PDA

View Full Version : Ignition Timing Thread



Blackmount
01-23-2013, 01:28 PM
So I have a few questions, I am searching the Internet for articles, threads, videos etc that can answer my questions and so far I'm having no luck...

My biggest question so far is

Q: If you keep increasing your ignition timing advanced, is there a point you will start loosing power, but no knock will occur?

My understanding the point when it looses power, is when the timing being so advanced it happens too early, and the flame front starts trying to force DOWN the still moving UP Piston; fighting against it. I believe the term they used was "Negative Torque", and this would be described as knock; if no knock is occurring/being registered, is it still a possibility of "Negative Torque" resulting in power loss to happen? I hope I made this clear enough to understand exactly what I am asking.

I am really looking for no guess work but maybe some of our senior members who have some good experience and knowledge on this sort of thing.

edit if changing knock to "Pre-Ignition" helps you understand what I am asking please do so.

B-Man
01-23-2013, 01:37 PM
Engine Basics: Detonation and Pre-Ignition by Allen W. Cline (http://www.contactmagazine.com/Issue54/EngineBasics.html)

This article talks a bit about Minimum Best Timing and what can happen when you exceed that timing.


Production engines are optimized for the type or grade of fuel that the marketplace desires or offers. Engine designers use the term called MBT ( Minimum spark for Best Torque) for efficiency and maximum power; it is desirable to operate at MBT at all times. For example, let's pick a specific engine operating point, 4000 RPM, WOT, 98 kPa MAP. At that operating point with the engine on the dynamometer and using non-knocking fuel, we adjust the spark advance. There is going to be a point where the power is the greatest. Less spark than that, the power falls off, more spark advance than that, you don't get any additional power.

Blackmount
01-23-2013, 01:51 PM
That does not help with the question I was asking though.

Theres a point when power falls off due to too much ignition timing, the ECU SHOULD pick it up as knock, and if its enough retard timing.

Is it possible that you can get to that point where you loose power due to too far advanced timing; but the ecu will not register it as any sort of ping or knock because of it.

Ideally, you can keep increasing timing until knock occurs, then back it off half or a whole degree for optimum power, is that possible.


Your timing makes a huge difference on how much power and how well your engine runs. The whole idea of timing is to make the spark happen just before the piston gets to the top of the compression stroke. You are timing it to a perfect spot for that engine so the piston does not lose and momentum on the way up and gets blown back down with the maximum force possible. If you retard the timing to far, 20 deg BTDC, the explosion happens far before the piston gets to the top and it is trying to force the piston backwards against its stroke. this causes a ping or knock and a loss of power. If you advance your timing to far, 10 deg After TDC, the explosion happens after the piston has reached TDC. This explosion is weaker because the compession has started to lessen in the cylinder as the piston moves down and the momentum has slowed in the engine.

CoreyB
01-23-2013, 01:59 PM
Answer is yes

Blackmount
01-23-2013, 02:08 PM
Do you have a situation that can support this Corey or are you just mad because I own Chatbox :)

DG
01-23-2013, 02:58 PM
Have you ever tried to shoot a moving target? (or thow a ball to someone who is running?) You can't thow/shoot directly at them, because the ball/projectile takes time to cover the distance between shooter and target, and the target is still moving while the shot is in flight.

Ignition advance is the same thing - it takes some amount of time for the spark to light off the mixture and some amount of time for the flame front to spread through the whole combustion volume and reach peak pressure. So what you are trying to do with advance is light the mixture off early enough to put the pressure peak where you want it relative to the crank stroke so as to maximize the amount of work extracted from that pressure peak.

So the proper amount of advance is contingent on how fast the piston is moving and how fast the fuel burns. Fast piston speed - more advance. Fast burn speed - less advance.

Burn speed is partially determined by the richness/leaness of the fuel mixture, and partially determined by the chemical composition of the fuel itself.

So for a given engine at a given engine RPM, starting at maximum advance and working increasingly retarded, you go:

knock - suboptimal power - optimal power - suboptimal power - burned valves

Burn speed usually correlates highly with octane rating, where high octane numbers translate to slow burn speed. So a high octane fuel may not only allow the use of more ignition advance, but actually demand it. When I ran C16 in the Talon, it really liked a lot of advance.

The big question though is, for a given engine, how large is the window between "knock" and "suboptimal power"? If that window is small, then seeking to ride the knock limit is a legit strategy for maximizing power. If, however, the window is large, attempting to ride the knock limit both exposes the engine to risk and produces suboptimal power.

The only way to know is test.

This is one of the things that continues to baffle me about the import tuner world and has since Day 1: the old school muscle car / NASCAR guys all own engine dynos and play with this stuff in a controlled environment (I once spent a day at Lingenfelter trying a series of harmonic dampers with different elastomers looking for the combination that best damped the crank in our C5 motor) With an engine dyno, you can hold the motor at a specific RPM and then swing the timing back and forth looking for the power peak - it's easy. Import guys have never embraced this and I'm at a loss as to why.

DG

Greg E
01-23-2013, 03:56 PM
That does not help with the question I was asking though.

Theres a point when power falls off due to too much ignition timing, the ECU SHOULD pick it up as knock, and if its enough retard timing.

Is it possible that you can get to that point where you loose power due to too far advanced timing; but the ecu will not register it as any sort of ping or knock because of it.

Ideally, you can keep increasing timing until knock occurs, then back it off half or a whole degree for optimum power, is that possible.

On pump gas this tuning method works great because you will usually run out of octane long before you reach MBT.

On race gas and/or ethanol you run into the issue where you can run way more cylinder pressure without knock and ruin the pistons/ bearings. Obviously the closer to the top of the piston travel you fire the plug, the more cylinder pressure will result from the ignition in a smaller space. When this energy starts getting absorbed by the engine instead of pushing the piston back down, you're beyond MBT and thus losing power and killing your motor.

Greg E
01-23-2013, 03:57 PM
...and Dennis post was much better written than mine. :lol:

Blackmount
01-23-2013, 04:39 PM
Have you ever tried to shoot a moving target? (or thow a ball to someone who is running?) You can't thow/shoot directly at them, because the ball/projectile takes time to cover the distance between shooter and target, and the target is still moving while the shot is in flight.

Ignition advance is the same thing - it takes some amount of time for the spark to light off the mixture and some amount of time for the flame front to spread through the whole combustion volume and reach peak pressure. So what you are trying to do with advance is light the mixture off early enough to put the pressure peak where you want it relative to the crank stroke so as to maximize the amount of work extracted from that pressure peak.

So the proper amount of advance is contingent on how fast the piston is moving and how fast the fuel burns. Fast piston speed - more advance. Fast burn speed - less advance.

Burn speed is partially determined by the richness/leaness of the fuel mixture, and partially determined by the chemical composition of the fuel itself.

So for a given engine at a given engine RPM, starting at maximum advance and working increasingly retarded, you go:

knock - suboptimal power - optimal power - suboptimal power - burned valves

Burn speed usually correlates highly with octane rating, where high octane numbers translate to slow burn speed. So a high octane fuel may not only allow the use of more ignition advance, but actually demand it. When I ran C16 in the Talon, it really liked a lot of advance.

The big question though is, for a given engine, how large is the window between "knock" and "suboptimal power"? If that window is small, then seeking to ride the knock limit is a legit strategy for maximizing power. If, however, the window is large, attempting to ride the knock limit both exposes the engine to risk and produces suboptimal power.

The only way to know is test.

This is one of the things that continues to baffle me about the import tuner world and has since Day 1: the old school muscle car / NASCAR guys all own engine dynos and play with this stuff in a controlled environment (I once spent a day at Lingenfelter trying a series of harmonic dampers with different elastomers looking for the combination that best damped the crank in our C5 motor) With an engine dyno, you can hold the motor at a specific RPM and then swing the timing back and forth looking for the power peak - it's easy. Import guys have never embraced this and I'm at a loss as to why.

DG

^ This, I feel the same way, and being forced to be apart of that generation and have to separate the bullshit from facts is a huge headache for me. I try to take a step away from that by spending time on the dyno just to gather info and see what does which and how it reacts to X changes.

However with me living in a new area, and also finances being such a issue for me, it requires alot of waiting time, especially since I have to find a good Dyno Tuner who will let me do or at least do for me what I am wanting to do (should not be a problem if I am paying his/her normal rate for dyno time) also the issue rises finding the same type of dyno, and that the environment is different as those both have effects on dyno numbers and will create alot of naysaying from people when comparing my previous dyno sessions...

Now on the "suboptimal power Window" could you give me a example of maybe a Large Window vs a small/short one? is this something like the space in RPM band this has time to occur in? orrr.....?


On pump gas this tuning method works great because you will usually run out of octane long before you reach MBT.

On race gas and/or ethanol you run into the issue where you can run way more cylinder pressure without knock and ruin the pistons/ bearings. Obviously the closer to the top of the piston travel you fire the plug, the more cylinder pressure will result from the ignition in a smaller space. When this energy starts getting absorbed by the engine instead of pushing the piston back down, you're beyond MBT and thus losing power and killing your motor.

So with that being said, without using a dyno to tune which is obviously preferred:

Should I see if I can keep increasing Timing, until it knocks? I feel like I am already running alot of timing especially compared to how much I was running during my last few dyno runs I did. The car definitely feels great, and is responding well to it; but if there is a safe amount of room for more then I am down to keep going. (I always fill up with 93, never 91, or lower grade fuels if that contributes to the answers I seek) Currently I have it set at 9.5* for the Base Timing, which in my logs is about 34-35 Degrees @ WOT in the high rpm range. (4600-7200rpms)

..and this last portion:


On pump gas this tuning method works great because you will usually run out of octane long before you reach MBT.

On race gas and/or ethanol you run into the issue where you can run way more cylinder pressure without knock and ruin the pistons/ bearings. Obviously the closer to the top of the piston travel you fire the plug, the more cylinder pressure will result from the ignition in a smaller space. When this energy starts getting absorbed by the engine instead of pushing the piston back down, you're beyond MBT and thus losing power and killing your motor.

This was probably the best answer I will get, and almost exactly what I was looking for; which supports my suspicion true that under the right circumstances you can begin to loose power due to too much ignition timing advanced and you will not see the knock from it; it will also potentially lead to engine damage.. (Correct?)

Another "That Being Said": Our engines our pretty tough in stock form as far as the internals go, but from what I have seen on the board the Rings and that area seems to be the weak link, and occasionally the rod bearings...

Obviously too, I am here for advice, and will take it at my own risk. If I go out and run 11* of base timing and blow my engine to pieces; Then, well I will not come back and say it was your fault because blah blah blah. I am above that.

B-Man
01-23-2013, 04:41 PM
That does not help with the question I was asking though.

Theres a point when power falls off due to too much ignition timing, the ECU SHOULD pick it up as knock, and if its enough retard timing.

Is it possible that you can get to that point where you loose power due to too far advanced timing; but the ecu will not register it as any sort of ping or knock because of it.

Ideally, you can keep increasing timing until knock occurs, then back it off half or a whole degree for optimum power, is that possible.

The ECU only registers it as knock if it's actually detonation (ie 7 or more detonations detected by the knock sensor)

CoreyB
01-23-2013, 04:48 PM
I wouldn't be to worried, I would be very surprised if you blow your engine from too much timing. It will likely run terrible before you actually start doing damage. However, running too much timing for a long period of time, even on a low horsepower engine isnt exactly very good for the life of the bearings. You need to remember that pretty much all the story's you hear about people knocking and destroying these engines were people that were boosting and running out of fuel or detonating.

Greg E
01-23-2013, 05:03 PM
So with that being said, without using a dyno to tune which is obviously preferred:

Should I see if I can keep increasing Timing, until it knocks? I feel like I am already running alot of timing especially compared to how much I was running during my last few dyno runs I did. The car definitely feels great, and is responding well to it; but if there is a safe amount of room for more then I am down to keep going. (I always fill up with 93, never 91, or lower grade fuels if that contributes to the answers I seek) Currently I have it set at 9.5* for the Base Timing, which in my logs is about 34-35 Degrees @ WOT in the high rpm range. (4600-7200rpms)

Tuning till you see knock with race gas or ethanol will lead to a blown motor long before you see knock. Todd has now lost 2 engines from this tuning approach and is now scared to run any kind of alcohol fuel...

Without a Dyno you really need to just go by instinct. This just takes experience and research. If so and so with a similar setup put down such power and is still driving around the then its probably safe to assume you might be able to do the same.

DG
01-23-2013, 05:04 PM
All else being equal, I would expect low octane/pump fuel (93 is low octane; I ran 118 in the race car) to have a smaller timing window than with high octane. But this isn't something you can nail down discussing shit on the Internet; this has to be tested in the wild.

Let me say that again - the only way to know is to test.

Also, testing is the only way to know.

DG

CoreyB
01-23-2013, 05:08 PM
Does he have to test?

Blackmount
01-23-2013, 06:08 PM
Tuning till you see knock with race gas or ethanol will lead to a blown motor long before you see knock. Todd has now lost 2 engines from this tuning approach and is now scared to run any kind of alcohol fuel...

Without a Dyno you really need to just go by instinct. This just takes experience and research. If so and so with a similar setup put down such power and is still driving around the then its probably safe to assume you might be able to do the same.

That is why I started this thread; I don't see a whole lot of ignition timing being talked about in depth with the 3/s platform, or really any Import for that matter; but there is the possibility maybe I just haven't been paying as much attention as I think I have.

I don't want to make this about N/As OR my car, but this seems very uncharted, and I'm trying to make power the right way. "Make power smarter, not spending money harder." I believe there is power to be had through just timing in itself, and I would really like to see how much.



All else being equal, I would expect low octane/pump fuel (93 is low octane; I ran 118 in the race car) to have a smaller timing window than with high octane. But this isn't something you can nail down discussing shit on the Internet; this has to be tested in the wild.

Let me say that again - the only way to know is to test.

Also, testing is the only way to know.

DG

And that is what I am doing but I was looking for a little bit of advice and maybe some comfort before I did what I felt like was might pushing the limit, and or wasting time. (Loosing power)

I've never run one of MY cars on anything but pump gas, so 93 is high to me. LOL.


Does he have to test?

Troll :P

I will play with the timing some more and report back, and see what I can accomplish. I will maybe post logs if anyone is interested; speaking of which, Is there any other sensors I should monitor in my logs? I am using the the Android Version of MMCD. I usually just do Timing, TPS, RPM, Knock, and Coolant Temp.

Maybe I can see about getting the car to a dyno tuner, and really get some solid results. I would happily post online here as oppose to my butt dyno and a few logs. I would be really happy if this information could be used to benefit others who have questions on timing.

familyMAN
01-23-2013, 06:40 PM
That is why I started this thread; I don't see a whole lot of ignition timing being talked about in depth with the 3/s platform, or really any Import for that matter; but there is the possibility maybe I just haven't been paying as much attention as I think I have.


Spend some time on evo forums. Plenty of discussion on various setups. Every setup is different, cams, header, turbos, intake mani, fuel, afr all make a difference on what timing you can run or what your motor wants.

I am certainly no expert and have a blown headgasket as proof:) Trevor has posted his timing maps and experience several times, especially with his 3.7 setup. I can attest to his conclusion that the 6g74 wants MUCH less timing advance than the 72s. When it gets new head gaskets soon, I will be leaning it out under boost (e85) and low single digit timing at peak tq.

Great topic though.

Blackmount
01-23-2013, 06:43 PM
Spend some time on evo forums. Plenty of discussion on various setups. Every setup is different, cams, header, turbos, intake mani, fuel, afr all make a difference on what timing you can run or what your motor wants.

I am certainly no expert and have a blown headgasket as proof:) Trevor has posted his timing maps and experience several times, especially with his 3.7 setup. I can attest to his conclusion that the 6g74 wants MUCH less timing advance than the 72s. When it gets new head gaskets soon, I will be leaning it out under boost (e85) and low single digit timing at peak tq.

Great topic though.

Would the reason it likes LESS timing be because the piston is traveling a further distance?

familyMAN
01-23-2013, 06:46 PM
No idea. Thought a bigger bore would need more timing? I'm 10:1 though:). Trevor is 9:1, but I believe it was Hans that also said less timing for 74 swaps.

Blackmount
01-23-2013, 07:11 PM
Well the biggest different in displacement with the 6g74 is the stroke correct? The point of adjusting timing is to get the flame front to hit the piston right as it hits TDC, instantly forcing the piston down, no waiting time. As stated above it takes time for the created spark to travel and ignite the air fuel mixture, and then it takes time for that mixture to fully ignite to generate its full force.. well if the piston has more distance to travel you would need the spark to wait LONGER to fire...I would think.... I could be wrong...

familyMAN
01-23-2013, 08:44 PM
Well the biggest different in displacement with the 6g74 is the stroke correct?

Correct, almost 10mm more stroke and almost 2mm more bore.

Didn't want to turn this into a 74 thread, just wanted to point out that there is some timing info out there if you look for it. Chris H has posted most of his timing info as well.

Chris@Rvengeperformance
01-23-2013, 09:03 PM
There are some serious obstacle to getting import engines on a dyno, especially ones with miles of intercooler piping like our twin setup.

The domestic v8 guys only have o worry about a handful of flywheel and engine mount configurations on the dyno. Go to a regular engine tuning shop and get the flywheel adapters made, the engine mount brackets/adapters made, an appropriate cooling system configuration, and something to support your intercooler setup, and your engine wiring harness/ecu combination and then you'd be ready to start tuning the car on a stand that has a lot of differences to how the engine is going to be package into a engine bay like ours.

Or put it on a chassis dyno that just needs to me awd. You can hold the engine at a certain rpm with an eddy current chassis dyno anyway.

Chris@Rvengeperformance
01-23-2013, 09:06 PM
No idea. Thought a bigger bore would need more timing? I'm 10:1 though:). Trevor is 9:1, but I believe it was Hans that also said less timing for 74 swaps.

well at least with the longer stroke there is more time for the power stroke to complete, so it would stand to reason you may need less timing advance. There is also then a greater window for detonation.

DG
01-24-2013, 08:28 AM
There are some serious obstacle to getting import engines on a dyno, especially ones with miles of intercooler piping like our twin setup.

On an engine dyno you don't replicate that stuff. You have an air/water intercooler on a stand hooked up to municipal water. Air inlet, air outlet, and some flex hoses. Done.

If you want to get fancy, plumb the water inlet to both hot and cold water and put a temp sensor at the water inlet so you can control the temp of the cooling mechanism.

If you want to be cheap, you don't plumb to municipal water, you plumb to a water tank and recirculate. Make the tank small enough and you can replicate air/air heat soak.

If Lingenfelter's dyno can handle twin turbo V8s, there's no reason why an import shop can't do the same. Those are not serious obstacles.

DG

Chris@Rvengeperformance
01-24-2013, 10:42 AM
Often it is an obstacle to get shop that will even deal with dynoing an import at all, I think you underestimate the difficulty, or there would be more people that do it.

I guess my other question is why do you think it would be better than an eddy current chassis dyno? Especially if you are changing the intercooling and other factors that will affect the tune.

DG
01-24-2013, 11:09 AM
Well, the ability to quickly do things like A-B-A tests for stuff like cylinder heads, camshafts, and other parts where immediate access to the engine without having to work around the constraints of the as-installed engine compartment means the time to swap parts is reduced by an order of magnitude. That makes testing much more feasible.

I have worked with engine dynos guys; when you are doing development, they are WAY faster than chassis dynos of any sort.

DG

Chris@Rvengeperformance
01-24-2013, 11:11 AM
Well, the ability to quickly do things like A-B-A tests for stuff like cylinder heads, camshafts, and other parts where immediate access to the engine without having to work around the constraints of the as-installed engine compartment means the time to swap parts is reduced by an order of magnitude. That makes testing much more feasible.

I have worked with engine dynos guys; when you are doing development, they are WAY faster than chassis dynos of any sort.

DG

that is true. I guess the root issue then is most import parts companies do NOT want to do back to back testing because most of their parts don't make power.

DG
01-24-2013, 11:29 AM
I guess the root issue then is most import parts companies do NOT want to do back to back testing because most of their parts don't make power.

There is more than a little truth to this. Doubly true with small, captured audience markets serviced by only a couple of vendors.

The shitstorm that erupted when I started dynoing shocks....

DG

Blackmount
01-24-2013, 12:03 PM
I was specifically talking Chassis dyno, but it is my fault for not specifying.

I'm sure most Engine Dyno' guys around here would laugh at me if I told them I had a Mitsubishi Engine I wanted to put on their dyno. Besides; I'm more about what you make at the wheels anyways. anyways.

Did a new log today, however I bought a new phone last night, and its really nice...but I'm still working on getting the log onto the computer XD




The shitstorm that erupted when I started dynoing shocks....

DG

like what would happen if I actually got the resources to start Dynoing Cams?

and what happens everytime someone questions certain vendors cams?

-B

DG
01-24-2013, 01:14 PM
I'm sure most Engine Dyno' guys around here would laugh at me if I told them I had a Mitsubishi Engine I wanted to put on their dyno.

Are you kidding me?

When you have an investment in a piece of infrastructure like that, that costs as much as it does, the problem is keeping it working so it can pay itself off. In a machine shop context, "If a machine is not making chips it is costing you money".

Expanding your potential customer base is only a good thing. Any shop will be down for that, especially now when business is slow.

What you probably can't expect is for the shop to eat the fabrication cost for motor mount adaptors and flywyeel adaptors, under the premise that a flood of other Mitsubishis will suddenly show up. As a customer, I'd expect to pay for that (and to keep the adaptors!) But any dyno operator will happily sell you time on his dyno.

DG

Blackmount
01-24-2013, 02:01 PM
Hmm, I'll look into it, but for now, my engine is staying in my car because I need it.


Might throw some more timing at it this weekend.....

Chris@Rvengeperformance
01-24-2013, 03:29 PM
unless you start using a tool like virtual dyno I wouldn't keep throwing timing at it just because their is no detonation noise. Like Greg said earlier you can still be applying force to the engine at the wrong time and just beating up the bearings.

What I would do first is pickup a flash ecu where you can properly set the engine timing. This will also work for you when you want to go turbo.