PDA

View Full Version : Pacific Muscle Cars



Big_Mike
07-22-2013, 01:41 PM
Okay everyone, as corny as it may sound, I use the term "Pacific Muscle Car" to describe a sports car from Japan (and other Pacific countries) like the 3/S, Skyline, Imprezza, Supra, etc. Although I did not originally coin that phrase (borrowed it from Project Gotham Racing 2), I find it rather interesting since surely some people refuse to call cars like those mentioned above "muscle cars." However, I believe there is a HUGE difference between Pacific and American Muscle. And don't get me wrong I like just about any kind of car. What do you guys and gals think?

RealMcCoy
07-22-2013, 02:12 PM
Being old enough to have become accustomed to the term muscle car as it was originally coined, I can't roll with it... It comes across to me as comparing Ronnie Coleman to Bruce Lee and calling Bruce Japanese Muscle.. They may both be amazing in their own right, but there is no comparing them in a single context.

stealthify
07-22-2013, 05:35 PM
Though I see where you're coming from, when I think of the term 'muscle cars', something very specific comes to mind. It was an era, it was a style, and it was a classification of cars that we weren't really part of.

93STLTH
07-22-2013, 11:33 PM
There's more Pacific coast in the US than in any Asian country. Just sayin'. The Japanese make sports cars, the US makes muscles cars.

Street_Chally73
07-23-2013, 04:53 AM
^agreed...My Stealth shares a spot alongside my muscle car; a '73 Dodge Challenger.

My Challenger sits alongside my sport touring car; a Dodge Stealth R/T Turbo.


Yeah, that works!


Sent from the garage

95gto
07-23-2013, 10:47 AM
Since most people can't decide if a Camaro is a pony car or a muscle car I think you will have a hell of a time trying to call Japanese sports cars muscle cars, pacific or otherwise. Not to mention that a muscle car only does one thing really well where a sports cars does multiple things really well.

I think our cars fall victim to debate as to whether they are a true sports car or a grand touring car.

j2k4
07-23-2013, 11:18 AM
I was there - my first car was a '64 GTO. :)

When I discovered foreign cars and their overall competence relative to American cars, I began to think of American iron as "Muscle-Only" cars.

Don't get me wrong, I still LOVE straight-line power and drags, the Corvette is certainly a respectable platform, and Ford makes the GT, but our automotive history tracks a whole lot differently than the rest of the world.

j2k4
07-23-2013, 11:26 AM
BTW-

The term Pony Car is an understandable but not-very-descriptive adjunct to the success of the Mustang which eventually became another alley of muscle-car development.

The '64 GTO is recognized as the primary Muscle Car, although you might get an argument from those who remember 409 Chevys, 390/406 Fords, and Mopar Wedge fans.

HilbillyHomeboy
07-23-2013, 08:21 PM
I can't get on board with that, sorry.

I'll take a 70 GSX Stage 1, in Saturn yellow, please.

Jeremy

j2k4
07-23-2013, 10:09 PM
I can't get on board with that, sorry.

I'll take a 70 GSX Stage 1, in Saturn yellow, please.

Jeremy

Xlnt choice, Jeremy.

I owned a red '71 Stage; always coveted the GSX, but I couldn't talk my neighbor out of his. :)

Can't get on-board with what?

Big_Mike
07-23-2013, 10:19 PM
Good point(s)!

HilbillyHomeboy
07-24-2013, 11:08 AM
Xlnt choice, Jeremy.

I owned a red '71 Stage; always coveted the GSX, but I couldn't talk my neighbor out of his. :)

Can't get on-board with what?

The "Pacific Muscle Car" moniker.

Jeremy

j2k4
07-24-2013, 11:11 AM
The "Pacific Muscle Car" moniker.

Jeremy

Oh, absolutely right, there. :)

BaadVR4
07-24-2013, 05:33 PM
Weelllllllllllllllllllllllllllllll, boys and girls, not to rain on anyone's parade, BUT:

From Wiki:
Merriam-Webster dictionary defines muscle cars as "any of a group of American-made 2-door sports coupes with powerful engines designed for high-performance driving."[2] A large V8 engine is fitted in a 2-door, rear wheel drive, family-style mid-size or full-size car designed for four or more passengers. Sold at an affordable price, muscle cars are intended for mainly street use and occasional drag racing.[3][4][5][6] They are distinct from two-seat sports cars and expensive 2+2 GTs intended for high-speed touring and road racing.

And:
Opinions on the origin of the muscle car vary, but the 1949 Oldsmobile Rocket 88, created in response to public interest in speed and power, is often cited as the first muscle car. It featured America's first high-compression overhead valve V8 in the smaller, lighter Oldsmobile 76/Chevy body for six-cylinder engines (as opposed to bigger Olds 98 luxury body).[9]

While I WAS born before the 49 Olds, I wasn't driving yet. But I do have VERY fond memories of:
51-59 Firedome Hemis
57-59 348 Chevies
Multiple 55-59 Pontiac/Olds/Buick V-8 hot rods
59-70s Wedge Mopars
64-71 Hemi Mopars
1963 1/2 Ford Galaxy 500. 4 door pillar sedan with a tri-power 405HP 406CI and a 4 speed. From FoMoCo. Paid $500 for in 1969

You get the idea.

I feel entitled to state, with dogmatic certainty, there was NOT, is NOT and NEVER will be any such thing as "Pacific Muscle Cars". It is a contradiction in terms. And an automotive oxymoron.

As a majority of one, I have spoken. No further commentary required.

j2k4
07-24-2013, 07:14 PM
Weelllllllllllllllllllllllllllllll, boys and girls, not to rain on anyone's parade, BUT:

From Wiki:
Merriam-Webster dictionary defines muscle cars as "any of a group of American-made 2-door sports coupes with powerful engines designed for high-performance driving."[2] A large V8 engine is fitted in a 2-door, rear wheel drive, family-style mid-size or full-size car designed for four or more passengers. Sold at an affordable price, muscle cars are intended for mainly street use and occasional drag racing.[3][4][5][6] They are distinct from two-seat sports cars and expensive 2+2 GTs intended for high-speed touring and road racing.

And:
Opinions on the origin of the muscle car vary, but the 1949 Oldsmobile Rocket 88, created in response to public interest in speed and power, is often cited as the first muscle car. It featured America's first high-compression overhead valve V8 in the smaller, lighter Oldsmobile 76/Chevy body for six-cylinder engines (as opposed to bigger Olds 98 luxury body).[9]

While I WAS born before the 49 Olds, I wasn't driving yet. But I do have VERY fond memories of:
51-59 Firedome Hemis
57-59 348 Chevies
Multiple 55-59 Pontiac/Olds/Buick V-8 hot rods
59-70s Wedge Mopars
64-71 Hemi Mopars
1963 1/2 Ford Galaxy 500. 4 door pillar sedan with a tri-power 405HP 406CI and a 4 speed. From FoMoCo. Paid $500 for in 1969

You get the idea.

I feel entitled to state, with dogmatic certainty, there was NOT, is NOT and NEVER will be any such thing as "Pacific Muscle Cars". It is a contradiction in terms. And an automotive oxymoron.

As a majority of one, I have spoken. No further commentary required.

The Olds had a 303, as I recall...my Pops still had his when I was born in '58.

I will defer to Milt's more expansive postage. :wink:

93STLTH
07-25-2013, 01:20 AM
Is this where the old guys check in?? :lo5l:

While I'm pretty sure Japan has never made a car that could be considered in the muscle car class, the US has attempted to make sports cars that are similar to Japanese offerings. Most have failed though, at least, in the US market. Dodge Daytona and the Mercury Capri come to mind.

RealMcCoy
07-25-2013, 01:25 AM
Is this where the old guys check in?? :lo5l:


Apparently... Sure are a lot of us in here. :D

Street_Chally73
07-25-2013, 05:39 AM
Most have failed though, at least, in the US market. Dodge Daytona....


:cough: :cough: Shelby Charger :cough:

Those have still quite the cult following..,hell, I'd rock a Daytona Z if I could find a clean one...those Turbo 2.2s can make some power & take a beating!!



Sent from the garage

IPD
07-25-2013, 12:21 PM
japan has never made a muscle car. thank god. muscle car is something with absurd amounts of hp and no other redeeming qualities. i like twisties too much. pontiac--thank god--has finally DIAF as payment for the transgression of naming that brick shit-slab a "GTO".

BaadVR4
07-25-2013, 01:12 PM
"Old-est Guy" round two:

I don't have any pics of my first brand new car, a '67 GTX 440 wedge. With 4:30 gears, I don't remember ever losing a street race. (Including one best 2 out of 3 against a 435HP 427CI TriPower 69 Vette).

I DO HAVE PICS of my second new car. 69 Road Runner, 440 6BBL (Six Pack was the Dodge name). Fenderwell headers and a 4:56 went in the car before I took delivery. I never lost a street race with this car. I sold the car in Hawaii in 1971. The third owner after me contacted me in 2010 to tell me about the car and get more of the car's history. The pics are from May of 2011:

http://i221.photobucket.com/albums/dd54/BaadVR4/69RR3.jpg (http://s221.photobucket.com/user/BaadVR4/media/69RR3.jpg.html)

http://i221.photobucket.com/albums/dd54/BaadVR4/69RR5.jpg (http://s221.photobucket.com/user/BaadVR4/media/69RR5.jpg.html)

http://i221.photobucket.com/albums/dd54/BaadVR4/69RR4.jpg (http://s221.photobucket.com/user/BaadVR4/media/69RR4.jpg.html)

http://i221.photobucket.com/albums/dd54/BaadVR4/69RR.jpg (http://s221.photobucket.com/user/BaadVR4/media/69RR.jpg.html)

http://i221.photobucket.com/albums/dd54/BaadVR4/69RR2.jpg (http://s221.photobucket.com/user/BaadVR4/media/69RR2.jpg.html)

Chrysler entered the "muscle car wars" with the "Scat Pack". And Plymouth ads blared out "and the beat goes on" ala Sonny and Cher. The four color glossy brochure for the Plymouth muscle car line up proudly boasted: "This book is respectfully dedicated to the guy who would trade his sweet old Granny for a good, fast car."

And the "Red Stripe" Goodyear Polyglass tires on bare rims with special chrome lug nuts are exactly correct.

Enjoy!!!!!!! (or just drool!!!!!!!!!).

j2k4
07-25-2013, 01:21 PM
Memories...

Thanks, Milt.

Only pics of any of my cars that survived my divorce are in my garage; the rest are in the ether. :sad:

HilbillyHomeboy
07-25-2013, 02:16 PM
Oh lord, that Road Runner is truly badass. Wow! I was born too late... :(

Jeremy

j2k4
07-25-2013, 02:22 PM
Wow! I was born too late... :(

Jeremy

Yes, you were.

Slightly. :)

Street_Chally73
07-25-2013, 02:24 PM
Mmm, an A-12 RR!!


Sent from the garage

Alan92RTTT
07-26-2013, 02:49 PM
This is a thread about muscle cars. Their is no call for personal attacks.

If you have an issue please report the post and ignore it. Let Jeremy or myself take a look and deal with the issue. We do have jobs so it might take a while before we can look so just let it go and wait for us to deal with it.

Stay on topic

95gto
07-26-2013, 03:19 PM
I thought this was a thread about the automobile equivalent to a chupacabra

anyonebutme
07-26-2013, 04:42 PM
My post dissapeared.....and it was totally on the level.

Back to pacific muscle........has nothing to do with american muscle, its about a Japanese plain car that the factory stuffed in a more powerful engine than necessary. It has muscle. All the people butthurt about a term that didn't originally apply to 70% of the cars people call muscle cars today need to get a life. Z28 wasn't a muscle car by definition (it was originally designation for the trans am spec iirc)...the SS was closer but the chassis was a "pony" car size. People over the years tended to mold the term to fit ALL american v8 cars of the decade.

Cars like the Nissan skyline gtr and gts fit this bill nicely, they are plain Japanese cars stuffed with tons of HP and options by the factory........wow, sounds like exactly what Pontiac did that coined the term to start with.

BTW, NO mustang technically can be called a muscle car. Just putting that out there.

HilbillyHomeboy
07-26-2013, 05:14 PM
Sorry ABM, the cow catcher sometimes snags "good" posts, too. Thanks for re-posting. :)

Jeremy

R/T93
07-26-2013, 05:41 PM
He is talking about the trans am racing series not the firebird hence the trans am spec phrase he used.

j2k4
07-26-2013, 07:51 PM
The term "Muscle Car" - as I recall - was applied retroactively as the phenomenon of the '64 GTO (big-cube sedan) demanded explanation in the markets after Pontiac's core design/engineering people talked themselves into sneaking it past their bosses into production and then reporting tidy sales as a follow-on.

There are lots of rumors about that end of things, but the term issued from the media/car-enthusiast crowd, and it was a natural; lots of "Murrica" appeal.

I think, though, the umbrella of "Muscle car" has to be applied from a different perspective.

If we can agree, at least, that the term popularized with the GTO (Pontiac specie), then proceed to apply the simple Muscle Car formula of "Large-Cube Sedan", everything that follows is a big-block sedan.

I know this is not the case, cuz having had an SS396 Camaro to start, with roughly ten other BBC cars, and finishing with a '73 SS454 Chevelle and not even venturing into BB Fords, Buicks, Oldsmobiles, Pontiacs and Mercurys I've owned, I cannot look at a Camaro and see a sedan.

Nor a Firebird, a Mustang, or a Cougar.

I've had more small-block Camaros, Mustangs, Firebirds and Cougars than big-blocks by far, and if I limit my offerings to a '68 Z28, a '70-1/2 Z28, a '69 Boss 302, a '70 Cougar Eliminator, and a '71 Boss 351 Mustang, I can tell you that those were Muscle Cars.

I wouldn't suggest it as a standard, necessarily, but I've always thought a street car that could get inside 14 seconds was worth that status.

So-

Body type kills the 'sedan' issue, and hot small-blocks address the matter of inches.

My two cents, at any rate.

Small blocks also, for the price-difference, gave a lot more people access to the action, and in the spirit of Obama...:lol:

anyonebutme
07-26-2013, 08:55 PM
FWIW, I also do not consider a 3S a muscle car. You are also missing my entire point of "japanese muscle" being nothing like "american muscle". You just can't put your own culture background on something and expect it to match the rest of the world. Saying that muscle [powerful] cars have to have big cube engines or lot of torque just doesn't cut it. By both of your standard the shitbox domestic diesel cars of the 80's are "muscle cars". They had shit-tonnes of torque and 4 doors....

Trans-Am Series - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trans-Am_Series)

anyways, point was the small block performance packages (Z28, ect) were a direct result of the big 3 going racing against each other in a class with a 5.0L displacement limit in what was at the time the premier roadracing championship in the USA, rivaling NASCAR in the level of [unofficial mostly] factory support. It then spilled over into IMSA GT and other international series. I will go out and just say that the small block packages would not have ever happened if it wasn't for Roger Penske and Bud Moore, both who knew the big blocks just didn't have the power delivery style needed for roadracing.

Related note, the TransAm series was a reason behind Ford's collection of Jaguar. Not only did they revive a brand, but got a few championships out of the deal....win-win.


First thing is first, we have to all come to and agreement on what is the technical definition of "muscle car" in modern times.

I'm going with "a vehicle that shares chassis and body with a lesser model but has a far larger power output than it's platform stable-mates". revise.

j2k4
07-26-2013, 09:16 PM
FWIW, I also do not consider a 3S a muscle car. You are also missing my entire point of "japanese muscle" being nothing like "american muscle". You just can't put your own culture background on something and expect it to match the rest of the world. Saying that muscle [powerful] cars have to have big cube engines or lot of torque just doesn't cut it. By both of your standard the shitbox domestic diesel cars of the 80's are "muscle cars". They had shit-tonnes of torque and 4 doors....

Agreed - though many of the things we do to the 3S are geared to muscle and the beef to withstand it.

The fact drags are a feature of the NGs informs us of this.

As to the term, it pervades - to an extent - the ensuing history of the rest of the automotive world, insofar as America and it's auto industry had primacy in so many ways.

That is to say only that you could probably have talked to any engineer in Japan who worked in iron or steel during that period and gotten a correct answer to the question, "What is a Muscle Car", or, マッスルカー.

While a 3S may have been a next-generation Japanese interpretation of the American Muscle car, we would reserve to right to say that while a 3S is NOT a Muscle Car, it might be the echo of one. :)


anyways, point was the small block performance packages (Z28, ect) were a direct result of the big 3 going racing against each other in a class with a 5.0L displacement limit in what was at the time the premier roadracing championship in the USA, rivaling NASCAR in the level of [unofficial mostly] factory support. It then spilled over into IMSA GT and other international series. I will go out and just say that the small block packages would not have ever happened if it wasn't for Roger Penske and Bud Moore, both who knew the big blocks just didn't have the power delivery style needed for roadracing.

Exactly, and you might add that the demand for weight-savings led to the slightly weaker small-block and the myriad power-adders we employ to make up the difference.


First thing is first, we have to all come to and agreement on what is the technical definition of "muscle car" in modern times.

I'm going with "a vehicle that shares chassis and body with a lesser model but has a far larger power output than it's platform stable-mates". revise.

Sure.

How can we not? :wink:

BaadVR4
07-26-2013, 09:54 PM
A few random thoughts:

The biggest reason big blocks couldn't go road racing was weight..........both overall and distribution. Not only were the big blocks of the day a huge overall weight gain, most of it was over the front wheels...........lose-lose for road racing.

The factory rating for the Z-28 302 was 290 HP (at the crank). Dyno results were more like 400 (again at the crank).

The primary purpose of the "pony" cars (Mustang/Camaro/Firebird/Challenger/Barracuda/Cougar/etc) performance upgrades was to win in the "trans-am" series. The big block pony cars originated in various dealerships who made "custom" packages through "dealer installed options". These were so popular the factories picked them up for "special ordering".

The dyno chart for igofast's 95 VR4 show 598 ft-lbs torque and 609 hp. At the WHEELS. That's more than a match for most A/S and SS/A Hemi cars.

Whatever your ""end of the day" personal definition of what constitutes a "muscle car" might be, absolute HP/Torque numbers are not the "be all/end all" criteria. Nor are the corporate reasons for producing any particular package. But, as someone who was "of an age" to have been an active, licensed to drive participant in the "muscle car era", I am of the opinion I have a "leg up" on most here when it comes to knowing what a "muscle car" is or is not. Agree/disagree/don't care..................all the same to me. So, I stand by my previous posts regarding the definition of "muscle car".

Just my 1.5 cents worth

j2k4
07-26-2013, 09:58 PM
A few random thoughts:

The biggest reason big blocks couldn't go road racing was weight..........both overall and distribution. Not only were the big blocks of the day a huge overall weight gain, most of it was over the front wheels...........lose-lose for road racing.

The factory rating for the Z-28 302 was 290 HP (at the crank). Dyno results were more like 400 (again at the crank).

The primary purpose of the "pony" cars (Mustang/Camaro/Firebird/Challenger/Barracuda/Cougar/etc) performance upgrades was to win in the "trans-am" series. The big block pony cars originated in various dealerships who made "custom" packages through "dealer installed options". These were so popular the factories picked them up for "special ordering".

The dyno chart for igofast's 95 VR4 show 598 ft-lbs torque and 609 hp. At the WHEELS. That's more than a match for most A/S and SS/A Hemi cars.

Whatever your ""end of the day" personal definition of what constitutes a "muscle car" might be, absolute HP/Torque numbers are not the "be all/end all" criteria. Nor are the corporate reasons for producing any particular package. But, as someone who was "of an age" to have been an active, licensed to drive participant in the "muscle car era", I am of the opinion I have a "leg up" on most here when it comes to knowing what a "muscle car" is or is not. Agree/disagree/don't care..................all the same to me. So, I stand by my previous posts regarding the definition of "muscle car".

Just my 1.5 cents worth

Shit, Milt, move over - I'm standing there, too.

I can at least claim to have seen the damn things as you drove by...:p

BaadVR4
07-26-2013, 10:02 PM
And you were droooooooooooooooooollllllllllllllllllllllingggggg gggggggggggggggggggggggggg, right?

j2k4
07-26-2013, 10:13 PM
And you were droooooooooooooooooollllllllllllllllllllllingggggg gggggggggggggggggggggggggg, right?

Nope.

Didn't start drooling until three years ago. :wink:

wingnut
07-26-2013, 10:44 PM
:D fixed...


Nope.

Didn't stop drooling until three years ago.

...and on topic, im trying to find the pics of my old 69 SS , but no luck so far :(

Alan92RTTT
07-26-2013, 11:08 PM
FWIW, I also do not consider a 3S a muscle car.

But, but but.....


First thing is first, we have to all come to and agreement on what is the technical definition of "muscle car" in modern times.

I'm going with "a vehicle that shares chassis and body with a lesser model but has a far larger power output than it's platform stable-mates". revise.
You do realize that by your definition the 3S is a Muscle car :p(at least in the US market)

3000GT VR4 vs Base / SL
Stealth RT/TT vs Base/ES/RT

anyonebutme
07-27-2013, 02:40 AM
Alan double posted...must be trying to up his post count.

wingnut
07-27-2013, 02:47 AM
Alan double posted...must be trying to up his post count.

lol...why not, I'm sure not gonna give him any crap for it http://www.thetruckstop.us/forum/images/smilies/postho.gif

IPD
07-27-2013, 08:54 AM
so you mean a buick electra isn't a muscle car, milt? :(

BaadVR4
07-27-2013, 07:23 PM
so you mean a buick electra isn't a muscle car, milt? :(

Electra? No.
GSX Gran Sport? You bet your sweet ass!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

BaadVR4
07-27-2013, 07:38 PM
And the Grand Nationals are in a category all their own. Whether you consider a Grand National a "muscle" car probably depends on whether or not one of them had just blown the doors off your 70s Hemi-Cuda (an A-Body Hemi 'Cuda would likely not lose). Always those pesky one-off "exceptions". Don't fit quite right anywhere, huh?

anyonebutme
07-28-2013, 02:04 AM
So let me get this straight, an 80's 2 door V6 turbo is muscle while a later 80's 2 door V6 turbo that came with more power from the factory is not?

93STLTH
07-28-2013, 02:34 AM
So let me get this straight, an 80's 2 door V6 turbo is muscle while a later 80's 2 door V6 turbo that came with more power from the factory is not?

Now you're getting it!

IPD
07-28-2013, 07:55 AM
precisely why the GNX is not a muscle-car, nor the 3/s. i still maintain that the defining characteristics of a muscle-car are:

heavy
powerful
handles like shit

R/T93
07-28-2013, 10:18 AM
precisely why the GNX is not a muscle-car, nor the 3/s. i still maintain that the defining characteristics of a muscle-car are:

heavy
powerful
handles like shit

The origigal GTO really isn't heavy... and it was the first muscle car for the public.

From the phone.

j2k4
07-28-2013, 10:44 AM
I think some qualification is required.

The term became popular before these other vehicles (GN, et al) came to be, but was current during the birth of the big-block pony cars (Mustang, Camaro, 'Cuda, Challenger).

I believe we have sort of established - tell me if I'm wrong - that the parameters of "Muscle Car" (while not all-inclusive) are limited to V8-powered vehicles.

While I think this condition is arbitrary, I think it's proper, because as it was coined, it took into account that which was current, and can only be applied retroactively to include such as the old Pontiacs, the BB Fords, Chevys, and Mopars; the various lightweight cars would necessarily be included.

To apply it to cars from succeeding eras, then, should at least require adherence to the V8 formula, I think.

I don't see why we need to water down the meaning of the term by fighting to make it all-inclusive, primarily because we have language to define a difference - generationally, or whichever way we prefer.

It's not as if the term needs to be kept current, is it?

We're talking fast cars, quick cars...surely we can come up with descriptives?

BaadVR4
07-28-2013, 11:24 AM
Never said I held the GN (T-Type) was a muscle car. Said it was in a "class of its own", a "pesky one-off exception".

Just like igofasts's VR4, the Buick turbo entry made far more than enough power to compete at the top of the "muscle car" food chain. NEITHER IS A MUSCLE CAR.

As for the 64 GTO being the "first" "muscle car", I repeat:

"Opinions on the origin of the muscle car vary, but the 1949 Oldsmobile Rocket 88, created in response to public interest in speed and power, is often cited as the first muscle car. It featured America's first high-compression overhead valve V8 in the smaller, lighter Oldsmobile 76/Chevy body for six-cylinder engines (as opposed to bigger Olds 98 luxury body).[9]"

That was taken from Wikipedia. Enthusiasts of every ilk and stripe will claim their beloved brand is the true, original muscle car. Here's a sample from the Hudson camp:

"1951 was the first year for the Hornet, which boasted a 308-cubic-inch dual-carb flathead six — the biggest engine Hudson offered. With 145 horsepower, it was more powerful than Oldsmobile’s overhead-valve V-8."

The claim "more powerful than Oldsmobile's overhead-valve V-8" was true; and the power came from a more traditional in-line 6 cylinder. And the fight was on!!!

EVERYBODY had a horse in the race...more than one manufacturer had multiple entries..And they all claimed the "King of the Hill" spot in one form or another...Wins in Nascar/NHRA/etc/etc were more coveted than all the Motor Trend accolades ever penned..If there was a race and your car/brand won???? That was better than sex.....(obviously, because not many 14-18 y/o boys were having sex in 1955).......but every teen-aged boy was able to live those moments when the stars aligned and HE won......On the street, at the strip, one win or a career's worth......made no difference.......for that one moment, frozen forever in his memory.........HE was KING!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

And that is what fuels our passion. Whatever the genre of our passion may be..............

IPD
07-28-2013, 12:05 PM
good point, milt. so the term is inherently ambiguous. so is the term "sports car". hell, "GTO" isn't supposed to be an ambiguous term, and pontiac fucked that right up.

j2k4
07-28-2013, 12:22 PM
Never said I held the GN (T-Type) was a muscle car. Said it was in a "class of its own", a "pesky one-off exception".

Just like igofasts's VR4, the Buick turbo entry made far more than enough power to compete at the top of the "muscle car" food chain. NEITHER IS A MUSCLE CAR.

As for the 64 GTO being the "first" "muscle car", I repeat:

"Opinions on the origin of the muscle car vary, but the 1949 Oldsmobile Rocket 88, created in response to public interest in speed and power, is often cited as the first muscle car. It featured America's first high-compression overhead valve V8 in the smaller, lighter Oldsmobile 76/Chevy body for six-cylinder engines (as opposed to bigger Olds 98 luxury body).[9]"

That was taken from Wikipedia. Enthusiasts of every ilk and stripe will claim their beloved brand is the true, original muscle car. Here's a sample from the Hudson camp:

"1951 was the first year for the Hornet, which boasted a 308-cubic-inch dual-carb flathead six — the biggest engine Hudson offered. With 145 horsepower, it was more powerful than Oldsmobile’s overhead-valve V-8."

The claim "more powerful than Oldsmobile's overhead-valve V-8" was true; and the power came from a more traditional in-line 6 cylinder. And the fight was on!!!

EVERYBODY had a horse in the race...more than one manufacturer had multiple entries..And they all claimed the "King of the Hill" spot in one form or another...Wins in Nascar/NHRA/etc/etc were more coveted than all the Motor Trend accolades ever penned..If there was a race and your car/brand won???? That was better than sex.....(obviously, because not many 14-18 y/o boys were having sex in 1955).......but every teen-aged boy was able to live those moments when the stars aligned and HE won......On the street, at the strip, one win or a career's worth......made no difference.......for that one moment, frozen forever in his memory.........HE was KING!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

And that is what fuels our passion. Whatever the genre of our passion may be..............

Didn't mean to imply you thought the GN belonged, Milt, just that we need to find a place for it and the other vehicles that came after "Muscle Car", and manage a way to fit them in, relatively-speaking.

We're trying to dope out how to define/categorize the high-performance-genre, past-present, right?

All the different spines under the umbrella should allow us to do this, and "Muscle Car" can reasonably constitute one of the spines. :)


good point, milt. so the term is inherently ambiguous. so is the term "sports car". hell, "GTO" isn't supposed to be an ambiguous term, and pontiac fucked that right up.

Yes, we get that, Thadd - the Pontiac GTO isn't a Ferrari, and doesn't belong in the same sentence. :D

wingnut
07-28-2013, 06:20 PM
So after 6 pages, 53 posts (and a slight derailment) the answer to the question...


What do you guys and gals think?

...is still "no" :D

BaadVR4
07-28-2013, 06:42 PM
Ahhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh..................... .now it begins to crystallize!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!... ..............it's all in the eye of the beholder! And, somewhat like an electron at the quantum level, it CAN BE in more than one place (or car) at the same time.

Ferrari manufactured the term out of their marketing/advertising brain trust, not their hand crafted, seriously engineered automotive production team. Just like Pontiac did. Just different cars (very, VERY different cars) for different audiences.

And the passing of 50+ years has seen advances in every science that impacts a car's performances to the point we have all but completely redesigned the entire car. Fuel injection. Electronic controls. Computerized performance. As clever as the vehicles of yesteryear were, they are no match for today's electronic marvels. In 1957, 2.0 HP per cubic inch was Top Fuel territory. With today's ignition/fuel controls and superior metallurgic designs, we have DD cars making over 3.0 HP/c.i.

Yet here we are. There are still cars........different, but recognizable even to us fossils.............there are still horses and races (hell, a bunch more than there were in 1957, both manufacturers and racing venues).......and there are still the dreams..........the passion.

Like many other pursuits of passion, my advice: "Lead, follow or get out of the way"

Just my 1.5 cents worth

j2k4
07-28-2013, 07:44 PM
Ahhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh..................... .now it begins to crystallize!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!... ..............it's all in the eye of the beholder! And, somewhat like an electron at the quantum level, it CAN BE in more than one place (or car) at the same time.

Ferrari manufactured the term out of their marketing/advertising brain trust, not their hand crafted, seriously engineered automotive production team. Just like Pontiac did. Just different cars (very, VERY different cars) for different audiences.

And the passing of 50+ years has seen advances in every science that impacts a car's performances to the point we have all but completely redesigned the entire car. Fuel injection. Electronic controls. Computerized performance. As clever as the vehicles of yesteryear were, they are no match for today's electronic marvels. In 1957, 2.0 HP per cubic inch was Top Fuel territory. With today's ignition/fuel controls and superior metallurgic designs, we have DD cars making over 3.0 HP/c.i.

Yet here we are. There are still cars........different, but recognizable even to us fossils.............there are still horses and races (hell, a bunch more than there were in 1957, both manufacturers and racing venues).......and there are still the dreams..........the passion.

Like many other pursuits of passion, my advice: "Lead, follow or get out of the way"

Just my 1.5 cents worth

Four wheels then, four wheels now. :wink:

93STLTH
07-28-2013, 07:54 PM
Four wheels then, four wheels now. :wink:

http://www.remarkablecars.com/main/messerschmitt/messerschmitt-00001-1.jpg

:bigthumb:

j2k4
07-28-2013, 08:00 PM
http://www.remarkablecars.com/main/messerschmitt/messerschmitt-00001-1.jpg

:bigthumb:

A Messyshitt is not, never was, and never shall be a muscle car...cuz it's missing the all-important 4th wheel. :rolleyes:

RealMcCoy
07-28-2013, 10:34 PM
(and a slight derailment)

At the risk of him getting all but hurt over such an egregious personal insult, I'm still calling Kevin an old goat for using the term "jimmy equipment..." :lol:

j2k4
07-29-2013, 08:13 AM
At the risk of him getting all but hurt over such an egregious personal insult, I'm still calling Kevin an old goat for using the term "jimmy equipment..." :lol:

I don't think I actually heard anyone say Gee-Em-Cee until I was in my teens. :D

BaadVR4
07-29-2013, 10:51 AM
Just proves aviation engineering excellence doesn't necessarily translate to automotive engineering excellence. Or even adequacy.

Not to mention it is nearly as butt-ugly as the Citroen 2CV-6.

IPD
07-29-2013, 02:46 PM
Just proves aviation engineering excellence doesn't necessarily translate to automotive engineering excellence. Or even adequacy.

Not to mention it is nearly as butt-ugly as the Citroen 2CV-6.

tru'er words were never spoken about BMW. or mitsubishi.... :suspect:

93STLTH
07-30-2013, 01:21 AM
Just proves aviation engineering excellence doesn't necessarily translate to automotive engineering excellence. Or even adequacy.

Not to mention it is nearly as butt-ugly as the Citroen 2CV-6.

While I agree it is ugly, there's this to consider...


The top result at the RM Auctions Bruce Weiner Microcar Museum sale went to the 1958 F.M.R. Tg 500 “Tiger”, the rarest Messerschmitt of all and the fastest microcar ever built with a top speed of 78 mph. Attracting an opening bid of $140,000, bidding saw its price quickly escalate to a final $322,000 – a world record for a microcar sold at auction.

j2k4
08-14-2013, 12:09 PM
Just thought of something potentially important that may bear on this question, and that is the division between full-framed and unibody cars, which may indicate a separation of the Muscle Car/Pony Car categories.

Whatcha think?