PDA

View Full Version : Final word on FWD clutches that dont SUCK!



x2percentmilk
11-07-2010, 12:37 AM
I lovveed my ACT clutch (street disc + extreme pressure plate) before it completely locked up (without opening her up im assuming its my own fault using a bad release bearing). I think I had a spec 6 puck in before, didnt like it for DDing and it only lasted a year.

Im about to purchase another one, im in debt + broke, and just want to buy this once.

Do I buy another ACT? stealthee seems to love his but goes through them like candy on halloween (i think he has the maxx extreme pressure plate though).

I've heard horror stories across the board. I find it hard to believe that there is no clutch for our cars that will last more than a year and will take me around an autocross course every other weekened. Is there anything that is proven?

R/T93
11-07-2010, 01:05 AM
I have had good luck with my SPEC clutches, but others definately have not.

I raced the piss out of a Stage 2 for 30k miles with slicks until it started slipping from just wearing out. I bought a Stage 3+ and it is a very nice clutch, but I only have about 15k miles on it so I dont know what kind of mileage I am going to get out of it.

Everyone seems to like the southbend clutches, though.

91stealthrt2
11-07-2010, 01:17 AM
I loved my southbend TZ. Lasted me 80k miles with street and lots of autox use, and a few drag events.

x2percentmilk
11-07-2010, 01:37 AM
yeah, the specs seem like hit or miss. i was looking into the tz but im worried about clatter, how is it for a dd?

DocWalt
11-07-2010, 02:16 AM
ACT has kinda gone in the toilet. My friend blew up two of them less than two months apart. One older (a year or so) and one brand new. Driving to work in light traffic. The first one tore a hole in the trans, the second one just broke the bellhousing. Both times, the failure was a pressure plate finger. They offered to replace the broken parts in his trans, but still, they used to never have issues.

x2percentmilk
11-07-2010, 02:22 AM
Yeah, i'm completely locked up right now and I do nothing but DD the car...sucks that it happened 30+ miles from home. I can drive it but shifting is out of the question, gotta start in gear and pray nothing breaks.

Mike-92RT
11-07-2010, 02:53 AM
i use the Exedy oem replacement clutch. Works like a charm for me. Of course, i dont drive it only 4-5 months out of the year, since i live in canada. But its a good clutch.

PS: i drove the shit out of my car, red lined it almost every gear in 2007 (i know i know)... clutch held fine :)

Jeremy C
11-07-2010, 03:10 AM
I loved my southbend TZ. Lasted me 80k miles with street and lots of autox use, and a few drag events.

+1

TZ in my FWD TT. Put it in at about 104K. Still in the car at 165K. Pulled it for inspection at about 160K to check wear and it still had the fuzzy looking surface from when I put it in; in other words, it looked brand new still. It's handled the power FAR better than my trans itself has. About the ONLY issue I have is that I put a lightweight flywheel on at the same time, so launching is a little tricky, but I don't think that's really an issue with the clutch. When I have to replace the clutch in my SVT Focus, SBC will be getting my business.

x2percentmilk
11-07-2010, 03:11 AM
I was just looking at the OFE, but consdering how it held your TT power i guess ill be placing an order for the TZ :) IPS seems to have the best price I can find on it.

Thanks guys, just saved me 150 bucks and a bunch of headaches.

Jeremy C
11-07-2010, 03:15 AM
before ordering through a 3rd party, call SBC direct and tell them you're part of 3Si (yeah, I know, I know). That generally gets you the best price period (like $200 off my Focus clutch when I priced it IIRC)

x2percentmilk
11-07-2010, 03:19 AM
Good call, thank you.

TUFFTR
11-07-2010, 03:40 AM
Exedy sports TUFF clutch (HD) with about 10,000km's on it and held up great so far. great for DD'ing and held up with 200HP at the treads for ages now.

GordonRamsey
11-07-2010, 06:01 PM
About the ONLY issue I have is that I put a lightweight flywheel on at the same time, so launching is a little tricky

Explain this?

DocWalt
11-07-2010, 06:02 PM
Lightweight flywheels don't have enough momentum to make launching easy. It's much easier to bog or stall with a lightweight flywheel.

stealthee
11-07-2010, 07:00 PM
Lightweight flywheels don't have enough momentum to make launching easy. It's much easier to bog or stall with a lightweight flywheel.

This. More weight equals more momentum. Revs may raise faster, but in turn they also fall faster.

Maximal
11-07-2010, 07:08 PM
Surprised to hear some bad things about ACT. I beat on my 2600 Street Disc and it lasted 5 years before I it started slipping (this was with running 13's and 12's on a FWD).

I would have gone with an ACT in the TT transmission I put in if they weren't so expensive.

As for the lightweight flywheel, if I was building a drag car I wouldn't touch a lightweight flywheel again...probably the worst drag mod I did to my car. However, now that I'm more into the road course I love it. Just depends on what you're doing with your car. If you're not launching regularly it's a great mod.

stealthee
11-07-2010, 07:18 PM
My only issue with my ACT is it keeps pushing the center of the clutch out. I've popped several springs in the last 2 years. Annoying is not even the word for it. Thats why I went with a shitty OEM style clutch kit. No one has an explanation to why I have so many drivetrain issues.

Jeremy C
11-07-2010, 08:11 PM
Lightweight flywheels don't have enough momentum to make launching easy. It's much easier to bog or stall with a lightweight flywheel.

Yep. And with the TZ engagement takes a little to get used to. SBC uses more aggressive disk, with less clamping force for the pressure plate. The car is soooo easy to drive without having your left leg grow larger than your right, but the clutch is pretty much on/off without any give for slip. So learning to drive the car with the new clutch AND flywheel at the same time made for some embarrassing situation. Once you get used to it, though, you won't think twice of it. I've driven my car less than 3 miles in the past year, and each time I hop in the car I have zero issue with driving it. Anyone else get in and try to drive it, though, and they are stalling guaranteed.

x2percentmilk
11-07-2010, 09:23 PM
Surprised to hear some bad things about ACT.
I really suprised im considering elsewhere for a clutch. I honestly loved the thing, let me spin my tires all day long if I wanted and still felt smooth as butter in traffic. Ill know more once I open her up over the next day or two to see what really failed. Plus right now ~300 dollars sounds better than 460.

Chris@Rvengeperformance
11-08-2010, 03:19 PM
love my act clutch on my AWD at least.

x2percentmilk
11-08-2010, 11:51 PM
Theyre not kidding when they say use the recommended release bearing...pressure plate had a completely broken finger and half of the others were bent. I attribute it to my own fault and not ACT's, but for moneys sake im still going to give south bend a shot. Can anyone confirm wether or not the TZ (for fwd really) chatters when in traffic?

stealthee
11-09-2010, 12:07 AM
Im not sure what the TZ is, but stick with a full face clutch for daily driver duty.

x2percentmilk
11-09-2010, 12:11 AM
Its a wierd design, but is full face.