amongst us roadcoursers and one of my personal favorites)? As the name suggests, it is NOT a light amber fluid as with common brake fluid. It is a very dark blue (and can tend to stain the plastic a darker color when it's been the fluid of choice for years).
Max
i3igpete
06-29-2011, 05:50 PM
Can you absolutely confirm that they WEREN'T using ATE SuperBlue
good point. or maybe the road racers have the worst-maintained brake systems of all NG attendees. :eek4:
http://i129.photobucket.com/albums/p239/i3igpete/NG11/IMG201.jpg
bridge
06-29-2011, 06:04 PM
http://www.gtotwinturbo.com/images/ng11/content/bin/images/large/DSC_2429.jpg
Superblue here
green-lantern
06-29-2011, 08:19 PM
good point. or maybe the road racers have the worst-maintained brake systems of all NG attendees. :eek4:
http://i129.photobucket.com/albums/p239/i3igpete/NG11/IMG201.jpg
Damn Pete, I'm appalled!
J. Fast
06-29-2011, 08:39 PM
If he was that concerned about safety, why did he try to take someone out on the AutoCross with him in shorts?
WOW, what happens in instances like that? Do the drivers get black flagged? Speaking of safety, I know in a couple of videos from this years NG, both drivers and passengers were taped with their arms ouside the vehicle on a hot track, that's a big no-no too.
Anyway, from what I'm gathering... for the most part it sounds like there's some nit picking going on. I wouldn't normally have said anything but since the topic of safety came up I thought I'd mention the arms thing.
Either way I don't think anyone attending the meet had an utter disregard for safety, I just think track etiquette is something some folks aren't used too. Not saying people don't have manners, just saying track vs traffic = two different attitudes, i.e. no resting arms on the windows, driving with flip flops, wearing shorts, smoking cigs and sqeezing a drink in your lap, talking on the phone, blasting the radio with the windows up, or having back seat conversations. Like any habit things take a little getting used to if you don't do them all the time.
And on the topic of self policing. I have a friggin sign on my dash as a reminder to latch my hood pins and have forgotten to do so several times. Passenger says, "did you latch your hood pins?" Safety is easy to preach but hard to practice. I preach safety all the time and find I'm a hypocrite sometimes because I'm not a robot. Friends and co-workers police me when needed and I'm quite content with that.
bridge
06-29-2011, 08:58 PM
Guys we can nip pick till we are blue in the face. Yes people had their arms out, people who went two/four off should have come into the "pits" for a pep talk about what happen, came in too hot, fluid on the track, mushy brakes, too early/late an apex, etc.
We have to do what we can with what we are giving. No it's not a NASA event with six/eight people working tech with a check off list and beginners being signed official off before they are allowed to drive on their own. Heck don't think Memphis or Indy had black flags. I will say their were more corner workers this year it seem which I was pleased about. And they made the cars move from that one turn.
AudibleSilence
06-29-2011, 09:35 PM
I think he has a point with the cracked rotor (beyond the snarky bits), scary to me how many here are saying that they would run on it or even limp home..to me that's just fucking retarded at a car meet. Do like Terry said and have someone run you to Autozone. Will the rotor give limping home or even running at the track? Maybe or maybe not. Is it worth the risk? Nope. If someone wrecked and damaged my car because of their recklessness I'd be hard-pressed not to lose my temper.
On the brake fluid bit.. Dude shut the fuck up, seriously.
green-lantern
06-29-2011, 09:54 PM
I think he has a point with the cracked rotor (beyond the snarky bits)
I don't think anybody really disagrees with him on the rotor. The rest of the........never mind :beatdeadhorse:
AudibleSilence
06-29-2011, 10:04 PM
Meh, I ignored the rest.. Not worth my time getting riled up over someone else's feelings of superiority. The thing that bothers me though, is what would appear on the surface to be a quasi blasé approach to said rotor and tech by some of the guys here (and Lori). I guess when it comes down to it, it's really a mix of personal distaste for the way he presented his opinion and experience from the guys that road race all the time and see shit like this often. That said, the one time you don't double check or take heed is the one time you get bit in the ass by the issue..
If it were my name on the NG, I'd have someone checking things like this, telling the racers if they are in the right or not for things like the arms out the windows and hot lapping as mentioned by Bridge. I suppose it's all just cornflakes in the end.
p.s. What's the big deal about calling someone out for a lack of safety after the fact even if you mentioned it before? You can post pics of people having fun, but you can't post pics and mention what you think is a safety issue?
green-lantern
06-29-2011, 10:07 PM
It was more than one post that got me irritated.
AudibleSilence
06-29-2011, 10:11 PM
Meh, I just ignore people nowadays..it keeps me out of fights.
Greg E
06-29-2011, 10:17 PM
I drank alcohol and caffeine at NG. Pretty sure that's not safe either...
Chris drove my car for me though. :)
Chris GTO TT
06-29-2011, 10:39 PM
I drank alcohol and caffeine at NG. Pretty sure that's not safe either...
Chris drove my car for me though. :)
Not sure that was safe either :lol:
Sent from my HTC EVO
green-lantern
06-29-2011, 11:08 PM
Meh, I just ignore people nowadays..it keeps me out of fights.
Not sure that was safe either :lol:
Sent from my HTC EVO
I felt OK the next morning so it must be OK. ha ha
Mike, I certainly don't have a blase approach to safety issues. You haven't seen me comment on the cracked rotor because I have no clue how bad that could be. Remember - NOT A CAR GIRL. As an organizer, I have to believe these guys can be responsible for their vehicles. Why hasn't anyone asked when that picture was taken (or did I just miss it)? I thought it was at the car show, which means after all race events. Doesn't that also mean it could've happened at the drag races and possibly not even be noticed? I don't know - how would someone notice something like that?
BUT... I'll also say that he passed tech at the drag races, so it must've been fine at that point. Beyond that, the car was on city streets - not my responsibility. Monument Circle was my responsibility from the time the car was parked to the time it left. That's it.
If this is really such a big deal, then I'll start looking for people to tech cars for us again next year. That means everyone will need to show up about an hour earlier to the race events.
There are several things about this that irk me. First, this was never brought up to me on-site. Isn't it a little late to do anything about it now??? Second, the person bringing it up intentionally tried to take a passenger wearing shorts around the autocross and made a comment about "Damn, well, we tried" when I caught them. Come on! Really???
As for arms out the windows, I never caught it, and obviously the track guys didn't find it to be an issue either. The way you guys are pushing this makes me think you want us to really crack down hard next year. And if that's what you want, then so be it. I'm all for safety. If it's not what you want, you may want to rethink what you're bringing up and who you're trying to convince....
AudibleSilence
06-30-2011, 12:43 AM
There are several things about this that irk me. First, this was never brought up to me on-site. Isn't it a little late to do anything about it now??? Second, the person bringing it up intentionally tried to take a passenger wearing shorts around the autocross and made a comment about "Damn, well, we tried" when I caught them. Come on! Really???
Are we trying to discredit him for calling it out now bringing up the shorts thing? And yes, the event is over, but one would hope and pray that you'd be looking for it NEXT time instead of lighting off a torch trying to burn the guy down. Yes, he's a douche, but yes you should absolutely cover that base next time. Like I told GL, ignore the bullshit and take the rest for what it is. I mean you could have totally taken heed of it for next year without dropping the "Well you're not safe either!" drama bomb. Are we more interested in safety or being right? Looks like a little of both to me. Personally I could give a shit if he brought this up (the rotor) and had tried to run naked, a valid point is a valid point..his hypocrisy is what it is.
The way you guys are pushing this makes me think you want us to really crack down hard next year. And if that's what you want, then so be it. I'm all for safety. If it's not what you want, you may want to rethink what you're bringing up and who you're trying to convince....
I'm just saying that me personally, I'd err on the side of caution and safety, even if that means adapting the rules of a regular autox/road course event to cover my legal and moral bases so be it.
Questions I had:
1. Did you look into the liability you/the NG has if someone wrecks, regardless of the waiver? i.e. -if someone passes tech and then wrecks because of something tech or the lack of it, missed-
2. I saw it mentioned that this is not an official event or whatever and thus should be more lax. Well that is fine and dandy for someone that doesn't have their name on the event but how does this apply to you as the organizer?
3. Do have to follow SACC rules/tech to hold an autocross/roadcourse event from a legal standpoint?
Alex3000gt
06-30-2011, 12:47 AM
This discussion is important and likely should happen, your heart is in the right place - but does it need to happen out in public like this?
AudibleSilence
06-30-2011, 12:52 AM
This discussion is important and likely should happen, your heart is in the right place - but does it need to happen out in public like this?
Meh, he showed a lack of tact and he's a bit of a douche canoe from what I can tell..but honestly event safety is everyone's responsibility to an extent. Before this thread I had no idea that this was such a common thing with racers. Makes me respect them more and gives me something to check on when I run the goat this fall.
STLVR4
06-30-2011, 12:54 AM
Everyone, regardless of them racing or not, has to sign a waiver to be able to even enter the track. Im sure it adresses those issues (though I never actually read the waiver :rolleyes3: )
Im sure Lori covered all her bases when it comes to legal accountability and liability.
Alex3000gt
06-30-2011, 12:56 AM
Meh, he showed a lack of tact and he's a bit of a douche canoe from what I can tell..but honestly event safety is everyone's responsibility to an extent. Before this thread I had no idea that this was such a common thing with racers. Makes me respect them more and gives me something to check on when I run the goat this fall.
It is why I replaced my drilled/slotted rotors with solid rotors the weekend before the NG. :)
AudibleSilence
06-30-2011, 01:02 AM
Everyone, regardless of them racing or not, has to sign a waiver to be able to even enter the track. Im sure it adresses those issues (though I never actually read the waiver :rolleyes3: )
Im sure Lori covered all her bases when it comes to legal accountability and liability.
One would hope. FYI at least here in Texas autox is covered by your insurance depending on provider because it is not technically considered racing but a test of driver skill. I just fear for that one scummy kid with the 3s put together with spit and bubble gum that decides to try and sue or hit up the event insurance because he isn't covered. It's come up before at events on other forums.
mb3000
06-30-2011, 01:23 AM
I have no experience with auto racing, nor was I at the NG. But I do have experience with racing in general. Check in usually consists of a form stating that you & the vehicle you are racing are in proper shape to compete, and your signature on the x states that you assume all responsibility of racing and the track/organization is to be in no way accountable. It also states the bare minimum safety requirements (I'm guessing for this event would be a DOT/SNELL approved helmet & long pants) that are to be followed at all times when racing or "on deck". Failure to abide by these requirements can result in being denied access to track/being kicked off (which sounds like the crew at the NG did a good job of).
To the OP: If you noticed problems with people's vehicles at the NG as severe as a cracked rotor, and didn't say anything you're an ass. While it might be easy for you to spot, most people don't check their cars for cracked rotor's every time they get behind the wheel. If the owner of the car didn't understand the significance of the problem, explaining the severity of the issue would be the least you could do. What the driver chooses to do with the information is his/her decision.
To my knowledge, everyone who attended the NG had no problems at or on the way to/from the event (excluding Jester). This should not be a thread.
Racing cannot be compared to street driving. The responsibility is your's, and your's alone.
Boomer3000
06-30-2011, 01:49 AM
This thread has became stupid and about damn near pointless... Can a mod please close it...
Alan92RTTT
06-30-2011, 02:08 AM
Here is the real question.
What is the worst could have happened at the autoX is that rotor let go?(EXIF says it was taken on the 23rd)
tabasco122
06-30-2011, 02:25 AM
cracks like that are pretty common on crossdrilled rotors, im not an expert or anything but i dont think that could have caused catastrophic failure on autox. hell, terry had a rotor let go on road course and nothing major happened.
no real way to say, it didnt happen, we can speculate all day about it but that still wont answer anything. i do know that i have seen a bunch of drilled rotors have the same sort of cracks start to form, look off to the left of that pic and you can see more cracks forming near the drill holes. i hear its better to get rotors that are cast with holes than to have rotors drilled, because it weakens the area around the holes, that could be why the cracks are forming.
anyonebutme
06-30-2011, 02:32 AM
Well, that's partly why the longest straight in the autoX pointed to nothingville. Reguardless, brakes are for quitters. Real men don't use them...
Alan92RTTT
06-30-2011, 02:34 AM
Ok thats what I thought failure of that brake and maybe the pair(PS front and Dr rear).
Pete I have a question for you. I think its already been asked. If you think that crack is such an issue why didn't you say anything to anyone on the NG staff? Lori and I were easy to find on AutoX day. If you had a concern you should have said something.
At the NG we all need to look out for each other. If you have a issue tell someone.
Alan92RTTT
06-30-2011, 02:36 AM
Well, that's partly why the longest straight in the autoX pointed to nothingville. Reguardless, brakes are for quitters. Real men don't use them...
I am an autox noob and I do not recall using them on the test runs wed night with the exception of that straight and the stop.
bluemax_1
06-30-2011, 04:37 AM
Well, that's partly why the longest straight in the autoX pointed to nothingville. Reguardless, brakes are for quitters. Real men don't use them...
I am an autox noob and I do not recall using them on the test runs wed night with the exception of that straight and the stop.
He was joking about not using the brakes.
As far as racing/performance driving on a rotor as severely cracked as that, if I had noticed it on my own vehicle, I would have stopped immediately. If I had noticed it on another driver's car, I would have notified them before they could take the car out again, and if they had tried to brush it off, I would then have made it a point to notify whoever was in charge (and especially on a roadcourse where speeds are higher and there are other vehicles on the course concurrently), made absolutely sure that the vehicle was barred from running.
I've mentioned numerous times, repeating again and again (on the other forum) that crossdrilled rotors should absolutely NOT be used on roadcourses. It doesn't matter whether the holes are drilled or cast, they WILL develop those stress fractures, and if the driver continues to push the vehicle, the rotor can and will eventually frag, with potentially catastrophic results, which I've personally seen. No crossdrilled rotors and no slotted rotors where the slots reach the outer edge of the rotor (even the short edge slots used on DBA4000 rotors), because they WILL develop those stress fractures when used on a roadcourse. Regular civilized street driving may never stress them enough to cause the cracks to form, but roadracing is far harsher on the brakes.
I've seen the rotor fragments break wheels and wheel spokes, sever brake lines (causing the driver to lose practically all hydraulic pressure in the brake system) and the fragments themselves can pose an airborne hazard to other drivers and even innocent bystanders (though I've fortunately never witnessed either of those possibilities). Even if the rotor pieces don't do any damage, if the rotor happens to frag while coming into a turn behind another vehicle, the severely reduced braking could easily lead to the vehicle slamming into the one ahead because it couldn't decelerate adequately.
On an autoX where speeds are generally slower and only one vehicle is on course at a time, the risk factor is a little lower, but it is still present. On roadcourses, the risk is far too high. Folks can try an introduction to roadracing on a budget, but the 2 areas you do NOT want to skimp on are the brakes and the steering. As I've mentioned in previous threads, if you spin a bearing that sucks, your day is done, your engine is toast, but you should be able to stop safely. Poorly built turbo gives up the ghost? Same thing. Run too lean, run too rich, wastegates got stuck, boost controller malfunctioned etc. whatever, your loss. Your brakes or steering fail, you could easily get seriously hurt, and take others with you.
I concur with the OP in pointing out that a rotor with a stress crack that severe is definitely a hazard, but as far as the rest of it goes, as pointed out, brake fluid reservoir level in a properly maintained vehicle drops with pad and rotor wear and dark colored brake fluid when viewed through the opaque plastic of the reservoir is nothing to make a fuss about if you don't even know that not all brake fluid is the same color.
I will also concur that trying to come off as merely an observer 'concerned about safety' smacks of hypocrisy when viewed in light of their own transgressions.
Max
P.S. Sorry I missed yet another NG. One of these days, I'll have the darned car running again and be able to make it to these gatherings again. I do miss you guys and the fun of the events and camaraderie.
TT Eric
06-30-2011, 10:09 AM
P.S. Sorry I missed yet another NG. One of these days, I'll have the darned car running again and be able to make it to these gatherings again. I do miss you guys and the fun of the events and camaraderie.
Yes, please get that car running!
Eric
i3igpete
06-30-2011, 10:14 AM
whats wrong with your car max?
Questions I had:
1. Did you look into the liability you/the NG has if someone wrecks, regardless of the waiver? i.e. -if someone passes tech and then wrecks because of something tech or the lack of it, missed-
2. I saw it mentioned that this is not an official event or whatever and thus should be more lax. Well that is fine and dandy for someone that doesn't have their name on the event but how does this apply to you as the organizer?
3. Do have to follow SACC rules/tech to hold an autocross/roadcourse event from a legal standpoint?
1. That's precisely why they tech their own cars for road course and autocross. The event can't be held liable for missing something if we weren't responsible for tech'ing it.
2. I'd like to know where that was mentioned and what they were referring to. The races are all official events, as is the car show, pace lap, and banquet. I can't comment further until I know what the reference was.
3. No, we don't.
I'm inclined to agree with others. I think this thread should be closed. It serves no real point other than to drum up drama and negativity, neither of which are needed.
AudibleSilence
06-30-2011, 10:23 AM
Here is the real question.
What is the worst could have happened at the autoX is that rotor let go?
Your brakes or steering fail, you could easily get seriously hurt, and take others with you.
I mean this is why I was kinda harping. But go ahead and close the pointless negative thread. Just count on this being brought up at NG time next year :)
P.S.
Found this on the Scubby boards:
Felt a small vibe the day before at the track. With my audi, it would be normal at this track as it is hard on brakes.
I inspect the rotor, no cracks. Go to parts store that night and get rotors. Turns out they were the wrong ones. I take garnet paper to the rotors, put car back together and the vibe and noise are gone. So I continue to think its just build up. Continue to run it. This video was the first run of the morning.
Then you have the video.
http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=-4880534266972979760&q=slmp+brake+failure&total=1&start=0&num=10&so=0&type=search&plindex=0
^The real interesting part is when he loses control and careens into the grass. Imagine someone less experienced having that happen to them and they go into some cars..or people. Far fetched? Yep. Possible? Yep. Wouldn't want that on my name or at my event.
Everything I've found says cracked rotors are pretty common and no one that actually goes racing on a reg suggests using cross drilled or expensive rotors (even on the vette boards). They all say they crack so often a cheapy set of autozone rotors are a good alternative for someone that tracks often.
I don't see this as being negative, hell I learned a lot in this thread (especially about the safety conditions of the NG - what is checked and what isn't-, and what to look for when I track my car this season).
Maximal
06-30-2011, 10:38 AM
A strict tech inspection probably wouldn't have even caught this because I'm assuming it was not cracked before the road course. Unless there is a tech every single event it would be impossible to find that and I know the NG doesn't have the resources to do that.
An option here, which I'm sure no one is going to like, is to do what the track groups around here do...force you to print out a tech form and take it to a mechanic to check it off and sign. That way the track group has proof a mechanic looked at it and everything is fine. Now most places won't do that for free and if you forget it you're not running at the NG. I don't think anyone wants that but I could be wrong...
I understand the concerns. And frankly, there are concerns every time someone gets out on the track. If you think that's ever far from my mind, you're sadly mistaken. And with as little as I understand about the ramifications of such an "injury" to the car, I've read and understood this much... It can happen. It could've happened during the first run. And the truth is that we tech the vehicles before the road course or autocross starts. They aren't tech'ed every single time someone goes out onto the track. From what I'm reading, the rotor could crack on lap 1, and something could happen on lap 2. This is a risk everyone takes when they get out there. I don't think it makes my risk as the organizer any greater. The only real way to eliminate risk is to stop racing the cars. Sure, we could probably decrease the risk by tech'ing after every run. And maybe we should consider doing that for everyone's safety. Maybe we should no longer allow them to tech themselves. However, that puts us at greater risk and dramatically increases our liability.
I think what this all comes down to is that someone cracked a rotor and didn't see it. The picture was evidently taken on the 23rd, yet the problem wasn't pointed out to the owner of the vehicle or to myself, Alan, Peggy, or Bob. What's worse is that the owner of the vehicle was in danger, someone knew about it and said nothing to him/her. I think that's the sad part of the whole thing. The car was tech'ed by the track on the 24th. Luckily nothing happened, but the track didn't catch it either. Or they just didn't think it was such a big deal - I don't know and I won't speculate, although I realize that you all agree that it IS a big deal. I'm just laying it out there as a possibility - not as my opinion, so please don't jump all over me about that.
That car may have been driven home, putting the driver at risk because nothing was ever said. THAT is what I think is unfortunate. Why is it that we're tearing apart the tech'ing system (which admittedly may need some work after this) when all of this could have been avoided by one simple comment? We tech our own cars because we care more about our own lives than someone else potentially does. It also reduces the liability of the NG by not having someone do it for us. I guess we can't force simple common courtesy and looking out for one another.
whitedragon
06-30-2011, 10:57 AM
I mean this is why I was kinda harping. But go ahead and close the pointless negative thread. Just count on this being brought up at NG time next year :)
P.S.
Found this on the Scubby boards:
http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=-4880534266972979760&q=slmp+brake+failure&total=1&start=0&num=10&so=0&type=search&plindex=0
^The real interesting part is when he loses control and careens into the grass. Imagine someone less experienced having that happen to them and they go into some cars..or people. Far fetched? Yep. Possible? Yep. Wouldn't want that on my name or at my event.
Everything I've found says cracked rotors are pretty common and no one that actually goes racing on a reg suggests using cross drilled or expensive rotors (even on the vette boards). They all say they crack so often a cheapy set of autozone rotors are a good alternative for someone that tracks often.
I don't see this as being negative, hell I learned a lot in this thread (especially about the safety conditions of the NG - what is checked and what isn't-, and what to look for when I track my car this season).
Not sure what you're trying to say here....your example is from an experienced racer that inspected his own gear (as well as a tech inspection by the track officials presumably) and found no issue, and then goes to break on the course.
If you're suggesting that there be a stricter tech inspection, in this case it may not have even found the problem before hand as both the driver and officials already tech'd in this example and found everything good.
If you're just advocating against drilled/slotted rotors in the road course, that's a different story. Second, how could the above example be seen as something that you "wouldn't want that on my name or at my event?" If the proper procedures were followed (and apparently they were at both the NG and in your example) then there was no harm or foul in either case, and accidents happen. Heck Bill Buell's car caught fire on the road course, and it was properly teched as well, so I'm just not seeing what the problem is. Things break when you run them hard even when all the safety procedures are followed.
whitedragon
06-30-2011, 11:00 AM
I
I think what this all comes down to is that someone cracked a rotor and didn't see it. The picture was evidently taken on the 23rd, yet the problem wasn't pointed out to the owner of the vehicle or to myself, Alan, Peggy, or Bob. What's worse is that the owner of the vehicle was in danger, someone knew about it and said nothing to him/her. I think that's the sad part of the whole thing. The car was tech'ed by the track on the 24th. Luckily nothing happened, but the track didn't catch it either. Or they just didn't think it was such a big deal - I don't know and I won't speculate, although I realize that you all agree that it IS a big deal. I'm just laying it out there as a possibility - not as my opinion, so please don't jump all over me about that.
That car may have been driven home, putting the driver at risk because nothing was ever said. THAT is what I think is unfortunate. Why is it that we're tearing apart the tech'ing system (which admittedly may need some work after this) when all of this could have been avoided by one simple comment? We tech our own cars because we care more about our own lives than someone else potentially does. It also reduces the liability of the NG by not having someone do it for us. I guess we can't force simple common courtesy and looking out for one another.
This sums up this whole issue. Shame on the person that caught this and didn't bring it up to the organizers or the driver. Calling something out on the boards must be alot cooler than actually being concerned for someone's safetly, especially a fellow enthusiast that you probably hung out with during the event.
AudibleSilence
06-30-2011, 11:00 AM
Or we could do like the Scubby, Vette, and Miata guys and encourage people to not run the drilled/slotted rotors at the event and if they do, check them between sessions.
AudibleSilence
06-30-2011, 11:08 AM
Not sure what you're trying to say here....your example is from an experienced racer that inspected his own gear (as well as a tech inspection by the track officials presumably) and found no issue, and then goes to break on the course.
Alan asked what the worst that can happen is, I showed him. The guy is experienced and was able to stop safely.
If you're suggesting that there be a stricter tech inspection, in this case it may not have even found the problem before hand as both the driver and officials already tech'd in this example and found everything good. If you're just advocating against drilled/slotted rotors in the road course, that's a different story.
I am not saying stricter inspection is needed, the thing I took exception to was that there was self-inspection and then apparently guys were hot lapping as I understand it, which can lead to brake fade.
Second, how could the above example be seen as something that you "wouldn't want that on my name or at my event?"
Alan asked what's the worst that can happen, an inexperienced driver losing control and going off course into people or other cars is pretty bad. I thought I was pretty clear on that, apparently not.
If the proper procedures were followed (and apparently they were at both the NG and in your example) then there was no harm or foul in either case, and accidents happen. Heck Bill Buell's car caught fire on the road course, and it was properly teched as well, so I'm just not seeing what the problem is. Things break when you run them hard even when all the safety procedures are followed.
I'm not sure proper procedure was followed is my point. That added to the fact that shit can and does happen is just a recipe for disaster. Everything is no harm no foul until someone gets hurt...then come the frivolous negligence claims.
I guess we can't force simple common courtesy and looking out for one another.
You know what they say Lori, common sense ain't common.
i3igpete
06-30-2011, 11:13 AM
I'm not sure proper procedure was followed is my point. That added to the fact that shit can and does happen is just a recipe for disaster. Everything is no harm no foul until someone gets hurt...then come the frivolous negligence claims.
crashes happen more often than you think. at every track event i've been to for NASA/MCSCC, at least 1-2 cars ends up being taken home on a flat bed after hitting a wall. Hell, davey wiped out after a mustang brake-checked him in the middle of a high-speed corner. yeah, it sucks, but thats a risk you take and all road racers know that. no amount of tech will ever stop a crash from happening because we have human beings behind the wheel.
there's even an entire section in the NASA rulebook about common crash scenarios during w2w racing - and there's a reason why there is a 50-50 rule, because everyone has busted body panels from crashing.
Maximal
06-30-2011, 11:14 AM
The rotor I cracked was not drilled, dimpled, or slotted. It wasn't a cheap parts store one either as it was from a place that was recommended by some other road coursers around here. I've used them for a couple years now with no issue. I replaced it with a cheap NAPA rotor that Dan had and that held up to 3 more runs without any issue at all. It's not about the type/quality of part...if you beat on stuff it's going to break. We just have to be smart about catching them.
The main point here is any tech inspection out there wouldn't have caught that if it happened during the event. No events tech before and after every single run, it's just not possible and would kill your track time. Even some thorough tech inspections I've been through might have missed that...they always look at the brakes but never roll the car forward to check the whole rotor...that crack could have easily been hidden behind the caliper.
I don't really see why this is still going to be honest. It's not something any tech inspection could have caught unless they teched it before the autocross also. Even then I don't think it would have been an issue on that course. Something should have been said to the owner and it was then his decision to make...I think 99% of the people there are smart enough not to run something like in a situation that could make it worse.
I'm trying to learn from this thread... I understand the slotted/drilled rotors, I think. But what is "hot lapping"?
Thank you for that explanation, Terry. You actually cleared some things up for me and made me feel a lot better about this situation. I think we're taking this too far... I'm very cautious about safety issues when we're out there... Everyone has seen that and knows it. The issue now comes down to someone seeing it and not alerting the owner. Mike is right... common sense ain't real common.
AudibleSilence
06-30-2011, 11:25 AM
Lori, this is why many events just appoint a safety steward, takes all of the drama and politics out of it. I just don't want some dumb kid with his first 3s that is frankly beat to all hell and not track worthy to try and get you guys for his stupidity. As my mom used to say to me, I trust YOU, I don't trust the other people out there. ;)
i3igpete
06-30-2011, 11:40 AM
thing is though, who would want to be a safety steward? because if you miss one little thing, that broke ass kid is going to blame you.
AudibleSilence
06-30-2011, 11:52 AM
thing is though, who would want to be a safety steward? because if you miss one little thing, that broke ass kid is going to blame you.
Honestly, if I knew enough about the sport, sure..I would. I'd also not hesitate to tell someone to get fucked if their car wasn't safe. Pete you know me well enough to know I have zero qualms about sharing my opinion on a matter. People should have fun, but not at the expense of safety. Al and Lori work entirely too hard to have a bad incident ruin their event.
Meh, my gf tells me I plan, over-think, and thus worry about things too much.. :p Trust me when I say that my heart is in a good place here, it's just my OCD.
p.s. remember that green VR4 that ate a wall years ago at the NG road course? Who was that?
i3igpete
06-30-2011, 11:54 AM
I know, i'm just saying that it's a huge liability when anything on a car can go wrong and for it to come back to you. suppose the rotor cracks on lap 4, then shatters on lap 5. kid comes back and says it was your fault for not checking his brakes properly (when they were actually fine before the session). what do you do then?
AudibleSilence
06-30-2011, 12:08 PM
I get your point Pete...it's a huge responsibility. One not many would take on.
whitedragon
06-30-2011, 12:12 PM
Pete said "liability" not "responsibility". It means that if you were the safety steward, and someone wrecks (or catches fire), they come down with the lawsuit on you.
All drivers were required to sign the standard track disclosure and waiver (just like any race event) that covers the type of scenario you seem to be envisioning would come down on the NG.
Alan92RTTT
06-30-2011, 12:18 PM
Hot lapping is a car coming off the track from one run group and going right back on the track in the next group without a cool down.
Its something that we don't do.
i3igpete
06-30-2011, 12:42 PM
Pete said "liability" not "responsibility". It means that if you were the safety steward, and someone wrecks (or catches fire), they come down with the lawsuit on you.
Lawsuit:
Dipshit kid v. Lori Knits LLC, Michael Brown
Even if he won't win in court, it's still a pain in your dick.
lawdogg
06-30-2011, 06:29 PM
On a road course / autocross, rotors bust while braking and only while braking. For the non-car people, I would suggest not thinking that a broken rotor will make the car accelerate towards the nearest cliff or wall. But, a broken rotor deprives that tire of any braking force which changes the vehicle's direction by inducing a moment around the vertical traction axis, or whatever you want to call it (read: car wants to spin but will just pull real hard in one direction), after the rotor gives out. I broke a rotor at around 70mph on a small road course and the car just pulled to the right into the grass but was able to come to a stop quickly while fully in control.
I don't think any level of a safety inspection will guarantee the lack of mechanical failure on the course. Anyone who races knows that something is guaranteed to fail at any time. It's the racer's responsibility to know that he or she can't run ebay drilled rotors with carbotech pads on a fast course.
Even the most stringent safety inspections I've gone through (the hillclimb - NEHA - http://www.hillclimb.org/rules_regs/hillclimb_rules/11tech.pdf) look at tires, fire suppression, battery tie down, cage or roll bar (if required), seat & harness, door panels, brake fluid level, but never brake fluid color, never brand or condition of brake rotors, just that the pedal is solid and there are no leaks. These are SCCA safety stewards with decades of experience.
In any event, that's the point of the liability waiver you sign before you participate. If you race on a broken rotor and crash, IT'S YOUR OWN DAMN FAULT. I would hate to see the NG events made so idiot-proof that they would require a safety checklist to be signed off on by a licensed mechanic. Unless the NG implements racing classes with finely scruntinized equipment requirements (like spec miata), I think that's, for lack of a better word, absurd.
AudibleSilence
06-30-2011, 06:36 PM
Are you absolutely sure that rotors only break during braking?
Emilie@GZP
06-30-2011, 06:54 PM
Hans' mom's Porsche had cracked rotors just from regular every day driving. (drilled from the factory). I don't know how OK it would be to drive on a crack like the one in the first post, but, she was driving around with cracked rotors for what we imagine is quite a while before we noticed it, and she had no problems. :dontknow:
bluemax_1
06-30-2011, 07:33 PM
Yes, please get that car running!
Eric
Yep, and thanks again for the invitation Eric. Pity I couldn't manage it on short notice. Would ave been nice to be able to meet you in person too.
whats wrong with your car max?
It's been down since the NG when I was supposed to meet you guys to caravan down. I haven't had the time or chance to fix it (and admittedly, the motivation either). It's been on jackstands all this time. Finally got off the 6-7 day schedule though, so maybe I can finally git 'r' dun.
Everything I've found says cracked rotors are pretty common and no one that actually goes racing on a reg suggests using cross drilled or expensive rotors (even on the vette boards). They all say they crack so often a cheapy set of autozone rotors are a good alternative for someone that tracks often.
Mike, it's true that cracked rotors are a common occurrence from roadracing even with non drilled blanks, however, there is a distinct difference between cracking from heat stress, and cracking from mechanical failure. The cracking from heat stress is for the most part, cosmetic, and only occurs on the surface of the rotor face. It is characterized by many, many small cracks distributed all over the rotor face. They're different from the cracks that develop due to stress risers from running crossdrilled rotors, or rotors that are end-slotted (have any kind of slotting that bisects the outer edge of the rotor).
The cracks from heat stress for the most part are only on the surface and do not cause the rotor to frag. The cracks from stress risers go all the way through the thickness of the rotor and WILL eventually cause the rotor to frag into pieces if the rotor is continually used hard. Under moderate/light braking (as in civilized street use), they may never frag before being worn to discard depth.
Ryan, there is also a difference between mechanical rotor failure due to a rotor fragging from radial mechanical stress cracks (such as shown in the OP's pic) and a complete rotor-hat separation such as experienced by folks using cheapy rotors, where the entire rotor detaches completely from the hat into 2 neat pieces (the hat and the actual rotor ring). In the latter failure, both parts are still partially secured.
When a rotor frags from radial cracking though, it literally breaks into pieces. Sometimes, the pieces do little to no damage as they fly out, and other times, the flying fragments (as mentioned in my previous post) can do anything from break wheels and wheel spokes, to severing brake lines causing a loss of hydraulic pressure (meaning your pedal goes straight to the floor and you have little to no braking at ANY of the wheels).
As I keep repeating over and over again, folks should NOT use crossdrilled or end-slotted rotors for roadcourse use. I wouldn't use cheap rotors either, and if you think the rotors might be worn too near the discard depth, they may be OK for street driving but NOT for roadracing. This information is everywhere should anyone interested in trying roadracing/HPDE's choose to look.
As far as increasing the stringency of tech inspections (especially for things like the NG), I don't think that is the answer. I believe that the organizers did what they should. As mentioned, even a brake inspection might not have revealed a crack before the car ran the course for the first time. It is the onus and responsibility of the driver to ensure that their car is up to the task and that they've taken measures to ensure their own safety. Sure, it would be great to do something like banning any car with drilled or end-slotted rotors from running in any racing events, but it is ultimately up to the driver owner. Although I would never advocate using those for roadracing, some people do, and have managed to get away with it without experiencing rotor failure. Using them does not mean that they will, without doubt, fail the first time you run a roadcourse with them. It simply greatly increases the chances of it happening. As Terry has mentioned, even non-drilled rotors can crack from roadcourse use (if they're too close to discard depth or even new but poorly made ones).
As a community, we should be looking out for each other. If I'd noticed a flaw like this in someone else's car, I would have told them immediately, and notified any safety officials if the owner ignored it, but I will admit, I don't go around inspecting other people's cars before running a roadcourse even though I know that anyone running crossdrilled or end-slotted rotors is increasing the chance that they will crack a rotor under roadcourse use.
Max
P.S. Here are some examples of the differences between the surface cracks from heat stress (called heat checks) and cracks caused by stress risers.
http://www.cvsa.org/programs/documents%5C2006cmvbss%5Cpetresh.pdf
http://www.nagtroc.org/forums/index.php?showtopic=44681
Sometimes, heat checks can develop into cracks, at which point, the rotors should be replaced, but heat checking is common on rotors used in any kind of repeated hard braking.
Geordon
07-01-2011, 12:33 AM
WOW, what happens in instances like that? Do the drivers get black flagged?
[snip]
And on the topic of self policing. I have a friggin sign on my dash as a reminder to latch my hood pins and have forgotten to do so several times. Passenger says, "did you latch your hood pins?" Safety is easy to preach but hard to practice. I preach safety all the time and find I'm a hypocrite sometimes because I'm not a robot. Friends and co-workers police me when needed and I'm quite content with that.
I saw Lori check the passengers, including mine, throughout the week, and those not within guidelines were told to promptly exit the vehicle. I don't think anyone blamed her for taking a zero-tolerance stance in any instance.
I spent a fair amount of time with the OP during the NG, and feel bad the way this thread turned out, as he is a very likeable guy, from my limited personal experience, and, as a noobie racer, I learned several valuable tips from him. I agree with others that his concerns could have been voiced in a different manner. I have made that mistake before, myself, so will leave it at that.
As for self-policing and watching out for others, someone caught me heading out of the "pit" to the road course with a popped hood, and I caught another car lining up in a caravan with a popped hood. I also had other experienced drivers come up to me in my car and give me etiquette pointers, which I appreciated. Thankfully, I haven't noticed anyone calling me out on the board.
95gto
07-01-2011, 02:12 PM
Bad stuff happens you can't avoid it. For example, the day of the road course I properly torqued my lug nuts prior to my parade lap let alone full on session. Yet at the end of the third session I felt what seemed like brake fade followed by a shaky steering wheel. I cautiously slowed way down, waived around all traffic, and promptly pulled off the course. In the pits I found that I had a badly loose wheel. Had I not paid attention and slowed to a crawl I may well have lost it while running.
My point is this, even with proper preparation unexpected things happen. We can piss and moan about safety stewards and the like all we want but the bottom line is that even when you cover all the bases things can and will go wrong, Murphy's law. And the sad thing is that Murphy was an optomist.
If you want to help people keep up with vehicle conditions feel free to check out things like brakes and then talk to the owner about it. Don't post up a "you should have known better" thread after the fact.
Alan92RTTT
07-01-2011, 02:32 PM
IMO, safety is a concern for all of us.
I think the biggest thing is letting the owner know. If the owner does not seemed concerned tell one of the NG committee members. The person may me new to racing and not understand the safety issues. If we know we can look into the issue. Leaving this till the week after the event does not help anyone.
Checkered vr4
07-18-2011, 12:02 AM
Wow! I thought this was 3si for a while there!
I would like to introduce myself. My name is scott, also known as checkered vr4, and also the owner of the cracked rotor in the pics on the first post. First I would like to say I am thankful for people who look at other cars with safety in mind, I do that myself. Also, for the record, that crack happened after the first session on the road course while in the pits. I heard it crack as it was cooling down from its first experience of thermal shock. I kept a closer eye on it from that point than a mother does her child in the grocery cart. Those where new stillen rotors with probably 2000 miles on them with carbotech pads. The car did get trailered home and the rotors where promptly retired. By the way, auto zone, o'riley, advance auto, all had no rotors in stock and would have to order them- I checked. I do recommend ebc slotted and dimpled rotors for road racing. I just ran them quite a bit hotter than those stillen rotors on the track at blackhawk farms yesterday with no cracks at all.
DuTTch
07-18-2011, 12:24 AM
Wow! I thought this was 3si for a while there!
I would like to introduce myself. My name is scott, also known as checkered vr4, and also the owner of the cracked rotor in the pics on the first post. First I would like to say I am thankful for people who look at other cars with safety in mind, I do that myself. Also, for the record, that crack happened after the first session on the road course while in the pits. I heard it crack as it was cooling down from its first experience of thermal shock. I kept a closer eye on it from that point than a mother does her child in the grocery cart. Those where new stillen rotors with probably 2000 miles on them with carbotech pads. The car did get trailered home and the rotors where promptly retired. By the way, auto zone, o'riley, advance auto, all had no rotors in stock and would have to order them- I checked. I do recommend ebc slotted and dimpled rotors for road racing. I just ran them quite a bit hotter than those stillen rotors on the track at blackhawk farms yesterday with no cracks at all.
Thats why you keep your stock ones and take them with you as spares!
DuTTch
07-18-2011, 12:25 AM
Like we junked up monument circle or something.
was my dung from last year still there?
Boomer3000
07-18-2011, 02:58 AM
Wow really?
DuTTch
07-18-2011, 04:29 PM
Wow really?
Yes sir, 100% sure
Powered by vBulletin® Version 4.2.3 Copyright © 2026 vBulletin Solutions, Inc. All rights reserved.