PDA

View Full Version : Bad td04 rebuild kit = blown turbo. Need some legal advice



Toni
04-03-2011, 08:01 PM
So halfway on my way home from my dyno session I noticed power levels were low uphills and my rear turbo I swear was hooting more and more. Checked the shaft play on the turbo and there was a ton of side to side. UGH. Front however, was money.

Both were rebuilt by me. I used two rebuild kits from a supplier on ebay and had them balanced properly. I've rebuilt many turbos and have never had a problem from bad assembly.

Tore into the turbo today and found the problem. The compressor journal bearing had a ton of play. Something was not right. I checked the other bearing and it was fine. Very weird. I was expecting that both would be worn. Odd thing is the inside of the bearing was perfect. The only wear that occurred is my compressor wheel and housing. I also noticed the thrust bearing was cracked, I'm guessing from the excess wobble that was happening.

I pulled the front just to be safe and it is 100% clean, no wear no issues.

The only thing I can think of is that the kit had the wrong sized bearing in it. I'm pissed. Mostly I'm pissed that I didn't see it when I assembled. I put on like dyno 14 runs on the turbos and it wasn't until the highway that I noticed it. I'm guessing the high oil pressure kept it steady. I went through about a gas tank of miles.

Any thoughts or advice? Is there anyway I can confirm this bearing was wrong to start?

http://primaryboost.com/store/rt/badtd04kit/IMG_0760.JPG

http://primaryboost.com/store/rt/badtd04kit/IMG_0765.JPG

http://primaryboost.com/store/rt/badtd04kit/IMG_0766.JPG

http://primaryboost.com/store/rt/badtd04kit/IMG_0768.JPG

http://primaryboost.com/store/rt/badtd04kit/IMG_0769.JPG

http://primaryboost.com/store/rt/badtd04kit/IMG_0771.JPG

J_Parker
04-03-2011, 08:42 PM
If you've had them balanced and can prove it with pictures I'm certain that you could get a replacement kit, providing that you can bring it up to the right people.

J. Fast
04-03-2011, 11:59 PM
Damn that's a toughy. Was this straight up from a mitsu rebuild kit? Where did you get it from?

RealMcCoy
04-04-2011, 02:13 AM
If it was that way from the beginning, It would have had significant shaft play that I would think would have been noticed regardless of whether you actually checked the clearances prior to assembly.

Even if it was the wrong part, you unfortunatly were the one that installed it... I don't see this any different than installing the wrong size bearings in a motor. It would be pretty hard to blame that on the parts store that sold you the wrong size...

Toni
04-04-2011, 10:20 AM
If it was that way from the beginning, It would have had significant shaft play that I would think would have been noticed regardless of whether you actually checked the clearances prior to assembly.

Even if it was the wrong part, you unfortunatly were the one that installed it... I don't see this any different than installing the wrong size bearings in a motor. It would be pretty hard to blame that on the parts store that sold you the wrong size...

You know you are probably right. I'm cooled off a bit now and it's hard for me to really prove anything here. Ugh oh well. I guess the cost is really minuscule compared to the amount I've spent and should most likely just move on. It would be nice to be able to prove it wasn't my fault, maybe not for legal issues but for my own piece of mind.

UTRacerX9
04-04-2011, 10:26 AM
Well... while I don't think you can do anything against the parts company, if you had the turbos balanced by a shop... How the hell were they able to balance the assembly with the wrong parts? I'd say if anything, during their part, they should have easily noticed that you had the wrong parts in it.

Toni
04-04-2011, 10:52 AM
Well... while I don't think you can do anything against the parts company, if you had the turbos balanced by a shop... How the hell were they able to balance the assembly with the wrong parts? I'd say if anything, during their part, they should have easily noticed that you had the wrong parts in it.

Well the journal bearings aren't part of the balancing. Although you do make an interesting point here, how I do know the balance was done correctly? When I assemble I can make sure I line up their marks, but their marks could have been off. People make mistakes (I know I'm not perfect). It just irkes me because my car is so close to being reliable and putting down good power.

ViperZ
04-04-2011, 04:53 PM
Don't ever buy ebay kits again, they are pure crap. I've had my experience with ebay parts and it always ends in disaster. Gpop Shop makes great rebuild kits that you can trust

Amphiron
04-04-2011, 05:54 PM
Don't ever trust anything from eBay thats "new". Take it from someone thats learned the hard way. Most likely you did everything right and you got some half assed parts that weren't even close to in tolerance. You got it right in the title "Bad TDO4 Kit"

Toni
06-02-2011, 12:43 PM
Well I just wanted to follow up on this one. I rebuilt that rear and 2500+ boosted miles later and they are both solid. Zero shaft play. Seems good to go now!