PDA

View Full Version : Flash tuning results on a stock 99 VR4



Greg E
03-08-2011, 10:55 PM
Mitsu could have done a MUCH better job with tuning the 3/S out of the box. You would be amazed the HP potential these cars are limited to from the ECU. Thanks to the combined efforts of Ceddy and Gatecrasher in disassembling the stock 99 VR4 ROM this potential can finally be unlocked.

After months of patiently waiting for the snow to melt/salt to be washed away, i was finally able to get out tonight with the 99 and get to work tuning the tables in the ECU on my own car. No more asking others to take risks testing things out for me.

Few things to point out: My car is 100% stock. All emissions equipment still installed, stock air box (had to reinstall it), stock exhaust with all 3 cats, stock boost (controlled by the stock BCS), stock unrewired fuel pump and this is full weight car. With the exception of the rims, a forge closed loop BOV and 121K miles on the chassy, this car is just as you would have bought it back in 99.

The programs I use for flash tuning are ECUFlash (http://www.tactrix.com/index.php?option=com_content&view=category&layout=blog&id=36&Itemid=58), EVOScan 2.6 (http://www.evoscan.com) with a custom 3/S definition file (http://www.xtreme3s.net/mono/Data.xml) and a dyno calc program called VDR 5.71 (http://forums.evolutionm.net/ecuflash/427726-virtual-dyno-room-dyno-simulator.html) which uses your EVOScan logs to generate a dyno curve of your car. I had to add the gear ratios, Drag CoEff and Frontal areas for a VR4 to the program but that info was easy to find using Google. Been using these programs for years with great results!

Speaking of results, I had no idea how huge of a beast could be unleashed!

http://i.imgur.com/FBohi.jpg

What you're looking at are the before & after results of about half a dozen pulls in 3rd gear on a few back roads. The blue/red lines are the car with the stock tune, the yellow/green are after my tune.

Note: These are NOT actual dyno results, just a calculation based on RPM, time and a number of other variables (which you can see on the left hand side of the chart).

Yes, you're seeing that right. 47hp and 73 ft/lb gain in torque with just tweaking the timing, fuel and MAF tables. :muahaha: The ECU also has something called lean spool which I tried playing with a bit but I'm not sure if it does anything yet. More logging/testing will need to be done to confirm its function.

The first (base) pull was done on a flat stretch of road in 3rd gear starting at about 2700 rpms and holding the gas pedal to the floor till as close to redline as I felt comfortable going on the dark and narrow tarmac. The results were about what you expect on a stock car (225-230whp) so I was confident the variables I put into the program were going to be accurate enough. EVO guys have found this program to be within 5-10hp of an actual dyno but obviously, I'll need test this sometime.

After about half a dozen pulls on the exact same stretch of road we're left with a 47hp and 73 ft/lb gain in torque! This is a 0 knock tune on 93 Sonoco gas. Another couple degrees of timing got me a bit of knock so I had to back it off and settle with what you see.

My car has a bit of a stutter to it as well which I figure is from the old plugs, wires, fuel filter and injectors. So that's what you're seeing in the dips in the graph but even still, there's a HUGE gain in low end power! The butt dyno highly approves of this mod!

The weather is calling for flooding rains over the next couple days and I have other plans this weekend, so maybe early next week I'll reinstall the K&N open air filter and test the results. After that will be a full exhaust. :bandit:

mb3000
03-08-2011, 11:16 PM
Wow, wasn't expecting that big of gains.

DocWalt
03-09-2011, 12:20 AM
Great stuff Greg!

J. Fast
03-09-2011, 12:39 AM
That's awesome Greg! Keep up the good work!

AgentOblivious
03-09-2011, 01:20 AM
You need OBD II for this right?

Greg E
03-09-2011, 01:26 AM
You need OBD II for this right?

Yeah but this will only work for the 98 and 99 cars.

Gearheadvr4
03-09-2011, 01:38 AM
I knew Mitsubishi tuned conservative but that's a lot. Nice work!

x2percentmilk
03-09-2011, 03:05 AM
Im more excited to see what I can squeeze out of my NA with a standalone after seeing this. Obviously wont be seeing +50hp and 73tq, but im excited.

bboyalan
03-09-2011, 06:09 AM
Great work as always! I can already picture even more gains with some usable BCS tables hehe. Do you think there would be a noticeable difference with the factory plastic BPV re-installed?

Greg E
03-09-2011, 06:36 AM
Great work as always! I can already picture even more gains with some usable BCS tables hehe. Do you think there would be a noticeable difference with the factory plastic BPV re-installed?

At this boost level? Probably not...

Greg E
03-09-2011, 06:38 AM
Im more excited to see what I can squeeze out of my NA with a standalone after seeing this. Obviously wont be seeing +50hp and 73tq, but im excited.

I have the fuel and timing tables for a 99 SL ROM and was thinking of flash tuning my 98 next.

aaronatstate
03-09-2011, 03:40 PM
Doing this to J-Groove's 99 this weekend too. :)

mh3kgt
03-09-2011, 04:00 PM
Awesome work man, I wish I had a 98-99 even more now, and now not just for looks lol

J-Groove
03-09-2011, 04:57 PM
Doing this to J-Groove's 99 this weekend too. :)

:Clap:

-John

NOMIEZVR4
03-09-2011, 05:23 PM
damn...great stuff..:D Cant wait to see what a DP, k&N, and more boost will do!

Greg E
03-09-2011, 05:38 PM
damn...great stuff..:D Cant wait to see what a DP, k&N, and more boost will do!

Well, an exhaust will give more midrange power, but kill the high end. This is because the engine is able to flow air more efficiently than what the stock turbos can supply. This has been shown time and time again with these cars.

I don't anticipate much from an air filter either.

DocWalt
03-09-2011, 08:51 PM
Greg, if we manage to get a 3spa meet together, wanna give me a ride? :p

Greg E
03-09-2011, 10:29 PM
Greg, if we manage to get a 3spa meet together, wanna give me a ride? :p

If only you had tits....

DocWalt
03-09-2011, 10:44 PM
I can grow some before then... haha

CoopKill
03-09-2011, 11:08 PM
... :37: ...

Gearheadvr4
03-10-2011, 01:53 AM
Whoa, this turned south real quick. :Doh:

Greg E
03-10-2011, 08:12 AM
:Clap:

-John

Do you have a hotwired fuel pump john? This is going to make a significant change in the fuel map.

aaronatstate
03-10-2011, 09:38 AM
Do you have a hotwired fuel pump john? This is going to make a significant change in the fuel map.

I have a hotwired pump, and mine reads exactly what I put in the fuel tables on my WB02.

And your map wasn't much different from stock on the fuel side. It was actually .1 richer in some spots, and a few points leaner. I don't see the fuel pump being an issue with your map. We'll still log it and adjust as necessary though. :)

J-Groove
03-10-2011, 10:12 AM
Do you have a hotwired fuel pump john? This is going to make a significant change in the fuel map.

Nope. My car is 100% stock. Only mods on her currently are slotted rotors and an damn to heavy clutch.

Engine, fuel etc. all oem.

I will be pulling the ECU tonight, Aaron has me wondering, I didn't know the '99 ECUs were little black plastic boxes. haha

-John

Greg E
03-10-2011, 11:28 AM
I have a hotwired pump, and mine reads exactly what I put in the fuel tables on my WB02.

Apples to oranges man. You got a larger pump, larger injectors....


And your map wasn't much different from stock on the fuel side. It was actually .1 richer in some spots, and a few points leaner. I don't see the fuel pump being an issue with your map. We'll still log it and adjust as necessary though. :)

I was thinking about removing one of the rear o2s and putting my wideband in but that's not the best place to get a reading as it's after a cat. It's not worth welding in a bung elsewhere.

I'm sorry I didn't send you the email last night with the 1& 2 byte stuff either but I'll get it to you tonight. You'll need to make a few changes in the MUT and my latest evoscan xml for it to work.

aaronatstate
03-10-2011, 12:01 PM
Apples to oranges man. You got a larger pump, larger injectors....



I was thinking about removing one of the rear o2s and putting my wideband in but that's not the best place to get a reading as it's after a cat. It's not worth welding in a bung elsewhere.

I'm sorry I didn't send you the email last night with the 1& 2 byte stuff either but I'll get it to you tonight. You'll need to make a few changes in the MUT and my latest evoscan xml for it to work.

Biggest issue with hotwired pumps is over running the fuel pressure regulator. If you got a hotwired pump and an adjustable regulator, you're good.

As for where to put a WB02. I'd think it be more then fine to put it in the rear 02 spot on the rear bank (matter of fact thats where I had mine in my aftermarket downpipe.). I have moved it since then though to my test pipe where my main cat was. My readings though are pretty much the same. The sensor just wont last as long being closer to the hot turbo though.

Oh and for the evoscan xml file, just tell me what needs to be added. I have a really good one right now from Brett, that I like a lot, I'll just add the stuff to it.

Chris@Rvengeperformance
03-10-2011, 12:25 PM
my aem sensor died in less than 1 year in a bung near the rear precat housing (aftermarket y-pipe had an extra bung up there). I've since moved it to to the standard location.

Greg E
03-10-2011, 01:36 PM
Biggest issue with hotwired pumps is over running the fuel pressure regulator. If you got a hotwired pump and an adjustable regulator, you're good..

Right. ....but most people don't run a regulator.


As for where to put a WB02. I'd think it be more then fine to put it in the rear 02 spot on the rear bank (matter of fact thats where I had mine in my aftermarket downpipe.). I have moved it since then though to my test pipe where my main cat was. My readings though are pretty much the same. The sensor just wont last as long being closer to the hot turbo though..

Yeah, the main issue is the cat itself messing with the readings. My cats are still in place.


Oh and for the evoscan xml file, just tell me what needs to be added. I have a really good one right now from Brett, that I like a lot, I'll just add the stuff to it.

Brett's is just an older version of mine which is a revised version that gate started.:lol:

I'll just send the code to add to the xml. :)

rdmelton
03-10-2011, 01:46 PM
Is this going to convince you to keep your 99 vr4? Or is this just a bonus for the new owner?

Greg E
03-10-2011, 01:54 PM
Is this going to convince you to keep your 99 vr4? Or is this just a bonus for the new owner?

If this car sells, I'll get a 98 (prefer that body style) vr4 or convert my SL using the parts from my wrecked vr4. Unless I can make some decent money flash tuning cars or bring in more $$ turning wrenches, this is just going to be a bonus for the new owner. Not going to worry about that till I get a real offer on the car though.

aaronatstate
03-10-2011, 01:55 PM
Right. ....but most people don't run a regulator.



Yeah, the main issue is the cat itself messing with the readings. My cats are still in place.



Brett's is just an older version of mine which is a revised version that gate started.:lol:

I'll just send the code to add to the xml. :)

Yeah I've edited a few things myself, just to my liking, just dont want to do it all again :lol:

Why not get a test pipe? Not that hard to replace the main cat. THough you could run it in a rear location. Sensor life will be deminished, but it'll give you good readings.

Greg E
03-10-2011, 02:29 PM
Yeah I've edited a few things myself, just to my liking, just dont want to do it all again :lol:

Why not get a test pipe? Not that hard to replace the main cat. THough you could run it in a rear location. Sensor life will be deminished, but it'll give you good readings.

Yep I understand. Any new updates I come up with I'll just send you the code.

I have a full exhaust already with a dummy cat but it won't bolt to the stock pipes. Unless someone wants to let me borrow theirs with a bung in it, it's not really worth spending the $$ on.

The local awd dyno has a tail sensor they use but I can't pony up $100 to rent the thing for an hour.

Simace
03-10-2011, 03:26 PM
I will be pulling the ECU tonight, Aaron has me wondering, I didn't know the '99 ECUs were little black plastic boxes. haha

-John

I have a '99 VR4 and my ECU's exterior is no different, in appearance/size outside the actual harness connector, than previous years....or did I just misunderstand?

aaronatstate
03-10-2011, 04:56 PM
I have a '99 VR4 and my ECU's exterior is no different, in appearance/size outside the actual harness connector, than previous years....or did I just misunderstand?

No. A lot of the 99s had the later style Mitsubishi black box ECUs. All the real 99's I've seen, and all the Montero and Diamante ECU's from 98/99 were this style.

Greg E
03-10-2011, 05:26 PM
No. A lot of the 99s had the later style Mitsubishi black box ECUs. All the real 99's I've seen, and all the Montero and Diamante ECU's from 98/99 were this style.

my 98 has the black box as well

Simace
03-10-2011, 08:28 PM
Never knew that. Do you think it's attributed to Cali-spec vs Fed-spec? Or is it in the production run?

Greg E
03-10-2011, 08:34 PM
Never knew that. Do you think it's attributed to Cali-spec vs Fed-spec? Or is it in the production run?

They dropped the Cali-spec vs Fed-spec thing when OBD2 became a gov't standard.

J-Groove
03-10-2011, 09:21 PM
Here are the pics of my ECU

http://www.kimberlite-films.com/hosting/99vr4/99ecu01.jpg

http://www.kimberlite-films.com/hosting/99vr4/99ecu02.jpg

http://www.kimberlite-films.com/hosting/99vr4/99ecu03.jpg

1 thing, okay this looks funky, 2nd thing, THANK YOU TO AARON! For telling me that I needed 4 dimes to open it up. Made it very easy.

-John

Greg E
03-11-2011, 12:44 AM
Is it true that there's a finite number of times that these things can be reflashed?

Steve

Nope.

Edit: turns out there is a limitation but it's not significant enough to worry about!

Gearheadvr4
03-11-2011, 01:59 AM
I would disagree with that a bit. For all flash chips there is a limit but it's usually so high that you will not reach it. For tuning I would hope you never could unless you flashed it every day for the next 10 years.

Greg E
03-11-2011, 09:18 AM
I would disagree with that a bit. For all flash chips there is a limit but it's usually so high that you will not reach it. For tuning I would hope you never could unless you flashed it every day for the next 10 years.

Can you show me some technical documentation about that?

aaronatstate
03-11-2011, 09:40 AM
Brett also told me about, saying there was a finite amount of times. However, its usually the amount of times you can fully rewrite a chip. The nice thing about ECUFlash is it only rewrites the parts in needs to. Tuning a vehicle, you should'nt ever reach the limit I wouldn't think.

BlackStealth
03-11-2011, 09:52 AM
Embedded microprocessors that I work with have a limit of 10,000 re-flashes for program storage, and their EEPROM memory have 100,000 re-write limit. So yes there's definitely a limit --perhaps 10,000.

zapman2000
03-11-2011, 10:02 AM
Yea any thing that stores memory has a rewrite limit
Like how a battery builds a memory charge so do memory chips and processors

HTC EVO

Rocket
03-11-2011, 10:12 AM
Flash Ram - How long does it last? (http://www.electrondepot.com/australian/Flash-Ram-How-long-does-it-last-26127-.htm) "But in practice you are talking a decade or two at the least for
typical use in modern Flash micros. But if you are a pessimist..."

There are limits to any flash programmable chips. I can remember when you were talking 100 or so for some EEPROM. I hadn't looked this up in ummm better than a decade so it is nice to see that improvements have been made.

I am sure you could find the limits for our chipset listed somewhere. Post up the chip and I will see what I can find if you want a hard limit. For practical purposes you should never hit the wall tuning :)

Greg E
03-11-2011, 10:45 AM
Interesting. I had read a few rumors but no one showed any real data.

Chris@Rvengeperformance
03-11-2011, 02:06 PM
Technically you could only write to an e-manage or aem a finite number of times for the same reason.

apickle
03-11-2011, 09:14 PM
Looking good, Greg! I'm very tempted to try the '99 ECU in my '92, rather than go AEM or ARC2 for my 15G build. I'll have to check it out at the UMG :)

Chris GTO TT
03-11-2011, 10:26 PM
Looking good, Greg! I'm very tempted to try the '99 ECU in my '92, rather than go AEM or ARC2 for my 15G build. I'll have to check it out at the UMG :)

Check out aaron's 99 montero ecu thread its might be a cheaper alternative for us.

apickle
03-11-2011, 10:32 PM
I've been watching it, don't worry. I don't have the knowledge or skill to do the mods on a Montero ECU, but a flashable factory ECU would do nearly all that most people would need for less $ and less tweaking than an AEM setup.

aaronatstate
03-11-2011, 11:47 PM
Got John's flashed. Took a little longer, as my flash enable cable didn't work, which I had a sneaking suspicion it wasn't going to. I knew I fuxored the soldering up, so I'll have to rebuild it and see if I can get it to work next time. What did we do? Well being the good 3/S owner's we are we had tools handy, and we just swapped his ECU into my car real quick, and I flashed it in there. Worked like a champ, and his car is noticeably quicker :)

Logged about 4-5 pulls, and the most knock was 1-2 counts for a slip second. Good job Greg!

Greg E
03-12-2011, 01:20 AM
Logged about 4-5 pulls, and the most knock was 1-2 counts for a slip second. Good job Greg!

It gets better. I made a couple tweaks tonight!

Swapped in an air filter & drove the car a bit. No noticeable changes in anything really. Drove around for about 40 minutes which gave the trims more than adequate time to adjust to the change. Fuel trims seemed to go up which tells me the stock narrow bands were detecting a leaner condition and adding fuel. Went out for a pull on the strip to test.

http://i.imgur.com/TERUI.jpg

So there you have it. An air filter gained me 1hp and lost me 3 ft/lbs of torque. Not really surprised by the results to be honest. There have been threads where guys dyno tested adding an air filter to a stock car and found it made no difference. It makes sense if you think about it. The turbos are sucking air as hard as they're blowing it into the motor. This is just speculation from me but I think the stock air box wasn't designed to restrict air to the turbos, rather I think it was designed purely as a silencer to quiet the noises of the turbos. Take my amateur words for what they're worth though.

The stuttering finally got annoying and I wanted to get more power out of the car so I swapped in new plugs and wires, leaned out the fuel table a couple tenths in places and added a degree here and there in the timing map where I felt I could get away with it.

http://i.imgur.com/am6eA.jpg

Those are results worth a full nights work. :)

Greg E
03-12-2011, 01:36 AM
BTW bboyalan!

Look what I finally got working. :)

http://i.imgur.com/d3FzE.jpg

bboyalan
03-12-2011, 02:01 AM
Well how about that man! :Clap: :bigthumb: no more roughly computed estimations lol. Will the airflow be more difficult to nail down? I implemented a MAFless EMU tune this afternoon, and 32xx was popping up prior to the transition :eek4: funny since the max axis scaling is 3150.

Are you really on Pump-93?? That looks like a sweet tune :DevilSmile:

Greg E
03-12-2011, 08:45 AM
Well how about that man! :Clap: :bigthumb: no more roughly computed estimations lol. Will the airflow be more difficult to nail down? I implemented a MAFless EMU tune this afternoon, and 32xx was popping up prior to the transition :eek4: funny since the max axis scaling is 3150.

Are you really on Pump-93?? That looks like a sweet tune :DevilSmile:

Yes. Straight 93 from Sonoco (don't run any other gas if I don't have to). I gotta put a little fuel back in though. As you can see, the narrowbands are a bit lean. I'm not really comfortable running that tune long term.

I'm not really sure why 2-byte airflow doesn't work yet. I thought maybe it was something simple like a mis-typed address but it seems the ECU just chops off those upper 8 bits before sending it to the MUT. Not quite sure how to tackle this yet.

aaronatstate
03-12-2011, 09:48 AM
2-byte logging does indeed work. Load maxes at 200 which I hit :lol:

Greg E
03-12-2011, 11:11 AM
2-byte logging does indeed work. Load maxes at 200 which I hit :lol:

I got my car to touch 159 load last night in 4th gear but just couldn't seem to get another 2 points out of it. :lol: I need more boost.

Greg E
04-04-2011, 09:13 PM
Here you go Alan. This should make tuning a bit easier for you.

How To: Logging more than 160 Load and 1600HZ with EVOScan (tested) - 3000GT/Stealth International Message Center (http://www.3si.org/forum/f42/how-logging-more-than-160-load-1600hz-evoscan-tested-516710/)

bboyalan
04-04-2011, 09:53 PM
Cot damn! That is some impressive news Greg. I am very interested to see the actual plateau in our numbers now especially with the new MAS.

Have you been spiking yours turbos a little higher lately? Unless I am mistaken, we are still limited to 100-120-140-160 =/ so are we not still looking from behind a glass window so to speak? This is great nonetheless!

Gearheadvr4
04-04-2011, 10:55 PM
BTW bboyalan!

Look what I finally got working. :)


What is that exactly? 2byte is what?

Greg E
04-04-2011, 10:56 PM
What is that exactly? 2byte is what?

Click the link.

Drummer
06-16-2011, 09:03 PM
How has this been coming?

Greg E
06-16-2011, 09:53 PM
Still climbing over the learning curve. Been trying to find all the tables which need to be edited so I can swap in the EVO X map sensor and datalog boost.

TwIzTeD_3kGt
06-16-2011, 10:30 PM
Greg, do you mind posting your settings in the dyno program under 'vehicle list'?

Greg E
06-16-2011, 11:52 PM
Greg, do you mind posting your settings in the dyno program under 'vehicle list'?

Yes I can when I get home. You need the settings for a 2G?

TwIzTeD_3kGt
06-17-2011, 02:42 PM
Yes, I have the gear ratios but the 'frontal area' and 'drag coefficient' were guesses. I used 21.62 and .33 respectively.

Greg E
06-19-2011, 08:46 PM
Yes, I have the gear ratios but the 'frontal area' and 'drag coefficient' were guesses. I used 21.62 and .33 respectively.

I used 22 and .33 so you're spot on.

Gear ratios are 1.241 for 3rd, .918 for 4th and 3.869 for Final Drive.

TwIzTeD_3kGt
06-20-2011, 11:52 PM
Thanks, I had the same for the gear ratios too. :)

Cool program, seems to be about right compared to my previous actual dyno results. Can see on the graph where knock was happening before even looking at the data.

Jesters Deadd
06-22-2011, 12:14 PM
subscribed

Chris GTO TT
06-26-2011, 01:21 PM
I drove this car last night and I can attest that it drives absolutely fantastic. It has by far the smoothest power delivery I have ever felt in a stock 3/S

Sent from my HTC EVO

Greg E
06-26-2011, 11:03 PM
I drove this car last night and I can attest that it drives absolutely fantastic. It has by far the smoothest power delivery I have ever felt in a stock 3/S

Sent from my HTC EVO

Thanks Chris! I really appreciated you driving for me!

It was great meeting you in person finally. Hope we get to hang out again sometime.

Chris GTO TT
06-26-2011, 11:21 PM
I am planning on coming back again next year!

Goallie11
06-26-2011, 11:28 PM
What was the announcement you made at the NG? If you made it...

Greg E
06-26-2011, 11:34 PM
What was the announcement you made at the NG? If you made it...

Haha, Brett didn't really do a lot of advertising but Morgan Motorsports will be handing the distribution of the ECU adapters and flashable ECUs. The harnesses are ready, but the ECU's are not. Shoot Von (x-wire) a PM if you are interested in one.

ChargerX3
06-27-2011, 02:57 PM
How much is he asking for each?

JasonY
06-27-2011, 03:24 PM
Oh and we successfully made a 99 ECU happy with no CEL with absolutely zero factory emmissions shit on the car...:)

Jason

aaronatstate
06-28-2011, 12:04 AM
Oh and we successfully made a 99 ECU happy with no CEL with absolutely zero factory emmissions shit on the car...:)

Jason

I've had that since the beginning :p

J-Groove
06-28-2011, 10:03 AM
I've had that since the beginning :p

Show off. ;)

-John

Drummer
06-28-2011, 11:40 AM
.... and the 3000gt file for ECUFLASH evolves.... MWah

Jesters Deadd
06-28-2011, 11:48 AM
Oh and we successfully made a 99 ECU happy with no CEL with absolutely zero factory emmissions shit on the car...:)

Jason
I have been running zero emmission shiz and no O2 heaters since aaron showed me the periphs to flip for a month...:)

Greg E
06-28-2011, 01:37 PM
You guys don't understand. Jason car has been a tough cookie to flash. For some reason ECUFlash and EVOScan don't like his car. Connections are intermittent, flashing stops mid way randomly, CE codes don't even show up... Finally got it Saturday after the car show.

Greg E
08-01-2011, 09:51 PM
One final attempt with the car before I start upgrades!!

After weeks of staring at code, I finally located and disassembled the entire stock boost control system. Got lucky because the EVO BCS system is similar (although there are a few key differences) so figuring out how it all worked was a piece of cake!

The Boost control signal is a constant 16 HZ with varying duty cycle dependent on RPM. Boost solenoid is energized when the ECU pulls the white lead of the solenoid to ground. Logging this Waste Gate Duty Cycle (WGDC) from MUT request 86 shows:

RPM - WGDC
2000 - 100% Constantly energized = BCS shut
3000 - 80%
4000 - 70%
5000 - 55%
6000 - 46%
7000 - 44%

Here's a prequisite log of my car just before I started tweaking the tables.

http://i.imgur.com/oHaKn.jpg

The highlighted column in yellow is boost, the orange is WGDC. BTW you are seeing that correct. My stock car is boosting almost 14psi stock and it tapers to 7 by the redline. This has been verified on 2 other 99 VR4s. The service manual claims 2G cars only boost 10psi stock and as you can clearly see, that's understated!

Anyway, the results of modifying the stock boost tables weren't as grand as I was hoping. The stock solinoid with the restrictor pill only allows 16psi spike and 10psi by redline. Poor little 9Bs can't even push air on a stock car. I was amazed the stock fuel system was able to keep up. The wideband stayed perfectly flat at 11.5 so still quite conservative on AFR and timing.

HP wise was a bit of a disappointment though. My ignition system is 126K miles old and was nothing but blow out at anything above 14psi, it was 97 degrees outside and it seems 9B's flow nothing more than hot lava from satans asshole at 10psi because you can see the knock above 6Krpms in that log. It's not a fuel issue either.


http://i.imgur.com/zORqt.jpg

By the time I got a half way decent tune, these were the results:

http://i.imgur.com/m9HcR.jpg

I was really really hoping for 300whp and maybe I could get there with new wires and coils but this looks to be the end of this adventure.

After the last pull my crank pulley separated and that was just the excuse I needed to rip my car apart and begin the upgrades. Called Matt Monnett earlier and placed an order for a set of billet DR650's and I can finally install this closet full of parts I've been collecting.

So stay tuned!

Jesters Deadd
08-03-2011, 11:10 AM
One final attempt with the car before I start upgrades!!

After weeks of staring at code, I finally located and disassembled the entire stock boost control system. Got lucky because the EVO BCS system is similar (although there are a few key differences) so figuring out how it all worked was a piece of cake!

The Boost control signal is a constant 16 HZ with varying duty cycle dependent on RPM. Boost solenoid is energized when the ECU pulls the white lead of the solenoid to ground. Logging this Waste Gate Duty Cycle (WGDC) from MUT request 86 shows:

RPM - WGDC
2000 - 100% Constantly energized = BCS shut
3000 - 80%
4000 - 70%
5000 - 55%
6000 - 46%
7000 - 44%

Here's a prequisite log of my car just before I started tweaking the tables.

http://i.imgur.com/oHaKn.jpg

The highlighted column in yellow is boost, the orange is WGDC. BTW you are seeing that correct. My stock car is boosting almost 14psi stock and it tapers to 7 by the redline. This has been verified on 2 other 99 VR4s. The service manual claims 2G cars only boost 10psi stock and as you can clearly see, that's understated!

Anyway, the results of modifying the stock boost tables weren't as grand as I was hoping. The stock solinoid with the restrictor pill only allows 16psi spike and 10psi by redline. Poor little 9Bs can't even push air on a stock car. I was amazed the stock fuel system was able to keep up. The wideband stayed perfectly flat at 11.5 so still quite conservative on AFR and timing.

HP wise was a bit of a disappointment though. My ignition system is 126K miles old and was nothing but blow out at anything above 14psi, it was 97 degrees outside and it seems 9B's flow nothing more than hot lava from satans asshole at 10psi because you can see the knock above 6Krpms in that log. It's not a fuel issue either.


http://i.imgur.com/zORqt.jpg

By the time I got a half way decent tune, these were the results:

http://i.imgur.com/m9HcR.jpg

I was really really hoping for 300whp and maybe I could get there with new wires and coils but this looks to be the end of this adventure.

After the last pull my crank pulley separated and that was just the excuse I needed to rip my car apart and begin the upgrades. Called Matt Monnett earlier and placed an order for a set of billet DR650's and I can finally install this closet full of parts I've been collecting.

So stay tuned!

That is great, you found the boost solenoid control table! Are you using the stock boost solenoid for your testing or an AEM type?
Also just a thought, humor me here. If a person had a boost controller already and wanted... say a shift light, couldn't this table be modified a little to make a simple shift light to replace the boost control control? Or couldn't it be used for a simple MiVEC control if you put Mivec heads on?

Greg E
08-03-2011, 11:38 AM
That is great, you found the boost solenoid control table! Are you using the stock boost solenoid for your testing or an AEM type?
Also just a thought, humor me here. If a person had a boost controller already and wanted... say a shift light, couldn't this table be modified a little to make a simple shift light to replace the boost control control? Or couldn't it be used for a simple MiVEC control if you put Mivec heads on?

No. Everything you mentioned requires custom code be added to the ROM. That's way beyond me at this point.

I'm using the stock BCS. I had planned on pulling the restrictor pill out and doing more testing but my crank pulley broke.

Jesters Deadd
08-03-2011, 01:46 PM
No. Everything you mentioned requires custom code be added to the ROM. That's way beyond me at this point.

I'm using the stock BCS. I had planned on pulling the restrictor pill out and doing more testing but my crank pulley broke.
I have heard the stock Boost control solenoid is only good to about 14 psi. You may want to test with an AEm style solenoid.
Well what I was talking about was instead of using the BC circuit for Boost control... Change the circuit to a ground for a shift light, and change the table to
RPM - WGDC
2000 - 0% Constantly open = light off
3000 - 0%
4000 - 0%
5000 - 0%
6000 - 0%
7000 - 100% = light on

Then the shift light would come on at 7000 rpms and stay off below that.
Or do the same thing with say a Mivec controller.

RPM - WGDC
2000 - 0% Constantly open = Mivec off
3000 - 100%
4000 - 100%
5000 - 100%
6000 - 100%
7000 - 100%
Then the mivec would come on at 3000 rpms and stay off below that.

Greg E
08-03-2011, 02:25 PM
I have heard the stock Boost control solenoid is only good to about 14 psi. You may want to test with an AEm style solenoid.
Well what I was talking about was instead of using the BC circuit for Boost control... Change the circuit to a ground for a shift light, and change the table to
RPM - WGDC
2000 - 0% Constantly open = light off
3000 - 0%
4000 - 0%
5000 - 0%
6000 - 0%
7000 - 100% = light on

Then the shift light would come on at 7000 rpms and stay off below that.
Or do the same thing with say a Mivec controller.

RPM - WGDC
2000 - 0% Constantly open = Mivec off
3000 - 100%
4000 - 100%
5000 - 100%
6000 - 100%
7000 - 100%
Then the mivec would come on at 3000 rpms and stay off below that.

Who ever told you that is very obviously wrong. I'll post logs if you'd like to see them. Since this has never been done before, I'm not sure where your source is getting their info.

In fact, with the restrictor pill removed the solenoid should be able to bleed off even more air from the wastegates so we can get even more boost. I have a GM 3-port on stand by for when I get my car going again but I'm still going to play with the stock solenoid some more.

I see what you're saying now with the shift light. I don't see any reason why that wouldn't work.

As for MIVEC, it would be much better to use a 3D table that's both RPM and load based for control over that solenoid. I bet one of the unused fuel tables would make a great candidate for that.

Jesters Deadd
08-03-2011, 05:01 PM
Who ever told you that is very obviously wrong. I'll post logs if you'd like to see them. Since this has never been done before, I'm not sure where your source is getting their info.

In fact, with the restrictor pill removed the solenoid should be able to bleed off even more air from the wastegates so we can get even more boost. I have a GM 3-port on stand by for when I get my car going again but I'm still going to play with the stock solenoid some more. My comment was complete hear-say not based on any test I saw. But now that you mention it afterwards he did sell me a new solenoid.

I see what you're saying now with the shift light. I don't see any reason why that wouldn't work.

As for MIVEC, it would be much better to use a 3D table that's both RPM and load based for control over that solenoid. I bet one of the unused fuel tables would make a great candidate for that.

Cool! Unused fuel tables? which one are you referring too? there is the high octane map and the low octane map... maybe I am not remembering some?

Jesters Deadd
08-03-2011, 05:04 PM
Have the fuel solenoid map, egr solenoid map, charcoal canister solenoid map been found?

bboyalan
08-03-2011, 05:14 PM
Who ever told you that is very obviously wrong. I'll post logs if you'd like to see them. Since this has never been done before, I'm not sure where your source is getting their info.
I have only read about one person actually attempting to push the factory BCS to any reasonable limit, and that was BlackStealth who had set up DC maps as well for a measly 12psi lol.

My GM 3-Port has been sitting for over half a year, so I cannot wait to finally use it hahaha. GrimmSpeed seems to be what is "in" nowadays though.

Greg E
08-03-2011, 05:31 PM
My comment was complete hear-say not based on any test I saw. But now that you mention it afterwards he did sell me a new solenoid.


Cool! Unused fuel tables? which one are you referring too? there is the high octane map and the low octane map... maybe I am not remembering some?



:lmao: Sucker!

Mitsubishi liked to recycle code for some reason. In the OBD1 days, there were separate maps for fed and california ecus. So you have a high and low octane map for each emission ecu. I have to double check the code again but I think there maybe 6 or 8 maps total. Gate or Brett could probably back me up on this.

Anyway, hardware wise the California and fed spec ecus have their differences but they all shared the same (almost) code. The only difference in the code was which set of tables that ecu used.

When OBD2 became standard and every car shared the same ecu, they never got rid of those extra tables in the code for some reason. Even the EVOs have 3 high and 3 low octane fuel maps even though only one is used.

Greg E
08-03-2011, 05:36 PM
Have the fuel solenoid map, egr solenoid map, charcoal canister solenoid map been found?

I found the egr map but not the others. I probably won't spend any time looking for them. As you know we figured out how to disable them in the periphery so the only thing that's left to figure out is how to set the OBD2 tests to ready & pass.

Jesters Deadd
08-03-2011, 07:04 PM
I found the egr map but not the others. I probably won't spend any time looking for them. As you know we figured out how to disable them in the periphery so the only thing that's left to figure out is how to set the OBD2 tests to ready & pass.

If those other maps are found and the OBD2 tests can be set to ready & pass, couldn't we use the other unused solenoids then as other outputs? like shift lights, mivec, alcohol/water inj, whatever...

Jesters Deadd
08-03-2011, 07:08 PM
:lmao: Sucker!

Mitsubishi liked to recycle code for some reason. In the OBD1 days, there were separate maps for fed and california ecus. So you have a high and low octane map for each emission ecu. I have to double check the code again but I think there maybe 6 or 8 maps total. Gate or Brett could probably back me up on this.

Anyway, hardware wise the California and fed spec ecus have their differences but they all shared the same (almost) code. The only difference in the code was which set of tables that ecu used.

When OBD2 became standard and every car shared the same ecu, they never got rid of those extra tables in the code for some reason. Even the EVOs have 3 high and 3 low octane fuel maps even though only one is used.
I wonder if some of those extra peripheries are for switching between fuel maps, That would be neat!

BlackStealth
08-03-2011, 08:32 PM
Long time ago when I had an AEM EMS, I thought it would be cool to use the stock boost solenoid instead of the GM boost solenoid for a more sleeper look. I didn't use the factory boost solenoid as a bleeder configuration, I used the solenoid in the same way the GM boost solenoid was used, that is to restrict boost going into the wastegate. To my disappointment, I think 14psi was the maximum I could get, and I really wanted 17psi. In the end I ditched the stock boost solenoid in favor of the GM boost solenoid and problem was solved. I don't recall if I tried removing the "restrictor" inside the solenoid as mine was a 1st gen solenoid.

Greg E
08-03-2011, 11:51 PM
If those other maps are found and the OBD2 tests can be set to ready & pass, couldn't we use the other unused solenoids then as other outputs? like shift lights, mivec, alcohol/water inj, whatever...

I was thinking of using them for BIG maps.;)

Greg E
08-04-2011, 12:11 AM
Long time ago when I had an AEM EMS, I thought it would be cool to use the stock boost solenoid instead of the GM boost solenoid for a more sleeper look. I didn't use the factory boost solenoid as a bleeder configuration, I used the solenoid in the same way the GM boost solenoid was used, that is to restrict boost going into the wastegate. To my disappointment, I think 14psi was the maximum I could get, and I really wanted 17psi. In the end I ditched the stock boost solenoid in favor of the GM boost solenoid and problem was solved. I don't recall if I tried removing the "restrictor" inside the solenoid as mine was a 1st gen solenoid.

It doesn't seem to flow enough air for a feed vs a bleeder. I'll play with it some more on the new setup with the forge wastegates.

BlackStealth
08-04-2011, 09:12 AM
It doesn't seem to flow enough air for a feed vs a bleeder. I'll play with it some more on the new setup with the forge wastegates.
In order to raise boost, the wastegate actuator needs airflow to be restricted even further, so wouldn't that be opposite problem? The stock solenoid couldn't restrict the airflow enough.

Greg E
08-04-2011, 10:57 AM
In order to raise boost, the wastegate actuator needs airflow to be restricted even further, so wouldn't that be opposite problem? The stock solenoid couldn't restrict the airflow enough.

The stock solenoid doesn't block airflow, it bleeds air away from the wastegates. A larger opening is needed to bleed away more air.

Semantics....

I don't anticipate the stock solenoid is going to bleed away enough air to make any real boost with 15psi actuators. Even with the restrictor pill removed. Still going to try it anyway though just because its never been done. Worst case I'll only see 15psi at 100% duty cycle.