View Full Version : IC heat soak discussion and solutions
mb7050
11-13-2010, 04:54 PM
I noticed this summer that my car heat soaks pretty fast after mediate / hard driving or driving in heavy traffic.
We all know this robs your engine HP until it cools down again .
I have already purchased bigger Icīs but Iīm thinkin maybe it isnt enough because in traffic Icīs work more like heat sinks rather than intercoolers.
Iīm thinking of mounting spal fans and ic water sprays I want it all to be automatic so Iīm using this controller ( http://www.autospeed.com/cms/article.html?&A=0527&P=1 ) when this controller detects its necessary to cool down the system itīll switch on the fans and the water spray simultaneously ..
I have everything needed fans, 220 psi water pump, lines etc. etc but where could I find water nozzles that could create very fine mist and flow around 150-300 ml/h each ?
mb7050
11-13-2010, 07:32 PM
or just ditch this idea and install water / meth injection :)
I was just reading this. Meth is also VERY cheap here...
"
Benefits Of Water Methanol Injection:
*
Lower air charge temperatures by 40-200+ degrees
*
Increase your fuel’s octane by 10-25+ points
*
Increase horsepower safely by 10-15%
*
Allows you to safely run more boost and timing
*
Removes carbon build-up from combustion chambers, pistons and valves
*
Longer more stable combustion expansion and progression
*
Reduces and helps eliminate engine damaging detonation and pre-ignition
*
No need for expensive racing fuel or additives
Lower Air Charge Temperatures By 50-200+ Degrees
By injecting a fine mist of water methanol directly into the engines incoming air charge has a substantial cooling effect. As the water methanol injection mixes with the hot incoming air charge, it quickly converts from a liquid state to a gas state (steam). In doing so, it absorbs significant amounts of heat from the air charge. Depending on the build of the motor, whether naturally aspirated, supercharged or turbocharged; intercooled or non-intercooled, decreases in air charge temperatures will vary between 50-200+ degrees with cylinder temperatures dropping as much as 300 degree’s.
When combined with engines already out-fitted with air-to-air or air-to-water intercoolers, users will experience lower decreases (approx. 40-80+ degrees) in air charge temperatures due to the intercooler already removing a large portion of the heat from the air charge. While initial air temperature drops are not as significant as non-intercooled engines, lower overall air charge temperatures are achieved. Testing has shown that when combined with either air-to-air or air-to-water intercoolers on supercharged or turbocharged engines, nearly all the negative added heat from the supercharger or turbocharger can be removed. Imagine running 8-14 PSI without any of the added heat from the supercharger or turbocharger. That’s safe reliable horsepower on pump gas!
Increase Your Fuels Octane By 10-20+ Points
Many of you will be surprised by this. When injected properly, water alone will not only significantly cool down the air charge temperatures, but will also act as a very high-octane booster. Read that again if you need too. Researchers estimate up to a 20-point raise in octane can be achieved by using water injection with 87-93 octane gas. No need for expensive racing fuels or octane boosters. A simple water injection system will significantly cool down your air charge temperatures, while dramatically increasing your fuels octane. The best part is, water is free and racing gas is notoriously expensive.
"
mb7050
11-13-2010, 07:37 PM
http://cgi.ebay.com/ebaymotors/AEM-30-3002-Water-Methanol-Injection-Pump-Jet-Kit-_W0QQcmdZViewItemQQhashZitem1c0dd448eaQQitemZ12049 1100394QQptZMotorsQ5fCarQ5fTruckQ5fPartsQ5fAccesso ries
pretty cheap setup too with built in fail safe damn.
mb3000
11-13-2010, 08:04 PM
Water sprayers on the intercooler is the only thing that will cool them down, a water/meth kit will indeed cool the air charge giong into the engine but the intercoolers will still be heatsoaked.
mb7050
11-13-2010, 08:14 PM
yes but water / meth Lower Air Charge Temperatures By 50-200+ Degrees I think that would be enough .
mb7050
11-13-2010, 08:22 PM
or I could do both then I would have to install separate tank for the water / meth.
mb3000
11-13-2010, 08:24 PM
Water/meth systems usually come with a seperate tank. If it was me I would mount the w/m tank in the trunk somewhere and use the windshield fluid tank for the intercooler sprayers.
Just make sure you have access to methanol beforehand.
amicus
11-13-2010, 09:37 PM
What temps do you see at the throttle body and how much boost are you running? I have DSM sidemounts with meth/water injection and 19t's. I see 130 degrees +- at 20lbs of boost depending on outside temps. I use pump gas and I don't see any significant knock. I think this is less complicated than trying to cool your intercoolers unless you're looking to go all out.
when my car back in one peice, I should have water spraying on intercoolers, oil cooler and possibly power steering fluid cooler. with manual switch and intake air temp gauge
enigma
11-14-2010, 01:28 PM
I fitted aquamist water/meth injection and the difference is very noticable, I would certainly recommend fitting it to any turbo engine, I'm running 50/50 mix water/methelyted spirits, I was lucky and brought a used Aquamist, at the time I was looking at a new AEM setup with their new water pump which looked very good!
mb7050
11-14-2010, 02:47 PM
I would be only running water / meth for as an air temperature cooler so not tune for the water/methanol and let the computer do its thing with the now cooler air temperatures. Would this work Iīm guessing 50/50 blend would be too much and cause serious detonation but something like 10 % meth 90 % water ?
mb3000
11-14-2010, 02:49 PM
I would be only running water / meth for as an air temperature cooler so not tune for the water/methanol and let the computer do its thing with the now cooler air temperatures. Would this work Iīm guessing 50/50 blend would be too much and cause serious detonation but something like 10 % meth 90 % water ?
At this point I would just run 100% water.
mb7050
11-14-2010, 03:13 PM
I forgot to mention until I gain trust with the system then I might crank up the boost, tune and add more timing as I would be running race gas but without the expense of race gas. But at this point I wouldnt trust it as my "fuel supply" no way.
I got an impresssion that running 100% water could cause lean condition ? I already have 400 Litres methanol laying around as I sold my sled I have no use for it...
mb7050
11-14-2010, 03:22 PM
when my car back in one peice, I should have water spraying on intercoolers, oil cooler and possibly power steering fluid cooler. with manual switch and intake air temp gauge
What nozzles would you use ? I have been looking at some oil burner nozzless they create very fine mist and cost less than 1/4 the price compared to those nozless they use with water / meth kits...
KeithMac
11-14-2010, 05:33 PM
I got an impresssion that running 100% water could cause lean condition ? I already have 400 Litres methanol laying around as I sold my sled I have no use for it...
Injecting straight water has no effect on the AFR, people lean out the tune when injectiong water to increase the power output (injecting water into an engine with already rich mixture will probably lose you some power).
What nozzles would you use ?
still researching about it. I was thinking about some plastic ones (pretty cheap). but that might change.
amicus
11-19-2010, 12:57 AM
or just ditch this idea and install water / meth injection :)
I was just reading this. Meth is also VERY cheap here...
"
Benefits Of Water Methanol Injection:
*
Lower air charge temperatures by 40-200+ degrees
*
Increase your fuels octane by 10-25+ points
*
Increase horsepower safely by 10-15%
*
Allows you to safely run more boost and timing
*
Removes carbon build-up from combustion chambers, pistons and valves
*
Longer more stable combustion expansion and progression
*
Reduces and helps eliminate engine damaging detonation and pre-ignition
*
No need for expensive racing fuel or additives
Lower Air Charge Temperatures By 50-200+ Degrees
By injecting a fine mist of water methanol directly into the engines incoming air charge has a substantial cooling effect. As the water methanol injection mixes with the hot incoming air charge, it quickly converts from a liquid state to a gas state (steam). In doing so, it absorbs significant amounts of heat from the air charge. Depending on the build of the motor, whether naturally aspirated, supercharged or turbocharged; intercooled or non-intercooled, decreases in air charge temperatures will vary between 50-200+ degrees with cylinder temperatures dropping as much as 300 degrees.
When combined with engines already out-fitted with air-to-air or air-to-water intercoolers, users will experience lower decreases (approx. 40-80+ degrees) in air charge temperatures due to the intercooler already removing a large portion of the heat from the air charge. While initial air temperature drops are not as significant as non-intercooled engines, lower overall air charge temperatures are achieved. Testing has shown that when combined with either air-to-air or air-to-water intercoolers on supercharged or turbocharged engines, nearly all the negative added heat from the supercharger or turbocharger can be removed. Imagine running 8-14 PSI without any of the added heat from the supercharger or turbocharger. Thats safe reliable horsepower on pump gas!
Increase Your Fuels Octane By 10-20+ Points
Many of you will be surprised by this. When injected properly, water alone will not only significantly cool down the air charge temperatures, but will also act as a very high-octane booster. Read that again if you need too. Researchers estimate up to a 20-point raise in octane can be achieved by using water injection with 87-93 octane gas. No need for expensive racing fuels or octane boosters. A simple water injection system will significantly cool down your air charge temperatures, while dramatically increasing your fuels octane. The best part is, water is free and racing gas is notoriously expensive.
"
Originally Posted by steve68
It does if you're using speed density, that's the one major drawback of speed density, it only guesses at the air mass, injecting anything cold totally screws it up, unlike using a stock ECU. Stock ECU wins every time.
Steve
I don't agree that water/meth increases octane by 10-25 points or increases HP by 10-25%. Water/meth injection does lower Cylinder temps which reduces cylinder pressures. This allows you to retune your car for higher HP. If you don't retune your car you will experience a slight increase in HP and then you'll experience the dreaded fuel cut.
You didn't mention whether or not you have modified your engine, or are running increased boost pressure. Spraying your intercoolers or adding water/meth injection will not result in a signifcant increase your HP unless you make other modifcations and/or retune with a piggyback or stand alone. For this reason I don't agree with Steve that the stock ECU wins every time. It's great up to 14.5lbs of boost. Above this level you need a piggyback or risk other unpleasant results (fuel cut, detonation). If you're going above 16-17lbs of boost or are going to use larger injectors/turbos, it won't matter whether you use your MAF or speed density, and in reality, at higher boost levels speed density is better because you'll remove the MAF restriction.
If you decide to go the route of spaying the intercoolers, let us know how it worked out.
Good Luck,
Paul
blindmist
11-20-2010, 05:38 PM
Stock ECU wins every time.
Steve
Oh God. Not again. Just like the stock FPR is all you will ever need right?
How many stock ECU's are in the 9's?
aaronatstate
11-20-2010, 07:10 PM
Oh God. Not again. Just like the stock FPR is all you will ever need right?
How many stock ECU's are in the 9's?
One. And he's actually in the 8's. That being said, Speed Density is better :) Which is why we are trying to figure out how to make the flashable ECUs able to do it :)
mb7050
11-20-2010, 07:29 PM
how about make the stock ecu able to read the values from those late model ls mafs you can find them 4" and thatīll flow enough for 1000hp+ (draw through) and they have iat and baro built in...
http://www.ls1tech.com/forums/attachments/lsx-parts-sale/201571d1255557981-tsp-100mm-maf-tsp-100mm-maf.jpg
aaronatstate
11-20-2010, 10:52 PM
how about make the stock ecu able to read the values from those late model ls mafs you can find them 4" and thatīll flow enough for 1000hp+ (draw through) and they have iat and baro built in...
http://www.ls1tech.com/forums/attachments/lsx-parts-sale/201571d1255557981-tsp-100mm-maf-tsp-100mm-maf.jpg
Should be fairly simple. Just a matter of changing the code around to read GM Maf values instead of the Karman values. I'll talk with Brett and Jeff about it. :)
aaronatstate
11-20-2010, 11:01 PM
No dice with the GM Maf. Uses a different setup (hot wire) to measure airflow, and a 0-5V signal. It's not compatible.
blindmist
11-21-2010, 03:43 AM
One. And he's actually in the 8's. That being said, Speed Density is better :) Which is why we are trying to figure out how to make the flashable ECUs able to do it :)
Is there a place I can go to to fully wrap my head around speed density and how it works? I am wanting to end up SD with my EMU, but I want a full understanding of what is happening so that I can tune accordingly.
3000GT MR
11-21-2010, 09:39 AM
i have a 12" fan on the back of my IC in series with my rad fans. so all 3 turn on at the same time. It actually performs better than expected. Makes the AC colder too. It also aids in cooling the radiator because its moving alot more air threw the condenser. I have actual number reading in a thread on the other site ill post over hear some time. It dropped intake air to around 10-20 degrees above ambient.
And yes you still need a IC with meth/water injection. why wouldnt you want to cool the air before you cool it even more? And speed density doesnt care about it. Im surprised you dont have 10 stock IC because they are reliable and can find them in a junkyard
aaronatstate
11-21-2010, 10:31 AM
Is there a place I can go to to fully wrap my head around speed density and how it works? I am wanting to end up SD with my EMU, but I want a full understanding of what is happening so that I can tune accordingly.
I have little to no idea how to tune speed density. I just know that it uses air intake temperature and manifold pressure to calculate airflow.
KeithMac
11-21-2010, 10:41 AM
It does if you're using speed density, that's the one major drawback of speed density, it only guesses at the air mass, injecting anything cold totally screws it up, unlike using a stock ECU. Stock ECU wins every time.
Steve
I run a Supercharged Golf on Megasquirt in SD and straight water had no effect on the reultant AFR`s.
I prefer our MAS over Speed Density for daily driving, but if you want to wring every last horsepower out then SD is the way to go.
cjbyron
11-21-2010, 12:50 PM
I use speed density on all my 3000's with AEM EMS. But it really depends on your own needs and how you want your car setup. Each has it's benefits IMO.
I use water injection and tune for it above ~17psi. But the injection system (I use the aquamist style) can also easily be tapped and used as your source for intercooler sprayers. As for nozzles - just use the same kind as with the systems themselves. I use an HKS Fan Controller and it has a "spray" feature built into it. That controls the tap from the injection system pump and can initiate spray automatically. Just remember that for SMIC split the lines so they are even (same length). So sure, you can easily use water injection parts for a sprayer.
I can read my SMIC input and ouput temps inside the car. I've ended up never needing the sprayers. It was a nice idea when I had it all apart and installed it but the reality turned out that it was unneccessary. I never use it. As for SMIC getting heat soaked in traffic - I never noticed that myself but if they did they'd cool off pretty quickly once the car is moving. Not putting out a lot (nil) while in traffic so there's no heat soak sitting in traffic. Yes there is less cooling at the intercoolers but you're input temps are also much lower in slow traffic. End result is: not a problem. So, that's my experience.
Or if you have a FMIC and really want to cool it, put in a liquid CO2 system by DEI :)
mb3000
11-21-2010, 01:41 PM
I use speed density on all my 3000's with AEM EMS. But it really depends on your own needs and how you want your car setup. Each has it's benefits IMO.
I use water injection and tune for it above ~17psi. But the injection system (I use the aquamist style) can also easily be tapped and used as your source for intercooler sprayers. As for nozzles - just use the same kind as with the systems themselves. I use an HKS Fan Controller and it has a "spray" feature built into it. That controls the tap from the injection system pump and can initiate spray automatically. Just remember that for SMIC split the lines so they are even (same length). So sure, you can easily use water injection parts for a sprayer.
I can read my SMIC input and ouput temps inside the car. I've ended up never needing the sprayers. It was a nice idea when I had it all apart and installed it but the reality turned out that it was unneccessary. I never use it. As for SMIC getting heat soaked in traffic - I never noticed that myself but if they did they'd cool off pretty quickly once the car is moving. Not putting out a lot (nil) while in traffic so there's no heat soak sitting in traffic. Yes there is less cooling at the intercoolers but you're input temps are also much lower in slow traffic. End result is: not a problem. So, that's my experience.
Or if you have a FMIC and really want to cool it, put in a liquid CO2 system by DEI :)
Some people report actually loosing horespower after installing this sysytem. Something about the sprayed CO2 going back into the engine bay and then into the intake of the engine, starving the engine of oxygen. I would reccomend using Nitrous Oxide if anything at all if you choose to go this route. You can use everything the same just fill up the tank with N20 instead of C02.
cjbyron
11-21-2010, 02:06 PM
Some people is sorta like "they say". That is just talk rather than actual field experience IMO. Or someone not understanding it's application (more likely). If you're intake is directly in the way then that is plausible only in theory. However, you do not sit there with it flowing CO2 for any extended amount of time. It is a fairly quick shot and it's then dissipates quickly. The purpose is to cool down prior to a run. You hit it for a few seconds to supercool the IC. Done. It is not flowing when you are wanting to make HP. Also - if there was a problem of it being sucked in via your intake then you would have the same problem with using nitrous. Which would, in theory again, also present you with some real problems. I'd rather suck in a lot of CO2 than untuned for N2O...even if just for price, lol. But in reality this does not occur.
It's not a DD or average user add on by any means. But if you have the need and want to seriously cool down the IC it works very well. Better than anything else.
Theories aside, I use a DEI Cryo system and there's no problems at all. Works damned good. 2 seconds on the button and the FMIC quickly cools down like a MF'r. None enters the air intake to the degree of any noticeable change.
If you want to read more or ask the mfg's directly, check out DEI. Nice folks, good quality stuff, I've done a lot of business with them.
http://www.designengineering.com/category/catalog/cryo2-system-components/cryo2-intercooler-sprayer-kit
Powered by vBulletin® Version 4.2.3 Copyright © 2026 vBulletin Solutions, Inc. All rights reserved.