View Full Version : Main Bearing Failure Analysis
Alex3000gt
04-25-2017, 01:25 PM
Here's a presentation I put together for a class I took this semester. There's a few assumptions listed that make for this analysis not being completely linked with reality, but there are still some conclusions that I thought you guys might be interested in. Namely, that the bottom two holes on the main bearing are terrible from the standpoint of bearing wear and load capacity.
https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B9qufj3OWuZhX0VwNUFpMWczYmc/view?usp=sharing
Chris@Rvengeperformance
04-25-2017, 01:38 PM
really cool. Are you going to modify your bearings? Its crazy that going up .001 of clearance would cause leakage to increase by 1.6 times. Would this has an equivalent effect on hot idle oil pressure?
DocWalt
04-25-2017, 01:42 PM
Nice work, Alex. Interesting that the extra oil holes do exactly the opposite of the intention.
I noticed you didn't take into account the "lost" flow to feed the rod bearings. Seems pretty relevant to the discussion.
Alex3000gt
04-25-2017, 02:36 PM
really cool. Are you going to modify your bearings? Its crazy that going up .001 of clearance would cause leakage to increase by 1.6 times. Would this has an equivalent effect on hot idle oil pressure?
Thanks! While I've convinced myself that the bottom oiling holes are bad for the bearings' load carrying capacity, I'm still hesitant on experimenting on my own motor because I'm sure there are variables I didn't take into account. Implementing this would be pretty cool though. I'm thinking that one would have to weld shut the oiling holes on the bottom-half of the girdle, and replace the lower half OE journal bearings with a same-sized replacement which didn't have holes.
There's a lot of assumptions that went into this that aren't realistic:
-like the peak load on the bearing is actually much, much higher and isn't constant (varies with cylinder pressure)
-density and viscosity of the oil are dependent on temperature
-there's actually regions of the bearing that the oil "boils" since the pressure drops below the vapor pressure
That said, the oil pump is a positive displacement style, which means that the pump is going to flow about the same amount of oil at a given RPM, regardless of the flow resistance in the system. What this means is that oil pressure is a function of your flow resistance. If your main bearings are bleeding oil, then at a given RPM and given oil pump flow, you'll have lower oil pressure.
Nice work, Alex. Interesting that the extra oil holes do exactly the opposite of the intention.
I noticed you didn't take into account the "lost" flow to feed the rod bearings. Seems pretty relevant to the discussion.
Thanks! This course was a lot of fun, Navier-Stokes used to be all greek to me, so it was cool to finally start to understand it.
You're completely right about making a bullet point for lost flow to the rod bearings, I plan on speaking to that during my presentation, but definitely should have written it down too.
anyonebutme
04-25-2017, 09:47 PM
There's an issue I see, not sure if it's me not reading your paper correctly, looks like you have all the holes as oil feed holes. The holes at 11 and 1 are not oil feed holes, oil leaves those holes to be shot into the bottom of the piston to cool the piston, the 2 lower holes on the mains do not feed the bearing either. Those holes have something to do with the dynamics of feeding the crank oil as the channel ends and the crank hole passes into the solid section of bearing, they may not be necessary but they do not bleed oil out so therefore don't impact the amount of oil supporting the crank. Mains are fed only through 1 hole each, then the oil moves into the crank via crank holes to feed the rod bearings, which have a hole to feed the wrist pin. I don't see calculations on the rod bearings, but if you do you need to account for the fact they are loaded in both directions while the crank can be calculated as being loading constantly down. I also don't see calculations for off-axis crank, but unsure if it matters at this scale. At #1 and #4 main bearing, the crank isn't actually parallel to the bearing under load which changes the lost flow.
Best bet would be to compare blocking off the squirter holes to stock, but then would need to calculate how much oil flow they suck out in operation. They have a valve that is supposed to be closed at low RPM so they don't effect idle pressures BTW.
CoreyB
04-25-2017, 09:54 PM
Good information here.
Alex3000gt
04-26-2017, 03:57 PM
There's an issue I see, not sure if it's me not reading your paper correctly, looks like you have all the holes as oil feed holes. The holes at 11 and 1 are not oil feed holes, oil leaves those holes to be shot into the bottom of the piston to cool the piston, the 2 lower holes on the mains do not feed the bearing either. Those holes have something to do with the dynamics of feeding the crank oil as the channel ends and the crank hole passes into the solid section of bearing, they may not be necessary but they do not bleed oil out so therefore don't impact the amount of oil supporting the crank. Mains are fed only through 1 hole each, then the oil moves into the crank via crank holes to feed the rod bearings, which have a hole to feed the wrist pin. I don't see calculations on the rod bearings, but if you do you need to account for the fact they are loaded in both directions while the crank can be calculated as being loading constantly down. I also don't see calculations for off-axis crank, but unsure if it matters at this scale. At #1 and #4 main bearing, the crank isn't actually parallel to the bearing under load which changes the lost flow.
Best bet would be to compare blocking off the squirter holes to stock, but then would need to calculate how much oil flow they suck out in operation. They have a valve that is supposed to be closed at low RPM so they don't effect idle pressures BTW.
Really appreciate the feedback. Do you have any more info on those valves, like opening pressure? It'd be super easy to add that feature into boundary conditions for the code I wrote.
It looks like those bottom two holes on the main bearing might connect back to eachother. I could see this feature as maybe helping prevent localized cavitation on the low pressure side of the journal, but the cost is reduced/disturbed hydrodynamic pressure buildup on the leading edge.
Good information here.
Thanks! It was a tough semester, but this project was a lot of fun.
anyonebutme
04-26-2017, 04:04 PM
Opening pressure for the squirters is supposed to be 28psi. I never measured the outlet so I can't help with their flow calculations. I personally don't think the require that much flow from the system, as the na blocks don't have them and they don't make appreciably more oil pressure, maybe a few psi/rpm.
Alex3000gt
05-02-2017, 04:10 PM
Opening pressure for the squirters is supposed to be 28psi. I never measured the outlet so I can't help with their flow calculations. I personally don't think the require that much flow from the system, as the na blocks don't have them and they don't make appreciably more oil pressure, maybe a few psi/rpm.
Thanks for the input.
I re-ran the model with the bottom holes "closed" and allowing for oil to leave via the squirters. The squirters mess up the pressure build-up in a big way, leading to thinner oil films, leading to increased main bearing wear and more side-leakage of oil. These things really should be fed directly off of the oil pump.
It's no wonder the NA motors last longer, their main bearings do not have these poorly executed oil squirters.
Powered by vBulletin® Version 4.2.3 Copyright © 2026 vBulletin Solutions, Inc. All rights reserved.