PDA

View Full Version : Rebuild Cost Range



3000GTPro
07-30-2013, 09:42 AM
Well, I need to start preparing to do something about the fact that my car absolutely will not pass smog inspections anymore. I was able to have it pass one last time late last year, but now it fails highly over the limit of HC's, and WAY over the limit of NOx. I can see puffs of blue smoke behind me when the light turns green, if the car sits too long while warming up (this has pointed towards bad VSS from what I have learned most of the time), it has a small coolant leak that I'm told is happening somewhere around the thermostat housing, my data logger has pointed out (9) for knock at higher rpms with wide open throttle (does that stand for how many counts of knock has been found?) and I have maybe 210xxx miles on the car. I have been thinking either I'll just upgrade to a JDM Debonair 6g74 engine, or rebuild my stock engine within the next 2 years, but I don't know how much that could cost to pay someone to do it for me. I know a couple people that might be able to do me a favor and do it cheaper than most shops I know, but I still have no idea. Is there anyone who has been in my predicament that might be able to give me an idea of what I could be in for based off that info?

sergechronos
07-30-2013, 05:52 PM
Well without knowing local labor rates, it'd be hard to pin down what they'd charge to do VSS, but there's a variety of things that can be checked. You could look into having the fuel injectors replaced/serviced (Probably at least 70 bucks) which could do quite a bit to help with the HCs. EGR could also be shot, contributing to high NOx count and that is a distinct possibility given mileage and age. Fixing a coolant leak by the coolant housing is very easy and can be done with either gaskets or RTV (or both). I wouldn't bother with a JDM swap unless I could afford to tear it down to inspect it and possibly rebuild it. There's no guarantees that what you purchase will be in better shape than your current motor.

As far as rebuilding, provided no damage to crank, cams or heads, you could probably get it all done for less than 3k with labor if you pay a shop to do it with a 120k (since you're coming up on that time). Mine ran around 1800 (me doing the work) for hoist, stand, machine shop honing the cylinders and flywheel, plus gasket kit, OEM 120k parts and new clutch.

3000GTPro
07-30-2013, 06:52 PM
I believe the average labor rates here from independent shops to dealerships costs from $100 - $120 per hour.
It probably doesn't make that big of a difference, but I just remembered that my mileage is actually very close to 225xxx miles. Also that is everything that is wrong with the car that I have seen, and it has been well taken care of it's whole life. Sometimes it feels like it's not as powerful as it used to be, but I don't know if that's just because I have gotten used to it or not.

3000GTPro
07-30-2013, 07:07 PM
So from the sound of it, it will be more costly to put in a 6g74, knowing we can't trust it to be in perfect working order before using it. A lot of the JDM 6g74 engines I'm finding cost between $2400 and $2800!

sergechronos
07-30-2013, 07:28 PM
Not saying that it's always the case with a 6g74, but I wouldn't buy one expecting it to be in mint condition. I would at least do a 120k to it for peace of mind. Some guys get lucky, others don't. I don't want to waste a 3k investment in an engine though.

Anyhow, you could do a compression check. Your rings could be worn. This would reduce power and allow oil into the combustion process. You can check it with a compression gauge, numbers are listed in the service manual for what they should be. If they are low, you can put a very small amount of oil into the cylinder and if it brings pressure up would indicate rings. If the rings are good, then you could probably skip rebuilding the bottom end so long as you have good oil pressure. If the rings are good, then take it to a shop, have the VSS replaced (or you could do it yourself if you're mechanically inclined and have the patience and tools). The coolant leak by the thermostat is easy to remedy with new gaskets or RTV. Fuel injectors could probably use a good servicing or replacement, and clean the EGR system out (carb cleaner generally works well here). By no means is this an all-encompassing solution, but it may be enough to squeeze you through inspection on the cheap for now.

familyMAN
07-30-2013, 08:00 PM
Do the VSS yourself. There are plenty of good vids online. A 6g74 will need VSS also. They are usually fairly old engines also that have been sitting around in a warehouse for who knows how long. They also rarely have been services well so oil control rings will be gummed up and make you smoke also. Just fix the problems you have. Doesn't sound that costly.

Jimvr4
07-30-2013, 10:35 PM
David, take the car to Clark's. They did my machine work and can probably do a complete rebuild for under $5k. They did a 3S for that recently. I would trust Steve completely to address what it needs

3000GTPro
07-31-2013, 12:21 AM
I could do it myself maybe after I had the tools, and if I had the time. So more than anything, that's why I have to pay someone.
Maybe hopefully I don't have to have a full rebuild, and I can do the 3.5 swap later.
Awesome Jim! Is Clark's just an engine builder shop or do they do repair work as well?

wingnut
07-31-2013, 01:20 AM
how much really depends on you...

...i dare say most of us that rebuilt, spent a whole chit-ton more because once you get in there, its a whole lot easier to justify replacing this or that since you have things torn down. I know my own budget nearly doubled :wink:

sergechronos
07-31-2013, 01:31 AM
how much really depends on you...

...i dare say most of us that rebuilt, spent a whole chit-ton more because once you get in there, its a whole lot easier to justify replacing this or that since you have things torn down. I know my own budget nearly doubled :wink:

Same here. Mine was supposed to be cams, rocker arms and 120k...Ended up checking out the bearings, which were totally shot and needed replacing. Then I decided to upgrade to a forged crank rather than polishing my cast because you know..already in there. Decided to get my 9Bs turned into 13Ts instead of rebuilding because I already had them out and the cost fairly close. Ended up switching to 3g lifters while I had it all apart. Picked up a front mount because "it makes more sense to do it now with all this." Picked up a Chrome ECu because "well..mine is 20 years old.." Then picked up Evo560s because "the flash can support them and my stock 360s have 170k on them). Heck, reringed the block (even though I didn't need to) so that I could go ahead and have it hot tanked since I already had it almost completely torn apart for the new bearings and crank..

In truth, it would probably run you 3k either way. It's just how much do you get for your 3k? For me, selling old parts as I took them off and wheeling and dealing with parts is the only thing that kept this even remotely close to budget and even then I more than doubled my initial budget of 1.2k.

in short, this is what ends up happening if you build it yourself
https://lh4.googleusercontent.com/-q_CSd6VuGxg/UfeYTp6ci_I/AAAAAAAAgV8/gXy32wVX47A/w480-h360-no/programming.gif

A shop will do exactly as they need to do, and nothing else. Which may or may not work out for you if anything else goes wrong later. A complete rebuild for 5k may be a better idea for a shop.

3000GTPro
07-31-2013, 10:09 AM
What I would like to do, is get my 3 liter refurbished enough to where I'm not going to have to worry about passing smog inspections so much for a few years. The bare minimum is to just pass the smog test by the end of November in 2014. Maybe I should just find a good place to diagnose it for the smog issues, and I can let you guys know what I find out? Maybe then it will be an easier decision to make.

Jimvr4
07-31-2013, 10:38 AM
I could do it myself maybe after I had the tools, and if I had the time. So more than anything, that's why I have to pay someone.
Maybe hopefully I don't have to have a full rebuild, and I can do the 3.5 swap later.
Awesome Jim! Is Clark's just an engine builder shop or do they do repair work as well?

Clark's does engines, transmissions, and repair. Around the time I had my block, crank, and heads done by them, they had a customer bring a TT in that had spun bearings. The customer's prior head rebuild ($5K from a different shop :eek:) had been done improperly when they failed to clean the heads. Abrasive materials circulated throughout the engine and ruined it. Clarks rebuilt the heads and block, doing all the work from teardown to startup for under $5K.

I would check compression and timing first. If VSS haven't been done then you can be sure it's needed at your mileage. My heads also needed new valve guides on the exhaust valves and I was only at 105K. I think you will need the heads removed and rebuilt. A new gasket set and timing component set would be needed as well. Probably best just to pull the motor and do new bearings and oil pump. Might need new rings too.

The smog issue is just a symptom of a tired high mileage engine IMHO.

sergechronos
07-31-2013, 10:53 AM
If you're looking for Nov 2014, you need to make the decision shortly if you want to stay 3L or go 3.5. It's alla bout how much you want to invest in the car. You rebuild the motor, or swap (and IMO rebuild that motor if you do swap), or sell it and get something else.

Jim is probably right on smog being a symptom of a tired old engine, however following the suggestions put forth earlier MAY help you limp along for a bit. Generally NOx emissions are kept to manageable levels by the EGR system, if that fails (or is deleted) NOx shoots through the rough. Hydrocarbons is usually a sign of unburnt gas due to either bad injectors, vacuum leak, weak ignition components, cats gone bad/failed (generally has a noticeable smell and loss of power), failure of emissions equipment or worn rings. Vacuum and compression testing will tell you if the motor actually needs to be rebuilt or not though. If compression is good, then you can get new bearings put in, VSS and heads done (I agree with Jim that guides probably are worn as well), do the 120k and probably be good to go. You really need to do some testing to kind of narrow it down before you make a decision honestly. A uniformed decision is a wasted decision given how much time you have to work with.

3000GTPro
08-08-2013, 09:52 AM
Well if you guys were in my position, what would you do? What would be more worth while? Making the car good enough to pass for a couple more years, so I can get around while having a 3.5 built up for me, or going straight for building up a 3.5 now before November next year? I suspect I may have to go with the first because I'm not even making enough money for a full engine rebuild regardless right now, but that could change soon. So I'm willing to go straight for a built 3.5 right now, if only I had the funds for it, but obviously survival is more important.
By the way, I think you guys might be right about the fuel injectors. Maybe that's why I can't get more than about 20.5 mpg, no matter how relaxed my driving is.

familyMAN
08-08-2013, 11:17 AM
Do a compression test. If its fine, fix your problems and enjoy. Why in the hell would you want to tear into a running car if it doesn't need it?

Smoke on idle and take off...VSS. (Not rings)
Poor gas mileage...First thing to think about is o2 sensor(s) and general tune up (check air filter, new plugs, etc)

familyMAN
08-08-2013, 11:18 AM
you really need to do some testing to kind of narrow it down before you make a decision honestly. A uniformed decision is a wasted decision given how much time you have to work with.

^this!

3000GTPro
08-08-2013, 04:37 PM
Do a compression test. If its fine, fix your problems and enjoy. Why in the hell would you want to tear into a running car if it doesn't need it?

Smoke on idle and take off...VSS. (Not rings)
Poor gas mileage...First thing to think about is o2 sensor(s) and general tune up (check air filter, new plugs, etc)

It's definitely not the O2 sensor. I replaced that with a brand new one and it has only made an insignificant difference. Whatever it is, it's something engine related.

3000GTPro
08-08-2013, 04:49 PM
I'll report back to you guys in a few weeks with probably what Clark's has to say about it, and we'll go from there. I understand there's too many unknown variables to say whether one way is more worth it over another.

3000GTPro
04-10-2014, 05:32 PM
I know I'm bringing this back from the dead, but I finally have an answer. I recently had my check engine light come on, and the car wasn't behaving right under load. So I got my data logger on it, and long story short, I couldn't fully diagnose the problem, so I took the car to Clark's finally. Turns out my suspicion was right. Cylinder 4 wasn't igniting the fuel, and there was a vacuum leak thanks to a vacuum hose that somehow came off my fuel pressure regulator. There will be running much better than it was before, however cylinder 4 is only compressing at 100 psi while all the rest are in the normal range of close to 180 cold. He took the car to his machine shop and they quoted him $3800 for a complete overhaul since they said the engine was still pretty healthy overall. I just wish I had that much right now.
*correction I thought it was Clark's but it was the guy next door.*

Jimvr4
04-11-2014, 02:24 PM
What was wrong with 4? Did they do a leak down test? Who did you talk to?

Compression problem is rings or valves. Is the price for both bottom end and head work?

sergechronos
04-11-2014, 02:35 PM
Selling the car as is and putting that + the 3800 could get you a VR4 and then the 3L vs 3.5L swap would be a moot point IMO.

3800 should be a complete rebuild plus labor for a whole motor honestly

Sent from my XT1080 using Tapatalk

3000GTPro
05-02-2014, 02:50 PM
What was wrong with 4? Did they do a leak down test? Who did you talk to?

Compression problem is rings or valves. Is the price for both bottom end and head work?

I couldn't afford to find out more about it. I figured either way, it doesn't really matter right now since I can't pass smog until one of those is done anyway. I thought I went to Clarks, but it turned out I actually went to the place next door. Which still did a reasonable job. Turns out his machine shop is clarks actually. The $3800 is for a full engine rebuild from Clark's. For just the heads, Clark's quoted me...somewhere around $2100-2400 I think?
I'm thinking very much about going 3.5L because the engines themselves are much cheaper, but I don't know what the average condition those engines come in. So maybe it could cost more. Plus since I don't work on the major stuff like this and major tune-ups myself, what is this engine going to change in diagnosing breakdowns, or major tune-ups? I'm wondering if that is going to give me headaches at shops or not.

3000GTPro
05-02-2014, 03:06 PM
Selling the car as is and putting that + the 3800 could get you a VR4 and then the 3L vs 3.5L swap would be a moot point IMO.

3800 should be a complete rebuild plus labor for a whole motor honestly

Sent from my XT1080 using Tapatalk
The challenge with a car that wont pass smog anymore is it's technically illegal to sell it in CA. Even though I have no doubt people disregard that here all the time, selling this car would still be a REALLY hard sell. And I'm not in the position to own a VR-4 at this time, especially as my only car.

Jimvr4
05-02-2014, 03:45 PM
David, Make sure you get the pricing from Clarks directly. They're not associated with the business next door. My heads were re-done for under $1K by them but new parts needed was only 1 exhaust valve,12 new exhaust valve guides, and 24 VSS. Everything else was re-used.

I doubt anyone could give you a complete estimate without pulling the heads. If it were me I would want a cost breakdown for each step to make the decision easy.

sergechronos
05-02-2014, 04:28 PM
I agree with Jim. I don't know what labor runs out there, but I just had a set of heads disassembled, cleaned, valve and heads cut, new VSS and 24 new guides all done for about 700 including cost of parts.

Sent from my XT1080 using Tapatalk

3000GTPro
05-04-2014, 02:46 AM
David, Make sure you get the pricing from Clarks directly. They're not associated with the business next door. My heads were re-done for under $1K by them but new parts needed was only 1 exhaust valve,12 new exhaust valve guides, and 24 VSS. Everything else was re-used.

I doubt anyone could give you a complete estimate without pulling the heads. If it were me I would want a cost breakdown for each step to make the decision easy.
Well shoot, alright!


I agree with Jim. I don't know what labor runs out there, but I just had a set of heads disassembled, cleaned, valve and heads cut, new VSS and 24 new guides all done for about 700 including cost of parts.

Sent from my XT1080 using Tapatalk
Oh ok. The minimum for labor out here is $100 for independent shops usually.

3000GTPro
06-21-2014, 10:34 PM
David, Make sure you get the pricing from Clarks directly. They're not associated with the business next door. My heads were re-done for under $1K by them but new parts needed was only 1 exhaust valve,12 new exhaust valve guides, and 24 VSS. Everything else was re-used.

I doubt anyone could give you a complete estimate without pulling the heads. If it were me I would want a cost breakdown for each step to make the decision easy.
Well I went back to the shop and I talked to someone at Clark's who remembered when you came in Jim. He quoted me about the same as I already mentioned, only the full rebuild was more like $3000 rather than $3800. So I'm still looking out for 3.5 engines, and they took my number saying if they find anything they'll call me.

DocHoliday
08-01-2014, 02:38 PM
Well I went back to the shop and I talked to someone at Clark's who remembered when you came in Jim. He quoted me about the same as I already mentioned, only the full rebuild was more like $3000 rather than $3800. So I'm still looking out for 3.5 engines, and they took my number saying if they find anything they'll call me.

Honestly if you end up looking at $3800 to fix a car with that high mileage I would probably just sell any way you could and buy another. There's too many good 3000GTs out there around that price to dump all that money into your own. Your transmission could go tomorrow and you'll be kicking yourself for dropping that much coin to fix it.

3000GTPro
10-15-2014, 08:18 AM
Honestly if you end up looking at $3800 to fix a car with that high mileage I would probably just sell any way you could and buy another. There's too many good 3000GTs out there around that price to dump all that money into your own. Your transmission could go tomorrow and you'll be kicking yourself for dropping that much coin to fix it.
Honestly I took a look around online, and I haven't really found anything "nice". There's too many "project car" sales going on. I'd rather keep what I have, knowing how reliable it's been for me, where as when you change cars, you never really know 100% that it will take care of you like this car has for me. Plus, I'm not sure if anyone is aware of this, but my automatic transmission is on it's way out. Who in their right mind is going to buy a car like this with the powertrain on its way out, and enough mileage to put it WELL past the mileage of most cars out there, even for this platform?

DocHoliday
10-15-2014, 08:24 AM
Honestly I took a look around online, and I haven't really found anything "nice". There's too many "project car" sales going on. I'd rather keep what I have, knowing how reliable it's been for me, where as when you change cars, you never really know 100% that it will take care of you like this car has for me. Plus, I'm not sure if anyone is aware of this, but my automatic transmission is on it's way out. Who in their right mind is going to buy a car like this with the powertrain on its way out, and enough mileage to put it WELL past the mileage of most cars out there, even for this platform?

So take that 3 grand and add the cost a trans rebuild or at least a used working one plus install. Now you're definitely in the 4-5 grand range.

I bought a VR4 for that kind of money.

Jimvr4
10-15-2014, 01:10 PM
It looks like you are down to doing anything you can to limp through the smog check. If you can't pass then you have a project car on your hands. You say you know what you have but the reality is you don't. You won't know the true status of the motor without tearing it down. If you can't pass smog then you need to find a DD and part this car out unless you can come up with project funds and garage space to work on it :(

IPD
10-16-2014, 07:21 AM
move. fuck california. plenty of states without bullshit emissions checks.

IPD
10-16-2014, 07:23 AM
i wouldn't worry too much about the atx--they're way cheaper to fix than a 6-speed. but yes, if you need a new motor and tranny...it's time for a new car.