PDA

View Full Version : Car is finally on the dyno, but ran into issues in higher boost. Need input



Andr3w
11-25-2013, 09:15 PM
After two years, I finally got my car back together and running pretty well. Took the car into FSR to have them put in the ProEFI 128 ecu and give it a tune. It sounds like the 91 octane tune went fine staying conservative and getting to 19psi where I told them to stop and switch to e85. The car put down 300whp at waste gate 7.5psi and 390whp at 12.5psi on e85 (70% ethanol content was what the sensor measured).

Mods.
-Pro EFI 128 w/ ethanol sensor and dual wideband setup
-Billet DR-650 Turbos w/Forge wastegates and green springs
-Ported heads(no idea who ported) and high rev kit
-Adjustable cam gears - Zero'd with degree wheel
-HKS DLI
- MSD Spark plug wires
-Walbro e85 pump - Hotwired
-FIC 1100CC injectors
-8AN fuel and return lines
-Fuel lab FPR
-Generic intake w/ maf deleted
-Greddy type-s bov
-RPS Max 6-puck clutch
-Bellhousing brace
-3sx downpipe
-Maximal Performance High flow cat
-Maximal Performance solid motor mounts.

Here are the issues that was emailed to me:


-The IAC motor seems very slow to respond. Maye it is just dirty or maybe it is on its way out. It has been working less and less well over the last few days.
- I suspected an issue with this after initial startup. Cleaned and it seemed to go away. Looks like it needs to be replaced now

-The rear bank is requiring about 5-7% more fuel, and the differential gets bigger as boost is going up which is why we don't want to push it more.
- Before getting on the dyno, they were trying to locate the source of an exhaust leak in the rear manifold. Could not be isolated. I gave the go ahead for tuning.

-Boost comes on nicely early but falls off drastically without tons of extra wastegate duty cycle. These cars all do that... but this one does it excessively and requires a lot of wastegate percentage as rpm gets past 4000 to keep any boost on the motor; this is indicative of a breathing issue, usually on the exhaust side.

-IAT's are getting to about 200* and the proefi is pulling timing to try to save the motor. E85 helps to cool things down a lot and IAT's will be high with small turbos but not this high. There could be a boost leak only under high boost that we are not seeing with all that stock piping in there

-The y-pipe keeps blowing off anything above 18psi
- Ebay Y-pipe :( Never had issues when running my 13g's. Will upgrade now.

-At high RPM, the dyno shows something is holding up. At low boost we can pull clean to 7k, but with boost on the motor the air fuel starts to get erratic and you can also see on the dyno graph that something isn't holing up. The most likely causes would be excessive backpressure or something in the valvetrain. Below 5krpm it does not seem to be an issue, even with lots of boost such as 25psi


Any thoughts on what could be causing these issues? Car is still on stock bottom end, intercoolers, and catback exhaust. I have not received the dyno charts yet, but will post them up when they arrive. Thinking about replacing all the rubber intercooler lines with silicone lines or moving to an FMIC. I do have a test pipe that I can throw on next time to see if it helps with the back pressure as well.

Andrew

mehrshadvr4
11-26-2013, 06:52 AM
I would put better intercooler there. Who set your timing? If the car is at FSR then they should be able to locate the issues. Also it's a good idea to find out who ported the heads. Make sure the heads are ported equally or atleast pretty close. If the timing is set right it might be your rear head flow a bit better than the front ones. You don't want to have one head flow better than the other. This is the reason why I went with IPS CNC heads because I know both heads and each ports are flowing equally. What o2 housing are you using? Are you using factory ungutted o2 also? I would also check to see if both turbo wastgates are opening equally. If your rear turbo's wasgate open more or sooner than front that could cause issue and act like exhaust leak and running leaner on the back and your boost drop.

J. Fast
11-26-2013, 08:25 AM
I would put better intercooler there. Who set your timing? If the car is at FSR then they should be able to locate the issues. Also it's a good idea to find out who ported the heads. Make sure the heads are ported equally or atleast pretty close. If the timing is set right it might be your rear head flow a bit better than the front ones. You don't want to have one head flow better than the other. This is the reason why I went with IPS CNC heads because I know both heads and each ports are flowing equally. What o2 housing are you using? Are you using factory ungutted o2 also? I would also check to see if both turbo wastgates are opening equally. If your rear turbo's wasgate open more or sooner than front that could cause issue and act like exhaust leak and running leaner on the back and your boost drop.
If it was wastegate tension the afr would equalize at target boost and the boost would overshoot and undershoot on the log.

I might recommend you smoke test the exhaust and the charge piping to your target boost pressure. Make sure you turn the engine over by hand to a closed intake valve position for positive pressure and vice versa for the exhaust side. Also make sure you test when the engine is warm. There might be a slew of things to fix regarding couplers, clamps and intake seals. If you find no leaks then pull the injectors and see if they're clogged.

Disable the IAC on the EFI and see if you can lock it out. Log it locked and then unlock it and log it. Compare the voltage vs duty vs rpm vs idle correction. Also compare with your interpolating tables and look at timing with idle. Timing plays a big part in smoothing idle. You don't want a big overshoot like +/- 10° based on IAC and MAP in your idle controls.

I'm suspecting you are trying to diagnose, isolate, and correct these issues to avoid shop time expense? These are things FSR can give you answers for...?

Andr3w
11-26-2013, 11:38 AM
Yes the car is still at FSR, but it has been there for a good amount of time and I would like to take it home to give a good washing. I really don't have a problem with them doing the work, but they do seem pretty busy. It seems like I need to reverify some things on my part though. I have the oval pressure tester and whenever I started to go above 17psi or around there, the adapter would start to lose its seal. This should also be a good time to test the drivability out on the street and report any issues when taking the car back. I did the timing myself and zeroed the cams with a degree wheel. I checked multiple times over a few days while the engine was on the stand.

The heads were purchased on the forums used a few years ago and the owner is no longer on the boards. If I remember right, he ended up taking a sledghammer or something to his car. When I returned from my deployment, I finally got to take a look at the heads. They were in shitty packaging and got scratched up on the mounting surface. I had a shop take apart the heads and do repair. They found sand and some other crap in the galleys. After the repair was done, everything checked out to be good. Very dissappointed though lol.

I am also thinking that since black friday is coming up I can find some good deals on things, but the last thing I really want to do is throw more parts at it. He has mentioned since the start of the tuning that there is a lot of backpressure in the exhaust. I have the stock precats, but both have been gutted. I do have the Maximal performance high flow cat though. I may bring my test pipe up when I bring the car up to do a comparison.

Hopefully I will be able to get some of the dyno graphs today to post.

Andr3w
11-26-2013, 12:22 PM
Just got off the phone with Ian. He said the problem only exists with high boost and high rpm. low boost and high rpm it is fine. High boost low and mid rpm is great and makes a lot of torque. He is thinking either possibly a weak valve spring or lifter possibly. Something mechanical. Any thoughts? Other than that the car runs great on 91 octane and e85 at lower boost.

Andr3w
11-26-2013, 02:48 PM
Attached some quick snapshots of some of the dynos

mehrshadvr4
11-26-2013, 05:04 PM
Yeah get rid of the cat and see how the car reacts.

familyMAN
11-26-2013, 09:17 PM
As already mentioned. Throw on a test pipe and see what happens. Also sounds like you are on stock side mount intercoolers. If you haven't removed and cleaned inside thoroughly they are probably full of oil from blown 9bs at some point in their life. Cheap CXracing FMIC would be a good upgrade though.

FIX YOUR LEAKS. Pre turbo exhaust leaks can kill your spool and power. Intake leaks kill your turbos efficiency. Nothing wrong with an eBay y pipe. Just make sure your coupler is the right size and your clamps can be tightened down good. Order a new silicone reducer if you need to.

Ninjaperformance has IAC in Black Friday sale for $50. Buy one :D

CoopKill
11-26-2013, 09:39 PM
Hairspray will help with keeping couplers on.

familyMAN
11-26-2013, 09:43 PM
^this!

mehrshadvr4
11-26-2013, 10:27 PM
If you have good couplers, you can flip the edges of y pipe with a plyer. That should keep it intact.

Andr3w
11-26-2013, 10:48 PM
Thanks for the input guys. I will be picking the car up probably Friday. Definitely will pick up that IAT while its on sale. I also have been looking at the ETS Fmic since it is 15% off right now. FSR agrees that I should look into an FMIC since the temps seem to skyrocket. Also agreed that I should look at increasing the wastegate springs to 12psi.

So before the dyno revisit it looks like I will be installing an FMIC, putting the test pipe on, replace IAC (may have to wait till car is back to shop to recalibrate), and pressure testing both intake and exhaust to 27psi. There are also a few 9* bends in the fuel feed line that I want to try to get rid of. Oh and install some higher rating wastegate springs.

The ebay Y-pipe is actually popping off from the throttle body since it isn't reduced in size. The weird thing is that he said the y-pipe isnt popping off at peak boost. He said it is a bit after when boost beings to drop off. Any ideas what would cause this? Ian is thinking there could be a lot of turbulence or something going on inside. I believe all this occurs at the same time the AFR starts to go erratic.

I don't think they were able to get the car on the dyno without the high flow cat. Probably just enough time to checkout the tune on the street before he leaves for the Thanksgiving.

Is it even probable to have such a large restriction in the exhaust side to cause some of these issues or should I also be looking at removing the valve covers to see if anything is failing inside. Before dropping the engine back in I did a cold leakdown test on all the cylinders and they were all good.

mehrshadvr4
11-26-2013, 10:57 PM
well since you are going FMIC then forget about fixing the Y pipe. Yes cat can cause a massive back pressure. I'm not sure how much of improvement the high flow cats are, but I remember Matt said a car with cat and slip on down pipe was keep popping the exhaust pipes because of too much back pressure.

Andr3w
11-26-2013, 11:16 PM
I guess we will find soon. Should be interesting to get a comparison with the high flow cat and test pipe. Will be tempted to get an exhaust as well if the quad tip goes on sale on black friday. Thank you familyMan for pointing out the discount at Ninja Performance. If I remember right, Napa was wanting $130 for an IAC.

vTaKwiTHsLiCkS
11-27-2013, 12:47 PM
Are you running an aftermarket DP?

Also.. Why not go for higher rated springs to be able to hold the boost better on e85? I have 16-22 psi (red) I believe in mine.

Haha. I wanna check out your car..

jbuhrman
11-27-2013, 01:01 PM
As we discussed on the faceybook.

Get them the test pipe and have them do some runs to see if the problem cleans up.
Also it is the season for buying, black friday sales are here and may as well go ahead and spend what ever deployment money you have left.

Don't forget you have to have the car back to you prior to Dec 13th so I can check it out when I am down there.

Andr3w
11-27-2013, 01:03 PM
Yea 3sx downpipe. I really wasnt sure what spring to go with for 91 octane so I stayed on the safe side. I will probably move up to the 10-14psi spring.

You in Socal?

jbuhrman
11-27-2013, 02:06 PM
Yea 3sx downpipe. I really wasnt sure what spring to go with for 91 octane so I stayed on the safe side. I will probably move up to the 10-14psi spring.

You in Socal?


me no, not yet anyway.

Andr3w
11-27-2013, 02:26 PM
Not you

Sent from my SPH-L720 using Tapatalk 2

vTaKwiTHsLiCkS
11-27-2013, 02:26 PM
Yup. Live in SGV area and work in Ontario. Are you in the SD area or out by FSR?

Would love to compare against another e85 billet car.. ;[p

vTaKwiTHsLiCkS
11-27-2013, 02:29 PM
me no, not yet anyway.

always looking for another reason to get your post count up..

whore. lol.

Andr3w
11-27-2013, 02:34 PM
Yea I am in the San Diego area. I would love to do some comparisons with another billet e85 car :)

vTaKwiTHsLiCkS
11-27-2013, 02:48 PM
This might just get interesting.. ;[p

jbuhrman
11-27-2013, 03:01 PM
always looking for another reason to get your post count up..

whore. lol.

haters gonna hate

Andr3w
11-27-2013, 08:21 PM
Current safe settings on the car:
Setting 4: 425whp/ 485ftlbs
Setting 3: 400whp/ 450ftlbs
Setting 2: 375whp/403ftlbs
Setting 1: 300whp/ 331ftlb

vTaKwiTHsLiCkS
12-02-2013, 12:57 PM
if you don't mind me asking.. what is the psi at for the 4 settings?

Andr3w
02-08-2014, 05:27 PM
Finally pulled off the race cat to swap out the stock for emissions. It looks pretty beat up on the inlet side and a lot of the holes are deformed or mashed. Could this have been causing a lot of back pressure? Is the cat toast?

http://img.tapatalk.com/d/14/02/09/ryde7y8e.jpg

Sent from my SPH-L720 using Tapatalk 2

fastfalcon94
02-08-2014, 07:57 PM
I had the same problem with my high flow cat. It broke lose from the housing and wedged into the pipe. I removed it and put in a resonator instead. The metal shavings are from me cutting the pipe open. This is looking at the cat from the backside. The cat area of the pipe was wider, maybe 3.25 or 3.5". It was getting shoved down into the 3" section of pipe.

http://i1192.photobucket.com/albums/aa327/fastfalcon94/2012-07-27_17-40-02_731.jpg

mb3000
02-08-2014, 08:23 PM
Yes, ditch the cat...

Andr3w
02-08-2014, 09:09 PM
Wow definitely getting rid of it. I like the idea of using a resonator instead of just a test pipe. Will have to do that

Sent from my SPH-L720 using Tapatalk 2

CoopKill
02-09-2014, 01:08 AM
Resonator depending the tone?

Sent from the Man Cave!

*\( ^o^ )/*

fastfalcon94
02-09-2014, 08:13 AM
I've using it to try to quiet the tone. It does help. I went from an ek2mfg high flow cat with no mufflers to not cat, a vibrant 24" resonator, and 2 in line high flow magnaflow mufflers. The inside of the mufflers look just like the inside of the resonator. They have a 3" ID with some metal mesh around the edges. It sounds about the same.