PDA

View Full Version : Setting bearing preload (F5M33)



stealthee
05-15-2017, 10:20 PM
In my previous disassemblies of some of my transmissions one thing I never did was measure bearing preload. I am getting ready to tear two transmissions apart to make one good one and this is one thing I want to do this time. The FSM kind of jumps all over the place when it describes doing this so it leaves me in utter confusion.

Anyone who has ever done this willing to give me a simpler step by step? Or point me to where I can find an easier to understand one? Google has me chasing my tail too.

Thanks in advance.

RealMcCoy
05-16-2017, 12:54 PM
It's time consuming no matter what you do, but worth it... I do it a couple different ways. If I'm pretty sure I'm already pretty close, I'll just use 2-3 sets of feeler gauges at the flanges to measure the clearance. If I have no idea where to start, I use the solder method. Just replace each shim with some short pieces of rosin core solder and torque the housings. pull it apart, measure the thickness it crushed to, and add the desired pre-load to that number to get your shim thickness.

There's years of knowledge on that trans over in the DSM forums...

stealthee
05-16-2017, 01:28 PM
Thanks Larry. I'll continue to do more searching on it too.

Chris@Rvengeperformance
05-16-2017, 01:48 PM
My experience is only with Getrags. I use the solder method and as Larry said I verify with feeler gauges. One issue I have with the solder method is sometimes the bearing race must get cocked a little as the solder is crushed unevenly. I either average the two readings or try again.

I think optimally you'd make some setup bearing races. Grind the OD enough if almost falls in and out. Then do the solder method and you can be sure that its working right. You then would need to be careful that the weight of the shafts is not pressing against the solder. I have never found swapping just a bearing to make any difference in the pre-load, so using a different setup race won't hurt. They are all ground to ridiculous precision.

Another good test to make sure you are close is to try to turn the shaft or part. The shafts should be able to turn by hand if you try hard enough, but it seems like on the front diff it needs to be tight enough to really strain to turn it by hand. I usually use two axle stubs to turn it and it should take just a little effort to turn with both stubs in the same direction.

On the getrag I do what I can with the end case off, so I can easily reach in to turn the parts. On the counter shaft you can't do this. When its all together I turn the trans by the input shaft and output shaft. If the trans is setup right its very hard to turn by the output shaft in a forward gear by hand. I have an old spool I use to save the fingers or prevent needing channel locks.

I have found quite a variance with how various transmissions have "felt" before being built. I've never seen any burned up bearings, just scratches or putting from rust from sitting sometimes. I don't think its quite as particular as you may think. Obviously I try my best, but it doesn't keep me up at night. If there is "some" pre-load and the shafts aren't locked up they seem to live just fine. If you can set a shaft to spinning and it doesn't stop almost instantly its too loose.

Beau_Jester
06-04-2017, 08:56 AM
I have a specially shaved set of new bearing races that I had made specifically for this purpose on the F5M33. The sides were professionally sanded at a machine shop so they can slide in and out of the bearing race cavity in the transmission case and still maintain proper preload position. I then used the solder method to measure preload. After the preload is measured you install the proper size shims and the races that came with your new bearings (only works with new case bearings). When you are ready, I can loan them to you, but I would absolutely want them back in a couple of weeks. They cost me the price of new bearing sets plus $150 at the machine shop. I also have a Starrett micrometer to measure the crushed solder that I can loan you. I would just need you to cover postage with insurance.

stealthee
06-09-2017, 09:07 PM
Sorry I haven't responded sooner. I initially read this on my phone on my break at work and never got to respond.

I'll take you up on the special races though. I'll PM you my address and you can PM me your PayPal and the amount you need for shipping.

My bearings are on order and should be here by Wednesday. As soon as my trans is assembled and good to go I will send them right back. Your generosity is much appreciated.

stealthee
06-09-2017, 09:16 PM
My experience is only with Getrags. I use the solder method and as Larry said I verify with feeler gauges. One issue I have with the solder method is sometimes the bearing race must get cocked a little as the solder is crushed unevenly. I either average the two readings or try again.

I think optimally you'd make some setup bearing races. Grind the OD enough if almost falls in and out. Then do the solder method and you can be sure that its working right. You then would need to be careful that the weight of the shafts is not pressing against the solder. I have never found swapping just a bearing to make any difference in the pre-load, so using a different setup race won't hurt. They are all ground to ridiculous precision.

Another good test to make sure you are close is to try to turn the shaft or part. The shafts should be able to turn by hand if you try hard enough, but it seems like on the front diff it needs to be tight enough to really strain to turn it by hand. I usually use two axle stubs to turn it and it should take just a little effort to turn with both stubs in the same direction.

On the getrag I do what I can with the end case off, so I can easily reach in to turn the parts. On the counter shaft you can't do this. When its all together I turn the trans by the input shaft and output shaft. If the trans is setup right its very hard to turn by the output shaft in a forward gear by hand. I have an old spool I use to save the fingers or prevent needing channel locks.

I have found quite a variance with how various transmissions have "felt" before being built. I've never seen any burned up bearings, just scratches or putting from rust from sitting sometimes. I don't think its quite as particular as you may think. Obviously I try my best, but it doesn't keep me up at night. If there is "some" pre-load and the shafts aren't locked up they seem to live just fine. If you can set a shaft to spinning and it doesn't stop almost instantly its too loose.


Chris your post is much appreciated. Thank you for taking the time to write it out.

I am just swapping bearings, but I am also swapping the gearset into a different case. Either way, I'd rather take the extra time to check the preload since I am spending so much money anyway. I've got the bearings all removed and the gearsets and diff are sitting there ready for the new ones. Well I got all the inner races off but the damn input shaft. I actually removed all the bearings on the "junk" set of gears yesterday as "practice" so I didn't eff up the good shafts. The input shaft fought me on that set too, but I got it off after letting things cool.

I didn't want to fight it too much on the good one and the shaft may have been a little hot so I said eff and called it a day.

I probably need to go through my tote of junk transmission parts and gather all the shims I can find to go with the two sets I have at the shop so I make sure I have the right thickness for everything. Once I have an assembled trans I am actually going to junk a bunch of parts I have had sitting around for years from all of the trans I have trashed and the trashed ones I accumulated. LOL

Beau_Jester
06-10-2017, 03:11 AM
Okay. That will work out fine. I will check to see what the cheapest USPS flat rate box they will fit into Saturday morning. I haven't received the pm with your address, yet. It might be easier if you just sent me a text. I will pm you me cell number.

stealthee
07-03-2017, 01:50 PM
I ran into a few issues along the way, but the trans is assembled and today I want to get the preload set. I have read the manual's procedure on this countless times and it still leaves me confused.

I think part of the issue is it is the manual for all Mitsubishi transmissions so the procedure is all over the place. I just looked up and found the manual specific for 3s FWD transmissions and want to make sure I am understanding it correctly. I use .063 solder for all 4 bearings right? Once I crush the solder I measure the solder and install a spacer of thickness as close to the solder as I can get? Actually, as I read it I want the input shaft to be tight, having no endplay so if I measure .0490 for the input shaft, I can install the .0492 spacer and be golden? Or am I thinking backwards and that would be too tight?

For the intermediate, output, and diff preloads I see it needs to be between .05-.10 mm, so that means I need some play. If I measure .0296 I could put in a .0291 and be right in spec?

Sorry for what may be dumb questions, but I want to make sure I am doing it right. I want to get this done so I can get Dave back the races he loaned me.

RealMcCoy
07-03-2017, 02:35 PM
Clearance is "play", preload is the opposite... The factory ran the input shaft loose, most builders preload it a bit. The more preload you run, the more you're working the bearings and making heat. It's a compromise to how much you plan to beat on the trans. The harder you plan to work it, the more preload you're going to want. The example you used for the diff is backward. You would want to put in a thicker shim to get preload.

stealthee
07-03-2017, 03:00 PM
Okay, now that I look at it I see what you mean. I may run the input shaft a little tight since I have experienced so many trans problems over the years. It can't hurt at this point.

I measured around about .047" on the crushed solder for the diff. That means I need a spacer of around .049" to .051" to meet the proper preload of .002-.004"?

Can I stack spacers if I don't have the right thickness on hand? Or is that a bad idea?

RealMcCoy
07-03-2017, 04:44 PM
Stacking is no problem... The only thing I don't like to do if I can avoid it, is using shims that are extremely thin and could wad up if a race spins. For example .025+.020 is better than .040+.005

stealthee
07-03-2017, 04:54 PM
Right.

Well race spinning is one of the problems I am running into at the moment. A few of the races Dave sent me are a little too loose in my case and keep falling off before I can get the case seated. The solder is falling out in the process and I just lost a piece in one of the roller bearings. It literally fell between two rollers as I was trying to snag it.

I assume it is soft enough that it won't cause any harm?

I'm getting really frustrated at this thing. Every time I think I have it going on good it gets stuck on the shift rails and I have to give it a tap which makes the races fall out, which makes the solder fall out. If it keeps fighting me I am going to throw the damn thing across the yard.

RealMcCoy
07-03-2017, 05:50 PM
Falling out is much better than having to break out the puller to swap shims... a little grease will usually hold them in pretty well while you assemble it.

stealthee
07-03-2017, 07:00 PM
I didn't even think about grease. I think the lack of thought process is coming down to exhaustion as well as frustration.

Regardless I got some measurements.

input 1.02mm (.040")
output 1.27mm (.050")
intermediate 0.95mm (.0375")
differential 1.21mm (.0470")

I think I am going to take my measurements one more time to be sure. As you can see I didn't get much crush out of the output shaft so I want to just verify all my numbers are correct. Assuming they are correct I should run the following:

input 1.01 (.0398) shim to get a tight fit for endplay
output 1.34 (.0527)
intermediate 1.04 (.0409)
differential 1.28 (.0504)

Technically the FSM doesn't list a shim that thick for the diff, but I could use an output shaft shim if my measurements are indeed correct.

stealthee
07-03-2017, 08:20 PM
After redoing my measurements, and using grease to hold the damn races :p I got some new readings

input 1.07mm (.0420)
output .95mm (.0375")
intermediate .89mm (.0350")
differential 1.01mm (.040")

As you can see the measurements are a little different than what I first got, but this time the solder seemed to be much more consistent in thickness.

Based on these measurements it looks like my shims should be

input 1.07 (.0421) for no free play or 1.04 (.0409) for .03 of free play
output 1.01 (.0398)
intermediate 0.98 (.0386)
differential 1.07 (.0421) or a 1.10 (.0433)

Please let me know if my numbers look okay.

Thanks for all the help guys.

RealMcCoy
07-03-2017, 11:48 PM
Looks like you got it worked out... Personally I wouldn't be afraid of a little more preload, but as long as it's in spec, I don't think they're all that fussy. Are they new bearings or good used bearings? I usually give new bearings a couple thou more preload than used...

stealthee
07-04-2017, 12:01 AM
All new bearings. If you recommend a little more preload then I'll go that route. I'll probably have to order shims, but that's not a big deal.

In the morning I'll do the math and look at the list of shims and figure out what I should go with.

Thanks again Larry. You're the man as usual.

stealthee
07-04-2017, 09:59 AM
input 1.07 (.0421) Gives me little to no free play
output 1.07 (.0421) Gives me .12mm (.0046") preload
intermediate 1.01 (.0398) Gives me .12mm (.0048") preload
differential 1.13 (.0445) Gives me .12mm (.0045") preload

If that looks better to you on fresh bearings then looks like I will need: (2) MD720945, MD724149, MD700270