View Full Version : Failing Timing belt tensioners vs upgraded valve springs.
Streamln1
06-22-2013, 10:02 PM
Doing a tear down and clean up of my engine right now, and after removing the timing belt covers, I noticed that the timing belt tensioner was pushed all the way in, and of course had the typical slack between the front and rear heads, but I did a full rotation manually and the tensioner while moving, never did get back to the 'preset' position when you set it initially.
Heres the deal, I have Ferrea dual springs in my heads, so that puts greater tension on the cams, and I also am running a Gates Kevlar belt. Is anyone on board with me with the opinion that perhaps this added stress is too much for a stock tensioner? I have maybe 10k miles on it, I am of course going to replace it, even though it may not be blown, I believe its getting weak. I can't afford a skipped timing belt.
That being said, I did consider running a solid tensioner, but I do worry about not having the automatic compensation the hydraulic unit does.
Any opinions?
jake stealth
06-23-2013, 09:11 AM
I have Brian Crower springs and 272 cams and had a similar experience. The engine lost a little power and found the front intake cam had somehow advanced itself two teeth. Like you, I had a loose timing belt and my thought was along the same lines as yours - the tensioner couldn't handle the extra load as imposed by the stronger springs. My thought is the front cam advanced itself after the engine stopped as the cam "nested" into a place where there was reduced valve spring tension - all because of insufficient spring tension as provided by the auto adjuster.
I then adjusted the tensioner so it is fully compressed - it's now functioning like a solid tensioner. Perhaps a little too tight since there was a little timing belt noise that was not present beforehand, but that noise has been slowly deminishing with miles until it's no longer noticeable.
Have driven the car for over 7,000 miles like this with no problems and this includes top speed runs on the Bonnevile Salt Flats.
I would like to have a damped tensioner with perhaps 2-3 times the normal spring pressure - think it would work better with heavier springs.
Just my thoughts and what I did -
Jake
Beau_Jester
06-23-2013, 10:59 AM
"I then adjusted the tensioner so it is fully compressed"
Wouldn't fully compressed be the loosest set point where fully extended applies the most tension to the belt or am I missing something in the translation of your post?
Jimvr4
06-23-2013, 11:28 AM
Check how the tensioner pulley is setup. When you put more tension on the belt, the bracket of the tensioner pulley pushes the pin further into the hydraulic tensioner.
Beau_Jester
06-23-2013, 11:38 AM
When you adjust the tension pulley with the adjusting tool there are three forces at work: your exertion of force onto the tool, the opposing force of the hydarulic tensioner and the opposing force of the belt. So when you are making the adjustment you are applying pressure onto the belt and the hydraulic tensioner.
After you adjust the position of the tensioner pulley and tighten the bolt, only two opposing forces remain, that of the hydraulic tensioner and the belt.
Now the hydraulic tensioner applies the pressure onto the tensioner pulley which applies pressure onto the belt. As the belt becomes stretched over time, the tension piston extends out of the tensioner to take up the slack. If you push the pin in all the way, it tends not to come out again so you can get belt slack later.
You would be better off just getting a solid adjuster designed for that application.
keo92stealth
06-23-2013, 02:48 PM
My car bent valves because of it .. Had bc valve springs and 280 cams .. I went with a solid tensioner after that .. Ask ray p about it . He will tell u all about it..
donniekak
06-23-2013, 03:40 PM
The tensioner only takes up the slack in the belt. The only part of the belt that sees more tension based on springs/cams is the section moving clockwise from the front head, waterpump, rear head, and ending at the crankshaft.
green-lantern
06-23-2013, 04:49 PM
Glad I read this, if I go with stiffer springs and cams I'll go with a solid tentioner.
familyMAN
06-23-2013, 08:16 PM
I haven't seen an issue with DR springs and street cams. Upgraded to some bigger cams and decided to do the washer trick on tensioner just in case and added a little more tension than usual. I would do a solid tensioner and kevlar belt but I have a habit over torquing everything I touch so concerned I would snug it up too tight and do some sort of damage...
Streamln1
06-23-2013, 09:53 PM
So is the consensus solid tensioner with Kevlar belt? I do have the gates Kevlar belt that isn't supposed to stretch.
I had no skipped teeth BTW, I expected a little slack between the front and rear heads because that always happens but I don't think the tensioner should be getting fully compressed in either.
donniekak
06-23-2013, 10:57 PM
Someone care to explain how stiffer springs place more tension on the slack area of the belt? I run a stock tensioner on my 4g63 running duel springs with 265lbs over the nose of my cams, revving to 9,000 rpms, with no tensioner issues. What can happen is belt flutter at high rpms. This isn't related to stiff valvesprings though.
familyMAN
06-24-2013, 01:33 AM
Just pulled my timing belt today to change cam seals. Tensioner still perfect. Could slide the grenade pin in after a couple of rotations. This is with dual springs, race cams and a few blasts past 7500 rpms.
You guys with issues using new OEM tensioners?
Streamln1
06-24-2013, 03:53 AM
Mine was OEM. On the fence if I want to use a Solid or another OEM. Mine does move, just never returns to the 'grenade pin' position. BTW want those cam gears, I loved the way the Unorthodox ones look.
Beau_Jester
06-24-2013, 01:26 PM
As everyone should know, when doing to 60k or 120k timing belt replacement your tensioner is properly adjusted if you can freely insert and remove the grenade pin after several belt rotations.
green-lantern
06-24-2013, 04:22 PM
Mine was OEM. On the fence if I want to use a Solid or another OEM. Mine does move, just never returns to the 'grenade pin' position. BTW want those cam gears, I loved the way the Unorthodox ones look.
How far is it from the hole? 10k might be enough to stretch the belt so you can't put it back in.
keo92stealth
06-24-2013, 11:24 PM
Glad I read this, if I go with stiffer springs and cams I'll go with a solid tentioner.
Good idea . You will sleep better at nite ..
keo92stealth
06-24-2013, 11:26 PM
Someone care to explain how stiffer springs place more tension on the slack area of the belt? I run a stock tensioner on my 4g63 running duel springs with 265lbs over the nose of my cams, revving to 9,000 rpms, with no tensioner issues. What can happen is belt flutter at high rpms. This isn't related to stiff valvesprings though.
the springs put more twist load with the car off than the tensioner is designed to handle. cars with springs need to be set up tighter of it can jump depending on where the engine stops when shut off . That's ray pampena's exact words from my old thread.
keo92stealth
06-24-2013, 11:33 PM
This is what ray said to do if you use the stock tensioner with upgraded springs .
you had cams and lifters.. so does that mean it has aftermarket springs? if so, you need to set the hydraulic tensioner down near the bottom so when the car sits there is no room for the plunger to go down far enough to make the belt jump.
RealMcCoy
06-25-2013, 01:02 AM
Or shim the tensioner to reduce the clearance...
Streamln1
06-25-2013, 02:27 AM
How far is it from the hole? 10k might be enough to stretch the belt so you can't put it back in.
If the belt stretched it would be pushed out farther, not pushed all the way in like mine was. it was definitely 1-2mm from the grenade pin position.
I may try the shimming idea so it can't bottom out, a lot of these thread responses make sense, so there is more 'at rest' force on the tensioner than a stock setup, so its leaving more slack than necessary between the heads.
Another weird thing I noticed, theres a lot of blue belt residue on my water pump from the gates belt, its on there thick enough its made the pump pulley feel rough, its as if the pump was 'dragging' on the belt or at times the tension wasn't enough to drive it, which is very bad, I also suspect this may be a tension thing, the pump spins freely enough and it also has just a few thousand miles on it.
The timing is spot on, and I always checked it periodicly because I am paranoid (having $7k plus in an engine will do that to ya).
familyMAN
06-25-2013, 02:42 AM
You are running a gates racing belt? My understanding is they barely stretch. Is it possible you didn't have tension set correctly from the beginning? Or you happened to get a bad tensioner?
green-lantern
06-25-2013, 07:38 AM
If the belt stretched it would be pushed out farther, not pushed all the way in like mine was. it was definitely 1-2mm from the grenade pin position.
I may try the shimming idea so it can't bottom out, a lot of these thread responses make sense, so there is more 'at rest' force on the tensioner than a stock setup, so its leaving more slack than necessary between the heads.
Another weird thing I noticed, theres a lot of blue belt residue on my water pump from the gates belt, its on there thick enough its made the pump pulley feel rough, its as if the pump was 'dragging' on the belt or at times the tension wasn't enough to drive it, which is very bad, I also suspect this may be a tension thing, the pump spins freely enough and it also has just a few thousand miles on it.
The timing is spot on, and I always checked it periodicly because I am paranoid (having $7k plus in an engine will do that to ya).
I thought you said it popped out when you turned the engine? :confused2: All tensioners will compress when the engine sits there. Not every time but if the engine stops in a place where the springs are putting pressure on the tensioner it will compress.
Streamln1
08-09-2013, 03:00 AM
it never did return to its original stock position, although close.
Streamln1
10-27-2013, 03:27 PM
Im thinking im going to get a solid tensioner since there really is no definite answer as to any negative effects, since the Kevlar is not going to stretch is not going to be an issue. I could see how a solid on a stock belt could be an issue over time with no way to compensate for stretch. The stock tensioner is the biggest reason there is ever any slack between the heads
RealMcCoy
10-27-2013, 04:03 PM
Just make sure you set it up for optimum tension at operating temp, or set it up slightly loose cold... A Kevlar belt that's too tight will wipe out your cam bearing surfaces pretty easily.
I've never checked a Kevlar belt, but I've seen with my own eyes a stock tensioner with stock belt moving almost 1/8" from cold operation to full temp operation.
Streamln1
10-28-2013, 02:17 AM
That worries me. But the stock tensioner does as well, I just do not think its up to the task of handling dual springs, overcompensating by going a little tighter might work but its still not the right way. Either way, something was going on to leave that much belt residue on my water pump pulley, that could only come from the belt not making solid contact occasionally.
donniekak
10-28-2013, 03:15 AM
If the tensioner was located between the crank, and rear head, increased spring tension could over compress it. The location of the tensioner makes spring tension a non factor.
Try this, put a wrench on the front exhaust cam to keep it from moving. Take a breaker bar and try to rotate the crank. Watch what happens to the tensioner, it actually extends. The higher the force required to rotate the cams, the lower the tension on the tensioner. The job of the tensioner is to take up slack, not absorb tension.
Streamln1
10-28-2013, 04:34 AM
of course it does and that proves nothing, Your thinking about it the wrong way. You would be lessoning the tension on it by doing that, but the front head and the heads over all with upgraded springs put more tension on the belt overall than stock, its questionable if the stock tensioner is up to the task, and since prone to fail. At some points the front head is putting a lot of pressure on the belt between it and the crank sprocket. If the tensioner were strong enough, there would never be a point where the spring pressure was enough to create slack between the heads.
my tensioner compressed inward overall and did not return to stock position fully, there is no force other than constant pressure on the tensioner causing it to weaken that could do this, if the belt stretched it would go the opposite way, not compress inward. As others have stated this is not an uncommon thing with cars with upgraded valve springs and head work. Rays suggestion would work also but I am leaning towards a solid tensioner since that is basically doing the same thing as defeating the stock weak link . If someone came up with an upgraded hydraulic unit that would be great. The floating design if fail proof would be the best of both worlds.
donniekak
10-28-2013, 10:26 AM
More tension on the belt, doesn't mean more tension on the tensioner.
Only when the engine is stopped does the front cylinder bank put any tension on the tensioner.
If the crankshaft is turned backwards, then tension is placed on the tensioner.
Think about it. The crankshaft turns clockwise, and pulls on the rear head exhaust cam, it also has to turn the rear intake cam, water pump, front intake cam, then front exhaust cam. Now, it's back where it started, and cannot pull on itself. The tensioner is designed to take up the slack in the belt between the front head, and the crankshaft. The overall tension on the belt comes from the resistance the cams have to turning, as long as the tensioner isn't bottomed out.
Streamln1
10-28-2013, 11:38 AM
also not true, at rest when there is slack between the heads the tensioner is almost fully pushed in, thats the spring tension between the heads and the crank pushing it in. if it stays pushed in like that or is slow to push out for some reason thats how people jump timing.
donniekak
10-28-2013, 12:39 PM
also not true, at rest when there is slack between the heads the tensioner is almost fully pushed in, thats the spring tension between the heads and the crank pushing it in. if it stays pushed in like that or is slow to push out for some reason thats how people jump timing.
If you have slack between the heads with the car running, there is to much slack in the belt.
As I stated above, it's normal for the tensioner to compress from belt tension related to spring tension when the engine is not running.
On a side note, I see you also live in Arizona. I'm surprised we haven't met already. I thought I knew almost everyone out here.
Streamln1
10-29-2013, 12:16 PM
Not when it's running or rotated but it has pushed in more than it was orginally. That's the point of this thread I believe it's going to fail. It's definitely the tensioner. I have done about 20 timing belts on these cars
Ya in over in Gilbert. Once i get my restoration done i will reach out to the local group. Not a lot of active members here anymore
familyMAN
10-29-2013, 05:06 PM
Not much local gathering of 3S owners in AZ unless you count don's house when they need rebuilt:)
On topic, I had no issues with stock tensioner with high lift 280's, upgraded springs and 8000 rpm. I did the washer trick just in case though.
aaronatstate
10-30-2013, 12:15 PM
How far is it from the hole? 10k might be enough to stretch the belt so you can't put it back in.
Just as a note, synchronous belts with fiberglass tensile cords do not stretch more than .001-.003" over the lifetime of the belt. All automotive synchronous belts, from the stock Mitsubishi belt, to the Gates aftermarket belt, to the Gates racing belt all have fiberglass tensile members, and will not stretch. The kevlar portion of the racing belt comes from the kevlar fibers they put into the rubber compound to strengthen the teeth. It makes the teeth stiffer and stronger and less prone to sheering off. Being an engineer at Gates, I don't see any reasons why a Gates Racing Belt would require more tension than the standard belt.
Also, I would almost always advise against using a solid tensioner. It's not because the belt stretches, but as the engine heats and cools, the geometry of the drive system changes, and the forces on the belt change. By not having something to take up this slack and differences in changes, it may adversely affect the belt.
i3igpete
10-30-2013, 01:48 PM
silly engineer! what do you know about cars! we only listen to anecdotal evidence here!
Streamln1
10-31-2013, 12:41 AM
Just as a note, synchronous belts with fiberglass tensile cords do not stretch more than .001-.003" over the lifetime of the belt. All automotive synchronous belts, from the stock Mitsubishi belt, to the Gates aftermarket belt, to the Gates racing belt all have fiberglass tensile members, and will not stretch. The kevlar portion of the racing belt comes from the kevlar fibers they put into the rubber compound to strengthen the teeth. It makes the teeth stiffer and stronger and less prone to sheering off. Being an engineer at Gates, I don't see any reasons why a Gates Racing Belt would require more tension than the standard belt.
Also, I would almost always advise against using a solid tensioner. It's not because the belt stretches, but as the engine heats and cools, the geometry of the drive system changes, and the forces on the belt change. By not having something to take up this slack and differences in changes, it may adversely affect the belt..
That makes sense. Thanks for the input.
new93TT
07-04-2015, 07:18 PM
so people are still 50/50 on hydo vs solid tensioner basicly , great as i need to order a 60k service kit
futurevr4man
07-06-2015, 12:58 PM
Just as a note, synchronous belts with fiberglass tensile cords do not stretch more than .001-.003" over the lifetime of the belt. All automotive synchronous belts, from the stock Mitsubishi belt, to the Gates aftermarket belt, to the Gates racing belt all have fiberglass tensile members, and will not stretch. The kevlar portion of the racing belt comes from the kevlar fibers they put into the rubber compound to strengthen the teeth. It makes the teeth stiffer and stronger and less prone to sheering off. Being an engineer at Gates, I don't see any reasons why a Gates Racing Belt would require more tension than the standard belt.
Also, I would almost always advise against using a solid tensioner. It's not because the belt stretches, but as the engine heats and cools, the geometry of the drive system changes, and the forces on the belt change. By not having something to take up this slack and differences in changes, it may adversely affect the belt.
so people are still 50/50 on hydo vs solid tensioner basicly , great as i need to order a 60k service kit
I feel as if what Aaron said was pretty definitive. You know, working for the manufacturer of the belt and all...
lawdogg
07-06-2015, 04:55 PM
Thanks Aaron for the dose of objectivity. A very helpful thread!
Powered by vBulletin® Version 4.2.3 Copyright © 2026 vBulletin Solutions, Inc. All rights reserved.