PDA

View Full Version : J2534 Read Error / Error 16



Keyan
02-22-2013, 05:43 PM
I got the chrome ecu installed in my car and running but my laptop is having issues connecting with the tatrix cable. all the drivers installed successfully, and the laptop recognizes the adatper with no faults. but when i try to use ecuflash or ecuscan to connect to the vehicle, it gives me this error

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v162/Keyan/IMG_20130222_164051.jpg



im not sure what to do about it? :confused:

ive already tried redownloading and reinstalling the software - no go.



it is an amd x64 laptop running win7.

Keyan
02-22-2013, 06:05 PM
i went to try and drive my car home and now my car barely wants to run at all.

the chrome ecu came with a stock tune on it, yet when i pulled out my '93 ecu and put this one in, the car misfires like crazy. both ecus have a stock tune on it, shouldnt they both work the same?!

i am confused.

Jesters Deadd
02-22-2013, 06:56 PM
I know what that error is.
I believe you have my first obd1 - obd2 adapter plug.
I realized this today when i was making more plugs, but I accidently switched the blue and yellow wire on your adaptor plug.
Yours is the only one sent out like that, I caught the ones I was shipping today.
Just switch them at either end and it should work.
Sorry for the inconvienence.
Also your battery should be well above 12v before you attempt to flash it. put that sucker on a charger.

Keyan
02-22-2013, 08:41 PM
thanks. I will do that.



Also your battery should be well above 12v before you attempt to flash it. put that sucker on a charger.

I know :) I was merely trying to get the ecu to connect for data logging. for flashing i have a charger i will hook up that supplies a good 14v.

Chris@Rvengeperformance
02-22-2013, 09:04 PM
If you do not have the peripheries set properly for your model year it may not run well.

Greg E
02-22-2013, 09:18 PM
If you do not have the peripheries set properly for your model year it may not run well.

Someone read the manual. ;)

Keyan
02-22-2013, 10:57 PM
i did but i guess not well enough ;)

i had assumed i could just drive it around with a CEL if i didnt mess with the peripheries. i will flash the ecu tomorrow and give it another go

Jesters Deadd
02-23-2013, 12:06 AM
i went to try and drive my car home and now my car barely wants to run at all.

the chrome ecu came with a stock tune on it, yet when i pulled out my '93 ecu and put this one in, the car misfires like crazy. both ecus have a stock tune on it, shouldnt they both work the same?!

i am confused.

Weird, I put that ecu on a 91 vr4 completely stock and it started and drove very nicely on the V2 stock tune.
Please check all your wires and the condition of your ecu plugs. Then datalog in evoscan to see if you are getting any bizzare readings from your sensors ie air temp -60, etc.

Keyan
02-23-2013, 03:23 PM
I got the read problem fixed; the swapped wires did it.


The car not running right, however, is still borked.

I tried reflashing the ecu with the "1st gen" peripharies and it still misses / runs very very lean. (same as before)

It actually runs perfectly fine on cold start for the first 10 or so seconds, then starts running leaner and leaner until the car runs so lean that pressing down the pedal doesn't even make the rpms go up.

here is a video


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XuUfy6w94BE


now i am not running a stock 99 ecu, i am running jester's repinned 99 ECU. I am thinking that has something to do with it but i am unsure. Me and adam are trying to troubleshoot it via phone.

I will update this when I make headway.

Chris@Rvengeperformance
02-23-2013, 03:26 PM
disable closed loop functionality and report back.

Keyan
02-23-2013, 03:33 PM
I'd also like to mention i have an safc on board to correect my 550ccs (which isnt the problem, if i swap the 93 ecu back in the car runs perfect). and to get the car to run "not" lean i have to crank the safc from -22% to +47%. and even then, the car may idle at 13-15afr, but the car still misfires badly.

Keyan
02-23-2013, 03:34 PM
forrest i will try that tomorrow or sunday; i just put my stock ecu back in so i can drive it home (currently at work; mechanic)

Greg E
02-23-2013, 05:04 PM
Wait... You have 550s installed and you're running an SAFC with the clone ECU? The closed loop feature of the 99 ECU is different than that of the earlier gen cars. One of the main reasons the 98/99 cars were considered "untunable" with piggybacks. Many guys before swapped in earlier gen ECUs to get around this.

Set the Injector scalings and latencies for your 550s and zero out the SAFC. Car will run like stock.

Chris@Rvengeperformance
02-23-2013, 05:04 PM
I still suspect an o2 sensor signal issue.

Greg E
02-23-2013, 05:10 PM
I still suspect an o2 sensor signal issue.

If that was the case, this would have shown up when the ECU was tested. Also, the o2 sensor mixup was the result of there being different o2 pinouts between the 94/95 fed vs Cali cars. Doesn't apply with the 1G cars.

Chris@Rvengeperformance
02-23-2013, 05:14 PM
Well if he can datalog the 2 o2 readings would clear some things up. The thing going on with my car was similar, but the opposite. When the o2 read 0 due to my fault original ecu wiring harness the ecu tried to add fuel until it reached the trim limit. His is doing the opposite of that.

Keyan
02-23-2013, 05:44 PM
Wait... You have 550s installed and you're running an SAFC with the clone ECU? The closed loop feature of the 99 ECU is different than that of the earlier gen cars. One of the main reasons the 98/99 cars were considered "untunable" with piggybacks. Many guys before swapped in earlier gen ECUs to get around this.

Set the Injector scalings and latencies for your 550s and zero out the SAFC. Car will run like stock.



wait what?

i never heard this before.

I can run a MAFT but i cant run a SAFC? what's the difference? (im running both, actually. maft for gm sensor and safc for injector correction)

i'll do what you said, but can you explain how the closed loop feedback is different?

J-Groove
02-23-2013, 07:02 PM
wait what?

i never heard this before.

I can run a MAFT but i cant run a SAFC? what's the difference? (im running both, actually. maft for gm sensor and safc for injector correction)

i'll do what you said, but can you explain how the closed loop feedback is different?


There is absolutely no reason to run a SAFC with a flashable ECU. You use the ECU to tune for your injectors.

The '98 and '99 ECU codeing does not play well with a SAFC piggyback. Which as Greg had said is the reason why people would do an ECU swap in those cars to be able to mod them.

Do as Greg said, turn set your SAFC back to 0, basically to disable it and use the flash ECU to set your injectors.

-John

Greg E
02-23-2013, 07:28 PM
wait what?

i never heard this before.

I can run a MAFT but i cant run a SAFC? what's the difference? (im running both, actually. maft for gm sensor and safc for injector correction)

i'll do what you said, but can you explain how the closed loop feedback is different?

You can run both but you'll have to retune your SAFC and it'll drift around a lot and that still may not work.

The reason the flash ECU doesn't like piggy backs is because the older ECUs don't have the same emissions equipment. It operates the solenoids differently. When you change the airflow, this only further complicates the solenoid operations. It then has various fuel corrections for when these solenoids are operational. Even with the solenoid eliminated, the fuel corrections are still applied as disabling the periphery only disables the CEL not the solenoid function itself.

When you run a MAFT, you're supposed to leave it zeroed out. Not correct the airflow for your injectors. That's why it works.

Trust me, eliminate the SAFC and tune the flash ECU and the motor will run well. :)

Keyan
02-23-2013, 07:53 PM
The only reason I kept the safc corrected for 550s was I tend to take baby steps when doing mods, ya know?
Step 1: install ecu, make sure it works
Step 2: remove safc
Step 3: tune car


So I will combine step 1 and 2 see if the safc doing the correction (for the moment) was the issue! I was gonna yank it anyway but yeah. Thanks!

Keyan
02-25-2013, 01:35 PM
disabling the safc and flashing the chromeecu for 550s and proper battery latency did not correct the issue. it still runs exactly the same as before. runs perfect on a cold start for about 10 seconds and then develops a miss and runs leaner and leaner until the car wont move under its own power (that process takes about 30-45 seconds).

so its not the safc causing this issue.

i am going to try and do forrest's suggestion and then report back

Greg E
02-25-2013, 02:43 PM
If that doesn't fix it, shoot me an email along with your mods and the ROM currently flashed to tour ecu and I'll give you my phone number. We should be able to figure this out over the phone.

Keyan
02-25-2013, 05:07 PM
I couldn't find anything in the tech manual or the tuning guide to "disable closed loop functionality" so instead, i went in to the peripheries and disabled the
bit04 Short Term Fuel Trim Function
bit02 Dual Narrowband Fuel Trim Function
bit01 Long Term Fuel Trim Function

and i also disabled
bit07 P0170 P0173 Front Rear Fuel Trim Test
bit06 P0125 Excessive Time To Enter Closed Loop


and the car started up and ran fine. idle wasn't perfect-perfect (it idled around 13.5 during warmup) and during driving around the parking lot, tip-in on the gas pedal caused it to run lean but then after tip-in it would catch back up with itself and i could cruise at 14.7.

So it seems that the o2 sensors are involved somehow, perhaps?

Tell me what to log and I will get you a video / log file.

I have Adam's phone number right now, Greg i'll PM you for yours.


(PS; just an after thought, but since my car is a 93, i wonder if the pins are different than the 91-92, since my car has the cam/crank set up?)

Thanks guys.

Greg E
02-25-2013, 05:17 PM
Email me your tune and I'll call you in about half an hour

J-Groove
02-25-2013, 05:42 PM
disabling the safc and flashing the chromeecu for 550s and proper battery latency did not correct the issue.

Well shit.

In for results.

-John

BlackStealth
02-25-2013, 07:07 PM
(PS; just an after thought, but since my car is a 93, i wonder if the pins are different than the 91-92, since my car has the cam/crank set up?)
I have a 93 with a flashable ECU, and no problems, so that thought is not correct. Also I have no SAFC or any piggyback and it works great with the flash ECU alone. (RC550cc injectors).

Keyan
02-25-2013, 07:24 PM
I have it fixed, and a reason for why is pending, but i need to talk to jester about it first so i dont type it up improperly and confuse the hell out of anyone.


---


edit: talked to adam. He accidentally had the jumpers on his ecu set incorrectly. swapping them around cleared up my problem. what was happening was the o2 sensors were swapped around (front was rear, rear was front) so when the ecu tested the fuel trim function of itself, it would pull one bank lean and see it go rich, and pull the other bank rich, and see it go lean. that is why the car would misfire but my wideband would show 14.7 during warmup. my wideband is after the Y pipe so it was the mixture of both banks put together. because one bank was at 17+afr and the other bank was at 10-afr.


when the jumpers on the ecu were swapped back to their correct positions, the o2s were reading on the proper banks and the ecu was able to pass its trim test instantly, and the car would run normally.

this really only was a 1 in 1000000 issue. only someone with a jester ecu COULD have this issue, and i was the first one he made so there was room for error :)

Thanks to Greg and Adam for helping me get it sorted out! Now to tuning this bitch!

Greg E
02-26-2013, 12:00 AM
Win!!!

Jesters Deadd
02-26-2013, 12:24 PM
Easy fix. I misread my notes when setting up this first ecu. All future ecus willl be sent with jumpers in correct location.