PDA

View Full Version : Disappointed



UTRacerX9
05-18-2011, 05:58 PM
Well, without going into really specific detail like company names and what not, I'll just say what the situation is.

The last three material fabrication jobs that I have wanted to award to an American company, I've been forced to turn over to China. Their pricing for fabrication these days is just so much lower than what we do in the states. The sad part is, their quality is rapidly improving so that (in this example anyway) we can't even fall back on the old "Made in China = Crap" argument, because there is a negligible difference between what they are turning out vs what we do in the states.

This last time happened today. A fabrication company in TX gave us a bid of $84,000. China? $50,000. I really wanted to keep that money in the states (especially my state) but there's no way I can convince my boss to go with that.

I guess with all the recent talks about hitting the debt ceiling and what not is weighing on me, and I wanted to do my part to lower our trade deficit if possible. I went back to them to see if that was truly their best bid they could do, (I even gave them the price of the competing bid!) and they said they couldn't come close and to give it to China.

I don't think I'm going to bother hunting around for US companies anymore after this last episode. :(

AdamVR4
05-18-2011, 06:33 PM
Can you share any details about what was being fabricated?

Did you get any other US quotes? Was the company that bid $84k hungry for work?

EZnTn
05-18-2011, 07:29 PM
I ran into the same thing a few years back.
I ran a fab shop, we manufactured 316L SS structures that fit on paper machines.
My shop was closed by corporate, division was eventually sold to a Canadian firm.
They contracted to China for 50% of what it would cost for fabrication in the States or Canada.
I spent 5 weeks in China insuring they did it right.
As much as I enjoyed my time in China, putting the work over there put a sour taste in my mouth.
When clients here realize how important it is to keep the work at home, they'll be willing to pay the additional amount.
If they don't, it will be their shop closing out to a cheaper off shore competitor next.

DocWalt
05-18-2011, 09:28 PM
We've been using a fabshop in the US... If they don't up the quality of their work we're going to have to find someone else. I doubt it'd be cheaper for us to buy overseas, but geez.

Alex3000gt
05-18-2011, 11:33 PM
Do not be fooled, China is serious about growth. They do not care who or what they crush along the way.

You want to stay on top? Get on your game and take pride in your work.

UTRacerX9
05-19-2011, 01:20 AM
Adam,

When I first joined the company last year, a situation like this happened almost immediately, and I was given the name of the chinese company we'd worked with in the past, as well as a few names of companies here in the states that weren't able to price match in the past. After sending an email or two, I decided to go with the chinese company we'd already done business with before, as I really didn't have a ton of time to make a decision.

The products in this case are specialized metal racks/shelves/end caps designed to hold a variety of things. Technically, it really isn't my area at all to have to deal with fabrication costs, I'm in sales. But since the fabrication costs are part of our overall bid, it falls to the sales guys to get it done for the cheapest possible. If you don't have the cheapest total price, well, we don't get the business.

I had done some internet research trying to find an American company to compete this time around, and got in touch with a company here in TX. After giving them the specs, they came back with the cheapest bid among the American companies that I sent emails to. I don't think they are hurting for business, because they didn't even try to come back and counter with another price. The guy I spoke with also was pretty blunt when he told me to give the business to China, as if he'd had that conversation many, many times.

I dunno, if this happens again I will look into more companies, but I have a feeling no American company is going to be able to give me a bid that will be competitive. At this point, I think my next best option is to find another country, any country, besides China for this stuff.

AgentOblivious
05-19-2011, 01:24 AM
Printing off Yuan to make your currency seem cheaper doesn't hurt either...

DuTTch
05-19-2011, 02:23 AM
yeah no unions in China.

j2k4
05-19-2011, 09:50 AM
I literally live in a community made basically of fab shops - two villages, probably 3K population...there were probably 25 shops locally doing welding/bending/machine/hydraulics/powder-paint for outside manufacturers and a couple of locals - Pettibone and Terex.

Terex pulled out, Pettibone is hanging on by it's fingernails.

There are less than ten shops left, and they're scratching for just about anything they can get.

I oughta see if they can make some shelving/end-caps for Todd.

HilbillyHomeboy
05-19-2011, 11:16 AM
Do not be fooled, China is serious about growth. They do not care who or what they crush along the way.

You want to stay on top? Get on your game and take pride in your work.

Absolutely agreed on the first part, it won't be long (at this pace) and they will eclipse the US.

Pride isn't closing any gaps in wages paid, nor does it change the rate of electricity paid. Neither of which is remotely comparable between the US and China. Steel trades on the UK stock market cheaper than we can manufacture.


Adam,

When I first joined the company last year, a situation like this happened almost immediately, and I was given the name of the chinese company we'd worked with in the past, as well as a few names of companies here in the states that weren't able to price match in the past. After sending an email or two, I decided to go with the chinese company we'd already done business with before, as I really didn't have a ton of time to make a decision.

The products in this case are specialized metal racks/shelves/end caps designed to hold a variety of things. Technically, it really isn't my area at all to have to deal with fabrication costs, I'm in sales. But since the fabrication costs are part of our overall bid, it falls to the sales guys to get it done for the cheapest possible. If you don't have the cheapest total price, well, we don't get the business.

I had done some internet research trying to find an American company to compete this time around, and got in touch with a company here in TX. After giving them the specs, they came back with the cheapest bid among the American companies that I sent emails to. I don't think they are hurting for business, because they didn't even try to come back and counter with another price. The guy I spoke with also was pretty blunt when he told me to give the business to China, as if he'd had that conversation many, many times.

I dunno, if this happens again I will look into more companies, but I have a feeling no American company is going to be able to give me a bid that will be competitive. At this point, I think my next best option is to find another country, any country, besides China for this stuff.

That's not surprising to me. I deal with similar conversations every single day. Will you do this complex report for chicken scratch? No, I will not. Well we have a guy who will. That's great, call him? The difference is in my field, you do get what you pay for most of the time and there's no outsourcing possible other than some unreliable automated models.

It was cool of you to call them back and give them notice of how much under bid they were. Always good info to have, whether you can do anything about getting closer to the number or not. :)

Jeremy

UTRacerX9
05-19-2011, 12:05 PM
Thanks Jeremy. This stuff comes up once or twice a year, hopefully I'll have better luck next time.

IPD
05-21-2011, 12:57 AM
the only true resolution of the matter will come once the world has achieved relative "parity"; and it no longer costs less to buy from overseas as it does domestically. unfortunately, the USA has a long, long way to fall before that day comes.

the key concern i have with overseas manufacturing has to do with national security. we need to have enough raw-materials processing plants; manufacturing plants; and fabrication shops to handle the workload associated with supporting our military in a time of crisis. if every silicone chip we need for defense purposes is sourced from china...and we end up on the other side of a conflict with china....well...it will get ugly fast. this is probably why we'll eventually have to INCREASE defense spending via subsidies for domestic production--just as a safeguard; similar to why we have farm subsidies.

i wish the UN would crack-down on china's artifically devalued currency already.

AgentOblivious
05-21-2011, 04:18 AM
Hey UTracerX9, what do you think of this?

BCG - Press Release - Made in the USA, Again: Manufacturing Is Expected to Return to America as China (http://www.bcg.com/media/PressReleaseDetails.aspx?id=tcm:12-75973)

UTRacerX9
05-21-2011, 11:18 AM
That article makes US manufacturing sound a lot more rosy than it is. They even say that wages in China are 30% less (which is what they are now, or more) and after you factor in cost to ship things and such, the difference is negligible.

Well, that simply isn't correct. Putting goods on a container ship for example, is relatively cheap compared to the total number of units you can fit on one. (Average weight of a container is assumed to be 40,000 lbs - that's a lot of product for just about anything.) If a company can spend just one cent less per unit, they typically do it. I'd love to see more jobs and work staying here, but I don't think we're going to see it happen in 2015. Not even close.

BadHabit
05-21-2011, 08:09 PM
We have been fending off China for a few years now.I do not know how they do it but they were making some parts for what it cost us in raw material never mind the labor cost.I think they did that just to get in the door.The work we got to keep was only because of our commitment to a quality part and customer service.We had to do a lot of shifting to keep the costs down.Makes you take a good hard look at the way you operate a business and ways to cut down on waste.

AgentOblivious
05-21-2011, 11:04 PM
We have been fending off China for a few years now.I do not know how they do it but they were making some parts for what it cost us in raw material never mind the labor cost.I think they did that just to get in the door.The work we got to keep was only because of our commitment to a quality part and customer service.We had to do a lot of shifting to keep the costs down.Makes you take a good hard look at the way you operate a business and ways to cut down on waste.

The problem is a lot of work isn't being streamlined, but rather wages cuts are being used to cover it up. Also, for China, this pretty much explains it:


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=S-9iY1OgbDE&feature=player_embedded

marshallh
05-22-2011, 09:09 PM
I went with a chinese fab a couple months ago for some circuit board.

The one on top of the stack was perfect. Going down the stack I found boards that developed shorts under heat. I ended up having to transplant the entire board components from two of these bad PCBs (166 surface mount parts) onto some other ones. Not my fault, the boards still had shorts after I pulled the parts off. This is with 100% e-testing.


Watch your asses. I will be going with a different fab shop (in china). I have no choice because the assembly costs in America are almost 10 times higher and no shop over here will do low volume runs.