PDA

View Full Version : I think my water pump is going bad.



blindmist
10-20-2010, 06:21 PM
I am going to try and get some video of it, but I am pretty sure my water pump is going bad. But this is the first time that I have heard a water pump knock. Here is the thing. It sounds ALMOST like a lifter, and ALMOST like a rod. I put a stethoscope on it and the loudest is right on the water pump, and thats where it sounds like it is coming from externally as well. I am getting 0 knock on the logs even under hard pulls, and I have ran it lean and gotten 12 counts before so I know the sensor is good. When it first started happening, I thought I barely heard an exhaust leak.

Talk amongst yourselves.

Bluejediz
10-21-2010, 01:45 AM
My water pump recently went out. I started hearing a growling sound from my timing covers. Within 2 days the pump locked up and melted my belt. Im very lucky it didnt break or jump so if yours is going out I would NOT drive it...especially doing any hard pulls.

When I took my covers of I could see metal shavings from the bearings right under the pump!

terrets
10-21-2010, 04:27 AM
Thats odd man....Is your water pump new? Shoulda got a new one :)

blindmist
10-21-2010, 04:30 AM
Thats odd man....Is your water pump new? Shoulda got a new one :)

It was semi new. had almost 8,000 miles on it.

terrets
10-21-2010, 04:35 AM
Well thats odd. You never dropped it or anything, correct?

blindmist
10-21-2010, 07:05 AM
Well thats odd. You never dropped it or anything, correct?


Who knows, it sat around for a year.

terrets
10-22-2010, 02:49 AM
oh :/

blindmist
10-22-2010, 06:34 AM
But seriously, has anyone heard a water pump knock before?

green-lantern
10-22-2010, 07:24 AM
I’ve never heard one knock. Not saying it can’t but I’ve just never heard one do it. A video would help if you get a chance to take it. If you rev it up to about 3-4 grand does it get quieter?

terrets
10-24-2010, 12:24 AM
That does not sound good o.O

CoopKill
10-24-2010, 01:17 AM
Yes, but not always does it happen to create such drastic results.

Mine did start to sound similar to what you describe. It sat for 3 yrs before I bought it with 8k on a 60k. 3 weeks into owner ship the sound appeared.

The pump froze at 55mph the idler self destructed, the tensioner followed. The crank teeth stripped the belt smooth. I assumed carnage, but valves and pistons survived unscathed!

http://lh5.ggpht.com/_dcIEIvS3Pfc/Susdg5qywXI/AAAAAAAAI-Q/UY8jM0gdcj8/s720/Timing%20belt%20002.JPG

http://lh3.ggpht.com/_dcIEIvS3Pfc/SusdhD6jfoI/AAAAAAAAI-U/cgZIUi2u-QA/s720/Timing%20belt%20004.JPG

http://lh6.ggpht.com/_dcIEIvS3Pfc/Su4VfrpFBAI/AAAAAAAAI_U/mz5aG1Xl_wE/s720/DSC_5421.JPG

Luck, maybe! I would definitely figure it out before finding out the hard way though...

blindmist
10-24-2010, 02:32 AM
I just hope to get the pin back in my tensioner to save myself another $75. I am replacing the pump next weekend when I get some money in.

terrets
10-24-2010, 03:10 AM
If you need a new tensioner, I have one with ~8k miles on it...You should be able to get the pin in using a vice :)

blindmist
10-24-2010, 07:32 AM
If you need a new tensioner, I have one with ~8k miles on it...You should be able to get the pin in using a vice :)

Hopefully I can get the pin in before pulling the belt off.

terrets
10-24-2010, 03:14 PM
Hah good luck.

stealthee
10-24-2010, 03:33 PM
Waterpumps often go bad because the headgasket has already failed, there's an increase in pressure in the cooling system, that makes the pump seal fail, water gets into the pump bearings, it seizes, the cambelt melts, 24 bent valves.

Steve

I think you're smoking the good shit again.

Water pumps fail due to age and usually the bearings failing. If a headgasket were bad, he'd know it.

blindmist
10-24-2010, 03:57 PM
I think you're smoking the good shit again.

Water pumps fail due to age and usually the bearings failing. If a headgasket were bad, he'd know it.

I was gunna say, I compression checked it at 155psi. No water in the exhaust and it doesn't spray out of the thermostat when the cap is off and I am cranking the engine.

stealthee
10-24-2010, 04:34 PM
The knocking you are hearing sounds like it could be a timing belt slap from a possible failing tensioner.

blindmist
10-24-2010, 05:39 PM
The knocking you are hearing sounds like it could be a timing belt slap from a possible failing tensioner.

This is something I am going to check. But if that were the case, shouldn't I hear it more on the front exhaust cam than on the water pump? I mean the water pump is LOUD with a stethoscope, and the cams are fairly quite, even on the cam caps, not the valve cover.

Also, I have turned it on and off several times to get the motor in different positions, even turning it backwards slowly by hand and forwards as well. I don't ever see any excessive slack in the belt. I also have had a tensioner fail completely and some how caught it before it messed anything up and it doesn't sound like this, but then again, if it is starting to fail, it could sound different.

stealthee
10-24-2010, 05:46 PM
You dont ever want to tun the engine backwards. You are almost guaranteed to make it jump time like that.

blindmist
10-24-2010, 05:51 PM
You dont ever want to tun the engine backwards. You are almost guaranteed to make it jump time like that.

I've done it probably a 1000 times, you just have to be slow. I have never jumped time from turning an engine backwards slowly. I am not saying it can't happen, but I have never had it happen to me.

Steve '92ES
10-24-2010, 09:35 PM
I've got to agree with Stealthee on this. Not only is turning the engine backwards dangerous but its pointless as well. When you turn the crank clockwise it pulls the belt down from the fixed idler pulley and rear exhaust cam allowing the tensioner to maintain it's normal position. When you go counter-clockwise you pull the belt against the tensioner pulley which then pushes in against the tensioner, collapsing it. Even if you did find the belt loose after rotating backwards all that would mean is that you pushed in the tensioner. The only real way to test this is to rotate the engine around a couple of times (CLOCKWISE!), reset to TDC, and measure the protrusion of the tensioner.

blindmist
10-24-2010, 09:39 PM
Most kids wouldn't have a clue.

The first sign is the overflow bottle being low.
The second sign is the first popped hose.
The third sign is running hotter than normal and increased topping up needed.

A compression test doesn't work.
The junk yard here is full of 6Gs with melted cambelts, bent valves and rusty looking cooling systems.

Steve

Let me put it like this, I have about 7 years experience working on these cars. I have seen just about everything go wrong on these that can go wrong, including a transfer case lock up on me @90MPH.

My coolant levels haven't changed a single bit, besides moving from the res to the main system and vise versa. Compression check is higher than a normal engine, this is because of 8.5:1 and about 1300 miles on the engine. No water comes out of the main system with the cap off when cranking, or running the engine until it gets to temp. My temp stays just under halfway, as it has for the almost 5 years I have owned the car. No leaks, no pressure besides what should be there from hot water, no coolant in the exhaust. I highly doubt it is a head gasket issue.

blindmist
10-24-2010, 09:42 PM
I've got to agree with Stealthee on this. Not only is turning the engine backwards dangerous but its pointless as well. When you turn the crank clockwise it pulls the belt down from the fixed idler pulley and rear exhaust cam allowing the tensioner to maintain it's normal position. When you go counter-clockwise you pull the belt against the tensioner pulley which then pushes in against the tensioner, collapsing it. Even if you did find the belt loose after rotating backwards all that would mean is that you pushed in the tensioner. The only real way to test this is to rotate the engine around a couple of times (CLOCKWISE!), reset to TDC, and measure the protrusion of the tensioner.

I am not saying it isn't safe, but I trust my knowledge and my skills to do safe things on cars. I would never recommend a normal person to do this. You can do what you want to, and I'll do what I want to. Regardless, there is 0 slack. This still doesn't mean there wont be slack under a load in first gear when the engine is really torquing.

Steve '92ES
10-24-2010, 10:04 PM
Oh I know, and I'm not trying to pick a fight, but you've got to remember "normal people" read these posts too. Plenty of folks have gotten into trouble turning the engine backwards and you wouldn't want some one to try it because Blindmist has done it "a 1000 times".. Besides you've got to expect some push back when you go against conventional wisdom. :)
Like this:
This still doesn't mean there wont be slack under a load in first gear when the engine is really torquing.
Conventional wisdom would say that engine torque has little to do with t-belt tension. The amount of force working on the belt would be whatever it takes to turn the pulleys. Increasing speed might increase the load on the belt, as it takes more force to move things faster, but how hard the engine is pushing (against the vehicle's weight) has nothing to do with it ;)

blindmist
10-24-2010, 10:23 PM
Oh I know, and I'm not trying to pick a fight, but you've got to remember "normal people" read these posts too. Plenty of folks have gotten into trouble turning the engine backwards and you wouldn't want some one to try it because Blindmist has done it "a 1000 times".. Besides you've got to expect some push back when you go against conventional wisdom. :)
Like this:
Conventional wisdom would say that engine torque has little to do with t-belt tension. The amount of force working on the belt would be whatever it takes to turn the pulleys. Increasing speed might increase the load on the belt, as it takes more force to move things faster, but how hard the engine is pushing (against the vehicle's weight) has nothing to do with it ;)

I, sir, love your rebuttal. You need to further comment on the Legalization of Cannabis thread.

Anyway, I was more referring to the torque from the crank gear on the belt. I know there is more pressure on a belt. I am just not sure how much an if it would make a difference. Although, I am fairly certain the tensioner is good because it IS brand spanking new and I had the engine on a stand for a long time and checked it over and over. Like I said, I have had one fail, I wanted 0 chance on this build. BUT STILL, there is no 100% guarantee that the tensioner isn't the problem until I really get down and dirty with it.

Steve '92ES
10-24-2010, 10:38 PM
You need to further comment on the Legalization of Cannabis thread.
Comment further? I don't believe I've commented at all in that thread. If I had it would be to point out that anything I can grow in my backyard is just God's little gift to me...

stealthee
10-24-2010, 11:03 PM
Most kids wouldn't have a clue.

The first sign is the overflow bottle being low.
The second sign is the first popped hose.
The third sign is running hotter than normal and increased topping up needed.

A compression test doesn't work.
The junk yard here is full of 6Gs with melted cambelts, bent valves and rusty looking cooling systems.

Steve

I've seen several blown headgaskets and not once has a blown headgasket caused a failed water pump. A failed water pump can cause overheating issues though.

blindmist
10-24-2010, 11:07 PM
Comment further? I don't believe I've commented at all in that thread. If I had it would be to point out that anything I can grow in my backyard is just God's little gift to me...

I meant more alone the lines of Comment further in the Legalization thread, sorry. I just like the way you argue!

Steve '92ES
10-25-2010, 02:49 AM
I just like the way you argue!
Funny, it just pisses my girlfriend off...:boobs: :argue: :Slap:

blindmist
10-28-2010, 06:09 PM
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D9c5KRvZSoA

Here is the video with some ok audio. I know it sounds like lifters, but I have put the stethoscope on the cam caps and it isn't that loud. Especially compared to the water pump bracket.