View Full Version : Progression of Collar Bone fracture
vr4chick
05-09-2011, 04:53 PM
Looks like the doctors messed up on me :Doh:
Xray 4 hours after the accident
http://i26.photobucket.com/albums/c117/lindahaas/4-8.jpg
Xray today
http://i26.photobucket.com/albums/c117/lindahaas/5-9.jpg
The doctor basically in more words told me to deal with it. :shake2:
FeaRpb
05-09-2011, 05:00 PM
Oh my god, that looks painful!
Deal with it.... =P
vr4chick
05-09-2011, 05:10 PM
WTF!!!!! He tried saying he's never seen anything like this :lol: Guess he's never messed up on a patient before :Doh:
FeaRpb
05-09-2011, 06:39 PM
How does that happen? Also, how did that feel? I can only imagine weird.
vr4chick
05-09-2011, 07:36 PM
How does that happen? Also, how did that feel? I can only imagine weird.
It happened because the doctor decided to NOT brace my fracture. It hurts like hell and reduces my range of motion. Fractured Collarbones are the worst.
93STLTH
05-09-2011, 07:52 PM
When you sue him for malpractice, tell him to "deal with it".
vr4chick
05-09-2011, 07:57 PM
When you sue him for malpractice, tell him to "deal with it".
:lol:
seriously though...why not just solve the problem
sketch
05-09-2011, 11:02 PM
christ, that looks bad. i fractured mine a few years back - doctors told me i was borderline for surgery, basically told me to deal with it, too. on my 6 or 8 week checkup (not sure when exactly, but in that range) they took x-rays and were basically like "yeah...you should have had the surgery. oops." i lost two inches on my wingspan.
looks similar to my break:
http://i.imgur.com/BWP7V.png
http://i.imgur.com/CE0iP.png
http://i.imgur.com/raRJg.png
how'd you break yours?
vr4chick
05-09-2011, 11:18 PM
Mine broke in a car accident. Yours looks better than mine...I wish I had yours. I'm going back in a month for more xrays
enollava
05-09-2011, 11:29 PM
Just finished a semester of Human Osteology, and I saw many broken Clavicle segments. Of course all of them were ancient. Not sure why a doctor wouldn't decide to fix something like that. The bone is kinda important of you. It is the first bone to start to ossify, and the last to finish. So if you are below 30, that bone possibly isn't done fusing. If the bone can be set and immobilized, then surgery may not be needed, but obviously in both your cases, that wasn't possible. I'd have insisted on going under the knife for a break like that. Any chance you got any good pictures of you that aren't X-rays? I'd love to see the break and how the muscles in the neck likely pulled the section of it that is medial upwards.
sketch
05-10-2011, 12:10 AM
Mine broke in a car accident. Yours looks better than mine...I wish I had yours. I'm going back in a month for more xrays
i don't wish the break on either of us - out of my 14 breaks this was absolutely the most painful. by a long shot. yours looks like it's separated further - how are you staying immobile? i ended up sitting in a lazy boy recliner with my arm propped up for 2 weeks straight watching old episodes of house (i had JUST started marathoning the show for the second time), surviving vicodin and perks.
how much time passed between those xrays? you should insist on having the surgery. my left arm hangs directly on my body now if i let both arms hang down "naturally." after about 15-20 minutes of driving, my left pit smells. seriously. i have to prop it up on the door to get it some air.
vr4chick
05-10-2011, 08:46 AM
Just finished a semester of Human Osteology, and I saw many broken Clavicle segments. Of course all of them were ancient. Not sure why a doctor wouldn't decide to fix something like that. The bone is kinda important of you. It is the first bone to start to ossify, and the last to finish. So if you are below 30, that bone possibly isn't done fusing. If the bone can be set and immobilized, then surgery may not be needed, but obviously in both your cases, that wasn't possible. I'd have insisted on going under the knife for a break like that. Any chance you got any good pictures of you that aren't X-rays? I'd love to see the break and how the muscles in the neck likely pulled the section of it that is medial upwards.
I will take a pic today
vr4chick
05-10-2011, 08:55 AM
i don't wish the break on either of us - out of my 14 breaks this was absolutely the most painful. by a long shot. yours looks like it's separated further - how are you staying immobile? i ended up sitting in a lazy boy recliner with my arm propped up for 2 weeks straight watching old episodes of house (i had JUST started marathoning the show for the second time), surviving vicodin and perks.
how much time passed between those xrays? you should insist on having the surgery. my left arm hangs directly on my body now if i let both arms hang down "naturally." after about 15-20 minutes of driving, my left pit smells. seriously. i have to prop it up on the door to get it some air.
there was 31 days between the xrays. I'm going to call an independent person and ask about my collar bone. it hurts.
Dbeltran24
05-10-2011, 02:50 PM
Ask for the "Figure 8" brace. When I broke my collar bone, I was put in a sling and told to deal with it. Was in major pain for 2-4 weeks. Then I visited another doctor who gave me a "figure 8" brace, and suddenly no more pain. Well almost no more pain. I even had more mobility again. If you haven't seen one of those braces, just picture a "8" sideways, where the cross section is on your back. That type of brace makes it very difficult to move your shoulder the wrong way.
Since I wasn't placed in that type of brace right away, my collar bone healed incorrectly. Rather than line up right at the crack, the two pieces of bone healed one on top of the other. I have a shorter left shoulder now as a result. I didn't find this out until the second doctor visit. By that point the bone had already fused together and the only way to correct it would be to re-brake the bone. I wasn't about to go through that again.
Lets put it this way, after recieving the brace I went from not being able to do very much, to being able to play ping pong.
sketch
05-10-2011, 03:38 PM
Since I wasn't placed in that type of brace right away, my collar bone healed incorrectly. Rather than line up right at the crack, the two pieces of bone healed one on top of the other. I have a shorter left shoulder now as a result.
ditto on that. hence my massive wingspan going from 6' to 5'10" (I'm only 5'5")
thor'svr4
05-10-2011, 04:45 PM
if you don't get surgery the figure 8 brace is the way to go. luckily for me (or maybe unluckily?) i ended up just getting 8 screws, a plate and a massive scar. i don't think i lost any wingspan but my right shoulder doesn't really sit where it used to. its noticeably lower and more foreword than the left shoulder.
my left arm hangs directly on my body now if i let both arms hang down "naturally." after about 15-20 minutes of driving, my left pit smells. seriously. i have to prop it up on the door to get it some air.
at least im not the only one lol. i always use the 'ridge' under the coolant gauge to rest my right hand on and let the ac flow down my shirt sleeve to my pit.
good luck with a speedy recovery!
FeaRpb
05-10-2011, 05:21 PM
My brother had the figure 8 brace. I never heard a complaint from him.
Ninja Performance
05-10-2011, 05:26 PM
Take it from someone living with a collar bone fracture since 14 yrs old (football)...Get it fixed. You will still be in pain probably forever (again, trust me on this) but as it stands it's going to be debilitating. OUCH. WTF? They need to fix it ASAP.
-Chris
vr4chick
05-10-2011, 06:51 PM
Take it from someone living with a collar bone fracture since 14 yrs old (football)...Get it fixed. You will still be in pain probably forever (again, trust me on this) but as it stands it's going to be debilitating. OUCH. WTF? They need to fix it ASAP.
-Chris
I have a lawyer working on helping me obtain the surgery. My problem is, the bone is sharp and high enough to turn into a compound fracture later on. Once you have a compound fracture you are talking about hours more worth of surgery. He's also obtaining my 2 ankle and my 2 vertebrae xrays.
sketch
05-10-2011, 08:01 PM
christ. i hope you heal up well & soon.
GTOJOE
05-10-2011, 08:08 PM
I broke my collar bone in a bmx accident when I was 14-15 and I was just told to put it in a sling for a few weeks. Healed up fine but have a small bump in the bone and would have lost a small amount of wingspan. Have had no pain or issues ever since. However mine was not as bad as yours.
Dark-Hawk
05-11-2011, 12:24 AM
Ask for the "Figure 8" brace. When I broke my collar bone, I was put in a sling and told to deal with it. Was in major pain for 2-4 weeks. Then I visited another doctor who gave me a "figure 8" brace, and suddenly no more pain. Well almost no more pain. I even had more mobility again. If you haven't seen one of those braces, just picture a "8" sideways, where the cross section is on your back. That type of brace makes it very difficult to move your shoulder the wrong way.
Since I wasn't placed in that type of brace right away, my collar bone healed incorrectly. Rather than line up right at the crack, the two pieces of bone healed one on top of the other. I have a shorter left shoulder now as a result. I didn't find this out until the second doctor visit. By that point the bone had already fused together and the only way to correct it would be to re-brake the bone. I wasn't about to go through that again.
Lets put it this way, after recieving the brace I went from not being able to do very much, to being able to play ping pong.
Based upon that XRay she needs to have surgery. It's a displaced fracture right now and due to the degree of displacement it certainly needs surgical fixation in my opinion. A "compound" fracture or an "open fracture" you were already at slight risk for and honestly you're at risk for, any instance you have a fracture; it just depends on the modality of the break. With that said, I'd find a good shoulder specialist and take it from there. A doctor giving you a bad diagnosis is sometimes better than a doctor giving you a bad surgical outcome. I've seen some absolute MESSES in the OR before.
The first XRay also wasn't that good, they should have taken another as it ALMOST (read: almost) appears that the fracture wasn't all the way through the bone which could mean that a brace would be good enough.
As far as jumping to a lawsuit though? I wouldn't. You could have gotten a second opinion, he gave you a diagnosis based upon his medical opinion, he didn't operate on you.
vr4chick
05-11-2011, 10:03 AM
Based upon that XRay she needs to have surgery. It's a displaced fracture right now and due to the degree of displacement it certainly needs surgical fixation in my opinion. A "compound" fracture or an "open fracture" you were already at slight risk for and honestly you're at risk for, any instance you have a fracture; it just depends on the modality of the break. With that said, I'd find a good shoulder specialist and take it from there. A doctor giving you a bad diagnosis is sometimes better than a doctor giving you a bad surgical outcome. I've seen some absolute MESSES in the OR before.
The first XRay also wasn't that good, they should have taken another as it ALMOST (read: almost) appears that the fracture wasn't all the way through the bone which could mean that a brace would be good enough.
As far as jumping to a lawsuit though? I wouldn't. You could have gotten a second opinion, he gave you a diagnosis based upon his medical opinion, he didn't operate on you.
The only way my clavicle will get fixed is by the doctor doing it. I'm not sure if i can find another doctor that will go against this doctors reading. There are other reason as to why we are going after this doctor. The doctor refuses to let us see the xrays and right now I think I have a problem with my right ankle. I complained about the pain in the right ankle and the doctors refused to xray it for 5 days.
When they finally did xray my right ankle they found a fracture in the ankle. The doctor came up to me and asked if I had ever broken my ankle and I said no...Shes like, hmmmm its healing up weird. So I am a little worried about how the ankle looks
vr4chick
05-11-2011, 10:03 AM
and the doctor told me to not brace my clavice because it would cause more damage.
DocWalt
05-11-2011, 10:40 AM
Sounds like you need a new doctor, now. I hope it heals up well. :)
Dark-Hawk
05-11-2011, 11:12 AM
The only way my clavicle will get fixed is by the doctor doing it. I'm not sure if i can find another doctor that will go against this doctors reading. There are other reason as to why we are going after this doctor. The doctor refuses to let us see the xrays and right now I think I have a problem with my right ankle. I complained about the pain in the right ankle and the doctors refused to xray it for 5 days.
When they finally did xray my right ankle they found a fracture in the ankle. The doctor came up to me and asked if I had ever broken my ankle and I said no...Shes like, hmmmm its healing up weird. So I am a little worried about how the ankle looks
Doctors give follow up diagnoses all the time, it's par for the course in the field. I'm unsure why you're worried about other doctors NOT doing such - that makes zero sense.
As for a doctor not releasing your XRays, you have every right to your own medical documents, records, etc.
If a doctor is doing BOTH ankles, shoulders, etc, etc... Find a specialist. Orthopedics is far too specific of a field to rely on someone who is merely a general orthopedist. It's literally asking someone to be a specialist in the entire body.
Find another doctor.
vr4chick
05-11-2011, 11:23 AM
Doctors give follow up diagnoses all the time, it's par for the course in the field. I'm unsure why you're worried about other doctors NOT doing such - that makes zero sense.
As for a doctor not releasing your XRays, you have every right to your own medical documents, records, etc.
If a doctor is doing BOTH ankles, shoulders, etc, etc... Find a specialist. Orthopedics is far too specific of a field to rely on someone who is merely a general orthopedist. It's literally asking someone to be a specialist in the entire body.
Find another doctor.
My doctor is an Orthopedic Surgeon who only deals in Traumatology. The hospital has already filed the SS Disability paperwork, they filed it the first day I was in the hospital.
GTO Assassin
05-11-2011, 10:23 PM
Thankfully I've never had a broken collarbone and without stating the obvious, they look painfull as all hell! :scared: But I did let my hip go and not care as much as I should have when I was 21. Now it's been replaced and it's not what it should be. So definitely push this one and get it sorted now.
Scotty
Dark-Hawk
05-11-2011, 11:49 PM
My doctor is an Orthopedic Surgeon who only deals in Traumatology. The hospital has already filed the SS Disability paperwork, they filed it the first day I was in the hospital.
You're missing my point. Specializing in "Traumatology" is still being a general orthopedist. You need a shoulder specialist. Some days that guy deals with fractured ankles, some days he deals with fractured collar bones. They are VERY different.
Ninja Performance
05-12-2011, 08:44 AM
you need to kick him in the NUTZ.
-Chris
vr4chick
05-12-2011, 09:28 AM
Thankfully I've never had a broken collarbone and without stating the obvious, they look painfull as all hell! :scared: But I did let my hip go and not care as much as I should have when I was 21. Now it's been replaced and it's not what it should be. So definitely push this one and get it sorted now.
Scotty
Ouch!
vr4chick
05-12-2011, 09:29 AM
You're missing my point. Specializing in "Traumatology" is still being a general orthopedist. You need a shoulder specialist. Some days that guy deals with fractured ankles, some days he deals with fractured collar bones. They are VERY different.
Ah! what type of medicine? Is it still an Ortho surgeon?
vr4chick
05-12-2011, 09:29 AM
you need to kick him in the NUTZ.
-Chris
I agree. Doctors still suck. Especially when you are hospitalized. I like their 1 minute visits. Thanks for caring, doc.
Dark-Hawk
05-12-2011, 05:40 PM
Ah! what type of medicine? Is it still an Ortho surgeon?
Yes, find an orthopedic surgeon who specializes in shoulders.
I agree. Doctors still suck. Especially when you are hospitalized. I like their 1 minute visits. Thanks for caring, doc.
I've been on both sides of the bed, there is a LOT going on and you're not the only patient. Doctors have to spread their time around multiple patients, some with more serious ailments than others. Some doctors just also don't have much bedside manner, it all depends.
vr4chick
06-17-2011, 08:21 AM
Doctor is agreeing to do surgery. I have to go in next month. If he doesn't see any healing then he will schedule surgery:Bow:
vr4chick
06-17-2011, 08:29 AM
Sean's going to the doctors for his shoulder today....He has limited range of motion in his arm
HilbillyHomeboy
06-18-2011, 02:34 PM
Hope everything continues to get better for you two. :)
Jeremy
vr4chick
06-18-2011, 03:15 PM
Hope everything continues to get better for you two. :)
Jeremy
Thanks Jeremy. Sean has to have a MRI on his shoulder on Monday. The doctors going to make a determination then if he needs surgery. I guess part of the scapula became displaced and they want to see if its affecting his range of motion.
Dark-Hawk
06-28-2011, 07:07 PM
Doctor is agreeing to do surgery. I have to go in next month. If he doesn't see any healing then he will schedule surgery:Bow:
Still just the general ortho/"sports medicine" doctor? If so, I still recommend not having him do the surgery. I've seen the aftermath of these general ortho's and it's not pretty. A second surgery to correct another surgeons screw up is never fun.
Thanks Jeremy. Sean has to have a MRI on his shoulder on Monday. The doctors going to make a determination then if he needs surgery. I guess part of the scapula became displaced and they want to see if its affecting his range of motion.
I'd say that's likely.
vr4chick
06-28-2011, 07:13 PM
Still just the general ortho/"sports medicine" doctor? If so, I still recommend not having him do the surgery. I've seen the aftermath of these general ortho's and it's not pretty. A second surgery to correct another surgeons screw up is never fun.
I'd say that's likely.
He's actually a Trauma Orthopedic Surgeon. He only deals with Orthopedic Trauma patients.
JasonY
06-28-2011, 07:18 PM
You still arent listening. When i had my knee reassembled the Dr. that did it only did knee's. Nothing else.
You need a shoulder specialist, and nothing short of that.
Jason
vr4chick
06-28-2011, 07:36 PM
You still arent listening. When i had my knee reassembled the Dr. that did it only did knee's. Nothing else.
You need a shoulder specialist, and nothing short of that.
Jason
I don't think I will be able to get another one. Its not like I fell and broke my clavicle. I've inquired about getting another doctor, I can't find one to take me. I would have to attempt to see one in another part of the state.
FWIW, Sean has tried to get other doctors as well, they won't accept him if it deals with his accident injuries.
Dark-Hawk
06-28-2011, 09:37 PM
You still arent listening. When i had my knee reassembled the Dr. that did it only did knee's. Nothing else.
You need a shoulder specialist, and nothing short of that.
Jason
Exactly.
I don't think I will be able to get another one. Its not like I fell and broke my clavicle. I've inquired about getting another doctor, I can't find one to take me. I would have to attempt to see one in another part of the state.
FWIW, Sean has tried to get other doctors as well, they won't accept him if it deals with his accident injuries.
Find a better doctor. There's no reason for any specialists to turn you down. As for the doctor being a "trauma orthopedist" that doesn't mean he's fantastic with shoulders. Here's a good analogy for you. Would you rather take your car to get tuned by the guy at the quick lube place that says he's tuned his buddies VR4 before or would you rather take it to Ray Pampena?
Powered by vBulletin® Version 4.2.3 Copyright © 2026 vBulletin Solutions, Inc. All rights reserved.