PDA

View Full Version : Classified Verification Overkill



cjbyron
09-11-2010, 01:20 PM
1) Make a post with your full name, birth date, address and phone number.
2) Attach an image of your drivers license and a bill that shows your address.
3) Once the administration reviews your post your access to the classifieds forums will be granted

Seriously? On a frickin car forum? Reads like a business agreement. So it's also "When dealing with someone that you do not know please remember, "Caveat emptor" Let the buyer beware" on top of it.

Would like to be able to post some things for sale but honestly am NOT posting an image of drv's license and a bill. That is just too much personal info for posting on a car forum.

If the forum itself as an entity take zero responsibility then this is total overkill.

DCIV
09-11-2010, 01:23 PM
you know how many problems 3si had with scamming? Everyone wants to buy something with a good price so quickly they dont get to actually talk to the person or even search if they have had problems. I like the new classified stuff...its a lot but will cause less headaces I think.


Coop

lechnoid
09-11-2010, 01:28 PM
Instead of posting it publicly, how about getting a few trusted people to act on the community's behalf to privately verify the information.

Also, if a genuine verification is needed, do it through mail. It's too easy to photoshop stuff and post it up.

I can assure you that I won't post any of that info publicly. Aside from consumer dangers, I'm in the military and have a security clearance. If I publicly posted that info here, it would be cause for revocation of my clearance, in essence ending my military career.

Alan92RTTT
09-11-2010, 01:28 PM
Only approved mod staff(ie me) can see that forum. Posting the images proves that you are who you say you are. And they are private and available for easy reference.

IN the long run it will be faster then the 3si process.

lechnoid
09-11-2010, 01:31 PM
Could there be an alternate method used as well, such as emailing the mods instead of posting in a private section of the forums? Heightened security, FTW.

cjbyron
09-11-2010, 01:36 PM
I am quite aware of that yes. In fact probably more aware than many.

I also know that without any legit business agreement the posting of personal info is a minimum deterrent. And IMO overkill as stated. Plenty of people claim scammed anyway and this (or any other car forum) isn't going to back up anything by requiring such personal info.

I don't want to debate it. It was posted as my opinion and an educated one at that. If someone else wants to freely give out that kind of personal info on a forum in this day and age feel free. People only freak about SS# but that is not the sole thing for identity theft. IMO to give out such info online is stupid. Especially when it guarantees nothing.

ANYWAY...this section is titled suggestion box. That's my suggestion - lighten up,,,it's an internet forum. To ask for that info is, IMO, ridiculous. I'm glad to verify my email and other non-intrusive methods that are commensurate with selling online but drv's license copis, bill copies,,,,that's just waayyyyyyy over the top.

cjbyron
09-11-2010, 01:43 PM
Only approved mod staff(ie me) can see that forum. Posting the images proves that you are who you say you are. And they are private and available for easy reference.

IN the long run it will be faster then the 3si process.

I understand that but I have no assurance of that information's protection, release, etc. It is just NOT WISE to give out that sort of info in this day and age. Nothing personal at all towards you. It also proves nothing in reality since it wasn't presented in person. Plus, I am sure there are MANY people here that you "know" who they are just from their email address anyway. Lots of ways to check without such intrusive info request especially since buyers are not guaranteed anything anyway.

Hey, that's my suggestion. Nothing more, nothing less. It just seems to me a bit silly for a internet car forum to ask for that level of info.

lechnoid
09-11-2010, 01:50 PM
This is a suggestion box and I'm in brainstorming mode.....take all my thoughts, ideas, and suggestions in the context of "shoot out 100 ideas and we'll eventually find a good one" mode.

Is there a low-cost escrow service that would want to hop in bed with us? Require all forum transactions go through an escrow service and suggest a few companies that handle smaller transactions like we'd have.

Geordon
09-11-2010, 01:50 PM
I think a verifiable name, address, and phone number is acceptable. I know I always feel better when a seller gives me their phone number and address. If the site verifies these, that would be great. I have looked up numbers given to me before from Autotrader, and discovered they were hotel fax machines. Big Red Flag! I agree that drivers license and bill statement are a bit much, as they can easily be photochopped, and I doubt they can easily be verified by the site mods, which may also open them up to legal liabilities, if someone did get scammed, only to find out later the site vouched for them based on bogus information.

I think a compromise would be to allow optional secondary seller authentication, such as a confirmed ebay ID. This would allow interested buyers to check established feedback. If the ID was provided, a link would be provided by the site, if someone wanted to check it. Sure, the ebay ID could simply be included by the seller in their ad, but that would require each buyer to verify it is actually the seller's, and not just a link to a random ID.

Geordon
09-11-2010, 01:52 PM
Is there a low-cost escrow service that would want to hop in bed with us? Require all forum transactions go through an escrow service and suggest a few companies that handle smaller transactions like we'd have.

I stay away from escrow services, and am often advised against dealing with sellers who require them, as they are often alleged scams.

donnareed
09-11-2010, 02:03 PM
How about my CWP, it has my name on it?

cjbyron
09-11-2010, 02:03 PM
If someone is a scammer then they will get around these or other rules. The only ways around it would be totally foolish considering the venue here. So buyer beware applies here just like anywhere similar. Asking for more in depth info will do nothing but inconvenience the non-scammers/seller anyway. The info request exceeds reasonable levels without any added assurances at all. What's next,,,,a surcharge? Vendor fees?

When it becomes reasonable I'll verify to sell. Until then I guess I will stick to "other" forums, craigslist, ebay, and other places that do not require such levels of 'proof'.

lechnoid
09-11-2010, 02:06 PM
Many, possibly the majority, of real estate transactions involve escrow. The ones you're referring to are an escrow service recommended by the seller who is in cahoots with the seller to scam the buyer. Definitely avoid those. I'm talking about a legitimate 3rd party service. There's tons out there and they generally specialize in real estate, auto/marine, antique....whatever niche could use it. We'd just be creating another niche for them.

Alan92RTTT
09-11-2010, 02:29 PM
If you are totally against posting the images PM them to me.

Ultimate
09-11-2010, 02:38 PM
I thought the same thing as cjbyron, I personally will not "Attach an image of your drivers license and a bill that shows your address." Doesn't matter if Alan is the only one supposed to be able to see it.

It probably is a great idea to stop scamming for a large number of verified sellers. However there is no way I would give out that information over the internet to anyone ever. Just seems like too much of a serious security risk to warrant selling on here, and that is ok, I can stick to selling other places, it is not a big deal.:)

I know that everyone is bum rushing with the suggestions and want to state that I am not complaining, I am grateful that the forum is here now, no matter what the details are.

Ultimate
09-11-2010, 02:40 PM
When it becomes reasonable I'll verify to sell. Until then I guess I will stick to "other" forums, craigslist, ebay, and other places that do not require such levels of 'proof'.

Exactly.

Ultimate
09-11-2010, 02:45 PM
Instead of posting it publicly, how about getting a few trusted people to act on the community's behalf to privately verify the information.

Also, if a genuine verification is needed, do it through mail. It's too easy to photoshop stuff and post it up.

I can assure you that I won't post any of that info publicly. Aside from consumer dangers, I'm in the military and have a security clearance. If I publicly posted that info here, it would be cause for revocation of my clearance, in essence ending my military career.

Agreed, and I like the recommendation, "getting a few trusted people to act on the community's behalf to privately verify the information."

Downside: that will make probably not be efficient enough for the verification process others were complaining about the 3si process already.

brutten
09-11-2010, 03:44 PM
I guess I have to agree on this. The verification requirements do not bother me but posting them on a forum (even if hidden) that is hosted on a shared server concerns me. It would be horrible if digitized copies of drivers licenses were to end up in the wild. Is it unlikely.. yes. But it is not very difficult for a determined individual to hack a shared MySQL db.

Suggestion : Maybe some of us paid members could enjoy a relaxed policy as you already have access to our info from the PayPal transaction.

IPD
09-11-2010, 03:53 PM
i refuse to hand out personal information; it's a legitimate job-related security concern. i've NEVER had any negative feedback on any of my transactions--buyer or seller. if i can't get classified access here, that's going to really be an achilles heel for this forum.

i'll leave the decision in alan's capable hands for now; but i'm NOT some "fly by night" LMI, Midnight Haze, MyKiss69, etc.

a2j
09-11-2010, 03:53 PM
don't feel comfortable having someone else, besides admin, having my private info. a lot of sites getting hacked by ID theft criminals.

DocWalt
09-11-2010, 03:55 PM
Just to settle some nerves, Alan, can you set it up so we can wipe our posts after you verify us? That way you can grab the info you need, and then let us placate security concerns. I know I'd like that.

PsykoGamer
09-11-2010, 03:59 PM
I think with the feedback Alan is getting he will figure something else out guys. Give him a little time to figure it out as I am sure he is just getting overwhelmed with the response and buzz the new site is getting. Pretty crazy how about 500 people have registered so far lol

Intropy
09-11-2010, 04:04 PM
Just to add my feedback, I personally can say I would not sell here under these requirements. And I have about 50 successful trades on 3si.

a2j
09-11-2010, 04:19 PM
how about txt verification or something, google and craigslist do that I think.

cjbyron
09-11-2010, 04:47 PM
how about txt verification or something, google and craigslist do that I think.

That really has nothing to do with this. All that does is stop bots.

Boomer3000
09-11-2010, 04:56 PM
Hey alan ivwill be pm'ing you my info later tonight!!! And i like the new rules sounds alot safer!!

Chris GTO TT
09-11-2010, 05:09 PM
My only real concern is the Driver License Number being on the forum. I do trust Alan its the hackers I don't trust and DL # is a major part of identity theft.

Boomer3000
09-11-2010, 07:55 PM
So im guessing once your in you will have the big green box thing under your user name that says VERIFIED lol

Greg E
09-11-2010, 10:19 PM
Has there been a case of anyone's identity being stolen from 3si before? Shit, I'd be more worried about the security of the DMV database or even a car dealership before 3si.

I'd been a verified seller for so long, I had no idea 3si now required people submit a copy of their license. That's actually a great idea. This way if someone scams a member, their info can be submitted to the authorities to handle.

Show Killer
09-12-2010, 12:13 AM
I paid the $10 annual fee via PayPal and i am verified on PayPal. Also, you have my address from all my payments sent for NG's. That should be good enough verification, no?

hazards280
09-12-2010, 02:36 AM
i refuse to hand out personal information; it's a legitimate job-related security concern. i've NEVER had any negative feedback on any of my transactions--buyer or seller. if i can't get classified access here, that's going to really be an achilles heel for this forum.

i'll leave the decision in alan's capable hands for now; but i'm NOT some "fly by night" LMI, Midnight Haze, MyKiss69, etc.

Exact Same Thoughts Here.

DocWalt
09-12-2010, 02:38 AM
Just to settle some nerves, Alan, can you set it up so we can wipe our posts after you verify us? That way you can grab the info you need, and then let us placate security concerns. I know I'd like that.

Quoting myself, because this is something I want to see happen.

Alan92RTTT
09-12-2010, 02:46 AM
My goal is a system that quick and easy to verify.
Harder to get past that what the old place used.

I do understand the concerns. I will think about this see if I can come up with a reasonable quick process that will address the issues presented.

mikeyVR4
09-12-2010, 03:04 AM
Yeah I too am a bit weary to post that information online. I know I could black out the REALLY personal information. When things are deleted online, we all know that the information is just transferred to some unknown place.

I can see the point in verifying such documentation for a minimal scammer-free forum but.... I dont know.

Wildarmz
09-12-2010, 10:44 AM
IMO, the classifieds section is very important to this forum's success.

I think the key is to have multiple ways to verify. One suggestion is that we could cross-reference 3si seller feedback with our new accounts here. Sellers with X amount and X % rating are "grandfathered" in. Obviously there would have to be verification that they are the same person. That could be done via a simple PM reply on 3si and here. I, for one, think past transactions and reputation count for something. This idea takes care of a lot of our senior members.

oohnoo
09-12-2010, 11:23 AM
I also think the new way is way overboard. Not going to post personnel info even if it's private. I can post my drivers license "Image" but the Drivers ID number and my signature will be blacked out, same with a bill...ALL info besides address will be blocked out. Will this be acceptable?
Also would like to become a sponsor and asked about it in the Classified sales verification post but I never heard anything back yet

Alan92RTTT
09-12-2010, 11:51 AM
All I want from the images is the address. I have no issue if any other personal details are blanked out.

Bob, I need to get the sponsor page done so we can determine where you'll fit. (If you fall where I think you will its dirt cheap)

oohnoo
09-12-2010, 12:02 PM
Awesome...thanks for the quick reply Alan as I'm sure you got your hands full.


All I want from the images is the address. I have no issue if any other personal details are blanked out.

Bob, I need to get the sponsor page done so we can determine where you'll fit. (If you fall where I think you will its dirt cheap)

Ninja Performance
09-12-2010, 12:05 PM
All I want from the images is the address. I have no issue if any other personal details are blanked out.

Bob, I need to get the sponsor page done so we can determine where you'll fit. (If you fall where I think you will its dirt cheap)

That's a little more reasonable.

-Chris

Ninja Performance
09-12-2010, 12:17 PM
Where is the classified section? And why is it so hard to find?

-Chris

oohnoo
09-12-2010, 12:22 PM
Top of page, it's one of the tabs......SALES/SPONSORS

Ninja Performance
09-12-2010, 12:26 PM
Just fund it LOL, why not also make it a normal listed section?
Not that a tab on top is a bad idea, I kinda like that, but I found it hard to find, since I wasn't looking there for it.

-Chris

cjbyron
09-12-2010, 12:57 PM
Allowing people to buy/sell here is a two sided benefit. Making it difficult doesn't make sense IMO. Especially when asking for that information doesn't guarantee or assist anything at all. Many 'bad deals' fall into the misunderstanding catagory 90% of the time anyway. Real name and true phone number, email, mailing address should suffice for what the intention is.

An image of drv's license or anything else provides no further 'proof' than does an email. An image is so easy to manipulate/fake it is almost useless.

So what is the intention? Isn't it solely that the person is who they say they are? And if that's the case, the majority of a lot of people coming over here are already known. Aren't they?

Along similar lines I have a question about the 'sponsor' part. Namely:
"Do you sell new product? Do you make parts to sell? SO you sell used parts as a way to make money? If you do any of these things you probably need to be a sponsor. We have several sponsorship levels available that should be fair no matter the size of your business."

I can understand asking for money from a commercial retail business but this reads as if someone that is just selling something on the side, out of their garage, not as a business, has to pay money to the site to sell. Isn't this the SAME thing people complained and didn't like at 3si? Having to pay money for the 1-off parts, the sole person creating some new parts, the lifter group buy, etc. Perhaps something is different but it reads the same or is very unclear as to the requirements.

WTF?

Ninja Performance
09-12-2010, 01:52 PM
Cmon, verify me already ;)

-Chris

DocWalt
09-12-2010, 02:01 PM
Just fund it LOL, why not also make it a normal listed section?
Not that a tab on top is a bad idea, I kinda like that, but I found it hard to find, since I wasn't looking there for it.

-Chris

Greg (Monochrome) ran into the same issue yesterday. Definitely something that could be improved (that whole area is a bit compressed, and not very obvious).

fjm9898
09-12-2010, 02:53 PM
the small home seller is just who i am, and its always been a black area. right now i am not a vendor on any of the forums i currently make LED products for because i am just a guy in my garage making one off parts for a few people now and then.

i have emailed alan about this very same case for this forum. he said there is going to be a price range to become a vendor and i guess ill just have to wait and see how that turns out.

i agree the Driver license and receipts i just retarded overkill. there have to be some kind of happy medium

Ninja Performance
09-12-2010, 05:11 PM
Going on 6 hours with no Verification? What gives?
Pmd alan, no response.

-Chris

Boomer3000
09-12-2010, 08:26 PM
same here, i sent him a pm, but does anyone know how to attach photos to either a pm or the forum thing with out first having to use an online photo hosting sight??

cjbyron
09-12-2010, 08:44 PM
Must be a lot for just one person to handle or be the sole approver. Doesn't seem terribly effective to have just one person that can do any particular task. What happens if that individual is somehow incapacitated for whatever reason? Does the entire site just stop?

brutten
09-12-2010, 08:57 PM
Must be a lot for just one person to handle or be the sole approver. Doesn't seem terribly effective to have just one person that can do any particular task. What happens if that individual is somehow incapacitated for whatever reason? Does the entire site just stop?


Seriously? - The site has not even been on line for a week and the structure is still being worked out.. Don't unnecessarily rock the boat.

cjbyron
09-12-2010, 09:16 PM
IMO a perfectly fair question.
And a good time to ask is in the beginning. That's a major point of this section. At least I'd think so.

DrGonzo
09-12-2010, 09:25 PM
The largest problem with posting these images either in the post or in a PM is that they are now on the server. If chmod on that upload folder is not set correctly and the spider file is to created properly then you have a huge security risk on your hands. if a spider where to crawl the site and index that folder then all of those DL and Bill images would now be available on the web. Google caches all of there images for 24 hours which is more than enough time for that information to get out where it doesn't need to be.

Some other method needs to be established to verify members as uploading images of sensitive material is not safe!

Sorry to through a rock into the new machine Alan.

DocWalt
09-12-2010, 09:25 PM
Like I mentioned in another thread, the verification delay on 3si was way worse. I don't know how it was when you guys were getting verified, but a few months back when I finally bothered, it was terrible. No communication at all. I don't know if that was the norm, or I was an oddity because nobody felt like dealing with me, but it was unsettling.

IPD
09-12-2010, 09:44 PM
i pm'd alan. hopefully he's got what he needs. i REALLY don't want to have to continue selling shit on 3si.

stealthee
09-12-2010, 09:58 PM
The largest problem with posting these images either in the post or in a PM is that they are now on the server. If chmod on that upload folder is not set correctly and the spider file is to created properly then you have a huge security risk on your hands. if a spider where to crawl the site and index that folder then all of those DL and Bill images would now be available on the web. Google caches all of there images for 24 hours which is more than enough time for that information to get out where it doesn't need to be.

Some other method needs to be established to verify members as uploading images of sensitive material is not safe!

Sorry to through a rock into the new machine Alan.

Alan already noted all he cares about is the address. You can black out all pertinent info. He also stated if you dont want it posted (even though its hidden) to just PM him the info.

DrGonzo
09-12-2010, 10:13 PM
Alan already noted all he cares about is the address. You can black out all pertinent info. He also stated if you dont want it posted (even though its hidden) to just PM him the info.

I think he said to PM him the images not just the info! Did I miss interpret something????

Ninja Performance
09-12-2010, 10:17 PM
Cmon man, been all day now. about 11 hours. Still no verification. :(

-Chris

DocWalt
09-12-2010, 10:28 PM
Cmon man, been all day now. about 11 hours. Still no verification. :(

-Chris

http://www.msn101.com/content/emoticons/Troll_TUYLJ6.gif

stealthee
09-12-2010, 10:28 PM
I think he said to PM him the images not just the info! Did I miss interpret something????

Info = everything. ;)

TUFFTR
09-12-2010, 10:45 PM
Do what we have on another forum, Minimum post rule. You need 100 posts minimum to be able to "Sell" things but not buy.

This means no randoms can sign up and start flogging shit off, and in there posts you get an idea on weather or not they are serious about the platform, or just here to flog crap off and run away

I will not be giving personal information to anyone on the internet as i am part of another car forum, have almost 16,000K posts over 5 years and have never ripped anyone off in my life. In this day and age it's just too risky. Who knows if Alans account gets hacked into somehow and our information stolen? Hmmmm...

stealthee
09-12-2010, 10:47 PM
There were members on 3si who had several thousand posts and never ripped anyone off either, then one day got desperate and took people for thousands. With no verification process then there is no help that can be given from the forum.

Boomer3000
09-12-2010, 11:35 PM
Alan already noted all he cares about is the address. You can black out all pertinent info. He also stated if you dont want it posted (even though its hidden) to just PM him the info.

ok this is what i wanna do but cant find a way to send it with out using a url type link/ and dont want to post my private info on a pic hosting site/ am i just missing something??

stealthee
09-12-2010, 11:41 PM
Click on Alan's username and click send private message.

Geordon
09-13-2010, 12:26 AM
ok this is what i wanna do but cant find a way to send it with out using a url type link/ and dont want to post my private info on a pic hosting site/ am i just missing something??

Or you could email Alan, directly, I would think.

Alan92RTTT
09-13-2010, 12:40 AM
OK several things to address.

I was away today more than I planned. The growth of this site has outperformed expectations by and incredible factor. I told Lori at one point that I I had 100 member in 6 months I'd consider the site a success. At this rate we will his 1000 tomorrow. I was not prepared for this kind of response and I'm scrambling to catchup. Please bear with me as I get through this. Their will be more mods here so we don't have long lags like today.

Starting tonight here is my plan for the images. When I review your thread I will print the page and file the hard copy. I will then delete/remove the images from the thread. This way If their is ever an issue its on file but its not online. Is this acceptable?

mikeyVR4
09-13-2010, 12:44 AM
OK several things to address.

I was away today more than I planned. The growth of this site has outperformed expectations by and incredible factor. I told Lori at one point that I I had 100 member in 6 months I'd consider the site a success. At this rate we will his 1000 tomorrow. I was not prepared for this kind of response and I'm scrambling to catchup. Please bear with me as I get through this. Their will be more mods here so we don't have long lags like today.

Starting tonight here is my plan for the images. When I review your thread I will print the page and file the hard copy. I will then delete/remove the images from the thread. This way If their is ever an issue its on file but its not online. Is this acceptable?

Solution Idea:

Alan, do you have a fax machine? I would rather send my information via fax to you. In this procedure, you can save the faxes in file and the need for a online transaction wont be necessary and reduce the fear of hacking :).

Experience: Lean Six Sigma Silver Belt

-Mike

stealthee
09-13-2010, 12:45 AM
Thats an acceptable compromise to me Alan.

It is funny that there is such an outcry. There was a similar outcry when 3si started their verification process. While it wasn't bulletproof it helped some people get information on "bad sellers"

And on the notion of more mods, I would gladly help in that department if you would consider it Alan. As you may remember I moderate on AutomotiveForums, and am the 3spa moderator as well. I don't expect an answer any time soon, or even at all, I just thought I would throw the offer out there.

DocWalt
09-13-2010, 12:46 AM
I'm ok with that :) I'm just worried about what Gonzo mentioned.

Drweldin
09-13-2010, 12:52 AM
Can't we just transfer our verification from the other place, lol? It does seem a little overkill...I will eventually get there.

corys00
09-13-2010, 01:30 AM
Can someone please tell me what deterrent there is with this verification? I'm trying to understand how you having my address does anything to deter me from scamming?

stealthee
09-13-2010, 01:32 AM
It makes it easier to contact authorities if you do so. Internet fraud is a big no no and if your information is held by an entity, then you will think twice about screwing someone over.

awild
09-13-2010, 02:05 AM
I see major issues with posting personal identification scans online. I will flat out never use the for sale section if it comes to that. Why can't we all just use "paypal" and their security? I got hosed on a deal once and nothing ever got shipped. 10 days later after I filed an arbitration with paypal (took 10 mins), I got the money back.

PsykoGamer
09-13-2010, 02:35 AM
yeah but unfortunately Paypal doesn't always work that easily. I lost $400 on a scam from an auction website through Paypal and they refused to refund me. I wasn't the only one either. I guess this is just one of those places where everybody wants to be as careful as they can be because you really don't know who is selling you parts unless you've personally dealt with them. It's just a safety and precautionary step which I can understand. Maybe you can message him and work something else out like a fax or something.

cjbyron
09-13-2010, 02:36 AM
It makes it easier to contact authorities if you do so. Internet fraud is a big no no and if your information is held by an entity, then you will think twice about screwing someone over.

Sorry but I am going to have to disagree entirely. Having someone, a third party, claim to have proof of identity does nothing legally to any sale gone bad. Look at the scams in the past or bad selling or anything remotely related. The ID or verification did nothing to resolve anything nor have any legal standing at all. Big online talk is one thing, reality in practice is another. This is, IMO, unrealistic expectations.

The most it does is give some small amount of peace of mind (albeit false) or make it a little more difficult for people setout to scam someone. If it had any more teeth than that then there'd be no need for the disclaimer of buyer beware. Pay by paypal or credit card, that's what it's there for. The bank and/or credit card companies have the teeth. This forum or anyone on it has no teeth at all legally.

Having an address or phone number held by administration in order to maybe try some peer pressure or mediate is one thing. Expecting copies of drivers licenses or personal bills is another. In the end it will come down to the parties individually involved and their financial institution(s). Period. Having any added level of "identity verification" really does nothing to give any more power or authority here if there is a problem.

In short, it seems that members wanting to participate in classifieds are being asked to send personal information beyond what is reasonable given the situation (a car forum) while not obtaining any added guarantee or buyer/seller protection. That is a lopsided request. And people's security issues should be respected, right or wrong.

As for 3si being difficult - I do not recall that being the case (or ANY other forum I am a member, mod, or admin on). I remember filling out my address and phone number with an email verification. 'voila, done. Pretty easy.

That's how I see it. People can obviously do whatever they please. In the end, whatever is decided it can be left up to the individual if they want to participate by sending personal information like that or not. I think if left that heavy handed on verification then the classifieds will be left without quite a few sellers that would otherwise contribute positively to the section.

mikeyVR4
09-13-2010, 02:50 AM
Solution Idea:

Alan, do you have a fax machine? I would rather send my information via fax to you. In this procedure, you can save the faxes in file and the need for a online transaction wont be necessary and reduce the fear of hacking :).

Experience: Lean Six Sigma Silver Belt

-Mike

As I mentioned before. Please see my solution idea.

I can see Alan's point of view but the fear factor is still present. Don't worry guys, this is still a learning experience for all of us :).

Alan92RTTT
09-13-2010, 02:58 AM
Real scenario from 3SI.

A user is banned for scamming someone.

This user makes a new ID with an address and verifiable phone number.
Connects to 3SI via prosy server so we can't IP match.

He then pretending to be a woman scams some other people.


Having a image of your DL on file with a post from you showing your name and name/address while not 100% secure at lease gives us a change to find you if their is an issue. It is a good trail for any law enforcement agency to find you if you do something you should not do.


Don't want to post them? Fine. how about email?

cjbyron
09-13-2010, 04:03 AM
Real scenario from 3SI.

A user is banned for scamming someone.

This user makes a new ID with an address and verifiable phone number.
Connects to 3SI via prosy server so we can't IP match.
He then pretending to be a woman scams some other people.

Having a image of your DL on file with a post from you showing your name and name/address while not 100% secure at lease gives us a change to find you if their is an issue. It is a good trail for any law enforcement agency to find you if you do something you should not do.
Don't want to post them? Fine. how about email?

See that's the thing. How would any different outcome been had with your example? There wouldn't be because you would have just gotten an image of fake DL. Crooks will be crooks and this won't help. In fact isn't fake ID a real small (minute) portion of buy/sell complaints anyway?

Some are only concerned about posting such info or hacking to obtain said info. Personally I flat out will not give out such information, especially just to use the classifieds on a car forum. There's a ton of reasons and facts as to why this is a bad idea but in the interest of brevity here I will leave it at that. I'm sorry but that's how I see it and nothing personal at all should be taken from this. Giving out information of this level via the internet or to an individual carries a risk. Shit happens. And that risk is no where equal to the extremely minimul level of possible buyer protection it may provide in theory.

I'll abide by any reasonable expectations to sell on this forum. Such as: Having a verified paypal business account should easily suffice. A forum that I mod on overseas uses this method to verify. eg: email address provided, money request for $1 sent, it is paid by a verified seller account. Done. You won't get better than that on a forum classified IMO.

The point being that there are many other methods available to achieve the same degree of verification without risking peoples information that can be subject to theft or abuse if mishandled (unintentionally of course). I thought that was the reason for this section. Suggestions.

Plus there are many people on here that are already known either online for years or on a personal and/or face-to-face basis. Surely that matters.

If it requires the personal info as it stands now then I guess I am out. Not worth the risk IMO.

Thanks.

IPD
09-13-2010, 06:49 AM
Real scenario from 3SI.

A user is banned for scamming someone.

This user makes a new ID with an address and verifiable phone number.
Connects to 3SI via prosy server so we can't IP match.

He then pretending to be a woman scams some other people.


Having a image of your DL on file with a post from you showing your name and name/address while not 100% secure at lease gives us a change to find you if their is an issue. It is a good trail for any law enforcement agency to find you if you do something you should not do.


Don't want to post them? Fine. how about email?

my driver's license doesn't have my current address anyways. i pm'd you with my current address. i can probably find 6 people who will confirm that it IS my address, based on recent transactions.

lechnoid
09-13-2010, 10:15 AM
Email would be much better, Alan! The option to fax would also be wonderful.

The reason for a verified address is simple. Members make deal, deal goes bad, the wronged person files a suit in civil court. In order to file that suit, the initiating party MUST have a last known address. By requiring verification would give that address for the courts to begin the process. Also, on the chance that law enforcement would get involved, it gives somewhere for them to start.

I back the verification 100%. Just looking for a secure solution to present the information.

Keep up the great work, Alan, and don't forget to take some time for yourself.

awild
09-13-2010, 11:22 AM
There is no end all solution other than to buy only from people you know or can trust on the board. It's just like any other transaction in this world. Options that I can see "helping" and not requiring anyone to post/email/fax any personal information to sell things are:

1. Minimum post count
2. A link to a positive trader account on a different website (I have this on xceedspeed and greatlakes4x4 and ebay)
3. Requiring that every and all transaction go through a paypal link on 3SGTO. That way there is no bogus fake auction links to attempt to follow and I believe paypal has your address.
4. Explaining to every member the "buyer beware" ideology every time you click the classifieds section.

Tackhammer
09-13-2010, 12:47 PM
With those requirements i doubt ill ever be allowed to sell anything here even though i never had a single unsatisfied customer in 10 years on 3si

Atrosity
09-13-2010, 12:50 PM
It seems kinda overkill but I did it anyways.

Ninja Performance
09-13-2010, 02:02 PM
over kill, but I did it, Blanked out my lic # and was verified.

-Chris

cjbyron
09-13-2010, 02:27 PM
I provided my personal info (address, phone) but not good enough. Shows it has been viewed 5 times though.
Unfortunately it will not let me edit my post or anything. WTF?
SO, please remove my personal information, delete the post, whatever.
Thanks.

Atrosity
09-13-2010, 03:04 PM
I provided my personal info (address, phone) but not good enough. Shows it has been viewed 5 times though.
Unfortunately it will not let me edit my post or anything. WTF?
SO, please remove my personal information, delete the post, whatever.
Thanks.

Hey I did the same thing, I added a comment to the post with more information, hoping this would work.

Igovert500
09-13-2010, 03:09 PM
Can someone please tell me what deterrent there is with this verification? I'm trying to understand how you having my address does anything to deter me from scamming?

Ever seen the end of Jay & Silent Bob strike back? :D

TonyM
09-13-2010, 03:09 PM
Could a screenshot from 3Si trader rating work for those of us with 100% positive feedback over years of transacations?

I don't remember having to submit this much personal info to 3Si for my seller verification and I've never had a bad deal with anyone - 3Si, ebay, anywhere.

Tackhammer
09-13-2010, 03:37 PM
Let me clarify, its not that i dont want to provide the required info, its that i cant. I have no bills in my name and my home has 4 wheels and is propelled by a gasoline engine.

Even with these things being true, i still offer better service and faster ship times than a lot of other sellers, and if i dare say so, some sponsers

AaronVR4
09-13-2010, 03:40 PM
I agree with tony.

Plus I live in the city and my address on my DL shows my parents house in the country but i dont pay bills at my parents house so how are the addresses gonna be the same?

I also have 100% on 3Si itrader.

mikeyVR4
09-13-2010, 04:19 PM
PayPal verification should suffice. If we sent $1 to you and you can see our address on a Paypal form which is verified I think that should be enough.

Either way its not that big of a deal. I decided I wont be selling on this forum with the current protocols. I absolutely understand the safe-guards but if someone wants to scam another member they will still do it. They can send you a blacked out DL that only shows a address but how do you know its that persons drivers license? Same thing can be said with the bill. They can use someone elses DL and Bill which verifies same address but what does that do if its not the true person?

dtfromep
09-13-2010, 04:48 PM
Haven't read through all 9 pages, but why don't you make verification optional? A badge could be included on the profile indicating that SOME level of verification has happened.

Leave it to the buyer to make the decision to do business or not. In theory, verified sellers would be more likely to do business than non-verified. It would still allow those who can't, or don't want to post their personal information some options.

Alternative would be a references page with spots for ebay ID, paypal ID, etc... We could check those references instead of/in addition to the address verification.

tconrad
09-13-2010, 05:02 PM
Being a computer security engineer, there is no way I would post a picture of my driver's license on any Internet site. I wouldn't have as much problem posting a bill, as long as any sensitive information is sanitized. However, since most of my bills are paid online, I would have to supply a screen capture that could very easily be altered (same with a scanned copy, of course). I have a verified PayPal account--why not just "Sell" verifications for a reasonable amount (say $1-2) and use the PayPal verification when you receive the payment? The "fee" could be applied to site costs, etc.

--Tom

Atrosity
09-13-2010, 05:16 PM
How long does it take to be verified?

EvanH
09-13-2010, 05:29 PM
I cant see anything but my thread. I cant see anyone elses picture. However I think it is fine the way it was done to get it. But maybe apply on the Verification forum, then take care of it thru PM's and then delete it?

Paypal is a way to do it. You have to be verified on that. I like that idea.

IPD
09-13-2010, 05:34 PM
PayPal verification should suffice. If we sent $1 to you and you can see our address on a Paypal form which is verified I think that should be enough.

Either way its not that big of a deal. I decided I wont be selling on this forum with the current protocols. I absolutely understand the safe-guards but if someone wants to scam another member they will still do it. They can send you a blacked out DL that only shows a address but how do you know its that persons drivers license? Same thing can be said with the bill. They can use someone elses DL and Bill which verifies same address but what does that do if its not the true person?




same problem. my dl doesn't have my current address. i could have sent alan a screen cap of it and already been verified. instead, i pm'd him my current address--PAID FOR MEMBERSHIP (with a paypal account that has the SAME ADDRESS) and i still am not verified.

fml.

mb3000
09-13-2010, 06:09 PM
Being a computer security engineer, there is no way I would post a picture of my driver's license on any Internet site. I wouldn't have as much problem posting a bill, as long as any sensitive information is sanitized. However, since most of my bills are paid online, I would have to supply a screen capture that could very easily be altered (same with a scanned copy, of course). I have a verified PayPal account--why not just "Sell" verifications for a reasonable amount (say $1-2) and use the PayPal verification when you receive the payment? The "fee" could be applied to site costs, etc.

--Tom

^This

Phalse
09-13-2010, 06:14 PM
I'm not going to post my DL.

I'll post a utility bill or 2 from my address, but no way on the DL. Hell Mississhitty still uses our SSNs as our DL#, so.. no.

Drweldin
09-13-2010, 06:21 PM
I like the Paypal idea...since 99% of transactions will go thru them anyway, let's take advantage of their verification.
I too have a problem with the DL part. I just filled out an app. for credit and DL number was one of the things they wanted....

j2k4
09-13-2010, 06:27 PM
...and I'm not really on the radar as a seller, but I believe this site was conceived as something better in every way.

No reason this part shouldn't be better as well, right?

A little congress might go away down the road, here...what will push it forward?

Most sellers are buyers as well - start there.

Edit:

There's ^ your start - saw it too late.

stealthee
09-13-2010, 06:32 PM
People, read the thread. Alan said you can blank out everything on your DL other than your address. So no vital information is going to be out there other than your address, which was required on 3si too. This is just further and better verification.

cjbyron
09-13-2010, 08:11 PM
http://www.3sgto.org/showthread.php?390-Seller-verifications-what-do-you-want

So now there's two threads going on the same topic. Decision by poll? On personal information decision? LOL


I provided my personal info (address, phone) but not good enough. Shows it has been viewed 5 times though.
Unfortunately it will not let me edit my post or anything. WTF?
SO, please remove my personal information, delete the post, whatever.
Thanks.

Perfect example of "shit happens" regarding personal information. Now viewed 7 times and my personal info still there. Added a Post there to ask that it be removed. Nada. No reply, no removal. I still cannot even EDIT my post of personal information there. Something so many freaked about on another site. Funny.

Not a huge deal to me but it does show the very thing that myself and others have had concern over. i.e.-the handling of personal info.

I've no interest in selling here anymore. Too dramatic for a online car forum. Seriously. Maybe later when it can be done without such intrusive or lengthy methods. If not, that's fine too.

So, thanks anyway, no problems here..................over and out.......

...........Third request - PLEASE DELETE MY POST OF PERSONAL INFORMATION! In the verification section. I would gladly do it but this site will not let me.
THANKS!

Alan92RTTT
09-14-2010, 12:02 AM
OK after reading both threads and looking at the poll many want the verification and just as many seem totally opposed so how can I setup a system to take care of both groups.


I think I have a compromise. (some posted the seed for the idea I just can't find that post)

keep the current verification system but have a system that will let people that just provide name/address to get access to the classifieds. These people would have an icon indicating that they are have not been verified. This puts the decision in the buyers hands.

What do you say?

mikeyVR4
09-14-2010, 12:08 AM
OK after reading both threads and looking at the poll many want the verification and just as many seem totally opposed so how can I setup a system to take care of both groups.


I think I have a compromise. (some posted the seed for the idea I just can't find that post)

keep the current verification system but have a system that will let people that just provide name/address to get access to the classifieds. These people would have an icon indicating that they are have not been verified. This puts the decision in the buyers hands.

What do you say?

How about the one's that send their information to you via image and DL so that will say "verified" and the other option can show "Paypal Verified".

Not being negative...I just dont know why Paypal cant be a solution.

Geordon
09-14-2010, 12:09 AM
I think I have a compromise. (some posted the seed for the idea I just can't find that post)


I think I suggested a two-tier (optional full) verification, and I think this would be a good compromise, leaving the ultimate decision between the parties involved in the actual transaction. I also agree that this whole discussion is rather unfortunate, and probably has soured more than one member. Thanks for working through it with us.

mikeyVR4
09-14-2010, 12:12 AM
Fax?

As I mentioned multiple times before, why can't we just send you, Alan, a fax with a copy of our DL (real important info. blacked out) and bill. Then you can store the hard copy on your files. Eliminating the whole internet transaction entirely. But then anybody could use a persons address and bill so there is no real way to determine who is who. Also, some members have old addresses on their DL.

Paypal?

Paypal seems to be the best solution as they have already verified who we are and our Paypal accounts are tied into our bank accounts.

FlamboyantStealthTT
09-14-2010, 12:15 AM
i have no bills i have a scan of my license though is that ok?

Intropy
09-14-2010, 12:39 AM
So if I want to get verified, can I PM you my driver's license with the number blacked out and just the address visible? I'm OK with that.

Alan92RTTT
09-14-2010, 12:45 AM
I'll get setup for fax I just need some time for that.

If possible I just want two things with name and address. In the electronic age that may not be possible.

Why not paypal verification? It takes too long and the point is address verification. It does not get us contact information.

mikeyVR4
09-14-2010, 12:55 AM
I'll get setup for fax I just need some time for that.

If possible I just want two things with name and address. In the electronic age that may not be possible.

Why not paypal verification? It takes too long and the point is address verification. It does not get us contact information.

The fax option would definitely be a go for me.

GTOJOE
09-14-2010, 01:14 AM
I have already submittd using the origional setup. I'm happy as long as you delete everything and only keep a hard copy.

vr4_rider
09-14-2010, 01:22 AM
2) Attach an image of your drivers license and a bill that shows your address.

What's the purpose of the drivers license? As a member mentioned, some DLs have old addresses on it. Can we eliminate the whole DL since a bill with your name and address really serves the purpose of a DL?

Thanks,
TP

Bob
09-14-2010, 01:42 AM
OK after reading both threads and looking at the poll many want the verification and just as many seem totally opposed so how can I setup a system to take care of both groups.


I think I have a compromise. (some posted the seed for the idea I just can't find that post)

keep the current verification system but have a system that will let people that just provide name/address to get access to the classifieds. These people would have an icon indicating that they are have not been verified. This puts the decision in the buyers hands.

What do you say?


Sounds fair to me! :) This is where Caveat Emptor comes to play .

enigma9o7
09-14-2010, 01:43 AM
I haven't got a paper bill in years. My credit card bills, utilities, phone, bank statement, etc, all come online. 95% of my postal mail is junkmail.

Could you change it from bill to any piece of mail with name & address?

Bob
09-14-2010, 01:48 AM
I haven't got a paper bill in years. My credit card bills, utilities, phone, bank statement, etc, all come online. 95% of my postal mail is junkmail.

Could you change it from bill to any piece of mail with name & address?

I think he just needs a piece of mail with the address. I sent a photo of my Emissions Notice. :)

ktmryan53
09-14-2010, 02:00 AM
So someone with over a 400+ trader rating and 8 years can't be "grandfathered" in?

TwIzTeD_3kGt
09-14-2010, 03:29 AM
I'll get setup for fax I just need some time for that.

If possible I just want two things with name and address. In the electronic age that may not be possible.

Why not paypal verification? It takes too long and the point is address verification. It does not get us contact information.

Takes too long is fine with me. I'd rather it take longer than to post my documents on a forum. PayPal has address confirmation.

How about we grandfather in those who were verified on 3si? That would solve it for a lot of us here.

oohnoo
09-14-2010, 09:19 AM
I'd like to be grandfathered in but I don't think that's possible as only 3si has that information, not Alan. I also like the idea of either emailing it directly to a email address or faxing it, this way no information is stored on the server.

92RT-TT
09-14-2010, 09:53 AM
The problem with grandfathering in people from 3si, first and foremost is this is NOT 3si, so that should have no correlation with it. Thats like saying I want my Ebay feedback put on here. Would it be nice? Sure, I had 100% feedback from 36 transactions on 3si and 100% feedback from 180 transactions on ebay...

I think that in recent times 3si was pretty much verifying anyone and we already know they were letting scammers sign back on so who knows if they let them become verified again.

This is a new site so lets keep it as that, NEW!

Alan92RTTT
09-14-2010, 10:10 AM
How does the paypal verification work? I wonder if I can automate it.

92RT-TT
09-14-2010, 10:13 AM
How does the paypal verification work? I wonder if I can automate it.

Paypal verification makes two withdrawls in the persons bank acct. The person then has to see what the amounts were and type those in on paypal to become verified. Also I think if ups has delivered to your address it shows it as a valid address.

Show Killer
09-14-2010, 10:15 AM
I have already submittd using the origional setup. I'm happy as long as you delete everything and only keep a hard copy.

Same here. I submitted yesterday morning and i'm waiting patiently.

Phil

toyolet23
09-14-2010, 10:30 AM
PP doesn't work for me as I had my CC scammed 3 times in a 2 month period & my CC fraud dept traced it to PP. So I canceled my PP acct & no more problems. 2 months later it was on the news that they busted 7 people scamming CC's at PP (this happened at PP twice in a 2 yr period). I also found out PP is not Federally regulated so they can do just about anything they want (go into your checking acct-take funds-etc) without repercussion as per the contract you have with them. So I do things the old way when buying/selling=U.S. Postal Money Order sent Certified/Registered mail. Worked fine on Ebay for 8 yrs & still works great today.

cjbyron
09-14-2010, 12:06 PM
Probably safe to assume that over 90% of anyone wanting to buy/sell in classifieds has paypal. An alternative for the other 10% would also be easy.

Address verification is very possible with paypal and is a large part of being fully "verified".
The physical address must match that of the credit card or bank account billing address on file.
It's a little different than the verification to lift payout limits.
Address checking process can be automated to a degree with API. All that is on their developers site (www.x.com).
If you are a full business account customer they help you for free. Paypal has excellent customer service to get complex website solutions done.

While they are not regulated as a bank they still have to meet many federal regulations for electronic money transfer as well as a credit card and debit card company here in the US. Actually, in Europe I believe they are now recently listed/licensed as a bank. They cannot just 'do what they want', lol. In contrast to those that have had problems, I've used paypal for over 10 years, thousands of transactions, never a problem. I also find their debit card very handy to use instead of my bank debit card. Doing so limits the transactions if stolen or compromised (much like a cc) and my actual bank account that holds the higher balance is then protected. Anyway, off-topic, just a tip.

Bob
09-14-2010, 12:13 PM
Same here. I submitted yesterday morning and i'm waiting patiently.

Phil

Is your Info thread still showing on the Verification Forum? Besides the poster, Alan and the Mods are supposed to be the only ones that can view it. I posted my info thread at 9:03pm last night and the post is still there. However, it shows having 10 views! Don't know what's up with that! Pm'ed Alan with no reply. I don't feel comfortable with a photo of driver's license laying in the server for that long!

Alan92RTTT
09-14-2010, 01:08 PM
Probably safe to assume that over 90% of anyone wanting to buy/sell in classifieds has paypal. An alternative for the other 10% would also be easy.

Address verification is very possible with paypal and is a large part of being fully "verified".
The physical address must match that of the credit card or bank account billing address on file.
It's a little different than the verification to lift payout limits.
Address checking process can be automated to a degree with API. All that is on their developers site (www.x.com).
If you are a full business account customer they help you for free. Paypal has excellent customer service to get complex website solutions done.

While they are not regulated as a bank they still have to meet many federal regulations for electronic money transfer as well as a credit card and debit card company here in the US. Actually, in Europe I believe they are now recently listed/licensed as a bank. They cannot just 'do what they want', lol. In contrast to those that have had problems, I've used paypal for over 10 years, thousands of transactions, never a problem. I also find their debit card very handy to use instead of my bank debit card. Doing so limits the transactions if stolen or compromised (much like a cc) and my actual bank account that holds the higher balance is then protected. Anyway, off-topic, just a tip.
Thats what I was looking for I will look into it. It may take a bit to implement. I think I'll setup the "un-verified" option till I can setup the paypal thing.

Anyone waiting for verification I'm working long hours for the start of the week and I only do verifications from home. Please be patient. Hopefully I'll have time to run through them tonight.

tazman
09-14-2010, 01:27 PM
Same here. I submitted yesterday morning and i'm waiting patiently.

Phil

Me too...

Atrosity
09-14-2010, 02:08 PM
Me too...

Same boat! :/

toyolet23
09-14-2010, 03:06 PM
Well if you are doing the PP thing then I won't be able to buy/sell here because I will not have a PP acct again. Go to Ebay & go into the community discussion forums & click on PayPal & read some of the complaints/nightmares people are having with them. As stated earlier my CC was scammed 3 times in 2 months at PP that will not happen again. I also occasionally sell on craigslist & they do a phone verification every few months to make sure you are still at your listed phone number. You may want to think about that option for folks that don't have a PP acct.

cjbyron
09-14-2010, 03:15 PM
I've had my say regarding this level of verification for a car forum classified. I choose not to participate due to what I feel is excessive intrusion of personal info. That's my opinion and my personal decision.
I respect the forum owner/operator wishes to do whatever they think is approproriate. I hope you figure something out that is good for everyones security as well as the level of validation you seek.

With that being said, please respect MY wishes to remove/delete my posted personal information as requested.
It is apparently insufficient for this forum so please delete it since you do not accept it. I'm fine with not selling here.
This is now my 4th request and my posted data has been viewed 8 times (by who?).
You have purposely locked the edit feature. Due to this I have to request it be removed.

This lack of response just reinforces my concerns about providing in-depth personal information here.
I realize people are busy. Most of us are.
It does not alleviate the responsibility of properly handling personal information, especially when solicited or pointedly requested.

I've asked nicely now several times. I would like my request respected please.
Thanks.

GTOJOE
09-14-2010, 07:46 PM
The thread we have all posted our info into is a common thread. It's just setup in a way that means you can only see your own thread. Your thread prob counts views every time you look at it or every time Alan looks at the entire thread.

vr4_rider
09-14-2010, 07:52 PM
^^what he said.

I go to the sale verification page, and there's no thread ther...

stealthee
09-14-2010, 07:55 PM
The thread we have all posted our info into is a common thread. It's just setup in a way that means you can only see your own thread. Your thread prob counts views every time you look at it or every time Alan looks at the entire thread.

DING! No one is viewing your info but you.

cjbyron
09-14-2010, 07:59 PM
The thread we have all posted our info into is a common thread. It's just setup in a way that means you can only see your own thread. Your thread prob counts views every time you look at it or every time Alan looks at the entire thread.

I'm aware of how the forum software works but you seem to misunderstand it. And, Uhhh, no - each person posts their own thread in that category. Per the admin, only he (and/or mods?) can see new threads there plus the OP. Thread view count is specific to the individual thread not the category. My point re: view count is that my info has been seen and rejected (since no approval obtained).

No stealthee, I did not view my post 8 times. That's not the frickin point anyway. Is the overall concept too difficult to grasp?

It's become the principle pertaining to personal information vs. what was said would occur to protect said info (i.e. - remove off server once viewed/printed/copied/whatever) and especially since the edit capability of the OP has been disabled in that category.

billbrown72
09-14-2010, 08:15 PM
did everything I was supposed to do with verification process....post is now deleted by alan or somebody just waiting to hear back one way or another

IPD
09-14-2010, 08:32 PM
i don't care if i have to be "unverified". no one likes or trusts me anyways (well, except bob). it won't really make an ounce of difference.

Bob
09-14-2010, 09:33 PM
did everything I was supposed to do with verification process....post is now deleted by alan or somebody just waiting to hear back one way or another

I posted all required info (also a picture of license and a piece of mail) last night. The thread is still there....almost 24 hours later, and has had 11 views. I know that I didn't view it that many times? I just want the info hard copied/filed and the thread deleted. I guess everybody must have posted info at the same time to have such a backlog!

stealthee
09-14-2010, 09:36 PM
You guys need to make sure you are posting a phone number as well. Thats part of the required info.

cjbyron
09-14-2010, 09:49 PM
You guys need to make sure you are posting a phone number as well. Thats part of the required info.

Gee, Thanks! Awesome post. Who'd have ever thought of that.
Random guessing is sure helpful and applicable.
I guess it gets your post count up
:rolleyes:

Now if only we can get someone that has mod permissions in that category or Alan to repoly with some factual info or actions.

stealthee
09-14-2010, 09:56 PM
I could care less about my post count. Some peoples posts here indicate they ONLY posted a pic of the DL and a bill.

Besides, posts in this forum don't count toward your official post count.

IPD
09-14-2010, 10:09 PM
tell you what, if i'm not available by thread, pm, email or letter sent to my residence; you can ban me from the forum.

i'm NOT going to hand out my primary contact number. it's that way for a reason. i get recalled on that number; and i HAVE to answer it when it rings--for that reason. i'm not going to have it published for tom, dick, and harry, telemarketers, soliciters, etc. i don't care if only alan has it. i'm NOT giving my phone number out.

my continued use of 3si's classifieds is solely dependent upon my ability to sell on this forum. period.

Bob
09-14-2010, 11:11 PM
Some peoples posts here indicate they ONLY posted a pic of the DL and a bill.

The directions were pretty clear (or should have been) as to what info to provide. The "picture" posted was just of the DL and bill. The rest of the post included other typed info. :)

1) Make a post with your full name, birth date, address and phone number.
2) Attach an image of your drivers license and a bill that shows your address.

I'm probably just being over concerned for no reason. I'm sure Alan will get to me and the others when he has time. :)

Alan92RTTT
09-15-2010, 03:46 PM
I have created an option to sell without address verification. GOto your profile and join the group "not verified".

This will allow you to sell without verification.

If you choose this group you will get a red button similar to the green verified button stating you are not verified.

vr4_rider
09-15-2010, 05:15 PM
Alan, can you address my questions in regards to the photo ID?

Alan92RTTT
09-15-2010, 05:20 PM
WHat was it?

vr4_rider
09-15-2010, 06:49 PM
Oh, I was just wondering why you needed a photo of our drivers license.

Isn't a bill with our name and address enough for verifying our place of residence? I mean everything that is really of importance in selling is the name and address, not so much a picture of the seller, or the sellers DL number, etc.

I just don't feel safe having a picture and my DL number out there in the world wide web that's all.

Thanks,
TP

stealthee
09-15-2010, 07:30 PM
The DL is a second form of verification. As has been noted MANY times, you can blank out pertinent info like your DL number, etc.

vr4_rider
09-15-2010, 10:20 PM
Oh, my understanding was that it was to make sure there's a photo ID of the seller, but it's nice to know that's not the case.

tazman
09-16-2010, 12:44 PM
Still waiting to get "verified". I thought it was going to happen a couple of nights ago...

Alan92RTTT
09-16-2010, 01:49 PM
If you do not provide some proof of ID in the post, PM or email you won't get verified.

You can sell unverified if you choose(goto the verification forum for details. )

Dbeltran24
09-16-2010, 03:11 PM
What do people do that have DL address' that don't match their Bills? I'm in that boat. My DL has my parents address, but my bills come to my home. Would this technicality prevent us from being a verified seller?

tazman
09-16-2010, 03:32 PM
If you do not provide some proof of ID in the post, PM or email you won't get verified.

You can sell unverified if you choose(goto the verification forum for details. )

I filled out the required seller information when I registered (phone number, address, DOB). My trader rating on 3Si confirms that I'm legit. I'm also a Classifieds moderator on SoCal3S, and a moderator on 3S Forums. Even became a "paid" member here.

What more proof do you actually need for me to sell used parts on a car forum? At what point does reputation doesn't matter? Proof of ID can be falsified...

In the meanwhile, I joined the "Unverified" group...

stealthee
09-16-2010, 06:19 PM
This isn't 3si or some other website. When will people learn that? Hell I had a 150 trader rating with 170 positive feedback on 3si and I have 100% rating on ebay with 60 positive feedback. Alan can't go checking everyones reputation on other sites to get them verified. Whats asked for is a simple request. If you think it too difficult or don't want to post said info, then its not Alan's fault.

vr4_rider
09-16-2010, 07:02 PM
Alan, I have submitted all requirements.

Please verify me at your earliest convienence:)

Thanks,
TP

tazman
09-17-2010, 12:57 AM
This isn't 3si or some other website. When will people learn that? Hell I had a 150 trader rating with 170 positive feedback on 3si and I have 100% rating on ebay with 60 positive feedback. Alan can't go checking everyones reputation on other sites to get them verified. Whats asked for is a simple request. If you think it too difficult or don't want to post said info, then its not Alan's fault.

I see you're still bringing the same b.s. atitude from 3Si. Kids say the darnest things! Good thing we don't have a rep system here, or you'd try to neg rep me a couple of times over things that don't concern you, like you did on 3Si!

In any event, Alan created the "Unverified" group, which allows for members to post in the Sales section, without having to provide a bunch of personal information, copies of iD, etc. Thanks for that Alan! Hope this place doesn't turn into a "drama fest" so commonly seen on 3Si!

Alan92RTTT
09-17-2010, 01:37 AM
What do people do that have DL address' that don't match their Bills? I'm in that boat. My DL has my parents address, but my bills come to my home. Would this technicality prevent us from being a verified seller?

Why don't they match?

Alan92RTTT
09-17-2010, 01:39 AM
Hope this place doesn't turn into a "drama fest" so commonly seen on 3Si!

It take two for drama. If their is only one their is no drama.

Vantage
09-17-2010, 03:57 AM
Why don't they match?

For me at least in the military, my DL address is my parents house back in NY, but my bills go to my address back in Georgia..

stealthee
09-17-2010, 07:06 AM
I see you're still bringing the same b.s. atitude from 3Si. Kids say the darnest things! Good thing we don't have a rep system here, or you'd try to neg rep me a couple of times over things that don't concern you, like you did on 3Si!

In any event, Alan created the "Unverified" group, which allows for members to post in the Sales section, without having to provide a bunch of personal information, copies of iD, etc. Thanks for that Alan! Hope this place doesn't turn into a "drama fest" so commonly seen on 3Si!

I'd like to know where there is drama and attitude in my post. I posted simple facts. If you took offense to it then maybe it was because I made a point. I haven't asked for special permissions because of what I've done on other sites and neither should anyone else. Thats all I said.

Alan92RTTT
09-17-2010, 09:32 AM
For me at least in the military, my DL address is my parents house back in NY, but my bills go to my address back in Georgia..

Use your military id. (blank anything you can't share) That will prove your military and I understand that issue.

IPD
09-17-2010, 09:12 PM
probe my military?

heck, i work down the street from benson. he's actually the one who helped me figure out i have a bad wheel bearing. i fricking flew with him on a training sortie a few weeks ago. guess that's not enough though.

i'll see if i can find a scanner. $$^#$%#$ technology....

DocWalt
09-17-2010, 09:36 PM
*prove. lol

Alan92RTTT
09-17-2010, 11:55 PM
probe my military?

heck, i work down the street from benson. he's actually the one who helped me figure out i have a bad wheel bearing. i fricking flew with him on a training sortie a few weeks ago. guess that's not enough though.

i'll see if i can find a scanner. $$^#$%#$ technology....

YOu don't have a camera?

IPD
09-18-2010, 01:43 AM
what's your email?

Alan92RTTT
09-18-2010, 01:51 AM
alan@...org

IPD
09-18-2010, 09:18 PM
i emailed you last night. hopefully that'll work.

IPD
09-19-2010, 03:05 AM
ok, new beef with this setup:

i'm not verified. whatever, fine. what i did notice is that SMALLZ is verified. seriously. mr. "i'm going to buy big tyla's fwd-tt & not pay him for it" is a f**king verified seller.

is this a joke? the whole point of a new verification system is to prevent scammers & low lifes. the forum hasn't even been open for business a month--and you've already sanctioned a known low-life. i don't care if he IS a paid member--so am i; and i'm not verified, even though i've NEVER had any negative feedback.

you have GOT to be kidding me.

Alan92RTTT
09-19-2010, 03:48 AM
Verification is address verification. He provided the information which means he gets verified.

If you believe there is an issue that needs to be reviewed send me a PM with links and details and they will be reviewed.

IPD
09-19-2010, 11:46 AM
why a pm? the damn customer review was public. i really ought to post it here so that everyone can be warned, but in keeping with YOUR wishes, i'll pm it to you.

if all that is verified is the address, it should say so. currently it makes unverified members look sketchy--regardless of buyer/seller quality; while it makes verified people look reputable, which in this case--is clearly NOT the case. that's the only issue i have with how it's set up (other than my personal issue with smallz, aka lil john)

Alan92RTTT
09-19-2010, 12:46 PM
Why PM?
1) I did not want to clutter this thread of make a new thread for this.
2) I can't see the buyer/seller forum on 3si only people that are logged in can see it.

cjbyron
09-19-2010, 12:48 PM
currently it makes unverified members look sketchy--regardless of buyer/seller quality; while it makes verified people look reputable, which in this case--is clearly NOT the case.

Hate to say it, but, I agree 100%. The 'verification' has zero teeth for preventing any sale going bad while using verbage that makes it 'seem' otherwise. Falsely sense of some security or assurance that actually means zip legally.

Rather ridiculous IMO.

And over-restrictive yet allows known bad sellers to participate here. Great combination.

stealthee
09-19-2010, 12:56 PM
You guys have to pretend the other site never existed. When they started their verification process no one really knew of who the bad sellers were for the most part. All the verification is is providing information so that the seller can be held resonsible if they try to screw someone over, ie provides information to forward to authorities if it has to go that far.

No sale is ever guaranteed to go right, no matter where it takes place. You could meet someone face to face and they could still screw you over.

Alan92RTTT
09-19-2010, 01:07 PM
Hate to say it, but, I agree 100%. The 'verification' has zero teeth for preventing any sale going bad while using verbage that makes it 'seem' otherwise. Falsely sense of some security or assurance that actually means zip legally.

Rather ridiculous IMO.

And over-restrictive yet allows known bad sellers to participate here. Great combination.

Its not supposed to have "teeth" its to verify contact information and hopefully open a way to contact a seller if their is an issue.

People have the option of being verified or not.

If you don't want to go through the verification process you can opt into the "not-verified" group to sell.

If you do not want to go through the verification process and don't wan to opt-into the "not verified" group you can wait till I have the time to see if I can hook up an address verification via paypal.

cjbyron
09-19-2010, 01:15 PM
You guys have to pretend the other site never existed.
Actually no we don't. Nor does anyone. Why pretend what is universally known.
And it isn't all about "the other site". There is also paypal verification and many other variables.


All the verification is is providing information so that the seller can be held resonsible if they try to screw someone over, ie provides information to forward to authorities if it has to go that far.

This site cannot "hold anyone responsible". All it can do is ban or allow. There is zero legal standing with a third party claiming to have received proof of identity over the internet. This site keep all the logs and ID coupled with the server owner affidavits on such data? Of course not. And over 90% of any 'bad sales' are not about false ID anyway right? Product misrepresentation or not as advertised is the top of selling problems. So being a "verified" seller does nothing to prevent that.

Being "verified" seller implies that they are somehow vetted as a good seller. That is the implication. And falsely so.


No sale is ever guaranteed to go right, no matter where it takes place. You could meet someone face to face and they could still screw you over.

That's why there are rules, with teeth, based with the people that transfer the money (ie. paypal, CC comp.) or written (legal) contracts if face-to-face or otherwise.


Alan - yes , having someone paypal verified would actually then mean something verifiable. Unlike how it is now. Participating as 'non-verified' certainly comes with negative stigma. I understand what you are attempting to accomplish. At the same time I agree with the other assessment of the implicatications and how they are inaccurate as it stands currently. Therefore I agreed with his statement.

stealthee
09-19-2010, 01:20 PM
Being "verified" seller implies that they are somehow vetted as a good seller.

I do not agree with that. Being verified means your information is retained and if you screw someone over that information can be used to recoup losses.

cjbyron
09-19-2010, 01:30 PM
I do not agree with that. Being verified means your information is retained and if you screw someone over that information can be used to recoup losses.

First of all, look up what the word means. Verified by its nature does indeed imply a form of vetting, of facts and based upon some 'verifiable' process. It is misleading to the actual level of proof or evidence obtained.

There is nothing verifiable in an image sent via the internet that proves anything with someone's ID. All it does is expose the honest people to misuse of their personal information whilest making it very easy for someone to cheat the system.

Now if it said "approved" or something like that then it would be closer to representing the facts. Approved under the system in place here.

You keep thinking it allows for some form of legal "recoup of losses", etc. It doesn't at all. At best it gives info for the buyer to contact via phone or address. That's it. Nothing legal whatsoever. Fact. Period. Well, if the info is real, lol. Images are pretty easy to fake and manipulate. Again, false sense of security here.

Of course any site can do whatever it wants to. But just my opinion that it shouldn't imply or mislead with things like 'verified seller' which solely means some image was sent over the internet and the info was never verified (meaning - vetted,,,,,proved to be truthful).

In all actuality a very simple concept that seems difficult for some to grasp.

stealthee
09-19-2010, 01:35 PM
Verified here means verified information. The information is verified because there is two forms of it. Nothing else is implied.

cjbyron
09-19-2010, 01:37 PM
LOL. okay, whatever. The english language has altered meaning here.

stealthee
09-19-2010, 01:44 PM
No, you're just reading more into it than what needs to be read into it. There was no argument over 3si's "verified" program which had no forms of verification, yet there is a bitchfest here over the verbage? It doesn't make sense.

cjbyron
09-19-2010, 01:54 PM
No, you're just reading more into it than what needs to be read into it. There was no argument over 3si's "verified" program which had no forms of verification, yet there is a bitchfest here over the verbage? It doesn't make sense.



You guys have to pretend the other site never existed.

^ LOL.

I don't recall 3si having big colorful icons saying verified or anything. Maybe I missed that.
And it had 'verification' commensurate to what was involved.

Anyway,,,,,bitchfest? Because there isn't universal agreement or a differing point of view based upon verbage vs. reality? A differeing point of view or conceding errors doesn't always have to sink to arguments. Unless someone continues that stance.

Alan92RTTT
09-19-2010, 01:54 PM
The process for "verification" public. Its up to each person to decide what that means to them.

Even a paypal based address verification system provides no since of security. All it means is their is a checking account on the other end of the paypal account. Ad drkgreenvr4 proved that won't stop you from scamming member of over $10,000.

Verified means nothing more than you provided something that means the address we have is more than one copied from a phone book.

Alan92RTTT
09-19-2010, 01:57 PM
I don't recall 3si having big colorful icons saying verified or anything. Maybe I missed that.

No 3SI does not have verification status icons. But you have to be verified to swell there so a buyer can assume that the seller was verified. As their is a "not verified" option buyers need to know who has and has not been verified.

cjbyron
09-19-2010, 02:35 PM
I understand what you are trying to accomplish. And just so there's no typical misunderstanding, the reason I bring this up is from my past legal experiences with internet fraud as a server administrator. That's why.

But at the end of the day this site provides basically the same level of provable verification or buyer protection as 3si or other car forum. Give or take. While at the same time requiring a very high degree of personal information that has easy potential for identity theft. Yes I know some of that was relaxed with blanking out some info. Will all do it? Dunno. But at several levels administrators have a legal responsibility to protect information collected. And sometimes that responsibility is two-pronged and can backfire.

Verified from a transmitted image equates to the same as: "I read it on the internet, it must be true". LOL

I'm not saying that striving for a better way is a bad thing. But let's be realistic and factual on what things mean in the legal world or the ability of said verification system or info to have an impact at all. Words do matter as well as their usage and application.

Some people's past practices on other forums or online in general should matter too. Good or bad. To ignore that IMO is contrary to the very thing trying to accomplish (buyer protection). ref: inperfectdarkness's post.

That's all.

Black_Sunshine
09-20-2010, 03:43 AM
I pretty much agree with CJ. Here's my suggestion:

Since you are accepting money to keep the site going, find out what it would take to get a credit card system/ shopping cart in place. You then do a charge of $1.00. Since secure credit card transactions are only approved by Visa/Mastercard with the correct billing address, it should suffice as verification. The second portion of the verification would be for us to email or pm you the transaction number and include our current telephone number. You could match up the cc info to our pm/email and that would be it. During check out, just force a text field to include our user id.

Even if people don't have credit cards, they should have debit/check cards that would work the exact same way. If you have paypal, you have a checking account and should definitely have access to some sort of debit/check card.

You could also use it to accept the annual membership fee and use the verification process. That would save people time from having to verify to sell at a later date and would save them $1.

I don't understand the need for instant gratification for seller privilege on here. If the verification process takes 2 days, then it takes 2 days. There isn't anyone on here who doesn't have other ways to sell stuff, such as ebay if they really need to sell something right away and they think someone will buy it instantly. With additional mods, you could slot the people who are waiting in queue to be verified as unverified sellers until they can be verified. This will give them access to post in classifieds fast. Just have one of the mods take care of this function.

Lastly, please remove the verification from the WTB side of the classifieds. We shouldn't need to verify ourselves if we just wtb something.

Alan92RTTT
09-20-2010, 09:48 AM
Tri your suggestion works great to prove that a person is there. But the desire is to have contact information just in case.

Verification should only be required to reply in wanted(ie sell), I'll check the settings.

MK_94_3000GT
09-20-2010, 10:20 AM
why a pm? the damn customer review was public. i really ought to post it here so that everyone can be warned, but in keeping with YOUR wishes, i'll pm it to you.

if all that is verified is the address, it should say so. currently it makes unverified members look sketchy--regardless of buyer/seller quality; while it makes verified people look reputable, which in this case--is clearly NOT the case. that's the only issue i have with how it's set up (other than my personal issue with smallz, aka lil john)

Although rare, I have to say I agree with you. This should not be a place where we welcome those who steal or don't pay for what they buy. I say this because there are several known scammers and this is their new home too and its upsetting to say the least

BadHabit
09-20-2010, 11:12 AM
Why all the commotion? We all have some concerns yet,I don't think we are going to find a way that EVERYONE will agree on,I signed up on day 1 and it was pretty painless..
BH

Black_Sunshine
09-20-2010, 02:09 PM
Alan, wouldn't the cc process supply you with the correct address as well?

Alan92RTTT
09-20-2010, 02:22 PM
No, the CC process does not provide the address.

It "might" verify it but it does not provide it.

I will be looking at what I can do via the paypal API's as we have a paid merchant account.

If I can verify whats entered into the profile that would work.

Black_Sunshine
09-20-2010, 03:26 PM
So how do online stores work if it doesn't provide a billing/shipping address? Weird. Well good luck figuring it out. Btw, I can't find any info on sponsorships.

Alan92RTTT
09-20-2010, 03:57 PM
I'm 99% sure all website shopping carts make you enter the information and then you can send it in for verification.

The sponsor information link can be found at the top of the "sales/sponsors" page.

Sin'sVr4
09-20-2010, 09:58 PM
weeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee. This is like a merry go round. Alan, once you have a 100% this is it method, lets just go with that and lock this thread. I too, am 100% feedback on 3si, ebay blah blah...but this needs to be secure and I have had my identity stolen twice and I could care less if you asked for a pic of my mom, it wont happen unless by phone. I can send u a pic of my DL and bill either by fax or a pic message

GTO Assassin
09-20-2010, 11:04 PM
Was my post removed? Could have sworn I posted here yesterday.

green-lantern
09-20-2010, 11:08 PM
Was my post removed? Could have sworn I posted here yesterday.

Alan hired Lordwarlock

GTO Assassin
09-20-2010, 11:22 PM
Damned censorship! It's everywhere!

GTOJOE
09-21-2010, 02:49 AM
Damned censorship! It's everywhere!

I think your on drugs son :D

Alan92RTTT
09-21-2010, 02:19 PM
For he people that do not want to provide information online is fax a viable option.

Lori has said I can use the fax at her store (its in her office).

Is this a viable option?

IronmanTT
09-21-2010, 02:47 PM
Liking the idea of cell phone pic sent via text of DL and current bill... can I do this Alan??? :p

91STT
09-21-2010, 04:24 PM
For he people that do not want to provide information online is fax a viable option.

Lori has said I can use the fax at her store (its in her office).

Is this a viable option?

PM me the number please

Blue91SL
09-21-2010, 04:44 PM
Well, here's my quandary.
My driver's license address and my physical address are not the same.
And where I live, there are no bills that come in my name.

IPD
09-22-2010, 12:20 AM
For he people that do not want to provide information online is fax a viable option.

Lori has said I can use the fax at her store (its in her office).

Is this a viable option?

cool. but i already emailed you my ID & a bill with my address. wouldn't that be sufficient in this case?

Alan92RTTT
09-22-2010, 02:35 AM
inperfectdarkness, Make a post in the verification forum and mention the email.

You can email cell pics and that fine. Sending to my cell would be worthless and I'd just send it to my email.

IPD
09-22-2010, 02:45 AM
i'm confused. so the people that DON'T want to put their info online can fax it in? but they would still have to post it in the verification forum? isn't that counter-intuitive?

Alan92RTTT
09-22-2010, 02:50 AM
I use the forum as a queue so I do not miss anyone. I also print the address you type in your post with your forum name. and put all the paperwork together.

brutten
09-22-2010, 02:48 PM
Hey Alan - I emailed you my information last week and apparently that was not good enough so can you increase the limit of the pdf size? 19KB file size limit is beyond silly so I am not able to upload the scan of requested info to the site.

Alan92RTTT
09-23-2010, 12:49 AM
Did you post in the verification forum? As I said above I use that as my work queue so nobody gets missed and it puts everything I need at my fingers.

Intropy
09-27-2010, 01:25 PM
OK this is probably a stupid question... where exactly is the classifieds forum? How do I get there? I'm feeling dumb.

pezcore
09-27-2010, 01:26 PM
http://www.3sgto.org/forumdisplay.php?40-sales

Intropy
09-27-2010, 01:43 PM
http://www.3sgto.org/forumdisplay.php?40-sales

OK, now explain how you got that link. ;) I don't see classifieds listed under "forum".

Geordon
09-27-2010, 01:59 PM
OK, now explain how you got that link. ;) I don't see classifieds listed under "forum".

It is on the top row of links/tabs to the right of Forum, named Sales/Sponsors. Not intuitive to me, either.

Alan92RTTT
09-27-2010, 02:02 PM
"Sales" is not intuitive? Can you suggest a better word that not as long as classifieds?

IronmanTT
09-27-2010, 02:06 PM
Maybe taking the word "Sponsors" out and just say "Classifieds" or "For Sale". It's seems from the title might only pertain to "Sponsors" only section or something like that.. :D

Intropy
09-27-2010, 02:20 PM
It is on the top row of links/tabs to the right of Forum, named Sales/Sponsors. Not intuitive to me, either.

In my case I think I was just expecting it to be listed under "Forum". Any particular reason it's not?

Alan92RTTT
09-27-2010, 02:44 PM
The more forums on the list the more work that the server has to do to display them. By segmenting things it keeps us from having forum main page that is miles long. and slow to load.

It might take a minute or two to get used to but in the long run it will work out better.

Geordon
09-27-2010, 03:32 PM
Maybe taking the word "Sponsors" out and just say "Classifieds" or "For Sale". It's seems from the title might only pertain to "Sponsors" only section or something like that.. :D

I agreee. Inclusion with Sponsors made me think it was for Sponsors or to look at Sponsors. If you want a short version of "Classified Ads", why not the standard "Ads"?

pezcore
09-27-2010, 03:41 PM
The more forums on the list the more work that the server has to do to display them. By segmenting things it keeps us from having forum main page that is miles long. and slow to load.

It might take a minute or two to get used to but in the long run it will work out better.

Can you make a classifieds button and have it just go to the same page/forum as the sponsors button? Would that help with server load?