PDA

View Full Version : NG13 Dyno Day Results



rdmelton
07-13-2013, 06:08 PM
Thanks to Bill Buell and Morgans Motorsports for sponsoring the NG13 dyno day. Everything went very well. One footnote is that this dyno is a Dyno Dynamics, and several people have indicated that this dyno consistently reads quite a bit lower than other dynos (such as Dynojet)

Here are pictures of the dyno runs: NG13 Dyno Day Photos by rdmelton | Photobucket (http://s1281.photobucket.com/user/rdmelton/library/NG13%20Dyno%20Day?sort=3&page=1)

The car number is the I.D. number in the upper left. I will let each owner list their mods and any other info on each run. If someone does not want their dyno plots posted, please send me a PM and I will remove it.

Alex3000gt
07-13-2013, 06:40 PM
Thanks for putting this together guys, and thanks Bob for posting this!

J. Fast
07-13-2013, 10:18 PM
Who broke 500?

R/T93
07-14-2013, 03:11 AM
Scott Johnson (Checkeredvr4). No nitrous. Not maxxed out by any means (turbos)

From the phone.

familyMAN
07-14-2013, 11:36 AM
What mods were on the 220-240 hp dynos? If they were close to stock, than that dyno doesn't read really low....If they were full BPU, then it probably is low when compared to a dynojet.

lawdogg
07-14-2013, 12:52 PM
Congrats guys! Have the drags happened yet? Hopefully we can compare some of those charts to track times!

R/T93
07-14-2013, 03:34 PM
Congrats guys! Have the drags happened yet? Hopefully we can compare some of those charts to track times!

Von Trapped 124. Checkered on his fun run went 133. His car is full weight +.

I was trapping 104 mph and dynod 262 on Von's dyno. The dyno reads low comparatively.

From the phone.

lawdogg
07-14-2013, 04:54 PM
Nice - so 133 to 511, and 104 to 262? Which was von's chart? I'll make a graph with whoever wants me to add their data. I'm pretty curious to plot it and fit a regression line! Then we can compare similar regression lines between different dynos. FWIW, I did 116 with 330 dyno dynamics awhp. Sorry, I'll shut up. PM me if you want a data point!

R/T93
07-14-2013, 06:02 PM
Checkered didnt spray on the dyno but on the 133 run he did.

From the phone.

TurboSinceBirth
07-14-2013, 07:09 PM
Von Trapped 124. Checkered on his fun run went 133. His car is full weight +.

I was trapping 104 mph and dynod 262 on Von's dyno. The dyno reads low comparatively.

From the phone.

Actually, if Von's dyno read 262 for your car seeing your mods that's spot on with where you should be. Plenty of stock 9b cars have dyno'd 250-270AWHP with a boost controller and intake. I don't know why it would be different on higher hp cars.

R/T93
07-14-2013, 07:12 PM
Actually, if Von's dyno read 262 for your car seeing your mods that's spot on with where you should be. Plenty of stock 9b cars have dyno'd 250-270AWHP with a boost controller and intake. I don't know why it would be different on higher hp cars.

Cuz it takes 400 crank hp to take a 4050 lb car to 107 mph like i did last month. 400 crank is not 260 wheel. Add 20-22% for dynojet conversion

From the phone.

R/T93
07-14-2013, 07:13 PM
Also there was another 9b car that was in the 220's. I was out trapping him by 3-5 mph.

From the phone.

TurboSinceBirth
07-14-2013, 07:18 PM
Cuz it takes 400 crank hp to take a 4050 lb car to 107 mph like i did last month. 400 crank is not 260 wheel. Add 20-22% for dynojet conversion

From the phone.

I'm sorry but you're not making 400 crank hp running 14 psi of boost. You will need other mods to your car. Twisted ran 107 mph just like you and dyno'd 269AWHP/290AWTQ. Your dyno was very similar. AWHP Vs HP Vs BHP - Page 6 - 3000GT/Stealth International Message Center (http://www.3si.org/forum/f1/awhp-vs-hp-vs-bhp-536131/index6.html) I can provide a very long list of bpu or less 9b cars on the dyno with what numbers they put down. Some hit the track too. 2-3 psi over stock is another 30AWHP at most. Given how out of breathe 9bs are towards redline a stock car at 320hp with more boost may only be at 355hp now.


Also there was another 9b car that was in the 220's. I was out trapping him by 3-5 mph.

From the phone.

3-5 mph is not hard to make up. It can be the difference between a very healthy running car and one that has some issues.

R/T93
07-14-2013, 07:41 PM
I'm sorry but you're not making 400 crank hp running 14 psi of boost. You will need other mods to your car. Twisted ran 107 mph just like you and dyno'd 269AWHP/290AWTQ. Your dyno was very similar. AWHP Vs HP Vs BHP - Page 6 - 3000GT/Stealth International Message Center (http://www.3si.org/forum/f1/awhp-vs-hp-vs-bhp-536131/index6.html) I can provide a very long list of bpu or less 9b cars on the dyno with what numbers they put down. Some hit the track too. 2-3 psi over stock is another 30AWHP at most. Given how out of breathe 9bs are towards redline a stock car at 320hp with more boost may only be at 355hp now.



3-5 mph is not hard to make up. It can be the difference between a very healthy running car and one that has some issues.

Lol ok. Put it in any wallace racing horsepower calculator.
Bill Cooper dynod 312 awhp on stock fuel and 12 psi.
Explain that please? Seriously, explain it as it counters your entire previous post about mods and boost and also supports my previous completely.

From the phone.

Alex3000gt
07-14-2013, 10:27 PM
Cool! Hopefully the owner doesn't mind disclosing the exact #s, for the chart!

The man you seek is Uniuno.

Alex3000gt
07-14-2013, 10:31 PM
Just a friendly reminder before arguments break out on here, a dynamometer is a tool and nothing else. This tool is used to make A to B comparisons on your setup to help understand if your mods or tuning are taking you in the right direction. The real essence of the matter is who makes it to the finish line first after that light turns green - everything else is background noise.

Uniuno
07-14-2013, 11:01 PM
Yes, that was my car that was being out trapped. On our final run he was only .9 mph faster than me but he did get me by .4 seconds. It was an amazing run and I enjoyed it immensely!

My 9b car is on a Chrome ECU with stock tune, 9:1 pistons, hotwired Wally 255, Kind of lightweight flywheel, lightweight pulley, 360 injectors, Aeromotive fpr, and FMIC. I think that's all the relevant stuff. I was easing out of the hole at 3-4k rpms, it was my first time at the strip with this car. My best 60 foot was 2.015s. I don't mind sharing numbers, graphs, or whatever. So just ask.

TurboSinceBirth
07-14-2013, 11:01 PM
Lol ok. Put it in any wallace racing horsepower calculator.
Bill Cooper dynod 312 awhp on stock fuel and 12 psi.
Explain that please? Seriously, explain it as it counters your entire previous post about mods and boost and also supports my previous completely.

From the phone.

But what was his trap speed? According to your theory he should be making 375bhp and trapping probably 105-106. His numbers may be a little bit of a stretch unless he has more than a few mods which is why I'd want the list and track trap speeds since that will indicate his real hp. Horsepower calculators are just that an estimate. They get close but the real world results speak for themselves. A dyno is a tuning tool. There are dyno results of bpu cars over 300AWHP and a few around 320AWHP but they can read high or low. I'm wanting trap speeds for those cars that dyno'd close to 320AWHP since that should be a 107 mph trap according to you and Bill should be very close to their. It seems like it would be hard to pick up 80bhp off an intake, downpipe, boost controller, and no other mods but maybe there's a few healthy factory freaks out there to back up the trap speeds. 350bhp(280AWHP) seems a little more plausible.

Uniuno
07-14-2013, 11:22 PM
My best trap was 100.33 and my worst was 98.05 with 14.3ET. My best ET was 13.8.

pezcore
07-14-2013, 11:32 PM
Here is mine. It's the 06 WRX. http://i1281.photobucket.com/albums/a505/rdmelton/NG13%20Dyno%20Day/115-3_zpsfea334f8.jpg

I think the dip in mine can be explained by Von letting the RPMs sit at 4k before getting on it again because I definitely didn't feel any power drop at any of the other events. Only Von can tell me for sure. If I ever get it dyno'd again I can compare.


Related mod list

Kinugawa TD06SL 18G (heatwrapped)
Grimmspeed Up pipe (heatwrapped)
Injector Dynamics 1000cc Injectors
Walbro 255lph Fuel Pump
Fender intake + stock airbox
Tsudo Catless downpipe (heatwrapped), HKS catless midpipe, straightpipe exhaust
STI TMIC + ZeroSports IC Splitter

Thanks for having the Dyno Day!

vr4tune
07-15-2013, 12:02 AM
Lol ok. Put it in any wallace racing horsepower calculator.
Bill Cooper dynod 312 awhp on stock fuel and 12 psi.
Explain that please? Seriously, explain it as it counters your entire previous post about mods and boost and also supports my previous completely.

From the phone.

to add to your argument Nate, here is my 9b dyno.

Mod list was (k&n FPIC, Tanabe concept g blue exhaust, HKS ebc, and a HKS bov).

Purple graph was 15 psi peak
Black graph was 12.5 psi peak

http://i591.photobucket.com/albums/ss357/vr4tune/charts/scan0003.jpg

http://i591.photobucket.com/albums/ss357/vr4tune/charts/scan0002.jpg

CoopKill
07-15-2013, 12:35 AM
I was on English racing's dynojet, 312.9 uncorrected, 309.x corrected. Had to run it through a calc to get corrected numbers. FIPK, exhaust intake pipes, ic pipes, hks4 evc, hks bov, 92 pump.

The question about the 3 runs I have is the gear ratio in the upper left of the picture. I do not know enough about dyno's to know what that means, or affects.

https://lh4.googleusercontent.com/-1bVP7CY_Phs/T3pZnbUQmBI/AAAAAAAANbU/GiXFFHeq2D8/s800/1428424766.jpg

Jeff V.
07-15-2013, 12:45 AM
The question about the 3 runs I have is the gear ratio in the upper left of the picture. I do not know enough about dyno's to know what that means, or affects.

Dynos measure torque, and calculate horsepower based on that.

Your transmission is a torque multiplier (or divider in the overdrive gears). Hence, the gear ratios.

Many RWD cars have a 1.0:1 3rd or 4th gear. Dyno the car in that 1.0:1 gear, you're measuring actual engine torque minus drivetrain losses. There's no torque multiplication (or division) taking place.

The 3S does not have a 1.0:1 gear in any version of the transmission. So any torque you're seeing on the dyno is engine torque minus driveline parasitic loss multiplied or divided by whatever gear the dyno run was done in

Any dyno operator that does not take this into account, adds yet another variable to the already long list that makes dyno to dyno comparisons nearly impossible.

Have fun feeding that into your simulators.

Alex3000gt
07-15-2013, 01:36 AM
So, chances are that if you dyno'd at the NG, your 1/4 mile trap would equal your peak dyno HP * 0.1159 plus 74.759. :p

(trap in MPH = 0.1159*HP + 74.759)

That'll get more accurate as I get more data. (Current R^2 = 0.9816 based on 4 data points.)


Once you have enough points you should try a logarithmic or power curve and let me know what you see. My thought is that increased horsepower results in diminishing returns with trap speed due to aerodynamic drag being a function of v^2.

This is fun.

whitedragon
07-15-2013, 03:51 PM
Here is mine. It's the 06 WRX. http://i1281.photobucket.com/albums/a505/rdmelton/NG13%20Dyno%20Day/115-3_zpsfea334f8.jpg

I think the dip in mine can be explained by Von letting the RPMs sit at 4k before getting on it again because I definitely didn't feel any power drop at any of the other events. Only Von can tell me for sure. If I ever get it dyno'd again I can compare.


I'm pretty sure Von told you the dip was because your car was trying to come out of the rollers as it was dyno'd. From the outside, you could see the tires start to creep up the rollers a bit right as the dyno dipped. It's hard to strap a Subi down and that was reflected on the chart.

Checkered vr4
07-15-2013, 05:07 PM
5681Here are some #'s for you to play with.

rdmelton
07-15-2013, 05:10 PM
I can give my info, but it may be misleading. I made 372 WHP, but when I was at the track the stock clutch wouldn't hold the power so I had to turn down the boost a bit (obviously this directly affects the horsepower I was making at the track) and I was also "launching" at 1500 rpm (doesn't directly affect horsepower but I suspect that I was losing a little trap speed because I was starting so slowly). I had trap speeds around 107-109 mph.

Checkered vr4
07-15-2013, 06:53 PM
That's DR800's at 30 psi, 3.1L, no giggle gas. The time slips show a full pass without N2O, spraying in 2nd through the finnish (against Von), and the last one I sprayed off the line and spun all 4 alot which is why the 60' was slower but mph higher.

lawdogg
07-15-2013, 07:15 PM
Thanks! Congrats on the dyno #s and track times by the way, that's ludicrous speed!

Slacker1357
07-15-2013, 07:17 PM
Too bad I couldn't get on to the Dyno or drags.. But then again, with a bad ECU and improperly gapped plugs, not really going to throw down any decent numbers for an NA.

rdmelton
07-15-2013, 08:51 PM
I found a formula for estimating power from trap speed: HP = weight (in lbs) * (1/4 mile MPH/234)^3. Using an estimated weight of 3900 lb, it gives numbers that are slightly higher than the Morgans Motorsports dyno, but probably consistent with many other AWD dynos.

Checkered vr4
07-16-2013, 12:26 AM
I found a formula for estimating power from trap speed: HP = weight (in lbs) * (1/4 mile MPH/234)^3. Using an estimated weight of 3900 lb, it gives numbers that are slightly higher than the Morgans Motorsports dyno, but probably consistent with many other AWD dynos.
Here is my weight on the scales at just under a half tank of fuel.

familyMAN
07-16-2013, 04:46 PM
So 550awhp, full weight went 126mph. Doesn't seem like the dyno reads as low as it has been made out, to me. Certainly not the 15-20% as was thrown around on the forum. What am I missing?

rdmelton
07-16-2013, 09:06 PM
I agree. I heard several people saying 20-22%, but I think that it is probably closer to 10%.

Checkered vr4
07-16-2013, 11:17 PM
So 550awhp, full weight went 126mph. Doesn't seem like the dyno reads as low as it has been made out, to me. Certainly not the 15-20% as was thrown around on the forum. What am I missing?

You might be missing the fact that my car doesn't make power til 5000 rpm. I acually ran 11.3 with my dr500's and stock maf. Not as much power but it came on much earlier.

familyMAN
07-16-2013, 11:32 PM
We are talking trap, not ET. Bet your DR500 car didn't trap 126. Just saying that based on your results (good by the way:)), this dyno is not 20% lower than a dynojet.

Uniuno
07-17-2013, 01:09 PM
So, chances are that if you dyno'd at the NG, your 1/4 mile trap would equal your peak dyno HP * 0.1159 plus 74.759. :p

(trap in MPH = 0.1159*HP + 74.759)

That'll get more accurate as I get more data. (Current R^2 = 0.9816 based on 4 data points.)

According to your math I should have trapped 100.9524 with my 226awhp.


My best trap was 100.33 and my worst was 98.05 with 14.3ET. My best ET was 13.8.

I guess there's some driver skill I need to find to make up that last .6 :lmao:

Greg E
07-17-2013, 01:28 PM
LOL... My times and traps must show some crazy HP then. ;)

Alex3000gt
07-17-2013, 02:42 PM
Well it's funny, the logarithmic regression line was right on the money using Checkered's 133 trap ... but the 126 threw it all out of wack. :Doh: I need more data. Greg what was yours?

I am trying to think of a way to factor in another critical characteristic, weight.

If every car was the same weight then your curve that is a function of horsepower would predict the trap every time, but if the cars are varying wildly in weight then the results could be skewed.

Think of how to get a trap speed equation that is a function of both weight and horsepower.

Greg E
07-17-2013, 04:25 PM
...or we could just stop bench racing?

Alex3000gt
07-17-2013, 06:12 PM
...or we could just stop bench racing?

Who is doing that? This is just a couple of guys with engineering degrees having fun, party pooper.

Uniuno
07-17-2013, 09:26 PM
...or we could just stop bench racing?

Says the guy with the slower bench :poke:

:lo5l: :lo5l:

Sean Johnson
07-17-2013, 10:04 PM
Saw a couple good numbers. Thnx for posting the results...

Greg E
07-18-2013, 12:30 AM
Says the guy with the slower bench :poke:

:lo5l: :lo5l:

What can I say. Always preferred the hoop spoiler over the park bench. :p

95gto
07-18-2013, 11:05 AM
We are talking trap, not ET. Bet your DR500 car didn't trap 126. Just saying that based on your results (good by the way:)), this dyno is not 20% lower than a dynojet.


So 550awhp, full weight went 126mph. Doesn't seem like the dyno reads as low as it has been made out, to me. Certainly not the 15-20% as was thrown around on the forum. What am I missing?

So just to make sure I am following everyone's thoughts, what power should a car that is running 12.563sec @ 107.47mph be making? The car is stock weight aside from an aluminum drive shaft.

Uniuno
07-18-2013, 11:17 AM
107.47 - 74.759 / 0.1159 = 282.3.

That's the math. Maybe close to what you are making, ignoring variables such as weight, drag, etc..

95gto
07-18-2013, 01:28 PM
107.47 - 74.759 / 0.1159 = 282.3.

That's the math. Maybe close to what you are making, ignoring variables such as weight, drag, etc..

And that math doesn't match other HP calculators based on ET and or trap speed does it. Does that make sense?

Take Bob's car for example, even with turning down his boost and launching at low rpm would we expect him to lose 80hp? His lowest dyno pull suggests he should be trapping in the 116-117mph category, per the equation, yet he was trapping in the 107-109 range.

CoopKill
07-18-2013, 02:02 PM
low voltage in the calculator explains it all! :suspect:

HilbillyHomeboy
07-18-2013, 02:11 PM
I'm going to sponsor the dyno race at next year's NG. It will be on a running track, so we can stagger the starts so it's fair for everyone...

Shut up and race your damn cars!

Jeremy

familyMAN
07-18-2013, 03:47 PM
Obviously, the point of the dyno day at NG is to see what your car puts out which then leads to comparisons. It was not a tuning session, even though its a "tuning dyno." FYI, there is a NG drag thread going right now if you don't care to discuss ("bench race.);)

rdmelton
07-18-2013, 09:20 PM
Think of how to get a trap speed equation that is a function of both weight and horsepower.


I found a formula for estimating power from trap speed: HP = weight (in lbs) * (1/4 mile MPH/234)^3. - You can rearrange it to solve for trap speed if you want. MPH = 234 * (HP/lb)^(1/3)

Levi, using that formula for a 107.5 mph trap with a 3900 lb car, that would be ~378 whp.

R/T93
07-18-2013, 09:23 PM
Well I was trapping 107 with my 9b car 2 months ago and I dyno'd 262 at Von's shop. However I was only trapping 104 in STL.

HilbillyHomeboy
07-18-2013, 09:37 PM
107.5 is definitely well South of 378 wheel.

Jeremy

J. Fast
07-18-2013, 11:51 PM
Well I was trapping 107 with my 9b car 2 months ago and I dyno'd 262 at Von's shop. However I was only trapping 104 in STL.

The DA at the 400ft above sea level track, Gateway Park, was equivalent to 2500ft. You lose roughly 1 mph of trap speed for every 750ft in DA increase. Uncorrected numbers are likely spot on.

pezcore
07-19-2013, 03:12 AM
Here is mine. It's the 06 WRX. http://i1281.photobucket.com/albums/a505/rdmelton/NG13%20Dyno%20Day/115-3_zpsfea334f8.jpg

I think the dip in mine can be explained by Von letting the RPMs sit at 4k before getting on it again because I definitely didn't feel any power drop at any of the other events. Only Von can tell me for sure. If I ever get it dyno'd again I can compare.


Thanks for having the Dyno Day!

Update. Re-tuned a little today, and got a much nicer looking virtual dyno graph. Car definitely feels better. Would love to see how this looks on the same dyno.

https://sphotos-a.xx.fbcdn.net/hphotos-ash4/1003015_10200558964471456_534743981_n.jpg

95gto
07-19-2013, 10:44 AM
- You can rearrange it to solve for trap speed if you want. MPH = 234 * (HP/lb)^(1/3)

Levi, using that formula for a 107.5 mph trap with a 3900 lb car, that would be ~378 whp.

Bob my point is that the equation that was developed in this thread isn't accurate and conclusions drawn from said equation are also inaccurate. Jeremy's comment about da is spot on, and you have to remember that the dyno corrects for temp and humidity. So comparing corrected hp measurements against uncorrected times doesn't work so well.

kywhitelightning
08-03-2013, 05:50 AM
I finally excersized my NG13 demon. I found a busted meth line that looks like it got into a fight with the ds and lost.

http://i495.photobucket.com/albums/rr316/jjd222002/IMAG1232_zps21ba1e07.jpg

The hole.

http://i495.photobucket.com/albums/rr316/jjd222002/IMAG1233_zps548a3caa.jpg

This is how bad it was leaking. I'm really glad the hot exhaust didn't catch it on fire when it sprayed. I suspect that I was out of methanol by the time I even hit the dyno because I would hope that maybe someone would've seen this leak. If not, there wasn't very much actually making it into the motor. My meth tank was empty when I got home.


http://s495.photobucket.com/user/jjd222002/media/VIDEO0117_zps5abcb7b0.mp4.html

The motor seems fine and since I've been back I have changed the oil looking for flakes which I found none and put a new compression union where the bad piece of tubing was. I took it for a test drive and wow it's back to being quick again. There are still some bugs to work out of it but seeing 550 on virtual dyno again is nice.

Jeff