PDA

View Full Version : Feasibility of this idea??



GRSHOPR
12-16-2010, 02:38 PM
OK, so I was in the shower, where, consequently, I do my best thinking, and I was thinking about how I am dissatisfied with my FWD TT's ability to maintain traction, and so, ways to counter it. My mind ran on many tangents, but the one that seemed the most intriguing to me was RWD. I realize that AWD is available, but I was concerned about the maximum output of power, and if I recall, you lose ~30% of it from the transfer case on AWD?? So my next thought along that line was to remove the FWD, kind of a hack and slash job. For many reasons, I thought that too infeasible. So then I moved onto the more obvious (if not realistic) solution. Move the motor and tranny to the back of the car and eliminate the transfer casings altogether. Use an AWD tranny, with a welded VCU, and the power possible should be that much greater.

I went through the preliminaries, and aside from a but load of money, for custom fab, I figure I would need an AWD body, as the rear end is already set up for propulsion from the rear. Is there anything that I'm missing that would make this idea IMPOSSIBLE? Has anyone already done this?? I recognize it isn't feasible due to the large cost, but I'm just curious from a theoretical stand point, is it POSSIBLE, and if not, what's stopping it? Thanks.

DocWalt
12-16-2010, 03:10 PM
Not impossible, but kinda pointless. The car would handle terribly not having any weight up front (you'd obviously need to relocate the tank, run new coolant lines, power steering equipment, etc.) and wouldn't gain that much by going to that layout.

Goallie11
12-16-2010, 04:08 PM
There's a Russian or Bulgarian shop that put a 2nd engine in the rear but I believe they tore everything done and started from a bare frame.

It's a lot of work.

marshallh
12-16-2010, 04:21 PM
If I'm not mistaken, Evan (the guy who did some AWD conversions, goes by shooter83) ran his stealth ES RWD for a while, and noted that the car was definitely NOT designed to be RWD, and was far better as AWD

x2percentmilk
12-16-2010, 04:33 PM
Too much money, time, and work for something that wont give you great results.
If you want it for show, or just for the bragging rights, then wether or not its worth it is up to you.

The only car I know of (off the top of my head) that pulled it off was a mk1 golf, and it wasnt nearly as fast as it should have been and didnt handle too well.

Unless of course, you fully built two 6g72's to the max (ie: a combined >2000hp) :w00t:

EDIT: kinda didnt really read much of anything before posting. Mid engine idea is better than twin engine haha. If youve got the time and resources why not?

Maximal
12-16-2010, 04:49 PM
Yeah, it'll be a lot of work and a ton of custom fabrication but if you have the skills, time, and money to do it it'd be pretty sweet to see.

GRSHOPR
12-16-2010, 11:28 PM
Yeah, it's pretty much for bragging rights, and a drag strip. Now, I'm curious as to what makes it a bad RWD car? What is the difference between our car and higher end manufacturers to make them a good RWD?

11secondFWD
12-16-2010, 11:40 PM
I solved my FWDTT traction problems with 26x10 mt et drag slicks with 12psi of pressure. I had no traction loss. I know its not a great solution for daily driving but you will have traction at the track where it matters. Plus there is no need for street racing. And if you do punch it just start at 60mph in 3rd, lol. And if its cold maybe 80 mph in 4th. You will get traction then.

If you are looking for et and trap numbers buy a 500 dollar slick/rim combo. Its way cheaper and easy. Only 5 lug nuts on each side to remove and a jack. Being serious, with all that fab and money I seen it as best to use slicks at track and take it easy on the street. If someone wanted to try and run their mouth or race, I took it to the highway roll.

GRSHOPR
12-17-2010, 10:13 AM
Lol, I can't even keep traction with only 6-7 lbs of boost. I think it may be because I have all-weathers on for the winter, but it's still rather annoying.

Unknownvr4
12-17-2010, 12:49 PM
It would be much easier and probably cheaper to AWD convert than any of the other options listed here. (other than slicks)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4AwP_azDx7k

RL7
12-17-2010, 03:12 PM
This idea stayed in my head for some reason, but if you mounted the engine normally rather than transversely and put a transmission/transaxle in the back, I think you would have better weight distribution. You would almost definitely have to cut away a bunch of floor panels and stuff in the back to make room for a transmission, but that is probably feasible. Yes, it would require a large amount of custom fabrication, but it's nothing that hasn't been done before in the automotive world.

I think the reason people bring this up so regularly is that they love the looks of the car, but keep realizing that the awd drivetrain is complex and more prone to failure than many other drivetrains.

Ben_Pow!!
12-17-2010, 04:38 PM
I've thought about other options as well. One in particular was to rotate the 6G72 to be longitudinal. Make an adapter plate & everything else to fit a ford or chevy tranny. Fab up the rear to accept the ford/chevy diff. Now you have a ton of gearing options and less % of power lost. I took measurements from a friends tremec so I could see if it was even possible to fit in there. Man, those things are fucking huge. I noticed there is a recess in the transverse frame member under the firewall that may allow you to stuff a good amount of tranny under it. This was years ago, I've lost the measurements and lost interest as other projects came along. Do you guys think that's possible?

colt45 gto
12-17-2010, 04:54 PM
mounting a 6g72 longitudinal poses bigger problems.... the T/stat housing will be against the fire wall, you would have to configure engine mounts etc.

now if you mount the engine longitudinal behind the seats and make an adaptor plate to fit a VW, porsche or Audi gearbox you would have a full mid engined car thats well balanced. and with a bit of metal up front to convert the engine bay into the trunk with a fuel cell in there you would be onto a winner.

i have thought about and posted about rear mounting in a 3s a couple of years ago and indeed last year too on 3si. so its not a new idea at all but with some thought this could be done and made to handle very well too.

Unknownvr4
12-17-2010, 07:42 PM
I've thought about other options as well. One in particular was to rotate the 6G72 to be longitudinal. Make an adapter plate & everything else to fit a ford or chevy tranny. Fab up the rear to accept the ford/chevy diff. Now you have a ton of gearing options and less % of power lost. I took measurements from a friends tremec so I could see if it was even possible to fit in there. Man, those things are fucking huge. I noticed there is a recess in the transverse frame member under the firewall that may allow you to stuff a good amount of tranny under it. This was years ago, I've lost the measurements and lost interest as other projects came along. Do you guys think that's possible?

You would also have to modify the subframe too. And you probably could just use a vr4 rear end because thats what the rwd conversions usually just use. Someone sold a RWD conversion kit at one point as well.

GTOJOE
12-18-2010, 12:25 AM
Didn't the guy who made gull wing doors for his 3s also talk about a rear engined 3s? never saw any updates after he finished the doors.

GTwizard
12-18-2010, 01:11 AM
If you are looking for rear wheel drive. Get 1 of the these and get rid of the extra 1000 lbs, than your traction issues will be less. LOL
I have traction issues as well. Deal with it. Start with weight transfer issues, weight in general, LSD, slicks, and a ton of other thing that will get you closer to a reasonable goal. Your day dreaming will impress no one. It has been done. In fact a few time. If you wish to ride a horse, go get a horse. If you wish for a sports car get one. Be happy with what you have done so far. If it's a good reliable TT FWD, you have done good. I am NA FWD and will continue to be so. There are so many things left to do with a fwd drive that has not yet been done. Try improving what you have. Chopping it up into something it's not does not make any sense. Like My TT Firero. It is rear engine and rear drive and a bit qyicker than the 911. But it will never out handle like a Porsche and will never be a Porsche. Fairly simple. My NA out runs stock VR4s. But it will never be the same as a VR4. But it is a bad to the bone NA. And this is the platform we push. We will always strive to make it better, but not by changing it into something it's not. Just food for thought.
http://i498.photobucket.com/albums/rr343/GTwizard/S6306147.jpg

IPD
12-18-2010, 11:40 AM
yeah. c5 vette or 928 porsche (911's aren't my thing).

oh, and there HAS been a 3/s modified to have a longitudinal engine. i've seen the pics. can't remember who did it, but it was on a red car.

GTwizard
12-18-2010, 12:04 PM
mounting a 6g72 longitudinal poses bigger problems.... the T/stat housing will be against the fire wall, you would have to configure engine mounts etc.

now if you mount the engine longitudinal behind the seats and make an adaptor plate to fit a VW, porsche or Audi gearbox you would have a full mid engined car thats well balanced. and with a bit of metal up front to convert the engine bay into the trunk with a fuel cell in there you would be onto a winner.

i have thought about and posted about rear mounting in a 3s a couple of years ago and indeed last year too on 3si. so its not a new idea at all but with some thought this could be done and made to handle very well too.

You can buy the Porsche transaxle adapter plate on line. Porsche to any motor adapter are avail. G672/Porsche plates with clutch adapter are oin the shelf.

CoopKill
12-18-2010, 07:59 PM
Look up VR440

http://www.cardomain.com/ride/3134282/1993-dodge-stealth

http://www.3si.org/forum/f1/vr440-gets-new-engine-393916/


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=T3UwRgaJajU

GRSHOPR
12-19-2010, 10:46 PM
OK, just to be clear, I am not planning on doing anything like this to my FWD TT. It's amazingly fast and reliable, and for a DD, it's perfect. The next thing it's going to get is a welded VR-4 tranny, and I'll go from there. But I am thinking of this for my next car/project. Buy a salvage VR-4, and work on it. A project that would many years, but, if done correctly, would yield a bad ass, and unique car. Like you said, GT, no point trying to take a cow and make it a horse. But to go along with that analogy, it is possible to take a horse, and make it a zebra. I love working on our cars, and seeing what they are, and what they could become. If there are ideas for FWD that haven't been done yet, I think it'd be fun to try them, on a different car, but I haven't come up with them, and I don't think it'd be as fun if I followed someone else's idea.

On that note, has anyone come up with a reliable, efficient, and good looking ram air intake system for our cars??

IPD
12-20-2010, 06:28 AM
no.

cianci has a hood with a duct to push air to the element, but it's not a closed system. you're pretty much SOL if you want to buy it COTS. better off just trying to do it yourself; like the guy with 4 hood blisters.

ZeroAU
12-20-2010, 10:47 PM
mounting a 6g72 longitudinal poses bigger problems.... the T/stat housing will be against the fire wall, you would have to configure engine mounts etc.

now if you mount the engine longitudinal behind the seats and make an adaptor plate to fit a VW, porsche or Audi gearbox you would have a full mid engined car thats well balanced. and with a bit of metal up front to convert the engine bay into the trunk with a fuel cell in there you would be onto a winner.

i have thought about and posted about rear mounting in a 3s a couple of years ago and indeed last year too on 3si. so its not a new idea at all but with some thought this could be done and made to handle very well too.

Out of all these ideas of engines and driveline combination, the midmount is probably the correct set up if you want a balanced vehicle and get rid of a lot of the vehicle's inherent nose-heaviness with the big lump over its front wheels. The big pro to this idea is the huge amount of room back there if you remove the crap out of it, but that's where the easy bit ends!
After that, it really depends just how much engineering you can throw at it to do it properly.

GRSHOPR
12-22-2010, 04:21 PM
Well, assuming money is not an issue, where would be a good midpoint? Replace the back seat with a motor? How would the drive train work?? RWD or AWD?