PDA

View Full Version : So if the oil pickup fell of while driving...



TUFFTR
10-11-2010, 06:44 AM
After the drag races the oil light came on after driving through a puddle, thought it was the puddle! when in fact it was actually in fact my oil pickup tube. I thought the puddle had whacked the sensor out. Drove the car maybe 100m with pickup not attached (so i found out later)

Turns out when i put the pickup on the first time, i didnt use threadlocker or use the right torque settings. NFI what i smoking when i did that.

Didn't see any bearing material when i dropped the oil....filled it up, put the bolts back in PROPERLY and I've done about 200k's on it, no knocks, sounds, anything, drives like normal.

I'll be saving up for some new heads this year, for next year....but....after200k's is it still possible for one to spin? I mean, drives fine and everything....but is it possible I've done irreversible damage?

I mean what's done is done. Can't do much now. pretty pissed in myself really.
Hmmm...opinions?! Crank should of at least been spinning in 5L of oil so I dont think it's done damage.....

kywhitelightning
10-11-2010, 09:33 AM
The only way to truely know is to cut open your oil filter that was on the car at the time of the mishap. You said the oil in the bottom of the pan was clean and debris free, so as long as the filter is the same you should have nothing to worry about beyond normal bearing wear/milage. That is one great thing about using synthetic oil, it stays a lot longer than conventional oil. Not sure if you saw the old Castrol Syntec oil commercials or not, but that test was with engines running with the oil drained at WOT.

Jeff

green-lantern
10-11-2010, 10:22 AM
I don't see how the engine didn't blow up almost immediately. If the pickup fell down into the pan then you shouldn't have had any pressure at all.

Austin@STM
10-11-2010, 11:49 AM
Whats done is done. The only way to know for sure is to take it all apart and look. Its up to you whether you go that far, or just change your oil and carry on like nothing ever happened,

TUFFTR
10-11-2010, 06:55 PM
I don't see how the engine didn't blow up almost immediately. If the pickup fell down into the pan then you shouldn't have had any pressure at all.
I knew I typed this in a rush. I should clear it up, the 2 bolts for the pickup, well, one fell off into the bottom of the pan, the other one had about a turn left before the whole thing dropped off. so it didnt come completely off,....I should of said that..
I run Penrite Semi-syn 15w-60 in both my DOHC motor's and yeah, no complaints at all.

Austin - well thats it......even if my bearings were cactus wouldn't i need the crank polished at a minimum? which either way i want to look at it a full engine rebuild.

green-lantern
10-11-2010, 07:35 PM
I knew I typed this in a rush. I should clear it up, the 2 bolts for the pickup, well, one fell off into the bottom of the pan, the other one had about a turn left before the whole thing dropped off. so it didnt come completely off,....I should of said that..
I run Penrite Semi-syn 15w-60 in both my DOHC motor's and yeah, no complaints at all.

Austin - well thats it......even if my bearings were cactus wouldn't i need the crank polished at a minimum? which either way i want to look at it a full engine rebuild.

Ahh OK, At the least cut the filter open and check for bearing material or pull the pan and inspect the bearings.

edit: well I assume you have the pan off already because you know about the tube so yeah I guess I'd check the the bearings.

TUFFTR
10-12-2010, 12:09 AM
Ahh OK, At the least cut the filter open and check for bearing material or pull the pan and inspect the bearings.

edit: well I assume you have the pan off already because you know about the tube so yeah I guess I'd check the the bearings.

Mmmm....I had it all off....put it all back together though.....is it safe to just reaplce bearings even if the crank looks fine? or is this a shortcut of sorts?

kywhitelightning
10-12-2010, 02:54 AM
I think you're fine. It seems to me like you are looking for a concious clearer and the only way for it to be totally off your mind would be to inspect everything. No particle in the bottom of your pan when you had it off for the pickup installation tells me that it should be fine. Nothing wrong with checking though.

Jeff

terrets
10-12-2010, 02:57 AM
Mmmm....I had it all off....put it all back together though.....is it safe to just reaplce bearings even if the crank looks fine? or is this a shortcut of sorts?

Its a risky short cut....I developed a rod knock due to low oil the day I bought the car....I replaced just the bearings...It still knocks slightly and I will garantee that my crank is SHOT....I would not suggest this unless you can NOT afford to pull the crank now....

I don't see why you would have to replace the bearings if you hear no knock and they look/feel alright...Someone else might have a different opinion though.

Ive got to agree with kywhitelightning. ^

TUFFTR
10-12-2010, 03:30 AM
I have a spare (yeah a spare lol) 6G74 DOHC sitting on the stand which spun a bearing. Now that I've scored this P/T job during uni I am having bad bad thoughts! (to do it up lol)

I just started this thread to gauge opinions....If everyone said "dude, your an idiot, your motor will be fucked" then fair enough, I know what I'm in for kinda thing. but yeah, no knock at all at any RPM.

Better then what My mate did to his 72' DOHC anyway....dropped the oil....realized he parked in front of his other car, when he realized he forgot the oil at my house, so instead of pouring the oil back in to the motor, he started the motor up WITH NO OIL AT ALL and backed it out of the driveway and parked it on the street. To this day I give him shit lol.

Thanks dudes anyway. Just good to hear some clarification.

terrets
10-12-2010, 04:03 AM
I have a spare (yeah a spare lol) 6G74 DOHC sitting on the stand which spun a bearing. Now that I've scored this P/T job during uni I am having bad bad thoughts! (to do it up lol)

I just started this thread to gauge opinions....If everyone said "dude, your an idiot, your motor will be fucked" then fair enough, I know what I'm in for kinda thing. but yeah, no knock at all at any RPM.

Better then what My mate did to his 72' DOHC anyway....dropped the oil....realized he parked in front of his other car, when he realized he forgot the oil at my house, so instead of pouring the oil back in to the motor, he started the motor up WITH NO OIL AT ALL and backed it out of the driveway and parked it on the street. To this day I give him shit lol.

Thanks dudes anyway. Just good to hear some clarification.

AHAHA it ran??? When I was 16 I forgot to put oil in my Talon and tried starting it...it turned over twice and then stopped. Put oil in and it was fine lol.

TUFFTR
10-12-2010, 06:28 AM
Steve, This I made sure of, the time it was under load it was MINIMAL, I mean i was pretty much slipping the clutch on purpose to make sure it was under as leas tload as possible. When it was in 1st gear it was at 1500RPM max. I was thinking it was electrical at the time as it happened after i went through a big puddle, but knew not to take the chance and drive ULTRA carefully.

anyone know where i can get a 6g75 crank from anyway?:P

green-lantern
10-12-2010, 08:51 AM
Honestly if I had the car back together now I'd probably just run it. I would cut that filter open though. If I found bearing material then I would think about changing the mains.

OhioSpyderman
10-12-2010, 09:11 AM
I only see ONE (1) "material"..... time for a vacation?

Bob. :)

terrets
10-13-2010, 03:10 AM
Bob. Two of your kids have VR4's. :lol: Thats so awesome that 3s runs in the family! Must be in your DNA. :)

Ondonti
10-19-2010, 02:40 PM
I am guessing the gasket was still sticking to the pump and the pickup so it never actually detached?

If you run low on oil, the rods go before the mains every time.

green-lantern
10-19-2010, 05:59 PM
At home running fire fox it doesn't seem to do it (repeat word). I'm going to try something else tomorrow at work.

MaxClass
12-19-2010, 08:28 PM
OK, once again a post with problems and absolutely no indication of the model or type of engine involved. Still, sorry to hear of the oil problem.

After reading your post I immediately made a big note on a Post-it for myself. My rebuild [600hp] engine is still on the stand but the oil pan has not been attached as of yet. I work around aircraft [helicopters] 5 days a week and every nut and bolt has holes through the head for SAFETY WIRE. This makes it virtually impossible for those nuts or bolts to back themselves off.

BOTTOM LINE:

Before I attach the pan the oil pickup bolts will be replaced with bolts that can be safety wired in place with stainless steel wire.
[Make sure that the wire pulls in the direction of torque with one wire for both bolts going around the pickup tube.]

Such a cheap fix for total peace of mind that your problem will never visit me.

I suggest that everyone with their pan off do the same thing. This is not the first time this horror story has been told BUT it should be the last.

You have all been warned.

TUFFTR
12-20-2010, 01:59 AM
OK, once again a post with problems and absolutely no indication of the model or type of engine involved. Still, sorry to hear of the oil problem.

After reading your post I immediately made a big note on a Post-it for myself. My rebuild [600hp] engine is still on the stand but the oil pan has not been attached as of yet. I work around aircraft [helicopters] 5 days a week and every nut and bolt has holes through the head for SAFETY WIRE. This makes it virtually impossible for those nuts or bolts to back themselves off.

BOTTOM LINE:

Before I attach the pan the oil pickup bolts will be replaced with bolts that can be safety wired in place with stainless steel wire.
[Make sure that the wire pulls in the direction of torque with one wire for both bolts going around the pickup tube.]

Such a cheap fix for total peace of mind that your problem will never visit me.

I suggest that everyone with their pan off do the same thing. This is not the first time this horror story has been told BUT it should be the last.

You have all been warned.

Without wanting to be rude, I'm on a website where there are 2 engines being used. Both have 4 cams and 24 valves. one differ in size by half a litre and is not a stock item, so take a stab in the dark at which engine I am thinking of, either way, the torque settings for both of them are the same, so it shouldn't matter which engine I'm referring too...

Also, This was MY fault. I didn't use threadlocker and I did them up at the wrong torque, no-one to blame here but myself. The problem is now fixed and I shouldn't ever have to deal with this again. I am very lucky my engine still runs as smooth as ever as a rebuild is something I don't have the motivation right now to go through with.

May I ask what the wire is going to do? I mean, They use it on old school falcons through the tie rod ends and ball joints (instead of split pins) but that's a different setup. I Can't visualize how drilling a hole through the top of the bolt and threading wire through it is going to do anything besides run the risk of the wire coming out and fooking your engine up.

kywhitelightning
12-20-2010, 06:58 PM
While I agree with you totally TUFFTR, the wire he is referring to is used to hold the fasteners in place after they are torqued. The idea is that when the fasteners are "tied together" and one tries to back out it will attempt to tighten the other fastener keeping both in place until the wire is cut or untwisted. The odds of safety wire breaking are actually pretty astronomical because its only purpose is to keep the fasteners from backing out. They have no function for torquing nor for keeping parts together(that's the fasteners job).

Jeff

MaxClass
12-21-2010, 08:05 PM
Sorry, I didn't mean to be rude but I see so many posts where the poster asks about a problem without ever describing the engine the problem is connected to. As NA's and TT's have lots of differences it's hard to formulate a response with that information. Yes, I realize the oil pickup tubes are most probably the same so it shouldn't have mattered in this case.

Safety wire is stainless steel, very strong and used to make sure fasteners that should never come loose don't fall out even if they did. All aircraft engines us it. Makes be feel better when I have to fly too.

Here is a great example that I found online that will answer any questions you might have on proper use of safety wire how and why.

http://www2.tech.purdue.edu/at/courses/at308/Technical_Links/Ac43-13-1B/CH7_7.pdf

Once you see it you will totally understand why I mentioned it and how it works to keep things in place. Jeff said it correctly.