PDA

View Full Version : Firefighters looking for compensation before putting out a house fire



MADMarc
10-08-2010, 02:00 AM
whoah

http://news.yahoo.com/s/yblog_upshot/20101005/pl_yblog_upshot/rural-tennessee-fire-sparks-conservative-ideological-debate

Austin@STM
10-08-2010, 02:19 AM
That SUCKS!!!, It would really piss me off if firefighters came and watched my house burn down. I understand the reasoning but still you gotta have some heart.

Hammer
10-08-2010, 02:28 AM
Wait til they have another wild fire in California. If the state cuts the firemen's retirement and wages they might just stand around and watch homes burn as well. It would be there way of identifing their worth to the state of California and its people. Sports people get paid ungodly wages for playing a game. So I could very well understand this if it happened.

Rah
10-08-2010, 12:01 PM
Firefighter here.

I wish I knew more about the size and compositions of these departments. I am on a rural fire department and a suburban and the differences are night and day. For one, the small budget FD has an annual operating budget less than the wage of a single fulltime firefighter. When fuel costs were high we had to ask ourselves if we wanted to be invited to help at fires outside of our city when an all day operation meant $1,000 worth of Diesel fuel alone. Now compared to my other department with an annual operating budget of $1.3million they can be called to assist and not even notice. However if they were to be given sole responsibility for coverage in a city that is not their own the price would be extreme.

It sounds like in this case they setup this $75 a year to cover when your house does burn sounds more like an insurance policy. This gained them coverage from another city at a price.

The first fire departments in the US of A were insurance company run. If your house burnt down you had a mark on your front door stating you were covered and that corresponding fire dept came running. If the neighbor wasn't covered or was covered by someone else they wouldn't touch it. Not far removed from that in this story.

j2k4
10-08-2010, 12:09 PM
Sports people get paid ungodly wages for playing a game.

Then perhaps firemen should charger admission while they perform in order to qualify as 'entertainment'.

It's not the same thing, and to make the comparison signals a very basic mis-understanding of how things work.

Should you get LeBron money to do your job?

CoreyB
10-08-2010, 12:31 PM
Punishment doesnt fit the crime. The should have put the fire out and charge him full cost to do so. The person in charge should be fired immediatly.

DocWalt
10-08-2010, 12:36 PM
Isn't this illegal in a lot of states? I'm too lazy/busy to check myself.

i3igpete
10-08-2010, 01:08 PM
quick notes:

-FD doesn't cover his county, they cover the next one over. they provide optional service to the unprotected town for a fee.
-the two counties together are 1200 sq. miles
-the FD consists of two trucks total
-responding to an unpaid house is considered off duty. if someone gets hurt insurance won't cover the lawsuit.

CoreyB
10-08-2010, 01:16 PM
In responce to your first three notes, the FD went to the residence and watched.

91stealthrt2
10-08-2010, 01:24 PM
Yeah, when I read the story I was thinking how similar they are running their area like OLD Fire system. Like Rah said, you had to have a plaque on your home of which Fire company you paid to be covered and only they would put the fire out, even if another showed up first.

I grew up in a small town(population 2000 or so) and the FD was mostly volunteer. Not only did the only bar in town that was right NEXT to the FD burn down, but my next door neighbor's home did as well (2 blocks away from the FD) before they were able to arrive and do much. There was quite a few others as well.

Sometimes having a little higher taxes may not be a bad thing people!!

I really feel bad for the guy, but he knew that he could have been paying 75 a year, and choose not to. 75 a year is a lot cheaper than insurance(which I hope he had)

i3igpete
10-08-2010, 01:37 PM
news from the homefront (buddy's parents live in the next town)


it was a double wide trailer and the fire started in the grass

they had plenty of time to get the pets out
they called 911 before the house caught on fire
and it was a dbl wide trailor

I asked him why they didn't just back the truck up to it and pull it down the street
he laughed

Dad said it wasn the first time they have let a house burn either

personally i hope there are charges of cruelty to animals, arson, and insurance fraud brought to this guy.

Macky
10-08-2010, 01:46 PM
a bit off topic but one thing Id like to point out though, the FD here in my county seem to put their nose into all sorts of business, even when they technically arent needed. and they charge regardless too.

case in point, when my brother broke his arm, we called the paramedics. paramedics arrived (it was a private firm) but then moments later the FD came, fire truck and all, and the county paramedics too. I was like WTF? so besides being charged by the responding paramedics, the county paramedics charged us too (my brother wasnt covered by insurance at the time) and so did the county FD. and for what? that pissed me off. its almost they're itching to go out and do something.

sorry about the rant.

CoreyB
10-08-2010, 01:58 PM
news from the homefront (buddy's parents live in the next town)



personally i hope there are charges of cruelty to animals, arson, and insurance fraud brought to this guy.


Just to clarify, are you saying the guy who just lost his home should have these charges brought on him or the fire chief ?

NickS VR4
10-08-2010, 03:52 PM
Being a volunteer firefighter, I know we would run in and help, but it seems in this case the firefighters probably had their hands tied. Since there is an existing policy, if the firefighters went in, knowing they were not supposed to cover that house because of policy, they probably would not be covered by insurance. Say a firefighter gets hurt fighting that fire, the insurance company probably would not pay.

Its a crappy situation, but its a CYA (Cover your a**) type situation.

i3igpete
10-08-2010, 04:17 PM
Just to clarify, are you saying the guy who just lost his home should have these charges brought on him or the fire chief ?

the guy who lost his home. the fire was intentionally started by his grandson, he failed to pay for fire protection, they (guy AND grandson) intentionally left the animals in the house to die when they had plenty of time to save them.

Rah
10-08-2010, 05:19 PM
It also bears saying trailer homes burn FAST and are incredibly dangerous.

Not that it's an excuse but when it sounds like they watched it burn from beginning to end I'm sure it was a complete loss in a very short period of time.

There comes a point in any fire if big enough where it goes defensive any way. Not to say this was or was not the case but it a place is fully involved and nothing much will be salvageable the operation goes defensive and protects what we call 'exposures', i.e. the structures next to it.

To give you an idea of how it ranks, this is the priority scale:
Rescue
Exposures
Confine
Extinguish
Overhaul

MADMarc
10-08-2010, 05:29 PM
Very nice. Seemed to spark a bit of a thread here. So many responses...so little time.

Quick VR-4
10-08-2010, 05:46 PM
In responce to your first three notes, the FD went to the residence and watched.

You are mistaken. The FD did not respond to watch so they could laugh and point fingers. The neighbor had paid for protection so the FD was there to protect his property as the fire was spreading towards his place.

Is it sad...yes. Could it have been avoided if the cheap ass would have paid his $75...yes. What do you think would happen if they put fires out for everyone and then collect the $75 at the time of the fire? I am sure the majority of this rural FD's budget consist of these payments. If word got out they would put fires out regardless if you paid or not, what do you think their budget would drop to? What you are suggesting is similar to only paying for insurance when you had a wreck...how would that work?

HilbillyHomeboy
10-08-2010, 05:55 PM
Is it sad...yes. Could it have been avoided if the cheap ass would have paid his $75...yes. What do you think would happen if they put fires out for everyone and then collect the $75 at the time of the fire? I am sure the majority of this rural FD's budget consist of these payments. If word got out they would put fires out regardless if you paid or not, what do you think their budget would drop to? What you are suggesting is similar to only paying for insurance when you had a wreck...how would that work?

This.

Jeremy

ictponder
10-08-2010, 06:04 PM
I agree with the decision to let it burn down. Maybe this will be a lesson to everyone else thinking they can cheapskate the system.

91stealthrt2
10-08-2010, 06:07 PM
You are mistaken. The FD did not respond to watch so they could laugh and point fingers. The neighbor had paid for protection so the FD was there to protect his property as the fire was spreading towards his place.

Is it sad...yes. Could it have been avoided if the cheap ass would have paid his $75...yes. What do you think would happen if they put fires out for everyone and then collect the $75 at the time of the fire? I am sure the majority of this rural FD's budget consist of these payments. If word got out they would put fires out regardless if you paid or not, what do you think their budget would drop to? What you are suggesting is similar to only paying for insurance when you had a wreck...how would that work?

Exactly... PAY YOUR TAXES or INSURANCE.

This reminds me of a local restaurant/brewery that didn't pay their taxes. So what the county did was revoke their liquor license. Of course that was going to hurt their business. It sucks because they are now out of business and they had the best pulled pork I've ever had.

If you don't drive with car insurance and get caught your fine is over $600, which is probably much cheaper to just buy your policy.

CoreyB
10-08-2010, 08:42 PM
I still say you put the fire out, and you then bill the guy for the full cost to due so. If he doesn't pay then its just like non payment of taxes and they take his house. What the chief chose to do his heartless and wrong. I read that this guy has paid the fee for the past 20 years and hadn't yet paid this year, he supposedly was not refusing to pay, just hadn't yet.
Lesson learned is simple, pay your fee or you will owe the $20k or so it costs to put your house out.

NickS VR4
10-08-2010, 10:10 PM
The $75 is probably more than made up for in your home owners insurance too compared to no fire dept coverage.

MightyMouse
10-09-2010, 10:14 AM
Maybe they should make a fire department bill where the departments have to help even if the home owner didn't pay some form of fire insurance. This way, people with pre-existing home fires can sign up for the insurance while the house is burning..

MightyMouse
10-09-2010, 10:26 AM
Here's the thing that I find even more entertaining. The comments section you have people talking about the firefighters "moral obligation" to take care of the burning house, yet no one speaks of the neighbors moral obligation to help extinguish the fire before it got to the house or anything of the sort.
There is no moral obligation. There's a fee that has to be paid and that's that.. It'd be the same thing as someone signing up for auto insurance after their car is wrecked... Not really fair to people who maintain insurance at all times now is it?

beepbeep
10-09-2010, 10:52 AM
I read that this guy has paid the fee for the past 20 years and hadn't yet paid this year, he supposedly was not refusing to pay, just hadn't yet.


I saw him on the news and the comment he made was that he knew there was a yearly fee, but he didn't pay it and figured the fire department would still put out the fire, if it ever happened.
Fire department was in the right. Home owner was in the wrong. Sucks, but that's the way it is.