View Full Version : Researching a turbo failure - surge?
TurboSinceBirth
03-28-2013, 05:46 PM
Some of you may know I had a front turbo fail due to the shaft snapping for one reason or another. I was looking at some compressor flow maps of turbos unrelated to TD04s mostly due to sizing for future upgrade goals and I got to thinking about how much billet TD04s can actually handle. It's too bad none of the vendors are able to provide compressor flow maps so we could do more analysis.
I know GT-368SX turbos had issues going past mid to low 20s boost. GT Pro took a T3 60-trim and mated it to a TD04 exhaust side. Here's a flow map of the T3 60-trim.
http://www.stealth316.com/images/t3-60trim-jlspec.gif
You'll notice at 25 psi and above the turbo will surge everywhere spinning 153,700 rpms or better. I'm starting to doubt that 28-32 psi on my turbos is still on the compressor map. I'm sure they probably surged and came apart due to not being able to handle the boost and/or wheel speed. It's speculation without a compressor flow map but still plausible.
http://www.stealth316.com/images/td04h-19t-jlspec.gif
Even 19Ts can't handle more than 25 psi without surging. 170k rpms is really cranking it out too. Are the redesigned billet compressor wheels and porting really doing much to boost the ceiling height on the compressor maps of these new TD04 turbos? If you think about it probably 98% of the people run billet TD04s at 25 psi or less. There's only a handful that have pushed 25-30 psi. I don't know of anyone that has gone past that even or at least outside of an accidental spike once in awhile.
FeaRpb
03-28-2013, 05:50 PM
Very interesting.
We shall see how long my dr750's hold together at max boost.
wingnut
03-28-2013, 05:54 PM
subscribed...
AdamVR4
03-28-2013, 06:22 PM
You guys seem convinced that this 'heavy breathing' phenomenon is limited to quick spooling TD04's. My E16G's (ported hot sides) do it quite predictably at low load... The type-R BOV just continuously opens and closes (it's about as tight as it gets). DR headers, 3" FMIC, custom hard pipes, no balance tube. I really don't know how long it's done this, but it's very pronounced with my current intake tubes... I don't care that much, I just see it as an excuse to shove my foot to the floor, but it would be nice to understand the physics.
HilbillyHomeboy
03-28-2013, 06:32 PM
You guys seem convinced that this 'heavy breathing' phenomenon is limited to quick spooling TD04's. My E16G's (ported hot sides) do it quite predictably at low load... The type-R BOV just continuously opens and closes (it's about as tight as it gets). DR headers, 3" FMIC, custom hard pipes, no balance tube. I really don't know how long it's done this, but it's very pronounced with my current intake tubes... I don't care that much, I just see it as an excuse to shove my foot to the floor, but it would be nice to understand the physics.
I'm with you on that train of thought. My DR-1000's did the heavy breathing down low. Same type-R bov also, and tightened as far as it would go. Agreed, I just mashed through it.
Jeremy
familyMAN
03-28-2013, 10:03 PM
I think TSB is talking about actual surging and not the FMIC "flutter/surge" phenomenon.
I had zero issues cruising with my td05 billets (with td06sl2 turbine) on either 3.0 or 3.5. 2" hot sides. 3" cold. 4" CXRacing FMIC. Tial BOV on 3" hotside right before intercooler. SD of course. Custom "y" and less bends than the usual kit.
Can't say how they would be at high boost. Only hit 25psi on the 3.0 a couple times so likely still "on the map."
NOMIEZVR4
03-29-2013, 12:19 AM
Hoping to push my 19T's to the limit this season. If there is any data you need LMK, I"ll be more than happy to provide it.
FamilyMAN, how are you coping with the car nowadays? Has it sunk in yet? Figured out a gamplan yet? :)
TurboSinceBirth
03-29-2013, 03:13 AM
Hoping to push my 19T's to the limit this season. If there is any data you need LMK, I"ll be more than happy to provide it.
FamilyMAN, how are you coping with the car nowadays? Has it sunk in yet? Figured out a gamplan yet? :)
Outside of a compressor flow map that you can't help out with I don't really need anything else for definitive data. I'm not sure that over the long run anyone has pushed the biggest TD04 turbos at high 20s boost day in day out. You'd have to either run race gas or E85. Very few have. Some sprayed meth but that huge of an amount to get past 25 psi got them into trouble. I'm just curious the highest boost we can run without getting compressor surge due to spinning too many rpms and going off the map.
donniekak
03-29-2013, 03:41 AM
You're not reading the map correctly. Compressors surge when they are at to high of a pressure ratio in relation to flow. It causes the air to stall on the compressor blades, and reverse flow through the compressor. The surge line is the line the furthest left on the map. The furthest to the right is the choke line, and the horizontal lines represent rpms.
According to the compressor map, a 19t will surge at 25psi only if it's flowing less than about 150cfm. Surge is usually caused by to small of a turbine matched to a larger compressor. The turbo spools to soon, and bucks against the surge line.
I've had cars that I couldn't go full throttle in below a certain rpm, or the compressor would surge horribly.
FeaRpb
03-29-2013, 11:08 AM
anyone has pushed the biggest TD04 turbos at high 20s boost day in day out.
Matt M
Chris@Rvengeperformance
03-29-2013, 11:13 AM
I am sure ray runs his e85 DR750 car pretty hard.
Greg E
03-29-2013, 04:07 PM
Surge is usually caused by to small of a turbine matched to a larger compressor.
Can also happen when the engine can't suck in all of the air the turbos are trying to force into it. One of the main reasons I went with a stroker. :)
Ray Pampena
03-30-2013, 11:16 AM
i run my shit hard all the time. we also install tons of DR TD04s on customers cars and they all make great power and donr have any problems. i love the 650s and 750s
Turbo Beast
03-31-2013, 12:46 PM
i run my shit hard all the time. we also install tons of DR TD04s on customers cars and they all make great power and donr have any problems. i love the 650s and 750s
And chocolate milk
Ray Pampena
03-31-2013, 04:15 PM
And chocolate milk
That.. more than any of the turbos haha
Powered by vBulletin® Version 4.2.3 Copyright © 2026 vBulletin Solutions, Inc. All rights reserved.