PDA

View Full Version : Apple Orders Technicians to Feign Ignorance About Mac Malware



BigTyla
05-20-2011, 02:21 PM
DailyTech - Apple Orders Technicians to Feign Ignorance About Mac Malware (http://www.dailytech.com/article.aspx?newsid=21693)



Jobs and company hope to keep customers ignorant of the truth


Apple, Inc. (AAPL) long had the good fortune (from a certain perspective) of not being very popular with consumers and thus gaining security through obscurity. With millions of Macs in the wild and Apple sitting pretty in fourth place in PC sales, though, the company is seeing an increasing number of malware attacks.

I. The Customers Want the Truth? They Can't HANDLE the Truth!

In response to these attacks Apple has reportedly implemented a policy which is equal measures bizarre and baffling -- it's telling technicians to adopt a "don't ask don't tell" policy with regards to customers complaints about malware, feigning ignorance on the topic.

An Apple Store Genius (store technician) leaked internal documents to ArsTechnica. One memo reads:

Apple Internal Use Only - Issue/Investigation in Progress - Confidential Information - Do Not Disclose Externally

Symptoms

Customers may call AppleCare to report and issue with malware (trojan) software known as Mac Defender or Mac Security, or because they are concerned that their Mac could become infected. The name may vary as new variants are released onto the internet. This malware is installed from malicious websites.

Products Affected

Mac OS X 10.6, Mac OS X 10.5, Mac OS X 10.4

A second memo adds:

Important

Do not confirm or deny that any such software has been installed.
Do not attempt to remove or uninstall any malware software.
Do not send escalations or contact Tier 2 for support about removing the software or provide impact data.
Do not refer customers to the Apple Retail Store. The ARS does not provide any additional support for malware.
The disgusted Apple employee is quoted as stating, "Frankly, it's Social Engineering at it's finest. In some respects, I feel a little bad for the people hit by this, but at the same time, I can't help but be frustrated that people inherently trust everything they're prompted to do on their machines. The beauty of Mac OS X is its security model. That people blindly enter a password is going to be the undoing of it."

(The employee's comments allude to that Apple's OS requires users to verify installations using a feature similar to the UAC found in Windows 7.)

II. How Widespread is the problem?

Andy says that in the past about 0.2 percent of service Macs were suffering from some kind of malware -- "most always DNS trojans." Now that number soared to around 5.8 percent, mostly thanks to MacDefender -- a trojan that DailyTech previously reported on.

The employee states, "There's been a very real uptick in the number of malware instances we've seen."

"With regard to how the company is dealing with it, the answer is not very well," he adds. "As you know, OS X requires an admin user to authenticate and OK the install for pretty much anything that's not drag and drop. The response has been a case of 'they installed it, so it's not our problem.' Until something that makes use of a zero-day exploit hits, I really doubt that we're going to do anything, technology wise, to address this."

But is the OS X security model really superior to Windows 7?

Famed Mac security expert Charlie Miller, who won multiple years for the fast Mac hack at Pwn2Own, comments, "Mac OS X is no more secure than any other operating system. It has vulnerabilities, and it will let you download and run malware. The difference is that there simply isn't that much malware written for it. The bad guys have focused all their energies at Windows, which makes up the vast majority of the computers out there. However, as market share for Macs continues to inch up, that equation is going to change and bad guys will begin to focus in on Macs, if that hasn't already started to happen. And as I mentioned above, Macs are no more inherently secure than Windows, so when the bad guys decide to go after them with gusto, it'll get ugly fast."

Other hackers have also commented that OS X 10.6 ("Snow Leopard") has inferior security to Windows 7. To boot, Apple doesn't provide users with free antimalware software like Microsoft Corp. (MSFT) does.

III. How Long Can Apple Keep up the Charade?

In recent months botnet-forming worms and trojans have targeted OS X. Most of these pieces of malware have been amateurish efforts, though, or works in progress. Nonetheless it remains a very real possibility that Apple could one day see a serious attack.

The question remains how long Apple can continue to manage to deceive its customers and obfuscate the fact that its platform has malware on it, and that the threat is growing.

But the line still seems to be working on the most gullible of Mac users. For example in our coverage of the MacDefender infection one pro-Apple commentator and self proclaimed "expert", "TonySwash" wrote:

In the real world actual and successful malware attacks on Macs are virtually unknown, and if there are any at all the number is vanishingly small.

...

The really embarrassing thing is not that Windows get's (sic) all that malware, that's just the result of piss poor design decisions going back decades, what's really shameful is the way that some Windows fans choose to deal with this reality. They deny it. It's not Microsoft or Windows faults (sic), it's everybody's problem, or if it's not everybody's problem then its (sic) some sort of perverse reflection of Windows strength (sic).

...

Eventually Apple may have to face the music, though, particularly if customers take legal action against it for feigning ignorance, now that corporate documents have revealed that Apple is well aware of the attacks on its platform.

There's plenty of things you can fault Microsoft and the Windows platform for, but one thing you can say in their favor is that at least when they encounter malware they try to help customers and counter rather than claiming their products are "magic" and have no problems.



Let the lulz commence.

Zaroth
05-20-2011, 02:26 PM
These Apple threads remind me of the old abortion threads.

FeaRpb
05-20-2011, 03:54 PM
Apple hopes that if it pretends that malware doesn't exist its customers will believe so too. Apple techs are under strict orders not to help customers who are suffering from malware infections

Employees claim ~6 percent of Macs are now infected by malware, though many Mac owners are convinced their computers are "immune" to such problems.

Hey guys, Apple is badass. Its super stylin, super thin, super awesome. All my friends have them and I wanna be cool just like them! I am totally getting one!! The big price tag doesn't bother me, mommy and daddy love me enough to buy me one!

stealthify
05-20-2011, 08:49 PM
You can spot an article written by a PC fanboy a mile away. ;)

As Mike posted in the other thread, here's the original 'leaked' report:
http://m.zdnet.com/blog/bott/apple-to-support-reps-do-not-attempt-to-remove-malware/3362

And my take on it:

Sounds like a liability issue - as in, tossed in by Apple's legal department. Since the computer is not in the rep's possession, and because 95% of the time tech support callers have no frickin' clue what they're talking about, it would make sense to not give a definite answer over the phone on what the status of their machine may be. This is the task of anti-virus/malware detection software like ClamXAV (http://www.clamxav.com/), iAntivirus (http://www.iantivirus.com/download/), Norton, etc.

If we're implying that Apple is suggesting that their machines can't get malware'd, I invite you to look at the contradictions:

Apple - Why You (http://www.apple.com/why-mac/faq/#viruses)


no computer connected to the Internet [not even an Apple computer] is completely immune to all viruses and spyware

This article wasn't originally written by Fox News, was it? ;)

BigTyla
05-20-2011, 11:44 PM
Except that Apple's own employees are the source of the article! Is he now a PC fanboi, too? :p

stealthify
05-21-2011, 03:33 AM
Except that Apple's own employees are the source of the article! Is he now a PC fanboi, too? :p

For sure!! ;) I wouldn't be surprised what kind of people they let work the Apple retail stores or tech support lines. :P

Whether the source's identity is confirmed or not, or if this is just another 'leak' like most companies deal with and then flavored with anti-Apple commentary, is another question. :)

IPD
05-21-2011, 04:30 AM
For sure!! ;) I wouldn't be surprised what kind of people they let work the Apple retail stores or tech support lines. :P

Whether the source's identity is confirmed or not, or if this is just another 'leak' like most companies deal with and then flavored with anti-Apple commentary, is another question. :)

i wouldn't be either. apple is rather draconian about employing people who aren't willing to commit seppuku on the spur of the moment...if jobs willed it.

stealthify
05-21-2011, 06:08 AM
i wouldn't be either. apple is rather draconian about employing people who aren't willing to commit seppuku on the spur of the moment...if jobs willed it.

Spoken as though you, personally, know someone that worked at Apple... well, do you? Or more likely, you came up with these assumptions on your own based on your (personally) jaded views of the brand.

I can tell you that my sister has worked for the Apple financial branch in Austin, Texas for about two years back in 2007-2009. She didn't own a single Mac product at that time (and was indifferent about the company), but the company attitude there is really no different than Google (at least what I read about it). Employs get great benefits, no dress code, no Jobs breathing down your neck. In fact, she said the only times they heard from him was maybe once a month when he'd either visit in person or do a web conference to all of them as a group to get their feedback on things. Very hands on type and, despite the demonizing by some slanted news articles, surprisingly quite well received by the people working for him.

Yeah, yeah, they were all sheepified.

Anyway, I know you PC guys like to bash Apple, but I didn't think you all truly lost your common sense in the process. There are reasons to bash Apple, but this is not one of them. ;) ...or you're stretchin', like Fox News.

You don't want to be like Fox News, do you? :)

IPD
05-21-2011, 06:26 AM
i used to be a fan of apple. there was a point (in college) where i had seriously considered buying a power-mac. unfortunately, a never-ending torrent of jobs-decrees, increased exposure to brain-dead i-tards, and an as-of-yet unaddressed lack of support for the majority of computer games led me to order my first (and last) gaming desktop--and alienware--back in 2001. since then, i've switched to gaming laptops & haven't looked back. dollar for dollar, i can pay for an overpriced laptop by ponying up for an alienware--and it will hand-down be more capable than anything apple has to offer.

apple started this. apple came out with the "mac vs pc" ads. i mean it's ok if you want to poke fun of something...especially when it has admitted deficiencies. it's when apple started making the case that somehow apple was "infallible"--or at least trying to generate that impression (based on said commercials) that i start calling BS & handing it back.

if you don't mind the social/political commentary, and can take this for just want it says about apple...i think it's rather apt:


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rw2nkoGLhrE

stealthify
05-21-2011, 06:52 AM
i used to be a fan of apple. there was a point (in college) where i had seriously considered buying a power-mac. unfortunately, a never-ending torrent of jobs-decrees, increased exposure to brain-dead i-tards, and an as-of-yet unaddressed lack of support for the majority of computer games led me to order my first (and last) gaming desktop--and alienware--back in 2001. since then, i've switched to gaming laptops & haven't looked back. dollar for dollar, i can pay for an overpriced laptop by ponying up for an alienware--and it will hand-down be more capable than anything apple has to offer.

This could be the most personal response you've made yet on the topic. I appreciate you telling me about that, it's helping me understand you better.

Unfortunately, you're not telling me anything I haven't heard before. I remember looking at my PC friends with a little bit of jealousy back during the PowerPC days, wishing I could play their games. Sadly, I was stuck on my Mac with Hypercard and AOL.

Gladly (or sadly - I'm a little nostalgic), those days are over. Crysis II running smoothly in Bootcamp, no limitations on which programs or system I'm using, etc has given me renewed appreciation for the brand. Maybe its because I still actively used them for my work and in my personal life, that the hate didn't fully brew up in me. I learned the system and computers inside and out.



apple started this. apple came out with the "mac vs pc" ads. i mean it's ok if you want to poke fun of something...especially when it has admitted deficiencies. it's when apple started making the case that somehow apple was "infallible"--or at least trying to generate that impression (based on said commercials) that i start calling BS & handing it back.

And you're right, they did. Clever-ass marketing if you ask me, but I definitely saw it getting under the skin of some of my closest PC buds. It wasn't helping drive unity at all, and it was only building more contempt between the platforms. It certainly helped bring Apple more customers though, and in that way their marketing team did what it was supposed to do. I will admit that, in some ways, I did feel a little sweet retribution for how much I was made fun of growing up for enjoying my Mac for what it was.

ps - oh and trust me, I love the Apple parodies as much as you do. How close they hit to home sometimes.

IPD
05-21-2011, 07:12 AM
i wouldn't have given 2 shits about using an apple while growing up. some of the best fun of my childhood was on an apple II. (i will pwn you at oregon trail. 8040 is my personal best).

that said, i don't like having to run scripts/emulators to run games. that's why i still own my original NES; and it's also why i wouldn't like having to run bootcamp, wine, or anything else. to me, the "ease of use" for the consumer is CONSIDERABLY higher in the windows realm due to this. i spent a day and a half prepping my laptop for pc gaming before my last deployment--just so they were all installed, ran properly, and didn't have to use the CD's. i probably would have spent a week or more (with the bulk of that doing "why isn't this working" research) if i was using a mac. and even then, macbook GPU's suck. period. mobile gaming is a compromise as it is (especially if you are at 15" or less & have a single card). i'm not about to dillute the experience any further while paying MORE for it--and then have to spend longer getting it to work.

perhaps the best thing to happen for apple fans is the death of apple's indigenously produced CPU's. bootcamp wouldn't work if intel wasn't inside. ;)

p.s.

that's funny, i could swear it's the apple users who have the "holier than thou" attitude. i know very few "casual" apple owners who aren't self-absorbed and proselytizing to everyone they meet.

stealthify
05-21-2011, 07:23 AM
i wouldn't have given 2 shits about using an apple while growing up. some of the best fun of my childhood was on an apple II. (i will pwn you at oregon trail. 8040 is my personal best).
Bring it on. I don't recall my personal best, but I'll give you a run for your money. ;)


that said, i don't like having to run scripts/emulators to run games. that's why i still own my original NES; and it's also why i wouldn't like having to run bootcamp, wine, or anything else. to me, the "ease of use" for the consumer is CONSIDERABLY higher in the windows realm due to this.
This might be where we're not on the same page. Bootcamp isn't an emulator, but rather an option you can select from at startup (before Mac OS X even boots up). But you're right, a lot is owed to Intel and to Apple for the decision to switch to Intel in order to make this happen. I know I probably wouldn't be so objective in my criticism of the brand if we didn't have this as a tool in our arsenal.


that's funny, i could swear it's the apple users who have the "holier than thou" attitude. i know very few "casual" apple owners who aren't self-absorbed and proselytizing to everyone they meet.

I know the Apple users you speak of, I try not to be one of them.

BigTyla
05-21-2011, 11:27 AM
I'm not the kind of guy that tries to bash Apple at every turn. They make great products. They are a pretty innovative company. I just don't like their company mantra. I think ignoring this kind of problem is being disingenuous to your customer base and you risk losing said customers to other competitors. Then again, their fan base is so comparably small that they probably figure they have nothing to lose. I can't say for sure because I'm not Steve Jobs and I'm pretty sure no one has any clue what's going on in that lunatic's mind. :p

stealthify
05-21-2011, 11:50 AM
I'm not the kind of guy that tries to bash Apple at every turn.

Definitely Tyler, I didn't get that vibe from you.

Not to be a buster, but I hope you guys realize this is more about marketing than anything else. I highly doubt the people grinding away behind the scenes to develop these products consider their work "magic", but really the sad truth is its only us nerds that care about the real technical details. To everyone else, it might as well be magic, because I have a feeling they really don't care either way as long as it works, period.

Example, ever helped your mom with a computer issue? When you try to explain to her "technically" why something is happening, all you get back is a blank stare? Yeah, Apple is trying to avoid that. And I don't blame them. I get a kick out of when my mom's jaw drops to the floor when I show her something cool on her Android phone. She asks how it does these things, and I tell her.... 'magic.' She smiles, I smile. Winnings all around. :)

I'm sure you guys see this now, but this type of marketing isn't intended for you, and that's probably why its rubbing you the wrong way.


PS - just to reiterate, they're not ignoring the issue, but rather they've been instructed to not confirm or deny something they have no true way of verifying either way.

stealthify
05-21-2011, 12:07 PM
Kind of unrelated, but kind of related:

How God is managing the 2011 rapture - The Oatmeal (http://theoatmeal.com/comics/rapture)

Hope to talk to you guys later this evening. :p

IPD
06-03-2011, 12:10 AM
DailyTech - Apple Tries to Roll Out Trojan Protection, Only to See New Variety Pop Up (http://www.dailytech.com/Apple+Tries+to+Roll+Out+Trojan+Protection+Only+to+ See+New+Variety+Pop+Up/article21795.htm)
DailyTech - Chinese Boy Sells One of His Kidneys For iPad 2 (http://www.dailytech.com/Chinese+Boy+Sells+One+of+His+Kidneys+For+iPad+2/article21804.htm)

respective proof that:

1. it's not all wine and roses for "security through obscurity"

and

2. there is no limit to how retarded apple owners can be (not all of them, mind you--just a large portion of them).

stealthify
06-03-2011, 12:53 AM
Dead horse is dead. ;)

Apple decided to go proactive (despite what this thread was all about) and issued a simple, yet effective, method of quarantining all known (and few) malware releases for Mac OS X. The update also easily communicates with a live updating list of developing variants of said malware, and removes them without using tons of system resources to do active scans. Just as soon as a new variant was released (today), Apple quickly responded by updating their live updating list as well (today).

http://www.appleinsider.com/articles/11/06/01/mac_defender_variant_quickly_thwarts_apples_mac_os _x_security_update.html

As far as the kid goes, that's unfortunate and sad. :(

IPD
06-03-2011, 12:56 AM
i'll take anything i read on an apple fansite with several lbs of salt. dailytech > that.

stealthify
06-03-2011, 01:03 AM
And maybe that's why you only get half the story. :)

Take the AI article with a grain of salt, but the facts speak for themselves. Apple was prepared for variants, it would have been stupid not to be.

IPD
06-13-2011, 03:24 AM
DailyTech - Apple Accused of Ripping Off Developer's Rejected Wi-Fi Sync App (http://www.dailytech.com/Apple+Accused+of+Ripping+Off+Developers+Rejected+W iFi+Sync+App/article21871.htm)

apple. originality in its most heinous form.

p.s.
http://www.dailytech.com/Mac+Technician+Accused+of+Taking+Naughty+Photos+of +Women+Using+Spyware/article21873.htm

granted, this could be any tech at any store anywhere. still, the way that apple goes about security protection (or lack thereof) only lends itself wholeheartedly to this abuse.

stealthify
06-13-2011, 09:16 AM
DailyTech - Apple Accused of Ripping Off Developer's Rejected Wi-Fi Sync App (http://www.dailytech.com/Apple+Accused+of+Ripping+Off+Developers+Rejected+W iFi+Sync+App/article21871.htm)

We'll see how that one plays out in court (if it even makes it there), it's a rather general concept and wasn't ideal for a third party app. Also, if you hadn't heard, Apple actually called the developer that made the wi-fi sync app and told him that they'd be interested in offering him a job.

In other news:
eWeek - Apple Hires Jailbreak Developer (http://securitywatch.eweek.com/apple/apple_hires_jailbreak_developer.html)


DailyTech - Mac Technician Accused of Taking Naughty Photos of Women Using Spyware (http://www.dailytech.com/Mac+Technician+Accused+of+Taking+Naughty+Photos+of +Women+Using+Spyware/article21873.htm)

And in the world of PC's:

Breitbart.tv » Peeping-Tom Technician Activates Customer’s Webcam During Support Call (http://www.breitbart.tv/peeping-tom-technician-activates-customers-webcam-during-support-call/)
Meet the Peeping Tom worm ? The Register (http://www.theregister.co.uk/2004/08/23/peeping_tom_worm/)
High-tech Peeping Tom rigged laptop webcam to snap nude pics (http://arstechnica.com/gadgets/news/2008/08/high-tech-peeping-tom-rigged-laptop-webcam-to-snap-nude-pics.ars)
Hacker jailed for 18 months: Matthew Anderson spied on computer users using webcams | Mail Online (http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-1332336/Hacker-jailed-18-months-Matthew-Anderson-spied-users-using-webcams.html)
Rental Company Aaron's Inc. Allegedly Spied On PC Users Via Webcams (http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2011/05/04/aarons-inc-spy-webcam_n_857317.html)
Digital Peeping Tom Spies on Girls Through Their Own Webcams - The Internet Patrol (http://www.theinternetpatrol.com/digital-peeping-tom-spies-on-girls-through-their-own-webcams/) (Sub7 Trojan)

etc, etc.

The difference is, from what I understand, the Mac program still required users to read a dialog box and click accept, every time, in order for it to allow the use of their webcam. No security protection in the world can save people from themselves - the users are the weakest link.

:p

IPD
06-13-2011, 06:02 PM
so tossing out a job offer suddenly absconds the whole debacle? um, no. wrong is wrong. damages should be paid, imho.

p.s.
like i said, apple techs breaking the law aren't really news. any techs could be guilty of it. it's just that the type of customers that apple usually attracts are much more susceptible to shiens like this. i mean seriously, "You should fix your internal sensor soon. If unsure what to do, try putting your laptop near hot steam for several minutes to clean the sensor." that's like beyond ignorant. and some of these "victims" are college students. yikes. again, moronic customers aren't exclusive to apple--but apple certainly has more than a proportionate share of them.

stealthify
06-13-2011, 07:12 PM
so tossing out a job offer suddenly absconds the whole debacle? um, no. wrong is wrong. damages should be paid, imho.

And the creator of that app is hardly the first person to come up with the idea of wireless syncing. If Apple used his code, which they likely didn't, then you'd have a reasonable argument. Until then, the only similarities I see are the general concept and the general icon (ie: a commonly used sync icon mixed with a wifi signal icon - how original).

Apple offering him a job, when they didn't particularly need to, was certainly a step in the right direction.


moronic customers aren't exclusive to apple--but apple certainly has more than a proportionate share of them.

I firmly believe that every company strives to make their products as easy to use as possible. Just because Apple succeeds at this more than any other company is no reason to hate.

IPD
06-13-2011, 09:40 PM
And the creator of that app is hardly the first person to come up with the idea of wireless syncing. If Apple used his code, which they likely didn't, then you'd have a reasonable argument. Until then, the only similarities I see are the general concept and the general icon (ie: a commonly used sync icon mixed with a wifi signal icon - how original).

Apple offering him a job, when they didn't particularly need to, was certainly a step in the right direction.

originally is the litmus test? news flash! the BULK of apps are not original. even if it WAS an unoriginal idea, he still managed to get 50,000 copies sold via a 3rd party source. clearly the demand was there. apple's actions in this are clear. "wow! that's such an awesome idea, we want to do that with our stuff--but if we give this guy app rights, it's going to cost us--so let's marginalize him". not the first time apple has ripped off someone's ideas; won't be the last. you can argue semantics all you want--it still won't change the fact that apple's claim to fame is presenting existing tech in new ways. which would be fine--if they gave full credit to the inventors (or original pioneers) of that tech, rather than acting like dickholes about it.


I firmly believe that every company strives to make their products as easy to use as possible. Just because Apple succeeds at this more than any other company is no reason to hate.

negative. apple products "easy to use as possible" is a bald-faced lie. easy to use in some ways, for some uses....perhaps. universally across the board--HELL NO. i dare say though, ease of use isn't what attracts the techno-illiterate to apple; it's the perceived prestige that the apple user has.

stealthify
06-13-2011, 09:59 PM
originally is the litmus test?
No. Originality (or more specifically, uniqueness) is a deciding factor in patent and copyright infringement cases. Regardless, this is stupid to argue over. :p Wi-fi sync isn't a new innovation, and neither the developer of the app nor Apple tried to market it that way. Plain and simple, and you'd be a fool to think that Apple didn't at least consider the idea of wi-fi syncing back when they were debating on how their mobile devices would communicate with computers. Want to know why they didn't incorporate it years ago? I have a hunch as to why; feel free to ask if you'd like to hear it. I will give you a hint, it probably has nothing to do with being dicks.


apple products "easy to use as possible" is a bald-faced lie.
Is it? On one hand Apple haters bash Mac OS X and iOS on the grounds that they're so easy and simple to use that only simpletons will want to use it, but then here you go doing an about-face and saying the opposite. Which is it, man? :)

IPD
06-13-2011, 10:22 PM
No. Originality (or more specifically, uniqueness) is a deciding factor in patent and copyright infringement cases. Regardless, this is stupid to argue over. :p Wi-fi sync isn't a new innovation, and neither the developer of the app nor Apple tried to market it that way. Plain and simple, and you'd be a fool to think that Apple didn't at least consider the idea of wi-fi syncing back when they were debating on how their mobile devices would communicate with computers. Want to know why they didn't incorporate it years ago? I have a hunch as to why; feel free to ask if you'd like to hear it. I will give you a hint, it probably has nothing to do with being dicks.

simple. apple wants draconian control over its products. it won't implement something unless it feels it has force-choke grip over how it is being used. case in point: iphone bricking. again, not a new idea; just an idea that apple hadn't implemented. someone tried to offer the implementation to the community--and apple shot it down. regardless of whose idea it was first, apple didn't bring it to consumers first--so apple should--by rights--be forced to concede. you can't just prevent someone from bringing a product to market because of your own designs on "potential future use". bullshit. either get there first, or pay the dues for being a runner-up; it's that simple.



Is it? On one hand Apple haters bash Mac OS X and iOS on the grounds that they're so easy and simple to use that only simpletons will want to use it, but then here you go doing an about-face and saying the opposite. Which is it, man? :)

i didn't say the opposite. simpletons are who apple caters to; i.e. people whose tech demands are incredibly banal. what makes that incredibly dangerous is apple's subversion of its fallacies (virus protection, etc). so not only is the target consumer group fairly clueless about technology in the first place; apple relies & feeds upon this by not educating them. apple's scheme is to try and "simplify"--but doesn't educate. apple doesn't even have the virtue of its own version of "microsoft security essentials". oh sure, apple CLAIMS to have it, but it really doesn't. it's shoddy, difficult to understand, and unreliable. worse, since apple doesn't educate its consumers--they are pre-conditioned to click "ok" on anything and everything "official looking" that pops up onto their computers.

the cynical side of me says this is deliberate, because stupid people agreeing to install viruses/spam on their computers = more $$$ for tech support to fix apple products; but i'd like to believe apple deserves a little more credit than that. only bb's geek squad is that low (i hope).

stealthify
06-14-2011, 03:14 AM
Want to know why they didn't incorporate it years ago? I have a hunch as to why; feel free to ask if you'd like to hear it.simple. apple wants draconian control over its products. it won't implement something unless it feels it has force-choke grip over how it is being used.
Pretty much what I was going to say, kind of, just without the negative and real stick in the mud adjectives. But let me ask you a question. I have a basic idea of what you do for a living, but have you ever developed a large scale consumer product before? Simple yes or no is all I need, not a trick question, I'll tell you why I ask after you answer.


case in point: iphone bricking. again, not a new idea; just an idea that apple hadn't implemented. someone tried to offer the implementation to the community--and apple shot it down.
Bricking is a terrible thing to bring to any phone. :) I assume you must mean jailbreaking, or is this still in reference to the wi-fi syncing?



simpletons are who apple caters to; i.e. people whose tech demands are incredibly banal.
First part I agree with (at least who they primarily advertise to), but not so much with the latter half. My definition of simpletons are people that don't care how things work, but rather that they just want things to work - no questions asked. Perhaps this is just semantics again, but there's absolutely no reason to confuse 'ease of use' with 'lack of technical capability'. This is how I can tell you don't use a Mac these days. ;)

So what, exactly, is it that you don't think a modern Macs are capable of these days?


what makes that incredibly dangerous is apple's subversion of its fallacies (virus protection, etc). so not only is the target consumer group fairly clueless about technology in the first place;
Yes, this is a volatile mix. Your point about education (below) reinforces that the users are the weakest link - on any platform - and always will be...


apple's scheme is to try and "simplify"--but doesn't educate ... they are pre-conditioned to click "ok" on anything and everything "official looking" that pops up onto their computers.
... and education would be cool, if people wanted to hear it. Anything beyond a 2-3 sentence explanation seems to be the truest form of repellent of anyone that comes to me with a technical question, but maybe people don't want a college education or 1-2 years of experience under their belt in order to figure out how to operate their computer. Let's not kid ourselves: this is the audience both Apple and Microsoft are after, but by your own admission it is clear Apple is doing a better job at it.

However, the pre-conditioned 'clicking ok' on everything is something that has plagued Windows users for years. If not, how is it that these viruses are so rampant?

IPD
06-14-2011, 04:20 AM
Pretty much what I was going to say, kind of, just without the negative and real stick in the mud adjectives. But let me ask you a question. I have a basic idea of what you do for a living, but have you ever developed a large scale consumer product before? Simple yes or no is all I need, not a trick question, I'll tell you why I ask after you answer.

no. and neither have 75% of those who have smartphone aps on the market. just because someone has designs on an idea/product--and get beaten to the punch--doesn't mean that they can reneg & not have to pay the piper.


Bricking is a terrible thing to bring to any phone. :) I assume you must mean jailbreaking, or is this still in reference to the wi-fi syncing?

bricking is what apple has done--on numerous occasions--to those who have jailbroken their phones. this is no different than dell bricking your desktop because you decided to erase windows and install linux instead. it's outrageous, it's a crime, and it's acceptable--only according to the sheeple...and apple.


First part I agree with (at least who they primarily advertise to), but not so much with the latter half. My definition of simpletons are people that don't care how things work, but rather that they just want things to work - no questions asked. Perhaps this is just semantics again, but there's absolutely no reason to confuse 'ease of use' with 'lack of technical capability'. This is how I can tell you don't use a Mac these days. ;)

i'm not confusing them. they're distinct entities--though there is some collusion. i haven't used a mac since checking my email on unix in college. i've already shared all of that. i would rather get gang raped by justin bieber & dirty mike and the boys--in a prius--while being forced to watch twilight over and over--than buy an apple product.


So what, exactly, is it that you don't think a modern Macs are capable of these days?

the "magic" that its users seem to ascribe to it. a good excuse why they cost $500 more than competing pc's (read: that's not BS marketing hype). native support for PC games or PC software without the use of emulation/dual-boot software. (and seriously, if it's so "consumer friendly" why does the consumer have to go through so many more hurdles to run software that runs natively on windows? and how exactly do you run "windows live" on a mac...if you're a tech-newbie?)


Yes, this is a volatile mix. Your point about education (below) reinforces that the users are the weakest link - on any platform - and always will be...... and education would be cool, if people wanted to hear it. Anything beyond a 2-3 sentence explanation seems to be the truest form of repellent of anyone that comes to me with a technical question, but maybe people don't want a college education or 1-2 years of experience under their belt in order to figure out how to operate their computer. Let's not kid ourselves: this is the audience both Apple and Microsoft are after, but by your own admission it is clear Apple is doing a better job at it.

apple IS doing a better job of it. not for trying though. the same group of people who wallow in uneducated bliss are the same people who buy shit because "it's so shiny!". seriously, advertising that macs come with "spinners" would generate just as much crowd response as announcing that they have new CPU's. MS isn't after nincompoops--they want everyone. apple, on the other hand, doesn't seem to care. it almost would appear that apple thinks the educated consumer is the enemy.

and oh yeah, a college education (4-year degree) is worth less than the shit i took last week. so yes, if you can't figure out a computer--as a college student or graduate--i'm hardly surprised. it's no longer "in fashion" to be an educated consumer. the only reason people re-evaluate that behavior is when the economy takes a crap & budgets start becoming shoestring.


However, the pre-conditioned 'clicking ok' on everything is something that has plagued Windows users for years. If not, how is it that these viruses are so rampant?

now that's just beyone naive. windows viruses are so rampant because....let's see....

Usage share of operating systems - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Usage_share_of_operating_systems)

oh look. windows has 90 FREAKING % of the market! nah...that can't possibly be why so many viruses target windows--regardless of user competence. and "clicking on everything" isn't what plagues windows. in fact, most of the pop-ups that generate said "clicky things" are caused by malware ALREADY INSTALLED on the system. random ads for "spyware blocker software" result from deficiencies in internet-security-suite software in the first place.

better still...until recently, MS never even once insinuated that its users would be "safe and secure" just from using windows. (i'm still not sure that it has come out and overtly said that since it created security essentials). apple, on the other hand, gives you the "shit in a box with a guarantee on the side". now i could stick my head up a bulls ass to get a look at a t-bone steak...but i'll take the butcher's word for it.

stealthify
06-14-2011, 08:33 AM
have you ever developed a large scale consumer product before?no.
Don't worry, neither have I. But let us speculate for a moment, shall we? Your are a behemoth of a software and hardware development company and you have a product to offer but you must make an important decision on the route you will go. When choosing to offer your software open or closed, you are faced with the cold hard fact that this decision could potentially cost you far more in support than it does to actually create the software you intend to offer. You are in charge of providing your own technical support and you must do it with as much grace as possible in order to keep your clientele from jumping ship in a rather competitive market.

This may seem like business-theory rambling, but consider the implications. Everyone is in the business of making money, Google - Microsoft - Apple, and decisions like this do not come easy to all. It came easy to Google... who offers their tech support? Not them. Who do you call if you have a problem with your Android device? Your carrier, or HTC/Motorola, etc. Where is Google when you want to call them to get some official Android support? Gone... like the wind.

This doesn't seem like a plausible option for Apple. Put yourself in their shoes, and consider it from the perspective of a company interested in staying afloat. Do you want to toss all your company's money out the door providing tech support to some old lady that nonchalantly side-loaded a shady app and before she knew it her phone had become malware infested (http://www.androidarea.org/third-party-chinese-android-app-contains-trojan-malware/), was overheating (http://forum.xda-developers.com/archive/index.php/t-920811.html), and shedding battery life (http://www.slashgear.com/third-party-android-apps-causing-poor-battery-life-reckons-ceo-schmidt-1986077/) faster than she could charge it? Sounds like more trouble than it's worth. But hey, you don't have to take my word for it, listen to what Motorola's CEO had to say about it:


"Seventy per cent of devices are coming back because they have downloaded a third-party application, and the effect that has on performance is vast"
Source: Motorola CEO Disses Open Android, Bad Apps Hinder Performance - Sanjay Jha - Zimbio (http://www.zimbio.com/Sanjay+Jha/articles/d8FPpyMrWXk/Motorola+CEO+Disses+Open+Android+Bad+Apps)

This is the sole reason I can't fault Apple on their decision to not open iOS like Android, or to open Mac OS X like Linux. And on that note, who provides official Linux support? Ah... no one. ;)

I know I can't change your thinking on why Apple likely does the things it does, but I challenge you to think outside the box and really consider why Apple has had to make some paths more difficult (yet not impossible, mind you) to reach than others.

tl;dr: It would be absolutely impossible, financially, for Apple to open its systems and still offer the same caliber of technical support that their consumers have become accustom to. It would create more problems than it would solve, and they would be left with having to pick up the pieces. With Apple's current structure, it would be nothing short of company suicide.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

This is all I had interest in writing tonight, but while I'm here let me just point out a few more of your misguided 'facts':


bricking is what apple has done--on numerous occasions--to those who have jailbroken their phones.
False (http://www.wired.com/gadgets/mac/commentary/cultofmac/2007/10/cultofmac_1003). Apple users have bricked their own phone by using buggy jailbreaking methods and/or shoddy apps from Cydia, etc.


the "magic" that its users seem to ascribe to it.
You'll be happy to know that Apple did not use the word 'magic' a single time in their latest convention at WWDC. No mention of unicorns, leprechauns or the Easter bunny were to be found, either.


a good excuse why they cost $500 more than competing pc's
13.3in Intel i5 2.30ghz Sony Vaio - $1349.99 (http://www.sonystyle.com/webapp/wcs/stores/servlet/SYCTOProcess?catalogId=10551&storeId=10151&langId=-1&LBomId=8198552921666333954&categoryId=8198552921644796502)
13in Intel i5 2.30ghz Macbook Pro - $1199.00 (http://store.apple.com/us/configure/MC700LL/A?mco=MjEyOTY3NTg)


native support for PC games or PC software without the use of emulation/dual-boot software. (and seriously, if it's so "consumer friendly" why does the consumer have to go through so many more hurdles to run software that runs natively on windows?
The simple answer is that they don't. Read: Boot Camp Assistant (http://switchtoamac.com/guides/applications/utilities/boot-camp-assistant/what-is-boot-camp-assistant.html). It is literally a three step process to get up and running on Windows.


it almost would appear that apple thinks the educated consumer is the enemy.
Find me a quote where Apple is directly aiming to scare advanced consumers from their computers. You won't find one. I am more inclined to say Apple gives educated consumers the benefit of the doubt and doesn't feel the need to spend millions of dollars marketing to them. Think about it, do educated consumers really need to be advertised to? If they needed a commercial to tell them what to buy, something tells me they're probably not all that educated.


oh look. windows has 90 FREAKING % of the market! nah...that can't possibly be why so many viruses target windows
Well that makes plenty of sense, obviously, until you apply it to another operating system market... say - smartphones?

Android vs. iPhone and iPad by the numbers - Computerworld (http://www.computerworld.com/s/article/9217437/Android_vs._iPhone_and_iPad_by_the_numbers)

How many times have you heard of an iOS device getting some type of devastating malware? Now, how many have you heard about it on Android (http://www.androidpolice.com/2011/03/01/the-mother-of-all-android-malware-has-arrived-stolen-apps-released-to-the-market-that-root-your-phone-steal-your-data-and-open-backdoor/)?

Your argument just shat itself.


better still...until recently, MS never even once insinuated that its users would be "safe and secure" just from using windows.
And Apple never insinuated that either. Go back and re-watch that Apple commercial (you know, the one where Mac guy is making fun of the sick PC guy). The statement was that Mac OS X, at the moment, is more safe (in the numbers game) and less likely to get a virus than Windows - and that, sir, is not a lie. ;)

IPD
06-14-2011, 09:19 AM
tl;dr: It would be absolutely impossible, financially, for Apple to open its systems and still offer the same caliber of technical support that their consumers have become accustom to. It would create more problems than it would solve, and they would be left with having to pick up the pieces. With Apple's current structure, it would be nothing short of company suicide.

apple's "great customer support" is still a myth. i'm honestly surprised that tech support doesn't pull out bones, tarot cards, and a crystal ball when they have to work on apple shiz. it's not great customer support. it's, "pay us the $$$ we tell you to, and we'll make the problem go away for you." again, i don't think it's overtly bad...just a by product of owning a company that DELIBERATELY caters to technophobes and nincompoops--and doesn't care or desire to educate them.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

This is all I had interest in writing tonight, but while I'm here let me just point out a few more of your misguided 'facts':



False (http://www.wired.com/gadgets/mac/commentary/cultofmac/2007/10/cultofmac_1003). Apple users have bricked their own phone by using buggy jailbreaking methods and/or shoddy apps from Cydia, etc.

great. so apple isn't malicious, just bloody incompetant. really helping your case out here, bub. and no, bricking isn't isolated to one refresh or one particular phone. and at least once it was proven to be isolated to just jailbroken phones.


You'll be happy to know that Apple did not use the word 'magic' a single time in their latest convention at WWDC. No mention of unicorns, leprechauns or the Easter bunny were to be found, either.

semantics. i call it magic because that's what it is. apple calls it "proprietary circuitry", "integrated enhancements" and a whole bunch of other muckety-muck that doesn't mean anything except sound impressive. it's like watching a goddamn episode of star trek TNG. quasi-pseudo-scientific-late-20th-century-tech-sounding-words. oooooooh.....spooky!!!!!!!!!!!!



13.3in Intel i5 2.30ghz Sony Vaio - $1349.99 (http://www.sonystyle.com/webapp/wcs/stores/servlet/SYCTOProcess?catalogId=10551&storeId=10151&langId=-1&LBomId=8198552921666333954&categoryId=8198552921644796502)
13in Intel i5 2.30ghz Macbook Pro - $1199.00 (http://store.apple.com/us/configure/MC700LL/A?mco=MjEyOTY3NTg)

Newegg.com - TOSHIBA Satellite L635-S3104 NoteBook Intel Core i5 480M(2.66GHz) 13.3" 4GB Memory DDR3 1066 640GB HDD 5400rpm DVD Super Multi Intel HD Graphics (http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16834214184)
Newegg.com - HP ProBook 6360b (XU055UT#ABA) Notebook Intel Core i5 2410M(2.30GHz) 13.3" 4GB Memory DDR3 1333 320GB HDD 7200rpm DVD Super Multi Intel HD Graphics 3000 (http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16834157828)

oh sure, if you search, you can find 1 or 2 pc's selling for MORE than apple's crap--but you must REALLY be an idiot if you buy them. hell, i can get a 15.6" MSI gaming laptop for practically the same cost as that sony.

trust me, you can post up any apple PC/laptop/airbook/macpos & i can find an equivalent system for much less; and the contrast only gets worse the higher up the food chain you go.



The simple answer is that they don't. Read: Boot Camp Assistant (http://switchtoamac.com/guides/applications/utilities/boot-camp-assistant/what-is-boot-camp-assistant.html). It is literally a three step process to get up and running on Windows.

that's three more steps than i have to take. :) not to mention that the consumer STILL has to track down drivers, patches and any other quirky problems which the program may have natively. but just for the benefit of the doubt, let's assume that mac can "code-wise" handle games just as well as windows (which i know for a FACT that it can't). that being the case...who games on a mac? have you ever seen a south korean playing starcraft on one? how about fati1ity kicking some FPS ass? hell, has ANYONE ever seriously tried gaming on a mac? no? well...i guess that really says something, now doesn't it?


Find me a quote where Apple is directly aiming to scare advanced consumers from their computers. You won't find one. I am more inclined to say Apple gives educated consumers the benefit of the doubt and doesn't feel the need to spend millions of dollars marketing to them. Think about it, do educated consumers really need to be advertised to? If they needed a commercial to tell them what to buy, something tells me they're probably not all that educated.

trick question. the only "educated" consumers apple has are those that never rely on apple tech support. they're also likely those stuck with using apple products for work-related reasons. besides, apple doesn't need to scare away the users who learn. it's developed a virtual black-hole of apple apps and interconnectedness that anyone who tries to pull away finds it impossible to do so. (and those who do find that they're out of $$$ that they spent on itunes, istore, etc).

it's a self-perpetuating cash-cow. an ingenious design, but still diabolical.



Well that makes plenty of sense, obviously, until you apply it to another operating system market... say - smartphones?

Android vs. iPhone and iPad by the numbers - Computerworld (http://www.computerworld.com/s/article/9217437/Android_vs._iPhone_and_iPad_by_the_numbers)

How many times have you heard of an iOS device getting some type of devastating malware? Now, how many have you heard about it on Android (http://www.androidpolice.com/2011/03/01/the-mother-of-all-android-malware-has-arrived-stolen-apps-released-to-the-market-that-root-your-phone-steal-your-data-and-open-backdoor/)?

Your argument just shat itself.

about equal amounts of malware, actually. surprising, really, considering the death-choke that jobs has on the iphone. so even if you can presuppose that draconian control is what is keeping the viruses at bay--do you REALLY want to be forced to sacrifice your user liberty just so that you can "be protected"? if that's the cause, why are you online at all? unplug from the damn internet so you can't get hacked---PERIOD.

personally, i DON'T like being told what i can and can't do with my own stuff. i have anti-virus to guard against bad shit from happening to my PC. apple's solution has nothing to do with safeguards; it just wants to throttle everything to the point it can monitor everything. f-that.

as "problematic" as you seem to think android is, mark my words. android will have a VASTLY superior virus-protection offering to anything ios will have. why? because of exposure. android, like it or not, will be exposed to much more--because of its nature. this gives it a HUGE leg up on anti-virus efforts. and when the time comes (if it does) to upgrade to a smartphone, it'll be meego, android, or winmo. it will NOT be with a company that has a black hole to keep consumers from leaving, and an anti-virus posture that's a combination of "security through obscurity" and "big brother is watching you".



And Apple never insinuated that either. Go back and re-watch that Apple commercial (you know, the one where Mac guy is making fun of the sick PC guy). The statement was that Mac OS X, at the moment, is more safe (in the numbers game) and less likely to get a virus than Windows - and that, sir, is not a lie. ;)

less likely to get a virus? maybe if you ran both windows and a mac without ANY antivirus whatsoever. yet mac viruses are much more likely to cause MASSIVE damage...because the OS hasn't been exploited to the ends of the earth like windows. what can get hacked WILL get hacked--and on a mac, that will likely have devastating results.

now as an educated consumer, i understand this. the sheeple, however, do not. and that's what makes apple's claims not only heinous; it makes them downright evil.

stealthify
06-14-2011, 10:43 AM
apple's "great customer support" is still a myth.
Lie.
Apple Tops PC Customer Service Rankings - NYTimes.com (http://bits.blogs.nytimes.com/2009/04/17/apple-tops-pc-customer-service-rankings/)


it's not great customer support. it's, "pay us the $$$ we tell you to, and we'll make the problem go away for you."
Lie.
Walk into an Apple Store in need of technical support, walk out with the answers you were looking for. It's common knowledge that you can bring your busted machine to the 'Genius' bar and they'll do what they can, within reason, to help you right on the spot. No hourly charge, no major hassle. Easy.



Apple users have bricked their own phone by using buggy jailbreaking methods and/or shoddy apps from Cydia, etc.great. so apple isn't malicious, just bloody incompetant.
Huh?
What does jailbreaking have anything to do with Apple's competency level? This is a problem birthed from half-baked quick releases of jailbreaking tools. A third-party programmer makes a faulty patch, and you blame Apple for this? I suppose I shouldn't be surprised.


not to mention that the consumer STILL has to track down drivers, patches and any other quirky problems which the program may have natively.
False.
On the Mac side of things they only need one driver (again as mentioned, here (http://switchtoamac.com/guides/applications/utilities/boot-camp-assistant/what-is-boot-camp-assistant.html)), and that one is included on the CD that came with your computer. All other drivers are in Windows' hands, and are no different than the ones you'd need to download on any other machine.


has ANYONE ever seriously tried gaming on a mac? no? well...i guess that really says something, now doesn't it?
You'd be surprised. I mentioned it before but its worth mentioning again:


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fjLQ1dZIU7E


(and those who do find that they're out of $$$ that they spent on itunes, istore, etc).
False.
How are they out of the money? The stuff you buy on iTunes, the App Store, etc are yours for life. Transfer it as many times as you want between devices, convert your music to whatever format you please. iTunes, case in point, went DRM-free long ago.

If you are about to say (when it comes to the apps), that you'll then be locked into iOS in order to use them. Well man, I hate to break it to you, but this also applies to Android and Windows as well.


about equal amounts of malware, actually.
False.
How can you even say that? Please, provide your sources. iOS hasn't seen squat in terms of malware attacks, and yes, you're right, a lot of this is accredited to the App Store being the key provider of content on iOS devices.



do you REALLY want to be forced to sacrifice your user liberty just so that you can "be protected"?
I don't feel as though I'm sacrificing any liberties. My personal iPhone is jailbroken and has been for the last three years, despite the decreasing reasons for me to keep it jailbroken as Apple incorporated most of the features I desired but couldn't wait for (ie: copy/paste, tethering, multitasking, notifications, etc). Now all of this stuff is built-in, and I've found Apple's solutions to be far more reliable than their jailbroken alternatives. At this point I jailbreak only because I can, and because its really actually ridiculously simple.

Apple hasn't done a thing to tell me what I can and can't do with my phone. They've only made recommendations and put up these 'soft-walls' (or as you guys like to call it, the walled garden), that are just as easy to climb over as they've ever been. Four years of offering the iPhone, you'd think that if Apple wanted to make it more difficult to jailbreak, they would have. And they almost did (http://www.networkworld.com/news/2010/121010-apple-ios-jailbreak.html), but ultimately reverted that decision.

No harm, no foul.


apple's solution has nothing to do with safeguards; it just wants to throttle everything to the point it can monitor everything.
There is no throttling on Mac OS X. I can install what I want, when I want, how I want, while even posting on an anti-mac blog if I wanted to. Freedom is within reach.


android, like it or not, will be exposed to much more--because of its nature. this gives it a HUGE leg up on anti-virus efforts.
I won't particularly like it, if you'd really care to know. It sucks that Android has positioned itself to be such an easy target, and clearly some people are getting pretty fed up with that (ie: Motorola's CEO), but gaining anti-virus expertise by being an easy target is nothing to brag about, really.


yet mac viruses are much more likely to cause MASSIVE damage...
False until proven otherwise.

You understand the concept of sandboxing (http://techjournal.318.com/security/a-brief-introduction-to-mac-os-x-sandbox-technology/), right?

Also, we don't have a registry like you do. For example.

That's not to say we're bulletproof as I must keep reinforcing, but we are certainly more bulletproof now than we've ever been (especially compared to the OS 9 days). Something tells me Cupertino is not shaking in their boots thinking that, despite the fact their operating system marketshare is growing, their brand will be more susceptible to an overnight massive-level attack. Though, who knows, we could be living in a house of cards and just not know it yet - but until we see otherwise, making statements like that are pretty unwarranted.

IPD
06-14-2011, 09:06 PM
well, shaun, congratulations. i now feel like i'm arguing with AO. i don't feel like expending further energy. fools and their money are soon parted. the evidence is out there. those who seek it will find it. those who don't seek it are apple's target market.

/thread.

p.s.

you can find redeeming qualities about hitler if you look hard enough. doesn't change anything about who he was or what he did.

i3igpete
06-14-2011, 10:11 PM
well, you know, he didn't invent antisemitism. he was a product of the society he lived in: post war austria that was, in fact, bankrupted by western jews. and whether you like it or not, germany is better off because of him. incredibly clean, modern, and germans work hard and play hard. we should all be so lucky.

stealthify
06-14-2011, 10:13 PM
well, shaun, congratulations. i now feel like i'm arguing with AO. i don't feel like expending further energy. fools and their money are soon parted. the evidence is out there. those who seek it will find it. those who don't seek it are apple's target market.

Just playing with you man, all in good fun. Plus I know how your nights @ work can be rather boring (I think you might have mentioned before).

I know I can't change your mind, just as you likely know you can't change mine. But all this typing was getting pretty tiresome.

IPD
06-15-2011, 03:08 AM
well, you know, he didn't invent antisemitism. he was a product of the society he lived in: post war austria that was, in fact, bankrupted by western jews. and whether you like it or not, germany is better off because of him. incredibly clean, modern, and germans work hard and play hard. we should all be so lucky.

not bad. now....can you convince the rest of the world that the 3/s has significant resale value?

Mikes2nd
06-15-2011, 01:29 PM
oh sure, if you search, you can find 1 or 2 pc's selling for MORE than apple's crap--but you must REALLY be an idiot if you buy them. hell, i can get a 15.6" MSI gaming laptop for practically the same cost as that sony.

trust me, you can post up any apple PC/laptop/airbook/macpos & i can find an equivalent system for much less; and the contrast only gets worse the higher up the food chain you go.



I always love when the mac guy frantically searches for some insanely priced PC and uses that as an argument. It’s just a pathetic move and shows how much of a desperate Mac fan boi they are to post something so stupid.

Look I found a 5000$ PC! omg now you can see macs are cheap! See!!!

:lo5l:

arguing with this much of a brain washed apple fan boi is pointless, he obviously worships at the church of Jobs...

This type will even swear android has no chance against the almight Iphone... even today after its taken over...

No one can ever write a virus for a mac... its just IMPOSSIBLE man! ...

BigTyla
06-15-2011, 04:57 PM
False until proven otherwise.

You understand the concept of sandboxing (http://techjournal.318.com/security/a-brief-introduction-to-mac-os-x-sandbox-technology/), right?

Also, we don't have a registry like you do. For example.

That's not to say we're bulletproof as I must keep reinforcing, but we are certainly more bulletproof now than we've ever been (especially compared to the OS 9 days). Something tells me Cupertino is not shaking in their boots thinking that, despite the fact their operating system marketshare is growing, their brand will be more susceptible to an overnight massive-level attack. Though, who knows, we could be living in a house of cards and just not know it yet - but until we see otherwise, making statements like that are pretty unwarranted.

You aren't looking hard enough because you're afraid of what you'll find.

Apple's Safari will fall first at hacker contest, past winner predicts - Computerworld (http://www.computerworld.com/s/article/9128878/Apple_s_Safari_will_fall_first_at_hacker_contest_p ast_winner_predicts)


PWN2OWN's sponsor, 3Com Inc.'s TippingPoint unit, will pay $5,000 for each new bug successfully exploited in Safari, Microsoft Corp.'s Internet Explorer 8, Mozilla Corp.'s Firefox or Google Inc.'s Chrome. IE8, Firefox and Chrome will be running on a Sony notebook powered by Windows 7, Microsoft's still-under-construction operating system, while Safari and Firefox will be available on a MacBook.

"Apple's products are really friendly to users, and Safari is designed to handle anything, including all kinds of file formats," said Miller. "With a lot of functionality comes the increased chance of bugs. The more complex software is, the less secure it is."

Another factor making Safari easy pickings, said Miller, is Apple's Mac OS X, which lacks the workable defenses found in Windows Vista and Windows 7, including address space randomization -- which Microsoft calls "address space layout randomization," or ASLR.

And, contrary to your assertion that the Apple OSs are "more bulletproof now than they have ever been, I present:

Apple's Safari browser embarrassed at Pwn2Own, hacked in 5 seconds (http://www.bgr.com/2011/03/10/apples-safari-browser-embarrassed-at-pwn2own-hacked-in-5-seconds/)


But which browser faired the worst? That would be Apple’s Safari. A French security research firm named Vulpen managed to break into Safari running on a MacBook Air in a cool five seconds.

Furthermore, sandboxing is easily exploitable as well.

Safari, IE hacked first at Pwn2Own - Computerworld (http://www.computerworld.com/s/article/9214002/Safari_IE_hacked_first_at_Pwn2Own)


To exploit IE8, Fewer bypassed Protected Mode, said Aaron Portnoy, manager of TippingPoint's security research team and the organizer of Pwn2Own for each of its five years. Protected Mode is Microsoft's name for the sandbox-like anti-exploit technology designed to isolate the browser from the operating system and the rest of the computer.

stealthify
06-15-2011, 05:41 PM
I always love when the mac guy frantically searches for some insanely priced PC and uses that as an argument. It’s just a pathetic move and shows how much of a desperate Mac fan boi they are to post something so stupid.
Mike, if you're going to hate one brand for their prices, you might as well spread the hate to the other brands that charge the same. Not doing so makes you a hypocrite, just as blind as those fanboi's you hate on, and a waste of everyone's time to argue with.

Just so you know, but not that it matters, there was no frantic searches. In fact, I was reading an article just the other day while doing some research on videography that I ran across someone (just mentioning) that they bought a Sony Vaio S Series for north of what he could have gotten a MBP for. Then of course there was J-Groove's post in the other thread about Dell's all-in-one machines. These are huge and popular competing brands. This shit isn't hard to find. ;)


No one can ever write a virus for a mac... its just IMPOSSIBLE man! ...

(safari vulnerabilities)
You guys could at least do us all a favor and read what I've written, even if it's not what you want to hear, before responding. Never once did I say Mac OS X is bulletproof, never once did I say the Android has no chance against the iPhone (and that in fact I would probably own one of each, if there were reason), never once did I say Jobs was the f'n Messiah.

BigTyla
06-15-2011, 06:44 PM
You guys could at least do us all a favor and read what I've written, even if it's not what you want to hear, before responding. Never once did I say Mac OS X is bulletproof, never once did I say the Android has no chance against the iPhone (and that in fact I would probably own one of each, if there were reason), never once did I say Jobs was the f'n Messiah.

I read what you wrote. You stated


we are certainly more bulletproof now than we've ever been (especially compared to the OS 9 days).

and I posted evidence to the contrary. The OS and its associated browser are more vulnerable than ever.

stealthify
06-15-2011, 06:49 PM
Tyler, have you ever used classic Mac OS? As in OS 7, 8 or 9?

I did. And when I tell you it was more vulnerable to MASSIVE, computer-disabling attacks, I wasn't making stuff up. Those days were annoying as hell. :)

BigTyla
06-15-2011, 07:33 PM
Tyler, have you ever used classic Mac OS? As in OS 7, 8 or 9?

I did. And when I tell you it was more vulnerable to MASSIVE, computer-disabling attacks, I wasn't making stuff up. Those days were annoying as hell. :)

Classic? Negative. I can only comment on the recent increase in frequency of attacks and vulnerabilities on Mac OS. When your stuff gets hacked in 5 seconds that's never a good sign. :p

IPD
06-15-2011, 08:55 PM
Tyler, have you ever used classic Mac OS? As in OS 7, 8 or 9?

I did. And when I tell you it was more vulnerable to MASSIVE, computer-disabling attacks, I wasn't making stuff up. Those days were annoying as hell. :)

...and yet, for some unknown reason, you endured it? hell, if this is the "apple experience" of today, and it's supposedly "so much better than before" i'd be downright LIVID if i had to put up with the old crap.

and you know what? the best indicator of future performance is past performance. so i'm going stick with "situation does NOT look good for apple".

p.s.
now who is the fanboy?

p.p.s.
osx is like using IE6....only worse.

onebadmollafolla
06-15-2011, 11:06 PM
http://i.imgur.com/P8Mw0.png

stealthify
06-15-2011, 11:27 PM
Classic? Negative. I can only comment on the recent increase in frequency of attacks and vulnerabilities on Mac OS. When your stuff gets hacked in 5 seconds that's never a good sign. :p

I remember reading about Pwn2Own contest when it happened, but do you recall them ever saying exactly what vulnerability they found? I read the bad with the good, but I don't recall that very important point ever being identified. For all we know it was "ohh h3y l00k guyz, I m4de SaFaRi AuT0-quitz!! Vulnerability f0uNd!" Was it, actually, a vulnerability with Flash? Or perhaps Java? Do we blame Apple for this if it was?

Regardless, my point was simple, and it still stands. Mac OS X, completely rebuilt compared to OS 9, incorporated techniques to make it less susceptible to massive and system-shattering attacks. Gone are the days of corruptible extensions, conflicting control panels, etc. So yes, on a system level (ie: not just a browser bug), Mac OS is more secure and stable (not vulnerable-free) than it's ever been.

PS - One 'news-worthy' attack a year, which is nothing more than an app that poses as a legit app to score credit cards, hardly is an 'increase in frequency'. ;) Come on man, be reasonable.


osx is like using IE6....only worse.
Now you's just trollin'. ;) As if that's not what you were doing from the get-go.

x2xtreme360
06-15-2011, 11:34 PM
You can spot an article written by a PC fanboy a mile away. ;)


I'm not reading this whole damn thread, but I thought I'd just comment on the fact that it's actually 100% easier to spot an Apple fanboi than a PC one (do PC "fanboi's" even exist?) You guys wear all your merchandise, dress nicely, show it off in Starbucks, and on top of it all, the damn Apple store is ALWAYS cluttered with clueless morons who don't know how to GET THE F OUT OF YOUR WAY WHEN YOU WANT TO GET TO THE DAMN FOOD COURT!

stealthify
06-15-2011, 11:35 PM
I'm not reading this whole damn thread, but I thought I'd just comment on the fact that it's actually 100% easier to spot an Apple fanboi than a PC one

I'd agree with that.

But yeah, I think there's fanbois for every brand. Just about.

IPD
06-16-2011, 12:05 AM
DailyTech - Leaked Docs Showcase Apple's Meticulous Control of Retail Store Employees (http://www.dailytech.com/Leaked+Docs+Showcase+Apples+Meticulous+Control+of+ Retail+Store+Employees+/article21915.htm)

oh look. now you can't have a personal opinion about apple--if you want to stay employed with them. hell the CINC is my boss and i can publicly disagree with him (even if i still have to obey orders).

stealthify
06-16-2011, 12:09 AM
DailyTech - Leaked Docs Showcase Apple's Meticulous Control of Retail Store Employees (http://www.dailytech.com/Leaked+Docs+Showcase+Apples+Meticulous+Control+of+ Retail+Store+Employees+/article21915.htm)

oh look. now you can't have a personal opinion about apple--if you want to stay employed with them. hell the CINC is my boss and i can publicly disagree with him (even if i still have to obey orders).

So they're being trained how to be efficient sales people (staying away from negative terms like 'unfortunately', etc). Check.

This isn't something exclusive to Apple, hate to break it to you. This is Marketing and Sales 101.

IPD
06-16-2011, 12:14 AM
I'd agree with that.

But yeah, I think there's fanbois for every brand. Just about.

there's very few things i'm a fanboy of. ...but i'm an ANTI-fanboy of a lot more stuff. just a short list:

bob nardelli
chrysler in general--but especially the crossfire
xbox
honda civic
apple
"domestics-only" rednecks (they're the same ones who always yell about mitsubishi making the zero)
3rd-party shovelware...especially when it's on the wii
FPS's designed principally for consoles
1080p resolution (and 16:9 or "flatter" resolutions in general)
gloss tv and monitor screens
the cost of mobile GPU cards
LMI

i could go on...but i think i've made my point.

IPD
06-16-2011, 12:16 AM
So they're being trained how to be efficient sales people (staying away from negative terms like 'unfortunately', etc). Check.

This isn't something exclusive to Apple, hate to break it to you. This is Marketing and Sales 101.

steering language is one thing. crushing any dissenting opinions among employees is quite another. in typical itard fashion, you completely missed that part.

stealthify
06-16-2011, 12:16 AM
That's okay Thadd, I'm not hating.

stealthify
06-16-2011, 12:19 AM
steering language is one thing. crushing any dissenting opinions among employees is quite another. in typical itard fashion, you completely missed that part.

I don't believe that article said anything about them not being allowed to form their own opinions, but to work at their store and expect to still get a paycheck, yes, that makes sense to not bash your employer. They're being paid to sell stuff, not discourage people from it.

Keep in mind this isn't Best Buy they're working for.

IPD
06-16-2011, 12:25 AM
I don't believe that article said anything about them not being allowed to form their own opinions, but to work at their store and expect to still get a paycheck, yes, that makes sense to not bash your employer. They're being paid to sell stuff, not discourage people from it.

Keep in mind this isn't Best Buy they're working for.

saying it face to face to a customer is one thing. posting your opinion online is quite different. it's a "work here and forgo your 1st amendment right". it's just that simple.

and you're right. best buy employees are paid just as pitifully; but at least they can still have opinions.

stealthify
06-16-2011, 12:27 AM
saying it face to face to a customer is one thing. posting your opinion online is quite different. it's a "work here and forgo your 1st amendment right". it's just that simple.

and you're right. best buy employees are paid just as pitifully; but at least they can still have opinions.

Is this on par with 'treason'? Sounds ridiculous, doesn't it? But with so many people that are HAPPY to work for Apple (as that article states), if you don't like it, you should get the hell out.

IPD
06-16-2011, 12:42 AM
Is this on par with 'treason'? Sounds ridiculous, doesn't it? But with so many people that are HAPPY to work for Apple (as that article states), if you don't like it, you should get the hell out.

i don't do business with apple; it's my way of underlining my stance on the company.

i'm vocal about it because there's a LOT of people who don't know. apple is the tech version of the church of scientology--that is...if you don't classify apple as a religion in the first place. i think a lot of people are happy to work for apple because they're happy getting a paycheck PERIOD.

p.s.

apple making more $$$ per square foot than ANY OTHER RETAIL STORE. hmmmm.....nah. apple products COULDN'T POSSIBLY BE OVERPRICED.

/sarcasm.

stealthify
06-16-2011, 12:56 AM
It's a businesses' job to make money, man.

IPD
06-16-2011, 01:11 AM
It's a businesses' job to make money, man.

yep. and in good conscience, it's my prerogative to try and help people not get ripped off. thanks for impeding that...fanboy. ;)

stealthify
06-16-2011, 01:13 AM
I don't feel ripped off, fanboy of the anti-fanboys. :p

IPD
06-16-2011, 01:19 AM
I don't feel ripped off, fanboy of the anti-fanboys. :p

what you, personally feel, is not indicative of general evidence to the contrary. if you were a true apple believer, you'd encourage people to explore WHY apple products cost more--not just shout that they're justified in price.

p.s.
i'm not fan of anti-fanboys. i've seen/heard/read enough with my own two eyes to know all that i need to about apple. irony has come full circle:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OYecfV3ubP8

stealthify
06-16-2011, 01:31 AM
what you, personally feel, is not indicative of general evidence to the contrary. if you were a true apple believer, you'd encourage people to explore WHY apple products cost more--not just shout that they're justified in price.

I'm sorry, improper choice of words. I was not ripped off - consider that my testimonial. And I'm not just saying this to disagree with you.

I've gotten more than my money's worth out of my Apple products, and then some.

IPD
07-06-2011, 08:28 AM
DailyTech - Apple Lawyers Attempt Kill Shot on Samsung's Flagship Smartphones (http://www.dailytech.com/Article.aspx?newsid=22068&red=y#695977)

more amazing awesomeness from the land of apple. the fail never ends.

p.s.
comments by "macdevdude" have convinced me that astroturfing is real; it is a threat; and it needs to be cracked down on.

*edit*

p.p.s.
http://www.tuaw.com/2008/05/01/flickr-find-grand-theft-auto-hides-apple-and-iphone-parody/ :lmao:

stealthify
07-06-2011, 09:24 AM
Apple sues Samsung, Samsung sues Apple. Apple continues to do business with Samsung and puts over 6 billion dollars in their pockets annually for components. You're just getting wind of this now? :confused1:

You do understand that if Apple's legal team doesn't defend its patents, they'll lose them - right? This holds true for any business and applies not just to hardware design (in this case), but logos, likeness, etc as well. Losing these patents could be devastating, especially when some of your largest competitors are trying to get them out from underneath you for free.

I, personally, think this is a case of Samsung saying 'well, Apple's product has been working. It's a slick design. We could either re-invent the wheel or we can just model our phone closely after theirs and hope they don't notice.' (and by 'modeling it closely after theirs', I mean let's use the same exact colors, button/camera placement, backside bevel, icon design, design cues, materials, etc). I mean damn, just make it look like Apple made it! All this while not even consulting Apple about licensing any of these patents just to avoid the legal trouble.

The only thing Samsung is at risk of is having to go back to the drawing-board in order to come up with something with a bit more originality. Or, alternatively, they can do things right and talk to Apple about paying to share the patents so that they can continue to use them. Easy. They've got the money.

I know it's easy to criminalize someone who ties up the legal system with (what seems to us like) silly things having to do with menial patents and designs, but to these large companies these infringements could end up costing them a LOT of money. And Apple is not the only ones needing to do this (Microsoft v. Motorola, Google v. Specht, etc).

Those jerks. :runaway:

:)

IPD
07-06-2011, 10:36 AM
shaun, apart from the "biting the hand that feeds it" aspect of apple suing samsung...there's a bit more humor to this.

1. apple didn't create the first touchscreen phone; let alone even being the first to use this particular "form factor/desigin". at the very least, one has to credit the LG prada as beating it to the market--even though the prada wasn't the first touchscreen phone. i don't dispute the patents exist; i dispute the validity thereof. according to apple, everything that came before didn't exist; and everything that came after is a copycat/clone. this is laughable at best.

2. patenting a size of phone, color, or a generic icon (like the logo of a power button) is possible--but won't hold water in court. as commenters in my link had posted, this isn't like GM making a mustang. this is like GM making a black, 2-door coupe with a v8 engine--and ford suing them for patent infringement. apple suing amazon for having an app store. apple will sue whenever, wherever they think they can get away with it.

3. apple doesn't share. apple will NOT grant license rights to samsung if it did (by some freak accident) win these preposterous lawsuits. psystar was not allowed to make macs; it was trampled to death. apple wants to sue, it wants money, and it wants to ensure market dominance by bullying. hey, that's fine--it's a free market; but let's call it for what it is.

4. apple isn't unilaterally suing all smartphone makers who made a black, regangular, touchscreen phone with buttons. apple doesn't appear to be carrying a hatchet for LG. perhaps this is because apple knows that LG legitimately beat them to the punch, and they don't have a snowball in hell's chance of winning.

believe me, i'm all for defending one's territory. that said, apple is trying to make the claim that they're the only ones who own the rights to touchscreen phones--well technically, black, rectangular ones with buttons on the front.

stealthify
07-06-2011, 11:12 AM
shaun, apart from the "biting the hand that feeds it" aspect of apple suing samsung...there's a bit more humor to this.
See, this is where your hypocrisy is showing. Again.

Biting the hand that feeds? In your world, Samsung blatantly copying Apple, without Apple's permission, is not considered biting the hand that feeds? This double-standard is amazing.


apple didn't create the first touchscreen phone; let alone even being the first to use this particular "form factor/desigin".
As much as that article would have you believe, after they dumb down what this lawsuit is all about, you might walk away thinking that Apple is suing Samsung because they use a 'touchscreen' on their device. If this was the case, and just like you strangely mentioned in your point #4, Apple would be going sue-happy with every single cell phone manufacturer. But they're not. They're going after the ones that tried to boldly mimic Apple's style. When you look at the Galaxy S (not pro), what is the first thing you see? It looks almost exactly like a cheaper version of the iPhone 3G/3GS! This is no coincidence.

Did Apple go after Motorola for the design of the Droid 1 or 2, which also sports a touchscreen? No. The Droid is different enough to not be confused with Apple's patented design. Yet it still had buttons and a touchscreen.

This isn't about 'Samsung making a phone with a touchscreen that has some buttons,' this is about Samsung so brazenly copying Apple's form-factor and not paying a cent to do so.


apple suing amazon for having an app store. apple will sue whenever, wherever they think they can get away with it.
Just like Amazon suing time and time again over 'one-click purchasing (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1-Click)'. When you really open your eyes you will begin to see every company capable of doing so will defend its patents, no matter how 'generic' they seem.

But you're right, these patents will be tested to see if they hold water in court. And for the most part, they have been. And just like Apple pointed out some of the obvious ways that Samsung copied their design, Samsung is doing the same exact thing to Apple, saying Apple stole some of their ideas. As it stands right now, I believe the court has ruled that Apple has more of a case than Samsung. That is why Samsung isn't looking so hot right now.


apple doesn't share. apple will NOT grant license rights to samsung if it did (by some freak accident) win these preposterous lawsuits. psystar was not allowed to make macs; it was trampled to death.
I know Psystar is a touchy subject with you, but in many ways these cases relate. I could almost write a whole separate post about Psystar and how they could have handled things completely differently. But in short, this all ties back in to Apple's business model and trying to financially stay afloat. They make little to no money on their OS (charging $29), and instead they make their money on selling hardware. In essence, the price of Mac OS X is subsidized, because Apple knows it'll make its money back on the hardware end of things. Allowing Psystar to make hackintoshes essentially cut Apple out of the equation completely, and they would be losing money on every hackintosh sold.

You know, I watched an interesting conference the other day and I thought about you. If you're bored one of these nights, I really encourage you to watch it - even if it pains you to do so:

YouTube - ‪Apple WWDC '97 Steve Jobs (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3LEXae1j6EY&feature=player_embedded#at=2145)

It addresses the issues of cloning, and if you watch it through to the end you'll see that things aren't quite what they seem.

IPD
07-06-2011, 11:38 AM
"biting the hand that feeds it" was simply in regards to apple sourcing all of its screens from samsung. that's it.

look, there's legitimate patent lawsuits out there. dyson suing hoover was pretty clear-cut. dyson wasn't making claims about the design of an upright vacuum; it was rightfully defending its development of the use of centripidal force filtration in a vacuum.

apple doesn't have anything propritary. as i stated, it's like ford claiming that only it can produce the automobile in a 2-door, coupe with a v8 engine. it's preposterous.

p.s.
if apple has to fight clones so much, perhaps it should consider a change to its business model; like going software-only. of course, we know this will never happen....because as soon as apple only sells software, it will die off. there will be no physical hardware for itards to coo over and froth at the mouth over all the "propritary" functions that jobs tells them they need.

p.p.s.
even if you added another $200 to the cost of osx for clone-makers, you'd still have clones costing $300 less than macs. apple won't allow that.

BigTyla
07-06-2011, 11:42 AM
I read this yesterday. When I got to this part


Apple claims that Samsung's phones look too much like the iPhone in that they are small, thin black rectangles with buttons.


I laughed hysterically. I will be irate if Apple wins this portion of the suit.

stealthify
07-06-2011, 11:48 AM
As I said, compare the Galaxy S to the iPhone 3G or 3GS.

http://realitypod.com/wp-content/uploads/2010/07/galaxy-s-550x5051.jpg

Now compare the same iPhone to the Droid or the other hordes of touchscreen sporting smart phones that Apple isn't going after.

http://www.mobilecrunch.com/wp-content/uploads/2009/10/DROID-by-Motorola.jpg

You will see that these other smartphone manufacturers actually made an effort to be different. The same can't be said for Samsung. That is why this lawsuit exists, and that is why Apple is winning in the battle against them.

IPD
07-06-2011, 12:27 PM
really? they're suing the shit out of HTC, and htc's smartphones look no more like the iphone than the droid does.

no, i think the real factor here is that HTC was leading the smartphone sales race. samsung is the new leader. both are being sued by apple. that's too much of a coincidence.

BigTyla
07-06-2011, 12:27 PM
You screwed up by saying they make an effort to be different. There are differences in the Galaxy S, however subtle they may be. There's only so many ways you can produce a phone while meeting certain form factors. The smaller phones get, the more homogenized they become.

The Droid pictured above is also a "small, thin black rectangle with buttons." Should Apple be suing Droid as well? Do you see how asanine that is?

It would be an absolute travesty for Apple to win this lawsuit. I can't even begin to imagine the reprecussions this would have throughout the tech community. You'll have microchip producers going after each other because a competitor's chip looks too similar.

Hate to say it Shaun, but you and Apple are totally off base on this one.

stealthify
07-06-2011, 12:37 PM
really? they're suing the shit out of HTC, and htc's smartphones look no more like the iphone than the droid does.

no, i think the real factor here is that HTC was leading the smartphone sales race. samsung is the new leader. both are being sued by apple. that's too much of a coincidence.

Or, maybe these two manufacturers are selling so well because they're modeling after Apple?

While the Samsung argument is obvious (I mean look at the damn thing!), I'm not as well versed on the HTC patent infringement suit. However, it should go without saying that Apple isn't suing them because they are making a smartphone (as a device), they're putting their foot down on some very specific copying that has to do with patents that Apple was legally awarded PRIOR to these manufacturers copying them. If my memory serves me correctly, HTC had around 20 patent infringements that could have had to do with anything that Apple was granted a patent to. How generic these patents were, I have no idea. But in the end, the court will decide better than I ever could.

stealthify
07-06-2011, 12:49 PM
You screwed up by saying they make an effort to be different. There are differences in the Galaxy S, however subtle they may be. There's only so many ways you can produce a phone while meeting certain form factors. The smaller phones get, the more homogenized they become.

The Droid pictured above is also a "small, thin black rectangle with buttons." Should Apple be suing Droid as well? Do you see how asanine that is?

It would be an absolute travesty for Apple to win this lawsuit. I can't even begin to imagine the reprecussions this would have throughout the tech community. You'll have microchip producers going after each other because a competitor's chip looks too similar.

Hate to say it Shaun, but you and Apple are totally off base on this one.

I don't see how I screwed up, Tyler? The point was to be MORE than subtly different. If Toyota came out with a car that could easily be mistaken for a 3000GT (same taillights, sail panels, bumper, etc), would Mitsubishi go after them? I think so. Apple took the time to come up with a phone with pleasing aesthetics, Samsung leeched on that idea and tweaked it subtly. But not enough, and that's why this is an issue.

There are MANY ways to make a unique looking phone, just as there are many ways to make a unique looking car. While the overall concept will be the same (speaker, microphone, camera, screen, etc), it is how closely one manufacturer makes their product to look like another that inspires these patent lawsuits to come up.

As far as the Droid comment goes. No, Apple should not sue Motorola over that. It looks like a completely different phone. And that is why Apple is NOT suing them, no matter how well of a seller the Droid was.

You're currently in the mindset that this article is about Apple telling Samsung to stop making smartphones. That would be a travesty. The good news is that they are not. They're just telling Samsung to stop using their styling cues, especially in combination with one another to make it essentially look exactly like an iPhone 3G/3GS. This is where Apple has grounds to stand on.

In closing, Samsung will continue to make smart phones. They will NOT look like they were designed and made by Apple (with a glossy beveled back, a mute switch in the same exact location, a chrome bezel on the front, etc). The world will be fine, and competition will continue to thrive. That's all there is to it.

IPD
07-06-2011, 12:53 PM
Or, maybe these two manufacturers are selling so well because they're modeling after Apple?

While the Samsung argument is obvious (I mean look at the damn thing!), I'm not as well versed on the HTC patent infringement suit. However, it should go without saying that Apple isn't suing them because they are making a smartphone (as a device), they're putting their foot down on some very specific copying that has to do with patents that Apple was legally awarded PRIOR to these manufacturers copying them. If my memory serves me correctly, HTC had around 20 patent infringements that could have had to do with anything that Apple was granted a patent to. How generic these patents were, I have no idea. But in the end, the court will decide better than I ever could.

wait...you just said they're not cloning apple, because the phones are sufficiently different--and now you're saying they're "modeling after apple"? which is it?

stealthify
07-06-2011, 12:57 PM
wait...you just said they're not cloning apple, because the phones are sufficiently different--and now you're saying they're "modeling after apple"? which is it?

You said that HTC and Samsung happen to be two of Apple's largest competitors, and that is why you suspect Apple is going after them.

I said that perhaps the reason that HTC and Samsung have become such large competitors of Apple is BECAUSE they copied a number of Apple's registered patents.

No flip-flopping here.

IPD
07-06-2011, 12:58 PM
Apple Sues Motorola over Multitouch in Android Phones - Mobile and Wireless - News & Reviews - eWeek.com (http://www.eweek.com/c/a/Mobile-and-Wireless/Apple-Sues-Motorola-Over-Multitouch-in-Android-Phones-404214/)

apple isn't suing motorola? lol!

here's a test. type "apple sues" into google, and see what comes up. in fact, try and find tech companies that apple ISN'T suing currently. :)

stealthify
07-06-2011, 01:02 PM
Apple Sues Motorola over Multitouch in Android Phones - Mobile and Wireless - News & Reviews - eWeek.com (http://www.eweek.com/c/a/Mobile-and-Wireless/Apple-Sues-Motorola-Over-Multitouch-in-Android-Phones-404214/)

apple isn't suing motorola? lol!

here's a test. type "apple sues" into google, and see what comes up. in fact, try and find tech companies that apple ISN'T suing currently. :)

When someone makes a hot product, people will copy it and/or certain aspects of it. In the short amount of time that we've had this caliber of smartphones, it would make sense that certain manufacturers would be quick to copy JUST so they can hit the market faster. You'll see this trend with ANY emerging technology.

But as I said, Apple didn't sue Motorola for the Droid, they had an issue with them infringing on a single patent (multi-touch) that they were legally granted and therefore expected to defend.

IPD
07-06-2011, 01:07 PM
i'm sorry, but apple might as well claim it has a copyright on making a song about telling someone you love them--these patent suits are just that rediculous.

BigTyla
07-06-2011, 01:49 PM
You're currently in the mindset that this article is about Apple telling Samsung to stop making smartphones.

No I'm not. I'm in the mindset that that portion of the lawsuit is completely asinine, and it is. It's almost as bad as the failed Apple "Appstore" lawsuit. That was a real laugher too!

stealthify
07-06-2011, 05:54 PM
No I'm not. I'm in the mindset that that portion of the lawsuit is completely asinine, and it is. It's almost as bad as the failed Apple "Appstore" lawsuit. That was a real laugher too!

:)

You want to know some real asinine patents? Try these on for size:


'1-click purchasing (http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/news/2010/03/controversial-amazon-1-click-patent-survives-review.ars)' - Amazon
'Page up/page down (http://www.zdnet.com/news/microsoft-patents-page-up-and-page-down/218626)' on your keyboard - Microsoft
'Doodles (http://www.pcworld.com/article/222941/google_patents_google_doodles.html)' on Google's Homepage - Google
'Feed (http://www.pcworld.com/article/190329/facebook_news_feed_patent_could_change_everything. html)' for statuses/updates - Facebook


The list goes on.

You guys really should get off your high-horse. You make it sound like Apple is the first and only company to defend their patents. I suppose your vitriol should be pointed towards USPTO, they're the ones approving this stuff.

BigTyla
07-06-2011, 06:50 PM
:)

You want to know some real asinine patents? Try these on for size:


'1-click purchasing (http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/news/2010/03/controversial-amazon-1-click-patent-survives-review.ars)' - Amazon
'Page up/page down (http://www.zdnet.com/news/microsoft-patents-page-up-and-page-down/218626)' on your keyboard - Microsoft
'Doodles (http://www.pcworld.com/article/222941/google_patents_google_doodles.html)' on Google's Homepage - Google
'Feed (http://www.pcworld.com/article/190329/facebook_news_feed_patent_could_change_everything. html)' for statuses/updates - Facebook


The list goes on.

You guys really should get off your high-horse. You make it sound like Apple is the first and only company to defend their patents. I suppose your vitriol should be pointed towards USPTO, they're the ones approving this stuff.

If you think any of those is anywhere close in insanity to the attempt by Apple to patent the term "Appstore" then you are lost.

stealthify
07-06-2011, 06:57 PM
If you think any of those is anywhere close in insanity to the attempt by Apple to patent the term "Appstore" then you are lost.

:NotSureIfTrolling:

BigTyla
07-06-2011, 07:04 PM
:NotSureIfTrolling:

Then I am done speaking to you on the matter. :)

stealthify
07-06-2011, 07:08 PM
Then I am done speaking to you on the matter. :)

Didn't mean to offend you, just wanted to see if you were really serious before I went down this road.

IPD
07-06-2011, 07:24 PM
Didn't mean to offend you, just wanted to see if you were really serious before I went down this road.

i don't have a problem with defending IP. i do have a problem with lawsuits filed under the pretense of defending IP...but in reality are simply attempts to prevent justified competition. apple's track record does NOT speak to being original. it's done a wonderful job of popularizing new technologies--but it hasn't invented them. everthing from the GUI onward has been apple taking something that someone else has done--and making it popular. i'm ok with that--and if it generates sales for them, great.

what i have a problem with is apple trying to paint itself as though it invented something--therefore it has the only right to it. apple doesn't invent. not the mouse, not the smartphone, not the tablet pc, not capacative touchscreens. apple laying claim to these (as it has, as it is doing, and as it has filed numerous lawsuits over) is as inane as claiming that social-networking websites are propritary, and only apple can create them.

stealthify
07-06-2011, 07:38 PM
but in reality are simply attempts to prevent justified competition.

Speculative, and perhaps even warranted. But only Apple could say for sure, but of course they likely won't. No company would.

In the corporate setting it goes without saying, it's a dog-eat-dog world. This is why Nokia sued Apple, and won, and now Apple pays Nokia (http://news.cnet.com/8301-13579_3-20070970-37/apple-agrees-to-pay-nokia-patent-licensing-fees/) to license their patents. And Tyler, related to what you were mentioning, these patents are also considerably and ridiculously generic: ability to run on GSM/3G and Wi-Fi networks, wireless data, speech coding, security, etc.

Company A goes through the proper process to gain a valid patent, Company B swipes it and makes a bunch of money on it, and then Company A defends it if it's defendable. I'm just flabbergasted that this angers you guys. This is, like it or hate it, the way the system works.

BigTyla
07-06-2011, 10:59 PM
Speculative, and perhaps even warranted. But only Apple could say for sure, but of course they likely won't. No company would.

In the corporate setting it goes without saying, it's a dog-eat-dog world. This is why Nokia sued Apple, and won, and now Apple pays Nokia (http://news.cnet.com/8301-13579_3-20070970-37/apple-agrees-to-pay-nokia-patent-licensing-fees/) to license their patents. And Tyler, related to what you were mentioning, these patents are also considerably and ridiculously generic: ability to run on GSM/3G and Wi-Fi networks, wireless data, speech coding, security, etc.

Company A goes through the proper process to gain a valid patent, Company B swipes it and makes a bunch of money on it, and then Company A defends it if it's defendable. I'm just flabbergasted that this angers you guys. This is, like it or hate it, the way the system works.

I will explain this to you and then I am done.

1-click purchase - Feature.
Page up/down - Feature.
"Doodles" - Feature.
Facebook News Feed - Feature
Appstore - Term.

"One of these things is not like the other..."

Can you guess which one of these doesn't belong here?

The term "app" is a generic term used throughout the software world as shorthand for "application." For Apple to attempt to sue another company for describing an interface as an "App store" is idiotic.

This does not mean other companies aren't patent drunk. Apple is just the worst of all the offenders, bringing VERY liberal interpretations to the table to file patent infringements, throwing all of them on the wall and praying one of them sticks.

stealthify
07-07-2011, 04:08 AM
I will explain this to you and then I am done.

1-click purchase - Feature.
Page up/down - Feature.
"Doodles" - Feature.
Facebook News Feed - Feature
Appstore - Term.

"One of these things is not like the other..."

Can you guess which one of these doesn't belong here?

Tyler, you don't need to get so fussy. I'd love to discuss this with you if you'd hear me out, even if you don't agree.

I can tell you which one doesn't belong: App Store. Want to know why? Because that is a trademark infringement, not a patent infringement.

And on that note, do you want to hear another ridiculous trademark? The word 'face' in websites. And guess who owns it and has sued others for using it? Facebook. Now that's a wild one.

While the term 'app' and 'store' and very generic and commonplace words, 'App Store' together, while being the first to trademark it and make it a household name, is a different story. And on that note, even words like 'Apple' and 'Amazon' are fairly generic terms as well - but they have essentially become brands. Brands will association, brands that each company has spent millions to market and to keep associated with their company.

Before mid-2008, did you ever refer to anything as "The App Store"? I doubt you did. Hardly anyone did:

Google Trends: app store (http://www.google.com/trends?q=app+store)

Apple, while they didn't invent 'apps' or 'stores', was the first to really publicize and push the term 'App Store' into households and have it catch. Before long, when I said to someone: "you can find that in the App Store", they automatically knew I was talking about the store belonging to Apple.

And THAT is why Apple is defending it. They're not saying Amazon can't have their own store to sell applications, and even put a slogan under it saying that they specialize in selling apps, but that they essentially want to create their own sub-brand called the 'App Store' (or rather, 'Appstore') as well. And that might lead to confusion, and leeches off the marketing that Apple has already done to push the 'App Store' trademark.

In the end, Apple might lose this battle. They might have gone too far and mainstreamed a term that was too general. I suppose we'll see.

IPD
07-07-2011, 06:27 AM
disney tried to trademark the term "seal team six" after bin laden was taken out. i didn't know disney was merging with apple.

p.s.
if apple was making cars, they'd be trademarking "air conditioning", "power windows", and antilock braking system". :lol:

stealthify
07-07-2011, 07:01 AM
I will admit that the lawsuits get old after awhile, among all the companies. No doubt it's really making the lawyers fat and happy.

Samsung probably feels the same way. It seems everyone is out to get them these days:

Microsoft wants Samsung to pay smartphone license: report | Reuters (http://www.reuters.com/article/2011/07/06/us-samsung-microsoft-idUSTRE7651DB20110706)

GTO Assassin
07-07-2011, 07:19 AM
It shits me to get involved in another apple debate, but if you want to talk lawsuits, your country in fucking vented them! Do we really need to go there?

Here in Australia, lifeguards have apparently patented the term "lifeguard". Beach warfare as Surf Life Saving Australia trademarks the term 'lifeguard' | Courier Mail (http://www.couriermail.com.au/business/caught-off-guard-by-a-name/story-e6freqmx-1226078753987)

It's called life kids. You need to get over it.

Inp - again, you really have a hate for apple yet you wont stop going on and fucking on about the company. Like I said before, did they hurt you as a child or do you really not have better things to do with your time?

Scotty

stealthify
07-07-2011, 07:27 AM
You know, that's rather funny. I was once sent a cease and desist letter for using the name 'Stealthify' on my websites. The guy claimed to own the word 'Stealth,' and just about everyone that owned a domain or brand with the word 'stealth' in it was named as a defendant.

Is Famed Trademark Troll Leo Stoller Trying To Stealthily Reclaim Bogus Stealth Trademarks? | Techdirt (http://www.techdirt.com/articles/20100719/02130110270.shtml)

Fortunately it fell through, but it sucks that this stuff happens.

IPD
07-07-2011, 07:47 AM
It shits me to get involved in another apple debate, but if you want to talk lawsuits, your country in fucking vented them! Do we really need to go there?

Here in Australia, lifeguards have apparently patented the term "lifeguard". Beach warfare as Surf Life Saving Australia trademarks the term 'lifeguard' | Courier Mail (http://www.couriermail.com.au/business/caught-off-guard-by-a-name/story-e6freqmx-1226078753987)

It's called life kids. You need to get over it.

Inp - again, you really have a hate for apple yet you wont stop going on and fucking on about the company. Like I said before, did they hurt you as a child or do you really not have better things to do with your time?

Scotty

scooter, why do i get the feeling that if i wanted to castrate steve jobs, all i'd have to do is kick you in the chin?

GTO Assassin
07-07-2011, 10:36 AM
First of all, I'm pretty sure you WANT to castrate Jobsy. There's no if or buts about that. Second of all, go back and quote me where I've stated that Apple is better than a pc. You'll find that the only part where I've said anything close to that was where I was talking about MY profession (in a public sense), Mac's are considered the best option. (video editing using Final Cut)

Scotty

stealthify
07-07-2011, 10:43 AM
Uh oh, here comes the attack on Final Cut Pro X.

:Disdain:



;)

BigTyla
07-07-2011, 11:27 AM
Tyler, you don't need to get so fussy. I'd love to discuss this with you if you'd hear me out, even if you don't agree.

I can tell you which one doesn't belong: App Store. Want to know why? Because that is a trademark infringement, not a patent infringement.

And on that note, do you want to hear another ridiculous trademark? The word 'face' in websites. And guess who owns it and has sued others for using it? Facebook. Now that's a wild one.

While the term 'app' and 'store' and very generic and commonplace words, 'App Store' together, while being the first to trademark it and make it a household name, is a different story. And on that note, even words like 'Apple' and 'Amazon' are fairly generic terms as well - but they have essentially become brands. Brands will association, brands that each company has spent millions to market and to keep associated with their company.

Before mid-2008, did you ever refer to anything as "The App Store"? I doubt you did. Hardly anyone did:

Google Trends: app store (http://www.google.com/trends?q=app+store)

Apple, while they didn't invent 'apps' or 'stores', was the first to really publicize and push the term 'App Store' into households and have it catch. Before long, when I said to someone: "you can find that in the App Store", they automatically knew I was talking about the store belonging to Apple.

And THAT is why Apple is defending it. They're not saying Amazon can't have their own store to sell applications, and even put a slogan under it saying that they specialize in selling apps, but that they essentially want to create their own sub-brand called the 'App Store' (or rather, 'Appstore') as well. And that might lead to confusion, and leeches off the marketing that Apple has already done to push the 'App Store' trademark.

In the end, Apple might lose this battle. They might have gone too far and mainstreamed a term that was too general. I suppose we'll see.

Basically your argument means that Microsoft should sue any company that sells windows for homes and references itself as the Windows Store.

See how easy it is to refute your argument? I just did it in one sentence.

Admit it, attempting to trademark "App store" is just as ludicrous.

stealthify
07-07-2011, 12:25 PM
Basically your argument means that Microsoft should sue any company that sells windows for homes and references itself as the Windows Store.
No, because window makers (as in the physical piece of glass that you put in your house or cars) are not in the same business as, nor is it a competitor of, Microsoft. This is why Apple can't go after Apple Apartments (http://www.rentmoney.com/State/TX/Metro/Dallas/City/Irving/Property/Apple/ApartmentForRent.aspx) and Amazon can't go after Amazon Industries (http://www.amazons-inc.com/).

If I released a software product named 'Office Word Processor', you best believe Microsoft would hunt me down. They own the trademarks for both 'Office' and 'Word', and my product would be leeching off their name and marketing to boost my own. We'd be in the same market, and I would be a competitor... and I'd be sued up the wazoo.

See how this works now?


Admit it, attempting to trademark "App store" is just as ludicrous.
Alright, alright. I will admit that it's ludicrous now, but (always a but) it wasn't in mid-2008 when Apple was actually granted the trademark. ;)

You must admit - they scored big time, predicting that the word 'app' would be popping out of the mouths of everyone from age 5 to 95 within the next three years. Amazon and, in case you didn't know, Microsoft (http://blogs.wsj.com/digits/2011/01/12/should-apple-get-to-trademark-app-store-microsoft-says-no/), see's this now. And that is why both of them are working very hard to get that trademark nullified.

IPD
07-07-2011, 12:51 PM
then explain why world wildlife foundation successfully sued world wresting federation for trademark? i mean, after all, these aren't even remotely in the same market.

(and for the record, the term "app" was used well over a decade ago. so a store to buy "apps" from is hardly a trademark-able name).

stealthify
07-07-2011, 01:16 PM
From what I understand, that actually had to do with the World Wide Fund for Nature (also trademarked WWF), and that the trademark dispute actually took place in Europe courts as opposed to U.S. ones. I'm not sure what they do differently over there. Plus they had some sort of odd agreement back in 1994, and I believe someone violated the terms:

Agreement - WWF-World Wide Fund for Nature and Titan Sports Inc.(Jan 19, 1994... (http://contracts.corporate.findlaw.com/operations/ip/1755.html)

Theoretically they should have been able to co-exist without stepping on eachothers toes. Others claim that the World Wide Fund went back on their word and tried to do a shakedown on the wrestling group to get some extra money out of them:

http://www.capitalresearch.org/pubs/pdf/x3773144899.pdf

In the end, the World Wrestling Federation changed their name to avoid the hassle. But this should have never happened to begin with. Especially not between two U.S. based companies (which this particular case wasn't).

Back on track though, about the app thing. I never said the term 'app' wasn't around long before Apple grabbed ahold of it and made it as mainstream as can be, you and I both know that. Apple knows that. We all know that. But it was one of those border-line slang terms and I bet that is exactly why they were granted the trademark before EVERYONE started calling their applications 'apps'. If they tried to register a trademark for 'Program Store' instead, I'm pretty sure they would have been denied.

BigTyla
07-07-2011, 01:35 PM
You must admit - they scored big time, predicting that the word 'app' would be popping out of the mouths of everyone from age 5 to 95 within the next three years. Amazon and, in case you didn't know, Microsoft (http://blogs.wsj.com/digits/2011/01/12/should-apple-get-to-trademark-app-store-microsoft-says-no/), see's this now. And that is why both of them are working very hard to get that trademark nullified.

Surely the marketing of the term required some deal of foresight, but the fact that the word "app" is used so widely in the software industry means they should have also had the foresight to know that trademark would never fly.

stealthify
07-07-2011, 01:38 PM
By 'used so widely in the software industry', you can see the comparisons for yourself:

Google Trends: program, application, app (http://www.google.com/trends?q=program%2C+application%2C+app&ctab=0&geo=all&date=all&sort=0)

BigTyla
07-07-2011, 06:14 PM
By 'used so widely in the software industry', you can see the comparisons for yourself:

Google Trends: program, application, app (http://www.google.com/trends?q=program%2C+application%2C+app&ctab=0&geo=all&date=all&sort=0)

The fact that you resort to Google Trends to make a point shows me that you don't have a thorough understanding of the issue. Allow me to inject some insight.

"Application" is a term used to describe an interface used to perform a certain task. "App" has been used as shorthand for "application" throughout the software industry even before the days of FORTRAN. To put this in perspective for you, that is over half a century ago. So for over 50 years, software engineers have used the term "app" in discussion as well as official documentation of their applications. Use of the term became even more widespread with the advent of operating systems like Windows, which introduced apps like Microsoft Word, Internet Explorer, etc. These have historically been referred to as "apps" in shorthand.

Now, Apple decides to come out with an "App Store" which contains mobile applications for their customers. This has increased the popularity of the term beyond just the software world within the past couple of years, which explains the jump in searches for the term "app." You contend that this is justification for Apple's attempt at trademarking the term. That is silly. Just because Apple has made the term more popular does not mean they own exclusive rights to it. The term is just as standard now as it was before Apple even existed. Hence, your argument is invalid.

By the way, Google Trends is not a measurement tool for an industry standard. You should know better.

NickS VR4
07-07-2011, 06:52 PM
Google Trends: Droid (http://www.google.com/trends?q=Droid&ctab=0&geo=all&date=all&sort=0)

Motorola must own the term "Droid", it spiked after the Motorola Droid came out.

GTO Assassin
07-07-2011, 10:01 PM
then explain why world wildlife foundation successfully sued world wresting federation for trademark? i mean, after all, these aren't even remotely in the same market.

(and for the record, the term "app" was used well over a decade ago. so a store to buy "apps" from is hardly a trademark-able name).

As per usual, you can't back up your words. No shocker there.

You guys whinge and bitch about apple fanbois and their passion for apple pc's/notebooks/ipods etc. Yet here you are whinging and bitching AGAINST apple. You're like them, only worse. Atleast they believe in the product. You guys spend a shitload of your time trying to belittle it. And for what?

Scotty

NickS VR4
07-07-2011, 10:23 PM
As per usual, you can't back up your words. No shocker there.

You guys whinge and bitch about apple fanbois and their passion for apple pc's/notebooks/ipods etc. Yet here you are whinging and bitching AGAINST apple. You're like them, only worse. Atleast they believe in the product. You guys spend a shitload of your time trying to belittle it. And for what?

Scotty

Assuming you aren't talking about me... but to throw in my opinion, I just personally don't like Apple because of their closed business model. Everything about Apple is proprietary. That is why I like PCs, and my OG Droid. I do believe Apple does have its place, which is for end users that are satisfied with a polished product that they buy and don't worry about. They do not expect innovation until they buy a new product from Apple. This is great for people like my mom, that just want to buy and have it work. It isn't for everyone.

I do think the Apple Fanbois are ridiculous though, saying that Apple is better because its Apple. In college the kids that owned Macs were snobs, and the people I know that have iPhones are ignorant. That youtube video posted last year says it all...


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FL7yD-0pqZg

GTO Assassin
07-07-2011, 10:36 PM
It isn't for everyone.

And that is my point. And you are right. Apple fans are much like (but loads worse) than honda fans, they are stupid in some cases, but in others, I believe their passion is warranted. Even if the feel of an apple is what the user likes, you can't call them stupid or uneducated. Most people I know who use pc's dont like how an apple operates because of the OS. That's fine. But to constantly bag apple and their business sense/ethics is just pointless and I really am curious why many here and on other forums are so God damn passionate about hating apple that they feel they have to post about it every single day. There's really only a couple of us here who aren't waging war against apple. We aren't saying they rule supreme, but we are alot more objective than some of you. ;)

Scotty

stealthify
07-08-2011, 01:39 AM
your argument is invalid.

Tyler, I'm going to flip this around. So far in this very thread you have shown that you do not recognize the difference between a patent and a trademark. You have willingly accepted what you were fed that the patents Samsung violated had to do with a 'black rectangle with a touchscreen and buttons.' You refuse to admit that trademarked terms like 'face', 'office' and 'word' are any more ridiculous than the trademark on the combined words of 'App' and 'Store' to create a new trademark called the 'App Store'. Please forgive me if I don't spend any more time holding your hand through this.

IPD
07-08-2011, 08:35 AM
And that is my point. And you are right. Apple fans are much like (but loads worse) than honda fans, they are stupid in some cases, but in others, I believe their passion is warranted. Even if the feel of an apple is what the user likes, you can't call them stupid or uneducated. Most people I know who use pc's dont like how an apple operates because of the OS. That's fine. But to constantly bag apple and their business sense/ethics is just pointless and I really am curious why many here and on other forums are so God damn passionate about hating apple that they feel they have to post about it every single day. There's really only a couple of us here who aren't waging war against apple. We aren't saying they rule supreme, but we are alot more objective than some of you. ;)

Scotty

because, scooter, apple is a black-hole. i've already expressed this sentiment. once you start down the path to the apple-side, forever will it dominate your tech needs; consume you it will, as it has many before you.

i personally have friends/family members who would like to switch to android, but are mired by their previous use of apple. they will likely end up living out the rest of their natural lives with apple products--because freeing themselves from it's iron-grip is a financial disaster (when you consider all the $$$ that's already been paid into the system).

so why am i so outspoken against apple? because buying an apple product is like falling into a pit. no ladder, no rope, no roots, no gently sloping sides. you stay there until apple lowers the basket & tells you to "rub the lotion on its skin, or else it gets the hose again".

friends don't let friends buy apple.

stealthify
07-08-2011, 08:40 AM
Thadd, you are by far the most dramatic person on this board. I just want you to know that.

:)

IPD
07-08-2011, 08:46 AM
do not go gentle into that good night...rage, rage against the dying of the light.

BigTyla
07-08-2011, 01:38 PM
Tyler, I'm going to flip this around. So far in this very thread you have shown that you do not recognize the difference between a patent and a trademark. You have willingly accepted what you were fed that the patents Samsung violated had to do with a 'black rectangle with a touchscreen and buttons.' You refuse to admit that trademarked terms like 'face', 'office' and 'word' are any more ridiculous than the trademark on the combined words of 'App' and 'Store' to create a new trademark called the 'App Store'. Please forgive me if I don't spend any more time holding your hand through this.

I'm far beyond that argument now. You never mentioned trademarking the terms "face, office, and word" so I'm not sure why you are bringing them up now and getting on to me for supposedly thinking that their trademarking is allowable.

Stop straw-manning.

stealthify
07-08-2011, 01:48 PM
You never mentioned trademarking the terms "face, office, and word"


And on that note, do you want to hear another ridiculous trademark? The word 'face' in websites. And guess who owns it and has sued others for using it? Facebook.

If I released a software product named 'Office Word Processor', you best believe Microsoft would hunt me down. They own the trademarks for both 'Office' and 'Word', and my product would be leeching off their name and marketing to boost my own. We'd be in the same market, and I would be a competitor... and I'd be sued up the wazoo.

And I meant to include that Facebook also apparently owns the word 'book' too. Check it out:
Facebook Apparently Owns The Word “Book” – The Review Crew (http://www.thereviewcrew.com/news/facebook-apparently-owns-the-word-book/)

It's a crazy world we live in.

stealthify
07-08-2011, 01:53 PM
And I apologize if I came off rough there, Tyler. I just wasn't aware of how much you knew or didn't know on the subject.

BigTyla
07-08-2011, 02:17 PM
I can't view that site at work, but that supposed trademark is also ridiculous. So is the stupid "stealth" guy.

I'm curious as to how many of these trademarks actually make it through. I've heard of plenty of ridiculous attempts before but I'm not aware of any that actually stuck.

stealthify
07-08-2011, 02:32 PM
More than you'd believe. However, the good news is that most of these trademarks and patents generally only apply within the same field/genre of business (or, in other words, a company or product that could be considered a competitor - for example).

And while these aren't quite as 'prime' as the trademark Apple was awarded, it's worth mentioning that other competitors to the App Store, which were late to the party (2009), were able to successfully trademark these general terms as well:

Palm trademarked their webOS service: App Catalog

BlackBerry trademarked their OS's service: App World